AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: S.K. Dubey, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a claimants' appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, challenging the award dated 29.11.1994 in Claim Case No. 12 of 1991 by the Vth Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Raipur. On 6.3.1991 the deceased, Mohd. Ismail, travelling as a passenger in autorickshaw No. MPO 23-B-1005 (owned and driven by respondent No. 1 and insured with respondent No. 2), sustained severe injuries when the autorickshaw turned turtle due to negligent driving; he subsequently died in D.K. Hospital. The widow, Koushar Suraiya (who died during the pendency of the Section 166 application), together with the appellants as legal representatives, claimed Rs. 5,53,000 by way of compensation. The Tribunal held the accident was caused by negligent driving, awarded Rs. 1,32,000 with interest at 12% per annum from the date of application (3.5.1991) until realisation, and made respondent No.1 liable while absolving respondent No.2 (the insurer) on the ground that respondent No.1 did not hold a valid licence to drive the transport vehicle.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 1,32,000) was just and fair and should be enhanced having regard to the deceased's earnings, prospects and conventional heads of damages (consortium, loss of estate, funeral expenses).
  2. Whether the insurance company (respondent No. 2) is liable to pay compensation where the owner-driver (respondent No. 1) held a driving licence authorising him to drive a light motor vehicle but the licence did not bear a specific endorsement authorising him to drive a transport vehicle (motor cab/autorickshaw).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 1,32,000) was inadequate. The deceased was 47 years old and in regular employment at a Government Primary School, drawing gross pay of Rs. 2,360 per month (Exh. A-1).
  • The Tribunal's multiplicand (dependency) estimation at Rs. 1,100 per month and the multiplier of 10 were insufficient. The Tribunal failed to account for future prospects/advancement in life and career which should augment the multiplicand.
  • Additional conventional heads — consortium, loss of estate and Rs. 2,000 for funeral expenses — ought to have been awarded.
  • Cited General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corpn. v. Susamma Thomas (1994 ACJ 1 (SC)) in support of assessing future prospects and augmenting the multiplicand.
  • Challenged absolvement of respondent No.2 (insurer) as illegal: the owner-driver held a licence (Exh. A-6) to drive light motor vehicles; although it lacked a specific endorsement for a transport vehicle, he was not disqualified to drive such a vehicle and thus the insurer should not be absolved.

Respondent No. 1's Arguments

  • Submitted that the Tribunal's award of compensation was just and did not require enhancement.
  • Challenged the Tribunal's finding exonerating the insurance company (respondent No.2). Argued that the insurance policy permitted specified persons (including the insured) to drive, subject to the driver holding an effective driving licence with required endorsements.
  • Noted that the insured was the driver, held a licence for light motor vehicles, and was not disqualified to drive a light transport vehicle (autorickshaw), so the insurance company cannot escape liability.
  • Cited several authorities in support of insurer liability where the owner-driver held a licence and was not disqualified.

Respondent No. 2's Arguments (Insurance Company)

