AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This rule supplanted section 259 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1882,
  • provision of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXI, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • section 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • provision of Order XXI, rule 31(1)
  • section 259 of the Code of 1882
  • Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code.4.
  • provision in Order XXI, rule 31,
  • Order XXI, rule 30 of the Code
  • Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code.
  • Order XX, rule 10 of the Code
  • Order XXI, rule 31.15.
  • court.10. Sub-rule 3
  • Order XXI, rule 31(1)
  • Order XXI, rule 11
  • Order XXI, rule 31
  • sub-rule 2
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This rule supplanted section 259 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1882,
  • provision of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XXI, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • section 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • provision of Order XXI, rule 31(1)
  • section 259 of the Code of 1882
  • Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code.4.
  • provision in Order XXI, rule 31,
  • Order XXI, rule 30 of the Code
  • Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code.
  • Order XX, rule 10 of the Code
  • Order XXI, rule 31.15.
  • court.10. Sub-rule 3
  • Order XXI, rule 31(1)
  • Order XXI, rule 11
  • Order XXI, rule 31
  • sub-rule 2
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 6th June 1951, the decree-holder obtained a decree for specific delivery of possession of certain machines and alternatively for payment of Rs. 54,794-14 annas if delivery was not possible. The judgment-debtor neither delivered the machines nor paid the amount. Consequently, on 3rd August 1951, the decree-holder filed an application for execution of the decree, praying for delivery of the machines and attachment of a decree held by the judgment-debtor. The court provisionally attached the judgment-debtor's decree and issued a notice to show cause. The judgment-debtor sought time and failed to furnish security as directed by the court. The court then ordered issuance of a writ of possession on 20th December 1951. The judgment-debtor filed an objection petition under section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure, contending that the decree-holder could not simultaneously seek execution by seizure and attachment. The objection was dismissed by the learned Subordinate Judge on 16th February 1952. The judgment-debtor appealed against this order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a decree-holder under a decree passed in terms of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure must first exhaust remedy for delivery of specific movable property before seeking execution by attachment of the judgment-debtor's property.
  2. Whether the execution court has the power to direct a conditional attachment of the judgment-debtor's property.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The decree-holder must first exhaust the remedy for delivery of the specific movable property before seeking attachment or arrest under Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • The execution court lacked power to direct a conditional attachment of the judgment-debtor's property.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balmukund Bisseswarlal v. Bengal Nagpur Railway Co. (I.L.R 55 Cal. 26) Order XX, rule 10 and Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure – Execution procedures for specific movable property and money recovery Distinguished on facts; did not support the appellant's contention that simultaneous execution by seizure and attachment was impermissible.
Shibaprosad Sing v. Proyag Kumari Debi (I.L.R 61 Cal. 711) Followed Balmukund Bisseswarlal case on execution procedures Confirmed that the cited cases do not prohibit simultaneous execution modes under Order XXI, rule 31.
Hargobind v. Hakim Sing [A.I.R (1926) Lahore 110] Order XXI, rule 30 – Execution by arrest or attachment or both Supported the proposition that the court cannot refuse committal to prison merely because the decree-holder has not first proceeded against the property.
Manavikraman v. Moyankutti (13 M.L.J 444) Section 259 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1882 – Execution of decree for specific movable property Not directly applicable due to differences in statutory language; however, cited for context on execution procedures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions of Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which allows execution of a decree for specific movable property by seizure and delivery, detention of the judgment-debtor in civil prison, attachment of his properties, or by both. The Court emphasized the plain language of the rule, particularly the phrase “or by both,” indicating that the decree-holder may pursue more than one mode of execution simultaneously.

The Court found no legal basis for compelling the decree-holder to exhaust the remedy of delivery of the specific movable property before seeking attachment or other modes. The Court also distinguished the precedents relied upon by the appellant, noting differences in facts and statutory provisions.

Regarding the power of the executing court to order conditional attachment, the Court referred to section 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which grants broad execution powers, including attachment and sale of property, arrest, appointment of receiver, or other methods as the relief requires. The Court held that conditional attachment was within the court’s discretion and was justified to prevent rendering the execution ineffective.

The Court further noted that the judgment-debtor had not challenged the conditional attachment order or the writ of possession by appropriate proceedings in a timely manner, thus waiving such objections.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed with costs.

