Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (2) of Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Articles 14, 19, 31 and 311
  • Rule 244(2), Rule 285 of the Mysore Civil Service Rules, 1958, Article 311
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 14 or Article 16
  • Article 465-A and Note-1 appended thereto in the Civil Service Regulations
  • Article 311(2)
  • Articles 14, 19(1)(f), 31 and 311
  • Article 309 of the Constitution
  • Rajasthan Code Vol. I, Part B corrected upto December 31, 1967 Fourth Edition
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (2) of Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Articles 14, 19, 31 and 311
  • Rule 244(2), Rule 285 of the Mysore Civil Service Rules, 1958, Article 311
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 14 or Article 16
  • Article 465-A and Note-1 appended thereto in the Civil Service Regulations
  • Article 311(2)
  • Articles 14, 19(1)(f), 31 and 311
  • Article 309 of the Constitution
  • Rajasthan Code Vol. I, Part B corrected upto December 31, 1967 Fourth Edition
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Five consolidated writ petitions (Nos. 270 of 1970; 1253, 1353, 1448 and 1898 of 1973) were filed by Rajasthan Government employees who had been served with notices of compulsory retirement between March 1970 and November 1973. Each order invoked Rule 244(2) of the Rajasthan Service Rules after the petitioner had completed twenty-five years of qualifying service. Some notices expressly recited that the retirement was “in public interest,” while later orders omitted that phrase. The petitioners challenged the orders directly before the Supreme Court under Article 32 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether compulsory retirement orders made under Rule 244(2) infringe Articles 14, 19(1)(f), 31 and 311 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether deletion of the words “in public interest” from the amended Rule 244(2) leaves the power unguided and arbitrary.
  3. Whether the delegation of the retirement power to Collectors, made in 1963, survived the 1963 and 1972 amendments of the Rules.
  4. Whether the impugned orders are stigmatic and thus constitute “removal” attracting Article 311(2) safeguards.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • Rule 244(2) confers an unguided, discriminatory power, violating Article 14 because it contains no criteria for selecting employees for retirement.
  • Premature retirement before the normal superannuation age of 55 imposes an unreasonable restriction on the right to property in service, infringing Articles 19(1)(f) and 31.
  • Because compulsory retirement effectively removes a permanent employee, it can be passed only after following the procedure mandated by Article 311(2).
  • The 1963 delegation of power to the Collector lapsed after the rule was amended; therefore the Collector lacked authority to issue the orders.
  • In Writ Petition No. 1898 of 1973 the petitioner had not completed 25 years’ service and the order was allegedly issued on stigmatic grounds.

Table of Precedents Cited

PrecedentRule / PrincipleApplication by the Court
Ganga Ram v. State of Rajasthan, ILR 1961 Raj 371 Set out pre-1963 text of Rule 244(2) Used to trace statutory history of the rule under challenge
T.G. Shivacharana Singh v. State of Mysore, AIR 1965 SC 280 Compulsory retirement after long qualifying service upheld; not punitive Relied on to reject Article 311 challenge
R.L. Butail v. Union of India, (1970) 2 SCC 876 Exceptions to Article 311; retirement permissible where rule prescribes long service period Cited to support constitutional validity of Rule 244(2)
Union of India v. Col. J.N. Sinha, (1970) 2 SCC 458 Bona fide opinion for retirement not open to scrutiny; retirement not penal Invoked to limit scope of judicial review
Shyam Lal v. State of U.P., AIR 1954 SC 369 Notes appended to rules are integral and interpretative Used to hold that Notes to Rule 244(2) supply the “public interest” requirement
Union of India v. K.P. Joseph, (1973) 1 SCC 194 Administrative instructions can fill gaps in statutory rules Applied to treat Notes as binding guidance

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Court traced the evolution of Rule 244(2) through the 1963 and 1972 amendments and emphasised that the contemporaneously issued Notes were framed under Article 309 and “travel with the rule.” Although “public interest” was dropped from the main text, the Notes expressly limit compulsory retirement to cases where an employee’s efficiency is impaired but no formal charges are desirable. Applying Shyam Lal and K.P. Joseph, the Court held that these Notes form part of the rule and provide adequate guidance, foreclosing an Article 14 challenge.

