AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 18, Rule 17-A of the Code as the said provision
  • Rule 104 of the M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961
  • Order 6, Rule 17 and Order 18, Rule 17, CPC
  • Rule 105 of M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961
  • Rule 104 of M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961.
  • Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code
  • M.P. Civil Courts Rules, 1961,
  • Order 16, Rule 1(3) of CPC
  • Sub-rule (2) of that rule
  • Rule 10 of Order XIII
  • Order 13, Rule 10, CPC,
  • Order XIII, Rule 10(2),
  • Order 18, Rule 17, CPC
  • Information Act, 2005,
  • Order 16, Rule 1, CPC.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 18, Rule 17-A of the Code as the said provision
  • Rule 104 of the M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961
  • Order 6, Rule 17 and Order 18, Rule 17, CPC
  • Rule 105 of M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961
  • Rule 104 of M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961.
  • Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code
  • M.P. Civil Courts Rules, 1961,
  • Order 16, Rule 1(3) of CPC
  • Sub-rule (2) of that rule
  • Rule 10 of Order XIII
  • Order 13, Rule 10, CPC,
  • Order XIII, Rule 10(2),
  • Order 18, Rule 17, CPC
  • Information Act, 2005,
  • Order 16, Rule 1, CPC.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 24-08-2005 of the Second Civil Judge, Class-II, Katni in Civil Original Suit No. 12-A/2000 which rejected two applications by the petitioner: (a) an application under Order 18, Rule 17 CPC seeking recall of the plaintiff for further cross-examination and re-examination of a defendant witness in consequence of amendments to pleadings; and (b) an application under Order 16, Rule 1(3) CPC asking the trial court to summon records from the Municipal Corporation (Property Tax Assessment Register) after the petitioner alleged that a request for a certified copy had been refused.

Procedurally, after evidence was closed the petitioner filed an amendment to the written statement (18-07-2005) alleging that three related suits had been decided by compromise and that the accommodation from those suits had come into the plaintiff's possession, undermining the plaintiff's claimed bona fide necessity. The trial court allowed that amendment. The plaintiff also amended the plaint (18-07-2005) to add para 4A explaining that even after alleged possession of other accommodations the plaintiff's bona fide necessity for the accommodation occupied by the defendant would persist and that the plaintiff had not actually obtained possession from other tenants. Following these amendments the petitioner sought further cross-examination and re-examination, and also sought municipal records; both requests were rejected by the trial court for the reasons set out in the impugned order (closure of plaintiff evidence, absence of affidavit/supporting documents for municipal record application, etc.).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after amendment of pleadings following closure of evidence, the petitioner was entitled to recall the plaintiff for further cross-examination and to re-examine the defendant's witness under Order 18, Rule 17 CPC (or otherwise in the exercise of the trial court's discretion).
  2. Whether the trial court erred in refusing to summon the Municipal Corporation's assessment register (original or certified copies) in the absence of an affidavit or other proof that the petitioner had been unable to obtain certified copies, having regard to Rule 104 and Rule 105 of the M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961 and the Right to Information Act, 2005.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • After amendment of the written statement, the petitioner was entitled to further cross-examine the plaintiff and to re-examine the defendant to prove the factual contentions introduced by the amendment (three prior suits decided by compromise leading to plaintiff's possession negating bona fide necessity).
  • If permission to cross-examine and re-examine was not granted, the purpose of allowing amendment would be frustrated because amended pleadings require proof and without cross-examination the amended contentions cannot be substantiated.
  • The petitioner had applied to the Municipal Corporation for a certified copy of the Property Tax Assessment Register but was denied on the ground that a third person is not entitled to copies; this fact was said to be stated in the application under Order 16, Rule 1 CPC. If an affidavit was missing, the petitioner sought one opportunity to file it or to obtain the certified copy from the Corporation.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended the petitioner's conduct was intended to delay proceedings: the suit was filed in 2000, evidence had closed, and the amendment was sought belatedly.
  • The respondent argued that the plaint amendment clarified the position and made further cross-examination or re-examination unnecessary; allowing such further examination would cause delay and harassment.
  • Regarding municipal records, the respondent maintained the petitioner had not filed any affidavit or documentary proof that an application for a certified copy was made and rejected; municipal records are public and the petitioner had not produced cogent evidence to justify calling original records, so the trial court rightly rejected the request.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
J. Jermons v. Aliammal Explains that when an amendment raises additional factual matters (e.g., comparative hardship, occupancy details) those additional facts must be brought on record and, where appropriate, the matter may be remanded to give the opposite party opportunity to file further pleadings and adduce evidence. The Court relied on this authority to show that amendment may necessitate additional evidence and opportunities to be given to the opposite party when new factual matters are raised by amendment.
Dondapati Narayana Reddy v. Duggireddy Venkatanarayana Reddy Addresses scope of Order 6, Rule 17 and Order 18, Rule 17 CPC: amendments should generally be allowed unless unjust or prejudicial in a way not compensable by costs; when amendment affects the basis of the suit the other party acquires a right to lead additional evidence. The Court cited this decision to support the proposition that where an amendment challenges the basis of a suit (or introduces material issues), the opposite party should be permitted to lead additional evidence and that rejecting such a prayer rigidly is improper.
Parasram v. Smt. Gopibai (1985 MPWN Note 94) Holds that where amendments have been allowed, ordinarily the party should have an opportunity to establish by evidence the facts pleaded by way of amendments, including cross-examination of the other side's witnesses introduced by the amendments; the trial court has discretion under Order 18, Rule 17 to recall witnesses and should exercise it judicially. The Court used this authority to underscore that permitting amendment typically entails giving reasonable opportunity to lead evidence and to recall/cross-examine witnesses, and that a refusal may amount to failure to exercise discretion properly.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two analytical strands corresponding to the two applications under challenge.

