AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 24, with explanation to the Stamp Act
  • Section 24 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899
  • Section 24 of the Stamp Act
  • 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the excerpt, but mentioned as a reference)
  • Article 23, of the Stamp Act
  • Section 57 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899
  • Section 24, Article 23
  • Article 18 of Schedule I
  • Section 73, Statute 16 and 17 Vict.
  • Section 107 of the Kanpur Development Act, 1945
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 24, with explanation to the Stamp Act
  • Section 24 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899
  • Section 24 of the Stamp Act
  • 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the excerpt, but mentioned as a reference)
  • Article 23, of the Stamp Act
  • Section 57 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899
  • Section 24, Article 23
  • Article 18 of Schedule I
  • Section 73, Statute 16 and 17 Vict.
  • Section 107 of the Kanpur Development Act, 1945
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The vendors, lessees of two plots of land in Kanpur, had built and were operating Sri Govind Oil Mills and an Ice & Cold Storage Factory. These assets were equitably mortgaged to the Chartered Bank of India for a debt of Rs 10,00,000. To discharge this debt the vendors contracted on 15 December 1952 to sell the lands, buildings, plants, machinery, stores and goodwill to Messrs Oil Corporation of India Ltd. (“the vendees”) for Rs 5,55,000, of which Rs 1,00,000 related to the buildings and leasehold rights. The vendees agreed to pay Rs 4,89,000 to the Bank and the vendors undertook to pay the balance Rs 11,000.

Before execution of the conveyance the vendees had already paid Rs 3,89,000 to the Bank and taken possession of the movable assets. On 15 December 1952 the sale deed transferring only the immovable property (buildings and leasehold rights) was executed for a stated consideration of Rs 1,00,000. Clause 2 of the deed recited that the property was conveyed free of encumbrances except for the Bank’s charge, which would be discharged in the agreed manner.

The Board of Revenue, doubting the adequacy of the stated consideration for stamp-duty purposes, made a reference to the Allahabad High Court under Section 57 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. The High Court held that the consideration for the conveyance was Rs 1,00,000 and that stamp duty was chargeable only on that amount. Challenging this view, the Board of Revenue obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, for the purposes of ad valorem stamp duty, the sale consideration should be taken as (a) Rs 10,00,000 (the total mortgage debt), (b) Rs 5,55,000 (the composite contract price), or (c) Rs 1,00,000 (the amount stated in the conveyance).
  2. Whether Section 24 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, and its Explanation treating “unpaid mortgage money” as consideration, applied to the transaction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Board of Revenue)

  • Invoked Section 24 to contend that the unpaid mortgage amount must be added to the consideration, asserting that the true consideration was either Rs 10,00,000, Rs 5,55,000, or at least Rs 1,11,000.
  • Argued that stamp duty cannot be avoided by paying mortgage dues shortly before the execution of the conveyance; such prior payments should still be treated as part of the consideration.

Respondent (Executant/Vendor)

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments beyond reliance on the High Court’s view that only Rs 1,00,000 was chargeable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.K. Janardhana Rao v. Secretary of State, ILR 58 Cal 33 (1931) Phrase “subject to a mortgage” in Section 24 qualifies the word “sale”, not “property”. Relied on to hold that Section 24 applies only where the property is sold subject to an existing mortgage that remains unpaid after the sale.
Waman Martand Bhalerao v. Commissioner, Central Division (Bombay) Same interpretative principle as above regarding Section 24. Cited in support of a strict, taxpayer-favourable construction of the Stamp Act.
Commissioners of Inland Revenue v. Liquidators of City of Glasgow Bank, 8 Ct. of Sess. Cases (1881) Rationale for adding unpaid secured debt to consideration to prevent evasion of ad valorem duty. Quoted to explain the legislative purpose behind Section 24 but distinguished on facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice Sikri approached the question by first identifying the purpose behind Section 24: preventing evasion of stamp duty where property is sold subject to an unpaid mortgage by treating that unpaid sum as part of the consideration.

The Court then analysed the critical phrase “sale of property subject to a mortgage” and, in line with the Calcutta and Bombay precedents, held that the Explanation to Section 24 applies only when the mortgage continues to burden the property after the sale. Where the property is conveyed free of the charge, the unpaid mortgage money is not automatically added.

