Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opposite party filed an application under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code claiming maintenance. An ex parte order was passed by the learned Magistrate on 25th February 1976. The petitioner contended that he was unaware of the case and thus did not appear, resulting in the ex parte order. The petitioner only became aware of the order on 20th August 1976 during execution proceedings related to the maintenance claim. Subsequently, on 1st September 1976, the petitioner filed an application to set aside the ex parte order and restore the case. This application was rejected by the Magistrate on the ground of limitation, holding that it was filed beyond three months from the date of the order. The petitioner appealed to the higher court against this rejection.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the limitation period for setting aside an ex parte maintenance order under Section 125 of the Code runs from the date of the order or from the date of knowledge of the order by the aggrieved party.
  2. Whether the petitioner was entitled to have the ex parte order set aside and the case restored despite the delay in filing the application beyond three months from the date of the order.
  3. The extent to which service of summons and knowledge of the ex parte order affect the limitation period for filing an application under Section 126(2) of the Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner was unaware of the proceedings and the ex parte order passed against him on 25th February 1976 because the summons was not properly served.
  • The limitation period for setting aside an ex parte order should run from the date the petitioner gained knowledge of the order, not from the date the order was passed.
  • There is conflicting judicial authority on this point, but several decisions support the proposition that limitation runs from knowledge of the order.
  • Relied on decisions including AIR 1971 Calcutta 244 (Hemendra Nath Chowdhury v. Sm. Archana Chowdhury), AIR 1966 Andhra Pradesh 50 (Johra Begum v. Mohammed Ghouse Qadri Qadeeri), and an unreported decision in Criminal Revision No. 439 of 1963.
  • Argued that if there was no legal service of summons, the ex parte order is vitiated and limitation should not run from the date of such an order.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • Section 488(6) of the Old Code and proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 126 of the New Code clearly prescribe a three-month limitation period from the date of the ex parte order.
  • Interpreting the limitation period to run from the date of knowledge would add words to the statutory provisions, which is impermissible.
  • Distinguished the petitioner’s reliance on AIR 1961 SC 1500 (Harish Chandra v. Deputy Land Acquisition Officer) by noting that it involved a land acquisition award, which differs from a court’s ex parte order.
  • Relied on AIR 1950 Madras 153 (A.S. Govindan v. Margaret Jayammal), 1968 (2) Criminal Law Journal 581 (Hari Singh Ishar Singh Jat v. Dhanng Hari), and AIR 1971 Punjab and Haryana 88 (Smt. Parson Kaur v. Bakshis Singh) to assert limitation runs from the date of the order.
  • Contended that while delay can be condoned for sufficient cause, the limitation period itself begins from the date of the order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harish Chandra v. Deputy Land Acquisition Officer, AIR 1961 SC 1500 Limitation for setting aside an order runs from date of knowledge if there was no legal service or knowledge of the order. The Court relied on this principle to hold that limitation may run from knowledge of the order, not merely from the date of the order, especially where summons service is disputed.
Hemendra Nath Chowdhury v. Sm. Archana Chowdhury, AIR 1971 Calcutta 244 Affirmed that limitation to set aside an ex parte maintenance order runs from the date of knowledge of the order. The Court found this decision supportive of the petitioner’s contention and relied on it in interpreting limitation.
Johra Begum alias Aysha Begum v. Mohammed Ghouse Qadri Qadeeri, AIR 1966 Andhra Pradesh 50 Limitation for setting aside ex parte maintenance order begins from date of knowledge, not date of order. The Court accepted this principle as persuasive authority supporting limitation running from knowledge.
A.S. Govindan v. Margaret Jayammal, AIR 1950 Madras 153 Limitation runs strictly from date of the order, not from knowledge. The Court noted this decision but disagreed with its view, favoring the contrary authorities.
Hari Singh Ishar Singh Jat v. Dhanng Hari, 1968 (2) Criminal Law Journal 581 Application to set aside ex parte order must be made within three months from date of order. The Court acknowledged this but preferred the line of cases holding limitation runs from knowledge.
Smt. Parson Kaur v. Bakshis Singh, AIR 1971 Punjab and Haryana 88 Limitation begins from date of order; however, extension of time may be granted for sufficient cause. The Court recognized this principle but emphasized the need to consider the petitioner’s knowledge and allow opportunity to prove delay justification.
Unreported Criminal Revision No. 439 of 1963 Limitation may be extended where petitioner was unaware of ex parte order due to fraud or lack of knowledge. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that limitation runs from knowledge and to allow for exceptions based on facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined conflicting judicial authorities on whether the limitation period for setting aside an ex parte maintenance order runs from the date of the order or from the date the aggrieved party gains knowledge of it. The Court noted that the petitioner disputed proper service of summons and claimed ignorance of the order until several months later. The Court found persuasive the line of decisions holding that limitation should run from the date of knowledge to prevent injustice where legal service was not effected. It distinguished cases cited by the opposite party that strictly enforce limitation from the date of the order, noting that some involved different legal contexts such as land acquisition awards. The Court held that the petitioner must prove when he became aware of the ex parte order. Since the learned Magistrate rejected the petitioner’s application solely on limitation grounds without considering the petitioner’s knowledge, the Court set aside the Magistrate’s order and remanded the matter for fresh consideration, directing the Magistrate to decide the application expeditiously and on the merits of the petitioner’s knowledge of the order.

