AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 1.3 (P. 1),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 1.3 (P. 1),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner applied for admission to the Bachelor of Veterinary Sciences & Animal Husbandry (B.V.Sc. & A.H.) degree course at Haryana Agricultural University, Hissar, in 1979. The University had an admission rule (Rule 1.3) prescribing reservations in specified percentages for various categories, including 35% reserved for "Children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas", 20% for Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes, 5% for Backward Classes, 2% for children of University employees, and other categories.

Having failed to secure admission from the open quota, the petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the reservations in Rule 1.3 as violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution and sought a direction that he be admitted to the 1979 B.V.Sc. & A.H. course. The Registrar of the University filed a written statement defending the constitutional validity of the reservations.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the 35% reservation for "Children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas" is violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the aggregate effect of the reservations (as specified in Rule 1.3) — in particular the combination of 35% (rural), 20% (SC/ST), 5% (Backward Classes), and other reserved percentages — results in aggregate reservations exceeding 50% and thereby violates constitutional principles (relying on Ramesh Chander Garg).
  3. Whether the 2% reservation for children of University employees is constitutionally valid.
  4. Remedial question: If some reservations are invalid, what relief (if any) should be granted to the petitioner given the passage of time since 1979?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The 35% reservation for children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas violates Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution. Reliance was placed on a Division Bench decision in Kumari Promila Jain v. State of Haryana (C.W.P. No. 3371 of 1978, decided February 26, 1979), where a similar reservation for rural candidates was struck down.
  • The aggregate reservations (including 35% rural, 20% SC/ST, 5% Backward classes, etc.) exceed 50%, which according to Ramesh Chander Garg v. State of Punjab is constitutionally impermissible; therefore the impugned reservation cannot be sustained on this ground as well.
  • The 2% reservation for children of University employees is unconstitutional. Reliance was placed on Ajay Kumar v. Chandigarh Administration (AIR 1988 Punjab & Har) and related precedents (including Prasanna Kumar Sohail and Umesh Chandra Sithia) that held reservations in favor of wards of the institution/university employees to be invalid.

University's Arguments (Respondents)

  • The reservations made under Rule 1.3 are constitutionally valid and not violative of Articles 14 and 15.
  • Specifically, the 35% reservation is justified under "Cl(4) of Article 15" (as stated in the record) and is not violative of "Article 1 of the Constitution" (as described in the University’s submissions). The University argued that the rural sector targeted by the reservation is a socially and educationally backward segment that can be treated as a distinct class for Article 14 purposes and therefore deserves special treatment in admissions.
  • The University relied on the decision in Amar Bir Singh v. Maharishi Dayanand University, Rohtak (reported citations in the record) where a reservation for candidates from rural areas was upheld; it submitted that the impugned reservation in the present case is sustainable on similar grounds.
  • Practical/operative contention: some or all of the impugned reservations are "no more in vogue" and, the University contended, in the absence of the 35% reservation the petitioner would have secured admission in 1979 on merits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kumari Promila Jain v. State of Haryana (C.W.P. No. 3371 of 1978; decided Feb 26, 1979) Division Bench struck down a reservation for students from rural areas when certain eligibility conditions (parental name in village electoral roll, parent engaged in cultivation, candidate received primary education in a village school) were prescribed. The court found the impugned 35% reservation similar in substance to the reservation struck down in this decision and treated the Division Bench decision as a binding precedent applicable to invalidate the 35% reservation in the present case.
Amar Bir Singh v. Maharishi Dayanand University, Rohtak (reported in ILR and Punj & Har citations in record) Upheld reservation for candidates from rural areas where eligibility required education up to 8th standard in a common rural village; distinguished on facts from Kumari Promila Jain. The court held that Amar Bir Singh's reservation scheme was materially different and therefore its ratio could not be used to sustain the impugned 35% reservation in the present case.
Ramesh Chander Garg v. State of Punjab (AIR 1966 Punjab 476) Principle that aggregate reservations in favor of weaker sections should not, in the aggregate, exceed 50% of available seats; reservations exceeding 50% are invalid. The court accepted the petitioner's contention based on this authority and held that the impugned reservation could not be sustained on the ground that the aggregate reservations exceeded 50%.
Ajay Kumar v. Chandigarh Administration (Union Territory, Chandigarh) (AIR 1988 Punjab & Har) Held reservations in favour of wards/children of the institution's employees (wards of university employees) to be unconstitutional/invalid (as applied/following earlier precedents). The court applied this line of authority (including Prasanna Kumar Sohail and Umesh Chandra Sithia) to hold that the 2% reservation for children of University employees is unconstitutional and that the petitioner's challenge in this respect must prevail.
Prasanna Kumar Sohail v. Director-in-charge, Laxminarayan Institute of Technology, Nagpur (AIR 1982 Bom 176) View that reservations in favour of wards of the institution are unconstitutional. Cited as an antecedent authority followed in Ajay Kumar; used to support the conclusion that the 2% reservation for university employees' children is invalid.
Umesh Chandra Sithia v. V.N. Singh (AIR 1968, cited in record) Similar view on invalidity of reservations for wards of the institution/university employees (Full Bench reference in record). Referred to and relied upon to sustain the conclusion that reservations for wards of university employees are unconstitutional.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by direct comparison of the eligibility conditions prescribed by the impugned 35% reservation and those considered in Kumari Promila Jain. The impugned rule required that a candidate (a) have passed Primary, Middle or Matriculation from a village school, and (b) have his father's name in the village voters' list or revenue records showing landholding in the rural area.

