Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1,
  • O. XXVI Rule 1, C.P.C
  • Rule 16(1)(a), C.P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1,
  • O. XXVI Rule 1, C.P.C
  • Rule 16(1)(a), C.P.C,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Bakhtawar Khan — Revisions Nos. 7/86 & 27/86)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two revisions were filed by the defendant, Bakhtawar Khan, against two orders of the learned Addl. Munsif Magistrate No. 1, Jodhpur dated 19-10-1985 and 14-12-1985 in the same ejectment suit. The plaintiff's evidence had closed on 24-01-1985 and the suit was pending for the defendant's evidence on 19-10-1985. The defendant had not filed a list of witnesses and attempted to examine a material witness, Shri Narsinghdass Moondra, who was absent from court due to an alleged fractured thigh. The defendant applied under Order XXVI, Rule 1, C.P.C. for the issuance of a commission to examine Shri Narsinghdass; that application was supported by an affidavit from the defendant's counsel and opposed by the plaintiff. The trial court dismissed the application for commission on 19-10-1985 (while granting the defendant an opportunity to produce the witness personally on a later date). The matter was adjourned to 14-12-1985. On that date the defendant examined himself but Shri Narsinghdass remained absent; the defendant sought permission to examine Shri Ajeet Johar (an attesting witness to a sale deed) in place of Narsinghdass, but the trial court refused that prayer because Shri Ajeet Johar was not present and no cause was shown for his absence. The defendant challenged the 19-10-1985 order by Revision No. 7/86 (refusal to issue commission) and the 14-12-1985 order by Revision No. 27/86 (closing defendant's evidence and refusing to examine Shri Ajeet Johar).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in refusing to issue a commission under Order XXVI, Rule 1, C.P.C. to examine Shri Narsinghdass, who was alleged to be unable to attend court due to infirmity (fractured thigh), particularly when no list of witnesses had been filed by the defendant.
  2. Whether it was proper for the trial court to close the defendant's evidence and refuse to examine Shri Ajeet Johar (an attesting witness) when that witness was not present in court at the time.
  3. Whether a revision under Section 115, C.P.C. is maintainable against the trial court's refusal to issue a commission or refusal to permit additional evidence in the circumstances of this case (i.e., whether the authority relied upon by the plaintiff — Ramchand v. Laxmikumar — applies).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Defendant's) Arguments

  • The defendant's defence in the ejectment suit was that he purchased the equity of redemption from Shri Narsinghdass, making him the owner and not a tenant; therefore Narsinghdass was a material witness.
  • Shri Narsinghdass could not be produced because he was confined to bed with a fractured thigh; hence a commission under Order XXVI, Rule 1, C.P.C. was sought to record his evidence.
  • As an alternative, if a commission could not be issued, the defendant sought to examine Shri Ajeet Johar (the attesting witness to the sale deed) but could not produce him earlier without the trial court's permission; on 14-12-1985 the case was called late (about 4:30 p.m.) and Shri Ajeet Johar, being an advocate, was not available then.
  • The defendant requested an opportunity to produce at least one of these witnesses (either Narsinghdass by commission or Ajeet Johar in court) and stated that Narsinghdass remained confined to bed at the time of revision.

Non-petitioner's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The defendant had failed to file a list of witnesses under Order XVI, Rule 1, C.P.C., and therefore was not entitled to have witnesses summoned by the Court.
  • The defendant had been given opportunities to produce witnesses personally but failed to avail himself of those opportunities; therefore no further indulgence was warranted.
  • Since Shri Narsinghdass could not be summoned, a prayer to examine him on commission should also be disallowed.
  • The plaintiff further argued that refusal to examine a witness by the court is not a matter in respect of which a revision can be entertained and placed reliance on the decision in Ramchand v. Laxmikumar, AIR 1980 Raj 128.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramchand v. Laxmikumar, AIR 1980 Raj 128 Reliance by plaintiff that a revision under S.115 C.P.C. is not maintainable where a party seeks to produce a witness at the last hour after evidence has been closed; illustrative of refusal to admit late evidence when no failure of justice is shown. The court distinguished Ramchand: in that case the application to produce a witness was made orally after defendant's evidence had closed and there was no proof of failure of justice or irreparable injury. In the present case the commission was sought at the time defendant's evidence was being opened and there was a valid reason (infirmity) for the commission; refusal would have caused irreparable injury by preventing proof of the sale of the mortgaged property. Consequently, the precedent was held inapplicable to the facts of this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following legal analysis, based strictly on the material and arguments before it:

  1. On the factual question of Shri Narsinghdass's incapacity: the court observed that the fact of his age (73 years) and the fracture of his thigh were not disputed before the trial court. The plaintiff's affidavit merely surmised that the witness could be brought by taxi; the revising court found that such surmise was insufficient to rebut the defendant's counsel's affidavit stating the witness's inability to attend. The absence of a medical certificate, when the fact of fracture was not disputed, was not a proper ground to discard the affidavit of the defendant's counsel.
  2. On the legal effect of failure to file a list of witnesses: the court drew a distinction between (a) summoning a witness by court process and (b) examining a witness on commission. It observed that non-filing of the list under Order XVI, Rule 1, C.P.C. may deprive a party of the opportunity to have witnesses summoned, but it does not prevent the court from examining a witness who is present in court. The court referred to Rule 16(1)(a), C.P.C. (as cited in the opinion) to show that a party may, subject to sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, bring witnesses without applying for summons.
  3. On the purpose and scope of issuing a commission: the court considered Order XXVI, Rule 1, C.P.C., which empowers the court to issue a commission to examine any person resident within its local jurisdiction who is exempted from attending or is by sickness or infirmity unable to attend. The court reasoned that inability to attend due to infirmity is a matter concerning the witness's personal capacity and is distinct from a party's failure to file a list; hence the absence of a list cannot be a bar to issuing a commission to accommodate an incapacitated witness.
  4. Applying these principles, the court concluded that the learned Munsif's refusal to issue a commission for examining Shri Narsinghdass (chiefly on the ground that the plaintiff's affidavit suggested the witness could be transported and on the absence of a medical certificate) was legally unsustainable and amounted to illegality or material irregularity in the exercise of jurisdiction.
  5. As to the second order (14-12-1985) refusing to permit examination of Shri Ajeet Johar because he was not present: the court held that no exception could be taken to that order as such (the trial court was not bound to adjourn or summon the absent witness). However, the court further held that since the earlier order refusing commission to examine Shri Narsinghdass was unsustainable, directing a commission to be issued for Narsinghdass would remove the necessity for examining Shri Ajeet Johar.
  6. On maintainability of the revision under Section 115, C.P.C.: the court rejected the plaintiff's contention that revisions of this nature were barred by the authority relied upon. It explained that Ramchand was distinguishable because there the defendant sought to produce evidence late without adequate reason after evidence had closed; here the commission application was made when defendant's evidence was being opened and refusal would lead to irreparable injury (inability to establish the sale of the mortgaged property).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court issued the following dispositive rulings:

  • Revision No. 7/86 is allowed: the order of the learned Munsif dated 19-10-1985 refusing to issue a commission for examining Shri Narsinghdass is set aside and it is directed that a commission shall be issued for examining Shri Narsinghdass.
  • Revision No. 27/86 is partly allowed: the order of 14-12-1985 closing the defendant's evidence is set aside (i.e., the defendant's evidence is not to be regarded as finally closed in the light of the commission direction).

Immediate procedural consequences directed by the court:

  • The parties were directed to appear before the trial court on 18-02-1986.
  • On that date the trial court was to appoint a Commissioner and thereafter proceed in accordance with law to record the evidence as directed.

Broader implications:

The opinion confines itself to the direct effect on the parties — ordering issuance of a commission and reopening the defendant's evidence — and expressly distinguishes the cited precedent (Ramchand). The court did not purport to set out any new broad rule of law beyond its application and interpretation of Order XVI, Rule 1; Rule 16(1)(a) C.P.C.; and Order XXVI, Rule 1, C.P.C. Accordingly, the primary consequence is the restoration of the defendant's opportunity to prove his case by directing the commission; no broader binding precedent was declared beyond the reasoning applied to these facts.

Order: The revisions were allowed in the manner stated above and the trial court was directed to proceed as indicated. (Order dated to require appearance on 18-02-1986 and appointment of Commissioner.)

    Bakhtawar Khan v. Noor Mohamad .

    1. These are two revisions filed by the defendant Bakhtawar Khan against the two orders of the learned Addl. Munsif Magistrate No. 1, Jodhpur, dated 19-10-1985 and 14-12-1985 respectively in the same suit and as the matters, involved in these two revisions are connected, they are being disposed of by a common order.

    2. The plaintiff's suit for ejectment against the present petitioner was pending for the defendant's evidence on 19-10-1985. The plaintiff's evidence had already been over on 24-1-1985. It appears that the defendant had not filed any list of witnesses and, therefore, he was not entitled to get any witness summoned by the Court. One of the witnesses whom the defendant wanted to examine was Shri Narsinghdass Moondra but he was not present in Court on 19-10-1985 and an application under O. XXVI Rule 1, C.P.C was filed supported by the affidavit of the learned counsel for the defendant that the witness Shri Narsinghdass had suffered a fracture in his thigh and was unable to come to the Court and, therefore, a Commission may be issued to examine him. This application was opposed by the plaintiff and the plaintiff had filed an affidavit to the effect that the witness had suffered a fracture about 1½ months back. He further averred that merely because the witness was about 73 years old and had suffered a fracture in his thigh he cannot be deemed to be unable to attend the Court and that he could be brought in a taxi or some other conveyance. The Court relying on this averment of the plaintiff and also on the fact that the medical certificate had not been produced, dismissed the application for examining the said witness on Commission. It, however, granted an opportunity to the defendant to produce his evidence by keeping the witness ready in Court on 16-11-1985. On 16-11-1985, the learned Munsif was on leave and, therefore, the case was adjourned to 14-12-1985.

