Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 33(1) and 37(2) of the Kerala Stamp Act.4.
  • Article of 1 Schedule to the Kerala Stamp Act
  • Article 15 or 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act.
  • REGISTRATION ACT 1908
  • Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act,
  • Article 15 of the Kerala Stamp Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 33(1) and 37(2) of the Kerala Stamp Act.4.
  • Article of 1 Schedule to the Kerala Stamp Act
  • Article 15 or 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act.
  • REGISTRATION ACT 1908
  • Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act,
  • Article 15 of the Kerala Stamp Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, who acted both as Chairman and Managing Director of a private limited company and in his individual capacity, had earlier sold parcels of land to another private limited company of which the 3rd respondent is Managing Director. Those sale deeds were executed and registered on 31.08.2007 (marked Exts.R3(a) and R3(b)). Later, the appellant sought registration of two documents styled as cancellation deeds (marked Exts.P1 and P2).

When the cancellation deeds were presented for registration, the 2nd respondent impounded them and referred them to the District Registrar, Kozhikode under Sections 33(1) and 37(2) of the Kerala Stamp Act. The District Registrar (1st respondent) issued notices stating that stamp duty was payable under Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act at 10% of the consideration shown in the earlier sale deeds and demanded a penalty at 10 times the value of the stamp duty. The appellant objected to this liability.

On 03.03.2008 the District Registrar passed orders (Exts.P7 and P8) holding that stamp duty was payable under Article 21 and imposing a penalty of Rs. 500 each, and threatened recovery steps if remittances were not made. The appellant challenged these orders by filing W.P. (C) No. 9342 of 2008 before the High Court, which dismissed the writ petition by judgment dated 14.03.2011 (the judgment under appeal). The appellant filed the present writ appeal against that dismissal.

During pendency of the writ petition, pursuant to an interim direction, the challenged cancellation deeds were registered. The High Court judge, while dismissing the writ petition, directed the Sub Registrar, Kozhikode to cancel/strike off/revoke the cancellation deeds from the registers and directed that such registered cancellation deeds should not be shown as encumbrances in future encumbrance certificates.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a concluded sale can be unilaterally cancelled by the vendor.
  2. Whether a document purporting to cancel a duly executed and registered sale deed must, as a matter of course, be registered by the registering authorities without enquiry into its legality or validity.
  3. If such a cancellation deed is registrable, which Article of the Schedule to the Kerala Stamp Act applies: Article 21 (as held by respondents) or Article 15 (as contended by the appellant)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant (through counsel) relied upon the Full Bench decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Yanala Malleshwari v. Ananthula Sayamma [2006 (6) ALT 523], contending that a deed purporting to be a unilateral cancellation executed by the vendor is nevertheless bound to be registered when presented and that the registering authority has no jurisdiction to enquire into the legality or validity of such a document.
  • The appellant further argued in this appeal that the Supreme Court's subsequent decision (Civil Appeal No. 317 of 2007 dated 13.07.2010) which declared the Andhra Pradesh Full Bench decision no longer good law did not consider rules under the Registration Act applicable in Kerala (notably Rule 67). Therefore, the appellant contended the Supreme Court decision was not authoritative on the question whether registering officers in Kerala have discretion to enquire into legal validity of documents presented for registration.
  • The appellant also submitted that, independent of the legal position on unilateral cancellation deeds, he should have the right to seek a declaration in a civil suit that the past sale transactions (Exts.R3(a) and R3(b)) are illegal and not binding, and that this right should be preserved.