Relying on Shivacharana Singh, Butail and Col. Sinha, the Court reaffirmed that: (i) compulsory retirement after a reasonably long period of service is not a penalty; (ii) it does not attract Article 311(2); and (iii) judicial review is confined to testing whether the decision is bona fide and in public interest.

Regarding Articles 19(1)(f) and 31, the Court reasoned that public employment is held subject to statutory rules; Rule 244(2) lawfully curtails tenure after 25 years’ service, so no unconstitutional deprivation occurs. On delegation, Appendix 9 continues to empower the appointing authority (the Collector) to retire ministerial staff; the 1963 delegation therefore remains valid. The Court found no stigma in any order and confirmed that the petitioner in W.P. No. 1898 had indeed completed the necessary 25 years’ service.

Holding and Implications

All writ petitions were dismissed.

The Supreme Court upheld Rule 244(2) and the impugned retirement orders, clarifying that the embedded Notes supply the “public interest” criterion and thus cure any alleged arbitrariness. The ruling reinforces settled law that compulsory retirement, when based on a long qualifying service period and guided by public-interest criteria, does not violate Articles 14, 19, 31 or 311. No new constitutional doctrine was created; the immediate effect is that the petitioners remain retired and the State’s power under Rule 244(2) stands confirmed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Tara Singh And Others v. State Of Rajasthan And Others

    A.N Ray, C.J— These writ petitions challenge the validity of orders of compulsory retirement. In Writ Petition No. 1253 of 1973 the petitioner was served with an order dated March 30, 1973. The order was as follows:

    “Whereas Shri Tara Singh Patwari has completed 25 years of qualifying service and whereas the State Government is satisfied that it is in public interest to dispense with further service of the said government servant.
    Now, therefore, in pursuance of the delegation made under Rule 244(2) of the Rajasthan Service Rules vide Finance Department Order No. F. 1(34)FD-A (Rules/62) dated 13-12-63 the undersigned hereby gives notice to the said Shri Tara Singh requiring him to retire with effect from the date of the expiry of 3 calendar months from the service of this notice on him and further orders the compulsory retirement of Shri Tara Singh with effect from the said date.
    sd/-
    Collector,
    Ganganagar.”

    2. In Writ Petition No. 1353 of 1973, the petitioner was served with an identical order dated March 30, 1973.

    3. In Writ Petition No. 1448 of 1973 the petitioner was served with an order dated April 28, 1973. The order was in terms similar to that in Writ Petition No. 1253 of 1973 except that the order did not state that “the State Government is satisfied that it is in public interest to dispense with the service of the petitioner”.

    4. In Writ Petition No. 1898 of 1973 the petitioner was served with an order dated November 4, 1973 where also the order did not state that the compulsory retirement was made by the Government on being satisfied that it was in public interest.

    5. In Writ Petition No. 270 of 1970 the petitioner was served with an order dated March 30, 1970. The order was similar to Writ Petition No. 1253 of 1973 viz. that the petitioner completed 25 years of qualifying service and the retirement was in public interest.

    6. Counsel on behalf of the petitioners contends that the orders are bad because they violate Articles 14, 19(1)(f), 31 and 311.

    7. It is said that Article 14 is violated because there is no guidance as to who will be selected and on what basis the selection will be made for compulsory retirement. The impeached orders are said to violate Article 19(1)(f) because it is an unreasonable restriction on the right to continue until the age of superannuation which is 55 years. It is emphasized that there is a right to continue as long as one is physically fit. The orders of compulsory retirement are challenged to violate Article 31 because it is deprivation of property without authority of law. Lack of authority of law is said to be infraction of Articles 14 and 19. The orders are also said to infringe Article 311 because these are made to remove persons from government service.

