AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1988 INSC 281
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Stamp Act
  • First Schedule to the Act with effect from 1-3-1982
  • Section 3-A of the U.P Sales Tax Act, 1948
  • Section 11-A of the Central Excises and Salt Act
  • Finance Act of 1982
  • Section 11-A of the Act
  • Section 2(vi) of the Payment of Wages Act, 1936
  • The Act (no specific title or section mentioned)
  • Section 35-L(b) of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944
  • Item 68 of the First Schedule to the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1988 INSC 281
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Stamp Act
  • First Schedule to the Act with effect from 1-3-1982
  • Section 3-A of the U.P Sales Tax Act, 1948
  • Section 11-A of the Central Excises and Salt Act
  • Finance Act of 1982
  • Section 11-A of the Act
  • Section 2(vi) of the Payment of Wages Act, 1936
  • The Act (no specific title or section mentioned)
  • Section 35-L(b) of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944
  • Item 68 of the First Schedule to the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, M/s Krishna Carbon Paper Company, manufactured 5601 boxes, 20,288 reams and 45 packets of carbon paper between 25-3-1979 and 24-9-1979, valued at Rs 7,67,498.40. No central excise duty was paid on these clearances. A show-cause notice under Section 11-A of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 (“the Act”) was issued by the Superintendent of Central Excise, Lakhimpur Kheri, demanding duty on the ground that carbon paper was dutiable under Tariff Item 17(2).

The Assistant Collector, Sitapur, confirmed a demand of basic excise duty of Rs 1,15,124.76 and special excise duty of Rs 5756.23. On appeal, the Collector (Appeals) set aside that order, holding that carbon paper first became specifically taxable only on 1-3-1982 under new Tariff Item 17(3). The Revenue’s appeal to the Customs, Excise & Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (“CEGAT”) was dismissed; the Tribunal classified carbon paper under residuary Tariff Item 68 for the pre-1982 period. The Collector of Central Excise, Kanpur, then appealed to the Supreme Court under Section 35-L(b) of the Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, for the period 25-3-1979 to 24-9-1979, carbon paper was classifiable under Tariff Item 17(2) of the Central Excise Tariff (as “paper … subjected to … coating”) or under residuary Tariff Item 68.
  2. If classified under Item 17(2), whether the duty demand was nevertheless barred by limitation under Section 11-A of the Act (an issue left undecided by the Tribunal).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Collector of Central Excise)

  • Carbon paper is “coated paper” and has been covered by Tariff Item 17(2) since the 1976 amendment; the 1982 insertion of Item 17(3) merely listed a specific variety without retrospective effect.
  • Trade notices and tariff advices relied upon by the respondent are not binding for tariff classification.
  • The 1982 amendment was, at most, clarificatory and introduced ex abundanti cautela.

Respondent (M/s Krishna Carbon Paper Company)

