Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a writ petition filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution by Chaianjit Kaur (the petitioner) seeking a mandamus directing respondents Nos. 2 and 3 — Kurukshetra University and the Chairman, Department of M. Phil. (Hindi) — to admit the petitioner to the M. Phil. course by quashing the admission of Darshan Devi (respondent No. 4).

Relevant facts (as stated in the opinion):

  • The petitioner applied in response to the University's 1989–1990 prospectus and belongs to a Backward Class. She had obtained M.A. (Hindi) from Kurukshetra University with 58.50% marks (Annexure P.2).
  • Darshan Devi (respondent No. 4) also applied under the reserved quota for Backward Class and had obtained 53.44% marks, which was below the minimum standard prescribed (55%).
  • The petitioner challenged the Chairman's act in declining admission to her on merit and admitting Darshan Devi instead.
  • The University and respondent No. 4 defended the admission on the basis of prospectus provisions permitting (a) relaxation up to 5% to make candidates eligible under Regulation VI and (b) weightage (5 marks) for candidates who were Kurukshetra University students and for spouses/children of permanent University employees under Regulation V.
  • The writ petition disputes the admission, argues discriminatory treatment in the rules and challenges the manner in which weightages were applied for preparing the merit list.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the provision in the University's prospectus/regulations that grants a 5% (or 5 marks) weightage to permanent employees of the University (and their spouses/children) is discriminatory and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the respondent No. 4 (Darshan Devi) was rightly admitted in light of the prospectus provisions and the method adopted by the University for calculating merit (including application of relaxations and weightages).
  3. Whether the petitioner can challenge in this writ petition the discriminatory character of the weightage provision where it was contended by respondents that the question was not taken in the writ petition and was fact-dependent (i.e., whether the court should entertain that challenge at this stage).
  4. Whether the method adopted by the University in converting/using weightages (treating “5 marks” as equivalent to 5% when percentages were used) for determining merit was consistent with the Regulations in the prospectus.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The rule providing weightage to spouses/children of University employees is discriminatory and violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision in Ashwinder Kaur v. Punjab University (AIR 1989 P & H 190) to support the contention that such institutional weightage for children/spouses of employees is discriminatory.
  • The petition further contested the method by which weightages and relaxations were applied in preparing the merit list, arguing that the petitioner was ranked below respondent No. 4 by an erroneous application of the Regulations.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The University contended that the prospectus allowed relaxation (up to 5%) under Regulation VI to make candidates eligible and that Regulation V permitted weightage (5 marks) for Kurukshetra University students and for spouses/children of permanent employees; on this basis respondent No. 4 gained merit.
  • Respondents argued that the discrimination challenge should not be allowed because it was not specifically taken in the writ petition and because the issue was not purely one of law but involved facts that, if permitted, would require opportunity to present supporting facts. They relied on the Supreme Court decision in Dr. Jagdish Saran v. Union of India (1980 2 SCC 768) to support the contention that the question ought not to be permitted at that stage.
  • Respondents also contended that the University consistently prepared merit on a percentage basis and gave percentage weightages, and that if that method were held contrary to regulations, a wider upset of admissions might follow; accordingly the decision could have broader consequences.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashwinder Kaur v. Punjab University, AIR 1989 P&H 190 Holds that institutional preference weightages (e.g., studentship, NCC, sports etc.) are permissible if reasonably limited, but a specific 5% weightage to sons/daughters of University Fellows and employees (outside the general cap) is discriminatory and violative of Article 14. The court relied on this authority to conclude that giving weightage exclusively to employees' spouses/children of Kurukshetra University is discriminatory and violative of Article 14; the prior decision was cited as directly on point and applicable on the language of the regulation itself.
Dr. Jagdish Saran v. Union of India, 1980 2 SCC 768 Relied on by respondents to argue that a question not taken in the writ petition and constituting a mixed question of fact and law may not be permitted to be raised without opportunity to place supporting facts on record. The court considered this reliance but expressly held that the petitioner should succeed even if she were not permitted to raise that question; the court therefore proceeded to decide the point on the language of the regulation without requiring further factual pleadings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, relying on the language of the prospectus regulations, comparison of numeric calculations, and the cited precedent:

  1. Preliminary view on justiciability: The court acknowledged respondents' contention (based on Dr. Jagdish Saran) that the discrimination question had not been taken in the writ petition and was fact-dependent. Despite that, the court held the petitioner should succeed even if she were not permitted to raise that question, and considered the matter on the language of the regulations alone.
  2. Application of precedent: The court examined Ashwinder Kaur (supra) and quoted the passage in which institutional preference weightages were held justifiable within reasonable limits but a separate 5% weightage for children of employees/fellows (excluded from the general cap) was held discriminatory under Article 14. The court treated this decision as directly applicable.
  3. Textual analysis of the Regulations: The court reproduced Regulations II, V and VI of the University's 1989–1990 prospectus:
    • Regulation II: Selection on basis of merit in the qualifying examination (M.A./M.Sc./M.Com 100%) with weightages added as defined in Clause V.
    • Regulation V: Weightages — (A) Candidates who passed qualifying exam from Kurukshetra University/M.D. University: 5 marks; (B) Permanent employees of the University, their spouses, their sons/daughters: 5 marks.
    • Regulation VI: Relaxation of eligibility condition — weightage up to 5% marks may be given to certain categories to enable them to become eligible (example provided: to raise 42% to 45% by giving 3% etc.).
  4. Numerical comparison and identification of error in method of computation:
    • The court converted the percentages into marks out of 1600 to compare the candidates consistently (the opinion states these conversions): petitioner 58.50% = 936 marks; respondent No. 4 53.44% = 855 marks.
    • Respondent No. 4 was given a relaxation under Regulation VI amounting to 25 marks to make 55% (880 marks). Then weightage of 5 (K.U. studentship) and 5 (employees' dependent) were added, producing 890 marks for respondent No. 4.
    • The petitioner's marks, with only the relevant weightage for K.U. studentship (5 marks), were 941.
    • Thus, on a correct application of the Regulations (taking 100% marks and adding weightage marks — not converting a 5-mark weightage into 5% in a percentage-based calculation), the petitioner ranked higher than respondent No. 4. The court found the University's method of determining merit by applying percentage weightages (treating 5 marks as if they were 5%) to be erroneous and contrary to Regulation V.
  5. Consequences of correcting the calculation and treatment of discriminatory provision:
    • Even allowing relaxations to respondent No. 4 under Regulation VI, and allowing the weightage that legitimately applied, respondent No. 4 remained below the petitioner when the correct method (marks out of total plus weightage marks) was used.
    • The court held that granting weightage exclusively to present employees/their spouses/children of Kurukshetra University is discriminatory and violative of Article 14 (following Ashwinder Kaur) and therefore such weightage cannot be applied to place respondent No. 4 above the petitioner.
  6. Equitable consideration: The court observed there was no mala fide on the part of respondent No. 4 or the University. Recognising that cancelling an admission already granted to an innocent candidate would cause grave injustice, the court instead directed that the petitioner be admitted and, if necessary, an additional seat be created for her.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The court held that respondent No. 4 (Darshan Devi) was wrongly admitted when the Regulations are properly applied and when the discriminatory weightage given to employees' dependents is disregarded; the petitioner was entitled to admission on merit.

Direct Orders and Relief:

  • The court directed respondents Nos. 2 and 3 (Kurukshetra University and the Chairman, Department of M. Phil. (Hindi)) to admit the petitioner to the M. Phil. course and, if necessary, to create another seat for her.
  • The petitioner was awarded costs of the petition quantified at Rs. 1,000.
  • The opinion notes there was no mala fide on the part of respondent No. 4 and, given the circumstances, cancellation of respondent No. 4's admission would cause grave injustice; therefore, admission of the petitioner is to be provided by creating a seat if required rather than removing respondent No. 4.

Implications: The decision (a) applies the principle from Ashwinder Kaur that a separate weightage exclusively favouring children/spouses of University employees is discriminatory under Article 14 and (b) clarifies that the University's Regulations contemplate adding fixed weightage marks to the candidate's qualifying examination marks (i.e., 100% marks + weightage marks) rather than converting a 5-mark weightage to a 5% increment in percentage calculations in a way that alters merit unjustly. The court stated that its decision affects the parties to this litigation only.

Outcome language in the opinion: "While allowing the writ petition, direction is given to respondents Nos. 2 and 3 to admit the petitioner to the said Course and if necessary to create another seat for her. The petitioner will get costs of the petition which are quantified at Rs. 1,000/-. R.M.S. Appeal allowed."

    Charanjit Kaur v. State Of Haryana And Others

    A.L Bahri, J.:— In this writ petition filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, Chaianjit Kaur, the petitioner, seeks a mandamus directing respondents Nos. 2 and 3, Kurukshetra University and the Chairman, Department of M. Phil. (Hindi) of the said University, to admit the petitioner in M. Phil Course by quashing admission of Darshan Devi, respondent No. 4.