    8. Counsel for the petitioners also contended that the Government delegated power under the old rules and, therefore, the orders were bad. It was said in Writ Petition No. 1253 of 1973 that the order was made by the Collector pursuant to delegation under Rule 244(2) of the Rajasthan Service Rules under order dated December 13, 1963. The rules were amended in 1963 and again in 1972 and there was no delegation under the amended rules which governed the parties.

    9. Rule 244(2) of the Rajasthan Service Rules as it stood prior to the 1963 and 1972 amendments is set out in the decision in Ganga Ram v. State of Rajasthan ILR 1961 Raj 371. Rule 244 and the notes thereto are set out hereunder:

    “(1) A government servant may retire from service any time after completing 30 years qualifying service provided that he shall give in this behalf, a notice in writing to the appropriate authority, at least 3 months before the date on which he wishes to retire.
    (2) Government retains an absolute right to retire any government servant after he has completed 25 years qualifying service without giving any reasons and no claim to special compensation on this account will be entertained. This right will not be exercised except when it is in public interest to dispense with further service of a government servant.
    Notes
    1. The right conferred by Rule 244(2) is intended to be exercised only against a government servant whose efficiency is impaired, but against whom it is not desirable to make formal charges of inefficiency or who has ceased to be fully efficient but not to such a degree as to warrant his retirement on compassionate allowance. It is not the intention to use this rule as a financial weapon, that is to say, the provision would be used only in the case of government servants who are considered unfit for retention on personal as opposed to financial grounds.
    2. Compulsory retirement under this rule does not attract the provisions of clause (2) of Article 311 of the Constitution because such retirement is not conceived as a penalty but as the exercise of a right reserved to Government of retiring a government servant after he has served for a certain length of time. Accordingly, the procedure laid down in the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, for formal proceedings against government servants before removing them from service is not meant to apply to such cases.”

    10. Rule 244 was amended by notification dated August 31, 1963 as will appear from Rajasthan Code Vol. I, Part B corrected upto December 31, 1967 Fourth Edition. The amended rule is as follows:

    “244. (1) A government servant may, after giving at least three months' previous notice in writing to the Government, retire from the service on the date on which he completes 30 years of qualifying service or attains the age of 55 years or on any date thereafter to be specified in the notice:
    Provided that a government servant of Class IV can seek retirement only if he has completed 30 years of qualifying service.
    (2) The Government may, after giving him at least three months' previous notice in writing require a government servant to retire from the service on the date on which he completes 25 years of qualifying service or attains the age of 55 years or on any date thereafter to be specified in the notice:
    Provided that a government servant of Class IV can only be required to retire on the date on which he completes 25 years of qualifying service or on any date thereafter.”

    11. Rule 244 was again amended by notification dated August 19, 1972. Rule 244 as amended is set out hereunder:

    “244. (1) government servant may, after giving at least three months' previous notice in writing to the Government, retire from the service on the date on which he completes 30 years of qualifying service or attains the age of 55 years or any date thereafter to be specified in the notice:
    Provided that a government servant of Class IV can seek retirement only if he has completed 30 years of qualifying service.
    (2) The Government may, after giving at least three months' previous notice in writing or by payment of three months' pay and allowances in lieu of such notice require a government servant to retire from the service on the date on which he completes 25 years of qualifying service or on any date thereafter.”

    12. The notes which appeared to Rule 244 before the amendment dated August 31, 1963 remained as notes to Rule 244 after both the amendments dated August 31, 1963 and August 19, 1972. The notes were promulgated along with the Rules by the Rajpramukh under Article 309.

    13. Counsel for the petitioners contended as follows. The job of the permanent employee is not only property but perhaps the only property. Permanence involves the right to continue in service until one attains the age when one renders oneself not physically fit to discharge one's duty. The proper age of superannuation must be fixed on the scientific basis of the normal expectation of life. Rule 244(2) does not prescribe a minimum age for compulsory retirement and thus permits compulsory retirement of a permanent government servant long before the permissible age of superannuation. This is not only removal within the meaning of Article 311 but is also an unguided discretionary and discriminatory power.

