AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act
  • Section 2(j).(d) Constitutional
  • Section 2(j)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act
  • Section 2(j).(d) Constitutional
  • Section 2(j)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — V.K. Jhanji, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes of a bunch of writ petitions (C.W.P. Nos. 6882, 3883, 6808, 7993, 17370 of 1991, 4550 & 14993 of 1992, 2604 of 1993 and 15079 of 1994) by a common judgment because they raise a common question of law and fact. For convenience, facts are taken from C.W.P. No. 6882 of 1991.

The second respondent (workman) was appointed as a daily-rated worker by the Divisional Forest Officer, Hissar, on 3 October 1978 and worked until his services were terminated on 18 December 1987. He alleged termination without notice or charge-sheet and sought reference under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act claiming status as a "workman" under Section 2(s) and entitlement under Section 25-F for wrongful termination.

The government referred the dispute to the Labour Court (first respondent), which by award dated 13 December 1990 found that the management had not complied with Section 25-F and that the workman was entitled to reinstatement with full back wages and continuity of service. The Labour Court also held that the Forest Department of the State of Haryana falls within the definition of "industry" under Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act and that the reference was maintainable.

The State challenged the Labour Court awards by filing these writ petitions. While proceedings before the Labour Court were ongoing, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana, filed an affidavit (26 July 1996) describing the nature and objectives of the Forest Department's activities and projects (including afforestation, social forestry projects, saw mills for demonstration, manufacturing of polythene bags by the Haryana Forest Development Corporation, and a World Bank aided Social Forestry Project).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Forest Department of the State of Haryana is an "industry" within the meaning of Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Counsel for the State (Respondents)

  • Submitted that under Article 48-A of the Constitution it is a constitutional function of the State to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard forest and wildlife, and therefore the Department of Forests is not an "industry".
  • Relied on observations of the Supreme Court in Sub Divisional Inspector of Post, Vaikam v. Theyyam Joseph to support the proposition that certain state-provided services can be sovereign functions and not industries (example given in that case: telecommunication service being an essential sovereign amenity and not an industry).
  • Referred to a Division Bench judgment of this Court in State of Punjab through Assistant Director, Horticulture, Faridkot v. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Bhatinda which had held the Horticulture Department not to be an "industry".

Counsel for the Workman (Second Respondent)

  • Contended that the forest department is not discharging sovereign functions; its main activities involve plantation of trees, development of green lands and preservation of wildlife and forests.
  • Argued that the Forest Department has become a significant revenue-earning department for the State; even if not profit-making, the activity is systematic and coordinated and resembles trade or business.
  • Implicitly relied on factual material placed on record (affidavit of the Principal Chief Conservator) to demonstrate systematic activities, use of labour (daily-wage workers), and initiatives like saw mills, manufacturing of polythene bags and social forestry projects.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sub Divisional Inspector of Post, Vaikam v. Theyyam Joseph Observations that certain services provided by the State (example: telecommunication service) may be sovereign/welfare functions and not "industry". The Court observed these authorities lend some support to the State's argument but found them not determinative; the activities of the Forest Department, judged under the Rajappa test, still amounted to an "industry".
State of Punjab through Assistant Director, Horticulture, Faridkot v. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Bhatinda Held that the Horticulture Department was not an "industry" (as recorded in this opinion). The Court held this precedent was of no assistance to the State because the State did not produce the material on which that Division Bench relied; therefore it could not be equated with the Forest Department of Haryana.
Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa Sets out the test for "industry" under Section 2(j): (i) systematic activity, (ii) organised cooperation between employer and employee, (iii) production/distribution of goods or services to satisfy human wants; absence of profit motive is irrelevant; sovereign functions narrowly construed; departments with severable units may still be industries. The Court applied the Rajappa criteria to the activities of the Forest Department (systematic activities, employer-employee relations, services satisfying human wants such as pollution-free environment) and concluded the department is an "industry".
Chief Conservator of Forests v. Jagannath Maruti Kondhare Held that the Forest Department of Maharashtra is an "industry" under Section 2(j); emphasised that sovereign/non-sovereign dichotomy depends on nature and manner of exercise of power and welfare activities may fall within "industry". The Court relied on this three-judge Bench decision as directly supporting the view that a State Forest Department can be an "industry". It reinforced the conclusion that welfare/environmental activities undertaken by the State do not automatically exclude them from the Act.
Banerji's case; Nagendra Rao's case; Corporation of Nagpur case; University of Delhi case Referenced in the Rajappa exposition to explain contextual meanings and limits of "undertaking", and the test of predominant/integrated nature of services when departments contain mixed activities. Used by the Court indirectly via Rajappa's reasoning to emphasise that only strictly understood sovereign functions are exempt, and that predominant/integrated nature of activities decides the "industry" character.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in these principal steps, staying strictly to the material and authorities referenced in the opinion:

  1. Identification of the sole legal issue: whether the Forest Department of Haryana is an "industry" within Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act. Because the writ petitions raised common questions, they were heard together.
  2. Assessment of factual material: the Court considered the affidavit of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (filed 26 July 1996) that described the Department's activities (environmental stability, conservation, soil erosion control, afforestation and social forestry programmes), organisational structure (regular establishment plus large daily-wage labour force), auxiliary manufacturing (polythene bags through Haryana Forest Development Corporation), demonstration saw mills, and World Bank aided projects.
  3. Review of competing legal submissions: the State relied on Article 48-A and authorities (notably Theyyam Joseph and a Division Bench horticulture decision) to contend that forest protection is a sovereign/state duty and therefore outside the definition of "industry". The workman relied on factual descriptions showing systematic, organised activities and employer-employee relations analogous to trade or business and pointed out the Department's revenue-earning and project activities.
  4. Application of precedent: the Court applied the test from Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa — focusing on the functional test: systematic activity; organised cooperation between employer and employee; production/distribution of goods or services to satisfy human wants; irrelevance of profit motive; and that only strictly understood sovereign functions are excluded. The Court also relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Chief Conservator of Forests v. Jagannath Maruti Kondhare where a State Forest Department was held to be an "industry".
  5. Comparative evaluation of precedents: while the Theyyam Joseph observations were acknowledged as supportive of the State's position in part, the Court held that the Rajappa test and the Jagannath Maruti Kondhare decision were controlling and favored a wide interpretation of "industry." The Division Bench horticulture decision was held to be inapplicable in the absence of the material on which that decision rested.
  6. Synthesis and conclusion: applying the Rajappa criteria to the factual record (systematic activities, employer-employee relations, services that satisfy human wants such as environmental stability and pollution-free environment, presence of large daily-wage labour force, project work and production-related activities), the Court concluded that the Forest Department of the State of Haryana falls within the meaning of "industry" under Section 2(j). The Court expressly noted that noble objectives or lack of profit do not alter this conclusion and that merely being a welfare/ environmental function does not automatically make the department a non-industry.
  7. Consequential treatment of the Labour Court award: because the Court found the Forest Department to be an "industry" and there was no challenge to the Labour Court's finding of non-compliance with Section 25-F, the Court accepted that the Labour Court had jurisdiction and that the award ordering reinstatement and back wages should stand.
  8. Separate treatment of C.W.P. No. 12620 of 1993: this petition raised disputed questions of fact about whether the petitioner had abandoned service; the petitioner had not sought a reference for adjudication. On this procedural and factual basis, the Court dismissed that writ petition and left open the liberty to seek a reference.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Forest Department of the State of Haryana is an "industry" within the meaning of Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act.

