Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • clause (1) of article 320 of the Constitution. Rule 16
  • Art. 320 of the Constitution or R. 19 of the Rules,
  • provisions article 235 of the Constitution
  • provisions of rules 16 to 19 of the Rules,
  • provision of clause (3) of article 320
  • provision of rule 20 of the Rules,
  • rule 2(c) of the Rules, Commission
  • provisions of rule 20.13.
  • rule 20 of the Rules
  • rule 22 of the Rules,
  • rule 19 of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • clause (1) of article 320 of the Constitution. Rule 16
  • Art. 320 of the Constitution or R. 19 of the Rules,
  • provisions article 235 of the Constitution
  • provisions of rules 16 to 19 of the Rules,
  • provision of clause (3) of article 320
  • provision of rule 20 of the Rules,
  • rule 2(c) of the Rules, Commission
  • provisions of rule 20.13.
  • rule 20 of the Rules
  • rule 22 of the Rules,
  • rule 19 of the Rules
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary — Shinghal, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners (K.K. Bhatia and S.C. Sachdev) filed writ petitions under article 226 of the Constitution challenging selections made by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission ("the Commission") for appointment as Assistant Engineers in the Rajasthan Ground Water Board.

Brief chronology and relevant facts (as recorded in the opinion):

  • Petitioners had been appointed ad hoc and temporary as Assistant Engineers under a Scheme by State Government order dated 16 January 1967 and had taken over on 13 March 1967.
  • The Commission issued advertisement No. 6/70-71 dated 12 June 1970 inviting applications for 16 posts under the Rajasthan Ground Water Board Service Rules, 1969 ("the Rules").
  • The petitioners applied, appeared for interview before the Commission, but were not selected; intimation of rejection was sent by the Commission's Secretariat on 26 February 1971.
  • The Commission selected respondents Nos. 3 to 19 for appointment; the petitioners sought to restrain the State from giving effect to the Commission's recommendation and from appointing those selected candidates.
  • The Commission and State admitted that only the Chairman and Mr. R.D. Mathur (one member) had interviewed the candidates, and that the other members did not see the interview results or the list forwarded to the State Government.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the interviews conducted by only the Chairman and one member (and not by the whole Commission) contravened the Rules and/or the constitutional notion that the Commission must function as a body, thereby invalidating the interviews and the Commission's recommendation.
  2. Whether the association and changing of various experts with the interviewing members vitiated the interviews and rendered the process invalid.
  3. Whether the failure of the entire Commission to prepare and approve the list required by rule 20 of the Rules (and forwarding that list to the Government) vitiated the list forwarded by the Commission's Secretariat and thereby invalidated the Government's power to make appointments based on that list.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants / Petitioners (Mr. Joshi)

  • Interviews were invalid because the entire Commission did not participate; reliance on the definition in rule 2(c) and regulation 3 (Rajasthan Public Service Commission (Conditions of Service) Regulations, 1951) to contend that "Commission" means the full Commission and must function as a body (invoking the proviso to regulation 3).
  • Reference to Anandilal Verma v. State of Rajasthan to support the proposition that the Commission must act as a full body (analogy drawn to other constitutional provisions where "Commission" meant full bench).
  • The interviews were vitiated because certain experts were associated and changed on different dates.
  • The most important ground: contravention of rule 20 — the entire Commission did not prepare the list of suitable candidates and the Secretariat forwarded the list without the Commission's consideration, invalidating the recommendation and making any appointment based on it invalid (citing Chandra Mohan v. State of U.P., Prem Nath v. State of Rajasthan, A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India, Chandramouleshwar Prasad v. The Patna High Court).

