Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (G.D. Khosla, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government requisitioned portions of property owned by Roshan Lal Gupta in Karol Bagh, Delhi (ground floor of plot No. 23 and two floors of plot No. 24) under the Defence of India Rules in 1945. Compensation for the requisitioned premises was referred to an arbitrator. The owner claimed Rs. 80 per mensem per flat (total Rs. 240 per month). The Government relied on fair rents fixed by the Rent Controller (Rs. 43/8 per mensem for plot No. 23 ground floor and Rs. 96 per mensem for the floors on plot No. 24) and contended compensation should not exceed those figures. The arbitrator rejected the proposition that fair rent was an adequate measure and awarded Rs. 100 per mensem per flat (total Rs. 300 per mensem). The Union of India appealed against the arbitrator's award.

At earlier stages the case was heard singly by Bishan Narain J., who noted a conflict between two decisions of this Court and suggested a larger Bench. A Division Bench (Falshaw and Chopra, JJ.) considered the conflict required at least three judges. The matter was accordingly placed before the present Bench and argued at length; counsel referred to various relevant decisions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in assessing compensation under section 19 of the Defence of India Act (with reference to subsection (1) of section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894), the "fair rent" as fixed under Rent Control laws should be taken into consideration.
  2. If fair rent is to be taken into account, to what extent the fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller should determine or limit the compensation payable for requisitioned premises.
  3. Whether the requisitioning authority can be treated as a tenant within the meaning of Rent Control legislation (and thus whether rent-control determinations equate to market-value compensation for requisitioned property).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Union of India)

  • The Union argued that no landlord could have let the premises at a figure higher than the fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller; therefore, the fair rent figure represents the market rent or market value of the income obtainable from the property and should determine compensation.
  • Relying on authorities (some of which were cited), the Union maintained that statutory controls on rents must be considered so that the figure fixed by the Rent Controller is indicative of what the owner could realistically obtain in the market.

Respondent / Owner (as reflected in the arbitrator's award)

  • The arbitrator (and by implication the owner) contended that fair rent as fixed under Rent Control law was not an adequate or sole measure of compensation under section 19 of the Defence of India Act.
  • The arbitrator awarded a higher sum (Rs. 100 per mensem per flat; total Rs. 300) than the fair-rent figures relied upon by the Government, indicating the view that other factors and evidence must be considered in assessing compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court (as stated in the opinion)
Raghbir Saran v. The Punjab State (1954 56 P.L.R. 530) Held that compensation for requisitioned premises must be equal to the fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller. Identified as a decision supporting the Union's contention; however the Court found this decision inconsistent with earlier authority and ultimately stated it would be considered over‑ruled by the present decision.
Governor General in Council, New Delhi v. Shrimati Indar Mani (A.I.R. 1950 E.P. 296) Held that fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller was not adequate compensation for requisitioned premises; the requisitioning authority did not fall within the meaning of 'tenant' under the Rent Control Orders. Cited as an earlier Division Bench decision (Harnam Singh, J.) taking a contrary view to Raghbir Saran; used to show conflicting authorities and to support the view that rent-control determinations are not conclusive of compensation.
Province of Bengal v. Board of Trustees for the Improvement of Calcutta (A.I.R. 1946 Cal. 416) Expressed that compensation must be fixed on the basis of what is fair rent (the Court itself assessed what fair rent should be, after examining evidence); here 'fair rent' was determined by court examination of evidence rather than by a Rent Controller's fixation. Referred to as a case where the Court equated compensation with a court-assessed notion of fair rent (5% per annum was accepted as fair return). The opinion notes that the expression 'fair rent' in that case was not used in reference to a Rent Controller's fixation.
Dawoodali Rahematulla v. The State of Bombay (1954 56 Bom. L.R. 238) Observed that statutory restrictions upon the liberty of contract must be taken into consideration when assessing the value of property. Cited as a supporting authority for the proposition that rent-control restrictions can be relevant evidence affecting valuation, but not necessarily determinative.
Hazi Mohammad Ekramul Haq v. Province of Bengal (A.I.R. 1950 Cal. 83) Held that a requisitioning authority cannot be deemed a tenant; compensation must be assessed under Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act on the basis of fair market value of the interest taken. Fair rent may be a good criterion of market value, but rent-control legislation only bears upon valuation to the extent it affects obtainable income. Quoted to show an approach that treats fair rent as a criterion or piece of evidence for market value rather than as conclusive; the case was remitted to the arbitrator and later proceeded to higher courts.
Haji Mohammad Ekramul Haq v. State of West Bengal (A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 488) (As reported) The Supreme Court awarded a higher compensation (Rs. 3,200 per mensem) than the figure that would have been allowable under Rent Control (Rs. 1,950), indicating rent-control figures need not fix compensation. Referred to as demonstrating that the Supreme Court did not limit compensation to rent-control figures and awarded a higher amount, supporting the view that rent-control figures are not necessarily adequate compensation.
Union of India v. Ram Pershad (A.I.R. 1952 Punjab 116) Held that the rent fixed by the Rent Controller could not be equated with the compensation due on requisition. Cited as an authority in which Harnam Singh, J. expressed the view that Rent Controller's standard rent is not the principle by which requisition compensation is assessed.
Minister for Public Works v. Christopher Bowas Thistlethwayte (1954 A.C. 475) Privy Council held that where price-control regulations kept the price of land down, such controlled price was not adequate compensation for compulsorily acquired land. Used as an external/common-law comparison to support the proposition that regulatory controls depressing market measures are not necessarily adequate measures of compensation for compulsory acquisition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reference to the statutory framework: section 19 of the Defence of India Act requires compensation to be determined in accordance with principles similar to those in subsection (1) of section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, and section 23(1) of the Land Acquisition Act requires market value to be taken into consideration.

