AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 by the appellant insurance company against the award dated 12.1.1996 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Umaria (Distt. Shahdol). The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 2,20,608/- to respondent No.1 (father of the deceased) for death of Raju (aged 16), who died on 22.3.1988 while employed as a labourer loading/unloading truck No. MPL 3232. The Tribunal computed compensation on the basis of assumed earnings of Rs.16 per day and a multiplier of 44, and directed payment jointly and severally by the owner, driver and the insurer.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the insurer can challenge the quantum of compensation (multiplier of 44) in an appeal where insurer's defences are statutorily limited.
  2. Whether alleged breach of the insurance policy (driver lacking licence to drive heavy motor vehicles) absolves the insurer from liability.
  3. Whether carrying more than the permitted number of employees (if proved) constitutes a fundamental breach that limits the insurer's liability to Rs. 1,50,000/- under the policy/statutory provision applicable at the relevant time.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The quantum awarded by the Tribunal (multiplier of 44) is excessive and contrary to settled principles; maximum multiplier applied by courts is 16.
  • The driver (respondent No.3) only held a licence to drive light motor vehicles for the period 3.9.1984 to 2.9.1989 and thus lacked a valid licence to drive the heavy truck, constituting breach of the policy and absolving the insurer.
  • The insurer's liability should be limited to Rs. 1,50,000/- in respect of death of an employee other than the driver, and more than six employees were being carried, invoking that limitation.

Respondent / Claimants' Position (as appearing in record)

  • Claimants filed a photocopy of the driver's licence in reply to the insurer's plea; the document on record contains entries (including an authorisation to drive a transport vehicle) that make it unclear whether the driver lacked authority to drive heavy vehicles.
  • The evidence on record indicates the truck was proceeding at speed and turned turtle, and there was no case that the driver was inexperienced with trucks (factual material relevant to causation).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pratibha Rathi 1995 ACJ 819 (MP) That defences of an insurance company are restricted before Claims Tribunals and such restrictions apply in appeal. Cited to support the view that the Court's ability to re-open questions like quantum is limited in an insurer's appeal.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kamarjahan 1995 ACJ 1150 (MP) Same principle regarding restricted defences of insurer on appeal. Relied on alongside United India to delimit the scope of insurer's challenge on quantum.
B.V. Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan. 1996 ACJ 1178 (SC) Insurance policy terms should be read down to serve the main purpose; insurer not absolved unless fundamental breach of policy conditions contributed to the accident. Applied to reject insurer's contentions that (a) lack of a heavy vehicle licence and (b) carrying excess employees automatically absolved insurer of liability.
Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokila-ben Chandravadan 1987 ACJ 411 (SC) Principle approved by Nagaraju that policy terms must not be construed to defeat indemnity unless a fundamental breach causally connected to the accident is proved. Referenced (via Nagaraju) to support reading-down of policy exclusions and to deny insurer's absolution absent proof of causal, fundamental breach.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first observed that while the multiplier of 44 appears excessive, it could not re-open the quantum issue broadly in an appeal by the insurer because statutory and judicial authority restrict the insurer's defences on appeal. The Court permitted the insurer to raise specific grounds relating to breach of policy conditions and the insurer's limited liability under the policy.

On the licence point the Court examined the photocopy on record and noted it was not exhibited and no witness was examined to prove the driver lacked authority. The licence contained an ambiguous typed entry authorising driving of a transport vehicle; in the absence of evidence, the Court held it could not conclude the driver lacked a valid licence for heavy vehicles. Further, even if the driver lacked a heavy-vehicle licence, the Court found that mere want of skill was not shown to be the direct cause of the accident; factual evidence indicated the truck was speeding and turned turtle and there was no case that the driver was inexperienced.

Relying on the Supreme Court's rulings in B.V. Nagaraju (and Skandia), the Court held that policy terms must be construed so as not to defeat the indemnity unless a fundamental breach causally connected to the accident is shown. On the issue of excess employees, the Court also followed Nagaraju in holding that mere carrying of more than the permitted number of employees is not necessarily a fundamental breach absolving the insurer. The Court referred to the applicable statutory limitation on liability for employees under Section 95(2)(a) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (in force at the relevant time).

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal by the insurance company partly succeeds. The Tribunal's award dated 12.1.1996 is maintained but modified by limiting the appellant insurer's liability to Rs. 1,50,000/- with proportionate interest and costs. The remaining amount of compensation is made payable by the owner (respondent No.2) and the driver (respondent No.3). The costs of the appeal are to be borne by the parties as incurred.

Implications: Direct consequence is a re-allocation of payment responsibility—insurer liable only up to Rs. 1,50,000 and the balance by owner and driver. The opinion does not purport to announce a new precedent beyond applying existing decisions (as cited) about the limited scope of insurer defences on appeal and the requirement of a causal, fundamental breach to absolve an insurer.

    Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Bare Lal And Others

    1. This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 has been preferred by the appellant insurance company against the award dated 12.1.1996 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Umaria, Distt. Shahdol.

    2. Bare facts necessary for decision of this appeal are as follows: The deceased Raju aged 16 years who was employed as a labourer for the work of loading and unloading on truck No. MPL 3232 met with a motor accident and lost his life on 22.3.1988. The Claims Tribunal awarded a total sum of Rs. 2,20,608/- as compensation to the claimant-respondent No. 1 who is father of the deceased. The above quantum of compensation was on the basis that the deceased was earning Rs. 16/-per day and would have lived minimum for another 44 years. Multiplying the estimated yearly income by 44, the above amount of compensation has been determined as payable jointly and severally by the owner, driver and insurance company.