The Court held that a decree-holder under Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure is entitled to simultaneously seek execution of a decree by seizure of specific movable property and attachment of the judgment-debtor's property under Order XXI, rule 31. The executing court possesses the power to direct conditional attachment as part of its execution powers under section 51 of the Code. The judgment-debtor’s objections on these grounds were not accepted.

This decision directly affects the parties by affirming the execution court’s order and dismissing the appeal. No new precedent beyond the interpretation of Order XXI, rule 31 and the scope of execution powers under section 51 was established.

    Uma Kanta Banerjee Judgment-Debtor, v. Messrs. Renwick & Co. Ltd. Decree-Holder,

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Das, J.:— This is an appeal by the judgment-debtor and is directed against an order of Mr. M.N Mukherji, learned Additional Subordinate Judge, Birbhum, dated the 16th of February, 1952.

    2. The facts may be shortly put as follows: On the 6th of June, 1951, the decree-holder respondent obtained a decree inter alia for specific delivery of possession of certain machines described in schedule D to the plaint. The decree further directed that if possession could not be had, the defendant would have to pay a sum of Rs. 54,794-14 annas as the value of the said properties. As the judgment-debtor did neither deliver the properties mentioned in schedule D nor pay the price thereof as mentioned in the decree, the decree-holder filed on the 3rd of August, 1951, an application for execution of the decree. In the petition for execution the decree-holder prayed for a variety of reliefs including a prayer for delivery of the said specific properties and for attachment of a decree obtained by the judgment-debtor. The execution petition was registered on the 3rd of August, 1951, and on the prayer of the decree-holder for attachment of a decree obtained by the judgment-debtor the Court directed the issue of a notice to the judgment-debtor to show cause why the said decree should not be attached. The Court further directed provisional attachment of the said decree. The judgment-debtor appeared in pursuance of the notice to show cause and prayed for time. Later on, on the 18th of September, 1951, the decree-holder made a prayer for a direction on the judgment-debtor to deliver the said properties. This matter came up for hearing before the Court on the 5th of November, 1951. The order of that date records that the Court heard the pleaders of the parties and directed the judgment-debtor to furnish security for the value of the moveables described in schedule D, by the 26th of November, 1951. It was further directed that failing compliance with this direction a writ for possession of the said moveables will issue. On the 5th of December, 1951, the pleaders of the parties were again heard and the Court directed stay of issue of a writ of possession. The judgment-debtor was allowed time to furnish security till the 20th of December, 1951. On the 20th December, 1951, as the judgment-debtor failed to furnish security, the Court directed the issue of a writ of possession. The judgment-debtor took no steps to have the order of the 20th December, 1951, directing issue of a writ of possession vacated by appropriate proceedings. The judgment-debtor, however, came up with a petition of objection under section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The relevant objection which has been pressed before us is that it was not open to the decree-holder to pray for simultaneous execution of the decree by the issue of a writ for seizure of the property and for attachment of the judgment-debtor's property. The petition of objection filed by the judgment-debtor was heard by the learned Subordinate Judge and was dismissed on the 16th of February, 1952. It is the propriety of this order which has been challenged in this appeal.

    3. Mr. Lala Hemanta Kumar who has appeared in support of the appeal has raised only two contentions. In the first place, he has contended that in a decree passed in accordance with the provision of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure the decree-holder must, in the first instance, exhaust his remedy for delivery of the specific moveable property before he can pray for relief by way of arrest of the person of the judgment-debtor or attachment of his property. In support of this contention the learned Advocate has relied on two decisions of this Court, namely, the case of Balmukund Bisseswarlal v. Bengal Nagpur Railway Co., (1) (I.L.R 55 Cal. 26) and the case of Shibaprosad Sing v. Proyag Kumari Debi (2) (I.L.R 61 Cal. 711). I shall deal with these cases before I refer to the relevant provisions of the Code bearing on this question. The decision in the first of the above two cases laid down that holders of a decree in terms of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code cannot execute the money part of it without having recourse to the procedure prescribed by Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code.