1. On recalling the plaintiff and re-examining the defendant (amendment-related relief)

  • The Court examined the amended pleadings: the defendant's written statement alleged that three suits (Nos. 17-A/2004, 35-A/2004 and 10-A/2004) were compromised and resulted in possession of the relevant accommodation by the plaintiff, thereby negating the plaintiff's bona fide necessity; the plaintiff amended the plaint (para 4A) to explain that even if possession in other matters is obtained, the plaintiff's need for the specific accommodation would persist and that the plaintiff had not obtained possession from other tenants.
  • The Court observed that there was a clear controversy between the parties on this factual aspect: the defendant asserted that possession obtained via compromise eliminated bona fide necessity, while the plaintiff denied that and asserted continuing need. Given that contradiction, the Court reasoned that the amendment was material and that permitting amendment without an opportunity to prove the amended facts would render the amendment meaningless.
  • The Court articulated the governing legal principle: the purpose of amendment is to place material facts before the Court; where amended pleadings introduce disputed facts, the party in whose favour amendment is allowed is ordinarily entitled to a reasonable opportunity to prove those facts. The Court emphasized the need to balance this right against the risk of re-opening the entire case: any opportunity to lead evidence must be limited to the scope of the amended pleadings and not used to reopen the case de novo.
  • The Court relied on cited authorities (J. Jermons; Dondapati; Parasram) to reinforce that amendments normally permit additional evidence and recall/cross-examination if necessary, and that denial of such reasonable opportunity can frustrate the purpose of amendment.
  • Applying these principles to the facts, the Court found the petitioner's request for permission to further cross-examine the plaintiff and re-examine the defendant's witness to be reasonable and that the trial court erred in rejecting it. Accordingly, the Court quashed the portion of the impugned order rejecting that relief and allowed the petitioner's application for that prayer.

2. On calling the Municipal Corporation's assessment register (public record)

  • The Court noted that the petitioner had not produced particulars showing when any application to the Municipal Corporation for certified copies was filed, nor any order of the authority rejecting such request; the trial court found the application silent on these points and had also noted absence of an affidavit in support.
  • The Court reviewed Rule 104 and Rule 105 of the M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961 (and Order XIII, Rule 10 CPC referred therein), which require an affidavit setting out the necessity for production and explanation why a duly authenticated copy cannot be obtained without unreasonable delay or expense; Rule 105 states that originals of public/municipal records should not be called when duly authenticated certified copies are admissible.
  • Given these provisions and the petitioner's failure to place on record any documentary evidence or affidavit showing denial of certified copies, the Court held that the trial court's rejection of the application to call the Municipal Corporation record was not erroneous.
  • However, because the Court allowed the petitioner an opportunity to lead evidence on the amended pleadings, it exercised equitable discretion to give the petitioner a further practical opportunity: the petitioner may, within four weeks, file certified copies of the municipal record; if filed, the trial court shall receive those copies in evidence. If the petitioner cannot obtain certified copies, he may approach the trial court in accordance with Rule 104 and the trial court may reconsider the matter under law without prejudice from the earlier rejection.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Petition allowed in part.

