AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — In re: CAN 642 of 2005 (D.K. Seth, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

An alleged industrial dispute was referred to the Conciliation Officer. On the Conciliation Officer's report the State Government formed the opinion that the dispute was not fit for reference under section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. That formation of opinion was challenged by a writ petition (W.P. No. 8194(W) of 2004), which was dismissed by the learned Single Judge by a judgment and order dated 7 December 2004. The present appeal arises from that decision. An affidavit filed was taken on record. The Court treated the appeal, by consent, as part of the hearing on an application for stay and proceeded to hear the parties on the merits and to dispose of the appeal the same day.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in forming an opinion under section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, the State Government may adjudicate the merits of the dispute or determine rights of the parties.
  2. To what extent the State Government may consider prima facie materials (including merits) when deciding whether a dispute is fit for reference.
  3. Whether the accommodation provided to the head peon constituted a customary right or concession triggering the requirement of notice under section 9A and the Fourth Schedule.
  4. Whether the learned Single Judge's dismissal of the writ petition amounted to an impermissible adjudication on merits or was a permissible affirmation that no prima facie case existed for reference.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The State Government and the Conciliation Officer had, in substance, adjudicated the dispute; such adjudication is impermissible in the conciliation/formation-of-opinion process.
  • In the course of conciliation the officer or the State Government cannot decide or adjudicate rights or merits unless the parties agree to a settlement.
  • The State Government may only form an opinion whether a dispute exists and whether it is expedient to refer it; forming that opinion must not amount to deciding the merits.
  • Counsel referred to several authorities in support of the contention (to be addressed by the Court at the appropriate stage).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The State Government must form an opinion based on the prima facie materials placed before it and cannot blindly refer every dispute for adjudication.
  • The central consideration is whether a dispute exists and whether it is an industrial dispute fit for reference; to form that opinion the Government is entitled to look into the materials and conclude on the existence and nature of the dispute.
  • The State Government is required to refer disputes only when, on examination of materials, it is satisfied that it is expedient to do so; otherwise it can refuse to refer.
  • The respondents distinguished the decisions relied upon by the appellants and referred to authorities supporting prima facie consideration by the Government.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Workmen Employed By Hindustan Lever Ltd v. Hindustan Lever Limited Cited among authorities establishing the settled principle concerning formation of opinion under section 10 — namely, limitations on State Government adjudication of merits when forming an opinion. The Court grouped this case with others to show the law is well-settled that the State Government cannot adjudicate merits while forming an opinion; it supports the general proposition stated by the Court.
Management Of Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Workmen Cited as authority relevant to the proposition about the State Government's limited role in formation of opinion under section 10. Used as part of the body of precedents establishing the principle that the Government's role in forming an opinion is confined to examining existence of a dispute, not deciding merits.
Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana One of the authorities cited supporting the settled proposition on the scope of formation of opinion under section 10. Included by the Court in the list of decisions demonstrating the legal position that formation of opinion is limited and does not permit adjudication of rights.
Abad Dairy Dudh Vitran Kendra Sanchalak Mandal v. Abad Dairy Cited among supporting precedents on the limits of State Government's role in forming opinion under section 10. Referenced by the Court to show consistent authority for the stated proposition.
Sankari Cement Alai Thozhilalar Munnetra Sangam v. Government of Tamil Nadu Cited as part of the body of case law on formation of opinion and the prohibition on adjudicating merits in that process. Used to support the Court's statement that the law is well-settled on this point.
M.P Irrigation Karamchari Sangh v. State of M.P Cited among authorities on the scope and limits of formation of opinion under section 10. Included to demonstrate consistent judicial treatment of the formation-of-opinion issue.
Sharad Kumar v. Government of NCT of Delhi Holds that where determination requires examination of factual matters for which materials including oral evidence are necessary, the State Government cannot undertake such examination and thereby arrogate adjudicatory power. The Court relied on Sharad Kumar to explain the boundary: the State cannot undertake detailed factual adjudication requiring oral evidence; however, Sharad Kumar does not overrule Bombay Union of Journalists on the point that the Government may consider prima facie merit.
Telco Convoy Drivers Mazdoor Sangh v. State of Bihar Listed among authorities relevant to formation of opinion under section 10 and its limitations. Included in the collected authorities supporting the Court's articulation of the law.
U.P State Bridge Corporation Ltd. v. U.P Rajya Setu Nigam S. Karamchari Sangh Cited as a recent authority (SOL Case No. 122, 2004) dealing with the topic of formation of opinion under section 10. Part of the judicial material the Court relied upon in stating the settled legal position.
Secretary, India Tea Association v. Ajit Kumar Barat Affirms that the Government may consider prima facie the merit of the dispute and refuse to refer under section 10 when appropriate. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that prima facie consideration of merit by the Government is permissible when forming an opinion.
Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay Held that the Government while forming opinion was not precluded from considering prima facie the merit of the dispute and refuse to refer under section 10. The Court noted Bombay Union supports prima facie consideration and observed that Sharad Kumar did not overrule this aspect of Bombay Union; Ajit Kumar Barat repeats the same principle.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by stating the settled legal principle: when forming an opinion under section 10(1) the State Government must confine itself to examining whether a dispute exists, whether it is an industrial dispute and whether it is expedient to refer the dispute for adjudication. In that limited scope the Government may examine materials placed before it and determine whether a prima facie case exists for reference. However, the Government is not empowered to adjudicate the merits or decide the rights of parties; doing so would be beyond its jurisdiction when merely forming an opinion.

