Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Sections 302/364/34 Indian Penal Code
  • sections 201/34 Indian Penal Code
  • Section 364 I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Sections 302/364/34 Indian Penal Code
  • sections 201/34 Indian Penal Code
  • Section 364 I.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (P.K. Jain, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from the investigation of F.I.R. No. 43 registered on 6.4.1995 at Police Station City, Moga for offences under Sections 302/364/34 Indian Penal Code. Five persons were arrested as accused: Preet Mohinder Singh Jain, Raghu Nath Rai, Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi. Three separate bail applications were moved: one by Preet Mohinder Singh Jain (granted bail by Shri K.S. Uppal, Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot on 27.5.1995), a second by Raghu Nath Rai (rejected on 13.7.1995), and a third by the remaining three accused (Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi) (also rejected on 13.7.1995).

Petitioner Sunita filed Criminal Miscellaneous No. 14344-M of 1995 seeking bail and annexed the two orders (grant to Preet dated 27.5.1995 and rejection dated 13.7.1995). After perusal of those orders, this Court suo motu issued a notice to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain to show cause why the bail granted to him on 27.5.1995 should not be cancelled.

The prosecution alleges that Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai borrowed Rs. 2.5 lakhs from the deceased Dr. Subodh Singla, issued a cheque of Rs. 1 lakh which bounced, and thereafter the deceased was induced to accompany them to Chandigarh on 5.4.1995. The deceased's body was recovered from the rear seat of his Maruti car; Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi were found in the front seat. The prosecution alleges that Preet and Raghu hired the three others to murder and dispose of the body. Among recoveries, a cheque for Rs. 1 lakh (purportedly of Preet) and an attache case with deceased's clothes (from Raghu's house) were mentioned; Raghu is said to have made extra-judicial confessions implicating Preet and others.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the bail granted to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain by the Additional Sessions Judge on 27.5.1995 should be cancelled.
  2. Whether petitioner Sunita is entitled to bail in the circumstances of this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Sunita's) Arguments

  • Only specific allegation against Sunita is an alleged extra-judicial confession by Raghu Nath Rai which the Additional Sessions Judge did not accept while granting bail to Preet.
  • Other evidence is merely that Sunita was traveling with co-accused in the car from which the dead body was recovered; at most, an offence under Sections 201/34 IPC may be made out against her.
  • Therefore, she urged that Sunita be admitted to bail.

Counsel for Preet Mohinder Singh Jain

  • The order granting bail to Preet is based on facts and circumstances discussed in the 27.5.1995 order (Annexure P.2) and that once bail is granted it can be cancelled only for considerations germane to cancellation under Section 437(5) or Section 439(2) Cr.P.C.
  • Relied on para 11 of the Supreme Court judgment in Aslam Babalal Desai v. State of Maharashtra (1993) to support the point on cancellation and balancing liberty and public interest.
  • Argued that the extra-judicial confession by Raghu Nath Rai is not sufficient to implicate Sunita, and the FIR was recorded after deliberation and consultation suggesting a possible false implication.
  • Contended that the prosecution story (body being carried and intercepted as alleged) is highly improbable; hence bail cannot be cancelled in law.

State's Arguments (Deputy Advocate General for Punjab)

  • Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai are the main accused and there is evidence collected during investigation connecting them with the offences.
  • Petitioner Sunita and her co-accused were allegedly hired to assassinate the deceased and to dispose of the body; they were apprehended while carrying the body in the deceased's own Maruti car.
  • The Additional Sessions Judge did not exercise judicial discretion properly in granting bail to Preet; he ignored material evidence and based findings on surmise and conjecture.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State v. Captain Jagjit Singh, AIR 1962 S.C. 253 Lists various considerations to be taken into account when granting bail in non-bailable offences (nature and seriousness of offence, character of evidence, circumstances peculiar to accused, risk of absconding, tampering with witnesses, larger public interest, etc.). The Court cited these considerations as authoritative guidance for assessing bail in non-bailable offences and relied on them to judge whether bail should have been granted to Preet.
Gurcharan Singh v. Delhi Administration, (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 SC 179 Approval of the observations in State v. Captain Jagjit Singh regarding considerations for bail in non-bailable offences. The Court noted that the observations in Captain Jagjit Singh were approved in Gurcharan Singh and treated them as settled law to be applied in the present bail context.
Aslam Babalal Desai v. State of Maharashtra, (1992) 4 SCC 272 : AIR 1993 SC 1 (para 11) Emphasizes the need to balance individual liberty with the interests of administration of justice; cautions that over-solemn protection of accused's liberty can defeat public justice; pre-trial detention can be permissible to ensure administration of justice. Counsel for Preet relied on para 11. The Court referred to the principle to explain the correct balance to be struck between liberty and public interest, and considered it while assessing cancellation of bail and the appropriate exercise of judicial discretion.
Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, (1980) 2 SCC 559 : AIR 1980 SC 785 Warns that detailed examination of evidence and elaborate documentation of merits should be avoided while passing orders on bail applications; a prima facie satisfaction is required but not exhaustive exploration of merits. The Court held that the Additional Sessions Judge violated this principle by conducting a detailed examination of evidence and entering into surmises and conjectures when granting bail to Preet; this formed a central basis for cancelling that bail.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in several discrete steps, each grounded in the materials and authorities cited in the opinion:

  1. Initial procedural observation: This Court suo motu issued notice to Preet to show cause why his bail should not be cancelled after perusing the two orders (grant and rejection) produced in Sunita's petition.
  2. Evaluation of the Additional Sessions Judge's 27.5.1995 order: The Court found that the Additional Sessions Judge had engaged in a detailed examination of the prosecution's evidence, entered into conjectures and hypotheses, and reached positive findings as if at the final stage of trial. The Court described that approach as contrary to the Supreme Court's warning in Niranjan Singh that detailed merits should be avoided in bail orders.
  3. Independent consideration of the prosecution material: The Court perused the FIR and case diary and identified the principal circumstantial pieces of evidence collected against Preet Mohinder Singh Jain (enumerated as five discrete circumstances in the opinion):
    • Borrowing of Rs. 2.5 lakhs (motive) and issuance of a Rs. 1 lakh cheque that bounced.
    • The deceased accompanied Preet and Raghu from Moga to Chandigarh on 5.4.1995.
    • The dead body was recovered from the rear seat of the deceased's Maruti car while three co-accused were on the front seat.
    • The Rs. 1 lakh cheque was recovered from Preet's possession at the time of his arrest.
    • Raghu Nath Rai's extra-judicial confessions implicating Preet and the recovery of an attache case containing the deceased's clothes at Raghu's house.
  4. Prima facie conclusion on involvement and risk: On the basis of these circumstantial facts the Court concluded that prima facie Preet and Raghu are the main accused, had motive, were last seen with the deceased, and there was a possibility that Preet could tamper with evidence if at large. The Court specifically stated that the extra-judicial confession by Raghu cannot be brushed aside at this stage.
  5. Assessment of judicial exercise of discretion: The Court found that the Additional Sessions Judge had exercised discretion in an arbitrary and whimsical manner while granting bail to Preet, contradicting his own later order rejecting bail to other accused on similar facts. The Court held that the Additional Sessions Judge had misdirected himself by treating improbable aspects of prosecution story differently between the two orders.
  6. Conclusion on cancellation: Because the grant of bail to Preet was based on an erroneous exercise of judicial discretion contrary to established principles (as set out in authorities like Captain Jagjit Singh, Gurcharan Singh, Aslam Babalal Desai and Niranjan Singh), the Court concluded that it had the power to cancel that bail and that cancellation was warranted on the facts.
  7. Decision on Sunita's bail petition: Considering that Sunita was intercepted while traveling in the car containing the dead body, and was implicated by Raghu's extra-judicial confession, the Court found no justification to grant bail to Sunita at this stage.
  8. Administrative direction: The Court also directed that the trial should not be conducted by Shri K.S. Uppal, Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot; if already assigned, the Sessions Judge, Faridkot should withdraw the case to his own file for trial.

