Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Anil K. Narendran, J. (W.P.(C) No. 3206 of 2014 & TDB Report No. 13 of 2015)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a devotee of "Sree Vallabha", chief deity of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla (under the Travancore Devaswom Board), filed Writ Petition No. 3206 of 2014 seeking a writ of mandamus directing respondents 1 to 4 to conduct a public auction on an individual basis for the right to open/operate temporary stalls/shops on temple property, with adequate publicity, after sketching, identifying and estimating the available property, and within such time as the Court deemed fit.

By order dated 26.11.2014 the Court referred the matter to the Honourable Ombudsman, who conducted an enquiry and filed TDB Report No. 13 of 2015. The Commissioner of the Travancore Devaswom Board had also filed a report dated 5.3.2014 pursuant to an earlier order.

The record contains allegations by the petitioner of irregularities in prior public auctions for temporary stalls/shops during festival seasons. The Travancore Devaswom Board's Commissioner and the Ombudsman reported various irregularities, including historical practice of awarding the auction to a single nominee who then sub-let plots, division of land into plots for auction, under-participation at the auction, existence of unauthorised shops, and instances of re-auctioning by licensees to third parties. The Ombudsman suggested safeguards including police assistance and presence of the Chief Vigilance Officer at auctions.

By order dated 9.2.2015 the Court prescribed detailed conditions (Clauses (i)–(xiii)) to be incorporated in the tender notification to ensure fair and transparent auctions. Auctions conducted pursuant to that order on 16.2.2015 and 18.2.2015 resulted in total auction receipts of Rs. 3,95,915/-. W.P.(C) No. 3206 of 2014 and TDB Report No. 13 of 2015 were ultimately disposed of by the Court with directions described below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents should be directed to conduct public auction of the right to open/operate temporary stalls/shops on Sree Vallabha Maha Temple property on an individual basis with adequate publicity and prior identification/sketching of plots.
  2. Whether the irregularities disclosed by the Commissioner and the Ombudsman in earlier auctions justified judicial direction and specific conditions to ensure a fair and transparent auction process.
  3. Whether the procedural safeguards and conditions imposed for the Sree Vallabha Maha Temple auction should be continued in future and treated as general guidelines for all temples under the Travancore Devaswom Board, including reservation of stalls for charitable institutions publishing religious books.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner alleged serious irregularities in the conduct of public auctions for temporary stalls/shops during prior festival seasons and sought a writ of mandamus to direct properly conducted public auctions with adequate publicity and plot identification.
  • Counsel for the petitioner argued that auction proceeds for 2012, 2013 and 2014 were Rs. 67,000/-, Rs. 75,700/- and Rs. 1,79,375/- respectively, whereas the auction conducted pursuant to the Court's intervention for the current season fetched Rs. 3,92,950/-. The petitioner contended that the auctions of 16.2.2015 and 18.2.2015 were without adequate publicity and that adequate publicity would have produced still higher receipts.
  • The petitioner alleged deliberate attempts by Devaswom officials and the Temple Advisory Committee to prevent bids rising, to justify earlier monopoly-like practices.

Respondents' / Travancore Devaswom Board / Temple Advisory Committee Arguments

  • The learned Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board and the learned counsel for the Temple Advisory Committee challenged the bonafides of the petitioner in seeking relief, asserting that the petitioner had previously started the practice of taking the temple premises in auction through his nominee and then letting out portions for substantial amounts.
  • The Devaswom Board's counsel opposed the allegation that officials attempted to suppress auction receipts, and acknowledged the increase in receipts under the Court-supervised procedure; the Board proposed that if the Court directed continuation of the procedure, the Board should be permitted to reserve at least 10 (later reduced to five by the Court) stalls free of rent for charitable institutions publishing religious books.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from factual findings in the Commissioner’s report and the Ombudsman’s enquiry report. The key steps in the Court's reasoning were:

