Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This batch of appeals involves four appellants convicted under various sections of the Indian Penal Code in connection with the unnatural death of Pushpa Kumari on 28.12.1994. Pushpa Kumari, married to Munendra Singh, died from extensive burns in her marital home in Village Morsand, District Sitamarhi. Her brother, Ram Vinay Singh, lodged a report alleging dowry-related ill-treatment by her in-laws. The police investigated, arrested the accused, and submitted chargesheets. The appellants were convicted under Section 302/34 IPC (murder), Sections 304B (dowry death), 498A (cruelty by husband or relatives), and 201 IPC (causing disappearance of evidence), with sentences running concurrently. The trial court convicted the appellants accordingly. The appeals challenge these convictions and sentences.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the offence under Section 304B IPC (dowry death) is made out given the dispute over the date of marriage and whether death occurred within seven years of marriage.
  2. Whether the appellants can be convicted under Section 306 IPC (abetment of suicide) despite no charge being framed for this offence.
  3. Whether all appellants, including in-laws living separately, can be held liable under Section 306 IPC and Section 201 IPC (causing disappearance of evidence).
  4. The effect of omission to frame a charge under Section 306 IPC on the validity of conviction for that offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The marriage between Pushpa Kumari and Munendra Singh occurred prior to 1987, thus the death did not occur within seven years and Section 304B IPC is not applicable.
  • The prosecution failed to prove the essential ingredients of Section 304B IPC, so the burden of proof to establish murder under Section 302 IPC rests on the prosecution.
  • Evidence suggests that the deceased committed suicide, as the room was found bolted from inside and had to be broken open to rescue her.
  • The in-laws, living separately from the deceased and husband, cannot be convicted under Section 306 IPC.
  • The in-laws cannot be convicted under Section 201 IPC as suicide is not an offence and mere participation in cremation does not amount to causing disappearance of evidence.

State's Arguments

  • Discrepancies in the school name on the Admit Card and informant’s evidence do not invalidate the date of marriage evidence.
  • There is evidence of cruelty and harassment for dowry, supporting the charge under Section 304B IPC.
  • Even though no charge was framed under Section 306 IPC, the appellants can be convicted under this section to prevent failure of justice, relying on provisions of Sections 221 and 222 CrPC.
  • The in-laws, despite living separately, had knowledge of the circumstances and participated in acts that amount to abetment and causing disappearance of evidence under Section 201 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G.D Sharma v. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1960 SC 400 Conviction for an offence not charged can be upheld by appellate court without ordering retrial. The court relied on this precedent to convict appellants under Section 306 IPC despite no charge framed.
Willie (William) Slaney v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1956 SC 116 Effect of omission to frame charge and the validity of conviction. Supported the court’s view that omission to frame a charge does not necessarily invalidate conviction if no failure of justice occurred.
Palvinder Kaur v. State Of Punjab (I), AIR 1952 SC 354 Offence under Section 201 IPC requires knowledge of commission of an offence. Considered in evaluating whether in-laws could be convicted under Section 201 IPC despite suicide not being an offence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the evidence regarding the date of marriage and concluded that the marriage occurred before 1987, which excludes the applicability of Section 304B IPC requiring death within seven years of marriage. The prosecution failed to prove this essential ingredient, leading the court to reject the dowry death charge.

Evidence from witnesses indicated that the room was bolted from inside and had to be forcibly opened, supporting the theory that the deceased committed suicide rather than being set on fire by the appellants.

Although no charge under Section 306 IPC was framed, the court invoked Sections 221 and 222 CrPC, which allow conviction for offences proved by evidence even if not formally charged, to prevent failure of justice. The court found sufficient evidence of abetment of suicide by the husband and in-laws.

The court distinguished liability under Section 306 IPC, holding that only the husband, who lived with the deceased, could be convicted, while the in-laws living separately were given the benefit of doubt and acquitted of that offence.

Regarding the offence under Section 201 IPC, the court held that the in-laws who were present at the burning site could be convicted for causing disappearance of evidence, as they had knowledge of the abetment and participated in acts related to the crime. The father-in-law, who was not present, was acquitted.

The court also noted that the sentences already undergone by the appellants served the ends of justice and no further imprisonment was necessary.

