AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Faizanuddin, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenged proceedings before the Assistant Labour Commissioner and the order of reference dated 1.12.1989 (Annexure P.15) made by the Additional Commissioner (Labour) under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which referred a dispute to the Labour Court.

The petitioner is the State Institute for Rural Development, a department of the Government of Madhya Pradesh. Respondent No. 5, Naresh Kumar, was appointed as a driver on 19 May 1987 and his services were terminated on 16 August 1988. Respondent No. 5 filed an application under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act before the Assistant Labour Commissioner, Jabalpur, raising an industrial dispute.

The State Institute appeared before the Assistant Labour Commissioner and filed a reply contending that it was purely a government department, not an "industry" as defined in the Act, and that respondent No. 5 was not a "workman" within the Act; therefore, the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act did not apply and the dispute was outside the jurisdiction of the Labour Court. The Assistant Labour Commissioner forwarded the record to the Additional Commissioner (Labour), who made the reference to the Labour Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dispute constituted an "industrial dispute" within the meaning of Section 2(k) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, given the petitioner's contention that it was not an "industry" (Section 2(j)) and respondent No. 5 was not a "workman" (Section 2(s)).
  2. Whether initiation of conciliation proceedings and the subsequent order of reference to the Labour Court (without specifically framing a question on jurisdiction) were beyond the jurisdiction of the Assistant Labour Commissioner and the Additional Commissioner.
  3. Whether absence of a specific question on jurisdiction in the order of reference invalidates the reference, or whether questions of jurisdiction (industry/workman) are "incidental" matters that the Labour Court may decide under Section 10(4) of the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner argued that the facts showed the matter was not an industrial dispute under Section 2(k) because the State Institute was not an "industry" under Section 2(j) and respondent No. 5 was not a "workman" under Section 2(s), so the Act did not apply.
  • Accordingly, initiation of conciliation proceedings by the Assistant Labour Commissioner and the Additional Labour Commissioner and the impugned order of reference were beyond jurisdiction.
  • The petitioner contended that the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to proceed with the case as an industrial dispute.
  • It was further argued that though these points were specifically pleaded in the petitioner's statement of claim and written statement, neither the Assistant Labour Commissioner nor the Additional Commissioner dwelt on these jurisdictional points or framed any question on jurisdiction when making the reference; therefore, the entire proceedings were without jurisdiction and should be quashed.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 5's counsel argued that whether the State Institute is an "industry" and whether respondent No. 5 is a "workman" are matters incidental to the question already referred and could be examined and adjudicated by the Labour Court in the reference itself.
  • Therefore, the absence of a specific question regarding jurisdiction in the order of reference would not invalidate the reference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. v. The Workmen and Ors., 1967-I LLJ 423 Interpretation of the word "incidental" in Sub-section (4) of Section 10 — treated as something secondary or associated; incidental matters are adjuncts and ordinarily should not cut at the root of the main dispute. The court relied on this interpretation to explain that matters "incidental thereto" are subordinate and that the Tribunal may decide matters connected with the main dispute, but an incidental matter should not be one that destroys the main dispute unless it is necessarily connected.
Workman of Hindustan Lever Ltd. and Ors. v. The Management of Hindustan Lever Ltd., 1984 L.I.C. 276 (SC) Scope of issues in industrial adjudication: tribunals ascertain points of variance and frame issues; incidental issues (including mixed questions of law and fact) may be framed and adjudicated; tribunals may frame preliminary issues if they go to the root. The court cited this authority to support the view that a Tribunal can and should frame and decide incidental or preliminary issues that are integral to the dispute referred to it.
D.P. Maheshwari v. Delhi Administration and Ors., (1984)-2 LLJ 425 High Courts should not stay or stop tribunal proceedings merely to decide preliminary issues; tribunals should decide all issues promptly to avoid delay and prejudice; Article 226/136 should not be used to circumvent tribunal adjudication. The court relied on this precedent to stress that the High Court should be slow to decide such jurisdictional or preliminary issues in preference to the Labour Court and to discourage litigants from using constitutional jurisdiction to delay tribunal proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by referencing the statutory scheme governing conciliation and reference: Section 12 deals with duties of Conciliation Officers and when a reference should be made; Sub-section (4) of Section 10 (quoted in the opinion) provides that where the appropriate Government specifies the points of dispute for adjudication, the Labour Court/Tribunal "shall confine its adjudication to those points and matters incidental thereto."

