Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff (respondent 1) filed an application under Order 39, Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C.), seeking a temporary mandatory injunction against defendant 1 (respondent 2) and a temporary prohibitory injunction against defendant 2 (appellant). The trial court issued notices to the defendants but refused to grant an ad interim injunction initially. Subsequently, defendant 1 appeared and sought time to file a show cause. The plaintiff then filed another application under Section 94 of the Code renewing the prayer for an ad interim injunction against defendant 1. By consent of both parties, the trial court granted the ad interim injunction until the final disposal of the original application under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2, C.P.C., and disposed of the Section 94 petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court can grant temporary injunctions under two separate provisions of the Code—Section 94 and Order 39—or only under a combined reading of Section 94(c) and Order 39, Rules 1 and 2.
  2. Whether a court, after refusing an ad interim injunction and issuing notice to show cause, can subsequently grant an ad interim injunction until the disposal of the original application for temporary injunction.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manohar Lal Chopra v. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hiralal, AIR 1962 SC 527 Recognition that courts can grant temporary injunctions under their inherent powers saved by Section 151 of the Code, apart from the Code's provisions. The court acknowledged that while inherent powers exist, temporary injunctions under the Code must be granted under Section 94(c) read with Order 39, Rules 1 and 2; inherent powers are separate and not derived from the Code's procedural provisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code and clarified that temporary injunctions cannot be granted independently under Section 94 and Order 39 as separate sources of power. Instead, Section 94(c) must be read in conjunction with Order 39, Rules 1 and 2, which prescribe the conditions for granting temporary injunctions. The court noted that the trial court's initial refusal of an ad interim injunction followed by a grant on a subsequent application under Section 94 was based on a mistaken impression that there are two separate powers to grant such injunctions. The court corrected this by emphasizing that only one combined provision applies.

Regarding the procedural question, the court held that there is no bar to granting an ad interim injunction after an earlier refusal if there are new developments or altered circumstances justifying such grant. However, if the material facts remain unchanged, granting an injunction later would amount to an impermissible review of the earlier order. In the present case, the second application was based on further developments and altered circumstances, which justified the trial court's grant of the ad interim injunction.

The court concluded that both applications must be treated as made under Section 94(c) read with Order 39, and that the trial court's order granting ad interim injunction pending disposal of the main application was not erroneous. The court directed the trial court to decide the main application expeditiously and without being influenced by the appellate observations.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the trial court's order granting the ad interim injunction until the disposal of the main application under Order 39 stands confirmed. The court did not set any new precedent but clarified the correct legal position regarding the source of power for granting temporary injunctions under the Civil Procedure Code. The trial court is directed to proceed with the main application for injunction without prejudice to the appellate observations.

    Jagjit Singh Khanna v. Dr. Rakhal Das Mullick And Another

    Bhattacharjee, J.:— The plaintiff, who is respondent 1 before us, filed an application under the provisions of O. 39, Civil P.C, praying for a temporary mandatory injunction against defendant 1, who is respondent 2 before us and a temporary prohibitory injunction against defendant 2, who is the appellant before us. The trial court issued notices to the defendants to show cause as to why such injunctions shall not be granted, but refused the prayer for ad interim injunction.

    2. Within a week thereafter defendant 1 appeared and prayed for time to file his show cause. The plaintiff has then filed another application under the provisions of S. 94 of the Code renewing his prayer for ad interim injunction against defendant 1 and on consent of both the parties, the trial Court has allowed the application under S. 94 of the Code and has granted ad interim injunction “till the final disposal of the application under O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2, C.P.C” and has stated in the impugned order that “the petition under S. 94, C.P.C, be thus disposed of”.