Respondents — Commission and State (Mr. Daphtary)

  • It was permissible for the Chairman and one member to conduct the interviews. Article 320 requires the Commission to conduct examinations (clause (1)) and to be consulted (clause (3)); these are distinct functions and clause (3) cannot be used to interpret clause (1).
  • The Commission may formulate its own procedure for conducting viva-voce examinations; it could entrust the examination to one or more members so long as the process was unbiased, candidates had a fair opportunity, and decisions were taken responsibly.
  • Reliance was placed on Board of Eduction v. Rice and Local Government Board v. Arlige to support the permissibility of the Commission determining its procedure.
  • As the Chairman and member conducted the interviews, they were entitled to prepare and arrange the list of suitable candidates and the Secretariat's transmission of that list to the Government was a ministerial act amounting to substantial compliance with rule 20.
  • Distinguished the case of Devajit/Devjit Chaliha v. Narendra Nath Baruah on the ground that nomination there was made by the Commission (and thus that case was not helpful to petitioners here).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anandilal Verma v. State of Rajasthan Invoked by petitioners to support the proposition that "Commission" means the full Commission and must act as a body (analogy to cases interpreting constitutional provision requiring full bench). The Court held this decision to be not relevant to the facts: the Court rejected the contention that the Commission must act as a full body for conducting examinations under Art. 320(1).
Board of Eduction v. Rice Relied on by respondents to support the argument that a commission/board may formulate its own procedure for conducting examinations or proceedings. The Court accepted the respondents' broader contention that the Commission could entrust examinations to some members and adopt procedures so long as fairness and absence of bias were maintained.
Local Government Board v. Arlige Relied on by respondents for the same purpose as Rice — supporting procedural autonomy. The Court treated this authority as supportive of the proposition that the Commission could decide internal procedure for conducting viva-voce examinations.
Chandra Mohan v. State of Uttar Pradesh Invoked by petitioners to support the proposition that failure to comply with the procedural requirement for formulating and forwarding the Commission's recommendation (rule 20) can invalidate appointments. The Court treated this and related authorities as supporting the petitioners' contention about the distinct and important responsibility placed on the Commission by rule 20; these authorities were relied upon in concluding that non-compliance vitiated the list forwarded to Government.
Prem Nath v. State of Rajasthan Invoked by petitioners in support of strict requirement of Commission's own formulation/approval of the recommendation list. The Court accepted the line of authorities (including this case) as supporting the necessity for the Commission itself to consider and sanction the list before forwarding it to Government.
A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India Invoked by petitioners to support challenge where procedural requirements affecting selection are not complied with. The Court treated this authority as part of the precedents that justify scrutiny of the Commission's compliance with rule 20 and supported the conclusion that the forwarded list was vitiated.
Chandramouleshwar Prasad v. The Patna High Court Invoked by petitioners in support of the proposition concerning the importance of procedural compliance in selection processes. The Court regarded this decision as part of the authorities supporting the petitioners' rule-20 argument.
Devajit (Devjit) Chaliha v. Narendra Nath Baruah Cited by respondents; noted that in that decision the nomination of the selected candidate was made by the Commission. The Court found this decision distinguishable and of no avail to the respondents because that case involved an explicit nomination by the Commission, unlike the present case where the full Commission did not approve the list.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in distinct stages that track the petitioners' three principal complaints:

  1. Distinguishing the Commission's functions under Article 320:
    • The Court emphasized that Article 320 specifies two distinct functions of a State Public Service Commission: (1) to conduct examinations for appointments to State services (clause (1)), and (2) to be consulted on specified matters (clause (3)).
    • The Court held that clause (3) (consultation) cannot be read into clause (1) to require that the Commission must always act as a full body when conducting examinations; the functions are separate.
    • Therefore, the Commission was permitted to discharge its duty of conducting the viva-voce examination by entrusting the examination to one or more of its members; it was not necessary for the entire Commission to sit together to conduct interviews under Rule 19.
    • The Court examined the proviso to regulation 3 of the Commission's Conditions of Service Regulations, 1951 and found it irrelevant: the proviso deals with temporary vacancies and does not require the full Commission to sit for examinations.
    Conclusion on this issue: the first ground (that interviews were invalid because the whole Commission did not sit) was rejected.
  2. Role of experts associated with the interviewers:
    • The Court noted petitioners did not argue that experts could not be present, nor that the Commission had no opportunity to explain the circumstances for calling experts.
    • The Court found no evidence that the experts acted as examiners with authority to select or reject candidates; rather, they advised the Chairman and member on technical answers.
    • Accordingly, the mere presence of different experts on different dates did not vitiate the interviews so long as the ultimate result rested with the Chairman and the member.
    Conclusion on this issue: the second ground was rejected.
  3. Requirement of Rule 20 and the Commission's recommendation:
    • The Court analyzed Rules 16–19 and concluded they relate to the conduct of the examination up to the stage of requiring candidates to appear for interview.
    • Rule 20, by contrast, deals with a distinct stage — formulation and transmission of the Commission's recommendation (a list of names of those the Commission considers suitable for appointment to the posts concerned).
    • The Court reasoned that a mark-sheet or list prepared as a result of the examination (whether by outside examiners or by members of the Commission entrusted with the examination) records the result of the examination but does not automatically become the recommendation of the Commission.
    • For the marksheet/list to assume the character of the recommendation of the Commission, the Commission itself must consider, sanction or approve that list. Rule 20's language ("names of only those candidates whom the Commission consider suitable") indicates the Commission must examine and prune the list, and may prepare a reserve list as provided in the proviso.
    • Because the entire Commission did not discharge this distinct responsibility under rule 20 — the result of the interviews prepared by the Chairman and member was not placed before the other members, and the Secretariat forwarded the list without the Commission's consideration — the forwarded list was not a valid recommendation of the Commission.
    • The Court reviewed Devajit Chaliha and found it distinguishable because in that case the nomination was made by the Commission; that fact made that authority inapplicable to the present situation.
    Conclusion on this issue: the failure of the full Commission to prepare and approve the list under Rule 20 vitiated the list forwarded to the Government.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that the list of candidates forwarded by the Commission's Secretariat was not a valid recommendation of the Commission under rule 20 and that the State must be restrained from giving effect to that list.

Direct consequences and implications as stated by the Court:

  • The list of successful candidates produced from the viva-voce interviews could not ipso facto assume the status of the list required to be prepared by the Commission under rule 20.
  • Accordingly, the list forwarded by the Secretariat was invalid for the purpose of selection under rule 22 and the State was restrained from acting on it.
  • The petitioners were granted the relief prayed for in that respect and were awarded one set of costs against the respondents.

The opinion does not state that any new legal principle or precedent was laid down; the Court applied and distinguished existing authorities and determined the case on the basis of the Rules and Article 320 as expounded in the opinion.

    K.K Bhatia v. Rajasthan Public Service Commission

    Shinghal, J.:— As the learned counsel for the petitioners have not pressed some of the facts or grounds on which petitioners K.K Bhatia and S.C Sachdev have filed these writ petitions under article 226 of the Constitution, it will be sufficient to refer to those facts and grounds which have figured in the controversy before me.

    2. The petitioners were appointed as Assistant Engineers under a Survey and Investigation Scheme of the Rajasthan Ground Water Board, by an order of the State Government dated January 16, 1967. The appointments were ad hoc and temporary and the petitioners took over as Assistant Engineers on March 13, 1967. The Rajasthan Public Service Commission, respondent No. 1, hereinafter referred to as “the Commission”, issued advertisement No. 6/70-71 dated June 12, 1970 inviting applications for 16 posts of Assistant Engineers in the Rajasthan Ground water Board in accordance with the Rajasthan Ground Water Board Service Rules, 1969, hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”. The petitioners applied for those posts and appeared for interview before the Commission. They were however not selected and intimation Ex. 1 dated February 26, 1971 was sent to them to this effect by the Secretariat of the Commission. The Commission selected respondents Nos. 3 to 19 for appointment as Assistant Engineers. The petitioners have challenged those selections and their own rejection by the Commission, inter alia, on the grounds that (i) all the members of the Commission did not participate at the interviews which were held for selecting the candidates, (ii) “even the experts assisting the Commission were different on these different dates.” and (iii). the re-commendation of members of the Commission who interviewed the candidates was not circulated to the other members of the Commission before forwarding it to the State Government. The petitioners have prayed, inter alia, for a direction to the State government not to give effect to the recommendation of the Commission and not to appoint respondents Nos. 3 to 19 as Assistant Engineers.

