AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 40 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 40 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. challenged the validity of an order dated December 21, 1989, passed by the Assessing Authority, Jalandhar - I, for the Assessment Year 1986-87. The Assessing Authority had found that the petitioner was engaged in the sale of L.P.G. in cylinders and the sale and purchase of L.P.G. was inseparable from the supply of cylinders and regulators, which were integral and incidental to the transaction. The petitioner disputed this finding. The respondents raised a preliminary objection that the petitioner had an equally efficacious statutory remedy by way of appeal and that prior writ petitions challenging earlier assessment years had been dismissed, emphasizing the need to exhaust statutory remedies before invoking constitutional writ jurisdiction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the supply of cylinders and regulators is integral and incidental to the sale/purchase of L.P.G. for the purpose of tax assessment.
  2. Whether the petitioner can invoke writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution without exhausting statutory remedies provided under the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973.
  3. Whether Section 25(5) of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973, is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  4. Whether the petitioner’s appeal against the Assessing Authority’s order is barred by limitation and if any relief can be granted in this context.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner challenged the Assessing Authority’s finding that the supply of cylinders and regulators is integral to the sale of L.P.G., contending that this finding was unwarranted.
  • The petitioner contended that Section 25(5) of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, though no foundation or substantiation was laid out in the writ petition.
  • The petitioner argued that the judgment in the earlier writ petition would not operate as res judicata for the current assessment year since a fresh cause of action arises each year.
  • The petitioner submitted that the appeal against the Assessing Authority’s order had become time barred.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The respondents contended that the petitioner had an equally efficacious statutory remedy by way of appeal under the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973, which must be exhausted before invoking writ jurisdiction under Article 226.
  • They relied on earlier dismissals of writ petitions by the Division Bench, emphasizing the statutory scheme of hierarchical appeals under the Act.
  • The respondents offered a concession that if the petitioner filed an appeal within thirty days from the receipt of the judgment, the plea of limitation would not be raised and the appellate authority would entertain and dispose of the appeal on merits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. and Anr. v. State of Orissa and Anr., U.J (S.C) 1983 Page 503 Hierarchy of statutory remedies and requirement to exhaust them before invoking writ jurisdiction under Article 226. Supported the court's decision to decline interference until statutory remedies are exhausted.
Wolverhampton New Water Works Co. v. Hawkesford, (1959) 6 CB (NS) 336 at p.356 Where a statute creates a liability and provides a special remedy, that statutory remedy must be followed exclusively. Reinforced the principle that statutory remedies must be exhausted before seeking writ relief.
Nevile v. London Newspaper Ltd., (1919) A.C. 368 Approval of the rule that statutory remedies must be followed when provided. Affirmed the principle applied by the High Court in dismissing writ petitions without exhausting statutory appeals.
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v. Gordon Grant and Co., (1935) A.C. 532 Reaffirmation of the exclusivity of statutory remedies for enforcement of rights created by statute. Supported the court's insistence on pursuing statutory appeals before writ petitions.
Secretary of State v. Mask and Co., A.I.R. (1940) P.C. 105 Applicability of statutory remedy exclusivity to enforcement of rights. Used to justify dismissal of writ petitions in favor of statutory appeal mechanisms.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the petitioner’s challenge to the Assessing Authority’s finding regarding the integral nature of cylinders and regulators to the sale of L.P.G. Instead, it focused on procedural propriety, emphasizing that the petitioner had an equally efficacious statutory remedy by way of appeal under the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973. The court relied on prior judgments which established that when a statute creates rights and provides specific remedies, those remedies must be exhausted before seeking relief under Article 226 of the Constitution. The court noted that earlier writ petitions by the petitioner had been dismissed on this ground and that the petitioner had not challenged those dismissals before the Supreme Court. Although the petitioner argued that the limitation period for appeal had expired, the court directed that if an appeal was filed within thirty days of receiving the judgment, limitation would not be a bar and the appeal would be entertained on merits. The court thus declined to exercise its extraordinary writ jurisdiction, underscoring the statutory scheme for challenging assessment orders and the necessity to exhaust those remedies first.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is DISPOSED OF on the basis that the petitioner must exhaust the statutory remedies available under the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 before invoking writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. The court held that the petitioner’s appeal against the Assessing Authority’s order may still be entertained if filed within thirty days from receipt of the judgment, notwithstanding any prior limitation issues, and directed expeditious disposal of pending appeals by the appellate authority.

The decision does not set a new precedent but reiterates the established principle that statutory remedies must be pursued before seeking constitutional writ relief. The direct effect is that the petitioner must follow the statutory appellate process, and the writ petition is dismissed without adjudicating the substantive tax issues.

    Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. The State Of Punjab And Others

    1. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. has challenged the validity of the order dated December 21, 1989, passed by the Assessing Authority, Jalandhar - I, for the Assessment Year 1986-87.

