Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 4 of Samvat 1991, Section 110 of the Land Records Manual, Riyasat Gwalior and Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950. Section 2 (29)
  • Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, Section 2 (29), 2nd Proviso to Section 265
  • Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950.
  • Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959,
  • Section 248 (1) of the M. P. Land Revenue Code, 1959,
  • Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act.
  • Section 248 (1) of the Code. 5. Section 13
  • Section 248 (3) of the Code,
  • Section 237 (1) (j).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 4 of Samvat 1991, Section 110 of the Land Records Manual, Riyasat Gwalior and Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950. Section 2 (29)
  • Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, Section 2 (29), 2nd Proviso to Section 265
  • Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950.
  • Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959,
  • Section 248 (1) of the M. P. Land Revenue Code, 1959,
  • Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act.
  • Section 248 (1) of the Code. 5. Section 13
  • Section 248 (3) of the Code,
  • Section 237 (1) (j).
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenges an order passed under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, directing the eviction of the petitioner from 199 Bighas 11 Biswas of Muafi lands on the ground of unauthorized occupation.

The lands in question were originally granted as muafi (exempted) lands by Maharaja Jayajirao Scindia in 1857 for the upkeep of a temple of Shri Ramji and Shri Hanumanji located in Gangabai-ka-Bagicha, Dholpur. The muafi grant was resumed in 1939 by the Gwalior Darbar, and the then Pujari, Mahant Dwarkadas, was granted a Parwana under Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran for 199 Bighas 11 Biswas of these lands.

In 1949, the petitioner's father, Thakur Murlidharsingh, obtained the lands on a sub-lease from Mahant Dwarkadas. After the deaths of Mahant Dwarkadas (1954-55) and Thakur Murlidharsingh (1957), the petitioner came into possession of the lands. The successor Pujari, Mahant Ramkishandas, obtained mutation in his favor in 1961 and applied under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code for the eviction of the petitioner on the ground of unauthorized occupation.

Subsequent orders by the Naib-Tahsildar (1964), Sub-Divisional Officer, Additional Commissioner, and the Board of Revenue upheld the eviction order, though the penalty imposed was remitted on appeal. The authorities held that the lands were Government lands managed by the Aukaf Department, and the Pujari held only managerial rights without tenancy status.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the proceedings under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, for eviction of the petitioner from the Muafi lands were maintainable.
  2. Whether the former Pujari, by virtue of the grant under Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, acquired the status of a Mourusi Kashtakar, Government lessee, or ordinary tenant, thereby excluding the lands from being "unoccupied lands" within the meaning of Section 248 (1).
  3. Whether the petitioner’s remedy was by way of a civil suit rather than an application under Section 248 (1) of the Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The former Pujari, by virtue of the grant under Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, acquired the status of a Mourusi Kashtakar or Government lessee or ordinary tenant.
  • The Muafi lands were therefore not "unoccupied lands" under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code.
  • The non-petitioner’s remedy for eviction was by way of a civil suit, not under Section 248 (1) of the Code.
  • There was no restriction on sub-letting the land by the Pujari, and the terms "Mourushi Kashtakar" and "Dakhilkar Kashtakar Bila Lagani" were synonymous, implying a right of sub-letting.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The grant under Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran was clear that the Pujari was merely a manager and held no tenancy rights.
  • The Parwana expressly stated that the grant was resumable upon breach of conditions or death of the Pujari, indicating no permanent interest was created.
  • The Pujari had no rights of transfer, mortgage, or sale, and the lands remained Government property under the Aukaf Department’s management.
  • The petitioner was in unauthorized occupation as the grant lapsed upon the death of the former Pujari, and thus eviction under Section 248 (1) was proper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahant Ramcharan Das v. Mishri (1969 M. P. Revenue Nirnaya 550) Interpretation of Parwana indicating that lands granted to a Pujari under Kawaid Maufidaran were Government lands held for specific purposes and not tenancy rights. The court adopted the Board of Revenue's view that the Pujari was only a manager appointed by the Aukaf Department, not a tenant with rights to the land.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the language and legal effect of Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran and the Parwana granted to the former Pujari. The statutory provisions and the Parwana clearly indicated that the Pujari was a manager appointed to cultivate the lands for the upkeep of the temple, without tenancy or ownership rights. The grant was resumable upon breach of conditions or death of the Pujari, which occurred in this case, causing the grant to lapse.