The court analyzed the scope of Tribunal jurisdiction, noting that Labour Courts and Industrial Tribunals are not courts of general or inherent jurisdiction like civil courts; their jurisdiction is limited to the terms of an order of reference. On a plain reading, Section 10(4) permits the Tribunal to decide the dispute referred and matters "incidental thereto."

The central interpretive question was whether jurisdictional issues — specifically, whether the employee is a "workman" and whether the management is an "industry" under the Act — constitute matters incidental to the referred dispute or are matters that fall outside what the Tribunal may decide.

The court explained the meaning of "incidental" (drawing upon the Delhi Cloth decision): an incidental point is subordinate and connected to the main dispute; it commonly arises in connection with, or as a result of, the dispute and is an adjunct to it. Whether one matter is incidental to another depends on the facts, pleadings, and issues in each case.

The court gave examples and relied on authorities (Workman of Hindustan Lever and D.P. Maheshwari) to show that tribunals routinely decide both the issues referred by government and incidental issues (including mixed questions of law and fact) and may frame preliminary issues when they go to the root of the dispute.

Applying these principles to the facts before it, the court observed that the petitioner had specifically raised in its claim and written statement that it was not an "industry" and that respondent No. 5 was not a "workman." These were pleaded issues going to jurisdiction and, in the court's view, were matters incidental to the dispute referred for adjudication.

Consequently, by virtue of Section 10(4) the Labour Court had the power to decide those jurisdictional questions as incidental to the main dispute, and the High Court should not itself adjudicate them at this stage. The court emphasized that it would be slow to decide such issues on merits in preference to the Labour Court, echoing the policy set out in D.P. Maheshwari to prevent delays in industrial adjudication.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is DISMISSED.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The jurisdictional questions raised by the petitioner (whether the State Institute is an "industry" and whether respondent No. 5 is a "workman") are matters incidental to the dispute referred and are to be decided by the Labour Court in the reference proceedings.
  • The High Court declined to entertain these matters on merits at this stage and refused to quash the reference; the Labour Court may adjudicate the incidental issues as part of the reference under Section 10(4) of the Act.
  • No order as to costs was made. The opinion directed that any outstanding amount of security, if any, shall be refunded to the petitioner.
  • No broader or novel precedent was purportedly created by this opinion beyond applying and following existing authorities and statutory text; the decision leaves the determination of the incidental jurisdictional issues to the Labour Court in the referenced proceedings.

This summary is derived solely from the text of the provided opinion. No facts, arguments, or authorities beyond those contained in that opinion have been added.

    Rajya Gramin Vikash Sansthan, Jabalpur v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others

    Faizanuddin, J/

    1. In this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner challenges the proceedings before the Assistant Labour Commissioner and the order of reference dated 1.12.1989 (Annexure P.15) made by the Additional Commissioner (Labour) under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') referring the dispute to the Labour Court.

    2. The petitioner is a Department of the Government of Madhya Pradesh known as "State Institute For Rural Development" (hereinafter referred to as 'the State Institute'). Respondent No. 5 Naresh kumar was appointed as Driver in the petitioner State Institute by order dated 19th May, 1987 (Annexure P.2). By order dated 16th August, 1988 (Annexure P.5) the services of respondent No. 5 were terminated. Respondent No. 5 raised an industrial dispute by making an application under Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, before the Assistant Labour Commissioner, Jabalpur. The petitioner, State Institute entered appearance before the Assistant Labour Commissioner and filed reply stating that it is purely a department of the State Government and the activities of the State Institute do not fall within the definition of 'industry' nor the respondent No. 5 is a 'workman', as defined in the Act and, therefore, the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act are not attracted to the case and, therefore, the alleged dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of the Labour Court. The Assistant Labour Commissioner forwarded the record to the Additional Commissioner (Labour) who made the impugned reference to the Labour Court referring the following question for adjudication.

