Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Consumer Protection Act. There, 9 persons
  • Motor Vehicles Act and the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Consumer Protection Act. There, 9 persons
  • Motor Vehicles Act and the Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On November 8, 1996, at about 5:30–6:00 A.M., a goods vehicle (No. RJC 4009) capsized and turned turtle, resulting in the death of 12 labourers who were being carried in that vehicle. It was alleged that these labourers worked with one Gopi Kishan Tapria (a contractor) and were returning to resume work after Diwali holidays. The claimants asserted that the labourers were being carried under a contract between Gopi Kishan Tapria and the truck owner.

In the claim petitions the truck owner and driver pleaded mechanical failure (failure of brakes) and denied negligence. The Insurance Company denied liability on the basis of breach of policy terms and additionally contended it had no statutory liability to pay compensation.

The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal found the owner and the driver liable but absolved the Insurance Company of all liability, on the basis that the deceased persons were gratuitous passengers in the goods vehicle. The Tribunal relied on several decisions of courts (listed in the opinion).

Multiple appeals and cross-objections arose from that decision. The appeals (by the claimants) and the cross-objections (by the Insurance Company and by the owner) were heard together and are disposed of by the present common order. The Insurance Company also filed cross-objections seeking reimbursement of sums (Rs. 50,000 in each case) it had paid as no-fault liability because the Tribunal had not directed reimbursement by the owner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Insurance Company should be held liable (statutorily or contractually) to compensate the claimants for deaths that occurred while the deceased were being carried in a goods vehicle.
  2. Whether the Insurance Company, having paid amounts as "no fault" liability, is entitled to be reimbursed by the owner where the insurer is held not liable statutorily or contractually.
  3. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal requires enhancement.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Claimants') Arguments

  • The appellants principally challenged the Tribunal's finding absolving the Insurance Company of liability.
  • There was a limited attempt to argue for enhancement of the compensation awarded, though that was not pressed seriously by the time of hearing.
  • The appellants relied on several authorities (including Supreme Court decisions Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan and B.V. Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., and various High Court and this Court decisions) to support their contentions.

Insurance Company's Arguments (Respondent)

  • The Insurance Company asserted that it was not liable because of breach of terms of the insurance policy and also contended that it had no statutory liability to pay compensation for these passengers.
  • In support, the Insurance Company relied on the decisions cited by the Tribunal and additionally cited New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohanbhai Ravjibhai (1994 Acc CJ 970, Gujarat).
  • The Insurance Company also sought, by way of cross-objection, reimbursement of amounts it had paid as no-fault liability because the Tribunal had not ordered reimbursement by the owner.

Owner and Driver's Plea

  • The owner and driver defended on the basis that the accident arose from failure of brakes and denied negligence on the part of the driver.
  • The owner filed cross-objections challenging the Tribunal's absolution of the Insurance Company, i.e., seeking to maintain insurer liability.