On that basis the Court framed the legal task as assessing "the value of the income which the owner could have obtained in the market" from letting the premises. The existence of Rent Control laws complicates this inquiry because such laws impose restrictions on the free letting of property and may depress rents.

The Court reviewed conflicting authorities: some decisions equated compensation with the fair rent fixed by a Rent Controller (notably Raghbir Saran), while other decisions (including an earlier decision involving the same judge, Harnam Singh, J.) held that Rent Controller determinations were not adequate measures of compensation. The Court also considered cases where courts themselves assessed a 'fair rent' by looking at market evidence (Province of Bengal case) and authorities where judges observed that statutory restrictions are relevant but do not automatically determine compensation (Dawoodali Rahematulla; Hazi Mohammad Ekramul Haq).

Balancing these authorities and the statutory imperative to consider market value, the Court concluded that:

  • Rent-control determinations (fair rent fixed by a Rent Controller) are a piece of relevant evidence indicative of market rents, but they do not represent the entire enquiry required by section 19 read with section 23(1) of the Land Acquisition Act.
  • The requisitioning authority cannot be equated with a tenant in the sense used by Rent Control legislation; consequently, a Rent Controller's figure is not necessarily conclusive of the market value of the possessory interest taken by requisition.
  • Other circumstances and evidence bearing on market value must be considered; fair rent is not to be treated as the sole or determinative criterion for compensation for requisitioned property.

Applying these principles to the controversy before it, the Court found that there is a preponderance of authority against the proposition that Rent Controller-fixed fair rent alone should determine compensation. The Court therefore decided that the case should be remitted to the learned Single Judge for disposal in light of the decision that fair rent is only one piece of evidence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the amount of compensation for requisitioned property under section 19 of the Defence of India Act should not be determined solely on the basis of the fair rent fixed under Rent Control laws. The fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller is relevant evidence of market rents but is not the exclusive or conclusive criterion for assessing compensation. The Court expressly stated that Raghbir Saran v. The Punjab State will be considered over‑ruled.

