Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act
  • Section 498-A of Cr. P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act
  • Section 498-A of Cr. P.C,
Smart Summary

Summary of the Opinion — Family Court No. 2, Jaipur (Appeal)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal challenges a decree of divorce granted by Family Court No. 2, Jaipur. The original divorce petition was filed by the husband, Prem Chand Saini, under Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act. The parties were married according to Hindu rites on 11.04.1992 at Mansinghpura, Tonk Road, Jaipur. A male child was born of the marriage in June 1995. The husband alleged that after about six months of marriage the wife began pressurising him to live separately from his parents, engaged in cruel conduct towards him and his parents, and left the matrimonial home on 25.02.1995 and never returned. The divorce petition was filed on 12.07.1997 and decreed by judgment and decree dated 11.06.2002. The wife (respondent in the original petition) appealed against the decree of divorce; the husband filed cross objections challenging the grant of permanent alimony to the wife at Rs. 800 per month and to the minor child at Rs. 400 per month.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent-wife is guilty of cruel behaviour with the applicant-husband after marriage?
  2. Whether the respondent-wife deserted the applicant-husband for more than two years before the date of filing of the divorce petition without any valid reason and failed to perform matrimonial obligations?

Arguments of the Parties

Husband's (Applicant's) Arguments

  • The wife lived with the husband only for about six months and then insisted that he live separately from his parents (who were elderly and unwell).
  • She refused to live with his parents and frequently behaved abusively towards them.
  • She levelled false allegations including dowry demands against the husband and his parents, leading to a criminal case under "Section 498-A of Cr. P.C.", during which the husband remained in custody for about one week (as pleaded before the Family Court).
  • The wife's conduct continued; she left the matrimonial home on 25.02.1995 and never returned, and she refused to come back even after the birth of the child. On one occasion she allegedly pulled the husband's hair.
  • These acts amounted to cruelty and constituted desertion.

Wife's (Respondent's) Arguments

  • The wife denied insisting that the husband live separately from his parents.
  • She alleged that her in-laws demanded dowry and, despite the birth of the male child, she was not taken to the matrimonial home.
  • Because of the dowry demand she did not go to the matrimonial home after February 1995.
  • Other witnesses largely supported the respective versions presented by husband and wife.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed two substantive issues (cruelty and desertion). The applicant-husband gave evidence as PW-1 and called three other witnesses (PW-2 to PW-4). The defendant-wife and several supporting witnesses gave evidence for the defence (DW-1 to DW-5).

The court considered the testimony of PW-1 in which the husband described repeated pressure from the wife to live separately from his parents, abusive conduct towards the parents, false allegations (including alleged dowry demands) which resulted in a criminal case under "Section 498-A of Cr. P.C." and a brief custody period for the husband, and the wife's departure from the matrimonial home on 25.02.1995. The wife denied these allegations and maintained that she stayed away because of dowry demands and was not taken to the matrimonial home after the child's birth.

Weighing the totality of the evidence and the statements on record, the court concluded that the husband succeeded in proving cruelty and desertion by the wife. The court relied on facts found in the evidence: (a) undue insistence on the husband to live separately from his elderly and ailing parents; (b) the filing of a criminal case (Section 498-A of Cr. P.C.) during which the husband was in custody; (c) the wife's leaving the matrimonial home in February 1995 and not returning despite the birth of the child; and (d) leaving the matrimonial home without informing the husband or his parents. The court regarded these connected facts as sufficient indications of cruelty and as establishing desertion.

On the cross objections filed by the husband challenging the award of permanent alimony (Rs. 800 per month to the wife and Rs. 400 per month to the minor child), the court found the cross objections devoid of merit and dismissed them.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal by the wife is dismissed and the decree of divorce granted to the husband is upheld. The husband's cross objections against the alimony awards (Rs. 800 per month in favour of the wife and Rs. 400 per month in favour of the minor child) are dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct effect of the decision is that the divorce decree in favour of the husband stands and the permanent alimony awards to the wife and minor child remain in force as previously ordered by the Family Court. The opinion does not discuss or announce any broader legal principles or new precedent; it addresses the facts of this case and their application to the statutory grounds of cruelty and desertion.