Tribunal's Reliance

  • The Tribunal held the owner and driver responsible but absolved the Insurance Company, finding that the deceased persons were gratuitous passengers. It relied on several authorities (including Santra Bai v. Prahlad and others listed in the opinion) in reaching that conclusion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in this Opinion
Santra Bai v. Prahlad, 1985 Raj LW 354 : (AIR 1986 Raj 101) (Full Bench) Held that where a passenger is a gratuitous passenger going on a joy‑ride or on his own responsibility, the Insurance Company is not liable. Relied upon by the court as supporting the Tribunal's conclusion that gratuitous passengers in a goods vehicle are not covered by insurer's liability.
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Dhundhmma, 1992 Acc CJ 1 (Kant) This opinion notes the case was cited by the Tribunal; the specific principle from the case is not detailed in the text. Noted as one of the authorities relied upon by the Tribunal in absolving the Insurance Company; the Court treated it as supporting the Tribunal's position.
New India Insurance Company v. Kanchan, 1994 Acc CJ 138 : (AIR 1994 Orissa 65) (Full Bench) The opinion records that this case was cited by the Tribunal; the text does not specify the exact rule applied from it. Identified as authority relied upon by the Tribunal in absolving insurer; used to support the Tribunal's reasoning.
United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Jumibai, 1989 Acc CJ 1150 (Bombay) Cited by the Tribunal; the opinion does not elaborate the principle from the decision. Counted among the authorities relied on by the Tribunal to absolve the insurer.
Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, AIR 1987 SC 1184 (Supreme Court) Dealt with breach of policy condition regarding vehicle being driven by a licensed driver; held that an owner who engaged a licensed driver is not to be treated as breaching the policy solely because that driver negligently allowed an unlicensed person to handle the vehicle; it was a case of statutory liability under Sections 95–96 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The court analysed and distinguished this case on facts, holding it inapplicable because Skandia did not concern carriage of passengers in a goods vehicle.
B. V. Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Office, Hassan, AIR 1996 SC 2054 (Supreme Court) In that case a goods vehicle carried 9 persons though policy permitted 6; the Supreme Court read down the policy condition where the breach had no nexus with the accident; the claim there was for damage to the vehicle and the claimants were not the passengers. The court held Nagaraju distinguishable on facts and unsuitable as authority for imposing insurer liability where passengers (who are claimants) were carried in breach of policy and in violation of law.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Puni Devi, 1995 Acc CJ 486 (Himachal Pradesh) Cited by the appellants; the opinion does not detail the principle from this decision. Mentioned among authorities relied upon by appellants; the Court did not adopt it as determinative on these facts.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ved Prakash, 1995 Acc CJ 1125 (Himachal Pradesh) Cited by the appellants; the opinion does not specify the legal rule stated in the source text. Noted among cases relied upon by appellants but distinguished or not treated as controlling for the present facts.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Usha Rani, 1996 Acc CJ 489 (Punjab & Haryana) According to the opinion, in that case passengers were found not to be gratuitous and the issue of breach of law was not raised. Distinguished on facts: court found Usha Rani inapplicable because here passengers were gratuitous and breach of law was directly in issue.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Lachhmi Devi, 1996 Acc CJ 496 (Himachal Pradesh) Noted by the opinion as a case where passengers were not found to be gratuitous; the text does not provide additional principle details. Distinguished on facts by the court; the authority was held inapplicable to the present situation.
Jagdish v. Okhar, (1991) 2 Raj LW 357 (this Court) Cited by the appellants; the opinion does not elaborate the rule from this decision in the provided text. Mentioned among authorities relied upon by appellants but not treated as determinative in the present decision.
Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co., Solapur v. Hirabai Vithal Nikam, AIR 1988 Bombay 199 (Bombay Full Bench) Held that where a goods vehicle is not covered by permit for hire or reward and the insurance contract does not cover carriage of passengers for hire/reward, the insurer is not liable for death or bodily injury; the Full Bench held that even fare‑paying passengers in such a goods vehicle were not covered by insurer's liability. Relied upon by the court as persuasive support for the Tribunal's finding that insurer was not liable where carriage of passengers was not covered by policy/permit.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohanbhai Ravjibhai, 1994 Acc CJ 970 (Gujarat Division Bench) Held that a gratuitous passenger travelling in a goods vehicle is not covered by statutory or contractual liability of the insurer (as noted in the opinion). Adopted by the court as an authority consistent with the Tribunal's conclusion that gratuitous passengers in a goods vehicle fall outside insurer liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by identifying whether precedent authorities relied upon by the parties were applicable on the facts of these cases and then applying legal principles concerning statutory and contractual liability of insurers where passengers are carried in goods vehicles.

