Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 16(1)(a) of the Act
  • Section 28(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950
  • Section 14 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act 31 of 1952
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 18(1)(a) of the Act
  • Section 18, Part III of the Act
  • Article 71(3)
  • Section 18 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act, 1952
  • Article 71 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 71 (1)
  • Section 18 of the Act
  • The Presidential and Vice-Presidential Elections Act, 1952
  • Article 239-A, Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Chapter IX-A, of the Indian Penal Code
  • Part III and Section 21 of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 16(1)(a) of the Act
  • Section 28(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950
  • Section 14 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act 31 of 1952
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 18(1)(a) of the Act
  • Section 18, Part III of the Act
  • Article 71(3)
  • Section 18 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act, 1952
  • Article 71 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 71 (1)
  • Section 18 of the Act
  • The Presidential and Vice-Presidential Elections Act, 1952
  • Article 239-A, Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Chapter IX-A, of the Indian Penal Code
  • Part III and Section 21 of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Four election petitions were filed in the Supreme Court of India under Section 14 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act, 1952 and Article 71 of the Constitution challenging the election of Shri V.V. Giri as President of India. The petitioners alleged (a) commission of the offences of undue influence and bribery by the returned candidate and his supporters, (b) wrongful acceptance or rejection of multiple nomination papers, (c) unconstitutional exclusion of elected members of Union-Territory legislatures from the electoral college, and (d) the constitutional invalidity of Part III and Section 21 of the Act and Rules 4 and 6(3)(e) framed thereunder. A five-judge Bench (Sikri, Shelat & Vaidialingam JJ.; Bhargava & Mitter JJ. giving separate concurring opinions) heard extensive evidence, framed numerous issues across the four petitions, and delivered the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether specific nomination papers were rightly rejected or accepted by the Returning Officer.
  2. Whether elected members of Union-Territory legislative assemblies were constitutionally entitled to be part of the electoral college for the Presidential election.
  3. Whether Part III and Section 21 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act, 1952, and Rules 4 and 6(3)(e) framed thereunder, are ultra vires the Constitution or amount to excessive delegation of legislative power.
  4. Whether the offences of undue influence and bribery were committed by the returned candidate, his agents, or other persons, and, if so, whether the result of the election was materially affected.
  5. Whether petitioners could challenge the election on grounds not enumerated in Section 18 of the Act, particularly the publication of an allegedly defamatory pamphlet.
  6. What relief, if any, the petitioners were entitled to, including the question of costs.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Act and the relevant Rules curtail the Supreme Court’s jurisdiction under Article 71 and are therefore unconstitutional.
  • The Returning Officer erred in rejecting nomination papers of several candidates and in accepting those of Shri V.V. Giri and others.
  • Members of Union-Territory legislatures are “members of Legislative Assemblies of States” within the meaning of the Constitution and their exclusion vitiated the election.
  • Distribution of a pamphlet containing scurrilous allegations against Shri N. Sanjiva Reddy constituted undue influence/bribery and materially affected the election result.
  • Licensing decisions (e.g., for a polyester factory) amounted to a bribe intended to procure votes.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Act validly regulates the manner in which Article 71 jurisdiction is exercised; Parliament may restrict grounds of challenge under Section 18.
  • All impugned nomination papers were processed strictly in accordance with statutory requirements.
  • Union-Territory legislators are not members of State Legislative Assemblies and were rightly excluded from the electoral college.
  • The pamphlet, even if distributed, did not amount to undue influence and was not shown to have materially affected the election; no evidence established the respondent’s connivance.
  • No act of bribery was committed in connection with the grant of any industrial licence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harman v. Park, (1881) 7 QBD 369 English view that a proposer must sign before assenting electors Distinguished; Indian law on nominations interpreted differently
Cox v. Davies, (1889) 2 QBD 202 English nomination formalities Not followed; Indian practice contrasted
Jamna Prasad v. Sri Krishna Prasad (Doabia’s Election Cases) Validity of nomination signatures Relied upon for Indian approach to nomination forms
Rai Bahadur Prosanna Kumar Das Gupta v. Chittaranjan Das (Doabia) Nomination paper formalities Cited while upholding acceptance of nominations
Mahant Digvijai Math v. Shri Prakash Signature sequence on nomination papers Cited to sustain Returning Officer’s decision
Yanuma Prasad v. Jagdish Prasad Khare, (1957-58) 13 ELR 1 Nomination requirements Referenced in discussion of Issue III
King-Emperor v. Sibnath Banerji, 1945 FCR 195 Effect of phrase “without prejudice to the generality” Used to interpret the breadth of IPC s.171-C on undue influence
N.B. Khare v. Election Commission of India, AIR 1958 SC 139; 1958 SCR 648 Validity of the Act vis-à-vis Article 71 jurisdiction Followed to uphold constitutionality of Part III and s. 21
Ranjit Singh v. Pritam Singh, (1966) 3 SCR 543 Scope of delegated legislation Relied upon to sustain Rule 4(3) and Rule 6(3)(e)
Amolok Chand v. Raghuveer Singh, AIR 1968 SC 1203; (1968) 3 SCR 246 Rule-making power under election statutes Referenced while upholding rules’ validity
Baburao Patel v. Dr Zakir Husain, (1968) 2 SCR 133 Material-effect test and burden of proof Applied in analysing undue influence allegations
Vashist Narain Sharma v. Dev Chandra, (1955) 1 SCR 509 Burden to prove material effect on result Relied upon; petitioners failed to discharge burden
Mahadeo v. Babu Udai Pratap Singh, AIR 1966 SC 824 Material-effect principle Cited with approval
Poakai Haokip v. Rishang, C.A. 683/1968 Material-effect precedent Followed on same point
G.K. Samal v. R.N. Rao, C.A. 1540/1969 Material-effect standard Followed
Surendra Nath Khosla v. Dalip Singh, 1957 SCR 179 Election offences under IPC Referred to in undue influence discussion
Samant N. Balakrishna v. George Fernandez, (1969) 3 SCC 238 Affirmation of Vashist Narain principle Cited; Supreme Court declined to overrule earlier view
Rat Bahadur Surendra Narayan Sinha v. Babu Amulyadhone Roy (Doabia) Undue influence jurisprudence Referenced
Inayatullah v. Diwanchand Mahajan, 5 EIR 219 Historical election-law authority Cited illustratively
Radhakanta Mishra v. Nityananda Mahapatra, 19 ELR 203 Standards for corrupt practice proof Relied upon by Sikri J. and Bhargava J.
