Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 33 or section 34 (vide section 36(2)(b). Under sub-section (4) of section 36,
  • SECTION 33 A REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1951
  • provisions of section 33 (vide clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 36)
  • sub section (4) of section 33
  • sub section (8) of section 36,
  • sub-section (1) of section 33,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 33 or section 34 (vide section 36(2)(b). Under sub-section (4) of section 36,
  • SECTION 33 A REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1951
  • provisions of section 33 (vide clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 36)
  • sub section (4) of section 33
  • sub section (8) of section 36,
  • sub-section (1) of section 33,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the order of the Election Tribunal, Bhatinda, dated 31 December 1957, which dismissed the election petition filed by Shri Rup Lal (the appellant) that challenged the election of Shri Jugraj Singh (the respondent) from the Moga Constituency of the Punjab Legislative Assembly. The nomination papers for the election were required to be filed by 29 January 1957. The appellant's nomination (Exhibit P.W.1.F) listed Rawal Chand as proposer with electoral roll number 7852 (Ward No. 8, Moga Town). Another candidate, Sukhdev (Sukhdev) Singh (Exhibit P.W.1.H), listed Kabul (Kawal) Chand (electoral roll No. 7853) as proposer.

The scrutiny of nominations took place on 1 February 1957 before Shri Bhim Singh, Sub Divisional Officer, Moga, who was the Returning Officer. Both nomination papers were rejected by the Returning Officer with reasons indicating that the proposers' names at serial numbers 7852 and 7853 had been struck out in the supplementary electoral roll. The election petition alleged that the rejection was improper because the proposers appeared elsewhere in the rolls (at serial Nos. 1866 and 16970) and that this was pointed out during scrutiny. The Tribunal tried the petition on five issues (set out below) and decided issues Nos. 1 and 3 against the appellant, consequently dismissing the petition and leaving parties to bear their own costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the nomination of Shri Rup Lal was improperly rejected by the Returning Officer, Moga?
  2. If issue No. 1 is proved, what is its effect on the election of the respondent?
  3. Whether the nomination of Shri Sukhdev Singh was improperly rejected by the Returning Officer, Moga?
  4. If issue No. 3 is proved, what is its effect on the election of the respondent?
  5. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant (through Mr. Harbans Singh Doabia) challenged the Tribunal's factual findings, contending evidence showed the proposers' entries existed elsewhere in the electoral rolls and that this was pointed out to the Returning Officer during scrutiny.
  • It was argued that the entries of the proposers in the electoral rolls (albeit at different serial numbers) meant their qualification as electors was unaffected by the deletion of the specific serial numbers cited in the nomination papers, and that the defect was therefore not of substance.
  • The appellant relied on the authority of G. Raja Nainar v. N.T. Velusami Thevar (A.I.R. 1958 Mad. 198) to contend that the Tribunal's jurisdiction is co-extensive with the Returning Officer's and that the Tribunal may decide the issue after trial on evidence that was not available to the Returning Officer at the time of scrutiny; hence, on the Tribunal's finding that the proposers were actually entered in the rolls, the rejection should have been held improper.

Respondent / Returning Officer (as represented in the record)