Specific consequences directed by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The impugned order insofar as it rejected the petitioner's prayer for recalling the plaintiff for further cross-examination and for re-examining the defendant's witness is quashed; the petitioner's application for that relief is allowed. The trial court must permit a limited opportunity to prove the facts introduced by the amended pleadings (subject to judicial control to prevent reopening the case de novo).
  • The trial court's rejection of the petitioner's application to call the Municipal Corporation's assessment register was not found to be erroneous because the petitioner did not produce the requisite affidavit or documentary proof of denial of certified copies. Nevertheless, the petitioner is granted leave to file certified copies of the municipal record within four weeks; if filed, the trial court is directed to receive them in evidence. If the petitioner cannot obtain certified copies, he may approach the trial court under Rule 104 M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961 and the trial court may reconsider the request in accordance with law.
  • No order as to costs was made.

Broader precedential impact: The opinion applies established authorities on amendments and the right to adduce evidence (as cited) to reinforce that amendments which introduce disputed facts ordinarily justify a limited opportunity to lead evidence; the opinion did not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond the application of those precedents and rules to the facts of this case.

    Ram Vishal Alias Vishali Kachhawaha v. Dwarka Prasad Jalswal

    1. The petitioner has challenged order dated 24-8-2005 passed by Second Civil Judge, Class-II, Katni in Civil Original Suit No. 12-A/2000, by which petitioner's prayer for recalling the plaintiff for cross-examination in consequence of amendment in the pleadings and another application for sending for the records from the office of Municipal Corporation in respect of assessment of Property Tax has been rejected.

    2. The case of the petitioner is that a suit for eviction has been filed by the respondent against the petitioner in respect of residential accommodation. After closure of evidence an application for amendment was filed by the petitioner on 18-7-2005 in which the petitioner sought amendment of written statement stating that three civil suits were filed by the plaintiff in respect of his bona fide necessity. Those suits were decided by compromise and the accommodation involved in the aforesaid suit has come into the possession of the plaintiff and there is no bona fide necessity to the plaintiff in respect of suit accommodation. This amendment was allowed by the trial Court.

    3. On 18-7-2005, the plaintiff moved an application seeking amendment in the plaint in which para 4A of the plaint was amended by which the plaintiff has explained the aforesaid situation and has stated that the plaintiff is willing to settle all the family members as per his status and even after getting possession of the accommodation involved in the other suits, the bona fide necessity shall not be fulfilled. The plaintiff has not got possession of aforesaid accommodation. This amendment in the plaint was also allowed by the trial Court.

    4. Thereafter petitioner moved an application under Order 18, Rule 17, CPC on the ground that in view of the aforesaid amendment, the defendant is willing to further cross-examine the plaintiff and wants to further re-examine defendant in this regard. The said application was opposed by the plaintiff. The trial Court by the impugned order rejected the prayer on the ground that in the case evidence of plaintiff was already closed on 1-4-2005, the defendant was also examined on 13-4-2005. The defendant's another witness Sooraj Kachhwaha has also been examined on 13-8-2005. The petitioner's prayer so far as to prove the public document is concerned, the plaintiff has not raised any objection to read aforesaid document in evidence. On the aforesaid grounds the prayer of petitioner for recalling plaintiff and to further examine defendant has been turned down. The another application filed by the petitioner under Order 16, Rule 1(3) of CPC was for summoning the record of Municipal Corporation on the ground that petitioner moved an application before the Corporation for supply of certified copy of Property Tax Assessment Register, which has not been supplied, so original record be called. The application has been rejected by the trial Court on the ground that no affidavit in support of application was filed. Apart from this, the petitioner has not produced any document in support of the application that when he moved an application for supply of certified copy of the document and whether this was accepted or not. The Court found that in this regard the application is silent and rejected it by the impugned order.

    5. learned Counsel for petitioner submitted that :-

    (i) When the pleadings were amended the petitioner was entitled to further cross-examine the plaintiff and to re-examine defendant in support of aforesaid pleadings. As the subsequent pleadings have come on record and to prove the contentions raised in the pleading it is necessary to further cross-examine the plaintiff and defendant.

    (ii) If such permission is not granted the entire purpose of amending pleading shall frustrate and in absence of any proof or cross-examination of the plaintiff, the contention raised in the pleadings cannot take place of proof:-

    (iii) That the petitioner applied for certified copy of the record from the Municipal Corporation, but it was denied on the ground that third person is not entitled for the copies of assessment register. This fact was specifically mentioned in the application under Order 16, Rule 1, CPC. If the required affidavit was not filed, petitioner may be allowed one opportunity to file affidavit or to obtain certified copy from the Municipal Corporation.

