Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused-respondent, an assessee under the Income-Tax Act, filed two separate verified income-tax returns for the assessment year 1958-59: Ext. 1 dated 27-2-1959 showing income of Rs. 4,319.48 under the head "business" from his 1/3rd share in M/s. Consolidated Construction Co., Cuttack, and Ext. 2 dated 13-2-1959 showing income of Rs. 5,160.00 under the head "business" derived from a proprietory establishment, M/s. Hindustan Automobile, Berhampur. The Income-Tax Officer completed an assessment on 28-2-1959 believing no other income had accrued to the accused.

In February 1970 the Income-Tax Department detected what it treated as a fraud; summons under section 131 of the Income-Tax Act, 1961 were issued, and statements of the accused and two advocates were recorded. With sanction from the Commissioner of Income-Tax, a complaint was filed on 25-1-1974 by the Income-Tax Officer alleging offences under section 52 of the Income-Tax Act, 1922 (largely in pari materia with section 277 of the 1961 Act) and various sections of the Indian Penal Code. The Chief Judicial Magistrate (C.J.M.), Cuttack took cognizance of the offence under section 52 and tried the accused, who was acquitted by the trial court on the basis that he lacked the requisite mens rea. The Revenue appealed against that acquittal to the court of J.K. Mohanty, J.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accused made false statements in the verifications (Exts. 1 and 2) knowing or believing those statements to be false, thereby committing an offence under section 52 of the Income-Tax Act, 1922 (analogous to section 277 of the 1961 Act).
  2. Whether the mere submission of a verified return containing a false statement, without more, constitutes the offence under the statute, or whether prosecution must additionally prove the accused's knowledge or belief that the statement was false (mens rea).
  3. Whether, on the evidence, the accused had the requisite guilty intention (mens rea) to make false statements so as to evade tax.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (for the Revenue)

  • An assessee is obliged to file a single return disclosing his entire source of income; the respondent filed two separate returns for the same assessment year and thereby sought to evade tax.
  • The filing of two returns indicated an intention to evade tax, and the plea of bona fide should not be accepted.
  • The question of bona fide does not arise given the circumstances (submitted by Mr. D.C. Mohanty for the appellant).

Respondent's Arguments (for the Accused)

  • The two returns related to two different sources of income; they were not false statements in the verifications.
  • The accused did not possess the requisite guilty intention (mens rea) when the two returns were filed.
  • The accused signed blank forms which were subsequently filled and filed by the accountants and advocates; the consolidated return was filed later and the tax due was paid.
  • The accused's explanation was supported by the evidence of P.W.4 and P.W.5 (submitted by Mr. D.P. Mohanty for the respondent).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Biju alias Bijayananda Patnaik v. Union of India, through S.C. De, Income-Tax Officer, Calcutta — 19771 I.L.R Cutt. 779. The prosecution must show (a) that the statement made by the accused is false and (b) that while making the statement the accused knew it to be false or believed it to be false or believed that it was not true; mere submission of a verified return containing a false statement does not by itself constitute an offence. The court relied on this principle to conclude that the prosecution must prove knowledge or belief that the statement was false (mens rea). Applying the precedent, the court accepted that mere submission of separate verified returns did not automatically establish the offence in the absence of proof that the accused knew or believed the statements to be false.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the statutory offence under section 52 of the Income-Tax Act, 1922, which penalises making a false statement in a verification when the accused knows or believes it to be false (the text of the provision is reproduced in the opinion). The court identified mens rea as an essential ingredient of the offence: the statute requires that the statement be false and that the maker knows or believes it to be false.

The court reviewed the prosecution evidence: P.W.1 (the complainant Income-Tax Officer) and P.W.2 (the officer who detected the alleged fraud) described the case as one concerning false statements in verifications; P.W.3 proved the accused's signatures in Exts. 1 and 2; P.W.4 and P.W.5 (the advocates who filed the respective returns) testified that they filed the returns on instructions of accountants, that the accused was resident in Calcutta and not present at filing, and that blank forms containing the accused's signature were brought and filled by the accountants before filing.

The trial court accepted the advocates' evidence and concluded there was no reason to disbelieve these responsible witnesses. On this basis the trial court found that the accused had no intention to defraud the Income-Tax Department and therefore lacked mens rea.

On appeal the Revenue argued that filing two returns demonstrated an intention to evade tax and that bona fide could not be accepted. The court analysed whether the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that the accused knew or believed the statements to be false. The court noted there was nothing in the statute to exclude mens rea; therefore the prosecution had to establish the accused's guilty mind. Relying on the cited precedent, the court reiterated that mere submission of a verified return containing a false statement does not by itself constitute the offence; prosecution must show the accused's knowledge or belief of falsehood.