  • The respondent controverted the appellant's contentions. The Returning Officer testified that when the objection was raised about the proposers' names being scored out, nobody pointed out to him that those names were recorded elsewhere in the rolls; had this been pointed out, he would have recorded it and considered it before deciding.
  • The Tribunal found discrepancies and vital inconsistencies in the evidence adduced on behalf of the appellant; some appellant witnesses, on cross-examination, disclosed that the discovery that the proposers were recorded under other numbers was made only after scrutiny had concluded.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G. Raja Nainar v. N.T. Velusami Thevar, A.I.R. 1958 Mad. 198 That the jurisdiction of the Election Tribunal is co-extensive with that of the Returning Officer and that the Tribunal can consider evidence not available to the Returning Officer at the time of nomination or scrutiny. Noted as the appellant's authority for the proposition that the Tribunal may decide the propriety of rejection after a trial on evidence not before the Returning Officer; the court considered the argument but found the Tribunal's factual findings and the scheme of the Act justified the Tribunal's conclusion.
Brij Sunder Sharma v. Election Tribunal Jaipur, A.I.R. 1957 Raj. 189 That the requirement of mentioning the name and electoral roll number of the proposer in the nomination form is a matter of substance. Applied to support the conclusion that the particulars of the proposer (name and roll number) are substantive requirements and that substantial divergence can justify rejection.
P.N. Balasubrahmanyan v. Election Tribunal of North Arcot at Vellore, A.I.R. 1954 Mad. 730 Principle that omission or error in particulars required for identification (such as constituency or roll number) is substantive and cannot be treated lightly. Used to reinforce that the identification particulars in a nomination paper (including for proposers) are substantive and that errors of substance cannot be corrected under the proviso to s.33(4).
Karnail Singh v. Election Tribunal, Hissar, 10 E.L.R. 189 Where a defect does not impede identification (no difficulty in identifying the candidate), it is not of substantial character and the nomination should not be rejected. Cited to show the converse: if identification is possible beyond doubt, defects may be non-substantial; the court contrasted that factual situation with the present case where identification was in doubt at the time of scrutiny.
Rattan Anmol Singh v. Ch. Atma Ram, A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 510 When the law requires observance of a formality, it cannot be disregarded; the substance must be present, and the Returning Officer's satisfaction at the relevant moment is material. Applied to emphasize the importance of the Returning Officer's satisfaction at the time of scrutiny or nomination, supporting the view that uncertainty at that stage justifies rejection.
Partap Singh v. Shri Krishna Gupta, A.I.R. 1956 S.C. 140 Omission of certain particulars (occupation) may not be substantive if the candidate can still be identified beyond doubt; discussed Rattan Anmol Singh and clarified the identification test. Considered to show that only defects which do not go to the root of identification may be excused; the court observed that this did not modify the necessity of identification in cases like the present one.
Durga Shankar Mehta v. Raghuraj Singh, A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 520 If a candidate appears properly qualified on the face of the roll and nomination and no objection is raised, acceptance by the Returning Officer is proper; the Tribunal may later find a disqualification but that would void the election on constitutional grounds, not improper acceptance. Used to indicate the converse principle: where the face of the roll and nomination show a lack of qualification and the Returning Officer rejects, that rejection is not necessarily improper; supported the court's view that rejection based on the material before the RO was justifiable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by treating the Tribunal's factual findings as unassailable on the record: the Tribunal found that the entries at serial Nos. 7852 and 7853 had been scored out in the supplementary list, and that there was no proof that, during the period fixed for scrutiny, anyone had pointed out to the Returning Officer that those proposers appeared under other numbers in the rolls. The Tribunal disbelieved the appellant's witnesses based on vital discrepancies and admissions in cross-examination that the alternative entries had been discovered only after scrutiny concluded. The Returning Officer testified that he would have recorded any such representation if it had been made during scrutiny.

Turning to the law, the court analysed sections 33 and 36 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. Section 33 requires the nomination paper to state the full name and electoral roll number of the proposer; sub-section (4) of section 33 places on the Returning Officer the duty of satisfying himself, by comparison with the electoral rolls, that the names and numbers correspond. The proviso to s.33(4) permits correction of clerical or technical errors. Section 36 governs scrutiny and permits the Returning Officer, after summary inquiry, to reject a nomination for failure to comply with s.33; s.36(4) provides that the Returning Officer shall not reject a nomination on account of a defect which is not of a substantial character.

The court concluded that the requirement to state the proposer's name and roll number is a matter of substance because it enables the Returning Officer to identify that the proposer is an elector of the constituency. The permissible corrections under the proviso to s.33(4) are limited to clerical or technical errors where there is not substantial divergence between the nomination entry and the electoral roll entry. If the Returning Officer is left in doubt as to whether the nomination entry and the roll entry relate to the same person, and that doubt is not resolved at the scrutiny stage, he must reject the nomination.

Applying this framework to the facts, the court held that on the material available to the Returning Officer at the time of scrutiny there was no basis to identify the proposers as electors at the serial numbers given in the nomination papers because those entries had been struck out; there was nothing before the Returning Officer showing the names existed elsewhere. The court emphasised that the Returning Officer could not reasonably be expected to suspend scrutiny and search through the thousands of names in the entire electoral roll to discover whether the proposer's name appeared at some other number. Allowing a subsequent tribunal finding (based on evidence not before the RO) to convert such a rejection into an improper rejection would, the court held, invite uncertainty, delay, expense and potential for abuse in the election process.