Mohammed Sadiq v. Dr Saifuddin Kitchlew (Doabia) Corrupt practices & undue influence Discussed by Mitter J.
Amritsar City Constituency Case No. 2 (1938) Wide scope of “undue influence” Cited by Sikri J.
Lyallpur & Jhang General Constituency Case No. 2(3) Undue influence examples Referenced by Mitter J.
R.K. Shukla v. T.C. Maheshwar, 12 ELR 378 Corrupt practice standards Cited in several opinions
Northern Case, 1 O’M & H 236 English authority on undue influence Referenced by Mitter J.
Amir Chand v. Sucheta Kriplani, 18 ELR 209 Proof required for undue influence Discussed
Katara Takandas Hemraj v. Pinto Frederick Michel, 18 ELR 403 Undue influence Referenced
Mohan Singh v. Banwari Lal, (1964) 5 SCR 12 Standard of proof in election petitions Cited by Mitter J.
Jagdev Singh v. Pratap Singh, AIR 1965 SC 183 Standard of proof Referenced
Satvant Singh N. Balakrishna v. George Fernandez, 1969 (3) SCR 603 Burden of proof & corrupt practices Cited by Mitter J.
Sardal Singh Caveeshar v. Hukum Singh, 6 ELR 316 Undue influence Referenced by Bhargava J.
Jhujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lal, 7 ELR 457 Undue influence Cited by Sikri J. and Bhargava J.
Abdul Rehman Khan v. Radha Krishna Biswas Roy, AIR 1959 Ori 188 Corrupt practice interpretation Cited
Radha Krishna Shukla v. Tara Chand Maheshwar, 12 ELR 378 Undue influence Referenced
Lalroukung v. Haokho Lal Thangjan, C.A. 1315/1968 Material-effect principle Followed
Manubhai Nand Lal Amersey v. Popat Lal Mani Lal Joshi, AIR 1969 SC 734 Burden of proof in election cases Cited
Inder Lal v. Lal Singh, 1962 Supp 3 SCR 114 Publication of false statements Referenced
Ram Dial v. Sant Lal, 1959 Supp 2 SCR 748 Differentiation from English law on undue influence Cited by Bhargava J. and Mitter J.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Nomination Questions: The Court held that (i) the nomination paper of Phul Singh lacked a proposer or seconder, (ii) Shiv Kirpal Singh’s paper was unsupported by a certified electoral-roll copy, (iii) Charan Lal Sahu was under-age, and (iv) Yogi Raj had duplicate proposers; hence all were rightly rejected. Conversely, the nomination papers of Shri V.V. Giri and of other independent candidates were found valid because the accompanying electoral-roll extracts were duly certified and technical objections about signature sequence had no basis in Indian law, the Court expressly distinguishing the English decision in Harman v. Park.

Electoral College Composition: Legislatures created for Union Territories under Article 239-A are not “Legislative Assemblies of States”; their members were therefore rightly excluded from the electoral college. Once this was decided, consequential issues of material effect and Article 14 violation did not arise.

Constitutional Validity of the Act and Rules: Relying on N.B. Khare and principles of delegated legislation, the Bench upheld Part III and Section 21 of the Act and Rules 4 and 6(3)(e), finding no excessive delegation and noting that Parliament, acting under Article 71(3), may limit grounds of challenge.

Scope of Section 18 & Undue Influence: The judges diverged on whether distribution of an anonymous pamphlet could itself amount to “undue influence” under IPC s.171-C as imported by Section 18(2). Sikri J. (for the plurality) held that widespread postal and Central-Hall distribution constituted an “attempt to interfere” with free voting, thus falling within undue influence, though he found no connivance by the respondent and no material effect on the outcome. Bhargava J. considered the pamphlet to fall only under IPC s.171-G (false statements) and therefore outside Section 18. Mitter J. agreed there was wide circulation but insisted that some further act of persuasion was needed to convert mere publication into undue influence.

Material-Effect Test: All opinions agreed that even if an offence were proved, the election could only be voided if the result was materially affected. Following Vashist Narain Sharma and allied cases, the burden lay on the petitioners, and they failed to discharge it.

Bribery Allegations: The Court rejected the claim that grant of a polyester-factory licence to Swadeshi Cotton Mills constituted bribery, finding no evidence of corrupt intent.

Ultra Vires Pamphlet-Ground: The Bench held that petitioners could not enlarge grounds of challenge beyond Section 18; the additional ground of defamatory publication therefore failed at the threshold.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING — ELECTION PETITIONS DISMISSED. No ground was made out to declare the election of Shri V.V. Giri void; each petition accordingly failed. Costs were ordered to be borne by the respective parties, the Court noting that although the pamphlet justified litigation, many witnesses departed from truth.