Holding and Implications

Cr. Appeal No. 493/98 is allowed, resulting in acquittal of Siyaram Singh (father-in-law) of all charges.

Cr. Appeal Nos. 481/98 and 505/98 are allowed in part, modifying convictions and sentences of Narendra Singh and Amrendra Singh (brothers-in-law) and Munendra Singh (husband) as follows:

  • The appellants are acquitted of Section 304B IPC charges.
  • Munendra Singh is convicted under Section 306 IPC and Section 498A IPC, with sentence commuted to time already served.
  • Narendra Singh and Amrendra Singh are convicted under Section 201 IPC but not sentenced to further imprisonment beyond time served.

The appellant Munendra Singh is directed to be released if not wanted in any other case.

The decision does not set a new precedent but clarifies the application of Sections 221 and 222 CrPC in cases of omission to frame charges and delineates liability under Sections 306 and 201 IPC in the context of dowry-related cruelty and suicide.

    Narendra Singh Alias Narendra Kumar Singh Alias Chunnu Singh (In 481) v. Amarendra Singh Alias Amrendra Kumar Singh Alias Nipul Singh (In 481)

    S.N Jha and P.N Yadav, JJ.:— There are in all four appellants in this batch of appeals. They have been convicted under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life. They have also been convicted under Sections 304B, 498A & 201 of the Penal Code and sentenced respectively to rigorous imprisonment for five years, two years and two years thereunder. The sentences have been ordered to run concurrently. While appellants of Cr. Appeal No. 481/98 are brothers-in-law (Dewars) of the deceased, the appellant of Cr. Appeal No. 493/98 is the father-in-law and the appellant of Cr. Appeal No. 505/98 is the husband.

    2. The case relates to an incident of 28.12.94 in which Pushpa Kumari, sister of Ram Vinay Singh of Village Tilak Taj, PS Runni Saidpur, District Sitamarhi died unnatural death in her sasural at Village Morsand, PS Runni Saidpur, District Sitamarhi. Ram Vinay Singh lodged written report before the Officer Incharge, Ranchi Saidpur PS on the same day i.e on 28.12.94 at 4.30 PM. He stated that his sister Pushpa Kumari was married to Munendra Singh, the appellant in Cr. Appeal No. 505/98 on 28.2.89 She had been burnt to death at noon. He stated that earlier she was ill treated by her in-laws for dowry. The above report gave rise to Runni Saidpur PS Case No. 251/94 and investigation commenced. The Officer Incharge, SI Yogendra Paswan, on receipt of the report, went to Village Morsand and on coming to know that the dead body had been taken to Chakwa Ghat for cremation went there and seized the dead body of Pushpa Kumari. He also arrested Narendra Singh @ Narendra Kumar Singh @ Chunnu Singh, Amrendra Singh alias Amrendra Kumar Singh, the appellant of Cr. Appeal No. 481/98 and brothers-in-law of the deceased, and Munendra Singh, the husband, at the Ghat. The dead body was sent for autopsy which was performed by Dr. Vijyendra Satyarthi, on the next day i.e 29.10.94 at 1 PM. The doctor found the whole body was burnt and charred except both sides, inner part of the right thigh, outer part of left thigh and back side of scalp with hair. The extent of burn was assessed at 90 per cent. The doctor opened different parts of the body but did not find any mark of injury. The statement of the witnesses. (sic) After completing the necessary formalities he submitted chargesheet against the appellants who were thus put on trial.

    3. At the trial the prosecution examined ten witnesses to prove its case. Out of them PW 5 Sanjay Kumar Singh and PW 6 Radhey Shyam Singh were declared hostile while PW 4 Rajendra Jha and PW 7 Kaushal Kishore Singh were tendered. PW 1 Pradeep Kumar and PW 2 Uday Shanker Singh were examined on the point of inquest. The latter however too turned hostile. The Investigating Officer SI Yogendra Paswan was examined as PW 9 while the doctor who had held autopsy was examined as PW 10. PW 3 Sunil Singh and PW 8 Ram Binay Singh, the informant are thus material witnesses on facts who supported the prosecution case.