    3. The Commission and the State of Rajasthan have traversed the claim of the petitioners altogether. The remaining respondents have not filed any reply. I am in agreement with the learned counsel for the parties that no useful purpose will be served by mentioning the replies of the two contesting respondents as the points of controversy can easily be decided on the basis of the admitted facts. Before examining those points it may be stated, however, that the Commission and the State of Rajasthan have not disputed or controverted the fact that the Chairman and Mr. R.D Mathur, a member of the Commission, interviewed all the candidates and that the other members did not interview any candidate. So also, Mr. Daphtary has frankly admitted that the result of the interviews which were held by the Chairman and one member of the Commission was not placed before the other members of the Commission and that they did not see that result or the list which was forwarded to the State Government by the Secretariat of the Commission.

    4. It has been argued by Mr. Joshi, learned counsel for the petitioners, that in accordance with the definition contained in rule 2(c) of the Rules, “Commission” means the Rajasthan Public Service Commission, and that a cross-reference to regulation 3 of the Rajasthan Public Service Commission (Conditions of service) Regulations, 1951, shows that the Commission consists of the Chairman and such number of members not less than two and not exceeding four as the Government may appoint. The learned counsel has therefore argued that as only the Chairman and R.D Mathur interviewed the candidates, and not the entire Commission, the interviews were held in contravention of the provision of R. 19 of the rules and A. 320 of the constitution which, according to the learned counsel, required the Commission to function as a body and not in compartments. The learned counsel has, in this connection, made a reference to the proviso to regulation 3 of the aforesaid Regulations to support his argument. He has argued further that in the absence of any statutory rule authorising the Chairman and one member of the Commission to carry on the interviews envisaged by rule 19. It was not permissible for them to do so, and that the failure to associate the remaining members vitiated the interviews and invalidated the Commission's recommendation. The learned counsel has made a reference to Anandilal Verma v. State of Rajasthan (1) to support the argument that, as in the case of State of Rajasthan (1) to support the argument the provision in Art. 236 of the Constitution in regard to the control of the High Court over district courts and courts subordinate thereto, ‘Commission’ means the full Commission.

    5. Mr. Daphtary, learned counsel for the Commission and the State of Rajasthan, has argued on the other hand that it was permissible for the Chairman and one member of the Commission to interview the candidates. He has pointed out that according to article 320 of the Constitution it is the duty of the Commission, inter alia, to conduct examinations for appointments to the services of the State as required by clause (1), and to be consulted on the matters stated in clause (3). He has therefore argued that as in this case the Commission was required by rule 19 of the Rules to discharge the function of conducting a viva voce examination by interviewing the candidates, it was permissible for it to formulate its own procedure for that purpose, and that no objection could be taken as long as the Commission dealt with the matter without bias, gave every candidate a fair opportunity, and arrived at its decision with a sense of responsibility. The learned counsel has placed reliance on Board of Eduction v. Rice (2) and Local Government Board v. Arlige (3), for the purpose of supporting his argument. It has been contended by Mr. Daphtary that the argument based on the requirement of clause (3) of article 320 of the Constitution, which provides for consultation with the Commission, is quite misconceived and that the petitioners cannot advance their case by placing reliance on the decision in Anandilal Verma v. State of Rajasthan (1) or any other case in which the provisions article 235 of the Constitution have been considered.

    6. A reference to article 320 of the Constitution shows that this argument of Mr. Daphtary is quite Correct. That article specifies two important functions of a State Public Service Commission as follows—

    (2) to conduct examinations for appointments to the services of the State, and

    (2) to be consulted on the matters specified in clause (3).