  • Carbon paper became taxable only on 1-3-1982 when Item 17(3) (“carbon and other copying papers”) was inserted; prior to that date it fell in residuary Item 68.
  • The Revenue’s demand is time-barred under Section 11-A of the Act.
  • Trade Notice 56/76 and Tariff Advice 5/76 treated carbon paper as stationery and not as “paper” under Item 17.
  • Relied on precedent such as State of U.P. v. Kores (India) Ltd. and Khoday Industries Ltd. v. Union of India to contend that carbon paper is not “paper” in common parlance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sai Giridhara Supply Co. v. CCE, Bombay (1987) 28 ELT 438 (Trib.) Held carbon paper pre-1982 falls under Item 68. Relied upon by CEGAT; Supreme Court disapproved and overruled its effect.
CST v. S.N. Brothers (1973) 3 SCC 496 Trade meaning prevails over dictionary meaning when statute undefined. Cited to justify adopting trade understanding for tariff classification.
King v. Planters Nut & Chocolate Co. Ltd., 1951 CLR Ex 122 (Canada) Classification should reflect ordinary commercial understanding. Quoted in support of using popular trade meaning.
Union of India v. Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd., AIR 1963 SC 791 Indian Standards Institute (ISI) definitions may be accepted where market evidence lacking. Used to prefer ISI specification of “carbon paper” as coated paper.
Grenfell v. IRC (1876) 1 Ex D 242 Words in taxing statutes are construed in popular sense. Reiterated as governing interpretative principle.
200 Chests of Tea, 9 Wheaton 435 (US, 1824) Merchants’ understanding, not scientific, guides tariff terms. Cited analogically.
Porritts & Spencer (Asia) Ltd. v. State of Haryana (1979) 1 SCC 82 Popular meaning controls unless statute specifies otherwise. Relied upon for interpretative approach.
Attorney General v. Winstanley (1901) 6 ER 740 Commercial understanding governs tax terms. Cited approvingly.
State of U.P. v. Kores (India) Ltd. (1976) 4 SCC 477 Carbon paper not “paper” for U.P. Sales Tax notification. Invoked by respondent; distinguished by Supreme Court on different statutory language.
Khoday Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1986) 23 ELT 337 (Kant.) Carbon paper classifiable under Item 68 as stationery. Considered but held not decisive; trade notices on which it relied were found non-binding.
Orient Paper Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1969 SC 48 Board’s administrative directions not binding on quasi-judicial authorities. Cited to discount relevance of Trade Notice 56/76 and Tariff Advice 5/76.
Dunlop India Ltd. v. Union of India (1976) 2 SCC 241 Classification to be based on how goods are understood in commerce. Reaffirmed interpretative framework.
Md. Qasim Larry v. Mohd. Samsuddin, AIR 1964 SC 1699 Later amendment may be merely clarificatory. Cited by Revenue; Court found it unnecessary to rule on clarificatory nature.
Kores (India) Ltd. v. CCE (Tribunal) Relied on ISI glossary; held carbon paper is coated paper under Item 17(2). Supreme Court approved this reasoning.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice Sabyasachi Mukharji emphasised that:

  • No statutory definition of “paper” existed; therefore popular or trade meaning governed.
  • Tariff Item 17(2) (as amended in 1976) expressly covered “paper … which have been subjected to various treatments such as coating, impregnating, corrugation…”.
  • Technical dictionary definitions were of limited assistance; instead, evidence from the Indian Standards Institute’s “Glossary of Terms used in Paper Trade and Industry” (IS 4661) showed that the trade regarded carbon paper as coated paper.
  • Trade notices and tariff advices classifying carbon paper as stationery were administrative and not legally determinative, per Orient Paper Mills.
  • Insertion of Item 17(3) in 1982 did not imply earlier exclusion; the Finance Minister’s speech indicated a restructuring to compensate revenue loss and did not evince retrospective change in scope.
  • Precedents establishing the primacy of commercial parlance (e.g., Grenfell, Delhi Cloth) were applied, while decisions favouring Item 68 were distinguished because they dealt with different statutory language or relied on non-binding trade notices.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that, for the relevant period, carbon paper fell squarely within the words “all other kinds of paper … which have been subjected to … coating” in Item 17(2).

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; matter remanded to the Tribunal solely to determine the question of limitation under Section 11-A of the Act.

Immediate Effect: The Supreme Court set aside CEGAT’s classification of carbon paper under Item 68 and held it classifiable under Item 17(2) for the period 25-3-1979 to 24-9-1979. Liability to duty will depend on the Tribunal’s fresh finding on limitation. The judgment clarifies tariff interpretation for coated paper products prior to 1982 but does not establish a new general doctrine beyond reaffirming trade-parlance principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Collector Of Central Excise, Kanpur v. Krishna Carbon Paper Co. .

