Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-sections 3 and 4 of section 4 of the Indian Sale of Goods Act. Subsection 3
  • SECTION 83 INDIAN FOREST ACT
  • section 83, subsection (1) of the Indian Forest Act
  • section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act.16.
  • Section 83 (3) of the Indian Forest Act
  • section 83(1) of the Indian Forest Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-sections 3 and 4 of section 4 of the Indian Sale of Goods Act. Subsection 3
  • SECTION 83 INDIAN FOREST ACT
  • section 83, subsection (1) of the Indian Forest Act
  • section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act.16.
  • Section 83 (3) of the Indian Forest Act
  • section 83(1) of the Indian Forest Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Lahiri, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff purchased, by auction on 17 July 1941, lots Nos. A-19 and A-20 for Rs. 9,700, depositing Rs. 970 as security and paying a further sum by adjustment (pleaded as Rs. 1,555-15-8 in the plaint but at trial accepted as Rs. 1,474-8-0). Because the plaintiff failed to pay instalments as agreed, the Forest Department determined the agreement, took possession of the logs and timbers and re-sold them: one resale (of logs cut by the plaintiff) fetched Rs. 7,018-3-3 (after the Government incurred expenses of Rs. 2,300 for rolling/removing), and another resale (of remaining standing timber) to Messrs. Bose & Co. fetched Rs. 10,170. The plaintiff claimed a surplus of Rs. 7,714-2-11 under section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act; his administrative claim was rejected by forest authorities and by Government. The Subordinate Judge overruled the State's principal defence and gave a partial decree for Rs. 7,632-11-3; the State of West Bengal appealed against that decree to the court that produced this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, despite the Forest Department's valid determination of the agreement for non-payment of instalments, the plaintiff had acquired title to the trees (or to the money representing the value of the trees) under the agreement executed on 17 July 1941.
  2. Whether any surplus was payable to the plaintiff under section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act, after accounting for the Government's first charge (section 83(1)), expenses, and amounts already paid or deposited by the plaintiff.
  3. Whether the plaintiff's entitlement (if any) to proceeds from the resale of logs was lost for failure to make a timely claim within the period required by section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State of West Bengal) — Principal Contentions

  • The agreement was effectively determined by the Divisional Forest Officer upon the plaintiff's failure to pay instalments, and thereafter the plaintiff had no legal claim to the money.
  • The agreement only conferred licenses (to enter, to cut trees marked with the Government felling mark, and to remove trees once permitted); title to standing or felled trees remained with the Government until actual removal from the reserved forest.
  • Reliance on sub-sections 3 and 4 of section 4 of the Indian Sale of Goods Act: if the agreement was an agreement to sell rather than an immediate sale, property would pass only when the condition (removal/payment) was satisfied.

Respondent (Plaintiff) — Principal Contentions (as advanced by Mr. Bakshi)

  • Clause 7 distinguishes between standing trees and trees felled by the purchaser: while rights to standing trees are forfeited on determination, title to timber already felled by the purchaser remains vested in him subject only to Government's right to attach and sell to recover loss occasioned by re-sale.
  • Because the Government did not ultimately suffer loss on re-sale, the proceeds of the first resale (Rs. 7,018-3-3) belonged to the plaintiff as surplus under section 83(3).
  • The plaintiff sought to include the proceeds of the second resale (Rs. 10,170) as part of the amount available to determine surplus.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
James, Jones and Sons Limited v. Earl of Tankerville (1909) 2 Ch. Div. 440 (referred to in the opinion) A contract for sale of specific timber that the purchaser cuts and carries away confers a license to enter and cut, and as soon as the purchaser severs the timber the legal property in the severed trees vests in him; the license in respect of cut timber is irrevocable at law. The court relied on this authority to hold that the legal property in the trees cut by the purchaser had vested in the plaintiff (i.e., the plaintiff had, subject to statutory charge and clause 7 rights, residuary rights in the cut trees). This undercut the State's extreme contention that no title ever passed before removal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in sequence, construing the agreement form (Exts. A and A(1)) and relevant statutory provisions before applying them to the disputed facts.

1. Form of agreement and admissibility: The original agreement for lots A-19 and A-20 was not produced by the plaintiff. The defendant produced agreements in standard printed form (Exts. A and A(1)) and the court accepted evidence (including the plaintiff's witness and an affidavit by the Assistant Forest Officer) that the terms of the agreement in respect of A-19 and A-20 were identical with Exts. A and A(1). The court therefore construed rights on the basis of Exts. A and A(1).