Holding and Implications

Core Holdings:

  • Sunita's bail application is rejected. The Court found that, on the material before it, there is no justification to grant bail to Sunita at this stage.
  • The bail granted to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain on 27.5.1995 is cancelled. The Court directed that he surrender to judicial custody before the Sessions Judge, Faridkot.
  • The trial should not be conducted by Shri K.S. Uppal, Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot. If the trial has been assigned to him, it should be withdrawn to the Sessions Judge's own file for trial.

Implications:

The direct effects of the decision are (1) denial of bail to Sunita, (2) cancellation of bail previously granted to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain with a direction for surrender to custody, and (3) reassignment (or withdrawal) of the trial away from the Additional Sessions Judge who granted the earlier bail. The Court emphasized adherence to authoritative principles governing bail in non-bailable offences (balancing individual liberty with the administration of justice and avoiding detailed merits assessment in bail orders). The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent; rather it applies and enforces established Supreme Court guidance to the facts before it.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the opinion provided and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

    Sunita v. State Of Punjab .

    P.K Jain, J.:— During the investigation of F.I.R No. 43 registered on 6.4.1995 at Police Station City Moga for the offences under Sections 302/364/34 Indian Penal Code the investigating agency arrested five persons as accused, i.e Preet Mohinder Singh Jain, Raghu Nath Rai, Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi. Three bail applications were moved by the accused persons i.e one by Preet Mohinder Singh Jain, which was decided on 27.5.1995 by Shri K.S Uppal, Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot and he was granted bail, second one by Raghu Nath Rai and the third one by the remaining three accused, both of these applications were rejected by the same Additional Sessions Judge vide order dated 13.7.1995 Accused Sunita has approached this Court seeking bail by filing a petition Criminal Miscellaneous No. 14344-M of 1995. She has annexed P.1 the order dated 13.7.1995 whereby the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot has rejected her application including the three others, as well as copy of the order dated 27.5.1995 (Annexure P.2) whereby Preet Mohinder Singh Jain has been granted bail by the same Additional Sessions Judge. During the course of hearing of the application moved on behalf of Sunita, after a perusal of the two orders Annexures P 1 and P.2, this Court of its own motion issued a notice to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain to show cause why not bail granted to him vide order dated 27.5.1995 be cancelled.

    2. The prosecution story in brief is that Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai contractors, had friendly relations with the deceased Doctor Subodh Singla. These two accused had borrowed a sum of Rs. 2.5 lacs from the deceased with a promise to return the same within a short time. When the deceased visited Chandigarh and asked these accused to return the loan amount, they postponed the same on one pretext or the other. Ultimately a cheque of Rs. 1 lac dated 31.1.1995 favouring Doctor Subodh Singla issued by Preet Mohinder Singh Jain was handed over to the deceased but according to the information received from the bank there were not sufficient funds in the account of the said accused to honour the said cheque. On a message sent by the deceased, both the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath came to the house of the deceased in Moga on 5.4.1995 and they asked the deceased to accompany them to Chandigarh so that the cheque may be honoured with an assurance that there were sufficient funds in the account and there was some erroneous information given to him. Ashok Bansal, brother-in-law of the deceased present there, expressed his reluctance and advised the deceased not to go with these accused but the deceased accompanied these two accused persons in his own Maruti car bearing No. PB 04 9293. Since the deceased did not come back F.I.R under Section 364 I.P.C was got registered by the wife of the deceased on 6.4.1995 at Police Station City, Moga. The aforesaid Maruti vehicle was intercepted by the police party on Ludhiana-Kotkapura byepass and from the rear seat dead body of Dr. Subodh Singla was recovered. On the front seat three accused Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi were found sitting. During investigation, it was revealed that the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath hired Suraj Parkash, his wife Sunita and Gyatri Devi to commit murder of Doctor-Subddh Singla and to dispose of the dead body. On interrogation of accused Raghu Nath an attache case belonging to the deceased and containing the wearing clothes of the deceased was recovered from the house of the said accused. From the possession of accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain the aforesaid cheque of Rs. 1 lac was recovered. Accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai are alleged to have made extra judicial confession before Jagdish Pal Singh, Krishan Kumar and Parveen Kumar.