    4. The appellants also examined one witness Satyanarayan Singh in defence to prove the handwriting of the deceased Pushpa Kumari and the date of marriage. It may be mentioned here itself that according to the appellants the marriage between Pushpa Kumari and Munendra Singh had taken place seven years prior to her death and therefore the case does not come within the mischief of Section 304B of the Penal Code. It may also be mentioned that from the trend of cross-examination and suggestions put to the witnesses, particularly the informant, the appellants tried to make out a case that the deceased had committed suicide.

    5. At the end of the trial the trial court convicted and sentenced the appellants in the manner indicated above.

    6. Shri Prakash Narayan Pandey, learned counsel for the appellants, firstly submitted that Pushpa Kumari was married to Munendra Singh prior to 1987. The occurrence having taken place on 28.12.94, the offence under Section 304B of the Penal Code is not made out. He submitted that only when the essential ingredients of Section 304B IPC are proved, to wit-that the deceased died within seven years of her marriage, that she died an unnatural death and that soon before her death she had been subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or in-laws for or in connection with demand for dowry-that the offence under Section 304B can be said to have been committed so as to shift the burden of proof on the accused in terms of Section 113B of the Evidence Act. Inasmuch as the prosecution failed to prove that the death was within seven years of marriage the offence under Section 304B is not made out and therefore, onus lay on the prosecution to prove its case that the appellants had killed the deceased. He referred to Ext A which is the Admit Card of the Bihar School Examination Board in the name of Pushpa Kumari with respect to the Secondary School Examination commencing on 20.3.87 Shri Pandey submitted that witness no less than the informant himself in para 13 of his evidence stated that the deceased appeared at the Matriculation (Secondary School) examination after her marriage and that the Admit Card, if any, must be in possession of the accused. The Admit card admittedly was produced by the appellants. The date of commencement of the examination, as per the said Admit Card, being 20.3.87, Counsel submitted, it would follow that Pushpa Kumari was married earlier.

    7. On behalf of the State it was submitted that there is discrepancy in the description of the School as mentioned in the Admit Card and the one as mentioned by the informant in his evidence. Whereas, according to the informant, Pushpa Kumari had appeared at the Matriculation examination from Dhanaur School, in the Admit Card the name of the School was mentioned as High School, Gangewa. The submission appears, prima facie attractive but cannot be accepted, for, no such suggestion was made to the witness namely DW 1 who proved the Admit Card. As a matter of fact, the Admit Card was taken in evidence without objection. It is relevant to mention here except the Admit Card there is no other evidence on the point of date of marriage except oral evidence of the informant. However whereas in the written report the informant had mentioned the date of marriage as 28.2.89 in his evidence in Court he stated that the marriage was performed sometime in the year 1993. Even if the reference to the date in evidence is treated as slip of tongue, because the witness also stated about three years' old daughter of the deceased, in the face of documentary evidence i.e Ext. A. We find it difficult to accept that the marriage was within seven years of death. In any view, in his evidence the informant did not disclose any date of marriage. In these premises. We are inclined to accept the submission of the Counsel for the appellants that the marriage was performed before 1987 and if that is so, the case would clearly fall out of the realm of Section 304B of the Penal Code.

    8. Counsel for the appellants next submitted that there is evidence vide PWs 3, 5 and 6 who visited the place of occurrence and saw the dead body, to suggest that the room in which the occurrence took place was bolted from inside. It is true, Counsel submitted, that PWs 5 and 6 were declared hostile but it does not mean that every part of their evidence should be discarded, particularly when their evidence on the point is consistent with PW 3 who too stated that the door of the room had to be broken open. The Investigating Officer in course of spot inspection found bolt of the door broken which according to the Counsel, corroborates the evidence of aforesaid witnesses. In the circumstances, we are inclined to place reliance on the evidence of PWs 5 and 6, besides PW 3, to the effect that the room was bolted from inside and the door had to be broken open when smoke billowing out of the room was seen by the witnesses and suspecting something foul they rushed there and finding the door bolted from inside broke it open. The circumstance that the room was found closed and door bolted from inside, none being there, is sufficient to demolish the prosecution case of the appellants setting the deceased on fire. The circumstance strongly suggests that the deceased committed suicide.