    3. Mr. B.D. Jain, learned Counsel who appeared for the insurance company, questioned the correctness of the quantum of compensation determined by the Claims Tribunal and argued that it is per se excessive and against settled principles. It is submitted that a multiplier of 44 taken is too high when the maximum multiplier which has been applied by courts is 16. No doubt, the quantum of compensation determined by taking multiplier of 44 appears to this Court as extremely high and against the settled formula of working out the compensation. This court, however, cannot go into the question of quantum of compensation in an appeal preferred by the insurance company because the defences of the insurance company are limited by the provisions of the Act. Two Division Benches of this Court have taken the view that as the defences of insurance company are restricted before the Claims Tribunal, such restrictions with regard to it would also apply to the rights of the insurance company in appeal. [See: United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pratibha Rathi 1995 ACJ 819 (MP) and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kamarjahan 1995 ACJ 1150 (MP)].

    4. As the defences of the insurance company are restricted, we allowed the learned Counsel for the appellant to raise grounds with regard to the alleged breach of the conditions of the insurance policy and its limited liability under the terms of the said policy.

    5. On the question of the alleged breach of conditions of the policy, on behalf of the appellant the learned Counsel invited attention to the contents of photocopy of the driving licence of the driver (respondent No. 3 Chhanga). It is on record and appears to have been filed by the claimants in reply to the plea in that regard taken by the insurance company. It is submitted that the aforesaid driving licence shows that during the period 3.9.1984 to 2.9.1989, the driver possessed licence only to drive light motor vehicles and had no valid licence to drive heavy motor vehicles such as the truck. It is submitted that for want of valid driving licence, the insurance company is absolved of its liability by commission of the breach of the terms of the policy.

    6. The above argument advanced cannot be accepted for two reasons. We have carefully examined the contents of the photocopy of the driving licence which is on record. It has not been exhibited in the evidence and nobody has been examined either on behalf of the insurance company or on behalf of the owner or driver to prove the alleged fact of the driver not possessing licence to drive heavy motor vehicles at the relevant time. On a closer examination of the contents of the licence, we find that it was valid for 3.9.1984 to 2.9.1989 and was renewed up to 28.12.95. In the first part for description of vehicle, the entries regarding all other categories of vehicles have been scored out and the entry mentioning 'light motor vehicle' has been tick marked. In the licence, however, there is an entry against entry (f) mentioning 'the category of vehicles to be mentioned in other part of the licence'. Thereafter there is a typed entry reading thus:

    "Authorisation to drive a transport vehicle, 'the driver is authorised to drive a public carrier vehicle within the date'."
    It is not clear from the contents of the licence that the abovementioned entry did not exist in the licence right from the beginning, i.e., from 3.9.1984 when the licence was issued. In the absence of any evidence on record on behalf of the insurance company, it cannot be held on the basis of licence on record that the driver did not possess a valid licence to drive heavy motor vehicles on the date of incident.

    7. Even accepting the submission made by the insurance company that the driver on the relevant date did not possess a valid licence to drive heavy vehicles, such a plea cannot be accepted. Only want of skill to drive a heavy motor vehicle was not the direct cause of the accident. The evidence on record shows that the truck was proceeding in speed and turned turtle while taking a turn. It is nobody's case that the driver was not used to driving a truck. The Supreme Court in B.V Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan. 1996 ACJ 1178 (SC), has approved its own decision in Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokila-ben Chandravadan 1987 ACJ 411 (SC) and held that the terms of the insurance policy have to be read down to serve the main purpose of the policy and unless it is proved that there has been such a fundamental breach of the conditions of the policy which contributed to the causing of accident, the insurance company cannot be held as absolved from its liability to indemnify the insured.

    8. Learned counsel for the insurance company then submitted that the Tribunal completely lost sight of the fact that the liability of the insurance company was limited to a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- in respect of death of an employee other than driver carried in the vehicle. The case of the insurance company was that more than six persons were being carried in the vehicle as employees. Even if that be so, as held in the case of B.V Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan. 1996 ACJ 1178 (SC), by the Supreme Court, merely carrying of more than permitted number of employees in the vehicle was not such a fundamental breach of the policy as to absolve the insurance company from its duty to indemnify the owner of the vehicle, i.e., the insured. We have looked into the contents of the terms of the insurance policy and we have found that so far as the employees, six in number, who could be carried in the vehicle are concerned, the liability of the insurance company is limited by the provisions of Section 95(2)(a) of the Motor Vehicles Act 1939, which was in force at the relevant time. The provision reads as under:

    95. Requirements of policies limits of liability.

    10. In view of the discussion aforesaid, the appeal preferred by the insurance company only partly succeeds. The award of the Claims Tribunal dated 12.1.1996 is maintained, but modified only by making a direction that the liability of the appellant insurance company shall be limited to Rs. 1,50,000/- with roportionate interest and costs. The remaining amount of compensation shall be payable by the owner of the vehicle, respondent No. 2, and the driver of the vehicle, respondent No. 3. The costs of this appeal shall be borne by the parties as incurred.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Bare Lal And Others
    (Nov 28, 1996)