AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXII, rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXII, rule 3, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXII, rule 2, Civil Procedure Code,
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXII, rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXII, rule 3, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXII, rule 2, Civil Procedure Code,
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenges an order dated 4th March 1963 by a Subordinate Judge 1st Class, Delhi, which revived a suit originally instituted in 1951 for partition of joint Hindu family property. The suit had been stayed since April 1954 due to another suit for specific performance involving the same parties and related property shares. After the other suit was disposed of in November 1961, the plaintiffs applied for revival of the present suit. The defendants resisted on grounds including alleged abatement of the suit due to the death of a party, Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava, whose legal representatives were not brought on record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application for restoration is defective as alleged, and its effects.
  2. Whether the suit cannot be revived as per allegations in the reply.
  3. Whether the suit has abated as alleged, and the effects thereof.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Court below exceeded its jurisdiction by holding that the suit had not abated despite the absence of an application to bring on record the legal representatives of the deceased Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava.
  • Reliance on Shivrajsingh v. Gaurishankar Baldeo Prasad to support the contention that the suit should not be revived without proper representation of the deceased's legal heirs.
  • Argued that the suit must be held to have abated at least with respect to the interest of Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava.
  • Contended that the order bringing on record the legal representatives of Pt. Gokal Dhish Bhargava negates the plea of joint Hindu family and that Order XXII of the Civil Procedure Code is inapplicable to survivorship cases under Mitakshra law.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Contended that the suit did not abate in toto merely because the legal representatives of Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava were not brought on record within the prescribed period.
  • Asserted that the suit, originally instituted by Pt. Gokal Dhish Bhargava as Karta of the joint family, retains its representative character and continues despite the death of Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava.
  • Argued that a suit for partition can be filed by any co-sharer and the decree declares rights of all interested parties, so the absence of certain legal representatives does not cause abatement.
  • Maintained that the plea regarding necessary parties was not raised in the Court below and thus cannot be entertained on revision.
  • Rejected the contention that Order XXII is wholly inapplicable to survivorship cases governed by Mitakshra law, citing Bishan Narain v. Om Parkash.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shivrajsingh v. Gaurishankar Baldeo Prasad, AIR 1961 M.P. 147 Representation of deceased party's legal heirs during pendency of appeal under Order XXII, rule 2, CPC The court found the ratio wholly inapplicable to the present suit for partition by a joint Hindu family Karta and did not accept the argument based on this precedent.
Lilawati Bai v. Gangadhar, AIR 1953 Nag. 12 Order XXII, CPC exhaustively governs representation of deceased persons' heirs during pendency of suit or appeal The court rejected the application of this case to hold that the present suit abated in toto, distinguishing the facts and legal context.
Ramnath Kishan Lal v. Ramgopal Bhaulal, AIR 1951 Nag. 434 Legal representatives and heirs are necessary parties in partition suits involving joint Hindu family property The court acknowledged the principle but held that the issue of necessary parties was not raised below and the suit did not abate in toto due to absence of some legal representatives.
Bishan Narain v. Om Parkash, AIR 1952 Punj. 167 Applicability of Order XXII, CPC to survivorship cases under Mitakshra law The court relied on this precedent to reject the contention that Order XXII is wholly inapplicable to survivorship cases in joint Hindu family law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the procedural history and the nature of the suit, which was instituted by Pt. Gokal Dhish Bhargava as Karta of a joint Hindu family for partition of joint family property. The suit had been stayed pending another related suit and was sought to be revived after that suit's disposal. A key issue was whether the suit had abated due to the death of Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava and the failure to bring his legal representatives on record.

The Court noted that the first issue regarding defectiveness of the restoration application was not pressed and focused on whether the suit had abated in toto. It emphasized that a suit for partition can be maintained by any co-sharer and that a decree declares rights of all interested parties, meaning the suit survives despite absence of certain parties.

The Court carefully distinguished precedents cited by the petitioner, finding them inapplicable due to differences in facts, nature of suit, and legal context. It held that the suit retained its representative character and that the absence of Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava's legal representatives did not cause abatement of the suit as a whole.

The Court also rejected the argument that Order XXII of the CPC was inapplicable to survivorship cases under Mitakshra law, relying on authoritative precedent. The question of whether the legal representatives are necessary parties was noted as not raised below and thus not considered on revision.

Consequently, the Court found no jurisdictional error or material irregularity in the order reviving the suit and declined to interfere under section 115 of the CPC.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed with costs.

The Court upheld the revival of the suit for partition despite the absence of legal representatives of one deceased co-sharer, holding that the suit did not abate in toto. This decision directly affects the parties by allowing the suit to proceed on merits. No broader precedent was established beyond affirming the procedural propriety of reviving such a suit under these circumstances.