    6. learned Counsel for respondent vehemently opposed the aforesaid contention and submitted that the entire conduct of petitioner is to delay the hearing of the case. The suit was filed in the year 2000 and after closure of evidence the amendment application was moved. The respondent/plaintiff has clarified the position by amending plaint. In the circumstances it is not necessary to further cross-examine plaintiff or to re-examine defendant in this regard, this will cause delay and harassment to the plaintiff. So far as requisition of the record of the Corporation is concerned, the petitioner has not filed any affidavit in support of his contention nor any documentary proof that he ever applied for the certified copy of document which was rejected by the Corporation. The record of the Corporation is a public record and until and in absence of some cogent evidence in respect of contention of petitioner, the trial Court has rightly rejected the application and no further opportunity be allowed to the petitioner.

    7. To appreciate rival contention of the parties, firstly the prayer of the petitioner in respect of recalling plaintiff for further cross-examination and for re-examination of defendant in respect of pleadings may be seen. In this case it is not in dispute that after closure of evidence the petitioner moved an application raising a plea that in 3 suits bearing No. 17-A/2004, 35-A/2004 and 10-A/2004 there was compromise between the plaintiff and tenant concerned and the said accommodation has come into possession of the plaintiff, and the bona fide necessity has come to an end. The plaintiff in reply to the aforesaid pleading has amended plaint by incorporating para 4-A in the plainti, in which it is stated that the defendant is a tenant of one room and Parchhi and other tenants were also having similar accommodation. The plaintiff as per his status shall rearrange the accommodation for residence. After getting possession of accommodation in possession of defendant and other tenants, the bona fide necessity shall be fulfilled. The plaintiff has not got possession of the accommodation from other tenants. The defendant cannot assess the necessity of plaintiff and the said necessity shall be considered by the Court as per the status of plaintiff.

    8. From the perusal of aforesaid pleadings, it appears that there was admission in respect of the decree passed in favour of plaintiff. The plaintiff has explained it by incorporating para 4A in the plaint. The contention of plaintiff is that even after receiving vacant possession of the aforesaid accommodations, the plaintiff's need would not be fulfilled and still there is necessity of the accommodation occupied by the defendant. It is apparent that there is controversy in this regard. The plaintiff in the plaint was not pleaded in respect of other pending dispute for the bona fide necessity of his family members. If some decree has been passed, though on the basis of compromise in other suits and the petitioner has raised some contention in this regard, which has been specifically denied by the plaintiff, then the prayer of petitioner appears to be just and proper for further cross-examination of plaintiff and re-examination of defendant in this regard.

    9. The purpose of amendment of pleadings is to place material facts before the Court which are necessary, just and proper for deciding the real question in controversy between the parties. If some pleading has been amended after closure of evidence, the party in whose favour such an order has been passed would be entitled for reasonable opportunity to prove the contention raised in the pleading, otherwise the entire purpose of amendment of pleading shall frustrate. Without any proof there is no meaning of amendment of pleading or the pleading though on record, but in absence of proof no finding can be recorded by the Court. Particularly when the contention has been denied/contradicted by the other party, in these circumstances in the interest of justice the Court has to allow an opportunity in this regard to prove amended pleadings. Simultaneously the Court should also see that the aforesaid opportunity is not misutilised by any of the party and in the garb of such opportunity the case is not reopened de novo. In each and every case it is to be seen whether such an opportunity is necessary and to what extent. If the contention can be proved by recalling all the witnesses and/or by further examination of witnesses the Courts are empowered to grant such opportunity. The Courts while granting such an opportunity shall see that the entire case is not reopened and this opportunity shall be limited to the extent of newly amended pleadings. The Apex Court in J. Jermons v. Aliammal considering the similar question held (para 37) :-

    From the above discussion, it is evident that the requirements of Clause (a) are different from the requirements of Clause (c). For purposes of Clause (c), the following additional facts will be necessary viz. whether the landlord is occupying only a part of the building whether residential or non-residential and whether the tenant is occupying the whole or any portion of the remaining part of the building and the facts relevant to the consider ration with regard to comparative hardship to the landlord and tenant. Such facts are to be brought on record because they are not the subject-matter of consideration in an application filed under Sub-section (3)(a). In a case where the original application for eviction is based, inter alia, on the ground in clause (a) of sub-section (3) and an application for amendment of eviction petition is allowed permitting to raise further ground under Clause (c) either by the appellate authority or the revisional authority, the appropriate course will he to remand the case to the Rent Controller for giving opportunity to the opposite party to file further pleadings and adduce such evidence relevant to the issue, as they desire. Inasmuch as the petition filed by the respondents and allowed by the High Court was to raise additional ground in the revision and not to amend the eviction petition, we are of the view that it is not a fit case to remand the matter to the Rent Controller.