Applying this construction to the facts, the Court found:

  • Rs 3,89,000 already paid by the vendees before 15 December 1952 related to movable assets, not to the immovable property conveyed by the impugned deed, and therefore did not fall within Article 23.
  • The balance Rs 11,000 was an obligation assumed by the vendors, not the vendees; the property was expressly sold free from this charge, so the sale was not “subject to” the mortgage. Section 24 was therefore inapplicable.
  • Consequently, only the expressly stated consideration of Rs 1,00,000 for the buildings and leasehold rights constituted the base for ad valorem duty under Article 23.

The Court emphasised that the Stamp Act is a taxing statute to be strictly construed, and where two interpretations are possible, the one favouring the taxpayer must prevail.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The stamp duty is chargeable only on Rs 1,00,000.

Immediate Effect: The High Court’s determination stands, and the vendors are liable to pay duty only on the stated consideration.

Broader Implication: The judgment reinforces a narrow reading of Section 24, confirming that unpaid mortgage amounts are included in the consideration only when the property is conveyed subject to that mortgage. It underscores the principle of strict construction of taxing statutes but does not create new doctrine beyond existing precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Board Of Revenue, Uttar Pradesh v. Rai Saheb Sidhnath Mehrotra .

    Sikri, J.— This is an appeal by special leave against the judgment of the High Court of Allahabad in a reference under Section 57 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. The Board of Revenue referred the following questions to the High Court:

    (1) Whether the document is a sale deed for a consideration of Rs 1,00,000 as contended by the executants.
    (2) Whether in view of the provisions of Section 24 of the Stamp Act, the sale consideration shall be deemed to be Rs 5,55,000 and duty liable to be paid thereon as held by the Board.
    (3) Whether the consideration of the sale will be deemed to be Rs Ten Lakhs i.e the entire amount due to the mortgagee Bank, and duty is payable thereon.
    (4) On what amount is the additional stamp duty under Section 107 of the Kanpur Development Act, 1945, leviable.
    The High Court gave the following answer to the first three questions:
    “The document in question is a sale deed for a consideration of Rs 1,00,000 only and that the Stamp duty payable in respect of it was to be calculated on the amount and not on any higher amount.”

    2. The appellant, the Board of Revenue, challenges the answer given by the High Court to the said three questions. We may mention that the answer to the fourth question is not the subject-matter of appeal before us.

    3. The relevant facts are as follows. The respondent is one of the executants of the deed dated December 15, 1952. The executants, hereinafter referred to as the vendors, were lessees of two plots of land and on these plots they had constructed an oil mIII, known as Sri Govind Oil Mills, an Ice and Cold Storage Factory, and buildings in which the factories stood. The Ice and Cold Storage factory was being run by the vendors in partnership with Shyam Sunder Gupta and Satya Prakash Gupta. The vendors had equitably mortgaged these properties with the Chartered Bank of India, and a sum of Rs 10,00,000 was due to the Bank. In order to pay off the debt, the vendors entered into a contract with Messrs Oil Corporation of India Ltd., herinafter referred to as the vendees, for the sale of the lands, buildings, plants, machinery and stores and goodwill of the Govind Oil Mills & Ice & Cold Storage Factory for a sum of Rs 5,55,000, made up as follows; Rs 1,12,000 for the plant and machinery and goodwill of the Ice and Cold Storage Factory, Rs 3,00,000 for the machinery of Sri Govind Oil Mills, Rs 25,000 for stores, Rs 18,000 for goodwill, and Rs 1,00,000 for the buildings and the lessee rights in the plots. Out of this Rs 66,000 was payable to Messrs Shyam Sunder Gupta and Satya Parkash Gupta in respect of their share in the Kanpur Ice and Cold Storage Factory, and the remainder to the vendors.

    4. The Chartered Bank agreed to release from its charge the properties to be conveyed to the vendees provided a sum of Rs 5,00,000 was paid to it. The vendees agreed to pay the said Bank a sum of Rs 4,89,000, while the vendors agreed to pay Rs 11,000 to the Bank to make up the balance.

