Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 21 Rule 32(3) of the Code.
  • Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code
  • 21 rule 32(3) of the Code
  • Section 52, T.P. Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 21 Rule 32(3) of the Code.
  • Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code
  • 21 rule 32(3) of the Code
  • Section 52, T.P. Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Revision Petition Challenging Order dated 15.4.1981

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petition challenges an order dated 15.4.1981 of the Sub Judge 1st Class, Narwana, which dismissed the petitioner-decree holders' execution application under Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking execution of a decree passed on 14.10.1968. The original suit was filed by Bansi Lal against several judgment-debtors (Nos.1–4 and Nos.6–14). The suit resulted in a decree restraining judgment-debtors Nos.1–4 from raising any new construction on the suit land without partition.

In the execution application, respondent No.5 (later represented by legal heirs No.5-A to 5-F and referred to as Bhalla) was impleaded for the first time as an objector, accused of having raised construction over the suit land in violation of the earlier decree. Respondent No.5 denied raising new construction, claiming the room in question existed prior to his purchase (22.11.1978) and that he only performed repairs. The executing Court framed issues whether Bhalla disobeyed the injunction decree dated 14.10.1968, whether the decree was executable against him, and whether the judgment-debtors violated a stay order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether respondent No.5 (Bhalla) disobeyed the injunction decree dated 14.10.1968 such that execution under Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure was justified against him.
  2. Whether the decree for injunction was executable against respondent No.5 (Bhalla), who was not a party to the original suit and had purchased the property from a vendor who was not a party to the suit.
  3. Whether the judgment-debtors (including the objector) violated any stay order such that contempt or execution consequences should follow.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Petitioners - Decree Holders (represented by Shri S.P. Gupta)

  • The onus to prove that the room existed prior to the purchase by Bhalla was on the objector; the objector alleged pre-existing construction and therefore needed to produce proof (sale deed).
  • The trial Court erred by placing the burden of proof improperly; the petitioners could have produced secondary evidence (e.g., certified copy from the Sub-Registrar) if the objector failed to produce the sale deed.
  • If it were shown by proper proof that the sale deed recited that Daropati Devi sold only a plain plot (and not a constructed room), then Bhalla would be liable to civil imprisonment under Order 21 Rule 32(3) of the Code for disobeying the injunction decree.

Respondent No.5 / Objector (represented by Shri Rajesh Chaudhary, for Nos.5-A to 5-F)

  • Bhalla pleaded that a kutcha room already existed when he purchased the property from Smt. Daropati Devi and that he was only making repairs, not raising new construction.
  • Witness evidence (e.g., Raj Kumar OW1) supported the existence of a room used for a bicycle repair business prior to the purchase.
  • The primary burden to prove violation of the decree or stay lies on the petitioners/decree holders; contempt/execution proceedings under Order 21 Rule 32 are quasi-criminal and require cogent evidence to convict or find contempt.
  • Given the lack of cogent evidence and plausible explanations by the objector (including that construction occurred while an appellate stay had itself been stayed), the trial Court correctly found against the decree-holders.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1931 Bombay 280 (Amrit Lal v. Kanti Lal) The principle that a decree for injunction "does not run with the land" and, absent statutory provision, cannot be enforced against a purchaser from a judgment-debtor; however, where legal representatives are made parties under Section 50 and transferees from them can be bound under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, execution may be permissible against such transferees. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the injunction decree was not executable against Bhalla (a purchaser who was not a party to the original suit and whose vendor was not a party), and therefore answered the issue regarding executability in favour of the objector.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reviewing the findings of the executing Court and the evidence on record. The executing Court had considered documentary and oral evidence and concluded that:

  • It was not established whether the room (kotha) existed at the time Bhalla purchased the property; evidence was inconclusive (the executing Court found the petitioners/decree-holders failed to prove that Bhalla disobeyed the injunction decree dated 14.10.1968).
  • The executing Court applied the precedent in AIR 1931 Bombay 280 (Amrit Lal v. Kanti Lal) and observed the general rule that an injunction decree does not run with the land and cannot, in absence of statutory provision, be enforced against a purchaser who was not party to the original suit; execution against transferees is possible only under provisions such as Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act when statutory requirements are met.
  • On the issue of alleged violation of stay orders, the executing Court held that mere surmise is insufficient: contempt proceedings are quasi-criminal and require proof beyond conjecture; Bhalla had stated he ceased work on service of a stay order and pointed to appellate orders staying the operation of the stay (Ex. O.8), providing a plausible explanation that construction occurred when the stay's operation was itself stayed. Therefore the executing Court held the stay-violation issue not proved.