Direct consequences and disposition:

  • The case is remitted to the learned Single Judge (the arbitrator/proper forum) for disposal in conformity with the Court's conclusion that fair rent is only one factor in assessing market-value compensation.
  • Raghbir Saran v. The Punjab State is over‑ruled to the extent that it held that the Rent Controller's fair rent alone determines compensation for requisitioned property.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a detailed formula for valuation in every circumstance; it emphasizes that fair rent is a relevant piece of evidence but that other evidence and circumstances affecting market value must be taken into account when computing compensation.

Decision announced by a Bench of three (G.D. Khosla, C.J.; Falshaw, J.; Chopra, J.) with all three agreeing: "Answer accordingly."

    Union Of India v. Roshan Lal Gupta .

    G.D Khosla, C.J:— In this case we are concerned with the compensation which should be awarded for requisitioning property under section 19 of the Defence of India Act read with rule 75A of the Rules framed under that Act. The question, in short, is whether in assessing compensation for requisitioned property ‘fair rent’ as fixed under the Rent Control law should be taken into consideration and, if so, what is the extent to which the fair rent should be a determining factor in computing the compensation due. The matter came up before Bishan Narain J. sitting singly in the original instance and he noticed a conflict in two decisions of this Court, Raghbir Saran… v. The Punjab State…. . 1954 56 P.L.R 530. and Governor General In Council, New Delhi… v. Shrimati Indar Mani…. . A.I.R 1950 E.P 296.. He accordingly suggested that the case be placed before a larger Bench. The matter then came before a Division Bench consisting of my brothers, Falshaw and Chopra, JJ., who took the view that the conflict could only be resolved by an authoritative decision by at least three judges. The matter has now been argued before us at some length and all the relevant decisions bearing upon the question before us have been referred to by counsel at the Bar.

    2. The facts are that Roshan Lal Gupta owned plots Nos. 23 and 24 in Block No. 14-A, Western Extension Area, Karol Bagh, Delhi. The ground floor of the building on plot No. 23 and two floors on plot No. 24 were requisitioned by Government under the Defence of India Rules in 1945. The question of compensation for the properties thus requisitioned arose and the matter was referred to an arbitrator. The owner claimed Rs. 80/- per mensem per flat, i.e a total of Rs. 240/- per month. The Government contended that fair rent had been fixed for the ground floor on plot No. 23 at Rs. 43/8/- per mensem; and for the floors on plot No. 24 at Rs. 96/- per mensem; the owner was therefore, not entitled to claim compensation at more than Rs. 43/8/- plus Rs. 96/- per mensem for the entire requisitioned property. The arbitrator took the view that the fair rent was not an adequate measure of compensation to be awarded under section 19 of the Defence of India Act and fixed Rs. 100/- per mensem per flat, i.e a total of Rs. 300/- per mensem for the entire property. The Union of India then filed the present appeal against the Arbitrator's award.

    3. The relevant portion of section 19 of the Defence of India Act is in the following terms:—

    “19. (1) Where * * * by or under any rule made under this Act any action is taken of the nature described in sub-section (2) of section 299 of the Government of India Act, 1935, there shall be paid compensation, the amount of which shall be determined in the manner, and in accordance with the principles, hereinafter set out, that is to say:

    (a) Where the amount of compensation can be fixed by agreement, it shall be paid in accordance with such agreement.

    (b) Where no such agreement can be reached the Central Government shall appoint as arbitrator a person qualified under sub-section (3) of section 220 of the above-mentioned Act for appointment as a Judge of a High Court.

    (c) ***

    (d) ***

    (e) The arbitrator in making his award shall have regard to—

    (i) The provisions of sub-section (1) of section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, so far as the same can be made applicable; and

    (ii) Whether the acquisition is of a permanent or temporary character:

    Section 23(1) of the Land Acquisition Act requires the market value of the land to be taken into consideration. Therefore, what we have to consider in assessing compensation in respect of requisitioned premises is what is the value of the income which the owner could have obtained in the market. The matter is complicated by the existence of Rent Control Laws which impose restrictions upon free dealings of property, and the question at once arises what is the market value of the income which can be derived by letting out these premises by the landlord. It has been argued before us on behalf of the Union of India that no landlord could have let out these premises at a higher figure than the fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller; therefore, that figure represents the market rent or market value. On the other hand, it has been argued that the restrictive laws are not to be taken into consideration when assessing compensation under section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act. Our attention has been drawn to a number of cases in which this matter was considered from various aspects. I shall first consider the cases which would appear to support the contention of the learned counsel for the Union. The first of these is Raghbir Saran v. The Punjab State, A Division Bench case in which it was held that compensation for requisitioned premises must be equal to the fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller. This case was heard by Harnam Singh and Kapur, JJ. The view expressed by the learned Judges was that in requisitioning property, Government acquired the possessory interest of the owner and in assessing the market value of the possessory interest the fair rent fixed by the Rent Controller had to be borne in mind. Kapur, J. observed that the provisions of the Requisitioning Act were not to be divorced from reality and that the control on rents which the law in existence imposed had to be taken into account in determining compensation. It is somewhat surprising that an earlier decision of this Court by a Division Bench of which Harnam Singh, J. was a member was not cited or brought to the notice of the learned Judges. In that earlier case, Governor General In Council, New Delhi… v. Shrimati Indar Mani…., Harnam Singh, J. had expressed a wholly contrary view. He had said quite categorically that the authority requisitioning premises did not come within the meaning of word ‘tenant’ as defined in clause 2(4) of the New Delhi House Rent Control Order, 1939, or Clause 2(d), Delhi Rent Control Ordinance, 1944. Harnam Singh, J. after referring to a number of cases dealing with the matter, held that the fair rent as fixed by the Rent Controller was not adequate compensation for requisitioned premises. The facts in that case were that certain property was requisitioned by Government and after the cider of requisition was made, the Rent Controller fixed Rs. 1,313/- per mensem as fair rent. The landlord appealed against the order to the Chief Commissioner and the appeal was allowed mainly on the ground that this was not a case which should have gone to the Rent Controller and compensation should have been fixed by the appropriate authority under section 19 of the Defence of India Act. Compensation was awaited by the High Court at the rate of Rs. 3,600/- per mensem. Although an appeal had been allowed against the order of the Rent Controller, it nevertheless remains a fact that the Rent Controller had determined fair rent at Rs. 1,313/- per mensem and this figure had not been varied in appeal, and the only ground for allowing the appeal was that compensation should have been fixed not under the Rent Control Act but under section 19 of the Defence of India Act. The earlier view expressed by Harnam Singh J. therefore, differs completely from the later view expressed by him in Raghbir Saran… v. The Punjab State….. There is also a Calcutta Case, Province of Bengal v. Board of Trustees for the Improvement of Calcutta . A.I.R 1946 Cal. 416. in which the view expressed was that compensation must be fixed on the basis of what is fair rent, but the expression ‘fair rent’ was not used in reference to Rent Control law. No fail rent had, in fact, been fixed by the Rent Controller for the property requisitioned in that case. The learned Judges assessed fair rent themselves after going into all the evidence in the case and examining a large number of leases in respect of similar lands in the vicinty. Our attention, was drawn to an observation contained in paragraph 35 of the report which seems to support the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant—

    “We have already held that the effect of a requisition under the Defence of India Rules is to deprive the owner of his possession. He must, therefore, get the value of his possession. Looking from another aspect the requisitioning authority gets the possession from the owner and becomes, so to say, a statutory tenant. The basis of compensation must therefore be fair rent. * *”