    3. While accepting the application of the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and grating bail to him, the Additional Sessions Judge discussed the various aspects of the perosecution in details and gave positive findings as if he was recording a judgment at the final stage. In his order running into 11 pages the said Additional Sessions Judge has given a categorical finding that the First Information Report has been ante-timed that the story of the prosecution that the dead body was recovered from the aforesaid vehicle from its rear seat while three accused were sitting on the front seat when the car was being brought from Chandigarh to Moga, is highly unnatural, that the allegations of the prosecution that the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath made extra judicial confession before Jagdish Pal Singh or any other person, does not inspire confidence as there was no occasion for these accused to do so, that the cheque dated 31.1.1995 appears to have been planted by the police and could not be recovered from accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain, and as such the story set up by the prosecution is quite unnatural. With these findings the Additional Sessions Judge allowed the application of the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and granted bail to him vide order dated 27.5.1995

    4. However while dealing with the application of the accused Raghu Nath as well as the application of the remaining three accused person's Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi, the same Additional Sessions Judge while placing reliance upon the alleged extra judicial confession made by Raghu Nath before Jagdish Pal Singh, Krishan Kumar and Parveen Kumar, recovery of the attache case containing the clothes of the deceased from the house of accused Raghu Nath, the recovery of the dead body from the rear seat of Maruti car in which remaining three accused were sitting on the front seat came to the conclusion that all these four accused are involved in conspiracy whereby heinous crime of murder of Doctor Subodh Singla was committed and as such their bail applications were rejected vide order dated 13.7.1995

    5. I have heard Shri R.S Ghai, Senior Advocate being assisted by Shri Bipan Ghai, Advocate for the petitioner Sunita, Shri P.S Hundal, Advocate for Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Shri A.R Sidhu, Deputy Advocate General for the State of Punjab.

    6. Shri R.S Ghai, Senior Advocate the learned counsel for petitioner Sunita has argued that qua this petitioner there is only alleged extra-judicial confession made by Raghu Nath Rai which has not been believed by the Additional Sessions Judge while deciding the bail application of the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain. It has been further argued by the learned counsel that the other piece of evidence collected during investigation against this petitioner is that she was travelling alongwith her co-accused in the Maruti car from the rear seat of which dead body of the deceased was recovered and as such at the most an offence under sections 201/34 Indian Penal Code can be said to have been made out against her. Thus it has been urged that the petitioner may be admitted to bail.

    7. Shri P.S Hundal, Advocate-learned counsel for Preet Mohinder Singh Jain has argued that the order passed by the Additional Sessions Judge granting bail to this accused is based on the facts and circumstances of the case as discussed in the order dated 27.5.1995 (Annexure P.2). It has further been contended that once bail has been granted to an acused person the same can be cancelled only for considerations germane to cancellation of bail under section 437(5) or for that matter Section 439(2). The learned counsel has placed reliance on para 11 of the judgment of the apex Court rendered in Aslam Babalal Desai v. State Of Maharashtra., 1993 (1) Recent Criminal Reports 600 : (1992) 4 SCC 272 : AIR 1993 S.C 1. It has also been pointed out by the learned counsel that the extra judicial confession alleged to have been made by Raghu Nath Rai in itself is not enough to implicate the petitioner in the commision of the offences in question and that the First Information Report was recorded after due deliberations and consultations so as to implicate the petitioner falsely. It has also been pointed out by the learned counsel that the story of the prosecution that the dead body of the deceased was being carried in the Maruti vehicle and was intercepted on Ludhiana-Kotkapura byepass, is highly improbable in nature andas such the bail granted to the said accused cannot be cancelled in the eye of law.