    Sabyasachi Mukharji, J.— The Collector of Central Excise, Kanpur, is the appellant in this appeal under Section 35-L(b) of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 (hereinafter called “the Act”). The period involved in this appeal is the assessment period from 25-3-1979 to 24-9-1979, a period of about six months. The respondent M/s Krishna Carbon Paper Company was engaged in the manufacture of carbon papers. During the period from 25-3-1979 to 24-9-1979 the respondent manufactured and cleared from its factory a quantity of 5601 boxes, 20,288 reams and 45 packets of carbon papers for a total value of Rs 7,67,498.40 without payment of any duty under the Act. The Superintendent of Central Excise Lakhimpur Kheri, issued notice to the respondent demanding central excise duty on carbon paper cleared during the aforesaid period under Section 11-A of the Act. The respondent submitted a written reply stating that the notice was without jurisdiction because the respondent had taken out the central excise licence immediately on the direction of the department and it was only after 28-2-1982 that the product was subjected to duty under sub-item (3) of Item 17 by the Central Excise Budget of 1982. In support of this contention, the respondent relied on Notifications Nos. 107/1982 and 69/1982, both dated 28-2-1982. It was contended that the carbon paper was a new item which was specified under sub-item (3) of Item 17 of CET. According to the Revenue, however, the recasting of tariff Item 17 in 1976 was irrelevant and that the carbon being akin to coated paper (one side or both sides) was covered under sub-item (2) of Item 17 of the CET since 1976. The submission of the respondent was that sub-item (3) of Item 17 of the CET covering the carbon paper including copy paper was inserted by the Central Excise Budget, 1982, but it does not make any retrospective change. It was, according to the appellant, an introduction of specific name or variety of paper for being subjected to a different rate of duty. The carbon paper remained a coated paper already covered under sub-item (2) of Item 17 of CET. The Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Sitapur, by his order dated 27-4-1983/30-4-1983, confirmed the demand for basic excise duty amounting to Rs 1,15,124,76 and special excise duty of Rs 5756.23 on carbon paper cleared during the period from 25-3-1979 to 24-9-1979. The Appellate Collector, however, set aside the order of the Assistant Collector and was of the view that the carbon paper could not be classified under tariff Item 17(2) of the Act, as it was before 1982. The Collector (Appeals) accepted the respondent's contention that the carbon paper was brought under the purview of tariff Item 17 for the first time in 1982 when it was introduced as sub-item (3) of Item 17 of the First Schedule to the Act with effect from 1-3-1982. Being aggrieved thereby the appellant preferred an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal dismissed the appeal. Hence, this appeal.

    2. The question for decision in this appeal is: whether carbon paper before the introduction of Central Excise Budget in 1982 and consequential amendment in tariff, fell under Item 68 of the First Schedule to the Act, as held by the Tribunal or under Item 17(2) of the tariff item, which was claimed by the Collector of Central Excise. Following its previous decision in the case of Sai Giridhara Supply Co. v. CCE, Bombay (1987) 28 ELT 438 (Tribunal) the Tribunal upheld the contention of the respondent and held that for the period before the amendment of Central Excise Budget, in 1982, carbon paper fell under tariff Item 68 and not under tariff Item 17(2), as it then was. The Tribunal did not go into the question of the limitation, namely, whether the claim was barred in any event by the lapse of time in view of Section 11-A of the Act. The Tribunal came to the finding that the carbon paper in question fell under tariff Item 68 of the Central Excise Tariff. Shri Kapil on behalf of the respondent submitted before us that the claim, in any event, was barred by lapse of time in view of Section 11-A of the Act. In view of the fact that the Tribunal did not decide this question if we are persuaded to reject (sic) the Revenue's contention in this appeal, the matter has to be remanded back to the Tribunal to decide this question as to limitation, as there is no decision of the Tribunal on this aspect of the matter.

    3. Before the contentions are appreciated, it will be appropriate to refer to the position of tariff Item 17 at three different phases, namely, in 1975, after the amendment in 1976 and after the further amendment to Item 17 by the Finance Act of 1982. Item 17 was amended with effect from 27-2-1982 and two specific entries were added. These were (3) and (4). It is necessary to set out the position at different points of time. It was as follows:

    Tariff Item 17 — Position in 1975

    Item No. Description of goods Rate of duty 17. Paper, all sorts (including paste board, millboard, strawboard and cardboard), in or in relation to the manufacture of which any process is ordinarily carried on with the aid of power— (1) Cigarette tissue Rs 3 per kg (2) Slotting, toilet, target, tissue other than cigarette tissue, teleprinter, typewriting, manifold, bank, bond, art paper, chrome paper, tubsized paper, cheque paper, stamp paper, cartridge paper, (waxed paper, polythelene coated paper), parchment and coated board (including art board, chrome board and for playing cards) Re 1 and 20 paise per kg (3) Printing and writing paper, packing and wrapping paper, strawboard and pulp board, including grey board, corrugated board, duplex and triplex boards, other sorts 90 paise per kg (4) All other kinds of paper and paper board, not otherwise specified Re 1 and 20 paise per kg Position in 1976 17. Paper and paper board, all sorts (including paste board, millboard, strawboard, cardboard and corrugated board), in or in relation to the manufacture of which any process is ordinarily carried on with the aid of power— (1) Uncoated and coated printing and writing paper (other than poster paper) 25 per cent ad valorem (2) Paper board and all other kinds of paper (including paper or paper boards which have been subjected to various treatments such as coating, impregnating, corrugation, creping and design printing), not elsewhere specified. 30 per cent ad valorem
    There was further amendment to Item 17 by the Finance Act of 1982. Item 17 was amended with effect from 27-2-1982, and two specific entries were added. They are (3) and (4) which are reproduced below:
    Item Description of goods Rate of Duty 17. * * * (3) Carbon and other copying papers (including duplicator stencils) and transfer papers, whether or not cut to size and whether or not put up in boxes. 32½ per cent ad valorem (4) Boxes, cartons, bags and other packing containers (including flattended or folded boxes and flattened or folded cartons), whether or not printed and whether in assembled or unassembled condition. 32 ½ per cent ad valorem