    2. In response to prospectus of the University for the year 1989–1990, the petitioner applied for admission in the said Course. She belongs to Backward Class category. She had passed M.A (Hindi) from the said University securing 58.50 per cent marks as per certificate, Annexure P. 2. Darshan Devi, respondent No. 4, has also applied for admission out of the reserved quota of Backward Class. She had secured 53.44 per cent marks which was below the minimum standard prescribed which was 55 per cent. The act of the Chairman of the Department of M. Phil (Hindi) in declining admission to the petitioner on merit and arbitrarily admitting Darshan Devi, respondent No. 4, was challenged in the writ petition. The University took up the stand that as per prospecutus, by relaxing the rule and allowing weightage upto 5 per cent marks a candidate could be made eligible. Further, as per prospectus, weightage was to be given to the students who had passed the examination from the said University as well as to the spouses/children of permanent employees of the University. In this manner, it was asserted that respondent No. 4 gained merit over the petitioner. Similar stand was taken by Darshan Devi, respondent No. 4 in her written statement.

    3. The position of Charanjit Kaur, the petitioner, as well as Darshan Devi, the respondent, in the matter of giving weightage as shown in the written statement is as under:—

    Respondent No. 4 Petitioner Marks obtained in M.A 53.44% 58.50% Relaxation granted under Regulation VI: 1.56% … Weightage of K.U Studentship: 5.00% 5.00% Weightage of employees' dependent: 5.00% … 65.00% 63.50%

    4. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the rule providing for weightage to be given to spopses/children of the employees of the University is discriminatory and violative of the provisions of the Consitution. In support of this contention, reliance has been placed on the decision of this Court in Ashwinder Kaur v. Punjab University, Chandigarh . AIR 1989 P&H 190.. On the other hand, it has been strongly argued on behalf of the respondents that this question should not be permitted to be raised as the same was not taken up in the writ petition and such question is not purely a question of law or jurisdiction but is dependent upon facts. If opportunity had been given, the relevant facts would have been brought on the record for justifying the rule. In support of this contention, reliance has been placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in Dr. Jagdish Saran v. Union of India . 1980 2 SCC 768.

    5. I have given due consideration to these arguments and I am of the view that the petitioner should succeed even if she is not allowed to raise this question. Ashwinder Kaur's case (supra) related to the interpretation of rules and regulations of the Punjab University relating to admission to M. Lib. and Information Science. The question of granting weightage on different counts was considered and Amarjeet Chahdhary, J. observed as under:—

    “I have looked into this aspect. I consider that the weightages by way of institutional preference (students of Punjab University) certificates of N.C.C, N.S.S, participation in sports, Youth Welfare and Cultural activities, promotion of adult education and the like, are both justifiable and reasonable, so long as these are restricted to a reasonable limit. The maximum weightage on all these counts have been fixed by the University at 15% of the marks. This, to my mind is reasonable. I, however, find that there is weightage of 5% marks to sons/daughters of Fellows and employees (both serving and retired) of the University which is excluded from the operation of the restriction of 15%. I consider that such weightage to students for being children of employees/fellows of University, is discriminatory in nature and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.”

    6. The question of the regulation being arbitrary or discriminatory can be decided on its own language, without going into the facts of the present case.

    7. Regulations II, V and VI of the Prospectus for Admission to Master of Philosophy (M. Phil.) 1989–1990 of the University read as under:—

    “II. Selection Procedure:

    The admission to M. Phil. Course will be made on the basis of merit in the qualifying examination i.e Master's Degree in the relevant subject only subject to the fulfilment of the eligibility condition. The weightage of marks for the purpose of merit will be added as under:—

    (i) M.A/M.Sc/M Com. 100% (ii) Weightages (as defined under Clause V)

    xxxxxx

    V. Weightages for the Purpose of Merit:

    (A) Candidates who have passed the qualifying examination from Kurukshetra University/M.B.U Rohtak … 5 marks

    (B) Permanent employees of the University, their spouses, their sons/daughters.… 5 marks

    VI. Relaxation of the Condition of Eligibility:

    A weightage upto 5% marks shall be given to the following categories of candidates to enable them to become eligible. For example, if a candidate has obtained 42% marks, he/she will be given a weightage of only 3% marks so as to raise it to 45% marks i.e minimum eligibility condition. However, in case of a tie amongst such candidates as have been given this weightage their original marks would be taken into account. In the case of Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribes candidates, percentage of marks may be relaxed upto 7-10% if the seats reserved for them are not filled up with 5% relaxation:—

    (i) Scheduled Castes/Tribes/Socially Backward Classes (not for economically Backward Classes)

    (ii) Dependents of Military Personnel killed in action or Military Personnel permanently disabled in action or their dependents.

