Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 26 of the Rajasthan Forest Act read with Rule 2 of the Rajasthan Forest (Produce Transit) Rules
  • provisions of Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 193 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • SECTION 4 FOREST ACT
  • Section 182, I. P. C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 26 of the Rajasthan Forest Act read with Rule 2 of the Rajasthan Forest (Produce Transit) Rules
  • provisions of Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 193 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • SECTION 4 FOREST ACT
  • Section 182, I. P. C.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an application in revision by Prem Kumar. He was convicted under Section 26 of the Rajasthan Forest Act read with Rule 2 of the Rajasthan Forest (Produce Transit) Rules and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 100 by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Bundi. His appeal to the Additional Sessions Judge, Bundi was unsuccessful.

The two courts below found, on the evidence of prosecution witnesses Motilal (P. W. 1), Insafali (P. W. 2), Mathura (P. W. 3) and Gafurali (P. W. 4), that on the night of 1 November 1958 some Bhils were cutting trees from the reserved forest of Shikarganj and loading them into truck No. RJR 175 while the petitioner was present and armed with a gun. The forest produce was being taken away when forest department employees blocked the route by placing stones. The petitioner jumped out of the truck and ran away, leaving his gun in the truck. The petitioner's challenge to this finding was noted but the court observed that it is a finding of fact supported by evidence and not open to challenge in this revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved that the trees had been cut from land within the demarcation of the reserved forest of Shikarganj.
  2. Whether the trial was vitiated because the complainant (Surajprakash, Range Officer) was absent on certain hearing dates (7 and 28 October 1958) and the Magistrate proceeded with recording evidence without adjourning the case or recording an order dispensing with the complainant's personal attendance, in apparent contravention of Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Appellant's) Arguments

  • The prosecution failed to prove that the place from which the trees were cut was within the reserved forest.
  • The trial was vitiated because on 7th and 28th October 1958 the complainant (Surajprakash) was not present and the Magistrate recorded evidence and proceeded without adjourning the case or making any recorded order dispensing with the complainant's attendance, contrary to Section 247 CrPC; reliance was placed on precedent authorities (Arjandas Tulsidas v. G. K. Bhagat, Daulat Ram Bala Ram v. Ram Kishan, L. S. Patil v. Dundappa Malkajappa and State v. Reva Chand).