    4. The short question with which we are concerned is, whether during the relevant period, namely, 25-3-1979 to 24-9-1979 when the position mentioned above was prevailing, whether carbon papers could be included in “all kinds of paper including the paper which have been subjected to coating”, would come within sub-item (2) of Item 17 as mentioned hereinbefore or under residuary Item 68 of the Central Excise Tariff.

    5. The Tribunal followed a previous decision in Sai Giridhara Supply Co. v. CCE, Bombay (1987) 28 ELT 438 (Tribunal). There, the Tribunal had discussed the various aspects of the matter and felt itself bound by the decision of the Karnataka High Court to which reference will be made later. The Tribunal has referred to the observations of Buckley, L.J (1916) 1 AC 314 (HL) where the Lord Justice observed that once a precedent was held to be a binding one, then no deviation therefrom was permissible within the judicial polity except in the well-accepted categories of cases enumerated in the judgment. Those contingencies, the Tribunal found, were not applicable to the facts of this case.

    6. It is well settled that in order to ascertain the correct meaning of a fiscal entry reference to a dictionary is apt to be a somewhat delusive guide, as it gives all the different shades of meaning. In the instant case, our attention was drawn to the extract from the Oxford English Dictionary, Vol. III, p. 436 where the meaning of the word “paper” has been given. It reads as follows:

    Paper (pei'per), sb. Also 4 papure, 4-6 papir, 5 papire, papyre, (paupire, 5-6 pauper, 5-7 papyr, 6 papre). [a. AFr. papir=(0)Fr., Papier (=Pr. Papier, Cat. Paper, Sp. papel “paper”, It. papira papyrus), ad. L. papyrus the papyrus or paper-reed of the Nile, also writing material made of it, a. Gr. nanvpost the papyrus-reed. From the writing-sheets made of the thin strips of papyrus the name was transferred to paper made of cotton, and thence to paper of linen and other fibres. These extensions took place before the word became English, so that here its application to papyrus is only a later retrospective use.]
    I. The simple word. Without a or pl. (exc. as denoting a particular kind).
    1. A substance composed of fibres interlaced into a compact web, made (usually in the form of a thin flexible sheet, most commonly white) from various fibrous materials, as linen and cotton rags, straw, wood, certain grasses, etc., which are macerated into a pulp, dried, and pressed (and subjected to various other processes, as bleaching, colouring, sizing, etc., according to the intended use); it is used (in various forms and qualities) for writing; printing, or drawing on, for wrapping things in, for covering the interior of walls, and for other purposes.

    7. Our attention was also drawn to the meaning of the carbon paper in “Pulp and Paper Manufacture”, 2nd Edn., Vol. II which has been described as follows:

    Carbon paper is made by coating paper with a mixture consisting principally of a wax and a pigment. The colour is obtained from the pigment, usually a carbon black of low oil absorption, plus toners, usually lake pigments or oil-soluble dyes, which are added to increase the blackness. The wax, which acts as a binder for the pigment, must have a viscosity low enough to permit slight penetration into the paper, but not so low that the wax strikes through or sweats oil. Waxes with a melting point between 105°F to 120°F and a viscosity of about 60 or 70 Saybolt at 210°F are generally used. The principal wax used is carnauba, although some ceresin, beeswax, candelilla, ozokerite, ouricury, and synthetic waxes are also used. Special grades of microcrystalline waxes may be added to soften the coating and improve the printing qualities. In addition to the above ingredients, non-drying oils (mineral oils) are used to soften the coating and control the amount of coating transferred to the copy. Oleic acid is sometimes used as a solvent for oil-soluble dyes.
    All carbon papers must be free of offset, flaking, wrinkles, curl, or other defects, and must give a good impression on the copy paper. The coating must be hard enough not to smear in hot weather, but the exact degree of hardness depends upon the intended use, that is, whether the paper is designed as a pencil carbon, a typewriter carbon, or a one-time carbon. The amount of coating varies from a very thin coating used in making one-time carbons to a very heavy coating used in making high-grade typewriter carbons for multiple use. The latter, in which the paper may be reused up to 40 to 50 times, must have a coating of very high colour value and the coating must be compounded so that only a small amount is transferred to the copy sheet. A simplified formula for a typewriter carbon would be as follows:

    Carnauba wax .. .. .. 34 per cent Ozokerite .. .. .. 6 per cent Beeswax .. .. .. 7 per cent Petrolatum .. .. .. 6 per cent Mineral Oil .. .. .. 25 per cent Carbon black .. .. .. 13 per cent Toners .. .. .. 6 per cent Oleic acid .. .. .. 3 per cent

    In the coating of carbon paper, the molten wax mixture is applied to the paper at a temperature of about 200°F. Coating is done on a carbon paper coater which consists of an inking roll which is supplied with coating directly from a bath or from a heated fountain. The inking roll revolves in a direction opposite to that of the paper web. Excess coating is scraped off the paper by an equalizer rod and the sheet then passed over a water-cooled cylinder to chill and harden the coating. Crystallisation of the wax occurs upon chilling, and this process continues over a period of several days. For this reason, it is customary for carbon manufacturers to age their coated paper for two to seven days before shipping.
    It is absolutely essential that the coating be absorbed evenly by the paper. Therefore, the paper must have a smooth surface, uniformly high density, good formation, and above all, be free of pinholes. Further requirements are high strength, low basis weight, and freedom from flaws such as slime spots and dirt specks. Because of these rigid requirements, the base stock for carbon tissue is difficult to make. The best grades are made from new cotton or linen rags, or from manila hemp, whereas the cheaper grades are made from sulfate and sulfite pulps. The stock is beaten for a considerable period of time, often up to thirty hours, in order to develop maximum strength. The stock is only lightly sized. Calcium carbonate is often used as a filler, but the ash should not be over 5 per cent. The basis weight is usually 4, 5½, 7 or 10 lb. per ream (20x30-500). The 4-lb. paper is used when a large number of copies is to be made; the 5 and 7-lb. papers are suitable for ordinary work.

    8. Carbon paper under the specifications of the Indian Standards Institute, is described as follows:

    Carbon Paper — Paper coated (generally on one side) with a pressure transferable pigmented layer, used for making copies at the same time as an original manuscript or typescript is made.

    9. It is well settled, as mentioned before, that where no definition is provided in the statue itself, as in this case, for ascertaining the correct meaning of a fiscal entry reference to a dictionary is not always safe. The correct guide, it appears in such a case, is the context and the trade meaning. In this connection reference may be made to the observations of this Court in CST v. S.N Brothers, Kanpur (1973) 3 SCC 496, AIR 1973 SC 78, at p. 80 Para 5( and 5).

    10. The trade meaning is one which is prevalent in that particular trade where the goods is known or traded. If special type of goods is subject-matter of a fiscal entry then that entry must be understood in the context of that particular trade, bearing in mind that particular word. Where, however, there is no evidence either way then the definition given and the meaning following (sic flowing) from particular statute at particular time would be the decisive test.

    11. In the famous Canadian case in King v. Planters Nut and Chocolate Co. Ltd. 1951 CLR Ex 122 Cameron, J. observed that it is not botanist's conception as to what constitutes a fruit or vegetable ... but rather what would ordinarily in matters of commerce in Canada be included that should be the guide. Similarly, this Court has held in Union of India v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. AIR 1963 SC 791 at p. 794 para 12 that the view of the Indian Standards Institute as regards what is refined oil as known to the market in India must be preferred in the absence of any other reliable evidence. It must be emphasised in view of the arguments advanced in this case that the meaning should be as understood in the particular trade. In this case, we are construing not paper as such but a particular brand of paper with a meaning attributed to it. Sub-item (2) of Item 17 as was the position in 1979 paper referred to all kinds of paper including paper or paper boards which have been subjected to various treatments such as coating, impregnating. So, therefore, if all kinds of paper including coated paper is the goods, we have to find out the meaning attributed to those goods in the trade of those kinds of paper where transactions of those goods take place.