Respondents' Position

  • The 2nd respondent impounded the cancellation deeds and referred them to the District Registrar under provisions of the Kerala Stamp Act; the District Registrar issued notices assessing stamp duty under Article 21 and demanding a penalty.
  • The District Registrar's order held that stamp duty at 10% under Article 21 may be payable, but also took the view that a unilateral cancellation of a duly executed and registered sale deed is not registrable merely by payment of stamp duty; the registering authorities are not obliged to register documents without regard to their legal validity.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Noble John v. State of Kerala [ILR 2010 (3) Kerala 979] Support for the proposition that registering authorities are not required to register documents presented to them without regard to legality and that they may enquire into registrability. The High Court judge relied upon this judgment in support of the conclusion that a registered sale deed cannot be unilaterally cancelled and that registering officers are not bound to register documents which are not legally executable and registrable.
Yanala Malleshwari v. Ananthula Sayamma (Full Bench, Andhra Pradesh) [2006 (6) ALT 523] Held (as relied upon by appellant) that a deed purporting to cancel an earlier sale, even if unilaterally executed by the vendor, is bound to be registered and the registering authority has no power to enquire into legality/validity. The appellant relied on this Full Bench decision to contend that the registering authority must register such cancellation deeds. The court noted this decision but recorded that it was subsequently declared not to be good law by the Supreme Court.
Supreme Court — Civil Appeal No. 317 of 2007 (dated 13.07.2010) (since unreported) Held that cancellation deeds executed unilaterally by a vendor of a property already transferred/ conveyed earlier are void and non est; registration of such cancellation deeds is void unless cancellation is by a competent court with notice to parties. The bench treated the Supreme Court's statement as authoritative, rejected the appellant's submission that the Supreme Court decision did not apply in Kerala, and concluded that such cancellation deeds are void and fall outside the purview of the Registration Act and its rules.
Latif Estate Line India Ltd. v. Hadeeja Ammal (Full Bench, Madras High Court) (W.A. No. 592 of 2009) The Full Bench took a categorical view similar to the Supreme Court's view that unilateral cancellation deeds of concluded sale transactions are void. The court noted this Full Bench decision as reflecting a view similar to the Supreme Court's, reinforcing the position that unilateral cancellation deeds of completed sales are not registrable and are void.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded from the factual premise that the sale deeds in question were duly executed and registered and thus completed the transfer of title to the vendee. The court (following the High Court judge below) reasoned that once title has passed on execution and registration of a sale deed, the vendor cannot unilaterally divest the vendee of that title by executing a cancellation deed. The unilateral cancellation does not revest title in the vendor; only the vendee can confer title back by a conveyance.

The High Court judge had observed that while the District Registrar's view that stamp duty under Article 21 may be chargeable could be correct to a limited extent, it was incorrect to hold that payment of stamp duty under Article 21 would validate and render registrable a unilateral cancellation deed executed by the seller of a property already conveyed. The judge also concluded that the registering authorities, under the Registration Act, are not obliged to register every document presented; Part XII (Sections 71–77) indicates that there is no duty to register documents which are not legally executable and registrable.

The appellate bench placed significant reliance on the Supreme Court's pronouncement (Civil Appeal No. 317 of 2007 dated 13.07.2010) which categorically held that cancellation deeds executed unilaterally by the vendor of a previously conveyed property are void and non est, and that registration of such documents is meaningless absent a competent court declaration and notice to parties. The bench rejected the appellant's contention that the Supreme Court decision was inapplicable in Kerala because the Supreme Court did not consider specific State rules (for example Rule 67), reasoning that if a document is beyond the purview of the Registration Act, the rules framed under the Act cannot confer legality on such a document.

The court therefore treated unilateral cancellation deeds of completed sales as not constituting documents falling within the Registration Act, and concluded that the registering authorities are entitled to enquire into the validity and legality of documents presented and to refuse registration of documents that are not legally executable or registrable.

Practically, the High Court below had directed cancellation/ striking off/ revocation of the cancellation deeds from the registers and directed the Sub Registrar not to show such deeds as encumbrances in encumbrance certificates. The present bench, applying the law declared by the Supreme Court and the reasoning of the High Court, found that the appeal required dismissal but made additional protective directions (discussed below) concerning recovery of amounts and the award of costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding: THE APPEAL IS DISMISSED.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The dismissal confirms the High Court's conclusion that a duly executed and registered sale deed cannot be unilaterally cancelled by the vendor and that such unilateral cancellation deeds are void and do not fall within the Registration Act.
  • The court directed that the respondents shall not proceed to recover any amounts (either towards stamp duty or towards penalty) pursuant to Exts.P7 and P8 from the appellant. This is an immediate protective direction restraining recovery proceedings based on those orders.
  • The court set aside the High Court's order awarding costs to the 3rd respondent: it deemed it inappropriate to mulct the appellant with the liability of costs and therefore vacated the costs awarded in the judgment under appeal.
  • The High Court had ordered that the cancellation deeds registered pursuant to an interim order be cancelled/struck off/revoked in the registers and that they should not be shown as encumbrances in future encumbrance certificates; the appellate court's dismissal confirms the substantive legal position underpinning those directions.
  • No new legal precedent was created by this judgment; the court applied and followed the Supreme Court's ruling that unilateral cancellation deeds of concluded sale transactions are void and non est. The decision enforces that principle and the direct consequences for the parties (non-recovery of the assessed stamp duty/penalty and setting aside of costs), rather than establishing a novel legal proposition.

This summary is strictly confined to the content and statements contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

    P.A. Hamsa v. District Registrar General

    JUDGMENT

    J. Chelameswar, C.J

    Aggrieved by judgment dated 14.03.2011 in W.P (C) No. 9342 of 2008 by which the writ petition was dismissed with costs quantified at Rs. 25,000/- to be paid to the 3rd respondent therein, the unsuccessful petitioner preferred the instant appeal.