    (iii) Blind candidates.”

    8. By relaxation of the regulation and giving weightage upto 5% marks, candidates are made eligible. As per example given in Regulation VI, as reproduced above, 3% marks are given to raise it to 45% if the marks obtained are 42% and in the case of Scheduled Caste students relaxation can be upto 7-10% if the seats reserved for them are not filled up with 5% relaxation. The weightage of 5 marks is given if the candidate had passed the qualifying examination from Kurukshetra University or M.D University and 5 marks weightage is given to permanent employees of the University, their spouses, sons or daughters. Allowing of weightage to students of Colleges affiliated to Kurukshetra University and M.D University, as provided in Regulation V(A), is valid on the ground of institutional preference. However, allowing weightage to the present employees, their spouses, sons and daughters of Kurukshetra University only is discriminatory in nature and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

    9. The further question for consideration is as to whether Darshan Devi, respondent No. 4, was rightly admitted to the Course, if not, to what effect and as to whether the petitioner was wrongly denied admission. The method adopted by the respondents for the grant of admission under the regulations by giving weightages has already been reproduced above. The merits of the petitioner and respondent No. 4 has also been reproduced above from the written statement. Marks obtained in qualifying M. A have been calculated in percentage. In the case of the petitioner, it is 58.5% and in the case of respondent No. 4, it is 53.44%. Regulation II, as reproduced above, does not contemplate for taking into consideration for the purposes of determining merit, percentage of marks. What is contemplated is that 100% marks would be taken into consideration and to the same is to be added weightage marks. If that is so, the position with respect to the Petitioner vis-a-vis respondent No. 4 would be as under:—

    Respondent No. 4 Petitioner Marks obtained in M.A (out of 1600) : 855 936 Relaxation granted under : 25 … Regulation VI to make 55% : 880 … Weightage of K.U studentship : 5 5 Weightage of employees dependent : 5 … 890 941

    10. This would show that in spite of weightage to the extent of 1.50% being given to respondent No. 4 to make her eligible and giving other weightages, she would rank below to the petitioner as her marks would be 890 whereas petitioner's marks would be 941. Respondent No. 4 would rank below the petitioner if weightage on account of being relation of employees of the University is excluded.

    11. While determining merit, as has been done by the respondent-University, calculations are made on percentage, meaning thereby that instead 5 marks each for weightage for K.U studentship and employees' dependents, 5% marks were given. Five marks given to respondent No. 4 are being compared with 5% marks obtained by the petitioner. To further elucidate it, these 5 marks are made equivalent to 5% marks of 1600 marks i.e 80 marks obtained in the qualifying’ examination by the petitioner. In this way, the petitioner is put to loss. The weightage regarding studentship of Kurukshetra University has to be given to both the petitioner as well as respondent No. 4 of five marks. That will not make any difference while determining their merit. Thus in the process, when the petitioner did not get any weightage of 5% marks and, such weightage was given to respondent No. 4. she was shown above the petitioner in merit. This error is apparent. The method adopted by the respondent Not. 2 and 3 in determining merit is not warranted by Regulation V. referred to above. Respondent No. 4 Darshan Devi was thus wrongly admitted to the Course.

    12. It has been argued on behalf of the respondents that for preparing merit, only percentage of marks is taken into consideration and for giving weightage also, percentage of marks is given. This procedure is being followed by the University and if the same is held to be against the regulations, the entire admission had to be upset. This contention cannot be accepted. The decision in this case would effect the parties only.

    13. There was no fault of Darshan Devi, respondent No. 4, in getting admission to the Course No mala fides are attributed either to respondent No. 4 or the University in granting her admission in the circumstances, even if now it is held that she was wrongly admitted to the Course, it would cause gave injustice to her if her admission is cancelled. In the peculiar facts of the case, Charanjit Kaur petitioner is entitled to admission to the Course on merit and she was wrongly denied the same. While allowing the writ petition, direction is given to respondents Nos. 2 and 3 to admit the petitioner to the said Course and if necessary to create another seat for her. The petitioner will get costs of the petition which are quantified at Rs. 1,000/-.

    R.M.S
    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Charanjit Kaur v. State Of Haryana And Others
    (Nov 11, 1989)