AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — S.C. Parija, J. (CRLMC under Section 482 Cr.P.C.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. sought quashing of an FIR registered as Bhubaneswar Airfield P.S. Case No. 220 dated 18.09.2013 (C.T. No. 3611 of 2013) under Section 25 of the Arms Act. The petitioner is a United States citizen and an employee of STX Service Americas, LLC (Houston). He travelled from Houston (via Amsterdam and New Delhi) to Bhubaneswar on 18.09.2013 to attend maintenance work on an offshore drillship. At Biju Pattnaik Airport, Bhubaneswar, CISF personnel detected eight live 0.22 mm bullets in his handbag during X-ray screening. The CISF handed him over to the Airfield Police and filed a written report the same day; subsequent FIR was registered under Section 25 of the Arms Act. The petitioner was produced before the learned S.D.J.M. and remanded; later he was released on bail by the Addl. Sessions Judge (B.A. No. 359/1064 of 2013) upon execution of a P.R. bond and deposit of Rs. 50,000 cash, subject to surrender of passport and visa. In this petition the petitioner seeks quashing of the FIR, refund of the cash security, and return of passport and visa.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts alleged, the detection of eight 0.22 mm bullets in the petitioner’s handbag constitutes "conscious possession" such as to make out an offence under Section 25 of the Arms Act.
  2. Whether continuation of the criminal proceeding (registration and prosecution under Section 25) would amount to an abuse of process of court or otherwise require quashing under the inherent powers preserved by Section 482 Cr.P.C.
  3. Whether, in the circumstances (including the petitioner’s claimed inadvertent oversight and possession of a foreign arms licence), the FIR ought to be quashed and ancillary reliefs (refund of cash security, return of passport and visa) granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The bullets were left in the petitioner’s handbag by inadvertent oversight; he was unaware of their presence until detection at Bhubaneswar Airport.
  • The petitioner is a U.S. national and an STX Service Americas engineer deployed to perform specialized maintenance on a drillship; he was travelling in the course of his employment and was to return to Houston after the job.
  • The petitioner holds a valid Arms Licence issued by the State of Florida (Licence No. W 1223319) for possessing such ammunition; a photocopy was filed.
  • The recovered ammunition (0.22 mm) are for sporting rifles (non-prohibited bore); no firearm or weapon was recovered from him.
  • Given the above, the possession was not conscious and therefore cannot sustain an offence under Section 25 of the Arms Act. Counsel relied on precedents (notably Nurit Toker and a Delhi High Court decision) to support quashing the FIR.

State's Arguments

  • The State submitted that the petitioner, a U.S. citizen, was found in possession of eight live 0.22 mm bullets at the airport and did not have a licence under the Arms Act; this constituted an offence under Section 25 and so the FIR was rightly registered.
  • The State urged that, since the matter was under investigation, the High Court should not interfere at the initial stage when facts were still being developed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nurit Toker v. State of Maharashtra, 2012 (2) BCR (Cri) 154 (Bombay High Court) Held that mere detection of live cartridges during baggage screening did not necessarily constitute "conscious possession" to establish guilt under Sections 3 and 25 of the Arms Act. The court relied on this decision as an analogous instance where mere detection at airport screening did not amount to conscious possession; it supported the conclusion that the petitioner’s possession could be inadvertent.
Sanjay Dutt v. State Through C.B.I., (1994) 5 SCC 410 (Constitution Bench) Explained that "possession" in statutory offences carries a mental element — it requires conscious possession (awareness of possession) rather than mere custody without awareness. The court applied this principle to hold that the ingredient of conscious possession was not made out on the facts, and therefore an offence under Section 25 was not established.
CHAN HONG SAIK THR. SPA v. State, 2012 (3) JCC 1858 (Delhi High Court) Quashed FIR where a single live cartridge detected in baggage was treated as "minor ammunition" under Section 45(d) of the Arms Act; the petitioner’s status as a shooter and travel circumstances were considered. The court cited this case as an example where a court quashed FIR in airport-detection circumstances involving minor ammunition; it supported the petitioner's position that the bullets were insignificantly connected to criminality in context.
State of Karnatak v. L. Muniswamy, AIR 1977 SC 1489 Recognised that Section 482 Cr.P.C. empowers High Courts to quash proceedings when continuation would be an abuse of process or when ends of justice require quashing. The court invoked this authority to frame the exercise of inherent jurisdiction: if no offence is made out, continuation would be abuse of process and the FIR can be quashed.
State of Harayana v. Ch. Bhajan Lal, AIR 1992 SC 604 Set out categories and principles where Article 226/Section 482 may be exercised to quash criminal proceedings (including where allegations do not prima facie constitute an offence, where allegations are absurd/inherently improbable, etc.). The court applied the Bhajan Lal framework to assess whether the uncontroverted allegations and accompanying materials prima facie disclosed an offence under Section 25; it concluded they did not.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first outlined the nature and limits of the High Court's inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C.: it preserves pre-existing powers to prevent abuse of process, give effect to Code orders, and secure the ends of justice. The court emphasised that such power must be exercised sparingly and only where justified by established tests.