2. Contractual rights under Ext. A (selected clauses): Clause 1 conferred licences (enter, cut marked trees, remove timber). Clause 3 required a security deposit (normally 10%) to guarantee performance, refundable under clause 10 after deductions for dues. Clause 2 provided for payment by instalments; clause 4 restricted removal until Government marking and written permission; clause 5 gave the Forest Officer discretion to refuse removal if value removed equalled/exceeded instalments paid. Clause 7 set out consequences of purchaser's failure to pay instalments: (a) forfeiture of rights to cut standing trees and forfeiture of security deposit; (b) Government's right to attach and seize trees, logs or timber then in the reserved forest; and (c) purchaser's personal liability for losses sustained by Government from resale not covered by security deposit and sale of purchaser-cut logs.

3. Whether title to cut timber vested in the plaintiff: The court accepted the line of authority in James, Jones and Sons to the effect that where the contract is for sale of specific timber to be cut by the purchaser, legal property in severed timber vests in the purchaser once severed. Applying that principle and construing Ext. A, the court held that the legal property in trees cut by the purchaser had vested in the plaintiff (subject to the Government's right under clause 7 to attach and seize and subject to statutory charge under the Indian Forest Act).

4. Operation of the Indian Forest Act, section 83: The court then turned to the statutory scheme. Under section 83(1) the sale price (Rs. 9,700) was a first charge on the cut logs; section 83(2) gave the Forest Officer a right to sell cut logs and apply proceeds to discharge that amount; and section 83(3) (referred to repeatedly) dealt with surplus after satisfying Government dues.

5. Accounting and surplus computation: The court accepted the plaintiff's own figures for resale and expenditure: the first resale of the plaintiff-cut logs fetched Rs. 7,018-3-3; the Government incurred Rs. 2,300 in felling/removing those logs. Adding to the net receipts the plaintiff's security deposit Rs. 970 and the adjustment payment Rs. 1,474-8-0 produced a total ("net price") of Rs. 7,162-11-3. That total was less than Rs. 9,700 (the amount on which the Government had a first charge). Therefore, there was no surplus available to the plaintiff under section 83(3).

6. Plaintiff's alternative contention rejected: The plaintiff argued that the proceeds of the second resale (Rs. 10,170) should be added to determine surplus. The court rejected this, holding that Rs. 10,170 represented the value of standing trees, which never passed to the plaintiff (because clause 7 terminated his right to cut standing trees). As the standing trees were Government property, their sale proceeds could not be counted as the plaintiff's surplus.

7. Timeliness of claim under section 83(3): The court also relied on section 83(3) which forfeits the amount fetched by resale to the Government if the claimant does not claim it within two months of resale. The notice of demand dated 1 September 1942 (Ext. 1(e)) did not claim the Rs. 7,018-3-3; instead it asserted a claim to Rs. 10,170 (the mistaken claim to standing-timber proceeds). The plaintiff later made a claim under section 80 of the Civil Procedure Code dated 9 September 1949, but that was long after the statutory two-month period following resale and therefore not a valid claim within section 83(3). Consequently the plaintiff lost any entitlement to the first resale proceeds by failing to make the required timely claim.

8. Conclusion of law: For the combined reasons that (a) the net amount available after accounting for expenses and payments was insufficient to satisfy the Government's first charge, and (b) the plaintiff failed to make a timely statutory claim to the proceeds of the resale of the logs he had cut, the plaintiff's claim was not maintainable in law.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The appeal is allowed; the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge are set aside, and the plaintiff's suit is dismissed with costs throughout.

Immediate implications for the parties:

  • The plaintiff receives no surplus under section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act and the suit for Rs. 7,714-2-11 (or the sum decreed below) fails.
  • The State's determination of the agreement and exercise of its statutory rights under section 83, and under clause 7 of the agreement, stands as applied in this case.

Broader implications: The opinion does not discuss broader doctrinal changes or purport to set a new legal precedent beyond its application of the existing authority (notably James, Jones and Sons) and statutory provisions. No new precedent is announced in the text of the opinion.


End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion.