Holding and Implications

Rule made absolute.

The Court set aside the ex parte order dated 25th February 1976 and the order rejecting the restoration application under Section 126(2) of the Code. The case was remanded to the learned Magistrate for disposal of the petitioner’s application to set aside the ex parte order, with directions to consider the petitioner’s knowledge of the order and to decide the matter expeditiously. This decision directly benefits the petitioner by providing an opportunity to challenge the ex parte order despite the delay, emphasizing the importance of actual knowledge in computing limitation. The Court did not establish a new precedent but applied existing principles to the facts, allowing for equitable relief where service and knowledge are contested.

    Md. Akbar Ali Sardar v. Firoze Khatun Bibi & Ors.

    1. This Rule arises on an application under Ss. 401 and 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code read with Article 227 of the Constitution and is directed against ex parte order dated 25.2.76 and order dated 22.12.76 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate in Case No. 3 of 75 under S. 125 of the Code and also rejecting the restoration application of the petitioner under S. 126(2) of the Code.

    2. The facts of the case may briefly be stated as follows:—

    The opposite party filed an application under S. 125 of the Code claiming maintenance. An ex parte order was passed by the learned Magistrate on 25.2.76 It is the case of the petitioner that the petitioner did not know anything about the case filed against him, as such he could not appear and an ex parte order was passed against him. After having come to know of the order only on 20th August 1976 in connection with the execution case arising out of the maintenance proceeding, the petitioner filed an application on 1.9.76 for setting aside the ex parte order and for restoration of the case. The said application was rejected by the learned Magistrate only on the ground of limitation holding that the application was filed beyond three months from the date of the order. Being aggrieved, the petitioner has come up to this Court.

    3. In the first place it is stated by Mr. Satyajit Mondal, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner, that when on 25th of February 1976 the learned Magistrate passed an ex parte order he did not satisfy himself whether the summons was duly served on the petitioner. It appears that there is an endorsement refused on registered post card which is said to have been sent to the petitioner. From the endorsement ‘refused’ it is sometimes held that the service was duly effected. But in the present case the petitioner came up with a case before the learned Magistrate that the summons was never offered to him and he did not refuse to accept the same. It was only on 20th of August 1976 he came to know about the ex parte order passed on 25th of February 1976. Mr. Mondal submits that the limitation will run from the date of the knowledge and not from the date of the order. On this point there are conflicting decisions of several High Courts. I requested Mr. Prasun Chandra Ghosh learned advocate who was present in Court at the time of hearing to assist me to decide the point of limitation. Mr. Ghosh was kind enough to refer me to an unreported decision of this Court in Criminal Revision No. 439 of 1963. He has also referred to a decisions reported in AIR 1966 Andhra Pradesh 50 and 1974 Criminal Law Journal 1234. I am thankful to Mr. Ghosh for the assistance rendered by him. Mr. Mondal places before me a decision of this Court reported in AIR 1971 Calcutta 244 (Hemendra Nath Chowdhury… v. Sm. Archana Chowdhury…Opposite Party.). In this case Talukdar, J. relying on the principle of law laid down by Their Lordships of the Supreme Court in AIR 1961 SC 1500 (Harish Chandra v. Deputy Land Acquisition Officer) held that “If there was no knowledge on the part of the affected party about the relevant proceedings and the ultimate order passed ex parte therein, the period of limitation is not to run from the date of the order but from the date of the knowledge. Any other interpretation will unnecessarily circumscribe the intention of the legislature and would not be expedient in the interests of justice. If the ex parte order for maintenance is vitiated because of the absence of a legal service, the ultimate order passed is not a legal and proper one and as such there is no question of any limitation running from the same.” In AIR 1966 Andhra Pradesh 50 (Johra Begum alias Aysha Begum v. Mohammed Ghouse Qadri Qadeeri), Jaganmohan Reddy, J. relying on AIR 1961 SC 1500 held that “The limitation for setting aside an ex parte order of maintenance begins from the date of knowledge of the order to the aggrieved party and not from the date of passing of the order.” His Lordship also considered the contrary view expressed in AIR 1950 Madras 153. In 1974 Criminal Law Journal 1234 (Dhani Ram v. State) relying on the decisions reported in AIR 1961 SC 1500 and AIR 1966 Andhra Pradesh 50 it was held that “the limitation for setting aside an ex parte order of maintenance begins from the date of knowledge of the order to the aggrieved party and not from the date of passing of the order.” In an unreported decision of this Court in Criminal Revision No. 439 of 1963 disposed of by K.C Sen, J. on 28.8.64 while considering whether the petitioner against whom an ex parte order of maintenance was passed could take up a plea that he did not know of the ex parte order and as such he could not file the application within time as he was prevented by fraud practised by the opposite party, it was held that “There being no provision in the latter part of the proviso to Section 488(6) expressly excluding the provision of Section 18 of the Indian Limitation Act referred to before it will be attracted in suitable cases as enumerated therein.” In coming to such conclusion. His Lordship relied on a similar observation by this Court in a Bench decision reported in 33 CWN 227 (Raja Sati Prasad Garga Bahadur v. Gobinda Chandra See).