    5. In pursuance of this agreement, the vendors handed over the possession of plant and machinery of the two factories to the vendees, who paid before December 15, 1952, Rs 3,89,000 to the said Bank. On December 15, 1952, the sale deed in respect of the buildings and the lessee rights was executed. Clause 2 of the deed provided that ‘the vendees hereby declare that the properties hereby conveyed are free from all encumbrances except the charge in favour of the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China, The Mall, Kanpur, which would be paid off so far as the properties hereby conveyed are concerned in the manner set forth above.'

    6. On these facts, Mr C.B Aggarwala, the learned counsel for the appellant, contends that on a true interpretation of Section 24 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, the consideration for the purpose of calculating, ad valorem duty is either Rs 10,00,000, or Rs 5,55,000 or at least Rs 1,11,000.

    7. Section 24 reads thus:

    “Where any property is transferred to any person in consideration, wholly or in part, of any debt due to him, or subject either certainly or contingently to the payment or transfer of any money or stock, whether being or constituting a charge or incumbrance upon the property or not, such debt, money or stock is to be deemed the whole or part, as the case may be, of the consideration in respect whereof the transfer is chargeable with ad valorem duty:
    Provided that nothing in this section shall apply to any such certificate of sale as is mentioned in Article 18 of Schedule I.
    Explanation.— In the case of a sale of property subject to a mortgage or other incumbrance, any unpaid mortgage money or money charged, together with the interest (if any) due on the same, shall be deemed to be part of the consideration for the sale;
    Provided that, where property subject to a mortgage is transferred to the mortgagee, he shall be entitled to deduct from the duty payable on the transfer the amount of any duty already paid in respect of the mortgage.”
    The charging article is Article 23, which is as follows:
    “Conveyance [as defined by Section 2(10)], not being a transfer charged or exempted under No. 62, —
    Where the amount or value of the consideration for such conveyance… as set forth therein does not exceed Rs 50;
    Where it exceeds Rs 50 but does not exceed Rs 100. …
    The section has a history and it is set out in the judgment of Rankin, C.J, in U.K Janardhana Rao v. Secretary of State (1931) ILR 58 Cal 33. We need not repeat it here, for we do not propose to rely on it for interpreting Section 24.

    8. The first question which we may pose is: What is the underlying object of the section? Illustration 2 to the section reads:

    “A sells a property to B for Rs 500 which is subject to a mortgage to C for Rs 1000 and unpaid interest Rs 200. Stamp-duty is payable on Rs 1700.”
    In this illustration the consideration set forth in the conveyance is Rs 500, and under Article 23, the amount on which the Stamp Duty is leviable would be Rs 500 only. There is no doubt that this is not the real value of the property for if the property was not the subject-matter of mortgage, A would not sell the property for Rs 500 and B would pay more than Rs 500. The legislature, therefore, adopted a simple test for valuing the property taken by the vendees, and the test adopted was that any unpaid mortgage money or money charge, together with interest (if any) due on the sum shall be deemed to be part of the consideration for the sale. Therefore, in the illustration the sum of Rs 1000 and Rs 200 are added to Rs 500 and the sum on which the stamp duty is payable is determined at Rs 1700. The Lord President explained the underlying reason in the case of Commissioners of Inland Revenue v. Liquidators of City of Glasgow Bank (1881) 8 Ct of Sess Cases as follows:
    “If any other rule was adopted, it is quite plain that the fair incidence of this tax would be altogether frustrated and defeated. A proprietor has an estate worth £ 20,000. There is a bond upon it for £ 10,000. He sells that estate, and the purchaser pays to him the difference between the amount of the bond and the value of the estate, so that the bond being for £ 10,000 he pays £ 10,000. The day after he obtains infeftment he pays off the bond. Well, the practical result of that is that he has paid £ 20,000 as the purchase money of this estate, and he has obtained a conveyance with an ad valorem stamp of the value of £ 10,000. That is a simple defeating of the purpose and intention of the legislature as expressed in this clause, and therefore. I think, upon the plain meaning of this section, that there was no intention whatever to go back upon the enactment of the 16 and 17 Vict., and to restore the enactment of the 55 Geo. III, which is what the liquidators are contending for. On the contrary, it seems to me that the 73rd section plainly intended to continue the provision of the statute 16 and 17 Vict.”