  1. The court examined the Supreme Court decisions relied on by the appellants (Skandia and B.V. Nagaraju) and found both distinguishable on facts:
    • Skandia concerned a breach of a condition about a licensed driver and an incident where a cleaner unauthorisedly interfered with the vehicle; it did not involve carriage of passengers in a goods vehicle and therefore was not on point for the present facts.
    • B. V. Nagaraju involved a claim for damage to a goods vehicle where the policy permitted 6 persons but 9 were carried; the breach of condition was held to have no nexus with the accident and the claimants were not the passengers. Thus, Nagaraju could not be read as authority for imposing insurer liability for death or injury to passengers who themselves were travelling in breach of policy and of the Motor Vehicles Act and Rules.
  2. The court observed that in the present cases the deceased persons were being carried in the goods vehicle in contravention both of the insurance contract and of the Motor Vehicles Act and Rules, and that this fact materially distinguishes these cases from the authorities cited by appellants where such a legal breach was absent or where the claimants were not passengers.
  3. The court considered decisions where passengers were held not to be gratuitous or where the breach of law was not an issue (for example Usha Rani and Lachhmi Devi) and rejected their applicability, because in the present matter gratuitous carriage and statutory/contractual breach were central facts.
  4. The court relied on authoritative Full Bench and Division Bench decisions (Santra Bai; Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Solapur v. Hirabai; New India Assurance v. Mohanbhai Ravjibhai) supporting the proposition that gratuitous passengers carried in a goods vehicle are not covered by the insurer's statutory or contractual liability. The court found these authorities to be directly applicable and persuasive.
  5. Based on the foregoing factual distinctions and precedents, the court concluded that the Tribunal correctly absolved the Insurance Company both of statutory and contractual liability in respect of the deaths of the persons who were gratuitous passengers in the goods vehicle.
  6. On the quantum of compensation, the court reviewed the awards and found no substance in the limited enhancement arguments advanced; it held that the Tribunal had fixed compensation correctly in light of the record and circumstances.
  7. Regarding the cross-objections: the owner's cross-objections (challenging absolution of the insurer) were rejected as lacking merit (they raised the same points as appellants). The insurer's cross-objections, however, were allowed insofar as the insurer had paid amounts as no-fault liability which the Tribunal had not ordered to be reimbursed by the owner; the court considered that, since the insurer was not statutorily or contractually liable, amounts paid by it on behalf of the owner as no-fault liability were recoverable from the owner. The court observed that the Tribunal, apparently through inadvertence, had not ordered such reimbursement and rectified that omission.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • The appeals of the claimants and the cross‑objections of the owners are dismissed.
  • The cross‑objections of the Insurance Company are allowed in that the amounts paid by the Insurance Company as no‑fault liability in these cases shall be recoverable by the Insurance Company from the owners of the vehicle.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The Insurance Company is held not liable (statutorily or contractually) to compensate the claimants for the deaths of persons who were gratuitous passengers in the goods vehicle in breach of the insurance contract and of the Motor Vehicles Act and Rules; the Tribunal's absolution of the insurer is affirmed.
  • Reimbursement: The insurer is entitled to recover from the vehicle owners the amounts it had paid as no‑fault liability because it was not itself statutorily or contractually liable to pay compensation in respect of those passengers.
  • No enhancement of compensation was directed: the Tribunal's assessments of quantum are upheld.
  • Precedential scope: The court's decision rests on applying existing authorities to the specific facts (gratuitous carriage in a goods vehicle and breach of policy/Act); the opinion does not purport to create a new general rule beyond the application of those principles to the present facts.

Note: This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion. No additional factual or legal inferences beyond what is stated in the opinion have been made.

    Smt. Paroo And Others v. Likhma Ram And Others

    1. These appeals raise a common question as to whether the Insurance Company should have been held liable for compensating the claimants in respect of the accident to a goods vehicle in which the deceased were being carried at the time of the accident. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for short 'the Tribunal' hereinafter) has held only the owner and the driver liable and has absolved Insurance Company of all liability. In each of these appeals, the Insurance Company has filed cross-objections as the sum of Rupees 50,000/- in each case, the Insurance Company had to pay as no fault liability was not directed to be reimbursed by the owner to it. The owner also filed cross-objections against the Insurance Company being absolved of the liability. The appeals and the cross-objections were heard together and are being decided by this common order.