The court referred to statutory definitions, including Section 2 (29) of the Qanoon Mal, Gwalior, which excluded the Pujari from being a Kashtakar Mourushi (hereditary tenant), and Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950, which defined "pacca tenant" as one lawfully recorded as a tenant—something the Pujari was not.

The court rejected the argument that the Pujari or his sub-lessee had rights of transfer or sub-letting, holding that such rights would frustrate the purpose of the grant, which was solely for temple upkeep. The maufi lands were thus "unoccupied lands" set apart for a special purpose under Section 237 (1)(j) and subject to eviction under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code.

Furthermore, the court noted that the petitioner had an alternative remedy under Section 248 (3) of the Code by way of a civil suit to establish any rights, which he had not pursued.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed with costs. The court upheld the eviction order against the petitioner under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, holding that the petitioner was in unauthorized occupation of Government Muafi lands.

The direct effect is that the petitioner must vacate the lands and pay the costs as ordered. No new precedent was set beyond affirming existing interpretations of the status of Muafi lands and the rights of Pujaris under the relevant statutory provisions and Parwana.

    Panchamsingh v. Ramkishandas Guru Ramdas

    1. This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is directed against an order under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, for the eviction of the petitioner from 199 Bighas 11 Biswas of Muafi lands on the ground that he is in unauthorised occupation thereof.

    2. The material facts, shortly stated, are as follows:

    There is a temple of Shri Ramji and Shri Hanumanji situate in Gangabai-ka-Bagicha in Dholpur on the Gwalior-Agra road. During the mutiny of 1857, Maharaja Jayajirao Scindia of Gwalior halted at Dholpur while on his way to Agra and was pleased to endow 300 Bighas of lands in muafi for the upkeep of the temple by a Sanad. The muafi grant was resumed in the year 1939, by the Gwalior Darbar, and the former Pujari, Mahant Dwarkadas, was granted a Parwana under Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, in respect of 199 Bighas 11 Biswas of Muafi lands. On 15-6-1949, Thakur Murlidharsingh, the father of the petitioner, obtained the lands on a sub-lease, on a premium of Rs. 230/- per annum, from the former Pujari, Mahant Dwarkadas. Mahant Dwarkadas having died in the year 1954-55, the non-petitioner No. 1, Mahant Ramkishandas, who succeeded to the office of Mahant, started proceedings for mutation of his name. On 6-4-1957, Thakur Murlidhar Singh also died and thereupon the petitioner got into possession of the lands. By order dated 30-8-1961, the Collector, Gwalior, ordered mutation in favour of the non-petitioner No. I, Mahant Ramkishandas, who thereafter applied under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, for ejectment of the petitioner from the Maufi lands on the ground that he was in unauthorised occupation of the same.

    3. The Naib-Tahsildar, by order dated 30-7-1964, ordered that the petitioner be ejected from the maufi lands and asked to pay a penalty of Rs. 4,441.58 for being in unauthorised occupation. On appeal, the Sub-Divisional Officer, Dabra, by order dated 23-11-1964, upheld the order of ejectment but remitted the penalty. On further appeal, the Additional Commissioner affirmed the order of ejectment under Section 248 (1). Their decisions were affirmed by the Board of Revenue by its order dated 6-10-1969. The Sub-Divisional Officer was of the view that the lands were recorded as Milkiyat Sarkar under the Aukaf Department and were meant for the upkeep and Puja of the temple and that the Pujari was appointed to look after them. That view of his was affirmed by the Additional Commissioner who held that the lands belonged to the Government and were under the management of the Aukaf Department. The Board of Revenue held that the lands were Government lands set apart for specific purpose, i.e., for the maintenance of the Dcvasthan, that the status of the Pujari was merely that of a Manager appointed by the Aukaf Department, on the terms and conditions of the Parwana, and that he held no tenancy rights under the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act.

