AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 of Schedule II of the Excess Profits Tax Act
  • Section 2(3) of the Excess Profits Tax Act, 1940
  • Rule 2-A of Schedule II to the Excess Profits Tax Act
  • Rule 2 of Schedule II to the Excess Profits Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 of Schedule II of the Excess Profits Tax Act
  • Section 2(3) of the Excess Profits Tax Act, 1940
  • Rule 2-A of Schedule II to the Excess Profits Tax Act
  • Rule 2 of Schedule II to the Excess Profits Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee, Shree Ram Mills Limited of Bombay, was assessed for the year 1945-46 (accounting year 1944). While the Income-tax Officer determined taxable profits at Rs 46,18,384 (a figure that was not contested), the Excess Profits Tax Officer computed profits chargeable to excess profits tax at Rs 46,94,304 after excluding items such as charitable donations and presents. The dispute reached the court by way of an appeal raising two questions under the Excess Profits Tax Act, 1940: (i) the interpretation of Rule 5 of Schedule II, and (ii) the treatment of managing agency commission for capital computation purposes.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on a true construction of Rule 5 of Schedule II to the Excess Profits Tax Act, 1940, the phrase “so far as the contrary is shown” applies only to clause (a) or applies to both clauses (a) and (b).
  2. Whether the managing agency commission payable for the year 1943 constitutes “borrowed money” under Rule 2-A of Schedule II or a “debt” under Rule 2 of the same Schedule.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee’s Arguments

  • Rule 5 creates a single legal fiction: that profits accrue evenly throughout the period. Once that presumption is accepted or rebutted, clause (b) has no independent operation. Therefore, because the department accepted even accrual under clause (a), clause (b) must automatically apply, compelling inclusion of the whole profit figure in capital.
  • The managing agents’ decision to leave their commission with the company amounted to the company “borrowing” the money; hence the amount should be treated as borrowed capital under Rule 2-A.

Revenue’s/Department’s Position

  • The words “so far as the contrary is shown” qualify both clauses of Rule 5, permitting the department to demonstrate—independently of even accrual—that profits did not in fact swell capital because certain sums were diverted to charity and gifts.
  • The unpaid managing agency commission represents a “debt” owed by the company, not a loan or borrowing, because no agreement of lending existed.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Interpretation of Rule 5. The court held that the verb “deemed” governs both clauses (a) and (b) of Rule 5, establishing two distinct but related presumptions: (a) profits accrue evenly, and (b) profits, as they accrue, correspondingly increase or decrease capital. Likewise, the qualifying phrase “except so far as the contrary is shown” applies to both clauses, allowing either party to rebut either presumption. If only one presumption is rebutted, the other continues to operate.

2. Character of the managing agency commission. The commission became payable annually on 31 December but remained with the assessee because the agents did not immediately withdraw it. The court emphasized that a loan requires an affirmative act of lending and an acceptance of funds as a loan. Mere inaction by the managing agents could not transform the unpaid commission into borrowed money. Absent an agreement converting the amount into a loan, the sum remained a debt owed by the company under Rule 2.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.

The court affirmed the High Court’s answers: (i) the phrase “so far as the contrary is shown” applies to both clauses (a) and (b) of Rule 5; and (ii) the unpaid managing agency commission is a debt under Rule 2, not borrowed money under Rule 2-A. The immediate consequence is that the assessee cannot enlarge its capital base by treating charitable outgoings as capitalised profits, nor claim the commission as borrowed capital. The decision resolves the parties’ dispute but does not announce any broader doctrinal innovation beyond clarifying the interpretation of specific provisions of the Excess Profits Tax Act, 1940.

    Shree Ram Mills Ltd., Bombay v. Commissioner Of Excess Profits Tax, Central Bombay .

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Vivian Bose, J.— This appeal comes from Bombay. It raises two questions under the Excess Profits Tax Act, 1940. The first concerns Rule 5 of Schedule II of the Act and the other raises a question about the managing agency commission due to the managing agents of the assessee company.

    2. The assessee is the Shree Ram Mills Limited of Bombay. The assessment year is 1945-46 and the accounting year the calendar year 1944. The Income Tax Officer assessed the profits for income tax at Rs 46,18,384 and that is not questions.

    3. The Excess Profits Tax Officer computed the profits, for Excess Profits Tax purpose, at Rs 46,94,304. In reaching this figure he excluded certain items in the return for determining how the profits increased the capital; for example, he excluded moneys given away as presents and in charity etc.