    2. On November 8, 1996 at about 5.30 to 6.00 A.M. goods vehicle No. RJC 4009 capsized and turned turtle killing 12 labourers who were being carried in it. It was claimed that these labourers used to work with one Gopikishan Tapria Contractor and they were going back to resume their work after enjoying Diwali holidays. It was also claimed that they were being carried under a contract between Gopi Kishan Tapria and the owner of the truck. In reply to the claim petitions, the owner and the driver took the plea that the accident took place because of failure of brakes and the driver of the truck was not negligent. The Insurance Company denied any liability because of breach of terms of policy. The Insurance Company also contended that it did not have any statutory liability also to pay compensation. The Tribunal held the owner and the driver responsible but absolved the Insurance Company finding that the deceased persons were gratuitous passengers in the truck. The Tribunal relied on the decisions of this Court in Santra Bai v. Prahlad, 1985 Raj LW 354: (AIR 1986 Raj 101), National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Dhundhmma, 1992 Acc CJ 1 (Kant), New India Insurance Company v. Kanchan, 1994 Acc CJ 138 : (AIR 1994 Orissa 65) (FB) and United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Jumibai, 1989 Acc CJ 1150 (Bombay).

    3. The learned counsel for the appellants, mainly challenged the finding of the Tribunal that the Insurance Company was not liable. There was a feeble attempt for enhancement of compensation also but ultimately that also was not abandoned.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellants relied on the decisions of the Supreme Court in Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, AIR 1987 SC 1184 and B.V Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan., Divisional Office, Hassan, AIR 1996 SC 2054. Reliance was also placed on the decisions of the Himachal Pradesh High Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Puni, Devi, 1995 Acc CJ 486 (Him Pra), Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ved Prakash, 1995 Acc CJ 1125 (Him Pra), New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Usha Rani, 1996 Acc CJ 489 (Punj & Har), New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Lachhmi Devi, 1996 Acc CJ 496 (Him Pra) and this Court decision in Jagdish v. Okhar, (1991) 2 Raj LW 357.

    5. The learned counsel appearing for the; respondent Insurance Company relied on the decisions cited by the Tribunal in its order itself and in addition also cited decision in the New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohanbhai Ravjibhai, 1994 Acc CJ 970 (Gujarat).

    6. Skandia Insurance Company's case, (AIR 1987 SC 1184) (supra) related to liability arising out of breach of condition of the policy relating to: the vehicle being driven by a licenced driver. The case clearly was of statutory liability under Section 95 of the Act which had to be satisfied under Section 96 of the Act by the Insurer. Accident in that case arose as the truck after being unloaded was left stationary with the engine on by the driver who had gone to fetch snacks leaving the, truck in the control of the cleaner. The cleaner unauthorisedly interfered with the vehicle and the, accident occurred. In these circumstances, the Supreme Court held that the owner who had entrusted the vehicle to a licenced driver could not be held to have committed breach of a condition of the contract with the Insurance Company only because the licenced driver he had engaged negligently allowed an unlicenced driver to handle the vehicle.

    7. B. V. Nagaraju's case (AIR 1996 SC 2054) (supra) went to the Supreme Court from the decision of the State Commission and National Commission under the Consumer Protection Act. There, 9 persons were carried in a truck where the policy permitted only 6 and none of these 9 persons or their LRs were the claimants. The claim was in respect of damage to the vehicle only.