    3. It seems that the trial Court in refusing ad interim injunction under an application labelled as one under O. 39 of the Code and thereafter in granting ad interim injunction on an application purporting to be under S. 94 of the Code “till the final disposal of the application under O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2, C.P.C”, proceeded under the impression that the Code clothes the Courts with two sources of power to grant temporary injunction, one under S. 94 of the Code and the other under O. 39 of the Code. The impression is wholly erroneous as would appear from a bare perusal of the provisions of S. 94(c) of the Code whereunder the Court may grant a temporary injunction only “if it is so prescribed”. The expression “prescribed” in S. 94 would obviously mean, as defined in S. 2(16) of the Code, “prescribed by Rules”. The Rules which prescribe grant of temporary injunction are R. 1 and R. 2 of O. 39 and, therefore, a temporary injunction may be granted under S. 94(c) only if a case satisfying the requirements of Rr. 1 and 2, O. 39 is made out. As already noted, not that the Court has two sources of power, one under S. 94(c) and another under O. 39 of the Code and may resort to one or the other as and when necessary, but that under the Code the Court grants temporary injunction only under one set of provisions, namely, S. 94(c) read with O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2 of the Code. It is true that, as pointed out by the Supreme Court in Manohar Lal Chopra v. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hiralal, AIR 1962 SC 527, a Court can grant temporary injunction in exercise of its inherent powers also, but there it does not grant it under any power conferred by the Code but under powers inhering in its very constitution which are saved by and under S. 151 of the Code. The words “a temporary injunction granted under the last preceding section” in S. 95 of the Code indicate that temporary injunction is granted under the provisions of S. 94, but the words “any injunction granted… under R. 1 or R. 2” in R. 2A of O. 39 may give rise to the impression that a temporary injunction may be granted independently under the provisions of O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2 also. But, as already indicated, under the Code a temporary injunction can be granted only under one set of provisions namely, under S. 94(c) read with O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2.

    4. Both the applications for ad interim/temporary injunctions must, therefore, be treated as applications under S. 94(c) read with O. 39 of the Code, even though the first one was labelled as one under O. 39 only and the second one as one under S. 94 only. The net question, therefore, is that if a Court has refused ad interim injunction and has only issued notice to show cause on an application for temporary injunction, canit, on a subsequent application, grant ad interim injunction till the disposal of the earlier application for temporary injunction. A temporary injunction may, as it very often does, consist of two stages, one granted without finally disposing of the application for injunction to operate immediately till the disposal of the said application and the other granted while finally disposing of the main application to enure generally till the disposal of the suit and while the former is generally classed as ad interim injunction, the latter is generally called temporary injunction. Neither on principle nor on authority we find any bar to the Courts granting ad interim injunction till the disposal of the application for the temporary injunction, if subsequent developments or altered circumstances warrant such grant, even though it has refused to grant the same earlier on the materials then on record. If, however, the materials on record stand as they stood when the ad interim injunction was refused earlier, a grant of ad interim injunction on such materials may not be permissible as that might amount to impermissible review of the earlier order.

    5. The second application for ad interim injunction, labelled as one under S. 94 of the Code, has been avowedly made, as stated in Para thereof, on the ground of “further developments” and “altered circumstances” and those developments and circumstances have been stated in details in Para 4 of the application. The materials on record did not, therefore, stand where they stood when the ad interim injunction was refused on the earlier application. In granting the ad interim injunction on such further developments and altered circumstances, the learned Judge does not appear to have committed any error to justify any interference, particularly at this stage, when the main application for injunction is still awaiting his final adjudication. The net position, therefore, is that on the two applications for interlocutory injunctions taken together, one labelled as under O. 39 and the other as under S. 94, the trial Court has issued notice to show cause why the application for temporary injunction shall not be granted and has also granted ad interim injunction till the disposal of that application. It would be now for the defendants to file show cause and for the learned trial Judge to decide as to whether this is a fit case for the grant of temporary injunction as prayed for and the learned Judge must do so, as expeditiously as possible, without being in any way influenced by the fact that we are dismissing this appeal against the order of ad interim injunction and also by the observations, if any, made by us as to the merits of the case relating to temporary injunction.

    6. The appeal is accordingly dismissed, but in the circumstances of the case we make no order as to costs.

    Nayak, J.:— 7. I agree.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jagjit Singh Khanna v. Dr. Rakhal Das Mullick And Another
    (Apr 30, 1987)