  • Accepted that respondent No.1 had a driving licence for light motor vehicles but argued it did not bear the Licensing Authority's endorsement authorising him to drive a transport vehicle.
  • Contended that an autorickshaw is a motor cab (Section 2(25)) and a transport/public service vehicle (Sections 2(35), 2(47)), and therefore the licence must specifically entitle the holder to drive a transport vehicle under Section 3.
  • On that basis the insured did not hold a valid licence to drive the transport vehicle, and the insurer was correctly absolved by the Tribunal.
  • Cited Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi v. Ranguba (1994 ACJ 1280 (Gujarat)) in support of the need for endorsement and non-liability of the insurer where such authorisation is absent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corpn. v. Susamma Thomas, 1994 ACJ 1 (SC) Cited by appellants for the proposition that future prospects/advancement should be taken into account in assessing the multiplicand (augmenting the multiplicand). Cited by appellants; the Court considered future prospects and increased the multiplicand and overall compensation accordingly.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Devidas, 1986 ACJ 312 (MP) Cited by respondent No.1 in support of insurer liability where the owner-driver held a licence and was not disqualified. One of the authorities relied upon by respondent No.1; noted by the Court among a group of cases cited on insurer liability.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Prem Narayan Saku, 1996 MPLJ 399 Cited by respondent No.1 to support insurer liability in circumstances where the driver held a licence and was not shown to be disqualified. Cited by respondent No.1; noted by the Court among authorities supporting the insurer-liability stance.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Batulan Bi, M.A. No. 675 of 1994 (decided 31.7.1997) Cited by respondent No.1 as part of a line of authority on insurer liability. Cited by respondent No.1; included in the Court's review of decisions relied upon by parties.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sudama, M.A. No. 720 of 1995 (decided 25.6.1997) Cited by respondent No.1; also noted as a decision of the Court itself that followed a line permitting insurer liability absent proof of disqualification. The Court referred to and followed this line of authority when holding that, lacking evidence that the driver was disqualified, the insurer cannot escape liability.
Sanjay Gupta v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 1997 ACJ 216 (Allahabad) Cited by respondent No.1 in support of the insurer's liability where driver held a licence and was not disqualified. Cited by respondent No.1; noted by the Court among supporting authorities.
Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi v. Ranguba, 1994 ACJ 1280 (Gujarat) Cited by respondent No.2 for the principle that absence of specific authorisation/endorsement on the licence may disentitle the driver and absolve the insurer. The Court considered this authority but distinguished it on its facts, holding it was not helpful to respondent No.2 in the present circumstances.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Bare Lal, 1998 ACJ 248 (MP) Division Bench view that where the insurer fails to lead evidence that the driver was disqualified, the insurer cannot escape liability even if the licence lacks specific endorsement for the higher class of vehicle. The Court placed reliance on this decision, treating it as persuasive for the proposition that absence of proof of disqualification prevents the insurer from escaping liability.
B.V. Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan, 1996 ACJ 1178 (SC) Supreme Court authority relied upon for the position that, in the absence of evidence that the driver was disqualified, insurer cannot be absolved. Relied upon (through Bare Lal) by the Court as part of the Supreme Court line of authorities supporting insurer liability where disqualification is not proved by the insurer.
Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987 ACJ 411 (SC) Supreme Court authority cited for the principle that insurer must prove disqualification to avoid liability. Relied upon (through Bare Lal) by the Court in concluding that, absent proof of disqualification, the insurer cannot escape liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed two principal matters: (A) the quantum of compensation; and (B) the liability of the insurer.

A. Quantum of Compensation

  1. The Court accepted that the deceased was in regular employment drawing a salary of Rs. 2,360 per month (proved by Exh. A-1).
  2. Because the deceased would have earned increments (and possibly promotion), the Court assessed his notional earning at Rs. 3,000 per month.
  3. From Rs. 3,000 the Court deducted one-third towards the deceased's personal living expenses and a further sum of Rs. 500 for out-of-pocket expenses, arriving at a monthly dependency of Rs. 1,500 (i.e., yearly Rs. 18,000).
  4. Applying a multiplier of 10 to the annual dependency produced Rs. 1,80,000. The Court then added Rs. 8,000 for loss of estate and Rs. 2,000 for funeral expenses, making a total award of Rs. 1,90,000.
  5. The Court awarded interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of application until realisation (the same rate as the Tribunal had awarded originally on Rs. 1,32,000).

B. Liability of the Insurance Company

  1. The Court observed that autorickshaw was a motor cab and thus a transport vehicle under the Act; it also noted respondent No.1 was the insured owner-driver and possessed a driving licence authorising him to drive a light motor vehicle.
  2. Section 3 of the Motor Vehicles Act requires that a person shall not drive a transport vehicle unless his driving licence specifically entitles him so to do; Section 10 enumerates the classes of vehicles a licence may authorise and does not itself speak of an endorsement.
  3. The Court acknowledged prior authority (including the Gujarat High Court in Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi) to the effect that absence of authorisation on the licence may render the licence invalid for driving a transport vehicle and thus absolve the insurer.
  4. However, the Court proceeded to examine whether the insurer in this case had a valid defence under Section 149(2)(a)(ii) — namely, that the vehicle was driven by a person not duly licensed, or by a person disqualified from holding a licence. The insurer did not lead any evidence to show that the driver was disqualified from holding or obtaining a licence to drive a transport vehicle.
  5. The Court relied on a Division Bench decision (Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Bare Lal) which, referring to Supreme Court authorities (B.V. Nagaraju and Skandia Insurance), held that where the insurer fails to show disqualification, it cannot escape liability even if the licence lacks a specific endorsement for the class of vehicle driven.
  6. Applying that principle to the facts — insured owner driving, holding a licence for light motor vehicle, and no evidence by the insurer of disqualification — the Court concluded that the insurer (respondent No.2) could not be absolved and was liable to indemnify/pay the compensation awarded.
  7. The Court expressly distinguished Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi on its facts, explaining that that case related to a driver who lacked a licence to drive as a paid employee and was authorised only to drive a light motor vehicle which had no authorisation to be used as a transport vehicle; thus that decision did not aid the insurer in the present case.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeals are allowed. The Tribunal's award is set aside and substituted by the Court's determination.

