Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1966 INSC 268
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
  • Section 4(3) of the Debtors Act 1869
  • ss. 9, 15, 18, 46 and 48 of the Indian Partnership Act 1932
  • ss. 88, 94 and 95 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882
  • cl. (c) of the _proviso to s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1966 INSC 268
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
  • Section 4(3) of the Debtors Act 1869
  • ss. 9, 15, 18, 46 and 48 of the Indian Partnership Act 1932
  • ss. 88, 94 and 95 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882
  • cl. (c) of the _proviso to s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Prem Ballabh Khulbe, the respondent, Mathura Datt Bhatt, and two others operated a partnership business known as “Nayagaon Farm.” The respondent acted as the managing partner and had control over the partnership assets. After the firm was dissolved, the appellant filed a suit for taking accounts of the dissolved firm. A final decree was eventually passed in favour of the appellant for Rs. 17,143/11/0 and Rs. 3,171/6-0 as costs against the respondent.

Seeking to execute this money decree, the appellant applied for the respondent’s arrest and detention in civil prison under clause (c) of the proviso to section 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (“CPC”). The executing court found that clause (c) was satisfied and issued a warrant of arrest. On appeal, the Allahabad High Court set aside that order. The appellant then appealed to the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree against the respondent, a managing partner, was “for a sum for which the judgment-debtor was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account” within the meaning of clause (c) of the proviso to section 51 CPC, thus justifying execution by arrest and detention.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Relied on sections 9, 15, 18, 46 and 48 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 and sections 88, 94 and 95 of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 to contend that the managing partner stands in a fiduciary capacity toward the other partners.
  • Submitted that, because the respondent controlled partnership assets, the decree represented sums he was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account for, bringing the case squarely under clause (c) of section 51 CPC.

Respondent’s Arguments

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Piddocke v. Burt, [1894] 1 Ch. 343 A partner who fails to pay partnership money is not acting in a “fiduciary capacity.” Approved as correctly stating that mere partnership does not create the fiduciary relationship contemplated by s. 51(c) CPC.
Rodriguez v. Speyer Brothers, [1919] A.C. 59 Affirmed Piddocke; partners are not trustees for one another merely by virtue of partnership. Cited with approval to reinforce that detention cannot be ordered on fiduciary grounds absent special circumstances.
Bhuban Mohan Rana v. Surender Mohan Das, I.L.R. 1952 (2) Cal. 123 Indian authority endorsing the English position that partners are ordinarily not fiduciaries for the purpose of detention provisions. Relied on to support dismissal of the appellant’s contention.
Velji Raghavji Patel v. State of Maharashtra, [1965] 2 S.C.R. 429 Reaffirmed the non-fiduciary status of partners absent fraud or special circumstances. Approved to buttress the conclusion that s. 51(c) was inapplicable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice R. S. Bachawat, delivering the judgment of the Court, began by analyzing the text and purpose of clause (c) of the proviso to section 51 CPC, which permits arrest in execution only when the decree is for a sum for which the judgment-debtor was bound to account in a fiduciary capacity. The Court reasoned as follows:

  1. Partnership law, as reflected in the Indian Partnership Act, obliges partners to act in good faith and render accounts, but does not, per se, make one partner a trustee of the other partners’ property.
  2. Halsbury’s Laws of England (Vol. 38, Art. 1363) was quoted to state that partnership “does not create a fiduciary relation” unless special circumstances exist.
  3. The Court reviewed the English and Indian precedents cited above, all of which hold that failure to account by a partner is not a breach of a fiduciary obligation of the kind required for detention under s. 51(c).
  4. In the instant case, the respondent merely overdrew the partnership account; no allegation or proof of fraud or clandestine dealing was made.
  5. Consequently, the decree represented an ordinary money claim between partners, not a sum held in trust or other fiduciary capacity. Therefore, the statutory condition for arrest under s. 51(c) CPC was not met.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Allahabad High Court’s decision, holding that clause (c) of the proviso to section 51 CPC did not apply because the respondent, as a managing partner, was not accountable in a fiduciary capacity for the decretal amount. The immediate effect is that the warrant for the respondent’s arrest stands quashed, and execution must proceed, if at all, by other modes. The Court set no new precedent but reaffirmed existing jurisprudence that partnership, without more, does not create the fiduciary relationship contemplated by s. 51(c) CPC.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Prem Ballabh Khulbe v. Mathura Datt Bhatt

    http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 3

    PETITIONER:

    PREM BALLABH KHULBE

    Vs.

    RESPONDENT:

    MATHURA DATT BHATT

    DATE OF JUDGMENT:

    16/12/1966

    BENCH:

    BACHAWAT, R.S.

    BENCH:

    BACHAWAT, R.S.

    WANCHOO, K.N.

    SHELAT, J.M.

    CITATION:

    1967 AIR 1342 1967 SCR (2) 298

    ACT:

    Code of Civil Procedure (Act 5 of 1908), cl. (c) of the proviso to s. 51--Partners--If in fiduciary relationship.

    HEADNOTE:

    The partnership business carried on by the appellant, respondent and two others was dissolved. The appellant obtained a final decree for certain sums against the respondent, who was the managing partner of the partnership assets. The appellant applied for the execution of the decree by arrest and detention of the respondent in prison. The executing court held that the provisions of cl. (c) of the proviso to s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure were satisfied and issued a warrant for the arrest of the 'respondent. The High Court set aside this order. On appeal, this Court.