    The Apex Court in Dondapati Narayana Reddy v. Duggireddy Venkatanarayana Reddy considering the scope of Order 6, Rule 17 and Order 18, Rule 17, CPC held (paras 9 to 11) :-

    Rules governing pleadings and leading of evidence have been incorporated to advance the interests of justice and to avoid multiplicity of litigation. If the claim of the plaintiff Dondapati Narayana Reddy is based upon the Will dated 20-8-1994 executed by Dondapati Tirumala Ramareddy, the defendant-appellant has a right to seek the amendment of his written statement incorporating the plea sought to be introduced by way of proposed amendment. Such a prayer cannot be denied on hypertechnical grounds. The amendment should generally, be allowed unless it is shown that permitting the amendment would be unjust and result in prejudice against the opposite side which cannot be compensated by costs or would deprive him of a right which has accrued to him with the lapse of time. Amendment may also be refused, if such a prayer made separately, is shown to be barred by time. Neither the trial Court nor the High Court has found the existence of any of the circumstances justifying the rejection of the prayer for amendment of the written statement. Whether or not the amendment is allowed the trial Court is otherwise obliged to decide the validity of the disputed Will which is the basis of the suit filed by the plaintiff. We are of the opinion that the Courts below were not justified in rejecting the prayer of the defendant seeking amendment of his written statement.

    In view of the fact that the validity of the Will was sought to be challenged by way of amendment, the plaintiff acquired a right to lead evidence to prove its authenticity. Otherwise also when the basis of the suit was the Will dated 20-8-1994, the interests of justice demanded that the plaintiff should have been allowed an opportunity to lead additional evidence to prove its validity. The High Court appears to have adopted a very rigid and technical approach in rejecting the prayer of the plaintiff to lead additional evidence to prove testamentary succession by producing the registered Will dated 20-8-1994 executed by Dondapati Tirumala Ramareddy.

    In view of what has been stated herein-above, both the appeals are allowed by setting aside the impugned orders and by allowing the applications filed by the plaintiff and defendant 1. The trial Court shall allow the defendant to amend the written statement and permit the plaintiff to adduce additional evidence to prove testamentary succession by producing the registered Will dated 20-8-1994 as prayed for by him in IA No. 1283 of 2000. Costs made easy.

    A single Bench of this Court considering the effect of amendment of pleading and the right to examine and re-examine the witness, in Parasram v. Smt. Gopibai (1985 MPWN Note 94) held thus :-

    It is, no doubt, true that the defendants-applicants had been negligent in not incorporating the amendments in the written-statement which were allowed by the trial Court as far back as 27-11-1981 till 22-3-1984 i.e. for a period of two years and four months and the Court could have refused in its discretion to extend time for permitting incorporation of the amendments. But the learned trial Court permitted the defendants to incorporate the amendments. Normally when the amendments have been allowed the defendants should have opportunity to establish by evidence the facts pleaded by way of amendments and for that purpose would be given opportunity not only to examine their own witnesses but also to cross-examine the witnesses of the plaintiffs on the facts introduced by amendment of written-statement. The belated steps taken by the defendants, no doubt, prolongs the litigation but the plaintiffs can be compensated for the same by way of costs and the defendants can also be required to incur the expenses for recalling the witnesses of the plaintiffs for cross-examination on the amended pleadings.

    The learned trial Court has considered whether or not the evidence on the amended pleadings would be any avail to the defendants on merits. But whereas the consideration whether an amendment would be relevant for deciding the controversy in suit is to be made at the stage of deciding the amendment application and not later at the stage of calling the witnesses for proving the facts introduced by amendment.

    The learned trial Court appears to have rejected the prayer for the defendants for recalling the two witnesses of the plaintiffs on the view that the defendants are not entitled to produce evidence under Order 18, Rule 17-A of the Code as the said provision is not applicable in the facts and circumstances of the present case. All the same the learned trial Court had the discretionary power under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code for permitting recall of plaintiffs witnesses and it should have, in proper exercise of discretion, allowed the defendants application for recalling the plaintiffs' witnesses so that its order permitting incorporation of the amendments in the written-statement is not rendered nugatory but effectual and meaningful. The learned Court has apparently failed to exercise the discretion judicially. Revision allowed.