    8. On the other hand learned Deputy Advocate General Punjab has argued that Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai are the main accused and there exists evidence collected during investigation to connect them with the commission of the offences is question. It has also been pointed out by the learned State counsel that petitioner Sunita alongwith her two co-accused were hired for the asassinatiaon of the deceased Subodh Singla and then to dispose of his dead body, and that Sunita and her two co-accused were apprehended while carrying the body of the deceased in the Maruti car owned by the deceased itself. The learned Deputy Advocate General has further contended that the Additional Sessions Judge did not exercise his discretion in a judicial manner while granting bail to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain although the said accused is one of the prime accused in this case. It has also been pointed out that the Additional Sessions Judge ignored the real evidence collected during investigation and discussed certain other aspects of the prosecution on surmises and conjectures.

    9. I have given my careful thought to the respective arguments advanced at the Bar.

    10. It may be stated at the outset that the principles for granting or refusal of bail in non-bailable cases have been laid down by their Lordships of the Supreme Court of India from time to time. In State v. Captain Jagjit Singh, AIR 1962 S.C 253, while setting aside order of the High Court granting bail their Lordships made the following observations:—

    “It (the High Court) should then have taken into account the various considerations, such as, nature and seriousness of the offence, the character of the evidence, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused, a reasonable possibility of the presence of the accused not being secured at the trial, reasonabel apprehension of witnesses being tampered with, the larger interests of the public or the State and similar other considerations, which arise when a Court is asked for bail in a non-bailable offence. It is true that under Section 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the powers of the High Court in the matter of granting bail are very wide, even so where the offence is non-bailable, various considerations such as those indicated above have to be taken into account before bail is granted in a non-bailable offence.”

    11. The aforesaid observations were approved by their Lordships in a subsequent case Gurcharan Singh v. Delhi Administration, (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 SC 179. In Aslam Babalal Deasai's case (supra), his Lordship Hon'ble Mr. Justice A.M Ahmadi (now Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India) pointed out that the paramount consideration must be to balance the neeed to safeguard individual liberty and to protect the interest of administration of justice so as to prevent its failure. Oversolicitous homage to the criminal defendant's liberty can sometimes defeat the cause of public justice. In some quarters, a feeling seems to exist that the object of criminal law is to protect the rights of the accused and that criminal justifiying system is envisioned as a sentinel of the rights of the accused. It is not so. The law is the sentinel of rights of the society and of the individual. The rights of the criminal defendant will be as zealously guarded as the cause of public justice. Pre-trial detention in itself is not an evil nor opposed to the basic presumptions of innocence. Ensuring security and order is a permissible non-punitive objective which can be achieved by pre-trial detention.

    12. Before proceeding further it is just and proper to point out that while passing order dated 27.5.1995 whereby bail has been granted to the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain, the Additional Sessions Judge has discussed the entire prosecution evidence in minutest details and has entered in an arena of conjectures and hypothesis. He has gone beyond mere discussing the factual aspects and appreciated the prosecution case in depth as if he was recording a judgment at the final stage of the trial. A note of caution was sounded by their Lordships of the Supreme Court of India in Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, (1980) 2 SCC 559 : AIR 1980 SC 785 in the following words:—

    “Detailed examination of the evidence and elaborate documentation of the merits of the case should be avoided while passing the orders on bail applications. No party should have the impression that his case has been prejudiced. To be satisfied about a prima facie case is needed but it is not the same as an exhaustive exploration of the merits in the order itself.”

    13. Therefore, it is evident that while passing order dated 27.5.1995 the Additional Sessions Judge entered in the arena of surmises and conjectures contrary to the principles laid down by the apex Court in the aforesaid case of Niranjan Singh.