The court acknowledged the hardship to the appellant resulting from duplication/mistake in the electoral rolls (the name Rawal Ram/Rawal Chand appearing more than once), but considered the potential hardship and disruption to returned candidates of allowing retrospective invalidation of elections on such grounds to be greater. Consequently, given the Tribunal's accepted factual findings and the statutory scheme, the rejection could not fairly be characterised as an improper rejection under clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 100 of the Act.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED

Holding: The court upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that the nomination papers of the appellant (and of Sukhdev Singh) were not improperly rejected by the Returning Officer. The appeal was dismissed and the appellant was ordered to pay costs (counsel fee Rs. 250). The judgment records that Dulat, J. agreed.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the election petition challenging the election of Shri Jugraj Singh fails and the result of the election stands. The court's reasoning emphasizes that (1) particulars identifying the proposer in a nomination paper are substantive; (2) the Returning Officer must be satisfied on the material before him at the time of scrutiny; and (3) evidence discovered only after scrutiny may not convert an otherwise justifiable rejection into an improper one. The opinion frames these conclusions in the context of the statutory scheme (ss. 33 and 36 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951) and disavows any suggestion that the decision is founded on new precedent beyond applying established authorities cited in the judgment.

    Shri Rup Lal v. Shri Jugraj Singh .

    Capoor, J.:— This appeal arises from the order of the Election Tribunal, Bhatinda, dated the 31st of December, 1957, whereby the petition filed by Shri Rup Lal appellant culling in question the election of Shri Jugraj Singh respondent from the Moga Constituency of the Punjab Legislative Assembly, was dismissed, the parties being left to bear their own costs.

    2. The date on which Domination papers had to be filed for the above election was the 29th of January, 1957. The nomination paper filed by the appellant is Exhibit P.W 1.F, according to which his proposer was Rawal Chand P.W whose electoral roll number was 7852 in Ward No. 8 of Moga Town. Another candidate Sukbdev Singh P.W also filed his nomination paper. Exhibit P.W 1.H. on the same date and his proposer was Kabul (Kawal) Chand, son of Khazan Chand, with electoral roll No. 7853 in Moga Assembly Constituency Part 4. The date for scrutiny of the nomination papers was the 1st of February, 1957 and the scrutiny was conducted by Shri Bhim Singh, Sub Divisional Officer, Moga (R.W 1) who was the Returning Officer for the said election Both these nomination papers were rejected by him and on the date fixed for scrutiny the order on the appellant's nomination paper was as follows:—

    “The name of proposer Rawal Chand Dat at 7852 has been scored out of electoral rolls. Rejected”.

    3. The order on Sukhdev Singh's nomination paper was as follows:—

    “The name Kabul Chand proposer is not found in electoral rolls. Even if it is Kewal Chand at 7853, it is scored out. Rejected.”

    4. In the election petition it was stated that the rejection of those nomination papers by the Returning officer was improper inasmuch as the proposer of the appellant was shown at serial No. 1866 in the electoral roll and the proposer of Sukhdev Singh was shown as an elector at serial No. 16970. It was further urged in the petition that these entries were pointed out to the Returning Officer during the scrutiny, but he paid no heed, and, in any event, the defects were not of a substantial character. These arguments, however, were controverted by the respondent and the election petition went for trial on the following issues:—

    1. Whether the nomination of Shri Rup Lal was improperly rejected by the Returning Officer, Moga?

    2. If issue No. 1 is proved, what is its effect on the election of the respondent?

    3. Whether the nomination of Shri Sukhdev Singh was improperly rejected by the Returning Officer, Moga?

    4. If issue No. 3 is proved, what is its effect on the election of the respondent?

    5. Relief.

    5. The Tribunal decided issues Nos. 1 and 3 against the appellant and in the result the election petition was dismissed. The undisputed facts are that in Exhibit P.W 12/1 on page 232 at serial Nos. 7852 and 7853 appear respectively the names of Rawal Chand and Kawal Chand, sons of Khazan Chand, shopkeepers by occupation in the Sadar Bazar Moga. These two names were scored out by the supplementary list. Exhibit P.W 12/2, at page 724, the ground being “has left” (chala gia hai), but in the original list under Basti Rehgaran on page 57 at serial No. 1866 is the entry as to Rawal Ram, son of Khazan, labourer by profession, and at serial No. 16970 on page 495 of the supplementary list is the entry regarding Kabul, son of Khszan. The Tribunal has found that since there is no material discrepancy, it can be reasonably concluded that the elector shown at serial No. 1866 in Exhibit P.W 12/1 is the proposer of the appellant while that shown at serial No. 16970 in the supplementary list is the proposer of Sukhdev Singh. The Tribunal has, however, held on a careful consideration of the entire evidence that when the objection was raided before the Returning Officer that according to the supplementary list the votes of Rawal Chand and Kabul Chand had been scored out, it was not pointed out to the Returning Officer during the entire period fixed for scrutiny that the two proposers were shown as electors under other numbers in the electoral rolls, and it was, therefore, concluded that the rejection of the nomination papers by the Returning Officer could not be considered to be an improper rejection. The Tribunal was further of the view that even if it had been pointed out to the Returning Officer that the two proposers were entered at other places in the electoral rolls; he could not at the time of scrutiny allow any amendment of the two nomination papers in order to show the correct position, as the error in the two nomination papers was not a clerical or technical error which could be overlooked under the proviso to sub-section (4) of section 33 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (hereinafter to be referred to as the Act) nor was it a defect of an insubstantial character within the meaning of sub-section (4) of section 36 of the Act.