The court identified that these two conditions correspond substantially to the conditions in Kumari Promila Jain (parent's name in village electoral roll; parent engaged in cultivation or allied village activities; candidate received at least primary education in a village school). Because the facts and eligibility criteria of the impugned reservation were similar in substance to those in Kumari Promila Jain, and because that Division Bench decision struck down such a reservation, the court concluded that the impugned 35% reservation could not be sustained and must be declared constitutionally invalid.

The court distinguished Amar Bir Singh on the basis that the conditions in that case differed materially (e.g., education up to 8th standard in a common rural village and different certification requirements). Consequently, the ratio of Amar Bir Singh could not be invoked to support the impugned reservation.

Separately, the court considered the aggregate effect of the reservation scheme. The petitioner argued that the combined reservations (including 35% rural, 20% SC/ST and 5% Backward Classes, among others) resulted in aggregate reservations in excess of 50%, contrary to the principle stated in Ramesh Chander Garg. The court agreed that the impugned reservation could not be sustained on this ground as well.

On the 2% reservation for children of University employees, the court accepted the petitioner's reliance on Ajay Kumar, Prasanna Kumar Sohail, and Umesh Chandra Sithia, which hold that reservations in favour of wards of the institution (or of university employees) are unconstitutional. The court therefore held that the challenge to that reservation must prevail.

As to remedy, the court took practical considerations into account: the challenged reservations applied to admissions in 1979 and many of the students admitted under those reservations would by now have completed the course. The court found it futile and inappropriate to quash past admissions; it therefore granted a forward-looking, limited remedy to the petitioner. Specifically, the court directed the University to allow the petitioner admission in the forthcoming B.V.Sc. & A.H. course on the basis of his 1979 merit, if he so chooses.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition is allowed to the extent that the Haryana Agricultural University authorities are directed to admit the petitioner to the forthcoming B.V.Sc. & A.H. course on the basis of his 1979 merit, if he so desires. No order as to costs.

Other conclusions and direct effects on the impugned provisions:

  • The impugned 35% reservation for "Children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas" was held to be constitutionally invalid because it is similar in substance to the reservation struck down in Kumari Promila Jain.
  • The impugned reservation could also not be sustained on the ground that aggregate reservations exceeded 50%, applying the principle in Ramesh Chander Garg.
  • The 2% reservation for children of University employees was held to be unconstitutional based on precedents (including Ajay Kumar and related cases).
  • Because the admissions at issue date from 1979 and the impugned reservation scheme is no longer in vogue, the court declined to quash past admissions and instead granted the petitioner a prospective, remedial admission opportunity.

Implication regarding precedent: the court applied and followed existing precedents to invalidate certain reservation provisions; it did not purport to create a new broad precedent beyond these specific applications. The immediate practical effect is the limited remedy granted to the petitioner; broader institutional consequences (such as re-opening past admissions) were not ordered.

Disposition

The writ petition is allowed in part: petitioner to be admitted in the forthcoming B.V.Sc. & A.H. course on the basis of his 1979 merit, if he so desires. No order as to costs.