    3. On 14-12-1985, the defendant examined himself but his witness was not present and, he urged that the as Shri Narsinghdass could not be produced, he may be allowed to examine one Shri Ajeet Johar, Advocate in his place in order to prove his attestation on the sale deed executed by Narsinghdass in favour of the defendant. This prayer was also disallowed by the Court by its order dated 14-12-1985 on the ground that Shri Ajeet Johar was not present in the Court and no cause was shown why he was not present. Aggrieved of these orders the defendant has come up in revisions.

    4. The revision No. 7/86 has been filed against the order dated 19-10-1985, by which his application for issuance of Commission for examining Shri Narsinghdass was refused and revision No. 27/86 has been filed against the order dated 14-12-1985 closing his evidence and refusing to examine Shri Ajeet Johar.

    5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    6. It is contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the defence of the present petitioner in the suit for ejectment was that he had himself purchased the equity of redemption from Narsinghdass with whom the suit house had been mortgaged by the plaintiff and thus he himself had become the owner of the house and did not continue to be a tenant of the plaintiff. It was on this account that Narsinghdass was sought to be produced in evidence but he could not be produced oil account of his fractured thigh and in the alternative when the Court had refused to examine him on Commission, the defendant wanted to produce Shri Ajeet Johar the attesting witness of the sale deed but as the principal witness was Shri Narsinghdass and the defendant was trying to produce him or to get him examine on Commission, Ajeet Johar could not be produced on earlier occasions and without the permission of the Court he could not have produced him on 14-12-1985. It is further urged that the case was called at about 4.30 p.m on 14-12-1985, by which time Shri Ajeet Johar, who is an advocate was not available and, therefore, also he could not be produced. In these circumstances it is urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the orders of the Court below may be set aside and he may be granted an opportunity to produce at least one of these two witnesses. He has further urged that Shri Narsinghdass is still confined to bed and is unable to come to the Court but he would be satisfied if Shri Ajeet Johar is allowed to be produced as a witness in the Court.

    7. The learned counsel for the non-petitioner plaintiff, on the other hand vehemently opposed the prayer and urged that as the defendant had failed to file the list of witnesses under O. XVI, R. 1, C.P.C he was not entitled to summon any witnesses and he was given opportunities to produce the witnesses by himself, as he failed to avail of these opportunities and, therefore, he is not entitled to any further indulgence. It was also contended that since the witness Narsinghdass could not have been summoned, a prayer for examining him on Commission also could not have been allowed. It was also contended further that in matters of refusal to examine a witness by the Court no revision can be entertained and reliance was placed upon an authority of a learned single Judge reported in Ramchand v. Laxmikumar, AIR 1980 Raj 128.

    8. I have given my careful consideration to the rival contentions. It may be stated at the very out set that the fact that the witness Narsinghdass is 73 years old and had suffered a fracture in his thigh had not been disputed before the Court below. What was contended by the plaintiff in his affidavit was that merely because the witness is 73 years old and has a fracture of his thigh it cannot be assumed that he is unable to come to the Court because he can be brought in taxi or some other conveyance. I am unable to accept this logic. When a learned counsel representing the defendants had on the basis of his personal knowledge filed an affidavit that the witness was unable to move about and come to the Court, there was no justification for the learned munsif to hold on the surmises made by the plaintiff in his affidavit that the witness could not be said to be immobile. Further he also cannot be said to be justified in rejecting the affidavit of the learned Advocate merely on the ground that no medical certificate had been produced. As already stated above when the fact of the fracture itself was not in dispute the absence of the medical certificate was no ground to discard the affidavit of Shri Bhansali, learned counsel for the defendants. Therefore, it is absolutely clear that the learned Munsif was entirely wrong in rejecting the application for examining Shri Narsingdass on commission on the grounds stated by him.