    6. Mr. Harbans Singh Doabia, on behalf of the appellant, maintained that the finding of the Tribunal on the question of fact was not justified on the evidence, as the two candidates—the appellant and Sukhdev Singh—as well as the two proposers—Rawal Chand and Kabul Chand—and some other witnesses also appeared to say that it was pointed out to the Returning Officer during the time of scrutiny that though the names of the two proposers had been scored out from Nos. 7852 and 7853 in the original electoral roll they existed under other numbers. In particular, Mr. Doabia relied on the evidence of Shri Baij Nath (P.W 11), a Pleader of Moga, who was a candidate for the same election and who was in foot the person who objected that the names of Rawal Chand and Kabul Chand had been scored out according to the supplementary, list, Shri Baij Nath went on to say that it was represented to the Returning Officer that the names of the two proposers ware mentioned at other numbers in the electoral rolls, but that the witness raised the further objection that the amendment could not be allowed at that stage. All this evidence was duly considered by the Tribunal and was not believed on the ground of vital discrepancies as mentioned in the judgment under appeal. In fact the cross-examination of some of the appellants's witnesses disclosed that it was until after the time of scrutiny was over that the discovery was made that the two proposers were shown in the electoral rolls under numbers other than those mentioned in the nomination papers which had been rejected. On this matter the evidence of the Returning Officer is to the effect that when the objection was raised as to the names of the two proposers having been scored out by the supplementary list, no one pointed out to him that their names were to be found at other places in the electoral rolls. He asserted that if this had been pointed out to him, he must have made a rote thereof and must have taken it into consideration before announcing his decision. He also denied that any request was made to him for amendment and in fact no occasion could arise for that request, because as observed above the cross-examination of some of the appellant's witnesses disclosed that the fact of the two proposers' mention as electors at other numbers in the electoral rolls was discovered only after the scrutiny was over.

    7. In the circumstances, the finding of the Tribunal on the question of fact appears unassailable, and the next question for determination is whether in the circumstances the rejection of the two nomination papers by the Returning Officer can be considered to be an improper rejection within the meaning of clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 100 of the Act so as to invalidate the election.

    8. Whether there has been any improper rejection of a nomination is a question of fact depending on the circumstances of each case, and it is clear from the facts of this case as dismissed above that on the material before him at the time of the scrutiny there was no alternative for the Returning Officer but to reject the two nominations. Mr. Doabia has, however, contended that inasmuch as the two proposers were entered as electors in the relevant electoral rolls, though at numbers other than those stated in the nomination papers, their qualification to act as the proposers was not affected by the cancellation of the entries at Nos. 7852 and 7853 according to the supplementary list. It was the mistake of those responsible for preparing the electoral rolls that the names of these two proposers were entered twice over. Hence, according to Mr. Doabia the defect in the two nomination papers was not one of substance and should be ignored in view of the provisions of sub-section (4) of section 36 of the Act. He argued on the Authority of G. Raja Nainar v. N.T Velusami Thevar . A.I.R 1958 Mad. 198., that the jurisdiction of the Election Tribunal is co-extensive with that of the Returning Officer and while the enquiry open to the Returning Officer is summary in its scope, the issue has to be decided by the Tribunal after a trial, and it is open to a Tribunal to consider evidence which was not available to the Returning Officer at the time of the nomination or the scrutiny. It was urged by him that when the Tribunal in the present case found that the names of the two proposers were actually entered in the electoral rolls, it should have held that the rejection of the two nomination papers by the Returning Officer was improper.