    4. Now in order to determine the quantum of excess profits tax payable by an assesee it is necessary under the Act to compute, among other things, the average amount of capital employed by the business during a certain period. This under Section 2(3), has to be the average amount of capital “as computed in accordance with the Second Schedule”. That brings in the disputed rule, Rule 5 in Schedule II. It runs as follows:

    “For the purpose of ascertaining the average amount of capital employed in a business during any period, the profits or losses made in that period shall, except so far as the contrary is shown, be deemed—

    (a) to have accrued at an even rate throughout the period; and

    (b) to have resulted, as they accrued, in a corresponding increase or decrease, as the case may be, in the capital employed in the business.”

    5. The dispute centres round the words we have underlined. The learned counsel for the assessee contends that the words only govern clause (a) and not clause (b). The department has accepted in this case that the profits accrued at an even rate because the assessee has not rebutted that presumption nor has the department attempted to do so. The learned counsel for the assessee contends that that being so, the department is bound to apply clause (b) because the words we have underlined only govern clause (a) and not clause (b). His contention is that Rule 5 is an artificial rule which creates a fiction, namely, that, the profits accrue evenly over the year even when that is not the fact. Therefore the moment either party shows that this is not the case Rule 5 falls to the ground as a whole because the artificial presumption it created has been rebutted. Clause (b), he contends, cannot have any independent existence because it is a mere corollary to clause (a). In the same way, he says, if clause (a) is accepted, then clause (b) lives also, and as clause (a) has been accepted here clause (b) must also be applied without anything more.

    6. We do not agree. The word “deemed” clearly governs both clauses, for the fiction which the Rule creates is not only that the profits shall be deemed to have accrued at an even rate throughout the period, but further that they must be deemed to have resulted, as they accrued, in a corresponding increase or decrease in the capital. In the same way, the words “except so far as the contrary is shown” govern both clauses and it is open to either side to rebutt the artificial presumptions created by that Rule by showing that either clause does not represent the true facts. Thus, it can be shown either that the profits did not accrue at an even rate throughout the period or that the profits did not actually go to increase the capital, as for example when it was taken out of the business and handed over to charities and so forth, and if only one of the two presumptions is rebutted, the other stands.

    7. The High Court resettled the first question we are asked to answer as follows:

    “Whether on a true construction of Rule 5 of Schedule II of the Excess Profits Tax Act the expression ‘so far as the contrary is shown' applies only to sub-clause (a) or also to sub-clause (b)?”

    8. We agree with the answer given by the High Court, namely that the words “so far as the contrary is shown” apply to both clauses (a) and (b).

    9. The next question is about the managing agency commission. Under the articles of agreement entered into between the assessee and its managing agents the agents were to be paid a certain commission and the articles provided—

    “The said commission shall be due to the said firm yearly on the thirty-first day of December in each and every year during the continuance of this agreement and shall be payable and be paid immediately after annual accounts of the said Company have been passed by the shareholders of the Company....”

    10. The managing agents left the commission lying with the assessee. The assessee contends that this constitutes a “borrowing” within the meaning of Rule 2-A of Schedule II. The Commissioner of Income Tax says it is a “debt” within the meaning of Rule 2. We agree with the High Court that this is a “debt” and not a “borrowing”.

    11. At bottom this is a question of fact. Of course, money so left could, by a proper agreement between the parties, be converted into a loan, but in the absence of an agreement mere inaction on the part of the managing agents cannot convert the money due to them, and not withdrawn, into a loan. A loan imports a positive act of lending coupled with an acceptance by the other side of the money as a loan. The relationship of borrower and lender cannot ordinarily come about by mere inaction. The clause in the Articles of Agreement quoted above was relied on for the purpose of showing that there was such an agreement in the case. We are unable to construe the provisions in that way. They merely give the managing agents a right to receive their commission at a certain time. If the money is not paid in time it lies with the assessee as a debt due to the agents.

    12. The second question was framed as follows:

    “Whether the managing agency commission payable by the company to its managing agents for the year 1943 is borrowed money for the purposes of Rule 2-A or a debt for the purposes of Rule 2 of Schedule II to the Excess Profits Tax Act?”

    13. We agree with the High Court that it is a debt under Rule 2 and not a borrowing under Rule 2-A.

    14. The result is that the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shree Ram Mills Ltd., Bombay v. Commissioner Of Excess Profits Tax, Central Bombay .
    (Jan 16, 1953)