    2. The appellant herein in his capacity as the Chairman and Managing Director of a Private Limited company and also in his individual capacity sold certain parcels of land in favour of another Private Limited company of which the 3 respondent herein is the Managing Director. The said sale transactions were duly registered under the Registration Act, 1908. The documents so registered are dated 31.08.07 and marked as Exts.R3(a) and (b) in the writ petition. Subsequently, the appellant sought to get two documents, styled as cancellation deeds, (marked as Exts.P1 and P2 in the writ petition) registered.

    3. When such documents were presented for registration, the 2nd respondent herein impounded the documents and referred the documents to the District Registrar, Kozhikode ostensibly in exercise of the power under Sections 33(1) and 37(2) of the Kerala Stamp Act.

    4. The 1st respondent District Registrar issued Exts.P3 and P4 notices dated 02.02.2008 to the appellant intimating that the documents are liable for stamp duty calculated at 10% of the consideration shown in the sale deeds which are purported to have been cancelled under the deeds in question. It was indicated that such a duty is payable under Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act. The notice also demanded a penalty at 10 times the value of the stamp duty, which in the opinion of the 1 respondent, sought to be evaded by the appellant. The appellant disputed such liability and filed his objections.

    5. On 03.03.2008, the 1 respondent passed two orders (Exts.P7 and P8) directing that the Stamp duty on the abovementioned documents is payable under Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act at 10% of the consideration shown in the sale deeds, i.e, R3(a) R3(b) and also a penalty of Rs. 500/- each. It was further indicated in the said order that in the event of failure by the appellant to make remittances referred to above, necessary steps in law would be taken to realise the abovementioned amounts.

    6. Challenging the abovementioned documents, Exts.P7 and P8, the appellant herein approached this Court by way of W.P (C) No. 9342 of 2008 which was dismissed by the judgment under appeal.

    7. The issues before the learned Judge were that (1)whether a concluded sale could be unilaterally cancelled by the vendor (2) whether such a document purporting to cancel a sale deed which was duly executed and registered earlier is bound to be registered without any question by the registering authorities and (3) if the answer to the second issue is - yes - what is the relevant Article of 1 Schedule to the Kerala Stamp Act which applies to such a document, whether it is Article 21 as opined by respondents 1 and 2 or Article 15 of the Kerala Stamp Act as contended by the appellant herein. Incidentally the question is whether the registering authorities are legally competent to embark upon the enquiry into the question of legality of the documents or the legal authority of the executant of the document etc.

    8. The learned Judge by the judgment under appeal opined that a duly executed and registered sale deed cannot be unilaterally cancelled by paying the stamp duty invoking either Article 15 or 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act. The relevant portion of the judgment reads as follows:

    “The sale being complete on the execution and registration of the sale deed, it cannot be unilaterally cancelled by the seller thereof. Such a cancellation deed of a sale deed cannot be registered invoking Article 15 of the Kerala Stamp Act. Even if stamp duty is paid under Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act, a duly executed and registered sale deed cannot be cancelled unilaterally by the seller. On execution of the sale deed, title to the property passes to the vendee. The vendee cannot be divested of his title by the unilateral act of cancellation of the sale deed by the vendor. Even on cancellation of the sale deed, the vendor would not get title to the property and only the vendee can confer title to the vendor. Such conferment amounts to conveyance. The view taken by the District Registrar (General) that stamp duty is payable under Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act, to that extent, may be correct, but it is not correct to the extent that the unilateral cancellation deed of the sale deed executed and presented for registration by the vendor can be registered on payment of stamp duty under Article 21 of the Kerala Stamp Act.” 9. The learned Judge also opined that the authorities acting under the Registration Act are not obliged to blindly register every document produced for registration unmindful of the validity and legality of a document. The relevant portion of the judgment reads as follows:

    “It is not the duty of the Sub Registrar to register every document presented before him for registration, unmindful of its validity and legality. Only if a valid document is duly executed and presented for registration, the Sub Registrar is bound to register the document. Part XII of the Registration Act containing Sections 71 to 77 would clearly indicate that there is no duty cast on the Registrar to register a document which is not legally executable and registrable.”

    10. The learned Judge relied upon an earlier judgment reported in Noble John v. State Of Kerala [ILR 2010 (3) Kerala 979] in support of his abovementioned conclusion.