    9. The provisions of the Act bearing on the determination of this question are sections 33 and 36. The heading of section 33 is “Presentation of nomination paper and requirements for a valid nomination”. Under sub-section (1) of section 33, nomination paper has to be completed in the prescribed form and signed by the candidate and by an elector of the constituency as proposer. The form prescribed in the present case is 2-B which requires the full name of the proposer as well as the electoral roll number of the proposer. According to the footnote given in that form, the electoral roll number should include “—(i) the name of the assembly constituency, (ii) the serial number of the part of the electoral roll in which the name of the proposer or the candidate, as the case may be, has been entered and (iii) the serial number of the entry in that part.” According to sub-section (4) of section 33, on the presentation of a nomination paper, the Returning Officer shall satisfy himself that the names and electoral roll numbers of the candidate and hip proposer as entered in the nomination paper are the same as those entered in the electoral rolls. The proviso to that sub section lays down that the Returning Officer shall permit any clerical or technical error in the nomination paper in regard to the said names or numbers to be corrected in order to bring them into conformity with the corresponding entries in the electoral rolls; and where necessary, direct that any clerical or printing error in the said entries shall be over coked. The scrutiny of nominations is provided in section 36. On the date fixed for scrutiny the Returning Officer is required to examine the nomination papers and decide all objections which may be made to any nomination, and be may either on such objection or on his own motion, after such summary inquiry, if any, as he thinks necessary, reject any nomination on several grounds, one of which is the failure to comply with any of the provisions of section 33 or section 34 (vide section 36(2)(b). Under sub-section (4) of section 36, the Returning Officer shall not reject any nomination paper on the ground of any defect which is not of a substantial character. The essential question for determination in each case, where nomination paper has been rejected, would, therefore, be whether the defect was of a substantial character.

    10. One of the requirements for a valid nomination is that the candidature must be proposed by an elector of the constituency. The full name and the electoral roll number of the proposer are obviously required to be mentioned in the nomination form in order to enable the Returning Officer to satisfy himself that the proposer is actually an elector of the constituency, and as a matter of fact sub section (4) of section 33 now lays upon the Returning Officer the duty of satisfying himself after comparison with the electoral rolls that such is actually the case. The requirement of mentioning the name and the electoral roll number of the proposer in the nomination form must, therefore, be regarded as a matter of substance and this was also the view expressed in Brij Sunder Sharma v. Election Tribunal Jaipur . A.I.R 1957 Raj. 189., at page 197 as well as in P.N Balasubrahmanyan v. Election Tribunal of North Arcot at Vellore . A.I.R 1954 Mad. 730., at page 733. The latter was a case in which the defect was an omission to mention the name of the constituency in the electoral roll of which the candidate's name was included and the electoral roll number of the candidate himself, but the principle, of course, would be the same if those particulars were omitted or wrongly stated with regard to the proposer of the candidate in the nomination paper. The proviso to sub-section (4) of section 33 makes it clear that the correspondence between the names and electoral roll numbers as entered in the nomination paper with those entered in the electoral rolls need not meticulously be exact and any clerical or technical error would be permitted to be corrected and any clerical or printing error shall be overlooked. All the same there should not be so much divergence between the entries in the nomination paper and the relevant entries in the electoral rolls that the Returning Officer is left in doubt as to whether they relate to the same person. If there is any such doubt and it is not resolved at the scrutiny stage, the Returning Officer has no alternative but to reject the nomination. This appears to be the true cumulative effect of all the relevant provisions of the Act, and also finds support in authority.