Respondent / Prosecution Arguments

  • The prosecution witnesses' statements show that the trees were within the demarcation of the reserved forest; the petitioner did not deny that fact when specifically questioned.
  • The Deputy Government Advocate produced a Gazette notification dated 18 December 1954 (issued under Section 4 of the Forest Act) to indicate the area in question was part of the reserved forest (though the final notification under Section 20 was not produced).
  • With respect to absence of the complainant on hearing dates, the prosecution relied on the post‑1955 state of Section 247 (which permits the magistrate to dispense with the personal attendance of the complainant) and on authorities that an irregularity in proceeding in the complainant's absence does not vitiate a trial unless prejudice to the accused is shown.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Arjandas Tulsidas v. G. K. Bhagat, AIR 1954 Ajmer 31 (2) When the attendance of the complainant is not dispensed with the Magistrate can either adjourn the case for proper reasons or acquit the accused. Cited to show that a magistrate must either adjourn or acquit if complainant not present unless attendance has been dispensed with; used in analysis of the effect of absent complainant but not taken as automatically invalidating all subsequent proceedings.
Daulat Ram Bala Ram v. Ram Kishan, AIR 1958 Punj 317 Even when inquiry starts as a warrant case, if the charge is under a section tried as a summons case, provisions of Section 247 CrPC apply. Applied to confirm that Section 247 governed the procedure in the present summons case.
L. S. Patil v. Dundappa Malkajappa, AIR 1960 Mys 39 This authority was cited in argument. The court explicitly stated that L. S. Patil's case has no application in the present case.
State v. Reva Chand, AIR 1961 All 352 Section 247 is mandatory; personal attendance of the complainant is compulsory and absence requires acquittal unless adjourned or attendance dispensed with. Cited to demonstrate the mandatory language of Section 247 in earlier decisions; the court acknowledged the principle but distinguished the present facts and subsequent legal developments (1955 amendment).
Sudhir Kumar v. Emperor, AIR 1942 Pat 46 Held that if the complainant is absent the magistrate ordinarily must acquit or adjourn; proceeding and convicting in his absence renders the conviction illegal (decided under pre‑1955 Section 247). Not cited at Bar but relied upon in the opinion. The court noted this was decided before the 1955 amendment; it used the case to explain the pre‑amendment position and then distinguished it because after 1955 the magistrate could dispense with attendance irrespective of the complainant's status.
Amir Mia v. Sarafdi Hazi, AIR 1920 Cal 68 Examining witnesses in the complainant's absence does not vitiate the trial unless the accused was prejudiced; cross‑examination and right to call defence witnesses indicate absence of prejudice. Applied to support the proposition that mere examination of witnesses in the complainant's absence does not automatically vitiate proceedings when no prejudice to the accused is shown.
State v. Shivdayal Rajawat (unreported Bench Decision, Criminal Appeal No. 138B of 1957, decided 5‑9‑1958 Raj) Bench decision concerning absence of a complainant (Inspector of Factories) on some dates and appropriate stage for raising the objection. Referred to as persuasive factual guidance; the court noted observations about the proper procedural stage to seek acquittal when complainant fails to appear.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  1. Evidence on the reserved-forest issue:
    • The court observed that the objection that the trees were not within the reserved forest was raised for the first time in this court; it had not been taken in the trial court or in the first appeal.
    • The prosecution witnesses, unchallenged by the accused, stated the trees were cut within the demarcation line of the reserved forest. When specifically questioned, the petitioner did not deny that it was reserved forest.
    • The Deputy Government Advocate produced a Gazette notification dated 18 December 1954 issued under Section 4 of the Forest Act to show the area was part of the reserved forest, though the final notification under Section 20 was not shown. On the uncontroverted witness evidence, the court concluded it could be said the trees were cut and removed from the reserved forest.
  2. Procedural objection under Section 247 CrPC:
    • The court set out the text of Section 247 and explained that in a summons case the magistrate must normally acquit the accused if the complainant does not appear on the hearing date unless the hearing is adjourned or the magistrate dispenses with the complainant's attendance.
    • The court reviewed the chronology: on 23 September some witness statements were recorded and the case adjourned to 7 October; on 7 October the complainant was absent but his counsel appeared and the magistrate recorded further prosecution evidence; the order sheet did not show an order dispensing with the complainant's personal attendance. Similarly, on 28 October the complainant was absent, counsel was present, and statements of the accused and defence witnesses were recorded without any order dispensing with the complainant's attendance or any adjournment recorded.
    • No objection was taken by the accused on either 7 or 28 October, nor on any subsequent date in the trial court; the objection was raised for the first time in this revision application.
    • The court reviewed authorities. It noted decisions (Arjandas, Daulat Ram, State v. Reva Chand) emphasising the mandatory language of Section 247 and the consequences of absence, but also observed that earlier authorities (notably Sudhir Kumar) were decided before the 1955 amendment to Section 247 which limited the magistrate's discretion prior to amendment.
    • After the 1955 amendment the magistrate can dispense with personal attendance of the complainant whether or not the complainant is a public servant; proceedings can be taken in the complainant's absence provided the court dispensed with his personal attendance.
    • The court found that in the present case the only procedural irregularity was the magistrate's failure to record an order exempting the complainant from personal attendance on the dates he was absent. However, the proceedings were conducted in the presence of the accused, the accused cross‑examined prosecution witnesses and gave evidence, and it was not alleged that the accused suffered any prejudice from the absence. The court relied on Amir Mia and related authority to hold that taking evidence in the complainant's absence does not vitiate a trial unless prejudice is shown.
    • Therefore, in the absence of any shown prejudice and given the opportunity the accused had during trial, the court concluded that the procedural omission (failure to record exemption of attendance) was not of such a character as to render the conviction illegal.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court held that the procedural irregularity (the Magistrate's failure to record an order dispensing with the complainant's personal attendance) did not render the conviction illegal.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • On the factual issue of the trees' origin, the court accepted the uncontradicted testimony of prosecution witnesses and observed that the petitioner did not deny the reserved-forest character of the land when questioned; the evidence sufficed to conclude the trees were cut from the reserved forest (notwithstanding the absence of a Section 20 notification on the record).
  • On the procedural point, the court applied post‑1955 Section 247 principles and authorities to conclude that proceedings in the absence of the complainant do not automatically vitiate conviction where the court could dispense with attendance and where no prejudice to the accused is shown. The only recorded procedural defect was the omission to note the exemption; absent prejudice, that omission did not invalidate the trial.
  • The direct effect on the parties (as stated in the opinion) is that the irregularity does not render the conviction illegal. The opinion does not state that a new legal principle or binding precedent was laid down; the court primarily applied and distinguished existing authorities and the post‑1955 statutory framework.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the text of the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in that text.

    Prem Kumar v. State

    1. This is an application in revision by Prem Kumar who has been convicted under Section 26 of the Rajasthan Forest Act read with Rule 2 of the Rajasthan Forest (Produce Transit) Rules and has been sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 100/ by the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Bundi. His appeal before the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Bundi also failed.

