AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 9 January 2007 whereby the learned single Judge dismissed W.P. No. 2351 (W) of 2006 (reported in AIR 2007 Cal 108). The writ petition was filed on behalf of the appellant on the ground that the writ petitioner did not lawfully enter into the portion of the premises in question. Documents in the record show the Kolkata Municipal Corporation realised rent from the appellant, accepting him as occupier, and the appellant has occupied the portion for a considerable period without objection or proceedings by the respondents challenging his occupation. The appellant sought supply of electricity to the occupied portion. The single Judge had dismissed the writ petition; this appeal was preferred against that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an occupier of premises is entitled to electric supply under Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003 despite a dispute as to the legality of occupation.
  2. Whether the disputed legality/validity of occupation must be determined by a civil court before supply of electricity can be permitted.
  3. Whether permitting electricity supply will create or confer any right in favour of the appellant or prejudice the rights of other parties.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellant relied on various documents in the paper book to show the appellant's occupation and entitlement to supply.
  • The appellant had been occupying the portion for a considerable period and the Kolkata Municipal Corporation realised rent from him, accepting him as occupier.

C.E.S.C. Ltd.'s Arguments (Mr. Mukherjee)

  • The son of the appellant, Utkarsh Singh, is also residing at the portion and has deposited the requisite amount in compliance with C.E.S.C. directions.
  • Subject to completion of minor formalities, supply will be given to the son, and thereafter electricity will be supplied to the appellant after installation of a separate meter.
  • Earlier supply could not be effected to Utkarsh Singh due to objections raised by other occupants.

Respondents No. 11 to 14's Arguments (Mr. Saptangshu Basu)

  • Supply can be given at the premises occupied by the appellant without prejudice to any right of the respondents or creating any right in favour of the appellant.
  • Respondents also raised a concern that the appellant might change user of the portion in connivance with others (noted by the court as not decided at this stage).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chameli Singh v. State of U.P, (1996) 2 SCC 549 : AIR 1996 SC 1051 Right to life includes right to live with human dignity; right to shelter implies the right to shelter which includes electricity as an essential service. Relied upon to hold that electricity is part of the right to shelter and therefore supply should not be refused to the occupier.
State of Karnataka v. Narasimhamurthy (AIR 1996 SC 90) SCC p. 526 Characterisation of right to shelter as a fundamental right under Article 19(1) and components of right to shelter. Quotations from this authority used within Chameli Singh to support that right to shelter includes electricity and civic amenities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the documentary record and found that the Kolkata Municipal Corporation had realised rent from the appellant, accepting him as occupier, and that the appellant had occupied the portion for a considerable period without challenge by the respondents. Applying Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003, the court concluded that the appellant, as occupier, is entitled to enjoy electricity at the occupied portion. The court observed that the legality or validity of occupation is a matter for determination by a civil court but that such determination would not prevent the appellant from receiving an electric connection. The court invoked the Supreme Court's reasoning in Chameli Singh (and its citation of State of Karnataka v. Narasimhamurthy) that the right to shelter includes electricity, and on that basis held that refusal of supply was not permissible. The court balanced competing submissions by permitting supply while expressly preserving the rights and contentions of other respondents and clarifying that supply would not create or confer any right of occupation. The court also authorised the C.E.S.C. to seek police assistance to effect supply if necessary.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED

Direct effect: The judgment and order under appeal (9 January 2007) is set aside. The C.E.S.C. Ltd. is directed to take necessary steps to supply electricity to the portion of the premises occupied by the appellant without further delay but within three days from completion of necessary formalities by the appellant. Supply is subject to completion of formalities, will not confer any right in favour of the appellant, and will not prejudice the rights or contentions of other respondents. The competent C.E.S.C. authority may request police assistance to effect supply and the police shall provide assistance if requested. There is no order as to costs.

No broader precedent was created by this decision beyond the court's application of Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003 and the cited Supreme Court authorities to the facts of this case; the question of legal title to occupation remains for determination by an appropriate civil court.

    Amarendra Singh v. Calcutta Electric Supply Corporation Ltd. & Ors.

    1. This appeal has been preferred assailing the judgment and order dated 9th January, 2007 whereby and whereunder the learned single Judge dismissed the writ petition bearing W.P No. 2351 (W) of 2006 (reported in AIR 2007 Cal 108) filed on behalf of the appellant herein on the ground that the writ petitioner did not lawfully enter into the portion of the premises in question. The learned counsel representing the appellant invited our attention to various documents included in the paper book.

