Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Untwalia, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a minor student applying through his father, Shree Diwakar Jha, who was posted as Assistant Director of Agriculture at Netarhat Farm. The dispute concerns admission to Netarhat Residential School, a government-managed residential school providing instruction up to higher secondary level and situated in a remote area where no other nearby high/higher-secondary school exists within a 20-mile radius.

The petitioner's father was transferred to Netarhat on 16 October 1968 and applied to the Principal (respondent no. 2) for admission of his 14-year-old son into class X. The school, however, normally admits students only into the lowest class (entry by a competitive test) and ordinarily admits no day-scholars except limitedly for wards of school employees.

The petition challenges Government Instruction No. 2892 dated 12 August 1965 (annexed to the petition) under which up to 72 day-scholar seats (across six classes — effectively up to 12 per class) are available for children of school employees; the petitioner sought a declaration that the instruction is ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution and a mandamus directing admission either directly or on merit. The writ petition was filed on 18 September 1969 and supplemented in December 1969 to record further admissions made under the circular. A counter-affidavit was filed by the State defending the scheme; an intervening teacher was permitted to address the Court without formal joinder.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Government Instruction No. 2892 dated 12 August 1965 (providing for limited admission of day-scholars who are wards of school employees) is ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to a writ of mandamus directing admission either into the reserved day-scholar seats (one of the 72) or on merits.
  3. Whether the petitioner can be admitted into class X (a higher class) contrary to the school's established system of admitting students only into the lowest class via competitive examination.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (through his father) contended that the Government instruction dated 12 August 1965, as implemented by the Principal, violates Article 14 by discriminating in favour of certain categories (specifically, wards of government employees or school employees) and sought the instruction to be declared ultra vires.
  • The petition sought a mandamus directing admission into the reserved seats for day-scholars or, alternatively, admission on merits.
  • The petitioner's case included a factual assertion that, for residents of Netarhat, this school is the only available high school, so denial of admission would frustrate the child's ability to pursue higher studies locally.

State / Respondent's Arguments

  • The State explained the background and purpose of the school as a residential institution modelled on public schools and emphasised the need to attract and retain teachers of high calibre; certain facilities (including fee concessions and day-scholar admission for wards of school employees) were extended as service-related benefits.
  • Government Order No. 2892 (12 August 1965) extended facilities to specific categories of school employees (including bursar, P.A., and lower-grade staff) on conditions that day-scholar admissions in a year not exceed 72 and that priority be given to children of teachers.
  • The State pointed out that regular admission is by competitive test into the lowest class (60 residential boarder seats per class) and that the arrangement for day-scholars did not practically increase expenditure or boarding-house accommodation; it was not extended to all government employees posted at Netarhat.
  • The State also stated that a general question of extending facilities to children of all government servants at Netarhat was under consideration and that the petitioner could not be admitted before a government decision was taken. It was also emphasised that there is no system of admitting students to higher classes by transfer certificates — admission is to the entry class only.

Intervenor / Other Participants

  • A teacher of the school (Shree Ram Krishna Bhatnagar) applied for and was allowed to address the Court, contending that he would be affected by any decision striking down the reservation; his counsel addressed the Court on that basis. The record does not contain a detailed argument from him beyond the fact of his intervention and the basis that he would be affected.
  • An affidavit by a friend of the petitioner's father disputed aspects of the State's counter-affidavit but did not contradict the State's statement that admission is by competitive test into the lowest class.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Umesh Chandra Sinha v. V.N. Singh (A.I.R. 1968 Patna 3) Full Bench held that reservation of seats for children of University employees (on grounds of pecuniary difficulty and meritorious service) was discriminatory because there was no reasonable nexus between the object sought to be achieved and the principle of preferential selection. The Court considered this decision but distinguished it: the Full Bench rejection related to university admissions where the sole object was student admission to a course. In contrast, the Netarhat scheme was regarded as a service-related facility to attract teachers in a remote school and not merely a measure altering the composition of admitted students for academic purposes.
Kumari Chitra Ghosh v. Union of India (A.I.R. 1970 Supreme Court 35) The Supreme Court upheld reservation of seats for various categories in Maulana Azad Medical College. The Court cited this decision to indicate that reservation may be sustained in some contexts. It served as an analytic foil: the Court compared the two lines of authority to assess whether the Netarhat facility was constitutionally permissible, concluding that the factual distinctions supported upholding the school employees' facility.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a fact-sensitive analysis focused on (i) the school's established admission system and (ii) the character and object of the challenged governmental facility. The analysis unfolded in these principal steps:

  1. Admission Practice and Petitioner's Claim: The Court noted the undisputed practice that regular admissions are by competitive test into the entry (lowest) class and that there is no established system for admitting students into higher classes on the basis of transfer certificates. The petitioner sought admission into class X (a higher class), which departed from the school's admission practice. The Court examined the father's request letter and concluded that, given the petitioner's asserted desire for admission into class X, the letter could not be read as a readiness to accept admission into the entry class.
  2. Nature and Purpose of the Government Instruction: The Court accepted the State's factual account that the Netarhat school is remote, that attracting competent teachers is essential to its success, and that limited facilities (including day-scholar admission for wards of school employees) were extended as service-related benefits. The Court emphasised that these facilities were not given by increasing the school's boarding-house accommodation or the standard 60-seat class size for residential students; rather, the arrangement permitted limited day-scholars (up to 12 per class) without extra expenditure.
  3. Distinguishing Precedent and Evaluating Rational Nexus: The Court analysed the Full Bench decision in Umesh Chandra Sinha and the Supreme Court decision in Kumari Chitra Ghosh. While recognising that reservation for categories of persons can be unconstitutional when there is no reasonable nexus between the object and the basis for preferential treatment (as in Umesh Chandra Sinha), the Court found a material distinction here. The limited facility at Netarhat was a service condition intended to secure efficient teachers in a remote school (a personnel/service object), not an arbitrary redistribution of higher education places. Thus the rational nexus required under Article 14 was present on the facts put forward by the State.
  4. Equality Considerations and Scope of Relief: The Court observed that the school's employees' posts are non-transferable, whereas other government employees at Netarhat are posted on transfer and not permanently resident. Asking the State to extend the same day-scholar facility to all government employees posted at Netarhat — or to admit the petitioner in a higher class outside the school's system — would, in the Court's view, create an impermissible inequality and risk infringing Article 14. The Court also noted the procedural/standing limitation that it could not, at the petitioner's instance and on these facts, strike down the reservation scheme.
  5. Conclusion from the Combined Analysis: Considering the school's remote location, the service-object of the facility, its limited scope and the lack of additional expenditure or increase in residential capacity, the Court concluded that the reservation for children of school employees could not be struck down on the facts before it and the petitioner's claim to admission (particularly to a higher class) could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ application is dismissed. The Court refused to declare Government Instruction No. 2892/12-8-1965 ultra vires Article 14 or to direct admission of the petitioner to the school. The Court made no order as to costs. (Order affirmed by B.P. Sinha, J.)

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner is not granted admission and the challenged Government instruction was not set aside in this proceeding; the limited facility for admission of wards of school employees remains unaffected by this decision.
  • Broader legal statement: The Court distinguished the Full Bench decision in Umesh Chandra Sinha and the Supreme Court decision in Kumari Chitra Ghosh on their facts and concluded that a service-related facility to attract teachers in a remote residential school, limited in scope and not increasing residential accommodation or overall class capacity, was not shown on the record to violate Article 14. The Court did not purport to lay down a sweeping new principle beyond the factual distinctions described.

Disposition recorded in the opinion: "Application dismissed." No order as to costs. B.P. Sinha, J. agreed.

    Shiva Shankar Jha v. State Of Bihar & Another

    Untwalia, J.:— The petitioner in this writ case is a minor student, who has presented this application through his father Shree Diwakar Jha, posted as Assistant Director of Agriculture at Netarhat Farm, Netarhat, Police station Mahuadanr, in the District of Palamau.