    11. In Karnail Singh v. Election Tribunal, Hissar . 10 E.L.R 189. the only defect in the nomination paper was that the name of the sub-division of the electoral constituency was not stated therein, but on the evidence it was clear that there was no difficulty in identifying the candidate and accordingly their Lordships of the Supreme Court held that the defect was not of a substantial character and that the nomination paper should not have been rejected. In the case before us the entries, viz., the electoral roll numbers of the two proposers mentioned in column No. 2 of the nomination papers had been scored out by the supplementary electoral roll, and on the material placed before the Returning Officer during the period of scrutiny it had to be held that the proposers could not be identified with the electors mentioned at these entries. In Rattan Anmol Singh v. Ch. Atma Ram . A.I.R 1954 S.C 510., it was held that when the law enjoins the observance of a particular formality it cannot be disregarded and the substance of the thing must be there. In that case, the substance of the matter was the satisfaction of the Returning Officer at a particular moment of time (which in that case was the stage of nomination) about he identity of the person making a mark in place of writing a signature. In the present case, the Returning Officer had to be satisfied, if not at the stage of nomination at least at the stage of scrutiny, that the two proposers were duly entered as electors, and that also must be regarded a matter of substance. The decision in Rattan Anmol Singh's case was discussed by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Partap Singh v. Shri Krishna Gupta . A.I.R 1956 S.C 140. and the learned counsel for the appellant maintained that the previous view had been at least partially modified. In Pratap Singh's case the question before their Lordships was if under the relevant rules the occupation of the candidate had to be mentioned in the nomination form and their Lordships held that omission to mention the occupation on the nomination paper was not a matter of substance. Here again, the test laid down was that omission did not go to the root of the matter so long as there was any other material in the nomination paper to enable the candidate to be identified beyond doubt. In this sence, there was no modification of the earlier decision in Rattan Anmol Singh's case. The next case requiring consideration is that of Durga Shankar Mehta v. Raghuraj Singh . A.I.R 1954 S.C 520., where it was held that when the candidate appears to be properly qualified on the face of the electoral roll and the nomination paper and no objection is raised to the nomination, the Returning Officer has no other alternative but to accept the nomination, and in that case the acceptance of the nomination paper by the Returning Officer must be deemed to be a proper acceptance. It is certainly not final and the Election Tribunal may, on evidence placed before it, come to a finding that the candidate was not qualified at all, but then the election should be held to be void on the ground of the constitutional disqualification of the candidate and not on the ground that his nomination was improperly accepted by the Returning Officer. This authority gives some indication of the converse proposition, viz., that where the candidate or the proposer is not properly qualified on the face of the electoral roll and the nomination paper and the nomination is rejected, it would be not an improper rejection. In a case such as the present one, where the nomination paper has been rejected on account of the failure to comply with any of the provisions of section 33 (vide clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 36) as distinct from the requirements as to qualification mentioned in clause (a) of the same sub-section), the consideration of the propriety or otherwise of rejection of the nomination papers cannot be divorced from the state of evidence before the Returning Officer at the relevant time. The scheme of the Act is that the various stages in the election process should be gone through in orderly sequence with the greatest possible expedition and leaving at every stage the least possible room for controversy. According to sub section (8) of section 36, immediately after all the nomination papers have been scrutinized and decisions accepting or rejecting the game have been recorded, the Returning Officer shall prepare a list of validly nominated candidates and affix it to his notice board. In a case such as that before us, when the entries with regard to the two proposers, i.e electoral roll Nos. 7852 and 7853, were found to be deleted by the supplementary electoral roll. Exhibit P.W 12/2, and there was nothing before the Returning Officer to show that those entries exited at other numbers, the Returning Officer could not be expected to hold up the scrutiny until he could go through the thousands of names in the entire electoral roll of the constituency in order to discover if possibly the names of the proposers concerned were at some other numbers. It would be, to my mind, immaterial if at some subsequent stage such as that of the trial of the election petition, the candidates concerned could point out that the names of their proposers were entered under totally different serial numbers and at other places in the electoral rolls. To hold in such circumstances that the nomination papers were improperly rejected by the Returning Officer would open the door wide to much uncertainty, expense and chicanery of which there is perhaps already too much in elections. It is conceivable that a candidate may deliberately present a defective nomination paper knowing that it would be rejected at the scrutiny, but in case he failed in the election, to keep an argument in reserve for invalidating the election. I am not unaware that some hardship is involved in the present case. There was a mistake in the preparation of the electoral rolls, because the name of the proposer Rawal Chand (Rawal Ram) was entered at two places in the original electoral roll. Exhibit P.W 12/1, but a reference to the appellant's nomination paper, Exhibit P.W 1.F, would show that the appellant was aware that there was a supplementary electoral roll in as much as the appellant's own name was in that supplementary roll. The, hardships to the returned candidates in such cases would, however, be infinitely greater as they might have to undergo the trouble and expense of fighting election again on account of no fault of theirs. The conclusion, therefore, is that the appellant has failed to show that either of the nominations referred to in issues Nos. 1 and 3 was improperly rejected, and I would, therefore, dismiss the appeal with costs. Counsel' fee Rs. 250 (two hundred and fifty).

    12. Dulat, J.:— I agree.

    13. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Rup Lal v. Shri Jugraj Singh .
    (May 20, 1958)