    Santosh Devi (Smt.) v. Prem Chand Saini

    Shiv Kumar Sharma, J.:— This appeal is directed against the decree of divorce granted by the Family Court No. 2, Jaipur along with application under Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act of the husband Prem Chand Saini against wife Smt. Santosh Devi vide judgment and decree dated 11.06.2002

    2. According to the application the parties got married as per Hindu Rites on 11.04.92 at Mansinghpura, Tonk Road, Jaipur and out of the said wedlock in June, 1995 a male child was born. According to the applicant husband after about six months of living together, the respondent-wife started pressurising him to live separately from his parents who were not keeping well and used to go to her parents house even without informing him and her behaviour towards the applicant husband and his parents was cruel and she indulged in several fights with him and his parents and on 25.02.95 she left the matrimonial home and never returned thereafter. Thus on account of cruelty and desertion, the divorce petition was filed on 12.07.97 which was decreed by impugned judgment on 11.06.2002

    3. Being aggrieved by the said decree for divorce, the appellant-wife has preferred this appeal in this Court and cross objections have been filed by the respondent-husband against grant of permanent alimony in favour of wife @ Rs. 800/- per month and for the minor child @ Rs. 400/- per month.

    4. We have heard learned counsel on both the sides and have perused the record.

    5. The learned Family Court framed the following issues:—

    (1) Whether the respondent-wife is guilty of cruel behaviour with the applicant-husband after her marriage?

    (2) Whether the respondent-wife has deserted the applicant-husband for more than two years before the date of filing of the divorce petition without any valid reason and has not performed matrimonial obligations?

    6. In support of the petition, the applicant husband examined before the Family Court himself as PW- 1, PW-2 Lalchand, PW-3 Phooli Devi and PW-4 Pooran. As against this, the defendant-wife was examined as DW-1, Rama Devi, the mother of the respondent-wife as DW-2, Sitaram DW-3, Lalchand DW-4 and Ramji Lal Soni as DW-5.

    7. PW-1 the applicant-husband deposed before the learned Family Court that the defendant-wife lived with him in their matrimonial home in a normal manner only for a period of six months and thereafter she started pressurising the applicant-husband to live separately and she did not want to live with his parents as the father of the applicant-husband was not keeping well. She refused to live with his parents and frequently indulged in abusive behaviour with them. She levelled false allegations against all of them for demand of dowry etc. and as a matter of fact for a criminal case filed against the husband and his parents under Section 498-A of Cr. P.C, the husband had to remain in custody for about one week. The applicant-husband stated further that ultimately the father of the husband died on 28.09.97 and even after birth of the child when the applicant-husband wanted to bring her back to their home, she refused to come and his in-laws indulged in abusive behaviour with them. He also stated that the respondent-wife used to fight with him also and on one occasion she pulled his hair.

    8. As against this, the defendant-wife denied these allegations and deposed before the Court that she never insisted upon the applicant-husband to live separately and on the contrary her in-laws insisted for dowry upon her and despite birth of the male child, she was not taken to her matrimonial home and because of the dowry demand she did not go to her matrimonial home after February, 1995. The other witnesses appearing on both the sides have more or less supported the version given by the husband and the wife.

    9. Having perused the evidence and the statements on record and in view of the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the opinion that there is no force in the appeal filed by the respondent-wife and the applicant-husband has succeeded in proving the case of cruelty and desertion against the respondent-wife. Undue insistence on the husband to live separately from the old aged parents, particularly when one of the parents is ill and countering the filing of divorce petition by a case under Section 498-A of Cr. P.C, during which the applicant-husband had to remain in custody and then leaving the matrimonial home ever since February, 1995. These facts which have been proved by the various witnesses before the Court are sufficient indication, in the opinion of this Court, of acts of cruelty by wife towards the husband. Leaving matrimonial home without informing the parents and the applicant-husband and not coming to matrimonial home ever since February, 1995 shows that the respondent-wife was not at all interested in living with the applicant husband as wife and had deserted the husband, therefore, the learned Family Court has rightly granted the decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty and desertion.

    10. In view of this, we uphold the decree of divorce granted in favour of the applicant-husband and dismiss the appeal of the wife. At the same time, the cross objections filed by the husband against the award of alimony of Rs. 800/- per month in favour of the wife and Rs. 400/- per month in favour of the minor child are also found to be devoid of any merit and accordingly the cross objections are also dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Santosh Devi (Smt.) v. Prem Chand Saini
    (Feb 12, 2007)