    2. The two courts have concurrently found on the evidence of Motilal (P. W. 1), Insafali (P. W. 2), Mathura (P. W. 3) and Gafurali (P. W. 4) that on the night of 1st November, 1958, some Bhils were cutting trees from the reserved forest of Shikarganj and were loading them in truck No. RJR 175 while the petitioner was present there armed with a gun. After loading the truck the forest produce was being taken away when they were stopped by the employees of the forest department who had placed stones on the way in order to block the further movement of the truck. The petitioner on seeing the employees of the forest department, jumped out of the truck and ran away leaving behind his gun in the truck. This is a finding of fact and there is sufficient evidence in support of It. The petitioner has challenged the correctness of this finding but it is not open to him to do so in this revision.

    3. The only contentions which deserve consideration are :

    1. that the prosecution has failed to prove that the place from where the trees are said to have been cut, was within the area of the reserved forest.

    2. that the trial in the case was vitiated for the reason that on 7th and 28th October, 1958, Surajprakash Range Officer who was the complainant in the case was not present in the court and the learned Magistrate instead of acquitting the accused and without adjourning the case or dispensing with the presence of the complainant recorded the evidence of the prosecution and defence witnesses. It is urged that the procedure followed by the learned Magistrate was contrary to the provisions of Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In support of this contention learned counsel relied upon Arjandas Tulsidas v. G. K. Bhagat,, AIR 1954 Ajmer 31 (2) Daulat Ram Bala Ram v. Ram Kishan AIR 1958 Punj 317 L S. Patil v. Dundappa Malkajappa, AIR 1960 Mys 39 and State v. Reva Chand, AIR 1961 All 352.

    4. As for the first contention it may be pointed out that it is only in this court that this objection has been raised. Neither before the trial court nor before the learned Additional Sessions Judge this objection was taken. However, it appears from the statements of the prosecution witnesses that the trees were cut from a place which was within the demarcation line of the reserved forest. Specific question was also put to the petitioner in this behalf but he did not deny that it was a reserved forest.

    5. Learned Deputy Government Advocate has also produced notification published in the Gazette dated 18th December, 1954 to show that the place in question was a part of the reserved forest, but this notification was Issued under section 4 of the Forest Act and the final notification, which is issued under Section 20 was not shown, to me. But on the evidence of the prosecution witnesses which were not challenged by the accused it can safely be said that the trees were cut and were removed from the reserved forest.

    6. As for the second contention it is not disputed that the case was instituted on the complaint of Surajprakash Range Officer and was a summons cass. Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that :

    "If the summons has been issued on complaint, and upon the day appointed for the appearance of the accused or any day subsequent thereto to which the hearing may be adjourned the complainant does not appear, the Magistrate, shall, notwithstanding anything hereinbefore contained, acquit the accused, unless for some reason he thinks proper to adjourn the hearing of the case to some other day :

    Provided that, where the Magistrate is of opinion-that the personal attendance of the complainant is not necessary, the Magistrate may dispense with his attendance, and proceed with the case".

    In a summons case therefore, it is incumbent on the Magistrate to acquit the accused if the complainant is not present on the date of hearing unless he thinks proper toad journ the hearing of the case to some other date, or dispenses with the complainant's attendance and proceeds with the case.

    It appears that on 23rd September statements of some of the prosecution witnesses were recorded and the case was adjourned to 7th October, 1958. On this date the complainant was not present but his counsel Shri Raghbardayal was present. The learned Magistrate did not adjourn the case and proceeded to record the statement of Insafali and closed the prosecution evidence. It does not appear from the order sheet that the learned Magistrate was of opinion that the personal attendance of the-complainant was not necessary and should be dispensed with. Similarly, on 28th October, 1958, Suraiprakash was not present and only his counsel Shri Raghbardayal was present. The case was neither adjourned nor was any order dispensing with the personal attendance of the complainant recorded and the case was proceeded with and the statements of the accused and of the defence witnesses were recorded. The case remained pending in the court of the learned Magistrate for further proceedings and ultimately on 26th February, 1960, resulted in the conviction of the accused.

