Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

During the accounting year ended March 31, 1959 (assessment year 1959-1960), the assessee held 4,58,071 shares in Pilani Investment Corporation Ltd. and was entitled to receive a dividend of Rs. 1,83,228.40 at the declared rate of 40 paise per share. The dividend was paid partly in cash (Rs. 358.40) and partly in kind, consisting of shares from two companies: 13,087 shares of Gwalior Rayon and Silk Manufacturing Co. Ltd. valued at Rs. 10 each, and 416 shares of Hind Cycles Ltd. valued at Rs. 125 each.

The Income-tax Officer valued these shares at market rates (Rs. 14.60 per share for Gwalior Rayon and Rs. 128.50 per share for Hind Cycles), resulting in a valuation of Rs. 2,44,526, which exceeded the value shown by the assessee (Rs. 1,82,870). The Officer added the difference of Rs. 61,656 to the assessee's income as dividend. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner upheld this addition, but the Appellate Tribunal allowed the assessee's appeal and deleted the addition.

The Revenue, aggrieved by the Tribunal's order, sought a reference to this Court under Section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act on the question of whether the Tribunal was correct in excluding the sum of Rs. 61,656 from dividend income.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sum of Rs. 61,656, representing the difference between the market value of shares received as dividend and the value declared by the distributing company, should be included as additional dividend income of the assessee.
  2. Whether dividend paid in kind (shares) can be valued at market rates exceeding the declared dividend rate for tax assessment purposes.
  3. Whether the definition of dividend under Section 2(6A) of the Income-tax Act requires that the distribution be of accumulated profits and that valuation must correspond to the value at which the distributing company declared the dividend.

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Kantilal Manilal v. Commissioner of Income-tax where the distribution of rights to purchase shares was held to be dividend, taxable at the market value of those rights.
  • Asserted that the market value of the shares received by the assessee should be considered for determining dividend income, not the value declared by the distributing company.

Assessee's Arguments

  • Contended that the dividend declared and paid by the distributing company was at a fixed rate and that the shares received as dividend should be valued at the rate declared by the company, not at fluctuating market rates.
  • Argued that the definition of dividend under Section 2(6A) requires that the distribution be of accumulated profits, and the value of shares in the hands of the distributing company was accepted at the declared value.
  • Maintained that the assessee could not be taxed on an amount exceeding the declared dividend, as it had no right to any amount beyond that.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kantilal Manilal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay (1961) 41 ITR 275; AIR 1961 SC 1038 Distribution of rights or property by a company to shareholders can constitute dividend taxable at market value; dividend includes distribution of property or rights having monetary value. The Court distinguished the present case from Kantilal Manilal by noting that in the cited case, the rights were transferred and sold at market value, whereas here the shares were retained by the assessee at the declared value. Thus, market valuation for dividend assessment was not applicable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the definition of dividend under Section 2(6A) of the Income-tax Act, emphasizing that a distribution must be of accumulated profits of the company to qualify as dividend. It noted that in the present case, the shares given as dividend were valued by the distributing company at a certain rate, and the Income-tax Authorities accepted this valuation for the shares held by the distributing company.

The Court reasoned that it is inconsistent for the department to accept one valuation in the hands of the distributing company and a higher valuation in the hands of the assessee. The assessee was entitled only to the dividend declared by the company and had no right to any amount beyond that declared rate.

Further, the Court considered the possibility of the shares having a higher market value than the declared value and rejected the notion that the assessee should be taxed on the higher market value, as it would be unfair and inconsistent to impose a higher tax liability when the dividend was declared at a fixed rate.

The Court distinguished the Supreme Court judgment in Kantilal Manilal by highlighting that the rights in that case were sold for a higher price, constituting actual benefit realized by the shareholders, whereas here the shares were retained by the assessee without any sale or transfer at a higher value.

Additionally, the Court noted the practical implications regarding the certificate of deduction of income-tax on dividend declared; taxing on a higher valuation would cause the assessee to lose the benefit of such certificate and suffer double disadvantage.

Holding and Implications

The Court answered the reference in the affirmative, holding that the Tribunal was correct in excluding the sum of Rs. 61,656 from the dividend income of the assessee.

The direct effect of this decision is that the assessee’s dividend income should be assessed at the declared rate of dividend by the distributing company, and not at an enhanced market valuation of shares received in kind. No broader precedent was set beyond affirming that dividend valuation for tax purposes must align with the declared value of the distributing company’s accumulated profits, barring fraud or collusion.

The assessee is entitled to costs.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Central India Industries

    Banerjee, J.:— This reference, under Section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act, has been made in circumstances hereinafter related.