  1. The Ombudsman and the Commissioner had disclosed various irregularities in prior auctions: historical practice of awarding the auction to one person (who then sub-let plots), the presence of unauthorised shops beyond the number of plots auctioned, re-auctioning/sub-letting by licensees, and possible prevention of intending bidders by vested interests.
  2. To neutralise those irregularities and ensure fairness and transparency, the Court formulated detailed, specific conditions (Clauses (i)–(xiii) of the order dated 9.2.2015) to be incorporated into the tender notification. These conditions covered plot identification (limited to 49 plots as per sketch), upset prices, identity and EMD requirements, restriction on bidding for multiple plots (with a limited exception on a second day), prohibition on sub-letting, restriction on multiple stalls per plot, regulation of locations to sketches, exclusion of Temple Advisory Committee members/their relatives and Board employees/their relatives from participation, requirement of the Chief Vigilance Officer’s presence and police assistance, and an obligation not to interfere with religious rites.
  3. The Court next observed the results of auctions held pursuant to those conditions (16.2.2015 and 18.2.2015): total receipts rose substantially (to Rs. 3,95,915/- or Rs. 3,92,950/- as described in different places in the judgment). The increase (noted as Rs. 2,13,575/- compared to the previous year) was undisputed by counsel for the Board and the Temple Advisory Committee.
  4. The Court concluded that confining auctions to identified plots and enforcing the prescribed conditions would allow the Board to regulate stall placement so as to minimise inconvenience to devotees while securing better revenue and ensuring transparency and fairness.
  5. On that basis the Court decided that future auctions during festival seasons should be conducted strictly according to Clauses (i)–(xiii). The Court also accepted the Board’s interest in reserving certain stalls for charitable institutions and modified it to permit the Board to reserve at least five stalls (instead of the Board's proposed ten) of reasonable size to be allotted free of rent to non-profit institutions publishing religious books, on a first-come-first-served basis.
  6. The Court further directed specific publication and administrative steps: tender notifications incorporating the conditions should be published at least one month prior to auction on the Devaswom office notice board and temple premises, and in one or two vernacular dailies of wide local circulation; the Chief Vigilance Officer and subordinates were to conduct periodic visits during the festival season to ensure compliance and prevent unauthorised stalls.
  7. Finally, the Court extended the approach as a general guideline: it directed the Travancore Devaswom Board to incorporate the conditions (with necessary modifications) in all tender notifications for public auctions of temporary stalls/shops for temples under the Board, and allowed the Board to reserve up to five stalls for charitable institutions in all temple premises during festival seasons.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: W.P.(C) No. 3206 of 2014 and TDB Report No. 13 of 2015 are disposed of as above.

Core Rulings and Direct Orders:

  • The Court ordered that public auctions of the right to open temporary stalls/shops at Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla, during festival seasons must be conducted strictly in terms of Clauses (i)–(xiii) set out in its order dated 9.2.2015.
  • The Court permitted the Travancore Devaswom Board to reserve at least five stalls of reasonable size (per temple during festival seasons) to be allotted free of rent on a first-come-first-served basis to charitable institutions with non-profit motive engaged in publication of religious books and publications.
  • The Court required tender notifications to be published at least one month in advance on the Devaswom office notice board and temple premises, and in one or two vernacular dailies of wide local circulation; and required the Chief Vigilance Officer and subordinates to conduct periodic visits to ensure compliance and the absence of unauthorised stalls.
  • The Court directed that the above conditions should be incorporated, with necessary modifications, into tender notifications for public auctions of temporary stalls/shops in all temples under the Travancore Devaswom Board as a general guideline, and allowed reservation of up to five stalls in such temples for charitable institutions publishing religious books.

Practical Consequences:

  • Direct effect on parties: the Travancore Devaswom Board must implement the detailed auction conditions, publish notices as directed, and oversee compliance through the Chief Vigilance Officer; the Temple Advisory Committee and prospective bidders must observe the prohibitions and procedural requirements.
  • The order produced an immediate and undisputed increase in auction receipts for the relevant festival season (as recorded in the opinion), supporting the Court's view that the prescribed measures improve revenue and transparency.
  • No broader binding precedent was announced beyond the Court's directions and the instruction to treat the conditions as general guidelines for the Board's temples; the opinion does not cite or establish any new legal principle of general jurisprudential import beyond these administrative directions.

Disposition: W.P.(C) No. 3206 of 2014 and TDB Report No. 13 of 2015 disposed of in accordance with the directions and conditions summarized above.

    Sreekumar. V. v. Travancore Devaswom Board

    JUDGMENT

    Anil K. Narendran, J.

    The petitioner in W.P(C) No. 3206 of 2014 is a devotee of ‘Sree Vallabha’, the chief deity of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla, under the Travancore Devaswom Board. The Writ Petition has been filed seeking a writ of mandamus commanding respondents 1 to 4 to conduct public auction of the right to open/operate temporary stalls/shops in the property belonging to Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla, on individual basis to the prospective stall/shop operators, with adequate publicity in vernacular dailies, after sketching, identifying and estimating the available property, within such time as this Court may deem fit and proper in the interests of justice and for other consequential reliefs.

    2. By order dated 26.11.2014, this Court referred the above Writ Petition to the Honourable Ombudsman for his report. After conducting a detailed enquiry, the Honourable Ombudsman has filed TDB Report No. 13 of 2015.