    2. In scrutinising those documents, we find that the Kolkata Municipal Corporation authorities realised rent from the appellant accepting him as occupier in respect of a portion of the premises in question and the appellant although has been occupying the portion of the premises in question for a considerable period, neither any objection was ever raised nor any proceeding was initiated by or at the instance of the respondents challenging the authority of the said appellant to occupy the said premises. In view of the provisions in Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003, the appellant herein being the occupier is entitled to enjoy the electricity at the occupied portion of the premises in question.

    3. The legality and/or validity of the occupation of the premises in question by the appellant can be decided in the civil Court but that will not prevent the said appellant from enjoying the benefit of electric connection.

    4. The Supreme Court in the case of Chameli Singh v. State of U.P, reported in (1996) 2 SCC 549 : (AIR 1996 SC 1051) discussed the components of right to live and specifically observed that right to life includes the right to live with human dignity. In the aforesaid judgment, Hon'ble Supreme Court specifically observed that right to live guaranteed in any civilised society implies the right to shelter and while discussing the right to shelter, the Hon'ble Supreme Court also held that the same includes electricity which is undisputedly, an essential service to the shelter for a human being. The relevant portions from the aforesaid decision of the Supreme Court are set out hereunder:

    “7. In State of Karnataka v. Narasimhamurthy (AIR 1996 SC 90) SCC p. 526, para 7: JT at p. 378, para 7), this Court held that right to shelter is a fundamental right under Article 19(1) of the Constitution………………….”

    “8. …………………Right to shelter, therefore, includes adequate living space, safe and decent structure, clean and decent surroundings, sufficient light, pure air and water, electricity, sanitation and other civic amenities like roads etc. so as to have easy access to his daily avocation…………………..”

    5. In the aforesaid circumstances, request for supply of electricity at the premises in question occupied by the appellant should not be refused.

    6. For the reasons discussed hereinabove, we are not inclined to approve the judgment and order under appeal and the same is, therefore, set aside.

    7. Mr. Mukherjee, learned counsel representing the C.E.S.C Ltd. authorities submits that the son of the appellant herein is also residing at the portion of the said premises in question and has already deposited the requisite amount in compliance with the direction of the C.E.S.C Ltd. Mr. Mukherjee further submits that subject to completion of certain minor formalities, supply will be given to the said son of the appellant herein viz., Utkarsh Singh, where from electricity will be supplied to the appellant after installation of the separate meter. Mr. Mukherjee also submits that due to the objection raised by the other occupants, the supply could not be effected to Utkarsh Singh in the earlier occasion.

    8. Mr. Saptangshu Basu, learned counsel representing the respondents No. 11 to 14 submits that supply can be given at the premises in question under occupation of the appellant herein without prejudice to any right of his clients or creating any right in favour of the appellant.

    9. Considering the aforesaid submissions, we direct the concerned authorities of the C.E.S.C Ltd. to take necessary steps to supply electricity at the portion of the premises under occupation of the appellant without any further delay but positively within a period of three days from the date of completion of necessary formalities by the appellant herein. However, we make it clear that supply of electricity to the appellant at the portion of the premises in question will not confer any right in his favour or the same will not prejudice the rights or contentions of the other respondents under any circumstances.

    10. Mr. Basu, learned counsel of the respondents No. 11 to 14 also submits that the appellant herein may change the user of the portion of the premises in question in connivance with other interested persons. We are, however, not concerned with the aforesaid issue at this stage and the aforesaid respondents will be at liberty to take necessary steps at the appropriate stage in accordance with law. We also make it clear that we have not decided the right of the appellant herein to occupy the portion of the premises in question in the present proceeding and the same should be decided by the appropriate Civil Court in an appropriate proceeding.

    11. Needless to mention that the competent authority of the C.E.S.C Ltd. will be at liberty to request the Officer-in-charge of the local police station to provide necessary police assistance for the purpose of effecting supply of electricity at the portion of the premises in question in terms of this order and if such request is made, then the Officer-in-charge of the concerned police station shall provide necessary assistance without any further delay.

    12. With the aforesaid observations and directions, this appeal stands allowed. There will be, however, no order as to costs.

    13. Let xerox plain copy of this order countersigned by Assistant Registrar (Court) be given to the appearing parties on usual undertaking.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amarendra Singh v. Calcutta Electric Supply Corporation Ltd. & Ors.
    (Jan 10, 2008)