    Ajay Kumar Mittal v. The Haryana Agricultural University And Others

    1. The petitioner applied for admission to the degree course of Bachelor of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry of the Haryana Agricultural University, Hissar in 1979. The University had made reservations for purposes of admission under Rule 1.3 (P. 1), the relevant part of which reads.

    "For admission to various programs both undergraduate and master degree there will be reservation far categories as under:

    (i) Government of India nominee or candidates from other States or Union Territories 10%

    (ii) Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes 20%

    (iii) Backward Classes 5%

    (iv) Children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas 35%

    (v) Ex-servicemen or their children 5%

    (vi) Sportsmen 3%

    (vii) Children of University employees 2%

    (viii) Open Quota 20% The reservation in categories in serial Nos, (ii) to (viii) will be for candidate belonging to Haryana only. In the open quota too, preference will be given to candidates from rural areas. However, exception may be made in the College Sports, if good candidates are not available under reserved categories.

    Candidates claiming reservations under category (iv) mentioned above must have passed at least the Primary or Middle or Matriculation Examination from a village school.

    The fact. whether an applicant belongs to rural area family of farmers will be judged from the existence of his/her father's name in the concerned list of voters or from the revenue record indicating land held in rural area."

    2. The petitioner having failed to secure admission from the open quota category has filed the present writ assailing the reservations (P. 1) for purposes of admission being violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution and has prayed for a direction to be issued to the University authorities to admit him to the B. V. Sc. & A. H. course for the year 1979-80.

    3. In the written statement filed by the Registrar of the Haryana Agricultural University on behalf of respondents 1 and 2 it has been averred that the reservations made for various categories is constitutionally valid and is not violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution.

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that 35 per cent reservation for children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas is violative a f Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution Reliance has been placed so a Division Bench decision of this Court in C. W. P. No. 3371 of 1578 (Kumari Promila Jain v. State of Haryana decided on February 26, 1979, wherein a similar reservation, for candidates from rural area was struck down.

    5. The contention of the learned counsel for the University is that this 35 percent reservation is justified order Cl(4) of Article 15 and is not violative of Article 1 of the Constitution. According to him, the social and I backwardness of the sector of the society for which this reservation has been t de can be made use to treat it as a distinct class for purposes of Article 14. This class being a weaker section of the society deserves special treatment 'm the matter of admission in educational institution. The learned counsel has further argued that this case is covered by the ratio of Amar JiT Singh v. Maha Rishi Dayanand University, Rohtak 5 ILR (lAsO) 2 Punj and Har 493 (FB) wherein reservation for candidates from rural areas was been held constitutionally valid.

    6. In Kumari Promila Jain's. case {supra), 25. eats for, admission. to. Medical College, Rohtak, were reserved for students. from rural areas. The following three conditions were prescribed for being eligible for such reserved seats:

    1. The name of parent o# the candidate should 'be in the village electoral roll.

    2. The parent should be engaged'., in cultivation or allied activities in the village.

    3. The candidate should have received at least Primary Education from' a school situate i.e. any village not having a Municipality or notified area or Town Area Committee.":

    7. In Amar Bir Singh's case {supra), 25. seats in Medical College, Rohtak, were reserved for candidates from rural areas. The following. Condition was prescribed for being eligible for such reserved seats:

    "The candidate must. have received education up to 8th Standard in a common rural village situated in any village not having any Municipality or noticed area or town area Committee,.

    For. this purpose a: certificate is required to be submitted which may be' seen in Appendix 'C'."

    8. In Amar Bir Singh's case (supra) the Division Bench decision in 'Kumary Promila Jain's case (supra) was' noticed and it was held that the facts' of 'the latter's case are totally distinguishable and.the ratio thereof is,. therefore; not attracted: In other. words, in Amar Bir Singh's case (ILR (.198A) 2 Punj & Har 493) (supra),...the Full Bench did. not find any fault with the ratio of the decision is Kumari' Promila Jain'g case (supra):

    9. In this background the point. for consideration is whether: the impugned 35 percent reservation. in the instant case is similar. to the reservation which. was struck down In Kumari Promila.Jain's case (supra) not. It is obvious. that if the impugned 36 per cent reservation in the instant case is similar to the reservation. made in Kumari Promila Jain's, case (supra) been the same 'cannot by sustained. The comparison of the two reservations hardly leases any doubt that they are similar' in. substance. In the impugned 35 per cent reservation the candidate must fulfil' the following conditions for becoming eligible to be considered for admission.