Implications: The decision affirms (1) the constitutionality of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act and its Rules, (2) the exclusion of Union-Territory legislators from the Presidential electoral college, and (3) the high evidentiary threshold for voiding a Presidential election on grounds of undue influence or bribery. No new legal doctrine was created, but existing principles on material effect, burden of proof, and delegated legislation were reinforced.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh v. Shri V.V Giri .

    SHORT STATEMENT OF THE CASE

    These four election petitions filed under Section 14 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act 31 of 1952 and Article 71 of the Constitution of India challenge the election of the respondent Shri V.V Giri to the office of the President of India. The petitioners seek the declaration that the election be declared void on the ground (1) that the offence of undue influence at the election had been committed by the returned candidate, Shri V.V Giri, and by his supporters with his connivance as mentioned in the various paragraphs of the petition, (2) that the result of the election was materially affected by reason of the offence of undue influence at the election having been committed by various persons at the instance of the respondent, (3) and on several other grounds as envisaged in the ten issues raised hereunder:
    (i) that the nomination papers of candidates Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh, Shri Charan Lal Sahu and Shri Yogi Raj were wrongly rejected by the Returning Officer;
    (ii) that the nomination papers of the respondent were wrongly accepted by the Returning Officer;
    (iii) that the nomination papers of Shri Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, Shri Santosh Singh Kachhwaha, Shri Babu Lal Mag and Shri Ram Dulare Tripathi were wrongly accepted by the Returning Officer;
    (iv) that the offence of undue influence had been committed at the election by the respondent and his supporters with the connivance of the respondent;
    (v) that the result of the election had been materially affected by the commission of the offence of undue influence by persons other than the respondent without his connivance;
    (vi) that the offence of bribery at the election had been committed by the respondent and his supporters with his connivance;
    (vii) that the result of the election had been materially affected by the commission of the offence of bribery by persons other than the respondent;
    (viii) that Part III and Section 21 of the Act are ultra vires the Constitution, as well as Rules 4 and 6(3)(e) of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Elections Rules, 1952, promulgated under Section 21 of the Act, are ultra vires the Constitution and the Act;
    (ix) that the elected Members of the Legislative Assemblies of the Union Territories were entitled to be included in the Electoral College for the election of the President and their wrongful non-inclusion had materially affected the result of the election, as well as it had violated Article 14 of the Constitution; and
    (x) that the petitioners were entitled to dispute the election even on grounds other than those mentioned in Section 18 of the Act viz. that the respondent or any person with his connivance had printed, published and distributed a pamphlet containing scurrilous attacks against the personal and moral character of one of the candidates, Shri N. Sanjiva Reddy, which were false.
    Sikri, J., wrote the judgment for himself and Shelat and Vaidialingam, JJ., While Bhargava, J. and Mitter, J., Issued separate judgments.
    ISSUES AND FINDINGS
    I. Issues 1 and 2 in EP No. 3 of 1969
    1. Whether the nomination paper of Phul Singh, the petitioner, was wrongly rejected?
    2. What relief, if any, is the petitioner entitled to?
    Per Sikri, J.: “We hold that the nomination paper of Shri Phul Singh was rightly rejected on the ground that his nomination paper was not signed either by a proposer or a seconder. Election Petition No. 3 of 1969 accordingly fails and is liable to be dismissed.”
    (Para 4)
    II. Issue 1 in EPs Nos. 1, 4 and 5 of 1969
    EP No. 1: Whether the nomination papers of the petitioner, Charan Lal Sahu and Yogi Raj were wrongly rejected in as alleged in paragraphs 5(a) and (b), 6 and 7 of the petition?
    EP No. 4: Whether the nomination papers of Shiv Kirpal Singh, Charan Lal Sahu and Yogi Raj were wrongly rejected, as alleged in paragraphs 8(a) and 9(a), (b) and (c) of the petition?
    EP No. 5: Whether the nomination papers of Shiv Kirpal Singh, Charan Lal Sahu and Yogi Raj were wrongly rejected as alleged in paragraphs 8(a) and 9 of the petition?
    Per Sikri, J.
    “We hold that the nomination paper of Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh was rightly rejected on the ground that it was not accompanied by a certified copy of the entry relating to him in the electoral roll of the Parliamentary constituency in which he was registered as a voter. We further hold that the nomination paper of Shri Charan Lal Sahu was rightly rejected on the ground that he was not 35 years of age on the date of nomination. We also hold that the nomination paper of Shri Yogi Raj was rightly rejected on the ground that he had been proposed and seconded by the same electors who had proposed and seconded another candidate, Shri Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, the nomination paper of the latter having been received earlier by the Returning Officer.”
    (Para 4)
    III. Issue 2 in EP Nos. 1 and 5 and Issue 3 in EP No. 4 of 1969
    EP No. 1: Whether the nomination papers of the respondent were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 5(c) and 8 of the petition?
    EP No. 4: Whether the nomination papers of the respondent were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 8(c) and 11 of the Petition?
    EP No. 5: Whether the nomination papers of the respondent were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 8(b) and 10 of the petition?
    Per Sikri, J.: “We hold that the nomination papers of the respondent were validly accepted. The certified copies of the electoral roll filed with the nomination papers were issued by the appropriate authority.”
    (Para 4)
    IV. Issue 3 in EPs Nos. 1 and 5 and Issue 2 in EP No. 4 of 1969
    EP No. 1: Whether the nomination papers of Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji and Babu Lal Mag were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 5(d) and 9 of the petition?
    EP No. 4: Whether the nomination papers of Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, Babu Lal Mag and Ram Dulare Tripathi were wrongly accepted as alleged in paras 8(b) and 10(a), (b) and (c) of the petition?