    Hindi matter

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that having regard to the facts placed before the Assistant Labour Commissioner, it is not an industrial dispute within the meaning of Section 2(k) of the Act as neither respondent No. 5 is a workman as defined in the Act nor the petitioner State Institute is an industry within the meaning of the Act. He, therefore, urged that initiation of conciliation proceedings by the Assistant Labour Commissioner and the Additional Labour Commissioner and the impugned order of reference are beyond jurisdiction. For the same reason it has been contended that the Labour Court has absolutely no jurisdiction to proceed with the case assuming it to be an industrial dispute. Learned counsel for the petitioner further contended that though the petitioner has specifically pleaded the aforesaid facts in its statement of claim filed before the Assistant Labour Commissioner and in the written statement filed before the Labour Court; but neither the Assistant Labour Commissioner nor the Additional Labour Commissioner dwelt on the said points nor framed any question on the point of jurisdiction while making a reference of tne dispute to the Labour Court. He, therefore, submitted that the entire proceedings are without jurisdiction and must be quashed. As against this, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 5 contended that the question whether the petitioner State Institute is an industry and whether respondent No. 5 is a workman within the definition under the Act, are incidental to the question already referred and, therefore, the same can be examined and adjudicated in the order of reference itself and, therefore, the absence of specific question regarding the jurisdiction would not invalidate the order of reference.

    4. Section 12 of the Act deals with the duties of Conciliation Officers and the circumstances in which, on failure of the conciliation, a reference of the dispute is to be made by the appropriate Government for adjudication by the Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal, as the case may be. Where the appropriate Government does not consider it necessary to make a reference, it shall record reasons for the same and communicate the same to the parties concerned. In the cases where the appropriate government is satisfied that there is a case for reference, it shall refer the dispute in accordance with Section 10 of the Act. Here before examining the point in controversy, it would be relevant to refer to Sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the Act which is directly attracted to the facts of the present case.

    Sub-section (4) of Section 10 reads as under:

    "10. Reference of dispute to Boards, Courts or Tribunals.

    (1) xxx xxx xxx xxx (4) Where in an order referring an industrial dispute to 'a Labour Court, Tribunal or National Tribunal' under this section or in a subsequent order, the appropriate Government has specified the points of dispute for adjudication, 'the Labour Court or the Tribunal or the National Tribunal, as the case may be' shall confine its adjudication to those points and matters incidental thereto."

    5. It may be pointed out that (the Labour Courts and Industrial Tribunals are not a Court of general or inherent jurisdiction like a Civil Court embracing all matters of civil nature; but they have only specific jurisdiction circumscribed by the terms of an order of reference. A bare reading of Sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the Act will go to show that the Tribunal has to confine its jurisdiction to those questions and points which are referred to it and matters incidental thereto. According to the scheme of the Act, a Tribunal has only to determine the dispute referred to it and it has no jurisdiction to deal with a dispute beyond those questions and points which are referred to it.) The question, therefore, arises whether in the absence of specific question being referred in that behalf, a challenge to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal, inasmuch as the employee is or not a workman and the Management or employer is an industrial concern or not, covered by the definition of the Act, can be gone into or not by the Tribunal to which a reference has been made.

    6. A perusal of Sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the Act makes it clear that it permits the Tribunal to decide the dispute referred to it and also matters 'incidental thereto'. The question, therefore, that arises for consideration is whether the question of jurisdiction of the Tribunal in the facts and circumstances stated above would be a dispute or a point incidental to the question already referred as quoted in paragraph 2 above or not. A point would be incidental to another point/dispute when the former essentially and substantially depends upon the other. The expression "incidental thereto" implies a subordinate and subsidiary point concerning some other main or principal point requiring casual attention while considering the main point. In the case of Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. v. The Workmen and Ors., 1967-I LLJ 423 their Lordships had an occasion to construe and interpret the word 'incidental' occurring in Sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the Act with the aid of 'Webster's New World Dictionary' in which the words 'incidental' means an incident, cause, hence, secondary or minor but usually associated. The Supreme Court in the aforesaid decision took the view that something incidental to a dispute must mean something happening as a result of or in connection with the dispute or associated with the dispute. The dispute is the fundamental thing while something incidental thereto is an adjunct to it and, therefore, something incidental cannot cut at the root of the main thing to which it is an adjunct.

