Petitioner is the defacto complainant in C.C
No.1070/2007 of the Court of Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Ernakulam. His grievance is that by the impugned order
dated 06.01.2011, the learned Magistrate allowed CMP
No.73/2011 in C.C No.1070/2007, allowing the petition to re-
open the evidence under Section 311 of Cr.P.C, a petition
moved for and on behalf of the accused by a new counsel.
2. I have heard Shri.K.Ananad, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner, learned Public Prosecutor and
also perused the order impugned.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner emphatically
submitted that, the learned Magistrate erroneously allowed
the highly belated petition filed under Section 311 of Cr.P.C,
without properly understanding the oblique motive of
accused to protract the matter, inspite of the order dated
09.04.2009, in Crl. Appeal No. 688/2009 of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court. According to the learned counsel, the
change of counsel and filing petition under Section 311 for
Crl. Rev.Petn. No. 701 of 2011
re-opening of evidence are only dilatory tactics adopted by
the accused to protract the matter.
4. Learned Public Prosecutor on instruction submitted
that PW1, the defacto complainant was examined on
05.12.2007 and PW5 examined on 25.02.2008. The 313
questioning of the accused was conducted on 03.03.2008.
Allegation in the above case is that, the accused has
committed offence punishable under Section 420 of I.P.C
connected with a diamond transaction.
5. The offence alleged, according to me is a serious
one. It is true that, the prosecution evidence is over and the
accused was questioned under Section 313 of Cr.P.C on
03.03.2008 and the case was posted for hearing. It is at this
stage, the new counsel for the accused moved CMP
No.73/2011 under Section 311 of Cr.P.C. The learned
Magistrate, who is more familiar with the facts and
circumstances involved in the case and who are aware of
the nature of evidence so far adduced by the prosecution
and applying his judicial mind came into a conclusion that,
the petition preferred on behalf of the accused under Section
311 of Cr.P.C is to be allowed. Even though there is some
Crl. Rev.Petn. No. 701 of 2011
delay in filing the petition, considering the fact that the
learned Magistrate, after having satisfied the requirement
for re-opening of the evidence under Section 311 allowed
the prayer, I am of the view that, this court while exercising
the revisional jurisdiction may not be justified, interfering
with the order of the learned Magistrate, denying the
opportunity to the accused to adduce evidence in support of
his plea for an acquittal. Court must always open its door to
let in evidence, whenever the situation demand, either from
the side of the prosecution or from the side of the defence,
so as to come into a correct finding and thereby to dispense
the criminal justice.
In the above circumstances, I find no reason to interfere
with the order of the learned Magistrate and as such, this
revision petition is devoid of any merit and accordingly the
same is dismissed.
Sd/-
(V.K.MOHANAN)
JUDGE
ss/.
//True Copy//
P.A to Judge