Direct consequences and disposition:

  • The writ petitions filed on behalf of the State of Haryana challenging the Labour Court awards (CWP Nos. 6882, 6888, 7993 and 17370 of 1991, 4950 and 14993 of 1992, 2604 of 1992 and 15079 of 1994) were dismissed. The Court ordered no costs.
  • Because the Court accepted the Labour Court's finding of non-compliance with Section 25-F and held the Forest Department to be an "industry", the Labour Court award directing reinstatement with back wages and continuity of service stands (as to the matters contested in those writ petitions).
  • Civil Writ Petition No. 12620 of 1993 was dismissed on the ground that disputed factual questions existed and the petitioner had not sought the alternative remedy of a reference; the petitioner was given liberty to seek a reference for adjudication.

Broader implications: The Court's reasoning adheres to the tests laid down by the Supreme Court (Rajappa and Jagannath Maruti Kondhare). The opinion applies those tests to hold that State-run forest activities can fall within the statutory definition of "industry" despite being welfare- or environment-oriented; however, the judgment does not purport to announce a novel legal principle beyond applying existing Supreme Court authority.

Signed: Iqbal Singh, J.

    Divisional Forest Officer, Social Forestry Project, Hisar v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Hisar And Another

    V.K Jhanji, J.:— The sole question to be determined in a bunch of writ petitions, namely, C.W.P Nos. 6882, 3883, 6808, 7993, 17370 of 1991, 4550 & 14993 of 1992, 2604 of 1993 and 15079 of 1994, is whether the Forest Department of State of Haryana is an ‘industry’ within the meaning of Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act (Hereinafter referred to as the Act). Since common question of law and facts is involved in all the writ petitions, the same are being disposed of by a common judgment. For facility of reference, facts are taken from Civil Writ Petition No. 6882 of 1991.

    2. Second respondent was appointed as a daily-rated worker by the Divisional Forest Officer, Hissar, on 3.10.1978 He worked as such till 18.12.1987 when his services were terminated. Since according to the workman his services had been terminated without any notice or charge-sheet, he sought reference under Section 10 of the Act. He claimed that he being a workman under Section 2(s) of the Act and had a continuous service of more than 240 days during a period of 12 calendar months preceding the date of termination of services, is entitled to benefit of Section 25-F of the Act The matter was referred by the Government to the first respondent who vide award dated 13.12.1990 found that the management had not complied with the provisions of Section 25-F of the Act. It was held that the workman was entitled to reinstatement with other benefits. In regard to objection taken by the Divisional. Forest Officer that the forest department is a department of Haryana State and it cannot be termed as an ‘industry’, the first respondent observed as under:—

    “The forest deptt. of the State, which grows trees on land, arranges the sale of timber and incurs loss or pockets profits stands on the same footing as Irrigation Deptt. and Public Health Department of the State Government. It is industry in the light of the provisions of Section 2(j) of the Act. Both these issues are found against the management. The reference is maintainable and this Court has jurisdiction to try and decide the present reference.”

    3. In view of the finding that services of the workman had been terminated without any notice or charge-sheet and that the Labour Court had the jurisdiction to decide the reference, the order terminating the services of the workman was set aside and he was ordered to be reinstated with full back wages and benefit of continuity of service. The award of the Labour Court is being impugned in this writ petition. Similarly, in all the writ petitions except Civil Writ Petition No. 12620 of 1993, the awards passed by the Labour Court in various references are being challenged.

    4. While the proceedings were pending before the Labour Court, no material worth the name for showing the nature of activities or work carried on by the forest department was brought on record. In order to meet any possible objection form the side of workman and to fill up the lacuna, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana, has filed an affidavit dated 26.7.1996 for showing the activities carried on by the forest department. In his affidavit, he has stated that the principal aim of the forest department is to ensure ecological balance, including atmospheric equilibrium which are vital for sustenance of all life-forms, human, animals and plants. He in the affidavit has further stated that the National Forest Policy Resolution, 1988 has been adopted by the State Government. A copy of the National Forest Police Resolution, 1988, issued by the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, New Delhi, has also been placed on record. On the basis of National Forest Policy, it has been stated in the affidavit that the activities carried on by the forest department are as follows:—

    “(i) Maintenance of environmental stability through preservation and, where necessary, restoration of the ecological balance that has been adversely disturbed by serious depletion of the Forest of the State.