    EP No. 5: Whether the nomination papers of Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, Santosh Singh Kachhwaha, Babu Lal Mag and Ram Dulare Tripathi were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 8(c) and 11 of the petition?
    Per Sikri, J.
    “We hold that the nomination paper of Shri Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji was validly accepted, the certified copy of the electoral roll filed by him was a valid and a good copy. We further hold that the nomination paper of Shri Santosh Singh Kachhwaha was not invalid even though he signed his nomination paper before his seconder had signed it. His nomination paper, therefore, was rightly accepted. We further hold that the nomination paper of Shri Babu Lal Mag was not invalid even though he had signed all nomination paper before it was signed by the proposer and the seconder. His nomination paper was, therefore, rightly accepted. We further hold that the nomination paper of Shri Ram Dulare Tripathi was not invalid. The disputed signatures have not been shown to be not genuine.”
    (Para 4)
    Per Bhargava, J. “Though, in England, in the particular circumstances of the case in Harmon v. Park, it was held that a nomination paper was invalid if signed by the proposer after it had been signed by eight burgesses in token of their assent, the law as to nominations in India has throughout been interpreted differently”.
    (Para 236)
    Distinguishes :
    Harman, v. Park, (1881) 7 QBD 369; Cox v. Davies, (1889) 2 QBD 202.
    Indian cases relied on :
    Jamna Prasadv. Sri Krishna Prasad, Case No. 121, Doabia's Election Cases 1864-1935, p. 79, Vol. II, 1955 Edn; Rai Bahadur Prosanna Kumar Das Gupta v. Chittaranjan Das, Case No. 120, Doabia's Election Cases, 1864-1935, p. 73, Vol. II, 1955 Edn.; Mahant Digvijai Math v. Shri Prakash, Case No. 24, p. 147, Indian Election Cases 1935-51, by Sen and Poddar; Yanuma Prasad v. Jagdish Prasad Khare, (1957-58) 13 ELR 1. (Cases cited in paras 235 to 238).
    V. Issue 4 in EP No. 1 and Issue 7 in EPs Nos. 4 and 5 of 1969
    (a) Whether the elected members of the Legislative Assemblies of the Union Territories were entitled to be included in the electoral college for the election of the President?
    (b) If so, whether the non-inclusion of the members of the Legislative Assemblies of the Union Territories in the electoral college amounts to non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution? If so whether the result of the election has been materially affected by such non-compliance?
    (c) Whether the alleged non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution has violated Article 14 of the Constitution?
    Per Sikri, J.: “We hold that members of Legislatures created for Union Territories under Article 239-A cannot be held to be members of Legislative Assemblies of States. They were, therefore, rightly excluded from the electoral college. Issue 4(a) in Election Petition No. 1 and Issue 7(a) in Election Petitions Nos. 4 and 5 are accordingly decided against the petitioners. In view of this conclusion Issue 4(b) and Issue 4(c) of Election Petition No. 1 and Issue 7(b) and (c) of Election Petitions Nos. 4 and 5 do not arise.”
    (Para 4)
    VI. Issue No 5 in EPs Nos. 1, 4 and 5 of 1969
    EP No. 1: Whether Section 21 of the Act is ultra vires the Constitution of India?
    EPs Nos. 4 and 5 Whether Part III and Section 21 of the Act are ultra vires the Constitution of India
    Per Sikri, J.: “We hold that Part III and Section 21 of the Act are not ultra vires the Constitution of India”.
    (Para 4)
    Per Bhargava, J.: “Even if the argument advanced is accepted that Article 71 (1) defines the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, the manner in which that jurisdiction is to be exercised can only be regulated by an Act of Parliament passed in exercise of its power under Article 71(3). In exercise of that power to regulate all matters relating to or connected with the election of a President or Vice-President Parliament clearly had the power of laying down the grounds on which the election can be challenged and set aside, in addition to other matters relating to the election.”
    (Para 220)
    “The question of validity of the Act was considered by this Court in Dr N.B Khare v. Election Commission of India, where the Court dealt with the contention that the Act and the Rules framed thereunder are void on the ground that they derogate from the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to enquire into and decide all disputes and doubts arising out of or in connection with the election of the President or the Vice-President.”
    (Para 220)
    Relies on: Dr N.B Khare v. Election Commission of India, AIR 1958 SC 139 : 1958 SCR 648
    Per Bhargava, J.
    “The argument that Part III of the Act is ultra vires Article 71 (1) of the Constitution must be rejected.”
    “So far as the validity of Section 21 of the Act is concerned, it was challenged on the ground that the power of making rules suffers from the vice of excessive delegation of legislative powers inasmuch as even essential matters of policy are left to be prescribed by rules by the Government and there are no guiding principles, so that the power can be exercised arbitrarily. It was further stressed that, in the Act, no provision similar to Section 169(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 or Section 28(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, was included by Parliament so as to require that the Rules framed under Section 21 of the Act should be laid before each House of Parliament and that the Rules should be subject to modifications or annulment by Parliament. It is not possible to hold that Section 21 suffers from any such defects.”
    (Paras 221 and 222)
    VII. Issue 6 of EPs Nos. 1, 4 and 5 of 1969
    EPs Nos. 1, 4 and 5: Whether Rules 4 and 6(3)(e) of the Rules are ultra vires the Constitution and the rule-making power of the Central Government?
    Per Sikri, J.
    “We hold that Rule 4(3) of the Rules was validly made by the Government in exercise of its rule-making power under Section 21 of the Act. That rule being valid, Rule 6(3)(e) of the Rules, which is consequential, must also be held to be valid.”