Considering the evidence and the accused's explanation (supported by P.W.4 and P.W.5), the court concluded that it could not be held that the accused deliberately and intentionally filed two returns with a guilty mind to defraud the department. The High Court found no reason to overturn the trial court's findings.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Direct effect: The trial court's acquittal of the accused on the charge under section 52 of the Income-Tax Act, 1922 is upheld — the accused is not convicted on the count concerning false statements in verifications for the assessment year 1958-59.

Broader implications: The opinion applies an established principle (as cited in the precedent) that mere submission of a verified return containing a false statement does not, without evidence of the accused's knowledge or belief of falsehood, constitute the statutory offence. The judgment does not purport to lay down a novel rule of law beyond the application of that principle to the facts of this case; no broader new precedent is asserted in the opinion.

Appeal dismissed.

    D. Rahaman v. Bijaya Kishore Das .

    J.K Mohanty, J.:— The accused-respondent was charged under section 52 of the Income-Tax Act, 1922 (which is almost in identical terms with section 277 of the Income-Tax Act, 1961) and was tried in the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Cuttack. He was acquitted by the trial Court. This appeal has been preferred against the order of acquittal of the respondent passed by the C.J.M, Cuttack.

    2. The accused-respondent was an assessee under the Income-Tax Act. He submitted a return (Ext. 1) to the Income-Tax Officer, Cuttack for the assessment year 1958.59 on 27-2-1959 showing an income of Rs. 4,319.48 under the bead ‘business’ which comprise his income out of his share in M/s. Consolidated Construction Co., Cuttack. The return was verified as required under the Income-Tax Act. The accused had disclosed that he had 1/3rd share in M/s. Consolidated Construction Co. Cuttack, and had no other source of income. The assessment was completed by the Income-Tax Officer on 28-2-1959 on the belief that no other income had actually accrued to the accused. The accused had furnished another return (Ext. 2) of his income to the Income-Tax Officer, Cuttack, for the very same assessment year on 13-2-1959 showing an income of Rs. 5,160.00 under the head ‘business’. This income according to him, was derived from the sale of motor vehicles and spare parts in his proprietory business establishment. M/s. Hindustan Automobile, Berhampur. He has made a statement in the verification furnished in the above return that he had no other income except the aforesaid source during the relevant assessment year. The Income-Tax Officer completed the assessment in good faith believing the version of the accused. It is alleged that by submitting two returns the accused had made false statements, knowing or believing the same to be false with a view to avoid payment of lawful tax. It is also alleged that the accused deliberately suppressed the fact that two separate returns were filed by him and thereby succeeded in getting his false declarations accepted and acted upon by the Income-Tax Officer leading to two separate assessments by two different assessing officers. To avoid detection of the fraud committed by him the accused had engaged separate advocates for each case. It is alleged that if true state of affairs had been disclosed and if the income from all the sources would have been combined in one return as pet the provisions of law, the accused would have been liable to pay substantially higher income-tax and interest thereon for the said assessment year. In February, 1970, the Income-Tax Officer detected the fraud and issued summons under section 131 of the 1961 Act. The statements of the accused and his two advocates were recorded on oath. After obtaining sanction from the Commissioner of Income-Tax. the complaint was filed by the Income-Tax Officer, Cuttack (P.W 1) on 25-1-1974 alleging the accused to have committed offences under section 52 of the 1922 Act and under various sections of Indian Penal Code. The Court took cognizance of the offence under section 52 of the 1922 Act and summoned the accused to stand his trial.

    3. The plea of the accused was that during the relevant period he had his office at Calcutta. His brother, who was the partner of M/s. Consolidated Construction Co., Cuttack, died suddenly whereafter he was taken as one of the partners of the firm. The income of the firm was to be paid to the family members of the accused who were staying at Cuttack. So the accused had no knowledge of the income derived from the said company. He was under the bona fide impression that separate returns had to be filed in respect of the incomes derived from both the business establishments. He used to put his signature on the blank form of return under the verification which was subsequently filled up and filed by the Accountants of the firms through the lawyers. He had no intention to make any false statement nor he had concealed bis income. After the Department objected to the filing of two separate returns, the accused submitted a consolidated return in respect of the income derived from both the firms and due tax has already been paid.

    4. In order to prove the case the prosecution examined five witnesses and filed several documents. P.W 1, the complainant, is the Income-Tax Officer, Cuttack, Ward-B, P.W 2 is the Income-Tax Officer, Cuttack, Ward-B, who detected the alleged fraud committed by the accused P.W 3 is the Inspector of Income-Tax, Cuttack who has proved the signatures of the accused in Exts. 1 and 2 and p.ws 4 and 5 are the advocates of the accused who had filed Exts. 1 and 2 on his behalf. The learned Magistrate after considering the evidence on record and the plea of the accused came to the finding that the accused had no intention to defraud the Income-Tax Department; that he had not deliberately filed any false return; and that he had no mens rea.

    5. In this Court Mr. D.C Mohanty, learned counsel appearing for the appellant, submitted that an assessee is to file one return disclosing his entire source of income. The respondent filed two returns which go to show that he wanted to evade tax and the plea taken by him should not be accepted. He further submitted that the question of bona fide on part of the accused-respondent does not arise.