    10. The purpose of amendment of pleading and leading of evidence is to advance interest of justice and to prevent multiplicity of suits. If the pleadings are amended and the other party has denied the averments of amended pleading, naturally the other party has to substantiate its contention by adducing evidence. If the Court has permitted a party to amend the pleading in respect of controversy, but no opportunity to lead evidence is allowed to the party, the entire purpose to amend the pleading shall be futile. For additional pleadings, looking to the exigency of the case the trial Court has to allow the parties to lead evidence. What should be the extent of this opportunity is to be seen by the Court in the facts of particular case and no hard and fast rule can be laid down in this regard. But when there is controversy in respect of factual position, the trial Court should extend a reasonable opportunity to lead evidence, in absence of which the party who has amended pleading shall be deprived to prove his case as brought on record by him by amending the pleading.

    11. In the aforesaid circumstances, the trial Court committed an error in rejecting the application of the petitioner. The petitioner has only sought permission of the Court to further cross-examine the plaintiff and re-examine the witness of defendant, the prayer of petitioner was reasonable and ought to have been allowed by the Court below. In these circumstances, the order so far as it relates to the rejection of prayer of petitioner for aforesaid relief, is not sustainable under law and accordingly it is quashed and the petitioner's application for aforesaid prayer is allowed.

    12. Now the second contention may be seen by which petitioner has prayed to the trial Court to send for the record of Municipal corporation in respect of assessment register. The petitioner has not submitted particulars when the application was filed and whether it was allowed or rejected. No order of the authority was produced before the Court in this regard. The record of Municipal Corporation is a public record and usually it will be presumed that there should be no difficulty in getting the certified copy of public record. Apart from this after enactment of the Right to Information Act, 2005, the position has become more liberal. If the petitioner applies for the certified copy of public record and it has been denied there must be some reason and this reason ought to have been placed on record by filing appropriate record in this regard and needless to say that supported by an affidavit of petitioner. But the petitioner has not produced any record nor submitted any details in respect of his filing of application for supply of certified copy of aforesaid public record or about the reasons of aforesaid rejection of prayer. Apart from this no affidavit in support of application was filed by the petitioner.

    13. Rule 104 of the M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961 specifically provides that procedure envisaged under Order 13, Rule 10, CPC, shall be applicable to other public records and an affidavit setting forth the necessity for production of record should State not merely that the record is material to the suit, but must also show that the applicant cannot, without unreasonable delay or expense, obtain a duly authenticated copy or in what way the production of the original is necessary. Rule 105 of M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961 also provides that subject to any provision of law to contrary, the originals of public and municipal records should not be called for when duly authenticated and certified copies of the same are admissible in evidence and will serve the purpose for which the records are required. For ready reference, it will be necessary to reproduce the Rules 104 & 105, which reads as under :-

    104(1). Attention is invited to Rule 10 of Order XIII which states that law as to the production of Court records. The principle laid down in Sub-rule (2) of that rule may well be applied to other public records.

    (2) Affidavits under Order XIII, Rule 10(2), setting forth the necessity for production of records should state not merely that the record is material to the suit, but must also show how the record is material and also that the applicant cannot, without unreasonable delay or expense, obtain a duly authenticated copy or in what way the production of the original is necessary.

    105. Subject to any provision of the law to contrary, the originals of public and municipal records should not be called for when duly authenticated and certified copies of the same are admissible in evidence and will serve the purpose for which the records are required.

    14. In view of aforesaid specific provision under M.P. Civil Courts Rules, 1961, if the Court has rejected the prayer of petitioner for calling the record, no error can be found. However, as the petitioner has been allowed an opportunity to adduce evidence in the matter, the petitioner shall be free to file certified copy of aforesaid record within a period of four weeks from today. If such copies are filed by the petitioner within a period of four weeks from today, the trial Court shall receive the aforesaid copies in evidence. In case petitioner fails to get the certified copy, he will be free to approach the trial Court in accordance with Rule 104 of M.P. Civil Court Rules, 1961. If any such application is filed the trial Court shall be free to reconsider the matter, in accordance with law, without being prejudiced with the rejection of previous application.

    15. With the aforesaid, this petition is allowed in part as indicated hereinabove, with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Vishal Alias Vishali Kachhawaha v. Dwarka Prasad Jalswal
    (Dec 7, 2005)