    9. The next point that needs determination is: What does the phrase “sale of property subject to a mortgage” mean? Does this phrase mean that whenever mortgaged property is sold the explanation applies or does it imply that if mortgaged property is sold subject to the mortgage then and then only the explanation applies? In our view, the correct meaning is the latter meaning. Let us see what would be the position if A, instead of selling property as in illustration 2, adopts the following mode of selling. A sells property to B for Rs 1700, which is subject to mortgage to C for Rs 1000 and unpaid interest Rs 200. A agrees that Rs 1200 be paid to C and Rs 500 to him. If the first meaning is adopted, the consideration on which the stamp duty would be leviable would be Rs 1700, which is the consideration expressed in terms of Article 23, and Rs 1200 deemed to be consideration within Section 24, the total amounting to Rs 2900. In our opinion this result could never have been intended. We agree with the decision of the Calcutta High Court in U.K Janardhan Rao v. Secretary of State (1931) ILR 58 Cal 33 and of the Bombay High Court in Waman Martand Bhalerao v. Commissioner Central Division (1881) 8 Ct of Sess Cases that the phrase “subject to a mortgage or other encumbrance” in the explanation to Section 24 qualifies the word “sale” and not the word “property”. We need hardly say that the Stamp Act is a taxing statute and must be construed strictly, and if two meanings are equally possible, the meaning in favour of the subject must be given effect to.

    10. Before we consider the facts of this case, we may mention that it is plain from the explanation that it is only the unpaid mortgage money that is deemed to be part of the consideration. If the mortgage money has been paid off by the date of the conveyance the explanation does not require it to be added to the consideration. If the mortgage money has been paid off by the vendee before the date of the sale, as part of the consideration, it would be included in the amount leviable with stamp duty under Article 23, but not under the explanation. The conveyance deed would, in the above eventuality, recite the fact that so much money has been paid to the mortgagee and it would be the consideration expressed in the deed.

    11. Let us now apply the law as explained above to the facts of this case. On December 15, 1952, the date when the deed was executed, Rs 3,89,000 had already been paid by the vendees to the Bank. Mr Aggarwal contends that this amount should be included because it was consideration moving from the vendees. He says that stamp duty cannot be avoided by the simple device of paying money before a conveyance is executed. He is right in this but he must show that Rs 3,89,000 was an advance payment for the immovable property conveyed by the deed dated December 15, 1952. It is quite clear from the terms of the deed that Rs 4,55,000 was to be paid for items other than the immoveable property conveyed by the said deed and the sum of Rs 3,89,000 had nothing to do with the immoveable property. The payment of Rs 3,89,000 to the Bank left outstanding Rs 1,11,000 as mortgage money. Rs 1,00,000 is expressed to be the consideration for the conveyance of the immovable property, and therefore, falls within Article 23. This leaves Rs 11,000, and the question arises whether this sum should be taken into consideration for the purpose of levying stamp duty. Regarding this item, the High Court held as follows:

    “It is true that till the date of sale the sum of Rs 11,000 had not been paid and there was a charge on the property in respect of that amount. The vendors themselves had, however, taken liability for that amount and had agreed to pay it. It had been expressly provided in the sale deed that property was being sold free from the charge. The vendees were in no way liable for the amount and had not undertaken to pay it. In these circumstances the property cannot be said to have been sold subject to the charge of Rs 11,000, and if it was not being sold subject to that charge, the Explanation to Section 24 becomes inapplicable.”
    It has already been noticed that this sum of Rs 11,000 forms part of the price for items other than the immoveable property. Mr Aggarwala has not seriously controverted the finding of the High Court on this point. Accordingly, we hold that this sum of Rs 11,000 cannot be included for the purpose of levying stamp duty.

    12. In the result, we agree with the High Court that the stamp duty is to be calculated only on the sum of Rs 1,00,000. The appeal is accordingly dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Board Of Revenue, Uttar Pradesh v. Rai Saheb Sidhnath Mehrotra .
    (Nov 26, 1964)