The Court reconciled authorities by explaining that some decisions (e.g., Bombay Union of Journalists and Ajit Kumar Barat) permit the Government to consider the prima facie merits of a dispute and refuse reference when the materials do not disclose a prima facie case. At the same time the Court relied on Sharad Kumar to emphasize that the Government cannot undertake determination that requires full factual examination, including oral evidence, because that would amount to adjudication.

Applying these principles to the present facts, the Court examined the nature of the claimed right (accommodation in office premises provided to the head peon). The record (including a letter and a paragraph in the Shastri Award) indicated that the arrangement was not a concession or a condition of service but an obligation on the head peon to remain at the premises. The Court observed that the later statutory introduction of section 9A and the Fourth Schedule (which requires notice when a customary right or concession forming a condition of service is withdrawn) did not automatically convert what was not a concession or customary right into one. Because the accommodation, on the face of the records, did not constitute a customary right or a condition of service, no amount of additional evidence was necessary to hold the claim to be non est.

The Court therefore concluded that the State Government, in the process of forming its opinion, properly examined the records and found no prima facie case. That exercise did not amount to an unlawful adjudication of merit but was a permissible assessment confined to whether a dispute existed and whether it was expedient to refer it.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal and the application for injunction are DISMISSED; the judgment of the learned Single Judge is affirmed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the State Government's refusal to refer the dispute under section 10(1) was upheld: the Government had properly formed an opinion that no industrial dispute existed which was expedient to be referred.
  • The Court clarified the boundary between permissible prima facie examination by the Government and impermissible adjudication: the Government may consider prima facie materials but may not undertake detailed factual inquiries that amount to deciding disputed facts or rights requiring oral evidence.
  • The Court noted that no broader precedent-changing doctrine was established; the decision applies the existing line of authorities to the facts and affirms that when, on the face of the record, no condition of service exists, a dispute may be found frivolous and non-referable without extensive fact-finding.
  • Costs: There will be no order as to costs. An urgent certified xerox copy, if applied for, is to be provided on priority.

This summary is strictly confined to the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

    Bank Of Baroda Employees' Association & Anr. v. Union Of India & Ors.

    D.K Seth, J.:—

    In re: CAN 642 of 2005

    1. Affidavit filed today be taken on record.

    1.1 An alleged industrial dispute was raised before the Conciliation Officer for adjudication thereof. On the report of the Conciliation Officer, the State Government had formed an opinion that the alleged dispute was not fit for reference under section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. This has been challenged in a writ petition, since dismissed, being W.P No. 8194(W) of 2004 by or under judgment and order dated 7th December, 2004. This appeal arises out of the said decision.

    1.2 The learned Counsel for both the parties, while addressing the Court on the application for stay, addressed on the merit of the appeal. In the circumstances, having heard the learned Counsel for the respective parties at length, we feel that while disposing of the application for stay, nothing remains to be decided in the appeal. Therefore, the appeal, by consent of the parties, is treated as on day's list for hearing and is taken up along with the application for stay and is being disposed of as hereafter.