    12. It is a well-settled principle of construction, as mentioned before, that where the word has a scientific or technical meaning and also an ordinary meaning according to common parlance, it is in the latter sense that in a taxing statute the word must be held to have been used, unless contrary intention is clearly expressed by the legislature. This principle is well settled by a long line of decisions of Canadian, American, Australian and Indian cases. Pollock, J. pointed out in Grenfell v. IRC (1876) 1 Ex D 242 that if a statute contains language which is capable of being construed in a popular sense, such a statute is not to be construed according to the strict or technical meaning of the language contained in it, but is to be construed in its popular sense, meaning, of course, by the words “popular sense” that which people conversant with the subject-matter with which the statute is dealing would attribute to it. The ordinary words in every day use are, therefore, to be construed according to their popular sense. The same view was reiterated by Story, J. in 200 Chests of Tea (1824) 9 Wheaton US 435 where he observed that the legislature does not suppose our merchants to be naturalists, or geologists, or botanists. See the observations of Bhagwati, J. as the learned Chief Justice then was, in Porritts & Spencer (Asia) Ltd. v. State of Haryana (1979) 1 SCC 82. But there is a word of caution that has to be borne in mind in this connection, the words must be understood in popular sense, that is to say, these must be confined to the words used in a particular statute and then if in respect of that particular items, as artificial definition is given in the sense that a special meaning is attached to particular words in the statute then the ordinary sense or dictionary meaning would not be applicable but the meaning of that type of goods dealt with by that type of goods in that type of market, should be searched. In the instant case, we have “all kinds of papers including papers subjected to coating, impregnating etc.” If there is a market meaning or trade meaning of that kind of a paper that should be adhered to. In this case, there is no direct evidence how these peculiar goods are dealt with in the particular market dealing with those goods. But there is evidence how these are to be understood in the light of the specifications of the Indian Standards Institute which we have mentioned before. It is instructive to refer in this connection a passage of the Tribunal's decision in Kores (India) Ltd. v. CCE, where the Tribunal observed that on the point whether carbon paper is understood as a coated paper in trade, there is authority of the Indian Standards Institute's publication “Glossary of Terms used in Paper Trade and Industry” — IS: 4661. Therefore, understood in the accepted notion of construing entries of fiscal statutes not from a technical or scientific point of view but from the point of view of the people in the trade dealing with that particular type of goods and having regard to the evidence of the Indian Standards Institute and in the absence of any other evidence to the contrary, the Tribunal was justified in holding that on the basis of the definition of paper as it was in the year 1976 carbon paper would come within Item 17(2) of the tariff items.

    13. Learned counsel for the respondent placed reliance on the observations of this Court in State of Uttar Pradesh v. Kores (India) Ltd. (1976) 4 SCC 477, (1977) 1 SCR 837 where this Court was concerned with a notification under Section 3-A of the U.P Sales Tax Act, 1948. The question that fell for consideration before this Court in that case was whether carbon paper was taxable as paper and further whether ribbon was accessory or part of typewriter. This Court reiterated that a word which is not defined in an enactment has to be understood in its popular and commercial sense with reference to the context in which it occurs. The word has to be understood according to the well-established canon of construction in the sense in which persons dealing with and using the article understand it. For this principle this Court relied on the observations of Lord Tenterden in Attorney General v. Winstanley (1901) 6 ER 740 and the observations of Pollock, J. in Grenfell v. IRC (1876) 1 Ex D 242. Pollock, J. was construing the Stamp Act, where he correctly emphasised that the words should be construed in popular sense meaning thereby the sense in which people conversant with the subject-matter with which the statute is dealing, would attribute to it. That is the correct test. This Court observed further at p. 839 of the report that in popular parlance, the word “paper” is understood as meaning a substance which is used for bearing, writing, or printing, or for packing, or for drawing on, or for decorating, or covering the walls. Carbon paper is not commonly understood as paper. This Court thus held that paper simpliciter cannot include carbon paper because that would not be in consonance with the popular understanding of the expression “paper”. But where paper of a special type is defined in the particular statute as one including paper which has been subjected to various treatments such as coating, impregnating, how that paper be understood, there must be evidence of that understanding. In the absence of that evidence, the natural meaning following (sic flowing) from the expression used in the statute should be adhered to. In that light, it appears to us that in view of the facts of this case and in the principles of law as prevailing in 1976 papers of all kinds including paper with coating and impregnating and the views of the Indian Standards Institute, would include carbon papers.