    7. The question whether the adjudication of one matter is incidental to the adjudication of another depends on the facts of each case, the pleadings of the parties and the issues which properly arise for determination. For instance, an 'industrial dispute' being referred to the Labour Court/Tribunal, the question may arise whether the Labour Court/Tribunal has jurisdiction to determine on the facts placed before it and whether an 'industrial dispute' has really arisen within the meaning of Section 2(k) of the Act or the concerned persons are 'workmen' as defined in Section 2(s) or a particular establishment/undertaking is an 'industry' within the meaning of Section 2(j) of the Act. Such questions, therefore, can validly be examined and adjudicated in order of the reference itself as matters incidental to the points in dispute specified in the order of reference. Such incidental matters as aforesaid have to be determined necessarily as collateral or jurisdictional issues, because the jurisdiction of the Labour Court/Tribunal depends upon such determination which go to the root of the case. Here a reference may also be made to the decision in the case of the Workman of Hindustan Lever Ltd. and Ors. v. The Management of Hindustan Lever Ltd., 1984 L.I.C. 276 (SC) wherein the Supreme Court observed that 'ordinarily the Tribunal after ascertaining on what issue that parties are at variance raises issues to focus attention on points in dispute'. In industrial adjudication, issues are of two types (i) those referred by the Government for adjudication and set out in the order of reference, and (ii) incidental issues which are sometimes the issues of law or mixed issues of law and fact. The Tribunal may as well frame preliminary issues if the point on which the parties are at variance, as reflected in the preliminary issues as the same would go to the root of the matter.' See also -D.P. Maheshwari v. Delhi Administration and Ors., (1984)-2 LLJ 425.

    8. From the foregoing discussion it clearly turns out that once a reference had been made to the Tribunal, the Tribunal has to decide not only the main question referred to it in the order of reference but also all questions and points which are incidental to the main dispute. In the present case on perusal of the claim and written statement filed by the petitioner we find that it did raise the dispute that the petitioner was not an industry nor the respondent No. 5 was a workman within the meaning of the Act and hence no 'industrial dispute' can be raised nor the Laboour Court (sic) be ceased of the jurisdiction under (sic) Act. These points raised by the petitioner are matters incidental to the main question referred for adjudication and, therefore, by virtue of the provisions contained in Sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the Act, the Labour Court would be within its power to decide the same and this Court would be slow in deciding such issues on merits. The Supreme Court in the case of D.P. Muheshwari v. Delhi Administration and Ors., (supra), observe as under:

    "Tribunals entrusted with the task of adjudicating labour disputes where delay may lead to misery and jeopardise industrial peace, should decide all issues in disputes at the same time without trying some of them as preliminary issues. Nor should High Courts in the exercise of their jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution stop proceedings before a Tribunal so that a preliminary issue may be decided by them. Neither the jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution nor the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 136 may be allowed to be exploited by those who can well afford to wait by dragging the latter from Court to Court for adjudication of peripheral issues avoiding decision on issues more vital to them. Article 226 and Article 136 are hot meant to be used to break the resistance of workmen in this fashion."

    9. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the questions raised by the petitioner before this Court in this petition regarding the jurisdiction as aforesaid, are questions incidental to the question referred by the Addl. Commissioner (Labour) and hence the same would be decided by the Labour Court.

    10. Consequently the petition fails and is hereby dismissed. We make no order as to costs. The outstanding amount of security, if any, shall be refunded to the petitioner.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajya Gramin Vikash Sansthan, Jabalpur v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others
    (Aug 7, 1990)