    14. I have perused the First Information Report and have also gone through the case diary relating to the investigation of this case. Admittedly this case is based on circumstantial evidence. The prosecution, could collect the following circumstances against the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain:—

    (1) That this accused alongwith Raghu Nath Rai had borrowed a sum of Rs. 2,50,000/- from the deceased. This accused issued a cheque for Rs. 1,00,000/- being part payment of this loan but there were no sufficient funds in the bank account of this accused to honour that cheque.

    (2) That at the asking of Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and his co-accused Raghu Nath Rai the deceased accompanied them in his own Maruti car from Moga to Chandigarh on 5.4.1995

    (3) That the dead body of the deceased was recovered from the rear set of his Maruti car while the three co-accused Suraj Parkash, Sunita and Gyatri Devi were found sitting on the front seat thereof.

    (4) That a cheque of Rs. 1 lac stated to have been issued by the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain towards part payment was recovered from the possession at the time of his arrest.

    (5) That his co-accused Raghu Nath Rai made an extra-judicial confession before three different persons to the effect that he alongwith Preet Mohinder Singh Jain had hired the remaining three accused to do away with Doctor Subodh Singla and then to dispose of his dead body. In pursuance to his disclosure statement, an attache case containing the clothes of the deceased were recovered from his house.

    15. The aforesaid circumstances prima facie go to show that Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai are the main accused. Prima facie they had the motive to do away with the deceased. They were the persons with whom the deceased was last seen inasmuch as he had travelled with them from Moga in his Maruti car. Cheque for Rs. 1 lac stated to have been issued by accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain has also been recovered from his possession. Extra judicial confession stated to have been made by Raghu Nath Rai cannot be brushed aside at this stage. All these circumstances go to make out prima facie case regarding the involvement of the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain in the commission of the offences in question. It is also important to note that if the story of the perosecution that the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain and Raghu Nath Rai had hired the other three accused to do away with the deceased then to dispose of his dead body, is found to be true, then there is every apprehension that accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain may also tamper with the evidence of the prosecution.

    16. The Additional Sessions Judge has exercised his judicial discretion while granting bail to accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain in an arbitrary and whimsical manner contrary to the well established, principles for grant or refusal of bail in non-bailable cases. The order dated 27.5.1995 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge while granting bail to Preet Mohinder Singh Jain is directly in contradiction with the order dated 13.7.1995 whereby the same Additional Sessions Judge refused bail to Raghu Nath and three other co-accused. All those very facts which are alleged to be unnatural and highly improbable while discussing bail application of accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain, have been relied upon by the Additional, Sessions Judge while rejecting bail application of the remaining accused. Thus the Additional Sessions Judge completely misdirected himself while granting bail to the accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jam. It cannot be disputed that this court has got the powers to cancel the bail of an accused where Sessions Judge has exercised his judicial discretion in erroneous manner-contrary to the well established principles governing grant or refusal of bail in non-bailable cases. Accordingly bail granted to accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain is required to be cancelled.

    17. As regards the application filed on behalf of accused Sunita, the case of the prosecution is that she alongwith other two co-accused was hired to do away with the deceased and to dispose of his body. She alongwith her two co-accused were intercepted while travelling in the same Maruti car in which the dead body of the deceased was found on the rear seat. Extra judicial confession stated to have been made by the co-accused Raghu Nath Rai implicates her directly in the commission of the offences in question. Therefore, I do not find any justification to grant bail even to Sunita at this stage.

    18. For the reasons mentioned above the application filed by Sunita seeking bail, is hereby rejected. Bail granted to accused Preet Mohinder Singh Jain vide order dated 27.5.1995 is hereby cancelled and he is directed to surrender to the judicial custody before the Sessions Judge, Faridkot.

    19. In view of the reasons stated above, it is desirable that the present case shall not be tried by Sh. K.S Uppal, Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot. If this trial has been assigned to the said Court, the case shall be withdrawn by the Sessions Judge, Faridkot, to his own file for trial.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sunita v. State Of Punjab .
    (Oct 20, 1995)