    2. Challenge has been made to the finding of the Assessing Authority that the petitioner-Corporation is engaged in the sale of L.P.G. in cylinders and sale and purchase of L.P.G. and its enjoyment is not possible without cylinders and regulators. Therefore, the supply of cylinders and regulators is integral and incidental to the transaction of sale/purchase of L.P.G. The counsel maintains that this finding is not warranted.

    3. We are not inclined to express any opinion on the merits of the submission made.

    4. Learned counsel for the respondents has raised a preliminary objection that the petitioner-corporation has got an equally efficacious remedy by way of appeal. The petitioner-Corporation challenged the order of the Assessing Authority for the Assessment Year 1984-85 decided on June 13, 1989 through CWP No. 8495 of 1989. The same was dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court on June 23, 1989, observing thus :-

    "No ground to interfere in view of our judgment rendered in C.W.P. No. 7880 of 1989 dated June 23, 1989. Dismissed. However, the petitioner shall avail the statutory remedy available against the order of the Assessing Authority."

    In C.W.P. No. 7880 of 1989, the petitioner-Corporation had challenged the order of the revisional authority Under Section 40 of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 and a Division bench of this Court declined to entertain the writ petition observing thus:-

    " The petitioner has an equally efficacious remedy by way of an appeal Under Section 39 of the Act. When a right or liability is created by a statute which itself prescribes the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right or liability, resort must be had to that particular statutory remedy before seeking the discretionary remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution, The question arising for determination depends upon appreciation of evidence. We decline to interfere in the matter until all the statutory remedies are exhausted. It will be useful to refer to the dictum laid down by the Apex Court in Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. and Anr. v. State of Orissa and Anr., U.J (S.C) 1983 Page 503, which reads as under:-

    Under the Scheme of the Act, there is a hierarchy of authorities before which the petitioners can get adequate redress against the wrongful acts complained of. The petitioners have the right to prefer an appeal before the prescribed authority Under Sub-section (1) of Section 23 of the Act. If the petitioners are dissatisfied with the decision in the appeal, they can prefer a further appeal to the Tribunal Under Sub-section (3) of Section 23 of the Act, and then as for a case to be stated upon a question of law for the opinion of the High Court Under Section 24 of the Act, The Act provides for a complete machinery to challenge an order of assessment, and the impugned orders of assessment can only be challenged by the mode prescribed by the Act and not by a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. It is now well recognised that where a right or liability is created by a statute which gives a special remedy for enforcing it, the remedy provided by that statute only must be availed of. This rule was stated with great clarity by Willis, J. in Wolverhampton New Water Works Co. v. Hawkesford, (1959) 6 CB (NS)336 at p.356, in the following passage:-

    " There are three classes in which a liability may be established founded upon statute. xx xxx xxx xxx xxx But there is a third class, viz,. where a liability not existing at common law is created by a statute which at the same time given a special and particular remedy for enforcing it. xxx xxx xxx, the remedy provided by the statute must be followed., and it is not competent to the party to pursue course applicable to cases of second class. The form given by the statute must be adopted and adhered to."

    The rule laid down in this passage was approved by the House of Lords in Nevile v. London Newspaper Ltd. (1919) A.C. 368 and has been reaffirmed by the Privy Council in Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v. Gordon Grant and Co. (1935) A.C. 532 and Secretary of State v. Mask and Co., A.I.R. (1940) P.C. 105: It has also been held to be equally applicable to enforcement of rights, and has been followed by this Court througout. The High Court was therefore justified in dismissing the writ petition in limine."

    The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that Section 25(5) of the Act is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. He has not laid any foundation in the writ petition as to how the provisions are violative of Article 14 of the Constitution nor he could substantiate the same during the course of his arguments. We decline to interfere until all the statutory remedies are exhausted."

    5. We do not find any distinguishing features in the instant petition. It is not disputed that the judgment tendered in C.W.P. No. 8495 of 1989 was not assailed by the corporation in the apex Court. The learned counsel submits that the said judgment will not operate as res judicata as during each assessment year a fresh cause of action arises, to the petitioner. There can be no quarrel with this proposition. We decline to exercise our extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution for simple reason that the petitioner Corporation has got an equally efficacious remedy by way of appeal/revision under the Act.

    6. Learned counsel then submitted that the appeal against the order of the Assessing Authority had become time barred. If the petitioner-Corporation files an appeal against the order of the Assessing Authority within thirty days from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment, the respondents will not raise the plea of limitation and the appellate authority will entertain the appeal and dispose of the same on merits, provided the conditions for filing the appeal are fulfilled by the petitioner. It is further directed that the appellate authority will dispose of the appeals pending before it expeditiously.

    7. For the reasons stated above, the writ petition is disposed of as indicated above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. The State Of Punjab And Others
    (Jan 3, 1994)