Core ruling: The appellants are entitled to Rs. 1,90,000 with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of application till realisation; the insurance company (respondent No.2) is liable to pay this amount (less amounts already deposited by it) and must deposit the balance with accrued interest within two months of supply of certified copy, failing which the amount shall carry interest at 15% per annum. On deposit, disbursement shall follow the Supreme Court guidelines.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The Tribunal's award is enhanced and the insurer, which had been absolved by the Tribunal, is held liable to make the substituted payment (subject to the adjustments and timelines stated by the Court).
  • Counsel's fee and costs: Appeals allowed with costs; counsel's fee fixed at Rs. 1,500 if pre-certified.
  • Broader precedent: The Court applied existing precedent (including decisions of a Division Bench and the Supreme Court) to reach the conclusion that an insurer must prove disqualification of the driver to escape liability; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying those authorities to the facts before it.

Order: Appeals allowed; substituted award in favour of appellants for Rs. 1,90,000 with interest at 12% per annum; insurer to deposit the amount within two months (else interest at 15%); disbursement per Supreme Court guidelines; costs awarded.

    Mohd. Karim Khan v. Shamsher Khan Hasan Khan And Another

    JUDGMENT S.K. Dubey, J.

    1. The order passed in this appeal will also govern the disposal of M.A. No. 323 of 1995 (Shamsher Khan v. Mohd. Karim Khan). This is claimants' appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short 'the Act') against the award dated 29.11.1994 passed in Claim Case No. 12 of 1991 by the Vth Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Raipur.

    2. The facts giving rise to this appeal are thus: On 6.3.1991, the deceased Mohd. Ismail was travelling as a passenger in autorickshaw No. MPO 23-B-1005 owned and driven by respondent No. 1 and insured with respondent No. 2. Due to the negligent driving, the autorickshaw turned turtle as a result of which Mohd. Ismail received severe injuries. He was taken to D.K. Hospital but could not survive. The widow Koushar Suraiya, who died during the pendency of the application under Section 166 of the Act, for compensation along with appellants as legal representatives of the deceased claimed compensation of Rs. 5,53,000 for the death of Mohd. Ismail caused in motor accident. The Tribunal, after holding that the accident was caused due to negligent driving of autorickshaw, awarded the compensation of Rs. 1,32,000, with interest thereon at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date of application, that is, 3.5.1991 till realisation. The respondent No. 1 was made liable to pay the compensation, absolving the respondent No. 2, as the respondent No. 1 was not holding a valid licence.

    3. Mr. AloK Aradhe, learned Counsel for the appellants has submitted that the compensation awarded is not just and fair. The deceased was aged 47 years and was employed in Government Primary School at Ramnagar, Raipur, whose gross pay was Rs. 2,360 as is proved by Exh. A-1. The Tribunal estimated the dependency at Rs. 1,100 per month, yearly Rs. 13,200, in that a multiplier of 10 was applied, the amount was worked out to Rs. 1,32,000. The Tribunal had not taken into account the future prospects of advancement in life and career which also ought to have been sounded in terms of money to augment the multiplicand; multiplier selected is also on the lower side. Besides the conventional amount for consortium and loss of estate and a sum of Rs. 2,000 towards funeral expenses ought to have been awarded. A decision of the Supreme Court in General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corpn. v. Susamma Thomas, 1994 ACJ 1 (SC), was cited. Absolvement of the respondent No. 2 was challenged as illegal because the owner himself was driving who was holding valid driving licence, Exh. A-6, to drive light motor vehicles. It merely did not bear the endorsement to drive the transport vehicle; but he was not disqualified to drive the transport vehicle, that is, autorickshaw, which the Tribunal has not taken into consideration.