    But after making this observation, the learned Judges went on to examine the leases of lands in the vicinity and came to the conclusion that 5 per cent per annum was a fair return on the value of the property requisitioned. It was on this basis that the compensation was determined and the figure of 5 per cent per annum was accepted as fair rent. There is lastly a Single Bench decision of the Bombay High Court in Dawoodali Rahematulla v. The State of Bombay . 1954 56 Bom. L.R 238.. In this case Shah, J. observed that any statutory restrictions upon the liberty of contract must be taken into consideration when assessing the value of property. There is not a single case, therefore, apart from Raghbir Saran… v. The Punjab State…., in which standard or fair rent was fixed by the Rent Controller and the figure so fixed was accepted as determining the compensation which must be paid upon requisitioning the property in question. There are several cases in which the contrary view was taken. I have already mentioned the Punjab Case Governor-General in Council v. Indar Mani Jalia. Another case is Hazi Mohammad Ekramul Hague v. Province of Bengal . A.I.R 1950 Cal. 83.. In this case the Central Government held some property under a lease, the rent reserved being Rs. 1,950/- per month. On the expiry of the lease the owner refused to renew it. A requisitioning order was then made and the owner was offered Rs. 2,200/- as the monthly rent. This figure included the Corporation rates and, therefore, the rent offered remained at the original figure of Rs. 1,950/-. The offer was refused by the landlord who claimed Rs. 3,988/- as the monthly lent. The arbitrator fixed Rs. 1,950/- and the matter was taken up in appeal to the High Court. The High Court took the view that the requisitioning authority cannot be deemed to be a tenant in law. The learned Judges observed:—

    “It is clear that in case of a requisition like this, whether possession is taken, and there is not a complete acquisition of ownership of the land or building, compensation has to be assessed under Section 23, Land Acquisition Act, on the basis of fair market value for such interest in land. The relationship created is not that of a landlord and tenant. The requisition is by the Government by virtue of its suzerain position by which it can forcibly take away any one's property. * *. The market value of the interest taken away from the owner has got to be assessed. In the present case, it is the possessory interest which has been taken by the State, and, therefore in assessing the fair market value of the case, fair rent is taken to be a good criterion. It is as a criterion of market value of the interest that the question of fair tent arises, and the only bearing that the rent control legislation may have is in so far as it affects by way of fall in rent the income which will be obtainable from the property in a proper market by a landlord.”

    The matter was remitted to the arbitrator by the High Court. At a later stage it came before the Supreme Court, and the decision of the Supreme Court is reported as Haji Mohammad Ekramul Haq v. State Of West Bengal . A.I.R 1959 S.C 488.. The Supreme Court awarded Rs. 3,200/- per mensem as fair compensation, although on the basis of the Rent Control legislation Rs. 1,950/- only could have been allowed Harnam Singh J. considered this matter sitting singly in the Union of India v. Ram Pershad . A.I.R 1952 Punjab 116.. In that case also he held the view that the rent fixed by the Rent Controller could not be equated with the compensation due when property was requisitioned. He observed that “it cannot be conceded that the principle on which compensation is to be assessed is the principle on which a Rent Controller will assess standard rent for that property.” I may also make a reference to a Privy Council decision in a case which came from the Supreme Court of New South Wales. This was a case in which the Government compulsorily purchased certain lands and the question of compensation arose. The Privy Council held that where price control regulations compulsorily kept the price of land down, such price was not adequate compensation for compulsorily acquired land (see Minister for Public Works v. Christopher Bowas Thistlethwayte . 1954 A.C 475.).

    4. Upon a careful consideration of the matter, it appears to me that there is a preponderance of authority for the view that where property is compulsorily requisitioned, the amount of compensation should not be determined solely on the basis of fair rent as fixed under the Rent Control laws. The figure so fixed is merely a piece of evidence which may be taken into consideration as giving an indication of the market rents; other circumstances must be taken into consideration also. The requisitioning authority cannot be deemed to be a tenant of the landlord and is, therefore, not governed by the rent laws. The fair rent as fixed by the Rent Controller is no more than a piece of relevant evidence. It certainly should not be taken as the sole criterion for determining compensation. The case may now be remitted to the learned Single Judge for disposal in the light of the decision arrived at above. Raghbir Saran… v. The Punjab State…. will be considered as over-ruled.

    5. Falshaw, J.:— I agree.

    6. Chopra, J.:—I agree.

    Answer accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. Roshan Lal Gupta .
    (Jan 25, 1960)