    (Para 4)
    Relies upon: Ranjit Singh v. Pritam Singh, (1966) 3 SCR 543.
    (Para 222)
    Refers to: Amolok Chand v. Raghuveer Singh, AIR 1968 SC 1203 : (1968) 3 SCR 246.
    (Para 227)
    VIII. Issue 8 in EPs Nos. 4 and 5 of 1969
    EP No. 4: (a) Whether the petitioners are entitled to dispute the election of the respondent on grounds other than those mentioned in Section 18 of the Act?
    (b) If Issue 8(a) is decided in favour of the petitioners,
    (i) Whether the respondent or any person with his connivance printed, published and distributed the pamphlet, Annexure A-3, to the petition?
    (ii) Whether the pamphlet, at Annexure A-3, contained any false statement of facts relating to the personal character and conduct of N. Sanjiva Reddy, a candidate at the election and other persons named in the pamphlet?
    (iii) Whether the persons found responsible for publishing the pamphlet believed the statements made therein as true or had reason to believe them to be true?
    (iv) Whether the pamphlet was published with the object of prejudicing the prospects of the election of Sanjiva Reddy and furthering the prospects of the election of the respondent?
    (v) Whether the election of the respondent is liable to be declared void on this ground?
    EP No. 5: Issue 8 in Election Petition No. 5 is substantially the same except that the annexure in Petition No. 5 is Annexure A-38 and not A-3.
    Per Sikri, J.
    “On the first part of Issue 8 we hold that the petitioners are not entitled to dispute the election of the respondent on grounds other than those mentioned in Section 18 of the Act. The other parts of the issues, as a consequence, do not arise at all.”
    (Para 4)
    IX. Issues 9, 9-A and 10 in EP No. 5 of 1969
    9. Whether the respondent or any other person with his connivance committed the offence of bribery as alleged in para 15 of the petition?
    9-A. Whether the allegations in para 15 constitute bribery within the meaning of the Act?
    10. Whether the offence of bribery was committed at the election by any other person without the connivance of the respondent as alleged in para 15 of the petition, and if so, whether it materially affected the result of the election?
    Per Sikri, J.
    “We hold that no offence of bribery was committed in the matter of grant of licence for the Polyester Factory to Swadeshi Cotton Mills.”
    (Para 4)
    X. Issue 4 in EPs Nos. 4 and 5 of 1969
    EP No. 4: (a) Whether all or any of the allegations made in paras 8(e) and 13(a) to (m) of the petition constitute in law an offence of undue influence under Section 18(1)(a) of the Act?
    (b) Whether the said allegations made in paragraphs 8(e) and 13(a) to (m) are true and proved?
    (c) In the event of these allegations being proved and constituting undue influence,
    (i) Whether the returned candidate has committed the offence of undue influence?
    (ii) Whether the offence of undue influence was committed by his workers, and if so, with his connivance?
    (iii) Whether the offence of undue influence was committed by others without his connivance, and if so, whether that has materially affected the result of the election?
    EP No. 5: (a) Whether all or any of the allegations made in paras 8(e) and 13 of the petition constitute in law an offence of undue influence under Section 16(1)(a) of the Act?
    (b) Whether the said allegations in paragraphs 8(e) and 13 are true and proved?
    (c) In the event of these allegations being proved and constituting undue influence —
    (i) Whether the returned candidate has committed the offence of undue influence?
    (ii) Whether the offence of undue influence was committed by his workers, and if so, with his connivance?
    (iii) Whether the offence of undue influence was committed by others without his connivance, and if so, whether that has materially affected the result of the election
    (Para 4)
    From the pleadings and the evidence led the main points which arise for determination are:
    (1) What is the true interpretation of Section 18 of the Act?
    (2) Was the pamphlet distributed by post to the electors?
    (3) Was the pamphlet distributed in the Central Hall of Parliament?
    (4) Does the distribution of the pamphlet by post and/or in the Central Hall constitute undue influence under Section 18 of the Act?
    (5) Was this pamphlet distributed with the connivance of the returned candidate?
    (6) Whether the offence of undue influence was committed by others without his connivance, and if so, whether it had material effect on the result of the election?
    (Para 31)
    i. Per Sikri, J.
    First is the question of interpretation of Section 18. Bhargava, J., has held that the distribution of the pamphlet amounted to an offence under Section 171-G IPC, and not under Section 171-C IPC. According to Mitter, J., distribution of the pamphlet by post and in the Central Hall does not by itself fall within Section 18 of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act, 1952. According to him, before any publication of a defamatory matter relating to a candidate can be treated as commission of the offence of undue influence there must be some overt act in addition to the mere publication — some attempt or persuasion of a voter to restrain the free choice of a candidate before the law of undue influence is attracted. In our opinion, if distribution of the pamphlet by post to electors or in the Central Hall is proved it would constitute “undue influence” within Section 18 and it is not necessary for the petitioners to go further and prove that statements contained in the pamphlet were made the subject of a verbal appeal or persuasion by one member of the electoral college to another and particularly to those in the Congress fold.
    (Para 32)
    ii. Per Sikri, J.
    The Presidential and Vice-Presidential Elections Act, 1952, was passed to regulate certain matters relating to or connected with elections to the office, inter alia, of the President of India. Part III of the Act deals with dispute regarding elections and Section 18 therein contained lays down the grounds for declaring the election of a returned candidate to be void.
    (Paras 32 and 33)
    iii. Per Sikri, J.
