Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a revision petition challenging the order dated 26-7-1996 passed by the Additional District Judge No. 4, Jaipur City, which allowed an alleged "family settlement" document to be taken on record and rejected objections to its admissibility.

Procedural facts: In a suit for partition filed by the plaintiff-petitioner, the trial court summoned a copy of an alleged family settlement from the file of the Jagir Commissioner. During the cross-examination of Dr. Hari Singh (defendant No. 14), opposing counsel sought to exhibit that copy on the ground that Dr. Hari Singh had previously produced it before the Jagir Commissioner. The plaintiff-petitioner and Dr. Hari Singh filed two separate applications objecting to admissibility, contending that the alleged family settlement was unstamped, unregistered, and produced only as a copy without prior permission for adducing secondary evidence. The trial court dismissed both applications, and the petitioner filed the present revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the alleged "family settlement" document, which on its face creates rights in immovable property, is a document compulsorily registrable under the Registration Act and therefore required to be properly stamped and registered before it can be admitted in evidence.
  2. Whether a copy (secondary evidence) of an original document that creates rights in immovable property can be exhibited without producing the original or without prior permission for adducing secondary evidence.
  3. Whether the fact that the document was previously exhibited before the Jagir Commissioner without objection estops the objecting parties from raising admissibility and stamping/registration objections at trial.

Arguments of the Parties

Arguments advanced for the non-petitioners (counsel: Vidhya Bhushan Sharma)

  • It was argued that the plaintiff had already obtained the benefit of the document before the Jagir Commissioner when it was exhibited there and no objection was taken at that stage; therefore, no objection to admissibility could be tenable now.
  • It was contended that no stamp is needed for the execution of a family settlement and that a family settlement is not compulsorily registrable.
  • It was further argued that there was no jurisdictional error in the impugned order and hence the revision should not be interfered with.

Arguments advanced for the petitioner (counsel: D.D. Patodia)

  • The revision is maintainable.
  • The alleged family settlement was unstamped and unregistered and therefore could not be admitted in evidence.
  • Secondary evidence (a copy) could not be produced unless prior permission of the court was sought for adducing secondary evidence.
  • The impugned order suffers from grave jurisdictional error and should be set aside.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kale v. Deputy Director of Consolidation, AIR 1976 SC 807 Distinction between (a) a document that contains terms and recitals of a family arrangement (which, if reducing terms to writing, may require registration) and (b) a mere memorandum prepared after a family arrangement has been made for record or court information (which does not create or extinguish rights and is not compulsorily registrable). The court applied the Kale distinction to conclude that the document before it was not a mere memorandum prepared after an oral arrangement but a written instrument that creates rights in immovable property, and therefore was compulsorily registrable and required proper stamping.
Champa Lal v. Panna Lal, 1951 Raj LW 258 The contents of a document required to be executed on stamp, if not stamped or insufficiently stamped, cannot be proved by secondary evidence; estoppel does not permit proof by secondary evidence in such a case. The court relied on this authority to reject the estoppel argument that prior exhibition before the Jagir Commissioner cured admissibility defects. The court held that an unstamped or insufficiently stamped instrument cannot be proved by secondary evidence, and Section 36 of the Stamp Act applies only where the instrument itself is produced.
Nihal Singh v. Singh Ram, 1989 (1) Rai LR 384 Held that an unstamped and unregistered document required by law to be stamped and registered cannot be admitted in evidence even for collateral purposes; trial court ordering admissibility can be set aside in revision. The court invoked this decision to support the conclusion that the trial court erred in admitting secondary evidence of an unstamped and unregistered document and that such an order must be set aside on revision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a step-by-step analytical manner strictly grounded in the contents of the record and cited authorities:

  1. Examination of the document: The court first inspected the alleged family settlement itself and found that it on its face creates and transfers rights in immovable property. The opinion refers to specific columns in the document showing that the first party retains absolute and exclusive ownership of certain properties while other parties relinquish claims, and that transfer of interests and life interests are recorded.
  2. Application of precedent distinguishing memorandum from substantive instrument: Relying on Kale (AIR 1976 SC 807), the court drew the critical distinction between a memorandum prepared after an arrangement (which does not create rights and is not registrable) and a document that contains the terms of a family arrangement and thereby creates or transfers rights (which is registrable when it affects immovable property and is reduced to writing). The court found the present instrument to be of the latter category.
  3. Statutory framework: The court referred to Section 17 (documents requiring registration) and Section 49 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908, which stipulates that documents required to be registered by Section 17 (or by any provision of the Transfer of Property Act) shall not be received as evidence unless registered. Based on the document's nature, the court held it was compulsorily registrable and ought to have been executed on proper stamps.
  4. Rejection of estoppel/previous exhibition argument: Addressing the argument that the document had been exhibited earlier before the Jagir Commissioner without objection and therefore objections are now barred, the court relied on Champa Lal to hold that principles of estoppel do not apply to permit proving the contents of a document required to be stamped by secondary evidence where the original is absent or unstamped.
  5. On secondary evidence and the Stamp Act: The court noted that Section 36 of the Stamp Act is applicable where an unstamped or insufficiently stamped instrument itself is sought to be admitted; however, where the instrument itself is not produced at trial and only secondary evidence is tendered, Section 36 has no application to permit proof by secondary evidence. In the present case the original was not before the trial court and secondary evidence was permitted without proper legal foundation.
  6. Supporting authority and conclusion on illegality: The court relied on Nihal Singh v. Singh Ram to support its conclusion that admitting an unstamped and unregistered instrument required to be stamped and registered is impermissible even for collateral purposes. Consequently, the trial court's admission of the alleged family settlement and rejection of the applications objecting to admissibility were found to be illegal exercises of jurisdiction which would occasion a failure of justice if allowed to stand.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held the revision petition in favour of the petitioner. In the opinion's dispositive paragraph the court explicitly states: the revision petition is allowed and the order dated 26-7-1996 of the trial court is set aside. No costs.

(The text of the opinion also contains the line "Petition dismissed." presented as a block quote; the court's clear operative statement immediately preceding that line is that the revision petition is allowed and the impugned order is set aside.)

Implications (direct consequences for the parties):

  • The trial court's order admitting the alleged family settlement into evidence and rejecting admissibility objections is set aside.
  • Because the instrument was held to create rights in immovable property and to be compulsorily registrable, it could not lawfully have been admitted in evidence in its unstamped and unregistered form nor proved by secondary evidence without the original and requisite legal permissions.
  • The immediate practical effect is that the alleged family settlement, in the form in which it was tendered, cannot be relied upon as evidence in the partition suit unless brought into evidence in compliance with statutory requirements (i.e., proper stamping, registration where applicable, and appropriate proof of the original). The opinion does not purport to set any novel legal principle beyond applying established authority.

    Harshvardhan Singh v. Ranveer Singhn And Others

    1. Put cauli flower in a wooden box and affix a slip of ‘ROSES’ over it. Colour of cauli flower shall not turn into ‘pink’ ‘Cauli flower’ shall remain ‘cauli flower’. No matter you have kept it in a box of roses. Similarly if a document creates right in the property then unless it is registered, it cannot be taken into evidence. No matter it has been reduced into writing in the name and style of ‘family settlement’.

    2. This interesting situation has arisen in this revision petition, which has been filed against the order dated 26-7-1996 passed by the Additional District Judge No. 4 Jaipur City whereby the alleged family settlement was taken on record and objections raised by the petitioner regarding admisibility of the documents were rejected.

    3. In a suit for partition filed by the plaintiff-petitioner, a document allegedly stated to be a family settlement, copy of which was available in the file of Jagir Commissioner, was summoned by the trial Court. At the time of cross-examination of Dr. Hari Singh, defendant-non-petitioner No. 14, it was contended by the counsel for the other defendant-non-petitioners that Dr. Hari Singh produced the said copy of the family settlement before the Jagir Commissioner and as such he could exhibit the said document. Dr. Hari Singh, the defendant non-petitioner No. 14 and the plaintiff-petitioner objected to it and filed two separate applications stating therein that alleged family settlement being unstamped and unregistered could not have been admitted in evidence. It was also stated that alleged document was a copy of the original and unless application for seeking permission for adducing secondary evidence is filed it could not have keen permitted to be exhibited.

    4. The trial court dismissed both the applications by the impugned order which has been assailed in this revision.

    5. I have given my anxious and thoughtful consideration to the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the impugned order as well as copy of the alleged family settlement.