The court reviewed the factual matrix as alleged in the FIR and in the petitioner’s pleadings: petitioner is a U.S. national and STX employee who travelled in the course of employment; eight live 0.22 mm bullets were detected in his handbag at Bhubaneswar Airport; the petitioner asserted inadvertent oversight and produced a photocopy of a Florida arms licence; no firearm was recovered; the bullets are usable in sporting rifles (non-prohibited bore); and the bullets had passed undetected through several prior security checks during the journey.

The court then applied the legal principle — drawn from the apex Court's decision in Sanjay Dutt — that "possession" in similar statutory contexts requires a mental element of conscious possession. The court observed that conscious possession is a core ingredient to sustain an offence under Section 25 of the Arms Act.

Considering these principles and the particular facts (inadvertent oversight appears genuine; no attempt to conceal the ammunition; bullets not hidden in a secret compartment; multiple prior security checks where detection did not occur; petitioner held a foreign licence and no firearm was recovered), the court concluded the possession was not conscious. It also noted analogous High Court decisions (Nurit Toker and CHAN HONG SAIK) where courts quashed FIRs in analogous airport-detection scenarios.

On that basis, the court concluded that no offence under Section 25 was made out on the material before it and that permitting the criminal proceeding to continue would amount to an abuse of the process of the court. Consequently, the court exercised its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 to quash the FIR.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned FIR (Bhubaneswar Airfield P.S. Case No. 220 dated 18.09.2013, C.T. No. 3611 of 2013) registered under Section 25 of the Arms Act is quashed; the criminal miscellaneous petition (CRLMC) is allowed.

Direct consequences ordered by the Court:

  • The cash security of Rs. 50,000 deposited by the petitioner as a condition for grant of bail is ordered to be refunded to him.
  • The passport and visa deposited with the learned S.D.J.M., Bhubaneswar are ordered to be returned to the petitioner forthwith.
  • The CRLMC petition is accordingly allowed.

Implications beyond this case: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent; it applies existing authority regarding conscious possession and the scope of Section 482 to the facts at hand. The direct effect is the quashing of the FIR and the ancillary reliefs ordered above.

    William Michael Hurtubise Petitioner v. State Of Odisha And Others Opp. Parties

    S.C PARIJA, J. This application under Section 482 Cr.P.C has been filed for quashing of the FIR, registered as Bhubaneswar Airfield P.S Case No. 220, dated 18.09.2013, corresponding to C.T No. 3611 of 2013, pending in the Court of the learned S.D.J.M, Bhubaneswar, under Section 25 of the Arms Act and to refund the cash security of Rs. 50,000/- deposited by the petitioner, as a condition for grant of bail and to return his passport and visa, deposited with the learned S.D.J.M, Bhubaneswar.

    2. The case of the petitioner is that he is a citizen of United States of America (“USA” for short) and is an employee of STX Service Americas, LLC, at their Houston location in the State of Texas in U.S.A, as one of their field service engineers. The petitioner was deployed along with two other engineers of the Company and one technician, to attend the off shore drillship, which is under contract with the petitioner's Company, for engine maintenance. The petitioner and other engineers and technicians of the Company were required to perform specialized technical work on the drillship main diesel engines, which have been produced by the group of companies of STX Service Americas, LLC and built into the drillship for providing power for the positioning equipment, the drilling equipment and the vessel's accommodations. The petitioner and the other technical staffs of the Company were required to carry out specialized job, which the crews of the drillship are not experienced enough to perform. The owner of the drillship is a Houston based offshore drilling company. During the period of his deployment for engine maintenance of the drillship, the petitioner would continue to draw his salary from STX Service Americas, LLC, as he continues to be the employee of the said Company. It was planned that the petitioner and his three colleagues will return to Houston in U.S.A, immediately after completing their tasks on board the drillship.