    3. In the Writ Petition the petitioner has made serious allegations in the conduct of the public auction to sell the right to run temporary stalls/shops on the Devaswom property of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla, during the annual festival season. The learned Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board and also the learned counsel for the Temple Advisory Committee have raised serious objections about the bonafides of the petitioner in approaching this Court seeking such a relief. The learned counsel for the Temple Advisory Committee would contend that, it was the petitioner who started the practice of taking in auction the temple premises through his nominee, who used to let out portions of such premises to various intending stall/shop operators after collecting huge amounts. At the same time, the report dated 5.3.2014 filed by the Commissioner of the Travancore Devaswom Board, pursuant to the order passed by this Court dated 28.2.2014, prima facie discloses irregularities in the sale by public auction of the right to run temporary stalls/shops on the Devaswom property of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla, conducted during the previous festival season.

    4. The report filed by the Honourable Ombudsman also discloses various irregularities in the public auction conducted during the previous festival season. The Honourable Ombudsman has found that the practice followed in the temple for a long time was that the auction will be settled in favour of one person for and on behalf of the Temple Advisory Committee for a total amount ranging between 70,000/- to 80,000/- and such person or committee used to let out portions of such premises to various intending stall/shop operators after collecting huge amounts. The Devaswom Commissioner has in his report dated 5.3.2014 stated that, during the previous festival season the tender notice was published after dividing the land put up for auction into 30 plots, in order to prevent revenue loss by awarding the licence to a single person. In the auction conducted on 25.2.2014 nine persons participated and the revenue has increased to 1,03,675/-. It is stated that though more people had assembled near the auction hall only nine persons participated in the auction and that most of the plots were re-auctioned by the actual licensees to third parties after receiving substantially high amounts. Further, it is stated that as against 30 plots auctioned by the Board, 36 shops were found on the Devaswom property and the Commissioner had directed the Devaswom officers to remove the unauthorised shops or to negotiate with the unauthorised vendors and regularise their occupation, without causing any loss to the Devaswom. The Honourable Ombudsman has in his report suggested, among other things, that the practice of preventing the intending bidders by certain persons with vested interests should be prevented with the help of the Police and the Chief Vigilance Officer of the Devaswom may be directed to be present at the time of auction.

    5. By order dated 9.2.2015, this Court directed the Travancore Devaswom Board to incorporate the conditions enumerated in Clause Nos. (i) to (xiii) in Para.6 of that order in the tender notification in order to ensure a fair and transparent tender process in the public auction of the right to open temporary stalls/shops on the Devaswom property of Sreevallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla, during the current festival season. Clauses (i) to (xiii) in Para.6 of order dated 9.2.2015 read thus:

    “(i) The auction shall be confined to 49 plots identified in the site sketch prepared by the Assistant Engineer, Travancore Devaswom Board, Thiruvalla and produced before this Court;

    (ii) The upset price for the plots shall be as mentioned in the statement prepared by the Assistant Engineer, Travancore Devaswom Board, Thiruvalla and produced before this Court;

    (iii) The auction shall be conducted in the presence of the Chief Vigilance Officer of the Board, who shall ensure that the intending bidders are not prevented in any manner by persons with vested interests. The Chief Vigilance Officer shall also seek Police assistance for the smooth conduct of the auction, if found necessary;

    (iv) At the time of auction, the bidders shall carry their voters identity card issued by the Election Commission of India or any other proof of identity recognised by the Government and shall also furnish a self attested photostat copy of the identity card to the Officer conducting the auction.

    (v) The intending bidders shall produce the requisite EMD by way of Demand Draft drawn in their name.

    (vi) No bidder shall be permitted to bid for more than one plot. If there are vacant plots after the auction, such plots shall be put to auction on the very next day at the very same time. In the absence of sufficient number of bidders on the second day, more than one plot can be allotted to a single bidder;

    (vii) No licensee shall be permitted to put up more than one stall/shop on a single plot;

    (viii) No person shall be permitted to conduct any stall/shop in an area other than that shown in the sketch prepared by the Assistant Engineer, Travancore Devaswom Board, Thiruvalla;

    (ix) No licensee shall have the right to re-auction/sub-let the plot to a third party and if any such instance comes to the notice of the Board, the Board shall be entitled to cancel such license forthwith and evict the licensee from the plot, by forfeiting the entire license fee. But, the Board shall give the licensee a reasonable time to remove his articles;

    (x) The licensee should personally conduct the business in the stall/shop put up on the plot taken in auction and he should also carry his proof of identity with him while conducting such business;

    (xi) No licensee shall be permitted to occupy the plot allotted to him beyond the period of the license. But, it would be open to the Board to give a grace period up to one week, after collecting proportionate license fee, to enable the licensee to remove his articles from the plot or for selling the balance articles;

    (xii) No member of the Temple Advisory Committee or their near relations, or the employees of the Travancore Devaswom Board or their near relations shall be entitled to participate in the auction either personally or as a nominee of another;

    (xiii) No bidder shall interfere with the conduct of any religious rites, rituals, customs, practises and other ceremonies of the temple. Bidders shall be bound to follow the temple manners and instructions issued by the Board from time to time, failing which he will be summarily evicted after forfeiting the entire license fee.”