    State Of West Bengal v. Narendra Nath Roy

    Lahiri, J.:— This is an appeal by the defendant, the State of West Bengal, in an action to recover a sum of Rs. 7,714-2-11 which is said to represent the surplus sale proceeds of timbers and logs sold by the Forest Department. The plaintiff's case is that he purchased in auction lots Nos. A-19 and A-20 of 1941–1942 on the 17th of July, 1941 for a sum of Rs. 9,700/- and deposited Rs. 970/- as security money and he paid a further sum of Rs. 1,555-15-8 by way of adjustment. On account of certain difficulties however, the plaintiff could not pay the price according to the instalments specified in the agreement for sale with the result that the Forest Department took possession of the logs and timbers and sold a part of them for a sum of Rs. 7,018-3-3 after incurring expenses to the extent of Rs. 2300/- for rolling and removing the logs and sold the remaining part to Messrs. Bose and Co. for a sum of Rs. 10,170/-. According to the plaintiff the total amount received by the Government by the resale of the said two lots was Rs. 19,714-2-11 and the total dues payable by the plaintiff was Rs. 12,000/- as detailed in the schedule to the plaint. The plaintiff accordingly sued for the recovery of the balance of Rs. 7714-2-11 which, according to him, represented the surplus sale proceeds of the timbers and logs and which, according to his claim, was payable to him under section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act. The plaintiff further stated that he claimed this amount by his letter dated the 1st of September, 1942 which was refused and on an appeal by the plaintiff, the Conservator of Forests, Nor the Circle finally rejected the plaintiff's claim by his letter dated the 13th September 1946 and the Government also rejected the plaintiffs claim by its letter dated the 28th of February, 1948.

    1. The main defence of the defendant was that on account of the failure of the plaintiff to pay the instalments specified in the agreement, the agreement for sale was legally determined-by the Divisional Forest Officer and thereafter the plaintiff had no legal claim to the money. At the trial the defendant produced evidence to show that the payment claimed by the plaintiff by way of compensation was not Rs. 1555-15-8 as stated in the plaint, but was Rs. 1474-8-0 and this evidence was accepted by the plaintiff.

    2. As a result of the trial the learned Subordinate Judge overruled the main defence set up by the State of West Bengal and decreed the suit in part for Rs. 7,632-11-3 with proportionate costs and against that decree the defendant has brought this appeal.

    3. The main controversy in this appeal centres round the question whether the plaintiff had acquired title to the trees or the money which represents the value of the trees under the agreement with the: Forest Department executed on the 17th of July 1941, it being admitted that the Forest Department validly determined the agreement on account of the plaintiff's failure to pay the instalments.

    4. The consequences which flow from the determination of the agreement are set out in clause 7 of the agreement, Exts. A and A (1), but I shall have to construe the agreement as a whole in order to determine the rights of the plaintiff. There can be no doubt that in order to succeed the plaintiff must establish that he had acquired title to the trees which were standing in the forest or which had been cut down by him even before paying any instalment of the price and only on depositing a sum of Rs. 970/- as security and paying a sum of Rs. 1,474-8-0 by way of adjustment.

    5. A curious feature of this case is that the plaintiff did not produce the agreement under which he claims title to the money and called for the agreement from the defendant. The defendant by its petition and affidavit dated the 23rd of November, 1950 stated that the agreement of the plaintiff for the purchase of lots A-19 and A-20 was missing but produced another agreement with the plaintiff in respect of lot No. A-34 executed on the 23rd of September, 1941 alleging that the terms of the agreement in respect of lots Nos. A-19 and A-20 were identical with the terms of the agreement in respect of lot No. A-34. The defendant also produced another agreement dated the 19th of September, 1941 executed by one Sarajit Kumar Majumdar. These two agreements have been marked as Exhibits A (1) and A respectively.

    6. The learned Subordinate Judge observes that there is nothing to show that the agreement entered into between the plaintiff and the defendant in respect of lots A-19 and A-20 was in the same form at Exts. A and A (1). In making this observation the learned Subordinate Judge evidently overlooked the evidence of plaintiff's witness No. 1, Sarajit Kumar Majumdar, who admits in his cross-examination that all agreements with the Forest Department for the purchase of timbers are entered into the Form Ext. A and further that every purchaser gets a duplicate copy of the agreement. The learned Subordinate Judge also overlooked the affidavit of Birendra Nath Roy, the Assistant Forest Officer of the Jalpaiguri Forest Division, where he definitely states that the terms of the agreement with the plaintiff in respect of lots Nos. A-19 and A-20 were identical with the terms of the agreements Exts. A and A (1). These agreements are in standard printed forms and it is reasonable to hold that the same form was used in respect of the sale of lots A-19 and A-20 as in the case of sale of lot No. A-34. In fact, Mr. Bakshi appearing for the plaintiff respondent did net contend that the terms of agreement with the plaintiff in respect of lots Nos. A-19 and A-20 were different from those in Exts. A and A (1). Before us the agreement proceeded on the footing that the terms of the agreement with the plaintiff in respect of lots Nos. A-19 and, A-20 were identical with those in Exts. A and A (1). I shall, therefore, proceed to consider the rights of the parties on an interpretation of Exts. A and A (1).