    11. It may also be mentioned here that during the pendency of the said writ petition, pursuant to an interim direction, the disputed documents came to be registered by the respondents. In the circumstances, by the judgment under appeal the learned Judge, while dismissing the writ petition, issued certain directions. The relevant portion of the judgment reads as follows:

    “Now the question remains as to what should be done since the cancellation deeds were registered on the basis of the interim order passed by this court. It is trite that an act of court should prejudice none. The cancellation deeds were not liable to be registered at all. However, the cancellation deeds were registered only on the basis of the interim order passed by this court. The error has to be rectified. Therefore, I direct the Sub Registrar, Kozhikode to cancel/strike off/revoke the cancellation deeds referred to above by making appropriate entries in the relevant registers. There will be a direction to the second respondent that under no circumstances, the cancellation deeds which happened to be registered in the circumstances mentioned above, should be shown as an encumbrance in the encumbrance certificate that may be issued in future in respect of the properties in question.”

    Hence the appeal.

    12. Heard Sri. S.V Balakrishna Iyer, the learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf of the 3 respondent. The learned Senior counsel, Sri. V. Chitambaresh, appearing for the appellant, relying upon a Full Bench decision of Andhra Pradesh High Court reported in Yanala Malleshwari v. Ananthula Sayamma [2006 (6) ALT 523] argued that even a deed purporting to be a deed of cancellation (of an earlier sale transaction) unilaterally executed by the vendor is bound to be registered when presented before the registering authority and the registering authority has no authority in law to enquire into either the legality or validity of such document. But, it must be mentioned that, the abovementioned Full Bench judgment is no more good law as the same was declared to be so by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 317 of 2007 dated 13.07.2010 (since unreported). The relevant portion of the Supreme Court judgment reads as follows:

    “It is only when a sale deed is cancelled by a competent Court that the cancellation deed can be registered and that too after notice to the concerned parties. In this case, neither is there any declaration by a competent court nor was there any notice to the parties. Hence, this Rule also makes it clear that both the cancellation deed as well as registration thereof were wholly void and non est and meaningless transactions.”

    13. In the circumstances, an enquiry into the question in the instant appeal should normally come to an end in view of the law declared by the judgment of the Supreme Court. However, the learned counsel argued that the judgment of the Full Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court and the Supreme Court were rendered in the context of the rules framed by the State of Andhra Pradesh and the rules framed under the Registration Act by the State of Kerala, more particularly Rule 67 which clothes the registering officer with a duty to enquire into the validity of the document did not fall for consideration of the Supreme Court and therefore the decision of the Supreme Court is not an authority for the proposition in the State of Kerala that the registering officer has no discretion to enquire into the legality or validity of the documents presented for registration.

    14. We reject the submission for the reason that the Supreme Court categorically held that the cancellation deeds, such as the one in question before us as well as before the Supreme Court, executed unilaterally by the vendor of a property which had been duly transferred and conveyed earlier are documents which are void, non est and “meaningless transactions”. Therefore, such documents obviously are not documents falling within the provisions of the Registration Act, 1908. If a document is beyond the purview of the Registration Act, the rules prescribed under the Act cannot confer a better status on such documents. In the circumstances the submission of the learned counsel is rejected.

    15. We may also mention for the sake of the completion of the history of the proposition of law that a Full Bench of Madras High Court in W.A No. 592 of 2009 (Latif Estate Line India Ltd. v. Hadeeja Ammal) also took a categoric view similar to the view taken by the Supreme Court. It appears that the abovementioned unreported judgment of the Supreme Court was not brought to the notice of the Madras High Court.

    16. The net result is that the writ appeal is only required to be dismissed confirming the dismissal of the writ petition. However, the learned counsel for the appellant brought to our notice that notwithstanding the fact that the documents in question need not be registered in view of the law declared by the Supreme Court, in view of Exts.P7 and P8 there is a possibility of the respondents proceeding to recover the amounts mentioned therein, therefore appropriate directions may be issued in that regard. We see some justification in the prayer made by the learned counsel for the appellant. We, therefore, direct the respondents not to proceed to recover any amounts, either towards the Stamp duty or towards the penalty pursuant to Exts.P7 and P8, from the appellant.

    17. We also, in the circumstances of the case, deem it inappropriate to mulct the appellant/writ petitioner with the liability of costs. Hence, the judgment under appeal, in so far as it pertains to the award of costs, is set aside.

    The learned counsel for the appellant also submitted that independent of the legal position that a unilaterally executed cancellation deed of a concluded sale transaction has no legal validity, the appellant, in law, does has a right to seek a declaration that the past sale transaction to which he is a party (as vendor) is illegal and not binding on him before the Civil Court in an appropriate suit and such a right of the appellant may be preserved. The right of a party to avoid a transaction of transfer of property under certain conditions is well recognized in this country. If the appellant believes that he is, in law, entitled to avoid the legal consequences of the sale transactions covered by Exts.R3(a) and R3 (b), it is open for him to take such steps as are available to him in law in this country.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P.A. Hamsa v. District Registrar General
    (Jul 20, 2011)