    HELD:The appeal must be dismissed.

    In the absence of special circumstances a partner cannot. be regarded as a kind of trustee for the other partners or liable to render accounts to them in a fiduciary capacity.

    [300 D]

    In the present case, the conditions of cl. (c.) of the proviso to s. 51 were not satisfied. No fraud or clandestine dealing was alleged or proved. The facts did not disclose that the decree was for a sum for which the respondent was bound to account in a fiduciary capacity.

    [300 E]

    Piddocke v. Burt, Chitty, [1894] 1 Ch. 343, Rodriquez v. Speyer Brothers, [1919] A.C. 59, Bhuban Mohan Rana v. Surender Mohan Das, I.L.R. [1952] 2 Cal. 123 and Velji Raghavji Patel v. State of Maharashtra [1965] 2 S.C.R. 429, approved.

    JUDGMENT:

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 615 of

    1964.

    Appeal from the judgment and decree dated March 3, 1960 of the Allahabad High Court in Execution First Appeal No. 332 of 1956.

    1

    C. B. Agarwala and K. P. Gupta for the appellant. S. G. Patwardhan, Yashpal Singh and M. S. Gupta for the respondent.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by Bachawat, J. The appellant, the respondent and two other persons carried on business in partnership under the name and style of Nayagaon Farm. The respondent was the managing partner and was incharge of the partnership assets. The firm was dissolved and a suit was instituted by the appellant for the taking of the accounts of the dissolved firm. Eventually a final decree

    299

    was passed in the suit in favour of the appellant against the respondent for Rs. 1 7,143 /1 I /0 and Rs. 3,171 /6 as on account of costs The appellant applied for execution of the decree by arrest and detention of the respondent in prison. In this affidavit in support of the application, the appellant relied upon the grounds mentioned in clauses

    (a) and (b) of the proviso to s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908. At the hearing of the application those grounds were not pressed but his counsel relied upon the ground mentioned in cl. (c) of the proviso. By cl. (c) of the proviso to s. 51, the court is empowered to order execution of a money decree by detention of the judgment debtor in prison if it is satisfied "that the decree is for a sum for which the judgment debtor was bound in a, fiduciary capacity to account". The executing court held that the provisions of cl. (c) were satisfied and issued a warrant for the arrest of the respondent. On appeal, the High Court of Allahabad, set aside this order. The decree holder now appeals to this court under a certificate granted by the High Court.

    On behalf of the appellant our attention was drawn to ss. 9, 15, 18, 46 and 48 of the Indian Partnership Act 1932 and ss. 88, 94 and 95 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882, and it was urged that the respondent as the managing partner of the firm was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account for the assets of the partnership in his hands and the decree against him must be regarded as a decree for a sum for which he was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account. On the question whether a fiduciary relation exists between, the partners, the law is stated thus in Halsbury's Laws of England 3rd Edition, Vol. 38, art. 1363, p. 820 :

    "Partnership itself does not create a fiduciary relation between the partners or make one of them a trustee for the other or for his representatives. The relation may, however, arise on the death of one of them or be created by other special circumstances."

    This statement of law is consistent with the provisions of the Indian Partnership Act 1932 and the Indian Trusts Act

    1882.

    In Piddocke v. Burt. (1) Chitty, J. held that a partner failing to pay moneys in his hands and received by him on account of the partnership was not liable to be imprisoned under s. 4(3) of the Debtors Act 1869 as a person "acting in a fiduciary capacity" within the meaning of that statute. He said :

    "I should be straining the law if I were to hold that a partner receiving money on account of the partnership-that is, on behalf of himself and his co-partners-

    (1) [1894] 1 ch. 343

    300

    received it in a fiduciary capacity towards

    2

    the other partners. The law allows one partner-one of several joint creditors-to receive the whole debt on account of the firm to whom it is due, and I am unable to recognise any such distinction, as was endeavoured to be made by Mr. Church, between the case of a partner receiving money of the firm and not accounting for it, and that of a partner over-drawing the partnership account; because if this distinction were true, it would apply to every case where one partner wrongly over draws the partnership account."

    This decision was approved of by Lord Atkinson in Rodriguez

    v. Speyer Brothers,(1) and by Harries, C. J. in Bhuban Mohan Rana v. Surender Mohan Das.(2) The last case received the approval observe the utmost good faith in his dealings with the other partners. He is bound to render accounts of the partnership assets in his hands. But in the absence of special circumstances he cannot be regarded as a kind of trustee for the other partners or liable to render accounts to them in a fiduciary capacity.

    In the present case, the respondent as the managing partner was liable to render accounts of the partnership assets in his hands. .,On the taking of the accounts it was found that he overdrew the partnership account and a decree for the sum due was passed against him. No fraud or clandestine dealing is alleged or proved. On these facts it is not possible to say that the decree was for a sum for which he was bound to account in a fiduciary capacity. The High Court rightly held that the conditions of cl. (c) of the _proviso to s. 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure were not satisfied. The appeal is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.

    Y.P. Appeal dismissed.

    (1) [1919] A.C. 9,59 89.

    (2) I.L.R. 1952 (2) Cal. 23.

    (3) [1965] 2 S.C.R. 429.

    301

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prem Ballabh Khulbe v. Mathura Datt Bhatt
    (Dec 16, 1966)