| Harman v. Park, (1881) 7 QBD 369 |
English view that a proposer must sign before assenting electors |
Distinguished; Indian law on nominations interpreted differently |
| Cox v. Davies, (1889) 2 QBD 202 |
English nomination formalities |
Not followed; Indian practice contrasted |
| Jamna Prasad v. Sri Krishna Prasad (Doabia’s Election Cases) |
Validity of nomination signatures |
Relied upon for Indian approach to nomination forms |
| Rai Bahadur Prosanna Kumar Das Gupta v. Chittaranjan Das (Doabia) |
Nomination paper formalities |
Cited while upholding acceptance of nominations |
| Mahant Digvijai Math v. Shri Prakash |
Signature sequence on nomination papers |
Cited to sustain Returning Officer’s decision |
| Yanuma Prasad v. Jagdish Prasad Khare, (1957-58) 13 ELR 1 |
Nomination requirements |
Referenced in discussion of Issue III |
| King-Emperor v. Sibnath Banerji, 1945 FCR 195 |
Effect of phrase “without prejudice to the generality” |
Used to interpret the breadth of IPC s.171-C on undue influence |
| N.B. Khare v. Election Commission of India, AIR 1958 SC 139;
1958 SCR 648 |
Validity of the Act vis-à-vis Article 71 jurisdiction |
Followed to uphold constitutionality of Part III and s. 21 |
| Ranjit Singh v. Pritam Singh, (1966) 3 SCR 543 |
Scope of delegated legislation |
Relied upon to sustain Rule 4(3) and Rule 6(3)(e) |
| Amolok Chand v. Raghuveer Singh, AIR 1968 SC 1203;
(1968) 3 SCR 246 |
Rule-making power under election statutes |
Referenced while upholding rules’ validity |
| Baburao Patel v. Dr Zakir Husain, (1968) 2 SCR 133 |
Material-effect test and burden of proof |
Applied in analysing undue influence allegations |
| Vashist Narain Sharma v. Dev Chandra, (1955) 1 SCR 509 |
Burden to prove material effect on result |
Relied upon; petitioners failed to discharge burden |
| Mahadeo v. Babu Udai Pratap Singh, AIR 1966 SC 824 |
Material-effect principle |
Cited with approval |
| Poakai Haokip v. Rishang, C.A. 683/1968 |
Material-effect precedent |
Followed on same point |
| G.K. Samal v. R.N. Rao, C.A. 1540/1969 |
Material-effect standard |
Followed |
| Surendra Nath Khosla v. Dalip Singh, 1957 SCR 179 |
Election offences under IPC |
Referred to in undue influence discussion |
| Samant N. Balakrishna v. George Fernandez, (1969) 3 SCC 238 |
Affirmation of Vashist Narain principle |
Cited; Supreme Court declined to overrule earlier view |
| Rat Bahadur Surendra Narayan Sinha v. Babu Amulyadhone Roy (Doabia) |
Undue influence jurisprudence |
Referenced |
| Inayatullah v. Diwanchand Mahajan, 5 EIR 219 |
Historical election-law authority |
Cited illustratively |
| Radhakanta Mishra v. Nityananda Mahapatra, 19 ELR 203 |
Standards for corrupt practice proof |
Relied upon by Sikri J. and Bhargava J. |
| Mohammed Sadiq v. Dr Saifuddin Kitchlew (Doabia) |
Corrupt practices & undue influence |
Discussed by Mitter J. |
| Amritsar City Constituency Case No. 2 (1938) |
Wide scope of “undue influence” |
Cited by Sikri J. |
| Lyallpur & Jhang General Constituency Case No. 2(3) |
Undue influence examples |
Referenced by Mitter J. |
| R.K. Shukla v. T.C. Maheshwar, 12 ELR 378 |
Corrupt practice standards |
Cited in several opinions |
| Northern Case, 1 O’M & H 236 |
English authority on undue influence |
Referenced by Mitter J. |
| Amir Chand v. Sucheta Kriplani, 18 ELR 209 |
Proof required for undue influence |
Discussed |
| Katara Takandas Hemraj v. Pinto Frederick Michel, 18 ELR 403 |
Undue influence |
Referenced |
| Mohan Singh v. Banwari Lal, (1964) 5 SCR 12 |
Standard of proof in election petitions |
Cited by Mitter J. |
| Jagdev Singh v. Pratap Singh, AIR 1965 SC 183 |
Standard of proof |
Referenced |
| Satvant Singh N. Balakrishna v. George Fernandez, 1969 (3) SCR 603 |
Burden of proof & corrupt practices |
Cited by Mitter J. |
| Sardal Singh Caveeshar v. Hukum Singh, 6 ELR 316 |
Undue influence |
Referenced by Bhargava J. |
| Jhujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lal, 7 ELR 457 |
Undue influence |
Cited by Sikri J. and Bhargava J. |
| Abdul Rehman Khan v. Radha Krishna Biswas Roy, AIR 1959 Ori 188 |
Corrupt practice interpretation |
Cited |
| Radha Krishna Shukla v. Tara Chand Maheshwar, 12 ELR 378 |
Undue influence |
Referenced |
| Lalroukung v. Haokho Lal Thangjan, C.A. 1315/1968 |
Material-effect principle |
Followed |
| Manubhai Nand Lal Amersey v. Popat Lal Mani Lal Joshi, AIR 1969 SC 734 |
Burden of proof in election cases |
Cited |
| Inder Lal v. Lal Singh, 1962 Supp 3 SCR 114 |
Publication of false statements |
Referenced |
| Ram Dial v. Sant Lal, 1959 Supp 2 SCR 748 |
Differentiation from English law on undue influence |
Cited by Bhargava J. and Mitter J. |