    4. The short question for consideration is, whether the proceedings under Section 248 (1) of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, were maintainable. It is urged that the former Pujari, by virtue of the grant in his favour, under Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, acquired the status of a Mourusi Kashtakar or a Government lessee or an ordinary tenant and, therefore, the Maufi lands were not "unoccupied lands" within the meaning of Section 248 (1), and consequently the remedy of the non-petitioner was by way of a civil suit and not by an application uud"r Section 248 (1) of the Code.

    5. Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran reads as follows:

    . जब देवस्थानी माफी आराजी तहकीकात से या वक्त दाखिल खारिज नाकिस सनद पर मबनी पाई जाये तो वह नोइयत माफी से खारिज की जाकर वास्ते इन्तिजाम देवस्थान महक्मे औकाफ के सुपुर्द की जायेगी और कागजात पटवारी में ऐसी आराजी का इन्दराज वतरीक जेल किया जायेगा:- ‘‘मिलकियत सरकार वजहतमाम महकमा औकाफ मुतअल्लिक देवस्थान’’ माफीदार बतौर पुजारी या मुजावर देवस्थान मुतसब्बिर किया जावेगा और उसे ऐसी आराजी में बिलऐवज ऐसी खिदमात के हक काश्तकार मौरूसी हासिल होगा जिसका बिला लगानी पट्टा मिन-जानित महकमें औकाफ उसे दिया जायेगा, मगर शर्त यह है कि पुजारी या मुजाबर की खिदमत ठीक तौर पर अदा न होने की सूरत में महकमे औकाफ को यह इख्तियार होगा कि ऐसे काश्तकार मौरूसी को आराजी से बेदखल करके उसके बजाय दूसरा पुजारी या मुजावर मुकर्रर करे और उसे ऐसी आराजी का पट्टा दे’’

    6. The parwana was in the printed form in the following terms:--

    मुल्तजिम जागीरदारान सेक्शन औकाफ ग्वालियर गवर्नमेन्ट श्री अज महकमे औकाफ रियासत ग्वालियर जो कि किताअज आराजी मुन्दजर्े पुश्त जो साबिक में इस देवस्थान के पूजन बगैरा के वास्ते बतौर मुआफी कायम थी वह मुताबिक दफा कवाअद मुआफी। रजिस्टर मुआफी से खारिज होकर महकमे हाजा के सिपुर्द हुई है। अब महक्मे हाजा से यह आराजी देवस्थान के पूजन बगैरा के लिये बिल एवज खिदमात देवस्थान तुमको बिला लगानी अता की जाकर व अहतमाम मेहकमा औकाफ तुम्हारे रखी जाती है। तुमको चाहिये कि तुम इसकी आमदनी से खुद काश्त करके या किसी दीगर से काश्त कराकर देवस्थान की हालत व पूजन बगैरा का इन्तजाम ठीक रखो और जब तक तुम व तुम्हारे वारसान इन्तजाम देवस्थान ठीक रखेंगे उसी वक्त तक वह इससे मुस्तफीकद हो सकेंगे। अगर तुम्हारे या तुम्हारे जानशीन की जानिब से किसी किस्म की खराबी या बदइन्तजामी देवस्थान के पूजन वगैरा में पाई जावेगी तो फौरन अल्हेदगी की कार्यवाही की जाकर उसके बजाये दीगर शख्स अगर वारिसान में से कोई काबिल व लायक पूजन पाया जावेगा तो वह। वनर्ा दीगर कोई लायक शख्स देवस्थान के वास्ते मुकर्रर किया जाकर उसके कब्जे में यह आराजी दी जावेगी, क्योंकि यह आराजी मुआफी से खारीज हो जाने से बतौर मुआफीदार अब इस पर तुम्हारा कोई हक नहीं रहा और अब इस आराजी का इन्द्राज रजिस्टर व कागजात पटवारी में मिलकियत सरकार वजहतमाम महकमा औकाफ वास्ते इन्तजाम देवस्थान सदर हुआ करेगा।’’ 6।ण् The words of a statute are to be interpreted as bearing natural meaning. And if this is plain, there is no scope for rules of construction. The words of Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran are plain and unambiguous. Section 5 (4) of the Kawaid Maufidaran defines a Devasthani Maufi as a grant made for the upkeep of a temple. Under Section 13, the Maufidar was treated as a Pujari and the grant lapsed with the death or removal of the Pujari. The Parwana must be read in the context of Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran. The deed must be read as a whole in order to ascertain the true meaning of its several clauses. Strict legal language having been used in the Parwana, it must receive its legal meaning. Under the terms of the Parwana, the former Pujari had no other status than that of a manager. He could get the lands cultivated either himself or through servants, but he had no right to alienate the same in any manner. It cast a duty upon him to keep the lands under cultivation so that the income derived therefrom could be applied towards the Puja and the upkeep of the temple- He was under the direct control of the Aukaf Department. The Parwana expressly stated that the grant shall be resumed for breach of any of the conditions or upon the death of the former Pujari. The Maufi lands all the while belonged to the Government. The former Pujari was, therefore, not a Kashtakar Mourusi or a Government lessee or an ordinary tenant of the maufi lands, but was merely holding them on behalf of the Aukaf Department for purposes of management.