    14. Learned counsel drew our attention to the decision of the Karnataka High Court in Khoday Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1986) 23 ELT 337 (Kant) where the learned Single Judge held that carbon paper is an article of stationery classifiable under Item 68 of the Central Excise Tariff and not under Item 17(2) as coated paper prior to its amendment with effect from 27-2-1982. He took into account the Trade Notice No. 56/76 and Tariff Advice No. 5/56. The Trade Notice No. 56/76 issued by the Collector was based on the instructions issued by the Board as per Tariff Advice No. 5/76. Carbon paper was commercially recognised only as an article of stationery falling under Item 68 of the Central Excise Tariff and not under Item 17(2). This was in respect of the position as it stood prior to 1976 when paper did not include coated paper or impregnated paper. It appears from the said judgment of the High Court that the Trade Notice 56/76 was issued by the Collector on 2-3-1976 and Item 17 was amended on 27-5-1976 and sub-clause (2) as amended among other things included coated paper. The trade notices and the tariff advices are not relevant, as such, in construing items in Tariff Schedule. In this connection, reference may be made to the observations of this Court in Orient Paper Mills Ltd. v. Union of India AIR 1969 SC 48, (1969) 1 SCR 245, where this Court observed that a quasi-judicial body exercising quasi-judicial power is not bound by the directions of the Board. There is no provision in the Act empowering the Board to issue directions to the assessing authorities or the appellate authorities in the matter of deciding disputes between the persons who are called upon to pay duty and the department. Therefore, trade notices as such issued by the Board are not relevant considerations.

    15. The point which Shri Kapil, further urged is that Item 17 was amended by the Finance Act of 1982 and two specific entries were added, namely, Items 17(3) and 17(4) we have noted before. His contention was that if the carbon paper was already there then there was no purpose of introducing these subsequent amendments. Shri Kapil relied on a Full Bench decision of the Government of India in the case of In re Colgate Palmolive (India) (P) Ltd. 1979 ELT 567 (Govt. of India) where the Government of India observed that it was well-settled law that the proper rule of construction applicable to items and entries occurring in Excise Schedule should be to construe not in scientific or technical sense but in the sense as understood by the parties dealing with or commercially conversant with them. The Government of India relied on the observations of this Court in Dunlop India Ltd. v. Union of India (1976) 2 SCC 241, AIR 1977 SC 597. So far as that principle is concerned, this is applicable. It must be as understood by the persons dealing with this particular type of goods. We are concerned here not with paper simpliciter or how it is understood in common parlance but paper with a particular definition at the relevant time, namely, all kinds of paper (including paper or paper boards which have been subjected to various treatments such as coating, impregnating) stated in that context. In that context, it cannot be said that carbon paper cannot be coated paper as such. Shri Kapil submitted that if carbon paper was there then there was no purpose for introducing two sub-items by the Finance Act of 1982. The Finance Minister, however, observed in his speech (extract of para 123 at pp. 38-39 of Part ‘B’) dated 27-2-1982 as follows:

    123. I also propose to rationalise and restructure the tariff relating to paper and paper boards, the primary objective being to exempt small scale paper converters from payment of excise duty and to release them from excise control. In order to recoup the consequent loss in Revenue, I propose to raise the basic excise duty on industrial varieties of paper and paper boards by a small margin of 2½ per cent ad valorem. However, certain converted papers of high value-added categories are proposed to be subject to basic excise duty at 32½ per cent ad valorem. Similarly, specified articles made of paper and paper board are proposed to be brought within the purview of the tariff item but effectively restricting the levy to printed cartons and printed boxes.