    ii) Conserving the natural heritage of the State by preserving the remaining natural forest with variety of flora and fauna, which represent the remarkable biological diversity and genetic resources of the country.

    iii) Checking soil erosion and denudation in the catchment areas of rivers, lakes, reservoir in the interest of soil and water conservation, for mitigating floods and droughts and for the retardation of siltation of reservoirs.

    iv) Checking the extension of sand-dunes into Haryana from areas of Rajasthan.

    v) Increasing substantially the Forest tree cover in the State through massive afforestation and Social Forestry Programmes, especially on all degraded and unproductive lands to create and sustain environmental stability.”

    5. Apart from the aforesaid activities, it has also been stated that the polythene bags required for raising seedlings are manufactured at Kurukshetra, Hissar and Mohindergarh by the Haryana Forest Development Corporation. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests in his affidavit has further stated that the forest department employs its organisational establishment on regular basis, whereas the vast labour force required for various forestry operations is engaged on daily-wage basis. The Saw Mills installed by the department are for demonstration purposes. By adopting radial sawing technique and solar seasoning technique, developed by Forest Research. Institute, Dehradu, Eucalyptus wood is being used as timber and in furniture making. He has further stated that a World Bank Aided Social Forestry Project was in operation in Haryana from the years 1982-1983 to 1990-1991. The affidavit further goes on to state that most of the work undertaken under the Social Forestry Project related to environment improvement, institution building and enrichment of natural resources of Panchayats/communities. It has been stated that the primary and essential duty of the forest department is to protect the forests and for this purpose, the officers/officials have been given powers enjoyed by the police officials and also been vested with some powers of the judicial Courts. Besides the regulatory functions of the department, the other work of afforestation and their maintenance under various projects/schemes is done for the purpose of improvement and maintaining of ecological balance and environmental stability, which is in the universal interest.

    6. On the basis of the affidavit and the basic objectives laid in the National Forest Policy, as adopted by the Department of Forests, State of Haryana, Counsel for the State submitted that under Articles 48-A of the Constitution it is the constitutional function of the State to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forest and wild-life of the country, and therefore, Department of Forests is not an ‘industry’. In support of his argument, counsel referred to the following observations of the Apex Court in Sub Divisional Inspector of Post, Vaikam etc. v. Theyyam Joseph etc.,1:

    “India as a sovereign socialist, secular democratic republic has to establish an egalitarian social order under rule of law. The welfare measures partake the character of sovereign functions and the traditional duty to maintain law and order is no longer the concept of the State. Directive principles of State Policy enjoin on the State diverse duties under Part IV of the Constitution and the performance of the duties are constitutional functions. One of the duty is of the State is to provide telecommunication service to the general public and an amenity, and is open essential part of the sovereign functions of the State as a welfare State. It is not, therefore, an industry.”

    7. Counsel also referred to a Division Bench judgment of this Court in State of Punjab through Assistant Director, Horticulture, Faridkot v. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Bhatinda,2 wherein the Horticulture Department has been held not to be an ‘industry’. Counsel further argued that every department of the State exercises sovereign functions and therefore, the forest department is outside the definition of word ‘industry’ to make the provisions of the Act inapplicable. In answer to these submissions, Mr. Puneet Bali, Advocate, for the Workman contended that the forest department is not discharging any sovereign functions of the State as its main activity involves plantation of trees, development of green lands and preservation of wild life and forests in the State. He contended that forest department has come to be known as one of the biggest revenue earner department in the State exchequer. He also contended that even if it is taken that the forest department is not making any profits, then also it is of no consequence because the activity carried on by the department is systematic and coordinated and bears resemblance to what is found in trade or business.

    8. It is true that the observations of the Apex Court in Theyyam Joseph's case (supra) do lend support to the argument of the counsel for the State, but having regard to the activities carried on by the Forest Department and the test laid down in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa,3 in our opinion, it cannot be said that the department of Forests, State of Haryana, is not an ‘industry’.