    6. Pursuant to our order dated 9.2.2015, the public auction of the right to open temporary stalls/shops on the Devaswom property of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple Thiruvalla, during the current festival was conducted on 16.2.2015 and 18.2.2015 respectively and the stalls/shops were auctioned for a total amount of 3,95,915/-.

    7. We heard the arguments of the learned counsel for the petitioner, the learned Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board, the learned counsel for the Temple Advisory Committee and also the Amicus Curiae for the Honourable Ombudsman.

    8. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that in the auction conducted for the year 2012, 2013 and 2014, the total amount received by the Travancore Devaswom Board in the sale by public auction of the right to run temporary stalls/shops on Devaswom property of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple, Thiruvalla was 67,000/-, 75,700/- and 1,79,375/- respectively. On the other hand, in the public auction conducted for the current festival season, pursuant to the order passed by this Court on 28.12.2014, the Travancore Devaswom Board received a total amount of 3,92,950/-. The learned counsel for the petitioner would contend that the auction conducted on 16.2.2015 and 18.2.2015 was without adequate publicity and had those auctions been conducted with adequate publicity, the total amount would have gone much higher.

    9. The learned counsel for the petitioner would further contend that there was a deliberate attempt on the part of the Devaswom officials and the Temple Advisory Committee to see that the auction amount would not go higher so as to see that their earlier stand for monopoly auction would be justified. The said allegation made on behalf of the petitioner was strongly opposed by the learned Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board and the learned counsel for the Temple Advisory Committee. The learned counsel for the Temple Advisory Committee would also point out that it was the petitioner who started the practice of taking in auction the temple premises through his nominee, who used to let out portions of such premises to various intending stall/shop operators after collecting huge amounts from them.

    10. We notice that, in the public auction conducted pursuant to the order dated 9.2.2015, there is an increase of income to the tune of 2,13,575/- compared to the income received by the Travancore Devaswom Board for the previous year. The said fact is not disputed either by the Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board or by the learned counsel appearing for the Temple Advisory Committee. The learned Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board would also submit that, if this Court is directing the Board to continue the procedure contemplated in order dated 9.2.2015 for the coming years, adequate provision may be made permitting the Board to allot free of rent at least 10 shops/stalls of reasonable size to charitable institutions with non-profit motive who are in the field of publication of religious books and publications.

    11. We notice that in the public auction conducted pursuant to order dated 9.2.2015, there is a considerable increase in the income fetched by auctioning the right to open temporary stalls/shops on the Devaswom property during the festival season. Further, since the auction is confined to the plots identified in the sketch prepared by the Assistant Engineer concerned, the putting up of such shops can be regulated in such a manner that only least inconvenience is caused to the devotees coming to the temple premises during the festival season. Therefore, we are of the considered view that, in the coming years as well, public auction of the right to open temporary stalls/shops at the Devaswom property of Sree Vallabha Maha Temple Thiruvalla, during festival seasons, should be conducted strictly in terms of Clauses (i) to (xiii) referred to above. We also make it clear that it would be open to the Travancore Devaswom Board to reserve at least five stalls of reasonable size for allotment during festival seasons, to charitable institutions with non-profit motive who are in the field of publication of religious books and publications, free of rent, for selling such books and publications. The allotment of stalls, if any, to such institutions shall be on first come first served basis.

    12. The tender notification incorporating the above conditions along with the usual terms and conditions of the tender notifications issued by the Travancore Devaswom Board shall be published at least one month prior to the date of auction in the notice board of the Devaswom office and also in the temple premises. The Travancore Devaswom Board shall also publish a notification regarding the public auction in one or two vernacular dailies having vide circulation in the locality. The Chief Vigilance Officer of the Travancore Devaswom Board and his subordinates shall conduct periodic visits during the festival season to ensure that there is no violation of any of the tender conditions by the licensees and that no unauthorised stalls/shops are put up in the temple premises.

    13. We also deem it appropriate to direct the Travancore Devaswom Board to incorporate the above conditions, with necessary modifications in all tender notifications issued by the Board to conduct public auction of the right to open temporary stalls/shops on the Devaswom property of all the temples under the Devaswom, treating this as a general guidelines. It would also be open to the Travancore Devaswom Board to reserve upto five stalls of reasonable size in all such temple premises, during festival seasons, for allotment to charitable institutions with non-profit motive, who are in the field of publication of religious books and publications, free of rent, for selling such books and publications. The allotment of stalls, if any, to such institutions shall be on first come first served basis.

    W.P (C) No. 3206 of 2014 and TDB Report No. 13 of 2015 are disposed of as above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sreekumar. V. v. Travancore Devaswom Board
    (Mar 19, 2015)