    4. I fail to see how the above decision assists the appellant in the present case. The proposition of law laid down in the above decision does not say in terms that the holder of a decree in terms of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure cannot have simultaneous execution of the decree by way of seizure of the property and attachment of the properties of the judgment-debtor. Moreover, the facts which came up for adjudication in the above case are entirely different. In that case a decree was passed for compensation for damages done to the properties of the decree-holder by the judgment-debtor which was assessed at Rs. 3,500. The decree then provided for delivery of certain moveables belonging to the decree-holder and went on to add that if the moveables were not delivered the judgment-debtor would have to pay a sum of Rs. 500. This decree was executed by the decree-holder on a statement made by him that the decree-holder had demanded delivery of the goods from the judg-debtor which the judgment-debtor had failed to comply and that as such the decree-holder prayed for recovery of Rs. 500. This Court came to a finding of fact that there was no demand by the decree-holder as alleged in the execution petition and in that view this Court held that the execution of the decree for recovery of Rs. 500 for failure to comply with the direction for delivery of the moveables could not be allowed.

    5. The case of Shibaprosad Sing (2) merely followed the decision in the above case of Balmukund Bissweswar-lal (1). In my opinion, therefore, the cases cited do not purport to lay down the proposition that the decree-holder cannot in a petition filed by him for execution of a decree under Order XXI, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure claim relief both for recovery of the moveables and for attachment of the judgment-debtor's properties.

    6. The answer to this question must be found in the terms of Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This rule supplanted section 259 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1882, with some modifications. I shall first interpret the terms of Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code. The relevant provision of Order XXI, rule 31(1) provides that where the decree is for recovery of any specific moveable, the decree may be executed, if practicable, by the seizure of the moveable and by the delivery thereof to the party to whom it has been adjudged or by the detention in the civil prison of the judgment-debtor or by attachment of his properties or by both.

    7. The sub-rule on its plain reading contemplates more than one of the modes of execution mentioned in the sub-rule. This is apparent from the use of the words “or by both”. The fact that three alternative modes of execution are stated in the sub-rule does not indicate that only one of the modes should be availed of by the decree-holder first and before that is exhausted the decree-holder is not entitled to apply for execution in the other modes referred to in the sub-rule. Such an interpretation would render unnecessary the use of the words “or by both” occurring in that sub-rule. In my view, the Legislature clearly intended that the decree-holder would have the option of pursuing his remedy by way of execution in any one of the three modes mentioned therein or in more than one of such modes.

    8. That this is the true view of Order XXI, rule 31(1) is supported by the two sub-rules 2 and 3 which follow.

    9. The first part of sub-rule 2 envisages a state of things where the attachment of the judgment-debtor's property is in force for three months and the judgment-debtor has not obeyed the decree for delivery of specific moveables. In such a case the Court may, on the application of the decree-holder, sell the attached property for recovery of the sum mentioned in the decree, or, if the decree is silent therein, for such compensation as may be assessed by the executing court.

    10. Sub-rule 3 provides for cessation of the attachment of the judgment-debtor's property in two cases, namely, (a) where the judgment-debtor has obeyed the decree and (b) where the attachment has remained in force for three months and the decree-holder has not applied for sale of the attached property or his application for such sale, if made, has been dismissed.

    11. These two sub-rules, in my opinion, contemplate a state of things where the attachment of the property is in force and there is also a prayer in the execution petition for specific) recovery of the moveable properties.

    12. In interpreting the above rule one must bear in mind the well-settled principle that where the law prescribes more than one mode of execution, the option to choose the particular mode by which the decree-holder will seek his remedy rests with him. The above power of the decree-holder is, however, subject to the exercise by the Court of a judicial descretion vested in it under Order XXI, rule 11 of the Code.

    13. It must also be remembered that the rules of procedure are mere handmaids of justice and that the Court should aid the successful litigant in obtaining the relief to which he has been declared to be entitled under the decree of the Court.

    14. I cannot accede to the submission made on behalf of the judgment-debtor that the decree-holder should be compelled to exhaust his remedy for delivery of the specific moveables before he can be permitted to seek his remedy by the other modes mentioned in Order XXI, rule 31.

    15. A similar contention in regard to the interpretation of Order XXI, rule 30 of the Code which provides for the execution of a decree for payment of money by arrest of the judgment-debtor or by attachment and sale of his property or by both, was negatived by a Bench of the Lahore High Court in the case of Hargobind v. Hakim Sing (3) [A.I.R (1926) Lahore 110]. At page 111, Shadi Lal, C.J, made the following observation:

    “It” (the Court) “has no authority to decline to make an order for committal to prison on the grounds that the decree-holder should proceed in the first instance against the property of the judgment-debtor.”