    7. Clause 1 of the agreement, Ext. A gives the purchaser three kinds of liberty and license during a certain period: (a) to enter upon a specified portion of the reserved forest, (b) to cut down trees marked with Government felling mark and convert them into logs, and (c) to remove such logs or timber outside the reserved forest. Under clause 3 a certain sum, usually 10 per cent, of the price, is to be paid by the purchaser in advance and retained by the forest officer as security for the due performance of the covenants and agreements by the purchaser and under clause 10 this security deposit is to be refunded to the purchaser after deducting the dues of the Government, if any, in the event of termination of the agreement by effluxion of time or due performance by the purchaser of all the terms and conditions of the agreement, provided the purchaser makes a due requisition for it within six months from the termination of the agreement or from the date when he satisfies the Forest Officer that he has complied with all the terms and conditions.

    8. Clause 2 of the agreement requires the purchaser to pay the entire price in certain instalments. Clause 4 provides amongst other things that the purchaser or his agent or servant shall not be entitled to remove any logs or timber before it has been marked with the Government sale-mark and the written permission has been given by the Forest Officer for its removal. Clause 5 provides that the Forest Officer has absolute discretion to refuse permission to remove any logs or timber if the value of the logs or timber already removed equals or exceeds the total of the instalments then paid by the purchaser.

    9. The most important clause for the purpose of the present appeal is clause 7, the material portion of which provides that in the event of the purchaser failing to pay any of the instalments specified in clause 2, the Government will have the right to determine the agreement and thereupon the following consequences will ensue (a) the purchaser shall forfeit all his rights to cut and remove any trees that shall not have been already cut and he shall also forfeit his security deposit, (b) the Government will have the right to attach and seize all the trees that may have been cut, logs or timber which may then be in the reserved forest, (c) any loss which may be sustained by the Government inconsequence of any re-sale shall be paid personally by the purchaser in so far as the same is not covered by the security deposit and the sale of the logs cut and prepared by the purchaser.

    10. It is admitted by the plaintiff in his cross-examination that he got a letter from the Forest Department determining the agreement for sale on account of his failure to pay the purchase money and the only question in this appeal is what is the result of such determination.

    11. Mr. Bakshi appearing for the plaintiff respondent argues that under clause 7 a distinction is intended to be made between standing trees and trees which have been felled by the purchaser and that while the purchaser loses his right to cut down standing trees on account of the determination of the agreement, his title to the trees cut down by him remains subject to the right of the Government to attach and seize them and to sell them to recover any loss which may be occasioned by a re-sale. It is also argued that since the Government did not, in the present case, suffer any loss by the re-sale, the money which was received by the Government by the sale of the logs cut down by the purchaser amounting to Rs. 7,018-3-3 as shown in the schedule of the plaint belongs to the plaintiff. On behalf of the State of West Bengal it is argued by the learned Additional Government Header that the agreement does not purport to deal with title to the trees standing or felled by the purchaser and that the title to the trees standing or felled remains with the Government till the trees felled by the purchaser are actually removed from the reserved forest. It is further contended that the agreement merely confers three kinds of licenses to the purchaser, namely, the license to enter the reserved forest, the license to cut down specified trees and the license to remove trees so cut. The learned Additional Government pleader also relies upon sub-sections 3 and 4 of section 4 of the Indian Sale of Goods Act. Subsection 3 provides that where under a contract of sale the property in the goods is transferred from the seller to the buyer the contract is called a sale, but where the transfer of the property in the goods is to take place at a future time or subject to some condition thereafter to be fulfilled, the contract is called an agreement to sell. Subsection 4 provides that an agreement to sell becomes a sale when the time elapses or the conditions are fulfilled subject to which the property in the goods is to be transferred. It is quite clear that the application of these two sub-sections depends upon a true interpretation of the agreement which, in the present case, is Ext. A. If upon a true interpretation of that agreement we hold that with regard to cut trees also the agreement was merely an agreement to sell as distinguished from a sale, the argument advanced by the learned Additional Government Pleader must be accepted. It, however, appears from the entry in the remarks column of schedule I annexed to Ext. A that ‘timber portions only are sold.’ The sale notice Ext. C also shows that what was offered for sale by the Forest officer by public auction was ‘Clear Felling, Dry and other timber lots’. From this document it is quite clear that title to trees cut by the purchaser passed to him under the agreement for sale read with schedule I and the sale notice, Ext. C. A contract in similar terms fell to be considered in the case of James, Jones and Sons. Limped v. Earl of Tankerville (1) [(1909) 2 Ch. Division, page 440], a decision which, though not cited at the Bar, was found out by my learned brother for which I am indebted to him. In construing the contract Parkar, J. observed, as follows at page 442:—

    “A contract for the sale of specific timber growing on the vendor's property, on the terms that such timber is cut and carried away by the purchaser, certainly confers on the purchaser a license to enter and cut the timber sold, and, at any rate as soon as the purchaser has severed the timber, the legal property in the severed trees vests in him.”

