Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules (in Swamy's Compilation)
  • provisions of sub-rule (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules (in Swamy's Compilation)
  • provisions of sub-rule (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as an unskilled labourer on 26-12-1976. Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him for making a bogus LTC claim without undertaking the journey, resulting in compulsory retirement by order dated 2-7-1994, which was affirmed by the Appellate Authority. The petitioner challenged this in O.A No. 124 of 1997 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Jabalpur Bench. The Tribunal, by order dated 1-11-2002, directed the Appellate Authority to reconsider the quantum of punishment, noting that similarly placed employees had received lesser penalties. Following this, the Appellate Authority moderated the punishment on 28-1-2003 to a reduction of pay to the minimum of the pay scale for three years, treating the intervening period as dies-non without back wages. Consequently, the petitioner was reinstated on 21-2-2003 with the period from 1-7-1994 to 20-2-2003 treated as dies-non.

The petitioner filed O.A No. 44 of 2004 before the Tribunal seeking to quash the orders dated 28-1-2003 and 21-2-2003 to the extent they treated the period as dies-non and denied pecuniary benefits, and also challenged an order dated 12-6-2003 regarding recovery of pension paid during that period. He sought a declaration that the period should be treated as on salary or half salary. The Tribunal rejected this application by order dated 17-12-2004, which is under challenge in this petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the period between compulsory retirement and reinstatement should be regularised as period on salary or half salary with pay and allowances, or treated as dies-non when the punishment is modified by the authority following Tribunal directions?
  2. Whether FR 54-A(1) applies to cases where the punishment is set aside conditionally with directions to impose a lesser punishment?
  3. Whether the marking of dies-non for the period between termination and reinstatement is legally permissible under the applicable rules and government instructions?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner argued that when compulsory retirement is set aside by a Court and the employee reinstated, the period between termination and reinstatement must be regularised with pay and allowances under FR 54-A(1).
  • He relied on FR 54-A(1), which mandates regularisation of absence and payment of pay and allowances when dismissal or compulsory retirement is set aside unconditionally by a Court and reinstatement occurs without further inquiry.
  • The petitioner contended that marking the period as dies-non is impermissible except in three specific circumstances under Rule 11 of CCS (CCA) Rules (Swamy's Compilation), none of which apply to his case.
  • He sought a declaration that the period between 2-7-1994 and 20-2-2003 be treated as period on salary or half salary, with corresponding pecuniary benefits.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed FR 54-A(1) and found it applicable only where dismissal, removal, or compulsory retirement is set aside unconditionally by a Court and the employee reinstated without further inquiry or reconsideration of punishment. In this case, the Tribunal directed imposition of a lesser punishment, leaving discretion to the authority to decide the quantum of punishment and treatment of the period of absence.

The Court explained that the authority's direction to treat the period as dies-non means maintaining continuity of service but excluding that period from leave, salary, increment, and pension benefits. This is consistent with FR 54(1), which requires the authority to make specific orders on pay and allowances and whether the period counts as duty.

The Court rejected the petitioner's reliance on Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, clarifying that the three circumstances listed for marking dies-non relate only to absence or refusal to perform duty while in service, and not to periods between termination and reinstatement upon modification of punishment.

Ultimately, the Court held that the appellate authority acted within its discretion in treating the period as dies-non and that there was no legal infirmity in the order.

Holding and Implications

The Court's final decision is DISMISSED.

The petition was found to be without merit, affirming the authority's discretion to treat the period between compulsory retirement and reinstatement as dies-non when punishment is modified following Tribunal directions. The petitioner’s claim for pay and allowances during this period was denied. No new precedent was established; the decision directly affects the parties by upholding the treatment of the period as dies-non and denying pecuniary benefits for that time.

    Battilal v. Union Of India .

    1. The petitioner was appointed as an unskilled labour on 26-12-1976. Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him in regard to a charge of making bogus LTC claim without actually undertaking the journey, culminating in imposition of punishment of compulsory retirement by order dated 2-7-1994 which was affirmed by the Appellate Authority. That was challenged by the petitioner in O.A No. 124 of 1997 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Bench Jabalpur. The Tribunal by order dated 1-11-2002 disposed of the matter with a direction to the Appellate Authority only to reconsider the case of the petitioner in regard to quantum of punishment on the ground that in the case of some similarly placed the employees, a penalty of compulsory retirement had been reduced to a lesser penalty. In pursuance of the said order, the Appellate Authority reconsidered the matter and passed the following order on 28-1-2003:

    “…………In deference to the observations made by CAT regarding differential treatment meted out to the appellant, the undersigned has re-appreciated the case and after, proper examination has decided to moderate the penalty of compulsory retirement to reduction of pay to the minimum of the pay scale for a period of 3 years with cumulative effect with the stipulation that the intervening period between the date of compulsory retirement and the date of reinstatement shall be treated as dies-non and no back wages shall be payable for the period in question.”