    9. A question would arise as to whether the appellants can be convicted under Section 306 of the Penal Code notwithstanding that no charge was framed for the said offence against them. Such a question arises in view of the letters (Exts 3 & 3/1) which the deceased had written from her sasural, besides the oral evidence of the informant to the effect that the deceased was being subjected to cruelty for dowry. If a married woman is subjected to cruelty in sasural this may abet her to commit suicide. Section 107 of the Penal Code defines ‘abetment’ in the following manner:

    “A person abets the doing of a thing who-

    First ………

    Secondly …….

    Thirdly - Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the doing of that thing.”

    10. It is true that no charge under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code was framed against the appellants. However where a number of charges could be joined together but one or more of them are not put in, there can be conviction in respect of those offences despite absence of the particular charge to prevent failure of justice in cases where commission of the offence is otherwise proved. Reference in this connection may be made to Sections 221 and 222 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Sub-section (1) of Section 221 provides that where it is doubtful which of several offences the facts which can be proved will constitute, the accused may be charged with all or any of such offences. In such a case, under sub-section (1) if it appears in evidence that he committed a different offence for which he might have been charged under sub-section (1), he may be convicted of the offence which he is shown to have committed, although he was not charged with it. The illustrations appended to the Section may usefully be noticed as under:

    (a) A is accused of an act which may amount to theft, or receiving stolen property, or criminal breach of trust or cheating. He may be charged with theft, receiving stolen property, criminal breach of trust and cheating, or he may be charged with having, committed theft, or receiving stolen property or criminal breach of trust or cheatinig.

    (b) In the case mentioned, A is only charged with theft, it appears that he committed the offence of criminal breach of trust, or that of receiving stolen goods. He may be convicted of criminal breach of trust or of receiving stolen goods (as the case may be) though he was not charged with such offence.”

    11. Section 222 of the Code of Criminal Procedure too provides that when a person is charged with an offence consisting of several particulars, a combination of some only of which constitutes a complete minor offence, and such combination is proved, but the remaining particulars are not proved, he may be convicted of the minor offence, though he was not charged with it.

    12. The two ingredients of Section 306 of the Penal Code are (a) commission of suicide by a person and (b) that the accused abetted commission thereof. We have already noticed the definition of abetment under Section 107 of the Penal Code, and in terms of clause ‘thirdly’ where a person intentionally by an act or illegal omission, aids doing of anything he will be said to have abetted the crime.

    13. In the instant case, there is evidence to suggest that the deceased was subjected to cruelty for or in connection with demand for dowry soon before her death. It is only because she died beyond the period of seven years of marriage that the offence described under Section 304B of the Penal Code has been held to be not made out. If the death were within seven years the case would have fallen within the mischief of Section 304B. Any act of cruelty committed in sasural by the husband and in-laws often drives a married woman to desperation forcing her to take the extreme step of committing suicide. In terms of Section 222 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as seen above where the combination of only some particulars constituting a minor offence is proved, the accused may be covicted of that minor offence. As the prosecution has failed to prove only one particular constituting the graver offence under Section 304B, namely, that the death took place within seven years of marriage, but succeeded in proving other particulars constituting a different minor offence under Section 306 Penal Code. We are inclined to think that the case will fall within the mischief of Section 306 of the Code.

    14. The ordinary rule undoubtedly is that the accused could be charged specifically with all the offences he is alleged to have committed. However Sections 221 and 222 of the Criminal Procedure Code amongst others are exception to the ordinary rule so that the accused may not be let off on technical ground i.e omission to frame charge. Section 464 of the Criminal Procedure Code also provides that no finding, sentence or order by a Court of competent jurisdiction shall be deemed invalid merely on the ground that no charge was framed or on the ground of any error, omission or irregularity in the charge including any misjoinder of charge, unless, in the opinion of the Court of appeal, confirmation or revision, a failure of justice has in fact been occasioned thereby. Section 464 no doubt occurs in a different context but gives indication of the fact that omission to frame a particular charge inter alia does not go to the root of the matter.

    15. We are conscious of the fact that in such a case retrial is one option which the appellate court may consider. However, the Supreme Court in G.D Sharma v. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1960 SC 400, took the view that in such cases the appropriate course for the appellate court would be to convict the accused for the offence though he had not been charged for the same without ordering retrial. On the point of omission to frame charge and the effect thereof reference may also be made to the well known case of Willie (William) Slaney v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh , AIR 1956 SC 116. In these premises we are of the view that the appellants can be convicted for the offence under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code.