    Under Section 18, therefore, the election has to be declared to be void if, amongst other things, undue influence has been committed (i) by the returned candidate himself, (ii) by a person with his connivance, or (iii) by any person who is neither the returned candidate nor one having acted with his connivance, if the result of the election has been materially affected Section 18(2) declared that “for the purposes of this section the offences of bribery and undue influence at an election have the same meaning as in Chapter IX-A, of the Indian Penal Code.
    (Para 33)
    vi. Per Sikri, J.
    Section 171-C is enacted in three parts. The first sub-section contains the definition of “undue influence”. This is in wide terms and renders a person voluntarily interfering or attempting to interfere with the free exercise of any electoral right guilty of committing undue influence. That this is very wide is indicated by the opening sentence of sub-section (2) i.e “without prejudice to the generality of the provisions of sub-section (i)”. It is well-settled that when this expression is used anything contained in the provisions following this expression is not intended to cut down the generality of the meaning of the preceding provision. This was so held by the Privy Council in King-Emperor v. Sibnath Banerji, 1945 FCR 195.
    (Para 37)
    v. Per Sikri, J.
    “The freedom of election is two-fold; (1) freedom in the exercise of judgment. Every voter should be free to exercise his own judgment in selecting the candidate he believes to be best fitted to represent the constituency; (2) Freedom to go and have the means of going to the poll to give his vote without fear or intimidation.” Citation from a book on Elections by Nanak Chand, 1937 Edn., p. 362; do 1950 Edn., p. 263.
    (Para 39)
    vi. Per Sikri, J.
    The above view is supported by the Statement and Reasons attached to the Bill which led to the aforesaid enactment (vide Chapter IX-a). That statement explains in clear language that undue influence was intended to mean voluntary interference or attempted interference with the right of any person to stand or not to stand as or withdraw from being a candidate or to vote or refrain from voting, and that the definition covers all threats of injury to person or property and all illegal methods of persuasion, and any interference with the liberty of the candidates or the electors. “The Legislature has wisely refrained from defining the forms interference may take. The ingenuity of the human mind is unlimited and perforce the nature of interference must also be unlimited.” Ibid Nanak Chand.
    (Para 40)
    vii. Per Sikri, J.
    It is the degree of gravity of the allegation which will be the determining factor in deciding whether it falls under Section 171-C or Section 171-G. If the allegation, though false and relating to a candidate's personal character or conduct, made with the intent to affect the result of an election, does not amount to interference or attempt at such interference, the offence would be the lesser one. If, on the other hand, it amounts to interference or an attempt to interfere it would be the graver offence under Section 171-F read with Section 171-C.
    (Para 41)
    viii. Per Sikri, J.
    “It is true that the definition of undue influence is widely worded and covers all kinds of fraudulent acts or omissions which in any way, directly or indirectly, interfere with the free exercise of any electoral right, and it is also true that the definition extends not only to actual interference but even to an attempt to interference.” Cited from Amritsar City (Mohammadan) Constituency Case No. 2 — Indian Election Cases (1935-50) Doabia's Vol. II, p. 150-57.
    (Para 42)
    Relied on: Jujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lall, 7 ELR 457, 461
    Refers to: Radhakanta Mishra v. Nityananda Mahapatra, 19 ELR 203
    Baburao Patel v. Dr Zakir Husain, (1968) 2 SCR 133, 145
    ix. Per Sikri, J.
    It was said that the pamphlet cannot come under Section 171-C because it was issued anonymously and, therefore, it was not likely to interfere with the choice of the electorate particularly as the electorate consisted of only members of Parliament and members of State Legislatures. This argument is fallacious. First, this has no relevance to the question whether any attempt to interfere with the electoral right has been made or not. Secondly, a series of anonymous attempts in a country like ours would have as much, if not more, effect as one open powerful attempt. It would be dangerous to provide a sanctuary to anonymous attempts. Thirdly, on the facts of this case, can we say that the distribution in the Central Hall is the same thing as anonymous publication? If a member of Parliament distributes a pamphlet, is he not identifying himself with it unless he expressly disassociates himself from the pamphlet? It seems to us that the distribution in the Central Hall by members of Parliament has the same effect as if they had endorsed the pamphlet in writing. We are accordingly of the opinion that distribution of the pamphlet by post as also distribution in the Central Hall constituted an attempt to interfere with the free exercise of the right to vote within Section 18 of the Act.
    (Paras 49, 50)
    x. Per Sikri, J.
    Regarding the question of distribution of pamphlet by post there is overwhelming evidence to show that the pamphlet was widely distributed by post.
    (Para 53)
    xi. Per Sikri, J.
    As to the question of distribution of the pamphlet in the Central Hall, the evidence is extremely conflicting.
    (Para 54)
    (a) Conflicting evidence as to Shri Yunus Saleem distributing the pamphlet or giving it to 11 witnesses in the Central Hall of Parliament.
    (Paras 70 to 79)
    Shri Yunus Saleem himself has completely contradicted the evidence of all the 11 witnesses.
    (Para 80)
    (b) Conflicting evidence as to Shri Krishan Kant distributing the pamphlet.
    (Paras 81 to 84)
    (c) Conflicting evidence as to Shri Chandra Sekhar distributing the pamphlet.
    (Paras 85 to 87)
    (d) Conflicting evidence as to Shri Mohan Dharia distributing the pamphlet.
    (Paras 88 to 90)
    (e) Evidence as to Shri Amrit Nahata's part in distributing the pamphlet.
    (Paras 91 to 94)
    (f) Evidence as to five other distributors.