    14. With regard to Writ Petition No. 1898 of 1973 it was said that the order was passed though the petitioner had not completed 25 years of government service and the order cast stigma on the conduct and integrity of the petitioner.

    15. In T.G Shivacharana Singh v. State of Mysore AIR 1965 SC 280, (1967) 2 LLJ 246 Rule 285 of the Mysore Civil Service Rules, 1958 which conferred power on the Government to retire compulsorily a government servant in public interest on his completing twenty-five years of qualifying service or attaining fifty years of age, though the age of normal superannuation under Rule 95(a) was fixed at fifty-five years was upheld on the ground that the rule laid down a reasonably long period of qualifying service.

    16. This Court in R.L Butail v. Union of India (1970) 2 SCC 876, (1971) 2 SCR 55 held that there are two exceptions to the protection afforded by Article 311(2). First, where a permanent public servant is asked to retire on the ground that he has reached the age of superannuation which is reasonably fixed. Second, where he is compulsorily retired under rules which prescribe the normal age of superannuation and provide a reasonably long period of qualifying service after which alone compulsory retirement can be ordered. Article 311 deals with termination of service by way of punishment.

    17. In Butail case Fundamental Rule 56(j) conferred power on the Government to pass an order to retire a government servant after he has attained the age of 55 years if the Government is of the opinion that it is in the public interest to do so.

    18. This Court in Union of India v. Col. J.N Sinha (1970) 2 SCC 458, (1971) 1 SCR 791 said that if the authority bona fide formed the opinion to pass an order of retirement the correctness of the opinion could not be challenged though the aggrieved party could contend that the opinion was formed on collateral grounds or was an arbitrary decision.

    19. In Sinha case (1970) 2 SCC 458, (1971) 1 SCR 791 this Court said that compulsory retirement is not taking any penal action. An order of compulsory retirement is really passed after taking into consideration the rights of the government servant on the one hand and the interest of the public which ordinarily coincides with the interest of Government on the other. It is also established that an order of compulsory retirement does not deprive the government servant of benefits earned till the age of his retirement. An order of retirement is really passed on the basis of interest of administrative efficiency.

    20. Rule 244(2) as it stands now does not specifically mention that an order is to be passed in the public interest. The notes to the rule indicate that the right to pass an order of compulsory retirement is to be exercised only against the government servant whose efficiency is impaired and against whom it is not desirable to make formal charges of inefficiency or who has ceased to be fully efficient but not to such a degree as to warrant his retirement on compassionate allowance. The notes further say that it is not the intention to use this rule as a financial weapon, that is to say, that the provision should be used only in the case of government servants who are considered unfit for retention on personal as opposed to financial grounds. The notes are promulgated with the rules in exercise of legislative power. The notes are made contemporaneously with the rules. The function of the notes is to provide procedure and to control discretion. The real purpose of the notes is that when rules are silent the notes will fill up gaps.

    21. This Court in Shyam Lal v. State of U.P AIR 1954 SC 369, (1955) 1 SCR 26 considered Article 465-A and Note-1 appended thereto in the Civil Service Regulations relating to the retiring pensions of officers. Article 465 inter alia stated:

    “A retiring pension is also granted to an officer who is required by Government to retire after completing twenty-five years of service or more.”
    In Shyam Lal case Note 1 which was appended to Article 465-A was not only referred to but relied upon. Note 1 stated:
    “Government retains an absolute right to retire any officer after he has completed 25 years without giving any reason and no claim to special compensation on this account will be entertained.”
    The note further added by amendment later on:
    “The right will not be exercised except when it is in public interest to dispense with the further service of an officer.”
    One of the contentions in Shyam Lal case was that Note 1 was repugnant to Article 311 of the Constitution. This Court did not accept that contention. This Court said the purpose of Note 1 is not to confer on the Government any new right to retire compulsorily an officer on completion of twenty-five years of service but that it is intended to serve as a reminder that the Government has such a right which it means to retain. The reason is that one retains only what one already possesses. The word “retain” shows that it is not a fresh right. The right to retire compulsorily is derived from Rule 4 which conferred on the Government the absolute right to retire an officer who completed twenty-five years service. Article 465-A was based on Rule 4.