    2. The case of the petitioner is that there is a Government school, called Netarhat Residential School, located at Netarhat, where students are taught upto the higher secondary standard. It appears, the school is financed and managed under the Government of Bihar. Hence, the State of Bihar, through the Secretary to the Government of Bihar, in the Education Department is respondent no. 1 and respondent no. 2 in the application is the Principal of the school. The petitioner's father was transferred on the 16th October, 1968, from Barharwa in the District of Santhal Parganas to Netarhat, as Assistant Director of Agriculture. His case is that for the people residing in Netarhat, the only high school, within the radius of 20 miles is the school in question. If admission is refused in this school, it becomes impossible for the guardian of the child to arrange prosecution of his studies for the high school standard. The petitioner's father made an application to respondent no. 2 for the admission of the petitioner, who was aged 14 years, in class X of the school. It may be stated here that there are only six classes in the school, the sixth and the highest class being class XI, equivalent to higher secondary and class X spoken of in Paragraph 5 of the application would be next to the highest class.

    3. The petitioner's case further is that having failed to secure his admission, his father approached the Commissioner of the Division for reservation of some seats for the children of the employees of the Government. The Commissioner also tried in the matter. Upon this the Education Department of the Government of Bihar invited comments from respondent no. 2, who gave favourable comments for reservation of seats in the school for the children of other Government employees. There are 72 reserved seats in all the six classes of the school for the sons and daughters of the employees of the school employees of all kinds, members of the teaching staff, the clerical staff and the staff of the lower grades. The Principal, however, could not admit the petitioner as the Government order was not received for admission of the ward of any other Government employee. The petitioner's case is that respondent of no. 2 has acted in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India, inasmuch as he is implementing the Government instruction No. 2892 dated the 12th August, 1965, which is referred to in his letter to the Education Department, a copy of which is Annexure ‘2’ to the writ application, and which instruction of the Government is being attacked as violative of Article 14. With these statements, the prayer on behalf of the petitioner is to declare the Government instruction no. 2892 dated the 12th August, 1965 as ultra vires, void and illegal and to issue a writ of mandamus directing respondent no. 2 (Sic) to fill up the so-called reserved seats either by admitting the petitioner straightway or by admission taken on merits of the applicants.

    4. In the application it was stated that out of the 72 reserved seats only 26 had been filled up. The writ application had been filed on the 18th September, 1969. A supplementary affidavit was filed on the 3rd December, 1969, stating therein that ten more seats out of the remaining 46 reserved seats had been filled up by admitting children of the staff of the Netarhat School, on the basis of the impugned circular dated the 12th August, 1965.

    5. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the State. It is stated in the counter-affidavit that a residential school at Netarhat was established by the Government in the year 1954 on the model of public schools. It is entirely managed and financed by the State Government. The success of the school depends largely on teachers of outstanding ability and experience and in order to secure the services of such teachers, certain facilities have been sanctioned to the teaching staff from time to time. One of such facilities is that the education of the children of the teachers of the school will be without payment of tuition fee. Some other charges, of course, have got to be paid. The school is situated in a remote corner and there is no high or higher secondary school in its neighbourhood in which the children of the teachers could be admitted. From time to time, therefore, facilities to the staff of the school have been extended and lastly such facilities were extended to the. Bursar of the School, P.A to the Principal and the third and fourth grade staff of the school, in Government Order No. 2892 dated the 12th August, 1965. The facility was extended on the condition that the admission of such day scholars in a year should not exceed 72 in all and that priority should be given in admission to the children of the teachers. The further case in the counter-affidavit is that 60 students are selected every year as a result of competitive test examination for admission into the lowest class. Admission is made strictly on the basis of merit. In addition to these sixty seats, which are meant for residential boarders of the school, facility has been granted for admission of the children of the employees of the school, as the arrangement does not practically entail any extra expenditure to the Government. This facility has not been extended to all the Government employees posted at Netarhat, but extending these facilities for education of the children of the employees of the school cannot be said to be unconstitutional, ultra vires, void or illegal. The general question of extending the facility of admission to the children of all Government servants posted at Netarhat was under consideration of the State Government, but it was not possible to admit the petitioner before such a decision was taken by the Government. It is further stated in the counter-affidavit that admission to the Netarhat school is made in the lowest class, as a result of a competitive test examination and there is no system of admitting students in higher classes on the basis of transfer certificates. The petitioner wanted admission on such a basis.