    4. Mr. Jyotish Chandra Bose, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the opposite party, contends that S. 488(6) of the Old Code and proviso to sub-s. (2) of S. 126 of the New Code very cleary lay down that “an ex parte order may be set aside for good cause shown on an application made within three months from the date thereof…………….”. If the provisions referred to above are interpreted to say that the limitation runs from the date of the knowledge of the order that would be adding something to the sections which are not there and this adding of some words is not permitted in law. Referring to the decision reported in AIR 1961 SC 1500 Mr. Bose submits that the principle laid down in that case does not apply to the facts of the present case. In the said case it was an award by the collector. An award in a land acquisition matter must be considered as different from an ex parte order passed in a court proceeding. Talukdar, J. has considered this aspect and has held “The provisions contained in the proviso to S. 18(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 are pari materia with the provisions contained in the proviso to S. 488(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure relating to limitation”. In support of his contention Mr. Bose first refers to a decision reported in AIR 1950 Madras 153 (A.S. Govindan v. Margaret Jayammal). This case was considered by Talukdar J. in AIR 1971 Calcutta 244 and His Lordship disagreed with the view expressed in this decision. It has been held in this decision that “The period of three months does not mean three months from the date of knowledge of the order. Where the application is made more than three months from the date of the order, it is liable to be dismissed.”

    5. The next case referred to by Mr. Bose has been reported in 1968 (2) Criminal Law Journal 581 (Hari Singh Ishar Singh Jat v. Dhanng Hari. In this case also it has been held that “An application to set aside an ex parte order of maintenance has to be reckoned from the date of the ex parte order and not from any other date”.

    6. The last case cited by Mr. Bose has been reported in AIR 1971 Punjab and Haryana 88 (Smt. Parson Kaur v. Bakshis Singh). It has been held that “the limitation for setting aside an ex parte order begins from the date of the order and not from the date of the knowledge of the order”. In this case, however, His Lordship expressed an opinion that the aggrieved party can seek extension of time by showing that there was sufficient cause for his not coming to the court within the prescribed period from the date of the ex parte order. For that purpose, he is entitled to an opportunity to satisfy the court that there is sufficient ground for condoning the delay in coming to the court to have the ex parte order set aside.

    7. Considering all the decisions referred to above, I am inclined to rely on the proposition of law laid down in AIR 1961 SC 1500, AIR 1971 Calcutta 244 and the unreported decision in Criminal Rev. No. 439 of 1963 I hold that limitation to set aside an ex parte order of maintenance is 3 months from the date of the order. It is however for the petitioner to prove that he came to know of the order only on the date stated in the petition and not earlier. As the learned Magistrate rejected the application of the petitioner on the ground that the application is out of time having been filed beyond three months from the date of the order, this question was not considered by the learned Magistrate.

    8. In the result, the application succeeds and the Rule is made absolute. The order passed by the learned Magistrate is set aside. The case is sent back to the learned Magistrate who is directed to dispose of the application filed by the petitioner for setting aside the ex parte order. In the disposal of the said application the learned Magistrate will consider whether the petitioner came to know of the ex parte order on the date as alleged by him. The learned Magistrate is directed to dispose of the application as early as possible as the case is pending for a long time.

    Rule made absolute.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Md. Akbar Ali Sardar v. Firoze Khatun Bibi & Ors.
    (Sep 2, 1977)