    16. In my opinion, the decree-holder is clearly entitled to apply for simultaneous execution of a decree passed in terms of Order XX, rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure by more than one of the modes of execution specified in Order XXI, rule 31 of the Code.

    17. I would also point out that under the Civil Procedure Code of 1882 a somewhat similar question arose for decision in the case of Manavikraman v. Moyankutti (4) (13 M.L.J 444). This case was cited with approval in the two Calcutta decisions to which I have already referred. The relevant observation in the judgment of the Madras Court is in these terms:

    “It is, therefore, only when after putting in force section 259 of the C.P.C it is found that it is impossible to obtain the property ordered to be delivered that the alternative amount in the decree comes into operation.”

    18. In that case the decree-holder was the appellant before the High Court. The appeal succeeded. The judgment of the Lower Appellate Court was reversed and that of the trial Court restored. What was the precise form of the order made by the trial court or by the Lower Appellate Court does not appear in the Report which is extremely meagre.

    19. It must be remembered that section 259 of the Code of 1882 was in slightly different terms. Section 259 of the Code provided inter alia for execution of a decree for recovery of specific moveables either by seizure of such moveables and delivery thereof to the decree-holder or by arrest or by attachment of the judgment-debtor's property or by both arrest and attachment of the judgment-debtor's property. The provision in Order XXI, rule 31, is somewhat dissimilar. The provision in Order XXI, rule 31, omits the qualifying words “arrest and attachment of the judgment-debtor's property” which followed the words “or by both” in section 259 of the Code of 1882. This decision, therefore, is of no assistance in the present case. The first contention raised on behalf of the appellant must, therefore, be overruled.

    20. I may observe that Mr. Mitter who has appeared for the decree-holder respondent pressed us not to decide this question on the ground that in the court below the judgment-debtor did not press this point. There is considerable force in this contention. As the objection was raised in the execution petition, we have preferred to dispose of the contention raised on behalf of the judgment-debtor also on its merits

    21. The second contention on behalf of the appellant was that the execution court had no power to direct a conditional attachment of the judgment-debtor's property. As I have already-pointed out, the order for conditional attachment was made long ago and thereafter in spite of an order by the executing court requiring the judgment-debtor to show cause, he has not chosen to do so. It also appears that there was an order for furnishing security.

    22. The judgment-debtor took time to comply with it but did not do so. There was an order for issue of a writ for the seizure of the moveables decreed. The judgment-debtor did not at that stage raise an objection that the conditional attachment should be withdrawn. No attempt was made to have the conditional order of attachment set aside by appropriate proceedings nor was the previous order of the Court directing issue of a writ of delivery of possession challenged by a direct appeal. This objection, therefore, would not be available to the judgment-debtor at this stage.

    23. But even if the objection could be raised in the appeal I am clearly of opinion that the executing court possessed the power to direct a conditional attachment in the facts of the present case. I have already held that it was competent for the decree-holder to pray for simultaneous execution by the issue of a writ for seizure of the specific moveables as also by a writ for attachment of the judgment-debtor's property,—in this case a decree obtained by the judgment-debtor against the Railway Administration.

    24. The powers of an executing court to enforce execution are set forth in section 51 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The section provides for execution in the following modes: (a) by specific delivery of property; (b) by attachment and sale or sale without attachment of the judgment-debtor's property; (c) by arrest and detention in prison; (d) by appointment of a receiver; or (e) in such; other manner as the nature of the relief granted may require. This power is subject to such conditions and limitations as may be prescribed. In the present case, as I have already indicated, there is no provision which bars the power of the Court to order conditional attachment. As the Court has in the facts of this case; the power to direct attachment, as an aid to the effective exercise of such power the Court is empowered to direct conditional attachment so that the exercise of the power of ordering attachment may not be rendered infructuous. In my opinion, the second contention has also no force.

    25. In the result, this appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

    Debabrata Mookerjee, J.:— I agree.

    P.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Uma Kanta Banerjee Judgment-Debtor, v. Messrs. Renwick & Co. Ltd. Decree-Holder,
    (Apr 30, 1953)