Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter called "the Code")
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code
  • Section 115 of the Code.
  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC.
  • Order 6 Rule 17,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter called "the Code")
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code
  • Section 115 of the Code.
  • Order 6 Rule 17 CPC.
  • Order 6 Rule 17,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petition challenges an order passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Makrana, in Civil Suit No. 2/1996 dated 2.9.99, which rejected an application filed under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking amendment of the plaint. The trial court rejected the amendment application on the grounds that the facts sought to be added were already on record, evidence had been led on those issues, and the proposed amendment was not necessary to determine the real controversy between the parties.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an amendment under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure can be allowed at a belated stage when the facts sought to be added were already known and evidence has been led.
  2. Whether an amendment that does not alter the real controversy but adds facts already known to the parties is permissible.
  3. Whether the amendment application can be rejected if it causes injustice or prejudice to the opposite party or changes the nature of the suit.
  4. Whether the court can allow amendment after judgment has been reserved.
  5. The extent to which delay and limitation bar the allowance of amendments under Order VI Rule 17.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.H. Patil v. Pirgonda Hongonda Patil and Ors.; Nanduri Yogananda Laxminarsimhachari and Ors. v. Agasthe Swarswamivaru; Modi Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. Ladha Ram & Co.; Pandit Ishwardas v. State of M.P; Mulk Raj Batra v. District Judge, Dehradun General principles on amendment of pleadings, including allowance at belated stage but not causing injustice or creating a new case. Supported the principle that amendments should not create an entirely new case or cause prejudice.
G. Nagamma and Anr. v. Siromanamma and Anr Similar reiteration of principles regarding amendment; amendment not allowed after judgment reserved. Reiterated that amendment after judgment reserved is impermissible.
Laduram v. Sheodev; Gopal Krishanamurthi v. Shreedhara Rao; Gauri Shankar v. Hindustan Trust (Pvt) Ltd.; Union of India and Ors. v. Surjit Singh Atwal Amendment not allowed if facts were known at the time of plaint and application is belated; gross delay bars amendment. Applied to reject belated amendments based on known facts.
Radhika Devi v. Bajrangi Singh; Dondapati Narayana Reddy v. Duggireddy Venkatanarayana Reddy Amendment barred if it takes away a right acquired by limitation. Supported refusal of amendment that removes time-barred rights.
G. Nagamma and Ors. v. Siromanamma and Anr Alternative relief can be sought by amendment but not if it changes cause of action or materially affects relief claimed. Clarified limits of amendment under Order 6 Rule 17.
Vineet Kumar v. Mangal Sain Wadhera Amendment not allowed if it changes cause of action; allowed if it adds to facts already on record without new cause of action. Allowed amendment that added to existing facts without new cause of action.
Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v. Motor & General Traders Doctrine that right to relief must exist at suit institution; courts can bend procedural rules to promote substantial justice. Supported flexible approach to amendments to promote justice.
Muni Lal v. Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd.; Jagdish Singh v. Nathu Singh Amendment should render substantial justice without causing injustice or violating fair play; allowed even at appellate stage. Supported grant of amendment relief to promote justice.
A.K. Gupta & Sons v. Damodar Valley Corporation; Charan Das v. Amit Khan; L.J. Leach & Co. Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner & Co. Amendment allowed if it does not add new cause of action but only a different approach to same facts, even after limitation expiry. Applied to allow amendments that do not create new causes of action.
Smt. Ganga Bai v. Vijay Kumar Wide discretionary power to allow amendment in interest of justice, governed by judicial care and circumspection. Emphasized careful exercise of discretion in amendment applications.
M/S Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram; B.K.N. Pillai v. P. Pillai and Anr Amendment should be allowed if necessary to promote justice and not to defeat it. Supported allowance of amendments promoting justice.
Estrella Rubber v. Dass Estate Pvt. Ltd. Mere delay not sufficient to reject amendment; rejection requires new case or serious prejudice causing loss of accrued rights. Clarified conditions for rejecting amendment on delay grounds.
Siddalingamma and Anr. v. Mamdha Shenoy; Raghu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan and Ors Doctrine of Relation Back applies to amendments; amended pleadings deemed filed originally for evidence appreciation. Allowed amendments with relation back effect.
Vishwambhar and Ors. v. Laxmi Narayan Amendment changing suit basis does not relate back to original filing date for limitation purposes. Rejected relation back where amendment changes suit basis.
Laxmidas Dahyabhai Kabarwala v. Nanabhai Chunilal Kabarwala Amendment refused if it takes away accrued legal right by lapse of time, except clarifications not adding or altering pleadings substantively. Allowed clarificatory amendments not barred by limitation.
Om Prakash Gupta v. Ranbir B. Goyal Court can take note of subsequent events and mould relief accordingly if conditions of promptness, fairness, and litigation efficiency are met. Allowed amendments incorporating subsequent events necessary for real controversy determination.
Shri Mahant Govind Rao v. Sita Ram Kesho; Messrs. Trojan & Company v. Rm. N.N Nagappa Chettiar Amendment necessary as relief cannot be granted on grounds outside pleadings. Supported amendment to align pleadings with relief sought.
Fritiz T.M. Clement and Anr. v. Sudhakaran Nadar and Anr Amendments that do not change suit basis or prejudice defence should not be rejected; non-application of mind to nature of amendments is error. Condemned rejection of amendments without proper consideration.
Hanuwant Singh Rawat v. Rajputana Automobiles, Ajmer Summarized principles on amendment: necessity for just decision, delay compensation, no alteration of suit nature, bona fide requirement, and protection of accrued rights. Applied comprehensive criteria to assess amendment application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the settled legal principles governing amendments under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure. It emphasized that amendments are generally allowed, even at a belated stage, provided they do not cause injustice or prejudice to the other party, do not change the nature of the suit, or take away accrued legal rights. The Court noted that amendments which merely clarify or add to existing facts without setting up a new cause of action are permissible. However, amendments that introduce new facts known at the time of filing the suit but not pleaded, especially when sought after a long delay and after evidence has been led, are not allowed. The Court held that the amendment sought in the instant case was neither necessary to decide the real controversy nor did it go to the root of the case. Given the belated stage of the application and the knowledge of the facts by the petitioner at the time of the original plaint, allowing the amendment would cause prejudice and was therefore rightly rejected by the trial court. The Court found no irregularity or jurisdictional error in the impugned order and upheld the rejection of the amendment application.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the trial court's order rejecting the amendment application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC at a belated stage where the facts sought to be added were already known and evidence had been led. No new precedent is set; the Court applied established principles to deny amendment that was unnecessary for resolving the real controversy and would cause prejudice to the opposing party.