    7. A similar question arose before the Board of Revenue in Mahant Ramcharan Das v. Mishri, (1969 M. P. Revenue Nirnaya 550). A Division Bench of the Board of Revenue, while interpreting a Parwana in similar terms, stated as follows:

    ‘‘शासन के आकाफा महकमें की ओर से उसने इस भूमि को प्राप्त किया है। कवायद माफीदारान की धारा और उल्लिखित परवाने से स्पष्ट है कि भूमि मिल्कयत सरकारें वजहैतमाम सीगा औकाफ करार दी जाकर आवेदक के कब्जे में ‘खुद काश्त कराकर के या किसी दीगर से काश्त कराकर’ उसकी आमदनी से देवस्थान के पूजन बगैरा का प्रबन्ध रखने को दी गई थी और पूजन बगैर में खामी या बदइन्तजामी होने पर कब्जा हटाया जायगा। उपरोक्त शतर्ो पर शासकीय भूमि पर कब्जा आवेदक को दिये जाने में यह अर्थ नहीं निकलता कि भूमि पर उसे किसी षक या खातेदार के अधिकार दिये गये थे बल्कि भूमि पर कब्जा उसे इस विशेष प्रयोजन के लिये दिया गया था कि भूमि पर षि कराने से जो प्राप्ति हो उससे वह सेवा अचर्ा तथा देवस्थान का समुचित प्रबन्ध करके अपना निवर्ाह करे। दूसरे शब्दों मे आवेदक केवल शासन की ओर से नियुक्त प्रबन्धक था।’’ We are of the same view.

    7A. The construction of ours proceeds on Section 13 of the Kawaid Maufidaran, Section 2 (29), 2nd Proviso to Section 265 of the Qanoon Mal, Gwalior, Circular No. 4 of Samvat 1991, Section 110 of the Land Records Manual, Riyasat Gwalior and Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950.

    Section 2 (29) of the Qanoon Mal defines Mourushi Kashtakar as follows:

    ‘‘कास्तकार मौरूसी उसे कहते हैं जिसका हक्का का-बिल विरासत होकर उसे मालगुजार बिला हुक्म अदालत बेदखल नहीं कर सकता और न बिला रजाबन्दी उसके या बिला हुक्म अदालत के उस पर लगान इंजाफा कर सकता है। मगर शर्त यह है कि जिस पुजारी या मुजावर को कवायद माफीदारान जुज्वे आराजी वनक्दी रियासत ग्वालियर, संवत श्, की दफा की रू से हक्क मौरूसी हासिल हो उसकी जानिब से खिदमत मन्सबी ठीक तोर पर अदा न होने पर महक्मे औकाफ को बिला हुक्म अदालत बेदखल करने का इख्तियार होगा।’’ On a plain reading, the definition excludes a Pujari. The former Pujari was, therefore, not a Kashtakar Mourushi of the maufi land, but was merely holding them on behalf of Aukaf Department for purposes of management. Under the 2nd Proviso to Section 365 of the Qanoon Mal, Gwalior, he had no right of transfer. It reads as follows:

    ‘‘दफा 2श्श्, हक्का दखीलकारी व जयर्े बय या रहन जमाबन्दी शरायत बाब हाजा काबिल इन्तकाल होगा। शर्त मजीद यह है कि ऐसे पुजारी या मुजाविर का हक्क दखीलकारी जो उसे कबाजद माफीदारान जुज्वे आराजी व नक्दी। रियासत ग्वालियर। संवत , दफा की रू से हासिल हो, रहन या वय नहीं किया जा सकेगा।’’ ैमबजपवद 110 of the Land Records Manual, Riyasat Gwalior, Provided that a Pujari should be recorded as a Kashtakar Dakhilkar Bila Lagani, i.e., with no right or interest. Such a person could not, therefore, be recorded as a "Mourushi Kashtakar" or as an ordinary tenant.

    Circular No. 4 of Samvat 1991 reads as follows:

    "The entry of such land in the Jamabandi should be made in the Patti of Milkiyat Sarkar under the management of the Aukaf Department in the column of "owner" and the Pujari or Mujavir should be entered in ziman 4 as Mourusi Bila Lagani."

    Admittedly, the former Pujari was never recorded as such Kashtakar Mourusi- On the contrary, he was throughout recorded as Kashtakar Dakhilkar Bila Lagani. He could never become a pacca tenant under Section 54 (vii) of the Madhya Bharat Land Revenue and Tenancy Act, 1950. The expression "pacca tenant", as defined in that section, means a person who had been "lawfully recorded" as a tenant. The maufi lands were always recorded as "Milkiyat Sarkar" under the Aukaf Department.

    8. We are, therefore, of the view that the former Pujari had no other status than that of a manager of the lands on behalf of the Aukaf Department. While it is accepted before us that the former Pujari had no right of transfer by mortgage or sale, it is urged that there was no restriction on sub-letting. It is also urged that the terms "Mourushi Kashtakar" and "Dakhilkar Kashtakar Bila Lagani" were synonymous and that, as every Mourushi Kashtakar had the right to sub-let, it necessarily follows that a Dakhilkar Kashtakar Bila Lagani had also a similar right. We are unable to agree with this line of reasoning. It would be repugnant to the nature of the grant itself to clothe such a person with a right of transfer of any kind. The whole purpose of the grant, which was for the upkeep of the temple, would be frustrated if the maufi lands were allowed to be sub-let by the Pujari and new rights created in favour of a stranger.

    9. Where a grant of land is made in consideration for service to be rendered by a grantee, in lieu of wages, it is an implied condition of the grant that if the services are not performed or are not required, the grant can be resumed. The Parwana expressly stated that the grant in favour of the former Pujari was resumable for breach of any of the conditions set out therein, or upon his death or removal. The death of the former Pujari was, in the instant case, the terminal point. That being so, the grant lapsed with his death. As the grant created no interest in favour of the former Pujari, whatever rights the petitioner's father, Thakur Murlidharsingh had, also lapsed and he became a rank trespasser.

    10. There can be no dispute that the maufi lands were "unoccupied lands" as defined in Section 2 (z-3), and were also "set apart for a special purpose" within the meaning of Section 237 (1) (j). The petitioner was, therefore, liable to be evicted from the lands under" Section 248 (1) of the M. P. Land Revenue Code, 1959, being in unauthorised occupation of the same, at the instance of the present Pujari, Mahant Ramkishandas, the non-petitioner No. 1. On merits, the order of eviction cannot, therefore, be assailed. Apart from this, no interference is called for for another reason. Under Section 248 (3) of the Code, the petitioner had the alternative legal remedy of a suit for the establishment of his rights, if any. That remedy he has not availed of.

    11. In the result, the petition fails and is dismissed with costs. Hearing fee Rs. 100/- for each set of respondents. After payment of costs, the remaining security amount shall bs refunded to the petitioner.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Panchamsingh v. Ramkishandas Guru Ramdas
    (Apr 29, 1971)