    16. It appears that the Finance Minister was adding two items, one was 17(3) — carbon and other copying papers and the second was 17(4) — boxes, cartons, bags and other packing containers. He mentioned in his speech that in order to recoup the consequent loss in Revenue, he proposed to raise the basic excise duty on industrial varieties of paper and paper boards by a small margin of 2½ per cent ad valorem. Tariff Advice No. 5/76 contained the following statement:

    Tariff Advice No. 5/76

    (Board's Letter F. No. 61/2/73-CX. 2 dated 12-2-1976)

    Sub: Paper — Carbon paper and Stencil paper — Whether excisable under Item No. 17 of

    A doubt has been raised whether carbon/stencil paper, produced by conversion of duty paid base paper, should be treated as paper falling under tariff Item 17(4) of Central Excise Tariff or as on item of stationery, outside the scope of Item 17 of Central Excise Tariff.
    2. The matter was considered in the Central Excise Tariff Conference held at Cochin on 13-11-1975 to 15-11-1975. It was reported that carbon paper/stencil paper is sold in the market mostly cut to size by retail stationers. The Indian Customs Tariff Guide has also treated carbon paper as an item of stationery and not as paper. The Conference was therefore, of the view that carbon paper/stencil paper, were commercially recognised only as articles of stationery.
    3. The Board is accordingly advised that carbon paper and stencil paper should be treated as articles of stationery, and therefore outside the purview of Item 17-C Ex. Tariff.
    4. Receipt of this letter may kindly be acknowledged.

    17. These are relevant or proper materials to apply to construe the meaning of the Tariff Items. Moreover, in proper light these do not militate against the view that carbon paper in 1976, was included in the special type of paper, as defined at that time.

    18. In the aforesaid view of the matter, we are of the opinion that as at the relevant time the definition of paper being paper board and all kinds of paper (including paper or paper boards which have been subjected to various treatments such as coating and impregnating) and in the light of the ISI specifications as noted hereinbefore and there being no other reliable evidence as to how coated paper is understood in the market, except the opinion of the Indian Standards Institute in its specifications, in our opinion, the Tribunal was not right in the view it took.

    19. The Tribunal in Kores (India) Ltd. v. CCE, expressed the view that carbon would fall under Item 17(2) of the Tariff Items relying on ISI specifications. There was authority of the Indian Standards Institute's publication “Glossary of Terms used in Paper Trade and Industry” — IS: 4661. In view of the facts as appeared in para 14 of the Tribunal's judgment in Kores (India) Ltd. v. CCE, where the basis of the classifications of ISI in its specifications is explained, we are of the opinion that the carbon paper fell under Item 17(2) as it stood at the relevant period germane for this appeal, before 1982, and not in residuary Item 68 of CET.

    20. Learned Solicitor General submitted that this amendment so far as Item 17(3) was concerned was merely clarificatory and was introduced ex abundanti cautela. Our attention was drawn to the decision of this Court in Md. Qasim Larry, Factory Manager, Sasamusa Sugar Works v. Mohd. Samsuddin AIR 1964 SC 1699, (1964) 7 SCR 419, (1964) 2 LLJ 430, where the court was concerned with the question whether the term “wages” as defined by Section 2(vi) of the Payment of Wages Act, 1936 including wages fixed in an industrial dispute between the employer and the employee. The question had to be answered in the light of the definition prescribed by Section 2(vi) before it was amended in 1958. The subsequent amendment expressly provided by Section 2(vi)(a) that any remuneration payable under any award or settlement between the parties or order of a court, would be included in the main definition under Section 2(vi). In the view we have taken on the construction of the expression as it stood in the relevant time, it is not necessary to rest our decision on the question whether the amendment was clarificatory or not.

    21. In the light of the evidence referred to by the Tribunal in Kores (India) Ltd. v. CCE, and in the light of the definition of paper in CET Item 17(2) as it stood at the relevant time, it is sufficient to hold that it was covered by Item 17(2) of CET and would not fall into the residuary entry.

    22. In that view of the matter, the decision of the Tribunal cannot be sustained on this point and the appeal must be allowed. However, as the point of limitation has not been decided by the Tribunal, we remand the case back to the Tribunal to decide that question having regard to the facts found in this case. The appeal is, therefore, disposed of in the light of what is stated aforesaid. In the facts of this case, the parties will pay and bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Collector Of Central Excise, Kanpur v. Krishna Carbon Paper Co. .
    (Sep 16, 1988)