    (Paras 95 to 114)
    Viewing the evidence as a whole we are of the opinion that the pamphlet was distributed by post and in the Central Hall of Parliament by some members of Parliament and there was wide discussion about it in the Central Hall. As we have mentioned earlier, the evidence of the witnesses of the petitioners that there was distribution in the Central Hall is corroborated by contemporaneous documents. On the question as to who were the persons who were distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall it is not, in our opinion, necessary for us to arrive at a finding from a mass of evidence which is both conflicting and partisan.
    (Paras 124 and 125)
    xii. Per Sikri, J.
    There is contradictory evidence as to the pamphlet being brought to the notice of Shri V.V Giri by Shri R.K Gupta, or Smt Tarkeshwari Sinha or Shri N.P.C Naidu. Their evidence cannot be accepted in preference to Shri V.V Giri's, which is corroborated by the evidence of the Security Officers.
    (Paras 140 and 141)
    xiii. Per Sikri, J.
    As to connivance by Shri V.V Giri, there is no evidence whatsoever that there was any intimate connection between him and the alleged distributors. What they were doing in this connection they were doing on their own and Shri Giri cannot be held responsible for their deeds unless, of course, it is established that the result of the election had been materially affected by the distribution of the pamphlet. It is well settled that the burden of proving that the result of the election has been materially affected is on the petitioners.
    (Paras 145 and 146)
    Relies on :
    Vashist Narain Sharma v. Dev Chandra, (1955) 1 SCR 509; Mahadeo v. Babu Udai Pratap Singh, AIR 1966 SC 824; Poakai Haokip v. Rishang, CA No. 683 of 1968, decided on 12-8-1968; G.K. Samal v. R. .N. Rao, CA No. 1540 of 1969, decided on 20-1-1970.
    Refers to :
    Surendra Nath Khosla v. Dalip Singh, 1957 SCR 179; Samant N. Balakrishna v. George, Fernandez, (1969) 3 SCC 238; Rat Bahadur Surendra Narayan Sinha v. Babu Amulyadhone Roy, Doabia's Indian Election Cases, (1935-1950), Vol. II, pp. 368-78; Inayatullah v. Diwanchand Mahajan 5 EIR 219
    (Para 147)
    Samant N. Balakrishan case relies on Vashist Narain case which the Supreme Court declined to overrule. Sikri, J., added, “Parliament knowing of the view, held by the various commissioners and Judges, have failed to intervene and it is not for us to legislate.”
    xiv. Per Sikri, J.
    On the evidence adduced it is difficult to hold that the petitioners have proved that the publication and distribution of the pamphlet materially affected the result of the election. It only leads to the conclusion that it probably did have some effect but the vast majority of the electors were able to throw off the effect of the pamphlet and vote according to their own personal wish or according to the mandate of their party. In the result we hold that it has not been proved that the result of the election was materially affected by the publication and distribution of the pamphlet.
    (Paras 151 and 154)
    xv. Per Sikri, J.
    That Shri Dinesh Singh, Minister of External Affairs went to Lucknow to influence the ML As on behalf of Sri V.V Giri is not proved.
    (Paras 155 to 177)
    xvi. Per Sikri, J.
    That Shri V.V Giri tried to influence personally the ML As and M. Ps. is not proved.
    (Paras 178 to 195)
    xvii. Per Sikri, J.
    In conclusion we hold that the pamphlet was sent by post. Further, the pamphlet was distributed in the Central Hall of Parliament. This distribution itself constitutes undue influence within Section 18(1)(a) of the Act. It is, however, not proved that this pamphlet was distributed by workers of the respondent, or with the connivance of the returned candidate. We further hold that it has not been proved that the result of the election has been materially affected by the distribution of the pamphlet. The rest of the allegations either do not amount to undue influence or were not proved.
    (Para 212)
    xviii. Per Bhargava, J.: (Summing up on undue influence)
    The principal charge of undue influence, on which a mass of evidence has been led by the petitioners, relates to the publication of a pamphlet which contained scurrilous and vulgar allegations as to the personal character of Shri Sanjiva Reddy. It is not necessary for me to set out the details of the contents of that pamphlet. It is sufficient to mention that, apart from allegations against Shri Sanjiva Reddy, there were no other allegations in it which could amount to a threat of any adverse consequence to any voter in case he cast his vote in favour of Shri Reddy. Even in the evidence, no witness stated that, as a result of reading this pamphlet, he apprehended any adverse consequence either to himself or to anyone in whom he may be interested. No doubt, some witnesses stated that, on reading the pamphlet, they felt that, if Shri Sanjiva Reddy is elected as President, the Rashtrapati Bhavan may become a brothel; but that also does not amount to a threat of a nature which would constitute undue influence as explained above. Consequently, the publication of this pamphlet cannot constitute undue influence, so that it is totally unnecessary to go into the question whether it was printed, published and distributed at all; if so, by whom, and further, whether such printing, publication or distribution was or was not with the connivance of the respondent. As I have held earlier, in the Act there is no provision made for setting aside election on the ground of publication of false statements as to the personal conduct or character of a candidate even if it affects his prospects in the election, so that no evidence need have been taken with regard to the printing, publication or distribution of this pamphlet or with regard to the question as to whether there was any connivance by the respondent in its printing, publication or distribution. The challenge to the election of the respondent based on this petition fails on this preliminary ground. However, I may add that, having had the benefit of reading the judgment proposed to be delivered by my Brother Sikri, J., on these issues, I agree with his assessment of the evidence tendered by the parties and the findings recorded by him. These findings of fact are to the effect that, though the pamphlet was distributed by post and in the Central Hall of Parliament, it has not been proved that this distribution was with the connivance of the respondent or that the distribution materially affected the result of the election. Consequently, even on the assumption that the publication of this pamphlet could constitute undue influence, the election of the respondent is not liable to be set aside.