    Ratan Singh & Anr. v. Ram Prasad & Ors.

    1. The instant revision petition has been filed against the order passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Makrana, in Civil Suit No. 2/1996 passed on 2.9.99 rejecting the application filed under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter called "the Code") for amendment in the plaint.

    2. The said application has been rejected, giving the details of the plaint, by the learned trial Court on the ground that the facts suggested in the amendment application are already on record and on the said issues, evidence has already been led, thus, by amendment; the facts sought to be incorporated were not necessary to determine the real controversy in issue between the parties.

    3. It is settled legal proposition that amendment in the pleadings may generally be allowed and the amendment may also be allowed at a belated stage. However, it should not cause injustice or prejudice to the other side. The amendment sought should be necessary for the purpose of determining the real question in controversy between the parties. Application for amendment may be rejected if the other party cannot be placed in the same position as if the pleadings had been originally correct, but the amendment would cause him injury which could not be compensated in terms of cost or change the nature of the suit itself as it cannot be permitted to create an entirely new case by amendment. A right accrued in favour of a party by lapse of time cannot be permitted to be taken away by amendment. Amendment can also be allowed at appellate stage. Introduction of an entirely new case, displacing even admission by a party is not permissible. (Vide P.H. Patil v. Pirgonda Hongonda Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patil and Ors. (1), Nanduri Yogananda Laxminarsimhachari and Ors. v. Agasthe Swarswamivaru, (2), Modi Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. Ladha Ram & Co. (3), Pandit Ishwardas v. State of M.P. (4), and Mulk Raj Batra v. District Judge, Dehradun, (5).

    4. Similar view has been reiterated in G. Nagamma and Anr. v. Siromanamma and Anr. (6). However, a party cannot be permitted to move an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code after the judgment has been reserved. (Vide Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar and Ors. (7),

    5. In Laduram v. Sheodev (8), this Court held that if the plaintiff wants to add certain facts, which the plaintiff had not chosen to mention in the original plaint and the same had been in his knowledge when the plaint was instituted, the plaintiff cannot be allowed to make fresh allegation of facts by way of amendment at a belated stage. While deciding the said case, this Court placed reliance upon the judgment in Gopal Krishanamurthi v. Shreedhara Rao (9). In Gauri Shankar v. Hindustan Trust (Pvt) Ltd. (10), the Apex Court held that in case of gross delay, application for amendment must be rejected. Same view had been reiterated in Union of India and Ors. v. Surjit SinghAtwal (11).

    6. It is settled legal proposition that amendment sought time- barred, where the party acquires right by bar of limitation and if the same is sought to be taken away by amendment of pleadings, amendment in such circumstance must be refused. (Vide Radhika Devi v. Bajrangi Singh (12), and Dondapati Narayana Reddy v. Duggireddy Venkatanarayana Reddy (13).