    9. In Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board's case (supra), their Lordships of the Supreme Court had considered the concept and scope of term ‘industry’ as used in Section 2(j) of the Act. Their Lordships observed as under:—

    “(1) ‘Industry’ as defined in the sub-section has a wide import.

    (a) Where (i) systematic activity, (ii) organised by co-operation between employer and employee (the direct and substantial element is chimerical), (iii) for the production and/or distribution of goods and services calculated to satisfy human wants and wishes (not spiritual or religious but inclusive of material things or services geared to celestial bliss), prima-facie there is an industry in the enterprise.

    (b) Absence of profit motive or gainful objective is irrelevant, be the venture in the public, joint, private or other sector.

    (c) The true focus is functional and the decisive test is the nature of the activity with special emphasis on the employer-employee relations.

    (d) If the organisation is a trade or business it does not cease to be one because of philanthropy animating the undertaking.

    (II) Although the sub-section uses the words of the widest amplitude in its two limbs, their meaning cannot be magnified to overreach itself.

    (a) ‘Undertaking’ must have a contextual and associated meaning as explained in Banerji's case; so also service, calling and the like. Hence all organised activity possession the triple elements of systematic activity, organised co-operation between employer and employee and production and distribution of goods and services calculated, to satisfy human wants and wishes, although not trade or business, may still be industry provided the nature of the activity, namely, the employer-employee basis bears resemblance to what is found in trade or business. This takes into the fold of industry, undertakings callings, services and adventures “analogous to the carrying on of trade or business”. All features other than the methodology of carrying on the activity, namely, in organising the co-operation between employer-employee may be dissimilar but it does not matter if on the employment terms there is analogy.

    (3) xxx xxx xxx

    (4) (a) Where a complex of activities some of which qualify for exemption and others not, involves employees on the total undertaking, some of whom are not workmen as in the University of Delhi case or some departments are not productive of goods and services if isolated, even then the predominant nature of the services and the integrated nature of the departments as explained in the Corporation of Nagpur case will be the true test. The whole undertaking will be industry although those are not workmen by definition may not benefit by the status.

    (b) Sovereign functions strictly understood alone qualify for exemption, not the welfare activities or economic adventures undertaken by Government or statutory bodies.

    (c) Even in departments discharging sovereign functions, if there are units which are industries and they are substantially severable then they can be considered to come within Section 2(j).

    (d) Constitutional and competently enacted legislative provisions may well remove from the scope of the Act categories which otherwise may be covered thereby.”

    10. Recently, a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court in Chief Conservator of Forests etc. etc. v. Jagannath Maruti Kondhare, etc. etc.,4 has held that the Forest Department of the State of Maharashtra is an ‘industry’ within the meaning of Section 2(j) of the Act. The Apex Court also held that Pachgaon Parwati Scheme framed as per the Government resolution based on the policy decision taken in April, 1976 cannot be regarded as a part of inalienable or inescapable function of the State for the reason that the Scheme was initiated even to fulfil the recreational and educational aspirations of the people. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court observed “we are in no doubt that such a work could well be undertaken by an agency which is not required to be even an instrumentality of the State”. In this judgment, their Lordships have stated that definition of ‘Industry’ is of very wide import and should be interpreted in a manner so as not to whittle down but to advance the object of the Act. In paragraphs 12 and 13, their Lordships stated:

    “12. We may not go by the lables. Let us reach the hub. And the same is that the dichotomy of sovereign and non-sovereign functions does not really exist - it would all depend on the nature of the power and manner of its exercise, as observed in para 23 of Nagendra Rao's case. As per the decision in this case, one of the tests of determine whether the executive function is sovereign in nature is to find out whether the State is answerable for such action in courts of law. It was stated by Sahai, J, that acts like defence of the country, raising armed forces and maintaining it, making peace or war, foreign affairs, power to acquire and retain territory, are functions which are indicative of external sovereignity and are political in nature. They are, therefore, not amenable to the jurisdiction of ordinary civil court inasmuch as the State is immune from being sued in such matters. But then, according to this decision the immunity ends there. It was then observed that in a welfare State, functions of the State are not only the defence of the country or administration of justice or maintaining law and order but extends to regulating and controlling the activities of people in almost every sphere, educational, commercial, social, economic, political and even marital. Because of this the demarcating line between sovereign and non-sovereign powers has largely disappeared.