    2. During the accounting year ended on March 31, 1959, (the assessment year being 1959-1960) the assessee held 4,58,071 shares in a company known as Pilani Investment Corporation Ltd. and became entitled to receive as dividend Rs. 1,83,228.40 P. at the rate of 40 P. per share, namely, the declared rate of dividend. This dividend was paid to the assessee in the form of,

    (a) 13,087 shares of Gwalior Rayon and Silk Manufacturing Co. Ltd., @ Rs. 10/- per share Rs. 1,30,870/- (b) 416 shares of Hind Cycles Ltd. @ Rs. 125 per share Rs. 52,000/- (c) In cash Rs. 358/40 Rs. 1,83,228/40

    3. The Income-tax Officer valued the shares of Gwalior Rayon and Silk Manufacturing Co. Ltd. and Hind Cycles Ltd., at the market rate, namely, at Rs. 14.60 p. per share for Gwalior Rayon and Silk Manufacturing Co. Ltd. and at Rs. 128.50, per share, for Hind Cycles Ltd. and came to the conclusion that the total shares, received by the assessee in the aforesaid two companies, were equivalent in terms of money to Rs. 2,44,526/-. Since the assessee had shown the value of the shares at Rs. 1,82,870/- only he added back the difference between Rs. 2,44,526/- and Rs. 1,82,870/- namely, Rs. 61,656/- to the assessee's income as dividend. On appeal by the assessee, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner dismissed the appeal with the observation that the money's worth of the shares received by the assessee represented the assessee's income and came under the definition of dividend as in Section 2(6A) of the Indian Income-tax Act.

    4. On the further appeal to the Appellate Tribunal, the assessee succeeded. The Tribunal observed:

    “A dividend, in its ordinary meaning, is a distribution of the share of profits or incomes of a company given to its shareholders. The definition thereto as laid down under Section 2(6A) of the Act, however, gives an extended meaning to that expression inasmuch as it includes in its connotation such other receipts also as are set out in the definition. One such is laid down under sub-clause (a) of the said Section 2(6A), which reads as follows:—

    “Any distribution by a company of accumulated profits whether capitalised or not, if such distribution entails the release by the company to its share-holders of all or any part of the assets of the company.”

    5. In order, therefore, to bring any distribution within the category of dividend it must be proved as a fact that what was distributed by a company was its accumulated profits. In the instant case, no such thing has been done. On the contrary, although the department is trying to value the share scrips, according to the market value when they have reached the hands of the assessee, in the hands of the distributing company, however, the said share scrips have been accepted to be of the value put upon them by the distributing company. The department, obviously, cannot adopt two standings of value in respect of the same item.

    6. The departmental Representative also placed reliance upon the decision of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of Kantilal Manilal, (1961) 41 ITR 275 : (AIR 1961 SC 1038). The relevant observation, upon which great stress has been laid by the Departmental Representative, reads as follows:—

    “If instead of selling the right in the market and then distributing the proceeds, the mills directly transferred the right, the benefit in the hands of the shareholders was still dividend.”

    7. In that case the right to purchase shares by the assessee was equated to the distribution of dividends inasmuch as the transferee-holders thereof actually transferred them for much higher value than the one for which they had got them. It was under such circumstances that the value of the right shares, as indicated by the sale price was taken to be the actual dividend received by the transferee. In the instant case, however, no such position arises. Here the assessee-company has received the dividend, partly;n the form of cash and partly in the form of share scrips, the latter being kept intact with the assessee itself. It cannot, therefore, be said that the assessee was selling, the shares to himself for a higher price, namely, the market value. One cannot trade and earn profit out of one's self. We, therefore, hold that the value of the share scrips as adopted at the annual general meeting of the shareholders of the distributing company must be taken to be the value of the said share scrips when they reached the hands of the assessee-company. The question of a further valuation cannot arise.”

    8. In the view taken the Tribunal ordered deletion of the sum of Rs. 61,656/- from assessment.

    9. Aggrieved by the order of Tribunal, the Revenue asked for and obtained a reference to this Court on the following point:

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal rightly excluded the sum of Rs. 61,656 from being assessed as an extra dividend income of the assessee?”