The revisional court (the court delivering the opinion being summarized) reviewed submissions by both counsels, perused the record, and agreed with the executing Court's approach and findings. Key points in the revisional court's analysis:

  • The petitioners/decree-holders failed to discharge the onus of proof that Bhalla violated the decree or stayed orders; the evidence was neither cogent nor conclusive.
  • Where execution under Order 21 Rule 32(3) is sought for alleged violation of decree terms, the required standard of proof is high—"equivalent to the one required in criminal cases"—and allegations must be proved "to the hilt."
  • Smt. Daropati Devi (one of Bhalla's vendors) was not a party to the original suit and therefore could not seek execution of the decree; moreover, the decree was sought to be executed only against Bhalla, who also was not a party to the decree.
  • Given these facts and the evidentiary shortfall, the revisional court found no basis to interfere with the executing Court's conclusion that execution against Bhalla was not maintainable and that he was not guilty of violating the decree or stay orders.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the executing Court's order dismissing the execution application against respondent No.5 (Bhalla) stands; execution against Bhalla under Order 21 Rule 32 was held not maintainable on the facts of the case.
  • The objector (Bhalla) was not found guilty of violating the injunction decree dated 14.10.1968 or any stay order, due to lack of cogent evidence and the high standard of proof applicable in such proceedings.
  • The Court relied on existing precedent (Amrit Lal v. Kanti Lal) and established legal principles regarding executability of injunction decrees against purchasers and transferees; the opinion does not indicate that a new legal precedent was created.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not include information beyond that text.

    Raj Kumar And Ors. v. Parshotam Dass And Ors.

    1. This is a revision petition challenging the order dated 15.4.1981 passed by the Sub Judge 1st Class, Narwana dismissing the application of the petitioner-decree holder filed under Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking execution of the decree passed in their favour on 14.10.1968.

    2. The facts of the case are that one Bansi Lal filed a suit against respondent-judgment debtors No.l to 4 and respondent-judgment debtors No.6 to 14. Some of them are now represented by their legal representatives. The suit was decreed in favour of the petitioners/decree holders. The respondent-judgment debtors No.l to 4 were restrained from raising any other construction on the suit land without getting it partitioned with other share holders. In the application filed for execution of this decree under Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code respondent No. 5 Objector (now represented by his legal heirs 5-A to 5-F) was impleaded for the first time and allegation levelled against him was that he has raised construction over the suit land. It was further asserted that having violated the terms of decree passed by the Civil Court on 14.10.1968 he is guilty of flouting the orders of the Civil Court. It was alleged that the respondents-judgment debtor No.l to 4 has raised construction after the decision of the appeal and, as such, the construction is liable to be demolished

    3. Respondent No.5 (now represented by respondents No.5-A to 5-F) filed reply to the application and raised objection that the room allegedly constructed by him was already in existence before he had purchased the property on 22.11.1978 from Smt. Darapoti, Parshotam Dass and Sat Parkash for the consideration of Rs.5,280/- and his vendors were in exclusive possession of the suit property. He states that a room made of kutcha bricks was in existence and Purshotam Dass had a bi-cycle repair shop in that room. According to the objector/respondent No.5, he never raised any new construction and was simply getting some repair work done. He relied on an order dated 24.5.1972 passed by the learned Additional District Judge wherein he had ordered the demolition of construction. From that order it is shown that the construction was already in existence and no question of raising new construction would arise. It was further asserted by respondent No.5-objector that he had purchased the suit property from Smt. Daropati Devi who was not even party to the previous suit and, as such, decree is not executable. It was subsequently complained by making an application alleging that respondents No.l to 4-judgmcnt debtor have violated the stay order and had constructed a room to which respondent No.5-objector filed reply pointing out that in appeal filed by the respondent No.5-objector, the learned Additional District Judge, Jind had stayed operation of the judgment and decree and it was during that period respondent No.5-objector had completed construction. He claimed that he never violated or dis-obeyed any order of the Court. The executing Court framed the issues as to whether respondent No.5-objec-tor (Bhalla) has dis-obeyed the injunction decree dated 14.10.1968 and as to whether the decree was executable against respondent No.5-objector. After taking into consideration the documentary as well as oral evidence, the executing Court came to the conclusion that it is not clear as to whether the room was in existence at the time when Bhalta purchased the suit property from Smt. Daropati, Parshotam Dass and Sat Parkash. and that the petitioners/decree-holders have failed to prove that Bhalla dis-obeyed the injunction decree dated 14.10.1968. The finding on this issue as given by the Sub-Judge, 1st Class, Narwana reads as under:

    "There is no gain saying of the fact that Bhalta has purchased the suit property and has also applied for construction to the Municipal Committee. Smt. Daropati one of the vendors was not a party to the main suit in which the impugned decree sought to be executed was passed. Bhalla himself was also not a party to the suit in which the impugned decree was passed. At the costs of repetition, it may again be mentioned that it is nowhere the grievance of the decree holders that the other JDs are violating the terms of the injunction decree. In fact, the impugned decree for permanent injunction is not being executed against the other JDs. No act of invasion has been alleged or asserted against the other JDs. In view of the authority reported as AIR 1931 Bombay 280 (Amrit Lal v. Kanti Lal) wherein it has been held "The decree for injunction does not run with the land and in the absence of any statutory provision, such a decree cannot be enforced against the surviving members of a joint family or against a purchaser from a judgment-debtor. But where the sons of the judgment-debtor are brought on records as his legal representatives under Section 50 the decree can be executed against them and so also against the transferees from the legal representatives, under Section 52, T.P. Act. On the same principle viz. that they are bound by the result of the execution proceedings under Section 52, T.P. Act, the transferees from the original judgment debtor during the pendency of execution proceedings against them, can be held to be similarly bound and are liable to be proceeded against in execution." In my opinion, the present decree is not executable against Bhalla-objector. Hence, this issue is answered in favour of the objector and against the decree-holders."