    (1) He must have passed Primary or' Middle or Matriculation Examination from a village school..

    (2) His father's name is entered in the voters' list or in the revenue records indicating that he held land in the rural area.

    10. In Kumari Promila Jain's case (supra), a candidate should have fulfilled I the following conditions for becoming eligible to be considered for admission against.25 per cent seats reserved for rural areas:

    1. The name of thc parent of the Candidate should be entered in.thc village electoral roll.

    2. The parent should be engaged in cultivation or allied activities in. the village.

    3. The candidate should have received at. least. Primary Education from a village school.

    10A. The impugned 35 per. cent reservation in the instant Case is.similar to the reservation which. was. struck down in Kumari Promilla:Jain's. case (supra). The reservation made in Amar Bir Singh's case (supra) is completely, different and; therefore, the.ratio.thereof cannot be availed for sustaining.the Impugned reservation. The Division Bench-.decision is Kumari Promila Jain's case {supra) is a binding precedent. The impugned..reservation.,.35 per cent for Children. of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas in the instant case cannot be sustained as constitutionally valid. In.view of this finding. the contention of the learned counsel fop the University that this. reservation is justified on..the ground that the rural area is the source is misplaced and without force.

    11. The learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that apart from 35 per cent reservation for children of bona fide farmers and landless labourers from rural areas, 20 per cent reservation has been made for Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes and 5 per. cent for Backward classes apart from 20 per cent reservation for other categories. The reservation being more than 50 per cent is unconstitutional. Reliance has been placed on Ramesh Chander Garg v. State of Punjab, AIR 1966 Punjab 476. It has been held in Ramesh Chander Garg's case (supra) that reservation for weaker section. of the society under any liable whatsoever should not in the aggregate `exceed be percent of. the. total available seats and the reservation of BO per cent is invalid and violative of the rule of equal protection of laws and account to a fraud on Article 15(4)' of the. Constitution, In the instant case, the impugned reservation (P: 1) cannot be held to be constitutionally valid on this ground as well.

    12. The learned counsel for 'the petitioner has further specifically assailed 2 per cent reservation for University employees. It has been argued that ' such reservation is unconstitutional and reliance has been placed on Ajay Kumar v. ' Chandigarh Administration Union Territory, Chandigarh, 'AIR 1988 Punjab

    "and Har 8, and Umesh Chandra Sithia v V.N Singh; Air` 1968' Para 3 (FB). The contention of the learned counsel'' for the petitioner must prevail. In"
    Ajay Kumar's case (Supra), the view expressed in Prasanna Kumar Sohail v: Director-in charge, Laxminarayan Institute' of Technology; Nagpur; AIR 1982 Bom 176, that the reservations in favour of the wards of the University are unconstitutional and invalid was followed: A. similar-view was taken in Umesh Chandra' Singh's case (supra).

    13. v The petitioner had applied for admission to a degree course by`: B: V: Se: 'and A: fI. of Haryana Agricultural' University Hissar, in 1975'. ''The impugned reservations pertain to that year. The learned counsel for the University has: stated that the impugned reservations' and more in vogue' and. further in the absence 'of 35 percent. Reservations for this children-of bona fide farmers and landless labourers. of, the rural areas, the petitioner' would have secured admission in" 1979 On merits. Some of the reservations, including 35 percent reservation for children of farmers and landless labourers from rural-areas-.has 'been held to be unconstitutional and--invalid. It is futile to quash the impugned reservation at: this stage because it is no more in vogue, It will also not be appropriate to quash the admission of the candidates against invalid reservations because most of them must. have completed the course by now. Keeping is. view the facts and circumstances it will. be-proper that. the University authorities allow admission to the petitioner in the. forthcoming. B. V. Sc. &.A.':H. Course on.the basis of his merit in i979, if he so desires.

    14 In view of discussion above the writ petition is allowed to the extent that the Haryana Agriculture University authorities are directed' to admit the petitioner 'in the forthcoming B. V. Sc. &. A, H. course on. the basis of his merit in 1979, No order as to costs.

    15. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajay Kumar Mittal v. The Haryana Agricultural University And Others
    (May 1, 1984)