    3. The petitioner along with his colleagues left Houston in the State of Texas in USA and via Amsterdam, arrived in New Delhi. From there they boarded a flight to Bhubaneswar and arrived at Biju Pattnaik Airport in Bhubaneswar on 18.09.2013 While the petitioner and his colleagues were about to board the Helicopter to proceed to the place of work in Paradeep, he was detained by the CISF personnel and was informed that during screening of his baggage, 8 nos. of 0.22 mm bullets have been found in his handbag. The petitioner explained to the CISF personnel at the Airport that the bullets may have been left behind in his handbag due to oversight and that he is possessing a Arms Licence issued by the State of Florida in USA and if he is given some time, he can obtain copy of the said Arms Licence by fax. He further pleaded that the 0.22 mm bullets are harmless and is only used for sporting purpose in a Sporting Rifle. The CISF personnel did not heed to the request and plea and instead handed over the petitioner to the Airfield Police Station, Bhubaneswar and submitted a written report dated 18.09.2013, which reads as under:-

    “To

    The Inspector-in-Charge,

    Airfield Police Station, Bhubaneswar.

    Sub: Information of Ammunition detected at SHA of

    B.P Airport, Bhubaneswar, Reg.

    Sir,

    It is intimated that, one passenger namely, Mr. William Michael Hurtubise S/o Mr. William Oliver Hurtubise of 14827, Glade brook, Dr. Houston Tx-77068 (USA) Passport No. 454978968 was travelling from Bhubaneswa to Rig-plex offshore by Chartered Helicopter of M/s.-Global Vectra Helicorp. He was carrying 08 in Nos. 0.22 live ammunition in his hand bag which was detected at security hold area during hand bag X-ray screening by Sub-Insp/Exc. Prem Singh at about 08. 05 Hrs. on dt. 18.09.2013 The said S1./Exc. brought the matter to security hold in-charge, Insp./Ex. S.N Kumar who questioned the passenger about aramunition and its valid licence. But individual is unable to produce it and told that he is having USA arms licence which is in USA and he is working with ONGC under Contractor Mr. Baker Hughes of Mumbai.

    The passenger along with 08 in Nos. 0.22 Ammunition (live) produce before you for further legal action as per law.

    End: 1. 08 Nos. 0.22 mm live ammunition

    2. Seizure Memo

    3. Xerox of Passport No. 454978968

    4. Boarding pass

    5. Written statement of individual

    Sd/-

    18.9.13

    (Insp/E S.N Kumar)

    CISF/ASG BBSR

    BP Airport, BBSR.”

    4. The said written report was registered as Bhubaneswar Airfield P.S Case No. 220, dated 18.09.2013, under Section 25 of the Arms Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act) and the petitioner was produced before the learned S.D.J.M, Bhubaneswar and was remanded to jail custody. Subsequently, the petitioner has been released on bail by the order of learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Bhubaneswar, in B.A No. 359/1064 of 2013, on executing P.R bond by depositing cash of Rs. 50,000/- with the condition inter alia, that he will deposit the passport and visa before the learned S.D.J.M, Bhubaneswar.

    5. The case of the petitioner is that he is an American national employed in STX Service Americas, LLC and had come to India in course of his employment, to attend to the maintenance and repair of the drillship, engaged in off shore drilling by ONGC, in the high sea off Paradeep coast. It is the further case of the petitioner that the 8 nos. of 0.22 mm bullets, which were found in his handbag at the Bhubaneswar Airport, have been left in his handbag due to inadvertent oversight and that he is having a valid Arms Licence issued by the State of Florida in USA, vide licence No. W 1223319, for possessing such ammunitions, photocopy of which has been filed. It is the further case of the petitioner that the said 0.22 mm bullets can only be used for sporting purpose in Sporting Rifles, which is a non-prohibited bore, and as no arm or weapon has been recovered from his possession, no offence is made out under the Act.

    6. Learned counsel for the petitioner accordingly submits that as the petitioner is a qualified engineer of STX Service Americas, LLC, USA, who has been deployed by the said Company to work on the drillship, which has been engaged by the ONGC in the high sea off Paradeep coast for drilling operations and admittedly he was travelling from USA via Amsterdam to New Delhi and from there to Bhubaneswar, the detection of 8 nos. of 0.22 mm bullets in his handbag at Bhubaneswar Airport cannot be said to be a conscious possession.

    7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon a Division Bench decision of the Bombay High Court in Nurit Toker v. State of Maharashtra, 2012 (2) BCR (Cri) 154, where in a similar case, the petitioner therein, who was a citizen of Israel was detained at Mumbai International Airport for carrying two live cartridges (bullets) of 0.1 MM and 0.5 MM, which are compatible with M-16 assault rifle. The petitioner therein was found to be in military service in Israel. She had travelled with the baggage from Israel to Mumbai and was preparing to leave for Kathamandu, as per her pre-planned itinerary, when she was detained at Mumbai International Airport for carrying two live cartridges and charged of offences under Sections 3 and 25 of the Act.