    2. In pursuance of the order dated 28-1-2003; the petitioner was reinstated by order dated 21-2-2003 by treating the period between 1-7-1994 to 20-2-2003 as dies-non.

    3. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner again approached the Tribunal in O.A No. 44 of 2004 for quashing the order dated 28-1-2003 and 21-2-2003 to the extent it treated the period from 2-7-1994 to 22-2-2003 as dies-non and denied pecuniary benefits and consequentially for quashing the order dated 12-6-2003 regarding recovery of pension that was paid from 2-7-1994.

    4. He also sought a declaration that the said period should either be treated as period on salary or the period during which he was entitled to half salary. The said application has been rejected by the Tribunal by order dated 17-12-2004 which is under challenge in this petition.

    5. The petitioner contends that when an order of compulsory retirement or termination is set aside in pursuance of the order of the Court and the delinquent employee is reinstated, the period between the date of termination to the date of reinstatement should be regularised and he should be paid pay and allowances in accordance with the relevant rules. In that behalf, the petitioner relied on FR 54-A (1) which reads as under:

    “F.R 54-A (1). Where the dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement of a Government servant is set aside by a Court of Law and such Government servant is reinstated without holding any further inquiry, the period of absence from duty shall be regularised and the Government servant shall be paid pay and allowance in accordance with the provisions of sub-rule (2) or (3) subject to the directions, if any, of the Court.”

    6. A careful reading of the said clause would show that it applies only where the order of dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement is set aside unconditionally by a Court of Law and the Government servant is reinstated without holding any further inquiry and without any further consideration relating to punishment. It does not apply where the punishment imposed is set aside by a Court or a Tribunal with a direction to impose a lesser punishment, Where the Tribunal directs the authority to consider and impose a lesser punishment than what is imposed, the matter is wholly within the discretion of the authority who decides on the punishment, subject only to the condition that the punishment should be lesser than the earlier punishment. Therefore, FR 54-A would have no application. The authority imposing the punishment can direct how the period when the employee was out of service shall be treated. When the Authority directs that the period will be treated dies-non it means that continuity of service is maintained, but the period treated as decision will not count for leave salary, increment and pension. In fact, FR 54 (1) casts such a duty on the authority. It provides that when a Government servant who has been dismissed, removed or compulsorily retired is reinstated as result of appeal or review, the authority competent to order reinstatement shall consider and make a specific order—

    (a) regarding the pay and allowances to be paid to the Government servant for the period of his absence from duty including the period of suspension preceding his dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement as the case may be; and

    (b) whether or-not the said period shall be treated as a period spent on duty.

    7. The petitioner next referred to the Government instructions noted under Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules (in Swamy's Compilation) clarifying that marking of dies-non by the leave sanctioning authority is permissible, only in three circumstances, namely (a) when the official remains absent from duty without prior information (b) when on duty in office, the official leaves the office without proper permission and (c) the official remains in office, but refuses to perform duty assigned to him. According to the petitioner, dies-non can be marked only in the said three situations and not otherwise. The entire contention is misconceived and if we may say so, absurd. The three instances were referred, while clarifying that marking of dies-non is not permissible for late coming. It has nothing to do with the period between the date of termination and reinstatement being treated as dies-non where an employee is reinstated as a consequence of imposition of a lesser punishment. The disciplinary authority or the appellate authority, while imposing a lesser punishment in pursuance of the order of the Tribunal has full authority to direct how the period between the date of termination to date of reinstatement is to be treated and pass appropriate orders thereon. In this case the appellate authority has considered the matter and directed that the said period be treated as dies-non. Therefore, the question of interfering with it does not arise as there is no legal infirmity in the order

    8. The petitioner next contended that if the period between 2-7-1994 and 20-2-2003 was treated as dies-non, it would mean that he will not get any salary for the said period and the said period will also not be treated as qualifying service for purposes of pension, and that would cause hardship to him. The petitioner was earlier compulsorily retired. He should count himself lucky that in spite of the charge of production of fake documents for claiming benefit of LTC being proved, the Tribunal was kind enough to direct lesser punishment than compulsory retirement resulting in reinstatement. The petitioner should not expect more.

    9. The petition is absolutely without merit and is dismissed.

    10. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Battilal v. Union Of India .
    (Feb 21, 2005)