    7. In G. Nagamma and Ors. v. Siromanamma and Anr. (14), the Hon'ble Apex Court held that in an application under Order 6 Rule 17, even an alternative relief can be sought; however, it should change the cause of action or materially affect the relief claimed earlier,

    8. In Vineet Kumar v. Mangal Sain Wadhera. (15), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that normally amendment is not allowed if it changes the cause of action, but where the amendment does not constitute the addition of a new cause of action, or raises a new case, but amounts to not more than adding to the facts already on record, the amendment should be allowed even after the statutory period of limitation.

    9. In Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v. Motor & General Traders. (16), the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under :-

    "It is basic to our processual jurisprudence that the right to relief must be judges to exist as on the date a suitor institutes the legal proceeding. Equally cleanis the principle that procedure is the handmaid and not the mistress of the judicial process. If a fact, arising after the lis has come to court and has a fundamental impact on the right to relief or the manner of moulding it, is brought diligently to the notice of the tribunal, it cannot blink at it or be blind to events which stultify or render inept the decretal remedy. Equity justifies bending the rules of procedure, where no specific provision or fairplay is not violated, with a view to promote substantial justice-subject, of course, to the absence of other disentitling factors or just circumstances. Nor can we contemplate any limitation on this power to take note of updated facts to confine it to the trial court."

    10. In Muni Lal v. Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. (17), the Hon'ble Apex Court held that the relief of amendment should be granted to

    "render substantial justice without causing injustice to the other party or violating fair play and the Court should be entitled to grant proper relief even at the state of appellate forum."
    Similar view has beerj reiterated in Jagdish Singh v. Nathu Singh (18).

    11. In A.K. Gupta & Sons v. Damodar Valley Corporation (19), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that where the amendment does not constitute the addition of new cause of action or raises a different case but amounts to no more than an additional different approach to the same facts, the amendment should be allowed even if the statutory period of limitation has expired. While deciding the said case, reliance had been placed upon the judgment in Charan Das v. Amit Khan (20) and L.J. Leaon & Co. Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner & Co. (21). The Court observed as under :-

    The general rule, no doubt, is that a party is not allowed by amendment to set up a newtase or a new cause of action, particularly when . a suit on new case or cause of action is barred (Weldon v. Neal, ( 1887) 19 QBD 394), but it is also well recognised that where the amendment does not constitute the addition of a new cause of action or raises a different case, but amounts to no more than a different or additional approach of the same facts, the amendment can be allowed even after the expiry of statutory period of limitation. ( Charan-das v. Amir Khan, AIR 1921 PC 50; and L.J. Leach & Co. Ltd. v. Jardine Skinner & Co., AIR 1957 SC 357).

    12. In Smt. Ganga Bai v. Vijay Kumar (22), the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under :-

    "The power to allow an amendment is undoubtedly wide and may, at any stage, be properly exercised in the interest of justice, the law of limitation notwithstanding, but the exercise of such far-reaching discretionary power is governed by judicial consideration and wider the discretion, greater ought to be the care and circumspection on the part of the Court."

    13. In M/S Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram . (23), the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that where amendment is found to be necessary for promoting the ends of justice and not for defeating it, the application should be allowed. Similar view had been reiterated in B.K.N. Pillai v. P. Pillai and Anr. (24).

    14. In Estrella Rubber v. Dass Estate Pvt. Ltd., (25), the Supreme Court held that mere delay in making the amendment application is not enough to reject the application unless a new case is made out, or serious prejudice is shown to have been caused to the other side so as to take away any accrued right.

    15. Similarly, in Siddalingamma and Anr. v. Mamdha Shenoy (26), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the Doctrine of Relation Back applies in case of amendment for the reason that the amendment generally governs the pleadings as amended pleadings would be deemed to have been filed originally as such and the evidence has to be read and appreciated in the light of the averments made in the amendment petition. Similar view has been reiterated in Raghu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan and Ors. (27):

    16. But in Vishwambhar and Ors. v. Laxmi Narayan (28), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the amendment, though properly made, shall not relate back the date of filing of the suit and cure the defect of limitation where the amendment changes the basis of the suit itself and in such an eventuality, suit has to be considered to have been filed on the date of amendment for the purpose of limitation.

    17. In Laxmidas Dahyabhai Kabarwala v. Nanabhai Chunilal Kabarwala (29), the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under :-

    "It is true that save in exceptional cases, leave to amend under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code will ordinarily be refused when the effect of the amendment would be to take away from a party a legal right which had accrued to him by lapse of time. But this rule can apply only when either fresh allegations added or fresh relief sought by way of amendment. Where, for instance, an amendment is sought which merely clarifies an existing pleading and does not in substance add to or alter it, it has never been held that the question of a bar of limitation is one of the questions to be considered in allowing such clarification of a matter already contained in the original pleading. The present is a fortiori so."

