M.R Agnihotri, J.:— Municipal Committee, Sunam, District Sangrur writ petitioner before us, appointed Tarsem Singh, respondent No. 2 as Driver on 14th October, 1982, on probation for one year. Later on his services were terminated on 7th November, 1983, by passing the following order:
“Tarsem Singh Driver, who was appointed for one year probation period and his work was not found satisfactory his probation period was extended for one more year vide resolution No. 124, dated 15.9.83 But Shri Tarsem Singh has not performed his duties properly and it has been done in an irresponsible manner and with indiscipline. Now vide office Resolution No. 156, dated 7.11.83, the services of Shri Tarsem/Singh S/o Bakhtaur Singh driver are terminated from the date of resolution.
Executive Officer,
Municipal Committee, Sunam.
Aggrieved by this, the respondent workman raised industrial dispute before the Labour Court, Patiala, and by award dated 3rd November, 1988, the Labour Court ordered reinstatement of the respondent with continuity of service and full back wages. The Municipal Committee has come up in writ petition challenging the award mainly on the ground that services of the respondent-workman could be terminated during the probation period.”
2. We have heard the learned Counsel and have gone through the award of the Labour Court.
3. The view taken by the Labour Court that the impugned award of termination of services of the workman was not an order simplicitor but in fact it has stigmatized the career of the workman, is in accordance with law, and we endorse the same. No opportunity whatsoever was submitted to the respondent workman before stigmatizing the career of the workman by observing in the order that “Shri Tarsem Singh has not performed his duties properly and it has been done in an irresponsible manner and with indiscipline.”
4. Mr. G.S Sandhawalia, Learned Counsel for the petitioner Municipal Committee, has invited our attention to various judgments, to support his contention that such an order did not amount to imposition of stigma and the services could be terminated without affording an opportunity to the workman, that is, AIR 1958 SC 36 Parshotam Lal Dhingra v. Union Of India,); 1975 (2) SLR 483 Guru Nanak University, Amritsar v. Dr. (Mrs.) Iqbal Kaur Sandhu; 1989 (1) Recent Services Judgments 573 Bhupinderpal Singh v. Oriental Bank of Commerce and 1992 (2) Recent services Judgments 308 (Shri Baikuntha Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer, Baripada).
5. We have gone through the above judgments but no help can be drawn from these judgments.
6. Accordingly, this petition stands dismissed. No costs.
7. Petition dismissed.