    6. An affidavit in reply, sworn by a friend of the petitioner's father, was filed on the 29th January, 1970. In this affidavit in reply, the fact that admission in the Netarhat school is made by competitive test examination in the lowest class is not denied. It is merely stated in Paragraph 5 of the affidavit in reply that the contention of the respondent in Paragraph 2(G) of the counter-affidavit is wholly untenable.

    7. One Shree Ram Krishna Bhatnagar filed an application in this writ case on the 16th February, 1970, to allow him an opportunity of being heard, as he being a teacher of the school will be affected by any adverse decision, if the reservation for admission as day-scholars of the wards of the school employees is struck down by this Court as unconstitutional. Mr. Awadh Kishore Prasad has appeared for him at the time of the hearing of the application. We have permitted him to address us on his behalf without adding him as a party to the writ application. It has been so done in accordance with the proviso to Rule 5 of Chapter XXI-C of the Patna High Court Rules.

    8. A few more facts may be stated before discussing the points at issue. In the Netarhat School no day-scholars are admitted. The school is primarily meant for resident boarders, residing in the hostels of the school. The number of seats in each class is sixty, total being 360 in the six classes. Certain facilities have been extended to the employees of the school in order to attract good teachers for the efficient working of the school. When teachers join this school, their wards are permitted to be admitted as day-scholars and are not asked to sit at the competitive test examination meant for admission to the sixty seats in each class. No other day-scholar is admitted in the school. The question for consideration, therefore, is whether the petitioner is entitled to ask this Court to direct the State Government to include his case for admission into school as a day-scholar in one of the 72 seats for admission of the day-scholars, the sons and daughters of the school employees. I see no justification for giving any such direction to the State Government. The posts of the employees of the school, as stated in the counter-affidavit are not transferrable, while the employees in the other departments of the Government are posted at Netarhat on transfer and are liable to be transferred generally in about three years' time, as is the case in Government service. If other residents of Netarhat cannot have the facility of admission of their wards as day-scholar in the school, it is difficult to accept the argument put forward on behalf of the petitioner that such a facility, by our direction, should be extended for the wards of the Government employees only. To me it appears that asking the Government to do something like this would, undoubtedly, bring about an infraction of Article 14 of the Constitution.

    9. I think, on the facts and in the circumstances of this particular case, there is another difficulty in the way of the petitioner in succeeding in this writ application. His case in the writ application is that he wanted admission in class X of the school, that means, the fifth class of the school, as against the system prevailing in the school that all students, whether as resident boarders, or, being the wards of the employees of the School, as day-scholars, are admitted in the very first class. They are not admitted in any other higher class. From Annexures 2 and 3 as also from Annexure 6, to which our attention was drawn, it would appear that while recommending the case for admission of the wards of the Government employees, naturally, it was recommended that they may be admitted in different classes, but, there is nothing to indicate that the Government acceded to such recommendation. The petitioner's father, in his letter dated the 27th January, 1969, a copy of which is Annexure 5 to the writ application, requested the Principal of the school that his son may be admitted in any class. Upon this, his learned counsel argued that the request to the Principal was to admit the petitioner even in the lowest class, as was the system, prevalent in the school. But this is not correct, as after the phrase, “He may kindly be admitted in any class,” the phrase which occurs is “he is supposed to be fit.” Reading this letter in the light of the definite case of the petitioner that he wanted admission in the tenth class, it cannot be assumed that he was prepared to take his admission in the first class of the school.