    Each of these is a distinct function, so that the provision of clause (3) of article 320 making it obligatory that the Commission shall be consulted on the matters enumerated in it cannot be wrested for interpreting clause (1) thereof. It follows therefore that in discharging its duty of conducting an examination for the selection of candidates for appointment as Assistant Engineers in his Rajasthan Ground water Board Service, the Commission was required to discharge a duty which was quite different from what it was required to do while answering a reference on consultation under clause (3). It appears to me therefore that it was permissible for the Commission to discharge the duty of conducting the examination by entrusting it to one or more of its members and that it was not necessary for it to act in a body. In fact my attention has not been invited to any general or special requirement of any law under which it could be said that it was necessary for the entire Commission to constitute itself into a board of examiners for the purpose of selecting for appointment to a service of which the rules made a provision that the candidates shall appear before the Commission for interview. It follows therefore that it was permissible for the Commission to nominate the examiners from amongst themselves, and to conduct the examination in that manner. In such a case it would be futile to con-tend that the examination would be illegal merely because all the members of the Commission did not choose to examine the candidates. It would not therefore matter if the test of examining the candidates was assigned to one or more members of the Commission, and the examination would not be illegal if the other members were not directly associated with it.

    7. A reference to rules 16 to 19 of the Rules shows that they really pertain to the duty of the Commissioner to conduct an examination for selection of candidates for appointment to the Rajasthan Ground water service within the meaning of clause (1) of article 320 of the Constitution. Rule 16 provides for the inviting of applications by the Commission for selecting candidates to fill the vacant posts, rule 17 deals with the form to be approved by the Commission for those applications, R. 18 requires the payment of the fee fixed for the examination and R. 19 deals with the scrutiny of the applications so that as many candidates as may seem desirable to the Commission may appear for interview. The scheme and the purpose of these rules therefore is to provide for the conduct of a viva voce examination by the Commission. There is however no provision, either in Art. 320 of the Constitution or R. 19 of the Rules, requiring that the examination must be conducted by all the members of the Commission sitting together at the inter view. It has therefore been left to the Commission to decide whether all its members would examine the candidates sitting together or whether that responsibility would be discharged by some of the members nominated by it for the purpose.

    8. Mr. Daphtary has placed before me and the learned counsel for the petitioners a decision of all the members of the Commission dated January 15, 1967 that the interviews of the candidates for appointment as Assistant Engineers in the Rajasthan Ground Water Board Service shall be held by the Chairman of the Commission and its member Mr. B.D Mathur. The interviews were held accordingly from February 1, 1971 onwards under that sanction of the Board, and the conduct of the viva voce examination by the Chairman and Mr. B.D Mathur appears to me to be quite unexceptionable. I have examined the proviso to regulation 3 of the Rajasthan Public Service Commission (Conditions of Service) Regulations, 1951, on which reliance has been placed by Mr. Joshi, but it does not seem to have any bearing on the point in controversy because it merely provides that the Commission shall not be precluded from functioning as such merely because of a temporary vacancy in the office of the Chairman or a member.

    9. In this view of the matter, the decision in Anandilal Verma's case (1) is not relevant, and I have no hesitation in deciding the first point of controversy against the petitioners.

    10. It has next been argued by Mr. Joshi that the interviews which were held by the Chairman and one member of the Commission were vitiated because they associated certain experts with them, and went on changing these experts from time to time. This argument is however not tenable for two reasons. Firstly, the petitioners have not taken the plea that it was not permissible for the Chairman and the member to secure the presence of the experts at the time of the interviews, so that the Commission had no opportunity of explaining the facts and circumstances under which it was considered necessary to secure the presence of the experts and, secondly, it has not been contended or established that the experts sat as examiners along with the Chairman and the member and had the authority of selecting and rejecting candidates. The interviews were held for the purpose of examining candidates for recruitment to a technical service, and there is nothing unusual or wrong if some experts were required to be present for the purpose of advising the Chairman and the member whether a candidate gave correct answers to the questions which were put to him, for it may well be that a candidate may give a somewhat technical answer to an otherwise simple question. So long as the result of the examination rested with the Chairman and the member of the Commission, the mere presence of different experts on different dates would not matter for the simple reason that they were not the examiners.