    8. Both the aforesaid cases are clearly distinguishable on facts. In Skandia's case (AIR 1987 SC 1184) as already observed, the question was not of carrying passengers in a goods vehicle. In B. V. Nagaraju' s case (AIR 1996 SC 2054), the condition of the policy was read down because the breach of the condition had no nexus with the accident. It was held that when 9 persons were carried in a goods vehicle when 6 were permissible, that cannot be made a ground of avoiding responsibility for compensating damage suffered to the goods vehicle because of negligence of the driver of some other vehicle. In that case claimants were not the passengers travelling in the goods vehicle in breach of law as well as in breach of the conditions of the policy. The claimant was the owner of the goods vehicle which was damaged and the claim was for damage to vehicle only. This will make the whole difference 9. In the present cases, the claimants are such persons who were being earned in the goods vehicle not only in breach of contract of Insurance alone but also in violation of the Motor Vehicles Act and the Rules made thereunder. B. V. Nagaraju's case (AIR 1996 SC 2054) is also therefore distinguishable on facts. It cannot be taken to be an authority for ignoring the policy condition altogether and fixing the liability to pay compensation on the Insurance Company in respect of passengers travelling in the goods vehicle in breach of policy conditions as well as in breach of law.

    10. Usha Rani's case (1996 Acc CJ 489) (Punj & Hary) and Lachhmi Devi's case (1996 Acc CJ 496) (Him Pra) (supra) are also distinguishable on facts. In these cases passengers were found not to be gratuitous passengers on facts and the point of breach of law was not raised. These cases have therefore no application to the facts of the cases in hand.

    11. On the contrary, full Bench of this Court in Smt. Santra Bai v. Prahlad 1985 Raj LW 354 : (AIR 1986 Raj 101) has held that in case of a gratuitous passenger going on joy-ride or on his own responsibility, Insurance Company is not liable.

    12. Similar view has been taken by the Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Solapur v. Hirabai Vithal Nikam, AIR 1988 Bombay 199, in which it has been held that the vehicle in which the deceased travelled was the goods vehicle, the contract of insurance entered into with the appellant did not cover the carriage of passengers for hire or, reward in this vehicle, the vehicle was not covered by a permit to ply for hire or reward. When the vehicle was not covered by permit to ply for hire or reward, it was used for the purpose not allowed by the permit under which it was used. It was therefore, held that where a passenger is carried in a goods vehicle for hire or reward and the terms of the contract of insurance do not cover such carriage, the insurer is not liable for the death or bodily injury. Thus not only the gratuitous passengers but even fare paying passengers in the goods vehicle were held to be not covered by the liability of the Insurance Company.

    13. A Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohanbhai Ravjibhai, 1994 Acc CJ 970, also took the view that a gratuitous passenger travelling in the goods vehicle is not covered by the statutory or contractual liability of the Insurance Company.

    14. As a result of the aforesaid discussion, I am of the opinion that the Tribunal has rightly held the Insurance Company to be not liable statutorily or contractually and the appeals must fail on that count.

    15. I have gone through the quantum of compensation given in each case, even when no serious arguments were advanced for enhancement of compensation. I find that in all the cases, the quantum of compensation has been fixed rightly looking to the over all circumstances of the case and the material on record. There is no force in the appeals on that count also.

    16. So far as the cross objections of owner are concerned, in view of the aforesaid discussion that has also to be turned down. The owner has raised the same points which the claimants have (sic)ed in the appeals and there is no force in the contentions also. So far as the cross objections of Insurance Company are concerned, they deserve to be allowed because it has already been held that Insurance Company was not liable and when it was not statutorily or contractually liable, it was not liable for meeting the no fault liability either. It appears that through inadvertence, the Tribunal did not pass order for reimbursement of the amount paid by the Insurance Company on behalf of the owner - appellant as no fault liability. The cross objections filed by the Insurance Company are therefore allowed and it is directed that the amount paid in these appeals by the Insurance Company as no fault liability to the claimants shall be recoverable by it from the owners of the vehicle. 17. Consequently, the appeals of the claimants and the cross objections of the owners are dismissed. The cross objections of the Insurance Company are allowed. There shall however, be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Paroo And Others v. Likhma Ram And Others
    (Jan 31, 1997)