    16. Counsel for the appellants submitted that even then there cannot be any justification to convict the in-laws, except the husband, of the offence under Section 306, for, there is evidence coming from the mouth of the informant himself that they lived in another house at a distance of one and a half kilometers from the house in which the deceased and her husband, appellant Munendra Singh, lived and in which the occurrence took place. Though the circumstances which led the deceased to commit suicide are not known but the fact that the in-laws lived in another house, in our opinion, is sufficient to give them the benefit of doubt so far as the offence under Section 306 IPC is concerned. It would follow that the husband i.e Munendra Singh alone would be guilty of the offence under Section 306 of the Penal Code. Section 306 provides for punishment up to ten years. The appellant has remained in jail for more than five years. The occurrence having taken place eight years ago it would meet the ends of justice to sentence him for the period already undergone under Section 306 IPC. His conviction under Section 498A of the Penal Code for which he has been awarded sentence of two years is also maintained. Coming to the conviction under Section 201 of the Penal Code, though the in-laws have been held not guilty of the offence under Section 306 of the Penal Code, that per se may not be enough to acquit them of the charge under Section 201 of the Penal Code. In this regard Counsel for the appellants submitted that the in-laws cannot be convicted under Section 201 of the Penal Code. He stated that so far as the factual aspect is concerned, the Investigating Officer found presence of only Narendra Singh @ Narendra Kumar Singh @ Chunnu Singh and Amarendra Singh @ Amrendra Kumar Singh @ Nipul Singh at the burning Ghat and therefore Siyaram Singh, the father-in-law, in any case cannot be held guilty. As a matter of fact Counsel submitted that in view of the law laid down in Palvinder Kaur v. State Of Punjab (I), AIR 1952 SC 354, none of the in-laws can be held guilty for the reason that the offence under Section 201 of the Code can be made out only if the act is committed with knowledge of the commission of any offence. He pointed out that committing suicide is not an offence and therefore if the in-laws participated in the cremation of the dead body, they cannot be held guilty under Section 201. The submission appears to be attractive but difficult to accept. It is true that committing suicide is not an offence but, certainly, abetting commission of suicide is an offence under Section 306 for which appellant Munendra Singh has been found guilty. Though the in-laws did not live in the same house it is difficult to believe that they were unware of the circumstances in which the occurrence took place and if with knowledge of the acts overtly or covertly committed by Munendra Singh abetting the commission of suicide by the deceased, they participated in the crime they would be guilty of the offence under Section 201 of the Penal Code. Of course, Siyaram Singh, the father-in-law, not being present at the place he cannot be convicted of that offence. In the circumstances, we hold Narendra Singh alias Narendra Kumar Singh alias Chunnu Singh and Amrendra Singh alias Amrendra Kumar Singh alias Nipul Singh, the appellants in Cr. Appeal No. 481/98, as well as Munendra Singh, the appellant in Cr. Appeal No. 505/1998, guilty of the offence under Section 201 of the Penal Code. As regards sentence, keeping in view the fact that the former two also remained in jail for some time and the occurrence took place eight years ago it would not be proper to send them to jail at this stage. The sentence of imprisonment already undergone by them, as also Munendra Singh, would serve the ends of justice.

    17. In the result, Cr. Appeal No. 493/98 is allowed. The conviction and sentence awarded to Siyaram Singh is set aside and he is acquitted of the charges. Cr. Appeal Nos. 481/98 and 505/98 are allowed in part. The conviction and sentence awarded to the appellants therein, namely Narendra Singh alias Narendra Kumar Singh alias Chunnu Singh and Amrendra Singh alias Amrendra Kumar Singh alias Nipul Singh, are modified in the manner and to the extent mentioned above. They are discharged of the liability of the bail bonds. Cr. Appeal No. 505/98 is dismissed with the modification in conviction and sentence. The appellant, Munendra Singh, is in jail. He is directed to be released forthwith if not wanted in any other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narendra Singh Alias... v. Amarendra Singh Alia...
    (Jan 7, 2003)