    6. In this case it is the admitted fact that the accused had filed two returns in Exts. 1 and 2 for the assessment year 1958-59 and after detection he has submitted a consolidated return. Section 52 of 1922 Act reads as follows :—

    “If a person makes a statement in a verification mentioned in section 19A or section 20A or section 21 or section 22 or sub-section (2) of section 26A or sub-section (3) of section 30, or sub-section (3) of section 33, which is false, and which be either knows or believes to be false, or does not believe to be true, he shall be punishable, on conviction before a Magistrate, with simple imprisonment which may extend to six months, or with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees, or with both. ”

    7. So making a false statement in any verification under the Income-Tax Act with the knowledge or belief that it is false and with the belief that it is not true is an offence. In this case P.W 1 has stated that the case against the accused is not for escapement of tax but it is a case for making false statement in a verification. Similar is the evidence of P.W 2. P.W 3 has proved Exts. 1 and 2 and the signatures of the accused therein. These documents are admitted by the accused. P.W 4 has stated that he filed Ext. 2 on behalf of the accused. At the time of filing Ext. 2 he was not aware that another advocate had been engaged by the accused for filing the return for the same assessment year with respect to another concern. He filed Ext. 2 on the instruction of the Accountant of the firm, of which the accused was a partner. In cross-examination he has admitted that the accused was staying at Calcutta. During that year before filing of Ext. 2 the accused did not come to him for any discussion. He has further stated that the Accountant of the Firm brought the blank form of return containing the signature of the accused which was filled up and filed (which is Ext. 2). Similarly P.W 5 has stated that he was the advocate of M/s. Consolidated Construction Co. and submitted Ext. 1 on behalf of the accused. He has also stated that he was not aware of filing of Ext. 2 by P.W 4. The other statements made by him are identical to that of P.W 4. The learned trial Court has considered the evidence of these two advocates and has observed that there is no reason to disbelieve them who are responsible persons. Simply because they were the advocates of the accused, it cannot be said that they would make false statements before the Court in favour of the accused. From their evidence it has been satisfactorily proved that the accused was not present when Exts. 1 and 2 were filed before the Income-Tax authorities. On the instruction given by the Accountants of the firms, of which the accused was the partner, the returns were prepared and submitted to the Income-Tax Officers by p.ws 4 and 5. The Accountant had brought the blank forms of return wherein accused had signed which were subsequently filled up and filed. The trial Court has further held that merely because two separate advocates were engaged to file Exts. 1 and 2, one cannot jump to the conclusion that the accused had engaged them deliberately for the purpose of evading tax by misleading the Income-Tax Officers, There is nothing in the evidence to suggest that the accused had deliberately engaged two lawyers to evade tax.

    8. Mr. D.P Mohanty, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, submitted that the two returns that were filed were not false. They only related to two different sources. The accused has not made any statement in the verification which was false and which he either knew or believed to be false. According to him there is nothing in the prosecution evidence to suggest that the accused had any guilty intention while filing two separate returns. He pointed out that consolidated return has been filed for the same year subsequently and the accused has paid the tax that was due. He further argued that there was no mens rea on the part of the accused in filing the two returns and the accused has frankly explained under what circumstance both the returns were filed and his statement has been supported by p.ws 4 and 5.

    9. Mens rea is an essential ingredient of a criminal offence. But in this case nothing has been brought to my notice that the element of mens rea has been expressly or by necessary implication excluded by the statute. So considering the evidence on record and the plea of the accused and in the facts and circumstances of the case it cannot be held that the accused filed two returns for the assessment year 1958-59 deliberately and intentionally with a guilty mind and in order to make undue advantage or defraud the Income-Tax Department.

    10. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent cited a decision reported in Biju alias Bijayananda Patnaik v. Union of India, through S.C.De, Income-Tax Officer, Calcutta . 19771 I.L.R Cutt. 779.. In that case the accused was also prosecuted for filing false statement under section 277 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. It has been held :—

    “Prosecution must show that the statement made by the accused is false and that while making the statement the accused knew it to be false or believed it to be false or believed that it was not true. Mere submission of a verified return containing a false statement does not by itself constitute an offence. The prosecution has further to show that the false statement has been made either with the knowledge of the accused that the statement is false or under the belief that the statement is false.”

    11. From the facts and circumstance of this case I am of the view that mere submission of a verified return containing a false statement does not by itself constitute an offence. The accused has explained the circumstances under which the returns were filed and there is no reason to take a different view than that taken by the learned trial Court. It has also not been established that the false statement has been made with the knowledge of the accused.

    12. After hearing the argument of both sides and in the facts and circumstances of the case I see no reason to differ from the finding arrived at by the learned trial Court. The appeal has, therefore, no merit and is accordingly dismissed.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D. Rahaman v. Bijaya Kishore Das .
    (Jan 6, 1981)