    Neither on 7th nor on 28th October nor on any subsequent date objection was taken fay the accused regarding the legality of proceedings taken in the absence of the complainant. It is for the first time in revision that the question has been raised. The question therefore, is whether the conviction of the accused is bad and the trial was vitiated. In Arjandas's case, AIR 1954 Ajmer 31 (2) the facts were that a complaint under Section 182, I. P. C. was filed against the accused. oN 25th March, 1953, charge was explained to him. The case was next taken up on 9th April, 1953 and on that date statements of the complainant and one witness were recorded. The case was adjourned to 25th April, 1953. On this date the complainant was not present in court but the Assistant Public Prosecutor moved two applications; one for summoning certain additional evidence and the other for trying the case as a warrant case as the facts alleged constituted an offence under Section 193 of the Indian Penal Code. The court did not pass any orders on these applications. On 30th April, the accused submitted an application that as the complainant was absent on 25th March, 25th April and 30th April, he was entitled to acquittal under the provisions of Section 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This application was rejected.

    A revision was filed against this order before the learned Judicial Commissioner, Ajmer and it was held that when the attendance of the complainant was not actually dispensed with the Magistrate could either adjourn the case for proper reasons or acquit the accused. In Daulat Ram's case, AIR 1958 Punj 317 it was held that

    "even though the enquiry on a complaint may start as in a warrant case but if the charge framed is under a section which is tried as summons case provisions of section 247 would become applicable"
    .

    L. S. Patil's case AIR 1960 Mys 39 has no application in the present case. In AIR 1961 All 352 the accused was acquitted because the District Magistrate who happened to be complainant in that case was not present on the date of hearing. The State went in appeal to the High Court and it was held that :

    "Section 247 is mandatory. It makes the personal attendance of the complainant in court on the day of hearing compulsory. The section makes no distinction between a public servant complainant and an ordinary complainant in respect of his personal attendance.

    If on the day of hearing the complainant is absent while the accused is present, the Court is bound to acquit the accused unless it thinks proper to adjourn or the personal attendance of the complainant is dispensed with".

    7. None of these cases lays down that proceedings taken in the absence of the complainant without dispensing with his personal attendance are illegal and the conviction is liable to be quashed. However, in Sudhir Kumar v. Emperor AIR 1942 Pat 46 which was not cited at the Bar it was held that :

    "When the complainant is absent the only course open to the Magistrate is to ordinarily acquit the accused or for proper reason adjourn the case. He cannot proceed with the case and convict the accused. Such a conviction is illegal and should be quashed"
    .

    This case was decided on the terms of Section 247 as ft stood before the amendment of 1955. Under that law, the discretion to dispense with the personal attendance of the complainant was given only in the case of public servants and did not extend to other persons. After the amendment of 1955 the personal attendance of the complainant whether he is a public servant or otherwise can be dispensed with and the Magistrate can proceed with the case in his absence.

    In Sudhir Kumar Neogi's case AIR 1942 Pat 46 the complainant was not a public servant and therefore, in his absence the case could not be proceeded with and the Magistrate was bound to acquit the accused unless for reasons he thought proper to adjourn it. But in the present case proceedings could be taken in the absence of the complainant provided the court dispensed with his personal attendance. It, therefore, follows that proceedings can be taken in the absence of the complainant, provided the court has dispensed with the personal attendance of the complainant. In the present case no objection was taken by the accused on the dates the complainant was absent. Proceedings were taken in the presence of the accused and statements of prosecution and defence witnesses were recorded before him. it is not alleged that the accused has been prejudiced in anyway. The only irregularity which appears in the proceedings is that the learned Magistrate failed to noteabout exempting the complainant from personal attendance on the dates he was not present in the court. In the absence of any prejudice to the accused this irregularity. is not such which might render the conviction of the accused as illegal.

    In Amir Mia v. Sarafdi Hazi, AIR 1920 Cal 68 it was held that :

    "Section 247 gives power to a Magistrate to adjourn a summons case for sufficient reason when the complainant does not appear and the fact that some witnesses are examined in the absence of the complainant would not vitiate the trial unless it is shown that the accused was in some way prejudiced. The fact that he cross-examined the prosecution witnesses and examined witnesses in his defence would show that he was not prejudiced in any way"
    .

    Reference may also be made to an unreported Bench Decision of this Court in The State v. Shivdayal Rajawat (Criminal Appeal No. 138B of 1957 decided on 5-9-1958 Raj) where the Inspector of Factories who was a complainant did not appear in the court on some dates. On the last date i. e., 16th July, 1957 an objection was raised that the accused should be acquitted. The learned Magistrate fixed 1st August, 1957 for considering the objection and also summoned the Factories Inspector, On 1st August 1957, the complainant appeared but the learned Magistrate acquitted the accused. It was observed that the proper stage for the Magistrate to have dismissed the complaint and acquit the accused, if at all, was when the case came before him on 16th July, 1957 when the Factories Inspector who was the complainant in the case was not present and not on the 1st of August, 1957 when he was actually present in court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prem Kumar v. State
    (Dec 19, 1961)