    12. Then again, at page 443 the following observation was made:

    “When once the purchaser has cut any part of the timber, the legal property in the timber so cut is certainly in the purchaser, and the license so far as that timber is concerned is irrevocable even at law.”

    13. So, upon a construction of the agreement, Ext. A and also upon the authority of the decision in the ease of James, Jones and Sons Limited (1) (supra) I am unable to accept the extreme argument advanced by the learned Additional Government Pleader before us and I must hold that the legal property in the trees which had been cut by the purchaser had vested in him. The question, however, still remains whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover the value of the trees cut by him after deducting the expenses incurred by the Government. In considering this question, I must proceed on the basis that the plaintiff had the residuary right in the trees cut by him subject to the right of the Government to attach and seize them under clause 7. Under section 83, subsection (1) of the Indian Forest Act the sum of Rs. 9,700/- for which the two lots were sold to the plaintiff was a first charge on the cut logs, and under section 83(2) the Forest Officer had a right to sell the cut logs and apply the, proceeds of the sale in discharging the amount. On the plaintiff's own showing the price fetched by the sale of cut logs is Rs. 7,018-3-3 minus Rs. 2,300/- spent by the Government for felling and removing the logs. To this will have to be added the sums of Rs. 970/- deposited by the plaintiff as security and the sum of Rs. 1,474|8/- paid by adjustment. The net price therefore is Rs. 7,162-11-3 which is less than the amount of Rs. 9,700 for which the Government had a first charge under section 83(1) of the Indian Forest Act. There is, therefore, no surplus which can be paid to the plaintiff under section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act. To meet this difficulty the plaintiff made a claim in his) plaint which has been repeated before Us by Mr. Bakshi to the effect that to determine the surplus under Section 83 (3) of the Indian Forest Act the price fetched by the second resale to Bose and Co. amounting to Rs. 10,170/- must he added to Rs. 7,018-3-3. This claim, in my opinion, is based upon a confusion of thought. The sum of Rs. 10,170/- represents the value of standing trees, the title to which never passed to the plaintiff and the plaintiff lost his right to cut them under clause 7 of the agreement. If the standing trees did not belong to the plaintiff, the plaintiff had no title to the sum of Rs. 10,170/- which represents their value and this sum cannot be taken into account to determine the surplus under section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act. The standing trees belonged to the Government which has realised their value by selling them to Bose and Co. and the plaintiff cannot claim any part of this amount either under the agreement or under any

    14. There is still another reason why the plaintiff cannot claim the sum of Rs. 7,018-3-3 which was fetched by the first resale of the logs cut by the plaintiff.

    15. Under the third sub-section of section 83 of the Indian Forest Act the amount fetched by the re-sale would stand forfeited to the Government, if the plaintiff did not claim it within two months from the date of resale. In the notice of demand Ext. 1 (e) dated the 1st of September, 1942, however the plaintiff made no claim to the sum of Rs. 7,018-3-3 but filed his claim to Rs. 10,170/- which was realised by the Government by the second resale to Bose and Co. I have already pointed out that his claim was misconceived. The result, therefore, is that by the notice of demand the plaintiff claimed an amount to which he was not entitled and omitted to claim the amount to which he had title. Mr. Bakshi has pointed out that the plaintiff claimed the amount in the notice under section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure which is dated the 9th of September, 1949. This claim, however, cannot be said to be a claim under Section 83 (3) of the Indian Forest Act which must be made within two months of the date of resale. According to the plaintiff's case, the resale which fetched the sum of Rs. 7,013-3-3 was held between July, 1942 when the logs were seized by the Government and the 13th of August, 1942 when the second resale to Bose and Co took place. A claim made more than 7 years after the resale is not a claim within the meaning of section 83(3) of the Indian Forest Act.

    16. For both the reasons given above, I have reached the conclusion that the claim made by the plaintiff in the present case is not maintainable in law.

    17. The result is that this appeal must be allowed, the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge set aside and the plaintiff's suit dismissed with costs throughout.

    Sen, J.:— I agree.

    A.K.D.G

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of West Bengal v. Narendra Nath Roy
    (Feb 12, 1957)