    4. Another issue framed on 6.9.1980 was as to whether the JDs violated the stay order. The findings returned are that there was no violation of the stay orders and the same reads as under:

    As discussed above under issue No.l it is nowhere categorically proved by the decree-holders as to when the impugned kotha or room was constructed by Bhalla Ram-objector. Mere surmises or conjectures cannot take the place of proof, It was incumbent upon the decree-holders to prove the violation of stay order as contempt proceedings are quasi criminal in nature. The contemner is entitled to benefit of doubt. It is positive stand of Bhalla-objector in this case that he stopped the construction when he was served with the stay order. But in the appeal preferred, the operation of the stay order was stayed as is clear from the copy of order Ex.O.8. It is further stated by Bhalla-objector in his statement as OW4 that when he raised construction when the operation of the stay order was stayed by the learned Appellate Court. Thus Bhalla Ram-objector has explained the construction in a very plausible manner. Thus, this issue is held as not proved and is decided against the decree holders and in favour of the Bhalla objector.

    5. Shri S.P. Gupta, learned counsel for the petitioners-decree holders has argued that the onus to prove the purchase of the room by Bhalla was on him as he was one who had raised the objection that room was in existence. According to the learned counsel, the trial Court committed grave error in law by placing the burden of proof of showing the recital of the sale deed dated 22.12.1976 on the petitioners-decree holders. The learned counsel has drawn my attention to that portion of order where the trial Court has observed that on the failure of objector/respondent No.5 Bhalla to produce the sale deed dated 22.12.1976 the petitioners-decree holders could have ted secondary evidence by obtaining a certified copy from the office of Sub Registrar. Therefore, he contends that once the proof in writing from recital is established that Daropati Devi sold to objector/respondent No.5 Bhalla the plain plot and not a room constructed on the land and once it is shown then objector/respondent No.5 Bhalla is liable to be sent to civil imprisonment by virtue of provision under Order 21 rule 32(3) of the Code.

    6. On the other hand, Shri Rajesh Chaudhary, learned counsel for respondent No.5A to 5F have drawn my attention to the reply filed by objector/respondent No.5 wherein it has been categorically pleaded that already that there was a room made from kutcha bricks in existence when he purchased the property from Smt. Daropati Devi widow of Parshotam and Sat Parkash. He has further asserted in para No.4 that he is not raising any new construction but merely repairing the room. He also referred to the statement of Raj Kumar OWI where Raj Kumar has stated that there was one room constructed on the suit land and in that room one Lal Chand used to carry on the work of cycle repairs. He has further stated that Bhalla had raised 4 feet wall. On the basis of stand taken by objector/respondent No 5, Shri Rajesh Chaudhary has argued that it cannot be concluded that objector/respondent No.5 Bhalla has flouted either the decree of the Court dated 14.10.1968 or any stay order. He has further argued that primary burden to prove the violation of the terms of the decree lies on the petitioners/decree holders and the trial Court was right in placing the burden on then. According to the learned counsel, the proceedings of contempt are quasi criminal in nature and- unless the allegations are proved by cogent evidence it is not safe to convict a person. Therefore, he has further argued that since there is no cogent evidence on record and objector/respondent No.5 is not shown to have committed any violation of the decree, the order of the trial Court must be maintained.

    7. I have thoughtfully considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record with their assistance and I am of the view that the revision petition is liable to be dismissed because petitioner/decree holders have failed to prove on record any violation of the decree or any of the stay order. There is no evidence much less cogent evidence to substantiate the allegation concerning violation of decree dated 14.10.1968 and the stay order. The onus of proof was on the petitioners/decree holders to prove their assertions which they have remained unable to discharge. It is well settled law that in cases concerning under order 21 rule 32(3) of the Code where allegations of violation of terms of a decree are made, the evidence required to prove those allegations is equivalent to the one required in criminal cases and the charge has to be prove to the hilt. Moreover, Smt. Daropati Devi who was one of the vendor of the room sold to objector/respondent No.5, was not even party to the suit and, therefore, cannot seek execution of that decree. It has further come on record that decree was sought to be executed only against objector/respondent No.5 Bhalla and not against judgment debtor set No.l. Still further Bhalla was also not party to the decree. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of this case, it is not possible to hold objector/respondent No.5 guilty of violation of either the decree dated 14.10.1968 or any of the stay order. There is no plausible reason to differ with the conclusion reached by the trial Court that the execution itself is not maintainable.,

    8. For the reasons recorded above, this revision petition fails and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raj Kumar And Ors. v. Parshotam Dass And Ors.
    (Jan 23, 2002)