    6. Before adverting to the legal aspect of the case, it is necessary to examine the nature of the document stated to be a ‘family settlement’. A look at the document clearly demonstrates that it creates right in the property. In column number one it has been stated that the first party Rawat Surendra Singh shall retain possession of certain properties of Schedule A, as absolute and exclusive owner whereas second party Thakur Hari Singh and third party Mangi Mohan Kanwarji shall have no claim on these properties. Similarly transfer of interest in the property has been made in column No. two. As per column No. 5 Mahal of Thikana Nidhar will continue to be in the possession of the third party till her life and thereafter reverted back to Thikana and the first party relinquished all title over them.

    7. Mr. Vidhya Bhushan Sharma learned counsel for the non-petitioner No. 1, 12 and 17 vehemently contended raising preliminary objections that the plaintiff obtained benefit of the said document before the Jagir Commissioner where it was got exhibited and Dr. Hari Singh did not make any objection regarding its inadmissibility. When the document was exhibited in the court of Jagir Commissioner, no such objection is tenable now. It has also been contended that no stamp is needed for the execution of family settlement and it is not compulsorily registrable. There is no jurisdictional error in the impugned order and it cannot be interfered with in revision.

    8. Mr. D.D Patodia learned counsel for the petitioner canvassed that revision is maintainable. The alleged family settlement being unstamped and unregistered, could not have been admitted in evidence. The secondary evidence could not have been produced unless prior permission of the court is sought. The impugned order suffers from grave jurisdictional error as such deserves to be set aside.

    9. The Supreme Court had occasion to draw a distinction between a document containing the terms and recitals of a family arrangement made under the document and a mere memorandum prepared after the family arrangement had already been made either for the purpose of the record or for information of the court for making necessary mutation. In Kale v. Deputy Director of Consolidation, AIR 1976 SC 807) it has been observed that “the family arrangement may be even oral in which case no registration is necessary the registration would be necessary only if the terms of the family arrangement are reducing into writing. Here also, a distinction should be made between a document containing the terms and recitals of a family arrangement made under the document and a mere memorandum prepared after the family arrangement had already been made either for the purpose of the record on for information of the court for making necessary mutation. In such a case the memorandum itself does not create or extinguish any rights of immovable property and is, therefore, not compulsorily registrable.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    10. The alleged family settlement, in the case before me is not a memorandum, prepared after the family arrangement had already been made but, as already stated above, it creates rights in immovable property.

    11. Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 enumerated the documents requiring registration. Section 49 of the Indian Registration Act provides that no document required by Section 17 or by any provision of the Transfer of Property Act 1882 to be registered shall:

    (a) affect any immovable property comprised therein,

    (b) ……………………….

    (c) be received as evidence of any transaction affecting such property or conferring such power, unless it has been registered.

    12. In view of the law laid down by the Apex Court in Kale's case (supra) I have no option but to observe that alleged family settlement is compulsorily registrable document and it ought to have been executed on proper stamps.

    13. Dealing with another argument of Mr. V.B Sharma, the learned counsel that copy of the document was already exhibited in the court of Jagir Commissioner and no body objected its inadmissibility, it can be said that principles of estoppel are not applicable in such a situation. As is rightly held in Champa Lal v. Panna Lal 1951 Raj LW 258 by this court that the contents of a document which is required to be executed on stamp, if not stamped or is insufficiently stamped cannot be proved by secondary evidence. Section 36 of the Stamp Act is applicable only when an unstamped or insufficiently stamped instrument has to be admitted in evidence but where the instrument itself is not produced, the section has no application to the secondary evidence.

    14. In the instant case also original document is not before the trial court and without property appreciating the legal position, the trial court permitted the secondary evidence to be exhibited. This court in Nihal Singh v. Singh Ram, 1989, (1) Rai LR page 384 set aside in revision, the trial court's order holding a document as admissible in evidence for collateral purpose. It was held that an unstamped and unregistered document required under law to be stamped and registered cannot be admitted in evidence even for collateral purposes.

    15. It is thus clear that trial court has acted illegally in exercise of its jurisdiction in allowing the alleged family settlement to be taken on record and in rejecting the application of the plaintiff petitioner and defendant No. 14. If the impugned order is not set aside, it would occasion failure of justice.

    16. In the result the revision petition is allowed and the order dated 26-7-1996 of the trial court is set aside. No costs.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harshvardhan Singh v. Ranveer Singhn And Others
    (Nov 20, 1996)