    10. In contending for a negative answer to the question, the learned Counsel for the Revenue relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Kantilal Manilal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay (1961) 41 ITR 275 : (AIR 1961 SC 1038). What happened in that case was that the Bank of India, which had passed a resolution for increasing its share capital, offered new shares of Rs. 50 each to its existing shareholders in the proportion of one new share for every three shares held by them, at a premium of Rs. 50. The Navjivan Mills Ltd., which held 5,000 shares in the Bank and which became entitled to 1,666 new shares, purchased 66 shares in the Bank and pursuant to a resolution of its board of directors, distributed the right to purchase the remaining 1,600 shares among its shareholders in the proportion of two shares of the Bank for each share held by them in the Mills, The appellants who held 570 shares in the Mills and became entitled to purchase 1,140 new shares of the Bank, agreed to the allotment of those shares and ultimately transferred them to a private company. The assessment of the appellants was reopened under S. 34(1)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act, on the footing that release by the Mills of shares of the Bank of India amounted to a distribution of dividend and the value of the right released in favour of the shareholders was taxable. The reassessment made on the above footing was unsuccessfully disputed by the assessee and the matter was ultimately taken before the Supreme Court. In delivering the judgment of the Supreme Court, Shah, J., upheld the stand taken by the Revenue, namely, what the appellant got was dividend liable to tax, with the following observation:—

    “It was open to the mills to sell the right to the shares of the Bank of India in the market, and to distribute the proceeds among the shareholders. Such a distribution would undoubtedly have been distribution of dividend. If instead of selling the right in the market and then distributing the proceeds, the mills directly transferred the right, the benefit in the hands of the shareholders was still dividend.”

    11. The Supreme Court further observed:—

    “Dividend need not be distributed in money; it may be distributed by delivery of property or right having monetary value. The resolution, it is true, did not purport to distribute the right amongst the shareholders as dividend. It did not also take the form of a resolution for distribution of dividend; it took the form of distribution of a right which had a monetary value. But by the form of the resolution sanctioning the distribution, the true character of the resolution could not be altered. We are, therefore, of the view that the High Court was right in holding that the distribution of the right to apply for and obtain two shares of the Bank of India (at half their market value) for each share held by the shareholders of the mills amounted to distribution of dividend.”

    12. In this case, the amount received by the assessee is admittedly dividend. There is also no dispute that dividend may be paid in cash or in kind. Thus, the Supreme Court decision does not take us further than what is admitted in this case.

    13. The question for our consideration is when dividend is paid in the form of property, as in this case in the form of Shares of a limited company, can such property be valued at the market rate and the quantum of dividend determined at a rate higher than the rate at which the dividend, was declared. In other words, can it be said what was received by the assessee was not dividend at the declared rate but something more?

    14. Now, the material portion of Section 2(6A) of the Indian Income-tax Act, defining dividend, reads:

    “Dividend indudes:

    (a) any distribution by a company of accumulated profits, whether capitalised or not, if such distribution entails the release by the company to its share-holders of all or any part of the assets of the company.”

    15. In order, therefore, to bring any distribution within the category of dividend, it must appear what was distributed by the company was its accumulated profit. It does not appear that in the hands of Pilani Investment Corporation Ltd., the accumulated profit, in the shape of shares of Gwalior Rayon and Silk Manufacturing Co. Ltd. and Hind Cycles Ltd., was taken by the Income-tax Authorities at a figure higher than figure put upon them by the Corporation. On the contrary, the Tribunal found, the share scrips in the hands of the Corporation were accepted to be of the value put upon them by the Corporation. If the accumulation be of a particular value, it cannot assume a different value on distribution.

    16. Then again, the assessee was entitled to dividend at the rate declared by Pilani Investment Corporation Ltd. It could not aspire for more and had no right to anything more. It may be that what it got was more favourable than cash payment. But that is fortuitous.

    17. Let us examine it from another point of view. If the shares, received by the assessee, as dividend in kind, happened to be of lesser market value than what was put on them by the dividend declaring company and if the assessee received the same in full satisfaction of the dividend declared, could it take the stand that it received less than the dividend declared? The answer must be in the negative because it is always open to everybody to receive a smaller payment in satisfaction of larger debt. If this be the legal position it does not stand to reason why by receiving dividend in kind, at the price put thereon by the distributing company, an assessee should stand the risk of having received more, because the price put by the distributing company was found to be lower than the market rate. If there be collusion or attempt to defraud the revenue in such a matter be involved, then different consideration may apply. But where, as in this case, the accumulated profits, In the hands of the distributing company, namely, the value of shares, have been evaluated at the same figure by the Income-tax Authorities, as done by the distributing company while declaring dividend, there is no justification for valuing the distribution at a different figure.

    18. Further, the assessee in entitled to a certificate of deduction of income-tax on the dividend declared. If the amount of dividend declared be subsequently taken to be more than what was declared, that more remains uncovered by the certificate and the assessee doubly loses, namely, his income is enhanced and he does not get the coverage of the certificate.

    19. For all these reasons, we are of the opinion, that in the facts and circumstances of the instant case, the question should be answered to the affirmative The asessee is entitled to costs.

    K.L Roy, J.:— I agree.

    RSK/D.V.C

    20. Reference answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Central India Industries
    (Nov 15, 1967)