    8. The Division Bench of the Bombay High Court relying upon the Constitution Bench decision of the apex Court in the case of Sanjay Dutt v. State Through C.B.I, Bombay (I)., Bombay, (1994) 5 SCC 410, came to hold that merely because the petitioner was found to be carrying two live cartridges which were detected during screening of her baggage at Mumbai International Airport, the same cannot constitute conscious possession in order to establish the guilt for commission of offences under Sections 3 and 25 of the Act.

    9. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon a decision of the Delhi High Court in CHAN HONG SAIK THR. SPA v. State2012 (3) JCC 1858, where the petitioner therein, who is a citizen of Malaysia was detained at the IGI Airport, New Delhi, for possessing one live cartridge of 9 mm in his handbag without any licence, in contravention of Section 3 of the Act and was accordingly found to have committed an offence punishable under Section 25(1-B) of the Act. The Hon'ble Court considered the fact that the petitioner had travelled to India for a holy pilgrimage along with his fellow passengers and had travelled through different places in India along with his baggage and it was while boarding a flight back to Kuala Lumpur (Malaysia), the security personnel detected one live cartridge. Hon'ble Court also considered the fact that the petitioner therein was a member of the Rifle Club of Malaysia and was a renowned shooter and the live cartridge cannot be used for any purpose without the fire arm. Taking into consideration the fact that one live cartridge would come under the category of ‘minor ammunition’ as provided under Section 45(d) of the Act, the Hon'ble Court quashed the FIR.

    10. Learned counsel for the State while supporting the prosecution initiated against the petitioner under the impugned FIR submits that as the petitioner, who is a citizen and resident of USA, was found in possession of 8 nos. of live 0.22 mm bullets at the Biju Pattnaik Airport, Bhubaneswar, and he did not possess a valid licence under the Act, he had committed offence under Section 25 of the Act and therefore, the impugned FIR cannot be faulted. It is further submitted that as the matter is under investigation, no interference is warranted at this initial stage, when all facts are yet to come on record.

    11. The legal position is well settled that when a prosecution at the initial stage is asked to be quashed, the tests to be applied by the Court is as to whether the uncontroverted allegations as made prima facie establish the offence. Section 482 does not confer any new powers on the High Court. It only saves the inherent power which the Court possessed before the enactment of the Code. It envisages three circumstances under which the inherent jurisdiction may be exercised, namely, (i) to give effect to an order under the Code (ii) to prevent abuse of the process of court, and (iii) to otherwise secure the ends of justice. It is neither possible nor desirable to lay down any inflexible rule which would govern the exercise of inherent jurisdiction. No legislative enactment dealing with procedure can provide for all cases that may possibly arise. Courts therefore, have inherent powers apart from express provisions of law which are necessary for proper discharge of functions and duties imposed upon them by law. That is the doctrine which finds expression in the section which merely recognizes and preserves inherent powers of the High Courts. All courts, whether civil or criminal possess, in the absence of any express provision, as inherent in their constitution, all such powers as are necessary to do the right and to undo a wrong in course of administration of justice on the principle “quando lex aliauid alicui concedit, concedere videtur et id sine guo res ipsae esse non potest” (when the law gives a person anything it gives him that without which it cannot exist). While exercising powers under the section, the court does not function as a court of appeal or revision. Inherent jurisdiction under the section though wide has to be exercised sparingly, carefully and with caution and only when such exercise is justified by the tests specifically laid down in the section itself. It is to be exercised ex debito justitiae to do real and substantial justice for the administration of which alone courts exist. Authority of the court exists for advancement of justice and if any attempt is made to abuse that authority so as to produce injustice, the court has power to prevent abuse. It would be an abuse of the process of court, to allow any action which would result in injustice and prevent promotion of justice and in exercise of such powers, court would be justified to quash any proceeding if it finds that initiation/continuance of it amounts to abuse of the process of court or quashing of these proceedings would otherwise serve the ends of justice. When no offence is disclosed by the report or the complaint, the court may examine the question of fact. When a report or complaint is sought to be quashed, it is permissible to look into the materials to assess what the report has alleged and whether any offence is made out even if the allegations are accepted in toto.