    (Para 267)
    Relies on :
    Baburao Patel v. Dr Zakir Husain, (1968) 2 SCR 133, 145; Ram Dial v. Sant Lal, (1959) Supp 2 SCR 748 (differs from English Law); Inder Lal v. Lal Singh, (1962) Supp 3 SCR 114; Lalroukung v. Haokho Lal Thangjan, CA No. 1315 of 1968, decided on 9-1-1969; Manubhai Nand Lal Amersey v. Popat Lal Mani Lal Joshi, AIR 1969 SC 734; Rodhakanta Mishra v. Nityananda Mahapatra, 19 ELR 203
    Refers to :
    Sardal Singh Caveeshar v. Hukum Singh, 6 ELR 316; Jhujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lal, 7 ELR 457; Abdul Rehman Khan v. Radha Krishna Biswas Roy, AIR 1959 Ori 188; Amir Chand Tota Ram v. Sucheta Kriplani, AIR 1961 Punj 383 : 18 ELR 299; Radha Krishna Shukla v. Tara Chand Maheshwar, 12 ELR 378; Katara Takandas Hemraj v. Pinto Frederick Michel, 18 ELR 403
    xix. Per Mitter, J.: (Summing up at to undue influence)
    My conclusion therefore on the issues regarding undue influence may be summed up as follows. There was a fair amount of circulation of the pamphlet, in the Central hall of Parliament among members of the electoral college by a number of them. Undeniably there was considerable publication of it by post both to electors in Delhi and outside. The mere dissemination of the pamphlet did not amount to exercise of any undue influence or interference with any electoral right. It had to be followed up either by a personal verbal appeal or an appeal in writing but there was no evidence thereof in this case. There was no appeal to Muslim members on grounds of religion to vote in favour of the respondent in preference to Sri Sanjeeva Reddy. There was no evidence of exercise of undue influence by Central Ministers over any members of the electoral college by any threat that in case they failed to vote for the respondent they would lose the patronage of the Prime Minister. The offence of undue influence, was not committed by the respondent or any of his workers. The respondent himself was not guilty of any such commission. There was no commission of the offence of undue influence by anybody with the connivance of the respondent and the result of the election was not materially affected as a result of any commission of the offence of undue influence.
    (Para 346)
    Cases referred to as to corrupt practices and undue influence:
    Shri Mohammed Sadiq v. Dr Saifuddin Kitchlew, Doabia's Election Cases, Vol. II, p. 117; In Amritsar City (Mohammadan) Constituency Case No. 2(2). The Indian Election Cases of Doabia, Vol. 2, p. 150, dated 28th September, 1938; Lyallpur and Jhang General Constituency Case No. 2(3), Doabia's Election Cases, Vol. II, 243 at 256; R.K Shukla v. T. C, Maheshwar, 12 ELR 378 at 415; Northern Case, 1 O'M & H 236 at 242; Amir Chand v. Sucheta Kriplani, 18 ELR 209;
    Kataria Takandas Hemraj v. Pinto Fredrick Michael, 18 ELR 403; Radhakrishna Mishra v. Nityananda Mahapatra, 19 ELR 203; Abdul Rahim v. Radha Krishna, AIR 1959 Ori 188; Ram Dial v. Sant Lal, 1959 Supp 2 SCR 748; Inder Lal v. Lal Singh, 1962 Supp 2 SCR 114; Baburao v. Zakir Husain, (1968) 2 SCR 133
    Per Mitter, J.
    The above citation of the cases is in our view sufficient to reject the contention of Mr Daphtary that in order to establish undue influence it must be shown that there was some threat to a voter or at least an element of compulsion in the appeal to him. The cases also show that it would be futile to attempt to lay down a simple test applicable to all sets of facts and circumstances where undue influence is alleged to have been exercised.
    (Para 306)
    The court should come to conclusion on the issues framed and evidence adduced not on the balance probabilities but on the strength of the direct evidence adduced.
    Refers to :
    Mohan Singh and Others v. Banivari Lal; 1964 (5) SCR 12; Jagdev Singh v. Pratap Singh, AIR 1965 SC 183; Satvant Singh N. Balakrishna v. George Fernandez, 1969 (3) SCR 603
    xx. Per Mitter, J.
    Inasmuch as I have come to the conclusion that the evidence adduced does not establish the exercise of undue influence in the election in any of the forms raised in the petition, the question of the result of the election being materially affected thereby does not arise. But I may point out that in order to substantiate such a ground for setting aside an election it is not enough for witnesses to come and say that they were shocked or pained by reading the pamphlet as most of them gave out.
    (Para 345)
    XI. Issue 7 in EP No. 1 of 1969, Issue 9 in EP No. 4 of 1969 and Issue 11 in EP No. 5 of 1969
    What relief, if any, are the petitioners entitled to?
    Per Sikri, J.
    The petitioners are not entitled to any relief as no ground has been made out for declaring the election of the respondent to be void.
    (Para 213)
    XII. Issue as to Costs.
    Per Sikri, J.
    In our order, dated May 11, 1970, we had directed that the parties will bear their own costs. We passed this order regarding costs because we were satisfied that the pamphlet had been sent by post and distributed in the Central Hall and this justified the petitioners in bringing the two main petitions. Most of the evidence which was led in Court dealt with the question of the distribution of the pamphlet. Further, as pointed out in the judgment, a number of witnesses have not told the whole truth. As a matter of fact we were distressed to see truth being sacrificed at the altar of political advantage by these witnesses.
    (Para 214)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh v. Shri V.V Giri .
    (Sep 14, 1970)