    Jagat Dhish Bhargava v. Shri Jawahar Lal Bhargava And Others

    Dua, J.:— This is a revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure and is directed against the order of a learned Subordinate Judge 1st Class, Delhi, dated 4th March, 1963, reviving a suit which had been stayed as far back as April, 1954, on account of some other suit for specific performance between the parties in which the question of partitioning the shares of the property in the present suit was also involved. That other suit was disposed of in November, 1961 and an application for the revival of the present suit and its decision on the merits was thereupon filed by the plaintiffs.

    2. The defendants resisted that application and the pleadings gave rise to the following three issues:—

    1. Whether the application for restoration is defective as alleged? If so, to what effect?

    2. Whether the suit cannot be revived as per allegations in the reply?

    3. Whether the suit has abated as alleged? If so, to what effect?

    3. The first issue was not pressed in the Court below and does not concern this Court in the present proceedings either. Issues Nos. 2 and 3 were disposed of together. Here I may mention the circumstances which gave rise to these two issues.

    4. Originally the suit was instituted by Pt. Gokal Dhish Bhargava son of Pt. Bhawani Prasad Bhargava against Shri Jagat Dhish Bhargava son of Pt. Bhawani Prasad Bhargiva, Shri Dhurulal Bhargava son of Pt. Kaushaldhish Bhargava and Shri Umesh Kumar Bhargava minor son of Shri Kantilal Bhargava, for partition of the property mentioned in the plaint on the allegation that the sons of Pt. Bhawani Prasad Bhargava consitituted a joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshra Law and possessing considerable property; that in the years 1938–1939 a partition had taken place between the sons of late Pt. Bhawani Prasad Bhargava but the house property mentioned therein remained joint with a defined ¼th share of each branch of the sons of the deceased. A pedigree table was also reproduced in the plaint. This suit, it may be mentioned, was instituted in 1951. It appears that Pt. Gokal Dhish Bhargava died after the institution of the suit and Shri Chum Lal, Shri Jawahar Lal and Shrimati Shanti Devi were impleaded as his legal representatives for prosecuting the suit. It is necessary to giving the circumstance leading to these three persons being brought on the record because the learned counsel for the petitioner based his arguments on this circumstance. On 2nd May, 1951, an application was filed by Pt. Chuni Lal, Pt. Jawahar Lal and Srimati Shanti Devi widow of late Pt. Hira Lal, a pre-deceased son of Pt. Gokal Dhish Bhargava under Order XXII, rule 3, Civil Procedure Code, claiming to be heirs and successors under Hindu Law though the property was described to be joint and Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava was described to be the Karta of the family being the eldest son of the deceased. This application was resisted by Shri Jagat Dhish Bhargava who put in his reply in September, 1951, expressly averring that Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava and Shri Jawahar Lal Bhargava were owners of the property by right of survivorship and that Shrimati Shanti Devi was not an heir of the deceased, the suit, according to this reply, had been instituted by Shri Gokal Dhish Bhargava on behalf of the joint Hindu family constituted by him with his sons. It was admitted, in agreement with the assertion of the three petitioners in the application under Order XXII, rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the property in suit was the joint Hindu family property of the deceased and the first two applicants. In this view the petition under Order XXII, rule 3, Civil Procedure Code, was alleged to be incompetent and, therefore, liable to be rejected. It was also pleaded that these three applicants were necessary parties to the suit in the very first instance and having not joined earlier they could not bp added as parties to the suit at that stage and that they, according to the plea, could sue separately if so advised. On 16th October, 1951, it appears that Shri Jagat Dhish Bhargava gave up his objections with the result that application dated 2nd of May, 1951, was allowed.

    5. As already mentioned, in 1954 the suit was stayed and after the disposal of the other suit the petition giving rise to this revision was filed for reviving the present suit. In the meantime, Shri Chuni Lal is said to have died in May, 1954 and apparently no application for bringing on record his legal representatives was filed. It is on this circumstance that the defendants resist the application for revival of the suit alleging that the suit has abated in toto.

    6. Before me on revision the leaned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the Court below has exercised jurisdiction not vested in it by law by holding that the suit had not abated on account of application for bringing on record the legal representatives of Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava deceased having not been made till 1963, when admittedly Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava had died in May, 1954. In support of his contention he has, to begin with, cited Shivrajsingh v. Gaurishankar Baldeo Prasad . A.I.R 1961 M.P 147.. In that case a suit had been instiuted for a declaration of title and for possession of some property. The Court of first instance passed a decree in favour of the plaintiffs and on appeal having been preferred by some of the defendants one of them died. The other defendants applied to the Court under Order XXII, rule 2, Civil Procedure Code, stating that they were the legal representatives of the deceased and were already on the record. The plaintiff-respondents objected that the deceased had left a surviving widow and a daughter and that in their absence the appeal could not proceed. This objection was upheld by the Additional District Judge and on second appeal by the defendants it was held by a learned Single Judge of the Gwalior Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court that the widow represented the deceased and that she was a necessary party. Without expressing any opinion on the correctness or otherwise of the precise decision, in my opinion, the ratio of that case is wholly inapplicable to the case in hand which is a suit for partition by a member of the joint Hindu family claiming to be its Karta. Besides, I am wholly unable to understand how the suit on behalf of Shri Jawahar Lal Bhargava cannot be held to survive and how it is possible to contend that merely on account of Shri Chuni Lal's death the Court should decline to revive the said suit.