    Appellants' contention:

    2. The main thrust of the contention of Mr. Supriya Chattopadhyay, the learned Counsel for the appellants, is that the State Government had virtually adjudicated the dispute, which has since been reiterated by the learned Single Judge in the decision under appeal. In course of conciliation, the Conciliation Officer cannot adjudicate except as to the existence of the dispute unless agreed to the parties to settle the dispute between themselves. On the report, the State Government cannot undertake the exercise of deciding the case on merit and adjudicate the dispute by itself. It can only form an opinion; but that formation of opinion cannot lead to a decision on merit of the dispute. He had referred to several decisions to support his contention. We shall be referring to those decisions at appropriate stage.

    Respondents' contention:

    3. The learned Counsel, Mr. Aninda Mitra, ably assisted by Mr. L.K Gupta for the respondents, on the other hand, contended that the State Government has to form an opinion on the basis of the prima facie case and it cannot close its eyes and refer all disputes whenever it comes before it. The primary consideration is the existence of dispute and such dispute must be an industrial dispute fit for being referred to for adjudication. In order to form an opinion, it has to look into the materials placed before it and come to a conclusion as to the existence of a dispute and that such dispute is in the nature of an industrial dispute fit for reference. It is only when a dispute exists and it is expedient for being referred to, the State Government shall be bound to refer it and not otherwise. Reference has been made to certain decisions and the decisions cited by the learned Counsel for the appellant were also distinguished. We shall be referring to such decisions at appropriate stage.

    Section 10(1): Formation of opinion: Scope and extent:

    4. As rightly pointed out by the learned Counsel for the appellants that a notice under section 9A would be necessary whenever there is an attempt to withdraw any customary right or concession given to an employee, as prescribed in Clause 8 of the Fourth Schedule to the 1947 Act. He has also rightly pointed out that whenever a notice of strike is given under section 22(1) of the said Act, by reason of sub-section (3), it is incumbent upon the State Government to refer the dispute for adjudication when it appears that there are certain merits in it without adjudicating the merits itself. According to him, in view of the provisions contained in section 10(1) Second Proviso, the State Government cannot decide the dispute or adjudicate the merits of the demand raised by the employees in course of its process to form an opinion as to whether the dispute should be referred to or not.

    4.1 The law is well-settled, as has been held in Workmen Employed By Hindustan Lever Ltd v. Hindustan Lever Limited., 1985 SCC (L & S) 6 : 1984 (2) LLJ 391; Management of Management Of Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Workmen, 1975 (2) LLJ 319; Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana, AIR 1985 SC 915; Abad Dairy Dudh Vitran Kendra Sanchalak Mandal v. Abad Dairy, 1983 (3) LLJ (Suppl.) 885; Sankari Cement Alai Thozhilalar Munnetra Sangam v. Government of Tamil Nadu, 1983 (1) LLJ 460 (SC); M.P Irrigation Karamchari Sangh v. State of M.P, AIR 1985 SC 860; Sharad Kumar v. Government of NCT of Delhi, AIR 2002 SC 1724; Telco Convoy Drivers Mazdoor Sangh v. State of Bihar, AIR 1989 SC 1565 and U.P State Bridge Corporation Ltd. v. U.P Rajya Setu Nigam S. Karamchari Sangh, 2004 SOL Case No. 122, cited by the learned Counsel for the appellants.

    4.2 So far as the proposition of law, it does not admit of any second opinion or dispute. The principle is well-settled. The State Government has to form an opinion for the purpose of making a reference under section 10(1). In course of such formation of opinion, the State Government has no jurisdiction to decide the dispute or adjudicate on the merit of it. It cannot ascertain the rights of the parties. The only scope left with the State Government in the formation of opinion is confined to the examination as to the existence of a dispute and to decide whether such dispute is an industrial dispute and that it would be expedient to refer such dispute for adjudication. Within this confined scope the State Government can form its opinion on the basis of the materials placed before it. In the process of formation of opinion, the State Government has to examine the materials and to find out that there is a prima facie case as to the existence of the dispute and that such dispute is an industrial dispute and that it is expedient to refer the dispute for adjudication. It can also examine as to whether such dispute is frivolous or as to whether the materials support the existence of such dispute.