    9. The question, however, is, as has been sought to be raised by the learned counsel for the plaintiff non-petitioner, whether in the absence of the list of witnesses the defendants could have asked for commission for examining one of his witnesses. The argument is that since no list had been filed under O. XVI, R. 1, C.P.C, the defendant was not entitled to get his witness summoned and, therefore, he could not have asked for a commission for examining that witness. In my opinion the contention is wholly misconceived. Getting the witness summoned is quite different from getting the witness examined on commission. If the list of witnesses has not been filed as required by O. XVI, R. 1, C.P.C, the party can be deprived of the opportunity for summoning the witnesses but if the witness is present in Court the Court cannot refuse to examine such a witness. Rule 16(1)(a), C.P.C, clearly provides that subject to the provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, any party to the suit may, without applying for summons under R. 1, bring any witness to give evidence or to produce documents and it is why that despite the absence of the list of witnesses and despite his refusal to issue commission for examining Shri Narsinghdass, the Court by its order dated 19-10-1985 granted an opportunity to the defendant to produce his own witnesses. That being so, when the witness can be kept present and the Court would then examine such a witness despite the absence of the list of witnesses the further question which arises is that if such a witness who appears to be a material one could have been kept present in Court, cannot be so brought before the Court on account of his physical inability, should the Court refuse to issue a commission for examining him merely because the list of witnesses had not been filed and my answer to this is clearly in the negative. The purpose of issuing a commission is quite different from the purpose of summoning a witness. Order XXVI, R. 1, C.P.C, gives power to the Court to issue a commission for the examination on interrogatories or otherwise of any person resident within the local limits of its jurisdiction who is exempted under this Code from attending the Court or who is from sickness or infirmity unable to attend it. The inability to attend the Court in such a circumstance is not on account of the absence of the list of witnesses but because of the incapacity or inability of the witness himself and it is for this reason that instead of the witness being brought to the Court, the Court manages the recording of his evidence outside the Court so that the incapacitated witness is not put to any inconvenience and the party also does not suffer for not being able to examine such a witness. In these circumstances it cannot be conceived that a commission cannot be issued for examining a witness under O. XXVI, R. 1, C.P.C, merely because the list of witnesses has not been filed by the party concerned. In these circumstances, I am clearly of the opinion that the learned Magistrate was entirely wrong in refusing to issue a commission for the examination of Shri Narsinghdass and he acted illegally or at least with the material irregularity in exercise of his jurisdiction in dismissing the application for issuing commission.

    10. This brings me to the other revision against the order dated 14-12-1985 as in pursuance of the order dated 19-10-1985, the defendant could not produce Shri Narsinghdass as according to him Narsinghdass was still confined to bed, he prayed that he may be allowed to examine another witness Shri Ajeet Johar an advocate, who was an attesting witness to the sale deed said to have been executed by Shri Narsinghdass in favour of the defendant and this prayer was also refused because Shri Ajeet Johar was not present in Court. As the order stands no exception can be taken to it because Ajeet Johar was not present in Court and, therefore, the Court was not bound to either adjourn the case or to summon this witness but what the learned counsel for the defendant urges is that all that he wanted was to prove the sale deed and for that he either wanted that his witness Narsinghdass may be examined on commission and if that was not possible Shri Ajeet Johar may be examined in his place but since Ajeet Johar was not present in Court he prayed for an adjournment and that was refused. Now he wants that he may be allowed one opportunity either to produce Shri Ajeet Johar or to examine Shri Narsinghdass on commission. I have already stated above that the order refusing to issue a commission for examining Shri Narsinghdass cannot be sustained and if a commission is directed to be issued for examining Shri Narsinghdass, the defendant need not examine Ajeet Johar, Advocate.

    11. I cannot agree with the learned counsel for the non-petitioner that in matters like this, the revision does not lie under S. 115 C.P.C and in my opinion that authority relied upon by him does not apply to the facts and circumstances of this case. In Ramchand's case (AIR 1980 Raj 128) (supra) the position was that after the defendant's evidence had already been closed the defendant wanted to produce one more witness and he applied orally in that respect and the prayer was rejected. It was against that order that the revision was filed before the Court and the Court was of the opinion that such a revision cannot be maintained as the defendant did not produce the evidence at the appropriate time when full opportunity was given and wanted to examine the witness at the last hour. It was further observed that there was absolutely absence of proof of failure of justice or irreparable injury in such a case. This is not the position in the present case. The defendant's evidence was opened at the time the commission was applied for. There was valid reason for the defendant for asking for a commission and the refusal of such a prayer would certainly have amounted to irreparable injury to the defendant because he could have failed to establish the sale of the mortgaged property by Narsinghdass in his favour.

    12. For the reasons stated above the revision No. 7/86 is allowed and the order of the learned Munsif is set aside and it is directed that a commission shall be issued for examining Narsinghdass. The revision No. 27/86 is also partly allowed and the order closing the defendant's evidence is set aside.

    13. The parties shall appear before the trial Court on 18-2-1986. On the said date the Court shall appoint a Commissioner and thereafter it will proceed in accordance with law.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bakhtawar Khan v. Noor Mohamad .
    (Jan 28, 1986)