    13. The aforesaid shows that if we were to extend the concept of sovereign function to include all welfare activities as contended on behalf of the appellants, the ratio in Bangalore Water-Supply case would get eroded, and substantially. We would demur to do so on the face what was stated in the aforesaid case according to which except the strictly understood sovereign function, welfare activities of the State would come within the purview of the definition of industry; and, not only this, even within the wider circle of sovereign function, there may be an inner circle encompassing some units which would be considered as industry if substantially severable.”

    11. It is, thus, clear from the test laid down by the Apex Court in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board's case (supra) and the observations of the Supreme Court in Jagannath Maruti Kondhare's case (supra) that sovereign functions strictly understood (alone) qualify for an exemption not the welfare activities or economic adventures undertaken by the Government or statutory bodies. Even in the government departments discharging sovereign functions, if there are units which are severable, then they can be considered to come within the meaning of ‘industry’ as given in Section 2(j) of the Act. Simply because the Forest department of the State of Haryana has a noble objective and has undertaken the Forest Development Projects, by no stretch of imagination it can be said that the forest department discharges sovereign functions to qualify for exemption. The fact that the forest department is engaged in activities which do not necessarily make profits, does not alter the fact that it employs workers like the second respondent and carries on systematic activities which provides services for satisfying human wants for having pollution-free environment. In our opinion, therefore, having regard to the activities carried on by the forest department in the light of the test laid down in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board's case, the forest department is an ‘industry’ as defined in Section 2(j) of the Act.

    12. The judgment of State of Punjab through Assistant Director, Horticulture, Faridkot's case (supra) is of no help to the State counsel as he has failed to bring on record the material on the basis of which the Division Bench had held that the Horticulture Department being a part and parcel of Agricultural Department is not an ‘industry’. In absence thereof, it cannot be said that the horticulture Department is at par with the forest department of Haryana or the activities carried on by the Horticulture or Agricultural Department are akin to the activities carried on by the forest department.

    13. In view of our finding that the forest department of the State of Haryana is an industry as defined in Section 2(j) and there being no challenge to the finding of Labour Court in regard to non-compliance of provisions of Section 25-F of the Act, the writ petitions, CWP No. 6882, 6888, 7993 and 17370 of 1991, 4950 and 14993 of 1992, 2604 of 1992 and 15079 of 1994 filed on behalf of the State of Haryana are to be dismissed. We do so, No costs.

    14. In Civil Writ Petition No. 12620 of 1993, as per case set out in the petition, petitioner therein was appointed as Typist in the Divisional Forest Office, Gurgaon, on daily wages on 20.3.1987 and continued in service till 11.2.1991 when he was removed from service and not allowed to join his duties without any reason. He inter-alia has prayed that respondents 1 to 4 be directed to reinstate him in service as after his removal respondents 5 and 6 were appointed without any offer being made to him for re-employment. In the written statement, the case of the official respondents is that the petitioner left the work on 31.12.1990 of his own and so, is not entitled to reinstatement. In the replication, petitioner has reiterated that he never left the service of his own will. Since disputed questions of fact have been raised in this petition and the petitioner has come to this Court without seeking an alternative remedy of reference for adjudication of the dispute, it is not a possible for this Court to give any relief prayed for in this writ petition. Accordingly, Civil Writ Petition No. 12620 of 1993 shall stand dismissed, with a liberty to the petitioner to seek a reference for adjudication of the dispute raised by him.

    Sd/- Iqbal Singh, J.

    R.M.S
    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Divisional Forest Of... v. Presiding Officer, I...
    (Jan 6, 1997)