    4.3 This proposition can be supported by the decision in Secretary, India Tea Association v. Ajit Kumar Barat, AIR 2000 SC 915 and the decision in Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay, AIR 1964 SC 1617 cited by Mr. Mitra. In Bombay Union of Journalists (supra), the Supreme Court had held that the Government while forming such opinion was not precluded from considering prima facie the merit of the dispute and refuse to refer the dispute under section 10. The learned Counsel for the appellant, however, points out that this decision was subsequently overruled by the decision in Sharad Kumar (supra). In Sharad Kumar (supra), it was held that in a case where the determination of the question requires examination of factual matters for which materials including oral evidence are required to be considered cannot be undertaken by the State Government and thereby arrogate on itself the power to adjudicate on the merit of the question itself. This decision does not overrule the decision in Bombay Union of Journalists (supra) to the extent of consideration of prima facie case, which is repeated in Ajit Kumar Barat (supra).

    4.4 There is a distinction between the decision on merit leading to adjudication on the dispute and examination of the existence of the dispute having regard to the materials placed before it. Admittedly, the State Government, while forming an opinion, does not act either as a rubber stamp or a mere post office. It has to apply its mind in order to form an opinion as to the existence of the dispute and to find out that such dispute is an industrial dispute expedient to be referred to. No opinion can be formed without applying its mind to the materials placed before it. Examination of the materials for the purpose of formation of opinion would not amount to adjudication unless it purports to decide disputed question on facts.

    The present case: The principle applied: Whether a concession or right:

    5. In this case the dispute was based on the claim for accommodation in the office premises provided to the head peon. In fact from page 23 of the injunction application, it appears that this accommodation was not a concession but an obligation on the part of the head peon to stay in the premises. For the purpose of arriving at an opinion on the basis of the materials on record, no amount of disputed question of facts is required to be decided. The letter itself indicates that it is not a concession or a right but an obligation on the part of the head peon to remain in the office even outside duty hours. At the same time, it appears from paragraph 159 of the Shastri Award that such accommodation in the office premises is not a right conferred on the employee and is not a concession. However, on this question the learned Counsel for the appellants points out that this Shastri Award was given sometimes in 1953, whereas section 9A and the Fourth Schedule was introduced on 10 of March, 1957. Introduction of this provision had virtually superseded paragraph 159 of the Shastri Award.

    5.1 This proposition does not seem to be of any substance. Section 9A read with the Fourth Schedule, clause 8 requires giving of a notice when a customary right or concession being a condition of service, is sought to be withdrawn. Whereas, the accommodation in the office, which was held not to be a concession or a right or condition of service or employment, would not be converted into a concession or a customary right or condition of service simply because of an amendment of the provisions of the statute viz: by reason of introduction of section 9A and the Fourth Schedule. What was not a concession nor a customary right would not be converted as such by reason of any enactment until it is made part of the conditions of service by appropriate amendment in the statute governing the service of the employees. At the same time, it is admitted, in his usual fairness, by Mr. Chattopadhyay that the head peons/the workmen despite being required to stay in the office, draw house rent allowance. Therefore, the alleged condition of service on which the dispute was sought to be based, on the face of it appears to be non est and the dispute, as rightly found by the State Government, seems to be frivolous and inexpedient for being referred to.

    Conclusion:

    6. In order to be referred to, a dispute must be an industrial dispute. Industrial dispute is a dispute, which is related to the condition of service. Unless it is established or particularly when it appears that on the face of the records that such a condition does not exist at all and for which no amount of evidence is necessary except looking at the records, in such cases it can be held to be frivolous and that no such dispute exists.

    6.1 Therefore, the finding of the learned Single Judge would not amount to adjudication on the merit of the case but is a reasoning given to support its finding that there was no prima facie case, as was rightly found by the State Government in the process of its formation of opinion and that it was not a case expedient for being referred to.

    Order:

    7. For all these reasons, we are not inclined to interfere with the decision of the learned Single Judge. Though not happily drafted, the grounds on which the State Government had refused the reference seems to make out a case that it had formed an opinion that no industrial dispute existed which was expedient for being referred to.

    7.1 The appeal and the application for injunction, thus, stand dismissed. The judgment appealed against is hereby affirmed.

    7.2 There will, however, be no order as to costs.

    7.3 Urgent xerox certified copy, if applied for, be given on priority basis.

    Soumitra Pal, J.:— I agree.

    Appeal and application dismissed.
    A.D

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bank Of Baroda Employees' Association & Anr. v. Union Of India & Ors.
    (Jan 31, 2005)