    7. The next authority on which Shri Sawhney has placed reliance is Lilawati Bai v. Gangadhar . A.I.R 1953 Nag. 12.. It was held there that Order XXII, Civil Procedure Code, is exhaustive of the manner in which the persons who die during the pendency of a suit or appeal can be represented by their heirs and legal representatives. There in a suit for declaration a decree was granted by the two Courts that the impugned proceedings would not bind the plaintiffs after the death of the transferor. On second appeal by the defendants one of the defendants died and an application to bring on record his legal representatives was dismissed, being out of time. On these facts the appeal was held to abate in its entirety because otherwise it would lead to two contrary decrees. I am unable to understand how this decision is an authority for the proposition in the present case that the Court should decline to revive the suit on the ground that it has abated in toto. Lastly, reference has been made to Ramnath Kishan Lal v. Ramgopal Bhaulal . A.I.R 1951 Nag. 434.. Head note on which reliance was placed is in the following words:—

    “Where ‘A’ brings a suit for partition of property alleged to be joint, against ‘B’ and ‘C’, brothers who are in possession and ‘B’ dies during the pendency of the appeal leaving a widow, ‘B's’ interest in the joint family devolves on his widow and she is entitled to claim by partition the same interest which her husband had in the joint family and the estate of the deceased ‘B’ cannot during the life of his widow be represented by ‘C’ alone. Both the widow and ‘C’ are the legal representatives of ‘B’ and the appellants' failure to bring the widow on record within time results in the abatement of the appeal as a whole.”

    8. Relying on the ratio of this case the learned counsel has very forcefully contended that Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava's legal representatives are necessary parties to the suit for partition. Now whether or not they are necessary parties is not the precise question before me at this stage, for, this plea in support of the non-maintainability of the suit had not been urged in the Court below and cannot be raised before me on revision. That is a matter which, if permissible under the law, would be disposed of when raised and the question may have to be determined as to how far those persons can or cannot be made defendants to the suit. The question which falls for determination before me is: Has the suit on the facts and circumstances of this case abated in toto and, therefore, should not be revived? From what has been argued on behalf of the petitioner I have not been able to persuade myself to hold that the suit in the present case has abated in toto. A suit for partition can be filed by any co-sharer and on a decree for partition being granted every co-sharer is entitled to his share. As a matter of fact the decree has to declare the rights of the several parties interested in the property. From this point of view every party interested in the property may be considered to be a plaintiff even though not so arrayed. I am, however, unable to understand how in the presence of Shri Jawahar Lal Bhargava the suit can be held to have abated in toto merely because the heirs or legal representatives of Chuni Lal Bhargava are not made parties plaintiff.

    9. Shri Sawhney has, however contended that qua Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava's interest at least it must be held to have abated. The Court below has gone into this matter and has come to the conclusion that the suit originally brought by Shri Gokal Dhish Bhargava as a plaintiff cannot be held to have abated merely because Shri Chuni Lal Bhargava's legal representatives are not brought on the record within the prescribed period. The nature of the suit as originally filed, according to the Court below, died. The suit was in a representative capacity by the Karta and continues to retain its original character. In my opinion, this conclusion is not tainted by any material irregularity and certainly there is no question of jurisdiction involved, with the result that I find no cogent ground for interfering with this conclusion under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure. I have already observed that the effect of the absence of Chuni Lal Bhargava's heirs from the array of defendants has not been raised and, therefore, I need not advert to it.

    10. Shri Sawhney at one stage argued that the order passed in October, 1951, bringing on record the legal representatives of Shri Gokal Dhish Bhargava showed that the plea of joint Hindu family was negatived by the Court, for. Order XXII, Civil Procedure Code, is inapplicable to cases of survivorship under the law of joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshra school. This contention, in my opinion, is untenable because the said order is not capable of this interpretation and then Order XXII, Civil Procedure Code, cannot be held to be wholly inapplicable to the cases of survivorship: See Bishan Narain v. Om Parkash . A.I.R 1952 Punj. 167.

    11. For the foregoing reasons I see no ground for interference on revision with the result that this revision fails and is hereby dismissed with costs.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jagat Dhish Bhargava v. Shri Jawahar Lal Bhargava And Others
    (Apr 11, 1963)