    4. Mr. Awadh Tripathi, learned Counsel for respondent No. 1, though submitted that the award of compensation is just and fair and does not call for enhancement but challenged the finding of the Tribunal exonerating the insurance company from its liability to pay compensation. It was submitted that the policy of insurance, Exh. D-1, was for contract carriage. It was autorickshaw, a light motor vehicle permitted to carry 3 passengers besides the driver. The policy specifies the persons who arc entitled to drive, which reads thus:

    Persons or classes of persons entitled to drive: Any of the following --

    (a) The insured.

    (b) Any other person who is driving on insured's order or with his permission.

    Provided that the person driving holds or had held and has not been disqualified from holding an effective driving licence with all the required endorsements thereon as per the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and the rules made thereunder for the time being in force to drive the category of motor vehicle insured here-under.

    The insured was the driver, who was possessed of driving licence of light motor vehicle and was not disqualified to drive a light transport vehicle, therefore, the insurance company cannot escape its liability. Counsel cited the decisions in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Devidas, 1986 ACJ 312 (MP); National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Prem Narayan Saku, 1996 MPLJ 399; unreported decisions of this Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Batulan Bi, M.A, No. 675 of 1994, decided on 31.7.1997; and United India Insurance Co, Ltd. v. Sudama, M.A. No. 720 of 1995, decided on 25.6.1997; and a decision of the Allahabad High Court in Sanjay Gupta v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., 1997 ACJ 216 (Allahabad).

    5. Mr. K.L. Raj, learned Counsel for respondent No. 2 submitted that, true the respondent No. 1 was holding a driving licence to drive light motor vehicle but it did not bear endorsement of the Licensing Authority authorising him to drive the transport vehicle. Though autorickshaw is a light motor vehicle but it was motor cab under Section 2(25) of the Act constructed or adapted to carry not more than six passengers, excluding the driver for hire or reward. Motor cab is included in the definition of 'public service vehicle' under Section 2(35) of the Act, which is a transport vehicle under Section 2(47) of the Act. Therefore, an endorsement on the licence authorising the respondent No. 1 to drive a transport vehicle was essential. Hence, the insured was not holding a valid licence, therefore, the Tribunal exonerated the respondent No. 2 from its liability. Counsel cited the decision of Gujarat High Court in Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi v. Ranguba, 1994 ACJ 1280 (Gujarat).

    6. First we shall take up the grievance of the appellants in relation to compensation. It is not disputed that the deceased was in regular employment and was drawing a salary of Rs. 2,360 per month. He would have definitely earned increments if not promotion. Therefore, his earning is taken at Rs. 3,000; from that one-third is deducted towards his personal living expenses and a further sum of Rs. 500 for out of the pocket expenses, the dependency would not be less than Rs. 1,500 per month, yearly Rs. 18,000; to that a multiplier of 10 is applied, the amount would work out to Rs. 1,80,000 besides Rs. 8,000 for loss of estate and Rs. 2,000 for funeral expenses. Thus the total would come to Rs. 1,90,000 which the appellants would be entitled to get with interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date of application till realisation.

    Re: Liability of Insurance Company

    7. It is not in dispute that the auto-ricksnaw was a motor cab and was a transport vehicle as defined in Section 2(47) of the Act. It is also not in dispute that the insured himself was driving the auto-rickshaw, a light motor vehicle as defined in Section 2(21) of the Act. He had the licence to drive a light motor vehicle. Section 2(10) defines 'driving licence' as the licence issued by a Competent authority under Chapter II authorising the person specified therein to drive, otherwise than as a learner, a motor vehicle or a motor vehicle of any specified class or description.

    Chapter II deals with licensing of drivers of motor vehicles, of which Sections 3 and 10 are relevant for the purposes of this case, which we quote-

    3. Necessity for driving licence.-(1) No person shall drive a motor vehicle in any public place unless he holds an effective driving licence issued to him authorising him to drive the vehicle; and no person shall so drive a transport vehicle (other than a motor cab or motor cycle hired for his own use or rented under any scheme made under Sub-section (2) of Section 75) unless his driving licence specifically entitles him so to do.