    18. In Om Prakash Gupta v. Ranbir B. Goyal. (30), the Apex Court held that the ordinary rule of civil law is that the rights of the parties stand crystallised on the date of the institution of the suit and, therefore, the decree in a suit should accord with the rights of the parties as they stood at the commencement of the lis. However, the Court has power to take note of subsequent events and mould the relief accordingly subject to the following conditions being satisfied: (i) that the relief, as claimed ordinarily has, by reason of subsequent events, become inappropriate or cannot be granted; (ii) that taking note of such subsequent event or changed circumstances would shorten litigation and enable complete justice being done to the parties; and (iii) that such subsequent event is brought to the notice of the court promptly and in accordance with the rules of procedural law so that the opposite party is not taken by surprise. The Court further observed as under :-

    "Such subsequent event may be one purely of law or founded on facts. In the former case, the court may take judicial note of the event and before acting thereon put the parties on notice of how the change in law is going to affect the rights and obligations of the parties and modify or mould the course of litigation or the relief so as to bring it in conformity with the law. In the latter case, the controversy either as to their existence or in their impact, is expected to have resort to amendment of pleadings under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. Such subsequent event, the Court may permit being introduced into the pleadings by way of amendment as it would be necessary to do so far the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties."

    19. The amendment may be necessary for the reason that decision of a case cannot be based on grounds out-side the pleadings of the parties and it is the case pleaded that has to be founded; without the amendment of the pleadings, the Court would not be entitled to modify or alter the relief as relief not founded on pleadings cannot be granted. (Vide Shri Mahant Govind Rao v. Sita Ram Kesho (31); and Messrs. Trojan & Company v. Rm. N.N Nagappa Chettiar. (32).

    20. In Fritiz T.M. Clement and Anr. v. Sudhakaran Nadar and Anr. (33), the Apex Court examined the similar issue and held as under :-

    "There is nothing in these two sub-paras which changes the basis and character of the suit. Nor can they have any prejudicial effect vis-a-vis the defence of respondents.....Some of these averments may, at best be considered unnecessary but do not tantamount to setting up a new case or cause of action. So also, the mere fact that in regard to quantification of the fee, some changes are sought to be introduced while retaining the total amount claimed in the original plaint, does not mean that the nature of relief claimed has undergone a material change. Therefore, the grounds of rejection of amendments are legally unjustified and based on non-application of mind to the exact nature of amendments."

    21. In Hanuwant Singh Rawat v. Rajputana Automobiles, Ajmer (34), this Court (Jaipur Bench) summarised the legal position as under :-

    (i) That the amendment of pleadings should ordinarily be allowed by the Court, once it is satisfied that the amendment is necessary for the just and proper decision of the controversy between the parties;

    (ii) The amendment of the pleadings should not ordinarily be declined only on the ground of delay on the part of the appellant in seeking leave of the Court to amend the pleadings, if the opposite party can suitably be compensated by means of costs etc. Even inconsistent pleas can be allowed to be raised by amendment in the pleadings;

    (iii) However, amendment of pleadings cannot be allowed so as to completely alter the nature of the suit;

    (iv) Amendment of the pleadings must not be allowed when amendment is not necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in the controversy between the parties;

    (v) The amendment should be refused where the plaintiff's suit would be wholly displaced by the proposed amendment;

    (vi) Where the effect of the amendment would be to take away from the defendant a legal right which has accrued to him by lapse of time or by operation of some law;

    (vii) The amendment in the pleadings should not be allowed where the court finds that amendment sought for has not been made in good faith or suffers from lack of bonafides; and

    (viii) Ordinarily, the amendment must not be allowed where a party wants to withdraw from the admission made by it in the original pleadings."

    22. The instant case requires consideration in the light of the aforesaid settled legal propositions. In the instant case, as the amendment sought does not go to the root of the case, nor it is necessary to decide the controversy and the facts, which petitioner wanted to add, were in his knowledge and the amendment application has been moved at a belated stage, i.e. after several years, and at such a belated stage the amendment sought by the revisionist is not possible, nor the same is necessary to decide the real controversy in the dispute between the parties. Therefore, it cannot be held that in refusing the amendment, the Court below has committed any irregularity or jurisdictional error and as such, the order impugned requires to be interfered in exercise of jurisdiction of this Court under Section 115 of the Code.

    The revision is devoid of any merit and accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ratan Singh & Anr. v. Ram Prasad & Ors.
    (Mar 7, 2002)