    10. The petitioner wanted us to knock down the reservation in favour of the employees of the school. On the facts of this case, I do not think that at his instance it can be so done. I shall, however, briefly indicate my view in this regard and show that such a reservation is not violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and is not fit to be knocked down.

    11. In the case of (1) Umesh Chandra Sinha v. V.N Singh (A.I.R 1968 Patna 3) it has been held by a Full Bench of this Court that reservation of seats for children of the University employees on grounds of their extreme pecuniary difficulty and for rendering meritorious services to the University by the impugned Ordinances was discriminatory, as there was no reasonable nexus between the object intended to be achieved by the Ordinance on the one hand and the principle on which the children of the University employees were selected for preferential treatment on the other. This decision has been distinguished in a recent decision of the Supreme Court in the case of (2) Kumari Chitra Ghosh v. The Union of India (A.I.R 1970 Supreme Court 35), where reservation of seats for various categories of persons in the Maulana Azad Medical College was upheld. On a careful perusal of the two decisions aforesaid, it would be abundantly clear that reservation of seats for the Government employees posted at Netarhat will be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, as there will be no rational nexus between the securing of admission of the candidates to the school on the one hand and the conferring of special concession or benefit on the Government employees on the other. The question in the present discussion, however, is whether the Full Bench decision of this Court in (1) Umesh Chandra's case makes the facility given to the school employees also violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

    12. To sustain the validity of the impugned ordinance in (1) Umesh Chandra's case, when it was argued before the Full Bench that the efficient performance of the functions by the University depended on the meritorious service rendered by its employees and with a view to encourage such meritorious services it could reserve in the Ordinance seats for children of such employees, the argument was rejected as wholly untenable, but then it was pointed out in Paragraph 19 (at page 10 of the report), while rejecting the argument that “If the impugned law dealt with the conditions of service of the employees of the University, there may be some support for the view that in such a statutory provision special facilities and concessions may be given to those employees who have rendered meritorious services”. But it was pointed out that the sole object of the impugned provision in the Ordinance was to provide for admission of the students to the medical course. In the instance case, however, certain facilities have been extended to the employees of the school to attract efficient teachers for the efficient running of the school. The school is situated, as already stated, in a remote corner, where facilities for the wards of the employees even up to the secondary or higher secondary standard are not available. To reserve seats in colleges for the university education and specially in technical lines cannot be equated with giving of facilities for school education to the children of the employees of the school. On the facts stated in the counter-affidavit, without affecting the accommodation of sixty seats in each class, and without incurring any extra expenditure, the Government has extended the facility to the employees of the school, strictly speaking, not by increasing the number of seats in the school or in the boarding house, but by allowing admission of day-scholars to the maximum limits of twelve in each class of students who are the wards of the school employees. It is not that twelve seats have been increased in a particular class, it is just by way of special facility that it has been decided by the Government that children of the school employees, formerly the number fixed was two for each employees, which has been made three now, can be admitted into the school and the extent of such facility has been fixed at twelve in each class. The very fact that only 26, out of the total 72 seats, which recently made the figure 36, were filled up, shows that it was not a case of increasing seats in the school, but it was a case of giving special facilities by way of service condition to the employees of the school. The petitioner's stand that if all the seats in particular class were not so filled up, he should be given one such seat, is not tenable, as, in my opinion, it is not correct to say on the facts of this case, that number of seats increased by the Government in a particular class is from sixty to seventy two. I do not think, therefore, that the reservation of seats for the children of the school employees can or should (Sic) be knocked down as being violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. In any view, it cannot be so done at the instance of the petitioner, for the reasons already stated above.

    13. For the reasons stated above, the application fails and is dismissed, but I shall make no order as to costs.

    14. B.P Sinha, J.— I agree.

    Application dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shiva Shankar Jha v. State Of Bihar & Another
    (Jul 21, 1970)