    12. In the case of State of Karnatak v. L. Muniswamy, AIR 1977 SC 1489, the Supreme Court has observed that the wholesome power under section 482, Cr.P.C entitles the High Court to quash a proceeding when it comes to the conclusion that allowing the proceeding to continue would be an abuse of the process of the court or that the ends of justice require that the proceeding ought to be quashed. The High Courts have been invested with inherent powers, both in civil and criminal matters, to achieve a salutary public purpose. A court proceeding ought not to be permitted to degenerate into a weapon of harassment or persecution. The Supreme Court observed in that case that ends of justice are higher than the ends of mere law though justice must be administered according to laws made by the legislature. The aforesaid ratio of the case has been followed in a large number of subsequent cases of Apex Court and other Courts.

    13. The scope of exercise of power under Article 226 of the Constitution and Section 482 of the Code and the categories of cases where the High Court may exercise its power under it relating to cognizable offences to prevent abuse of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice were set out in some detail by the Supreme Court in State of Harayana v. Ch. Bhajan Lal, AIR 1992 SC 604 The Hon'ble Court made it clear that it may not be possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an exhaustive list to myriad kinds of cases wherein such power should be exercised:

    “(1) Where the allegations made in the First Information Report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused.

    (2) Where the allegations in the First Information Report and other materials, if any, accompanying the F.I.R do not disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police officers under S. 156(1) of the Code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of S. 155(2) of the Code.

    (3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make out a case against the accused.

    (4) Where, the allegations in the F.I.R do not constitute a cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under S. 155(2) of the Code.

    (5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.

    (6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act, providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party.

    (7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and personal grudge.”

    14. Admittedly, the petitioner is a citizen of USA and employed under STX Service Americas, LLC, USA and had come to India along with his colleagues for carrying out maintenance of the drillship, operating under ONGC in the high sea off Paradeep coast, for oil and natural gas drilling operation. After reaching Bhubaneswar Airport, while the petitioner was boarding the Helicopter to go to Paradeep, the security personnel detained him on the ground that during screening of his baggage, 8 nos. of 0.22 mm live bullets were found in his handbag. The petitioner possess a valid Arms Licence issued by the State of Florida in USA and the 0.22 mm bullets recovered from his baggage can only be used in Sporting Rifles, which is a non-prohibited bore.

    15. The plea of the petitioner that he was not aware of the bullets lying in his handbag and that the same must have been left in the bag due to inadvertent oversight appears to be genuine and bona fide, as no attempt has been made by him to conceal the said bullets nor the said bullets were found hidden in a secret compartment of his baggage to evade detection. Moreover, the petitioner while travelling from U.S.A via Amsterdam to New Delhi and then to Bhubaneswar, had passed through several security checks in different Airports abroad and in India before landing in Bhubaneswar and no where the said bullets could be detected.

    16. The law is well settled that conscious possession is a core ingredient to establish the guilt for the offence under Section 25 of the Act and the apex Court in Sanjay Dutt (supra), while dealing with a case under Section 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987, has held that the expression ‘possession’ occurring in the Section 5 of the said Act must mean possession with the requisite mental element, that is, conscious possession and not mere custody without the awareness of the nature of such possession. There is a mental element in the concept of possession, which means that the possession must be conscious possession. The apex Court has held that only then the ingredient of possession in similar context of a statutory offence importing strict liability on account of mere possession of an unauthorized substance has to be understood.

    17. Applying the said principles, as discussed above, to the facts of the present case and considering the attending circumstances, it can be safely said that the petitioner had left behind 8 nos. of 0.22 mm bullets in his handbag by mistake and/or inadvertent oversight, when he started his journey from USA. He was not aware of its presence in his handbag till it was detected by the security personnel during screening of his baggage at the Bhubaneswar Airport and therefore it was not a conscious possession. Further, the petitioner holds a valid licence for possessing such bullets, issued by the State of Florida in USA and admittedly no fire arm or weapon has been recovered from him. Therefore, no offence under Section 25 of the Act is made out against the petitioner and allowing continuance of the criminal proceeding against him would be an abuse of the process of Court.

    18. Accordingly, the impugned FIR, registered as Bhubaneswar Airfield P.S Case No. 220, dated 18.09.2013, corresponding to C.T No. 3611 of 2013, pending in the Court of the learned S.D.J.M, Bhubaneswar, under Section 25 of the Act is hereby quashed.

    19. The cash security of Rs. 50,000/- deposited by the petitioner as a condition for grant of bail be refunded to him. The passport and the visa deposited with the learned S.D.J.M, Bhubaneswar, be returned to him forthwith.

    CRLMC is accordingly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    William Michael Hurtubise Petitioner v. State Of Odisha And Others Opp. Parties
    (Jan 17, 2014)