    22. In Shivacharana Singh case the order of compulsory retirement was challenged on the ground that Note 1 to Rule 285 in the Mysore Civil Service Rules was not valid. This Court held that the note applied to all government servants and was not open to challenge either under Article 14 or Article 16. The note was given effect to because the note required that the government servant against whom an order of compulsory retirement was proposed to be passed must have completed either 25 years of active service or attained 50 years of age.

    23. The reason why we refer to these two decisions in Shyam Lal AIR 1954 SC 369, (1955) 1 SCR 26 and Shivacharana Singh AIR 1965 SC 280, (1967) 2 LLJ 246 cases is that notes which are appended to rules are of aid not only in applying the rules but also in interpreting the true import of the rules.

    24. In Union of India v. K.P Joseph (1973) 1 SCC 194, (1973) 2 SCR 752 this Court considered the effect of a Government Order. Under that order certain benefits would become applicable to certain persons who completed a number of years of qualifying service. Brother Mathew, speaking for the Court said that although the Government cannot supersede statutory rules by administrative instructions yet if the rules framed under Article 309 of the Constitution are silent on any particular point, the Government can fill up gaps and supplement the rules and issue instructions not inconsistent with the rules already framed and these instructions will govern the conditions of service.

    25. In the present case, the notes are part of the rules because they are for the guidance of the authorities. They are not inconsistent with the rules but are intended to fill up gaps where the rules are silent. The only question here is that formerly the rules said that compulsory retirement would be made in public interest but the present rule does not contain that part of the old rule. The deletion of that part of the rule does not mean that the orders of compulsory retirement are not made in public interest. The notes to the rule make explicit what is implicit in the rules.

    26. The right to be in public employment is a right to hold it according to rules. The right to hold is defeasible according to rules. The rules speak of compulsory retirement. There is guidance in the rules as to when such compulsory retirement is made. When persons complete 25 years of service and the efficiency of such persons is impaired and yet it is desirable not to bring any charge of inefficiency or incompetency, the Government passes orders of such compulsory retirement. The government servant in such a case does not lose the benefits which a government servant has already earned. These orders of compulsory retirement are made in public interest. This is the safety valve of making such orders so that no arbitrariness or bad faith creeps in.

    27. In Appendix 9 to the Rajasthan Service Rules, Vol. II the power to retire government servant after completion of 25 years of service is in the case of ministerial service (gazetted and non-gazetted post) conferred on the appointing authorities. In the present case, the appointing authority is the Collector. The content of the power is not changed by any amendment of the rule. Therefore, the delegation is valid.

    28. There is no stigma in any of the impeached orders of compulsory retirement. Counsel for the petitioners said that the order in Writ Petition No. 1898 of 1973 was passed in the background that the petitioner outlived his utility to Government. The order does not say so. The order does not contain any stigma. It was also said that he was not in continuous employment for 25 years. The petitioner alleged his stage of service should be counted from April 1, 1961. The facts alleged by the State are that the petitioner was appointed as Assistant Cashier with effect from December 5, 1942. He was a minor at that time. He attained 18 years of age on December 4, 1946. He completed his qualifying service of 25 years on December 4, 1971. He has been in continuous service for 25 years.

    29. For these reasons we are of opinion that the orders of compulsory retirement which are challenged do not violate Articles 14, 19, 31 and 311. The writ petitions are dismissed. Parties will pay and bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tara Singh And Others v. State Of Rajasthan And Others
    (Mar 19, 1975)