    (2) The conditions subject to which Sub-section (1) shall not apply to a person receiving instructions in driving a motor vehicle shall be such as may be prescribed by the Central Government.

    XXX XXX XXX

    10. Form and contents of licences to drive.-(1) Every learner's licence and driving licence, except a driving licenceissued under Section 18, shall be in such form and shall contain such information as may be prescribed by the Central Government.

    (2) A learner's licence or, as the case may be, driving licence shall also be expressed as entitling the holder to drive a motor vehicle of one or more of the following classes, namely:

    (a) motor cycle without gear;

    (b) motor cycle with gear;

    (c) invalid carriage;

    (d) light motor vehicle;

    (e) medium goods vehicle;

    (f) medium passenger motor vehicle;

    (g) heavy goods vehicle;

    (h) heavy passenger motor vehicle;

    (i) road-roller;

    (j) motor vehicle of a specified description.

    8. The respondent No. 1 possessed the licence of the class of the vehicle specified in clause (d) of section 10. section 10 does not speak of any endorsement. However, Section 3 lays down that no person shall drive a motor vehicle in any pubiic place unless he holds an effective driving licence issued to him authorising him to drive the vehicle; and no person shall so drive a transport vehicle other than a motor cab hired for his own use or rented under any scheme made under Sub-section (2) of Section 75 unless his driving licence specifically entitles him so to do. It is true that if there is no authorisation on the driving licence to drive the transport vehicle as required by Section 3 such person cannot be said to be possessed of a valid driving licence to drive transport vehicle and, therefore, the insurer of such vehicle would not be liable to pay compensation or to indemnify the insured. [See the decision of Gujarat High Court in Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi v. Ranguba, 1994 ACJ 1280 (Gujarat)], referred by this Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sudama, MA. No. 720 of 1995, decided on 25.6.1997.

    9. In the circumstances when the insured owner himself was driving the vehicle, who was in possession of the driving licence, whether the insurance company can absolve itself from the liability is to be seen in terms of the valid defence available. Under Section 149 of the Act as Sub-clause (ii) of Clause (a) of Sub-section (2) prescribes the condition excluding driving by a named person or persons or by any person who is not only duly licensed, or by any person who has been disqualified for holding or obtaining a driving licence during the period of disqualification. It is not the defence of the respondent No. 2 that the respondent No. 1 was disqualified for holding a driving licence for driving a transport vehicle. A Division Bench of this Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Bare Lal, 1998 ACJ 248 (MP), where the accident was caused by a truck and the driver of the said truck was holding a licence to drive light motor vehicle which had no special authorisation to drive heavy motor vehicle, took the view, placing reliance on the decision in B.V Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan., 1996 ACJ 1178 (SC) and Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandra-vadan, 1987 ACJ 411 (SC), that as the insurance company did not lead any evidence that the driver was disqualified to hold or obtain the driving licence to drive a transport vehicle, it cannot escape its liability to pay the compensation or to indemnify the insured. This decision was followed by this Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sudama, M.A. No. 720 of 1995, decided on 25.6.1997. Hence we are of the view that as the vehicle was being driven by the insured himself who was possessed of the valid licence to drive light motor vehicle and was not disqualified for holding or obtaining a driving licence to drive a transport vehicle, the autorickshaw being light motor vehicle, the respondent No. 2 cannot escape from the liability.

    10. In the circumstances, the decision of the Gujarat High Court in Manohar Jamatmal Sindhi's case, 1994 ACJ 1280 (Gujarat), is of no help to respondent No. 2 wherein the case relates to driver who was not having a licence to drive vehicle as a paid employee and was authorised to drive light motor vehicle which had no authorisation to drive the transport vehicle.

    11. As an upshot the award of the Tribunal shall stand substituted. The appellants shall be entitled to Rs. 1,90,000 with interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date of application till realisation. The respondent No. 2 shall deposit the amount with accrued interest less the amount already deposited by it within a period of two months from the date of supply of certified copy failing which the amount shall carry interest at the rate of 15 per cent per annum. On deposit the amount shall be disbursed keeping in mind the guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court.

    12. In result, the appeals are allowed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 1,500, if pre-certified.

    C.C. as per rules.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohd. Karim Khan v. Shamsher Khan Hasan Khan And Another
    (Nov 3, 1997)