    11. This leaves for consideration the third argument of Mr. Joshi that a serious illegality was committed inasmuch as, contrary to the provision of rule 20 of the Rules, the entire Commission did not prepare the list of the candidates who were considered suitable for appointment as Assistant Engineers and did not forward that list to the Government. The learned counsel has supported his argument by reference to the decisions in Chandra Mohan v. State of Uttar Pradesh (4), Prem Nath v. State of Rajasthan (5), A.K Kraipak v. Union of India (6), and Chandramouleshwar Prasad v. The Patna High Court (7). He has also pointed out that it was not in dispute in Devajit Chaliha v. Narendra Nath Baruah (8) that the nomination of the selected candidate was made by the Commission so that decision can be of no avail to the petitioners.

    12. It may be stated that this ground for challenging the validity of the list containing the names of the suitable candidates was taken by the petitioners by an amendment to which Mr. Diphtary had no objection. In fact, as has been stated, he frankly admitted that the result of the interviews held by the Chairman and one member of the Commission was not placed before the other members of the Commission and they did not see that result or that list before it was forwarded to the Government. Mr. Dephtary has however argued that as it was permissible for the Chairman and one member of the Commission to interview the candidates in their capacity as examiners, it was inevitable that they should have prepared a list of the suitable candidates and arranged their names in order of merit. On these premises Mr. Daphtary has argued that it was merely a ministerial act for the Secretariat of the Commission to forward the list to the Government so that there was substantial compliance with the provisions of rule 20.

    13. I have already made a reference to the provisions of rules 16 to 19 of the Rules, and they leave me in no doubt that while they provide the procedure for direct recruitment to the Rajasthan Ground Water Board Service up to the stage of requiring the candidates to appear for interview. R. 20 deals with a different stage and a different matter altogether, namely, the formulation and transmission of the recommendation of the Commission. It cannot be doubted that this is a very important matter, and its importance will emerge more clearly with reference to a service or post to which recruitment is made on the basis of a viva voce examination for which the Commission does not appoint any of its members but entrusts the examination to outsiders in such a case, those examiners will no doubt interview the candidates and prepare the mark-sheet or list as a result of the examination, but that sheet or list will not automatically become the recommendation of the Commission. The reason is that the marks sheet or list records the result of the examination conducted by the examiners and no more. It does not therefore automatically turn itself into the recommendation of the Commission even though the examination was held in pursuance of the over all duty of the Commission to conduct the examination under its direction and control. To assume the character of the recommendation of the Commission, it is necessary that the Commission should consider the marks sheet or list prepared by the examiners, and give it its sanction or approval. This view finds support from the provision of R. 20 of the Rules that the list should contain the names of only those candidates whom the Commission consider suitable for appointment to the “posts concerned”, so that it is clearly necessary for the Commission to examine and prune the list by deleting the surplus names. Then the proviso to R. 20 provides that the Commission may keep the names of other suitable candidates on a reserve list to the extent of 50 per cent of the advertised vacancies, and to recommend them on a further requisition from the Government. The responsibility which has thus been placed on the Commission by rule 20 of the Rules is important and is distinct from the holding of the examination. It does not require much argument to say that what holds good in the case of an examination by outsiders, will hold good in a case in which the examination is entrusted by the Commission to some of its members.

    14. It therefore appears to me that by the very nature of the responsibility which was placed on the Commission by rule 20 of the Rules, it was necessary that it should have been discharged by the Chairman and all the members of the Commission, and not merely by the Chairman and one member. The failure to do so vitiated the list which was forwarded by the Secretariat of the Commission to the State government. I have gone through Devjit Chaliha's case (8) and it appears that there is justification for Mr. Joshi's argument that the petitioner there did not deny that the nomination of respondent No. 1, who was the selected candidate, was made by the Commission. That case is therefore clearly distinguishable and cannot be said to benefit the respondents.

    15. In the result, as the list of the candidates who came out successful at the viva voce examination could not ipso facto assume the status of the list of the suitable candidates which was required to be prepared by the Commission in accordance with rule 20, it could not have been forwarded by the Commission's Secretariat to the Government and was not, at any rate, a valid list on the basis of which the Government could select the candidates under rule 22 of the Rules, and there is justification for the prayer that the respondent State should be restrained from giving effect to it. It is ordered accordingly. The petitioners will be entitled to one set of costs from the respondents.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.K Bhatia v. Rajasthan Public Service Commission
    (Nov 1, 1971)