The question that arises for consideration is whether a civil court
will have territorial jurisdiction to entertain a suit against a company
having a branch office within its jurisdiction in respect of a cause of
action that did not arise at least in part within its jurisdiction.
2. Ext.P5 judgment of the Sixth Additional District Judge,
Ernakulam in C.M.A.No.981 of 2002 by which the finding in Ext.P4
order entered by the Second Additional Subordinate Judge, Ernakulam
on issue No.5 regarding the territorial jurisdiction of the court has been
set aside, is under challenge in these proceedings under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India.
3. The defendant in the suit is M/s.HCL Info Systems Ltd., a
Company incorporated under the Companies Act. The contention
which was seriously raised by the plaintiff answering the question of
jurisdiction was that the defendant having submitted to the jurisdiction
of the court is not entitled to contend at a later stage that the court
has no territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The above
contention was rightly overruled by the learned Sub Judge who found
that going by the amended plaint, the cause of action for the claim
WP(C)N0.20973/04
(arrears of incentives due to the respondent-plaintiff, a former
employee of the Company) arose partly at Madras and partly at
Bombay and accordingly found, applying the Explanation to Section 20
of the Code of Civil Procedure, that the suit could be maintained at
New Delhi where the Registered Office of the Company is situated or at
Madras or Bombay where the cause of action had arisen in part.
C.M.A.No.981 of 2002 was preferred by the respondent-plaintiff and
in the C.M.Appeal also the learned Additional District Judge was not
inclined to uphold the plea of waiver which was pursued by the
respondent. But the learned Judge noticed that going by the address
and seal of the defendant-Company contained in the written
statement, the defendant-Company is situated at Cochin within the
jurisdiction of the trial court. Observing that the defendant does not
have a case that the Company at Cochin is a branch or that the
Company's Head Office or Principal Office is elsewhere and taking note
of the submission of the defendant's counsel that the Company is
running business at Cochin, the learned District Judge applied Clause
(a) of Section 20 of the Code to hold that the Ernakulam Sub Court is
having territorial jurisdiction since the Company-defendant is carrying
on business within the territorial limits of that court.
WP(C)N0.20973/04
4. I have heard the submissions of Sri.George Thomas Mevada,
learned counsel for the petitioner and those of Sri.Mathew Kuriakose,
learned counsel for the respondent.
5. My attention was drawn by Mr.George Thomas Mevada to
Section 20 and also to Order 29 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The
learned counsel also drew my attention to Ext.P1 lawyer notice which
had been produced along with Ext.P2 plaint as document No.11.
Referring to the judgment of this Court in Commercial Financiers v.
Thressia (1990 (1) KLT 774), the learned counsel submitted that
Ext.P1 having been produced along with the plaint is to be construed
as part of the pleading itself.
6. Mr.Mathew Kuriakose per contra would give thrust to the plea
of waiver which was unsuccessfully raised both before the trial court
and before the District Judge. According to him, having submitted to
the jurisdiction of the court by filing a written statement answering the
original plaint, it is not open to the petitioner to contend at a later
stage that the court did not have jurisdiction. The plea of waiver
raised by the plaintiff, in my view, has been rightly repelled by the trial
court and the appellate court, and this Court will not be justified in
considering the same over again in these proceedings initiated by the
WP(C)N0.20973/04
defendant-petitioner. The contention that the Ernakulam Court lacks in
jurisdiction became available only when the plaint was amended and
could not have been raised with respect to the original plaint.
7. It is admitted by the respondent-plaintiff himself through
Ext.P1, which is to be construed as a part of his own plaint in terms of
the judgment of this Court in Commercial Financiers v. Thressia
(1990 (1) KLT 774), that the defendant-Company has its Registered
Office at New Delhi. It is admitted by him by his further pleadings
that the Company has branches at Madras and Bombay and the suit
claim as limited by the order of amendment pertains to his service at
branches at Madras and Bombay. I am at a loss to see how the
learned District Judge can blame the petitioner-Company for not
contending that the Company's Head Office is elsewhere and that the
office at Cochin is a branch. It is seen that the District Judge has
relied on what is described in the judgment as admission by the
defendant's counsel that the Company runs business at Cochin. It is
common ground that the company, which has its Registered Office at
New Delhi, through its branch at Cochin runs business at Cochin also in
the same way as it runs business at Madras through its branch at
Madras and at Bombay through its branch at Bombay. But what is
WP(C)N0.20973/04
pertinent is that the cause of action upon which the amended plaint is
instituted did not arise in the Cochin Branch.
8. The three clauses of Section 20 C.P.C. are subject to the
Explanation which reads as follows:-
"Explanation.-- A Corporation shall be deemed to
carry on business at its sole or principal office in India or,
in respect of any cause of action arising at any place
where it has also a subordinate office, at such place."
It means that when the defendant is a Corporation, the same shall be
deemed to carry on business at its sole or principal office in India or, in
respect of any cause of action arising at any place where it has also a
subordinate office, at such place. The defendant is obviously
Corporation governed by Order 29 of the Code. Going by the amended
plaint, the cause of action has obviously arisen at Madras and Bombay
only. Thus for the purpose of Section 20, it has to be deemed that the
defendant-Company carries on business at New Delhi, Madras or
Bombay only. The court at Ernakulam will not have jurisdiction in view
of the conceded position that no part of the cause of action has arisen
within the local limits of that court. The suit could be entertained by
courts either at New Delhi, seat of the Company's registered office or
WP(C)N0.20973/04
at Madras or Bombay where the cause of action arose in part, but not
at Ernakulam. The learned Subordinate Judge was, in my opinion,
justified in returning the plaint to the plaintiff-respondent for
presentation before the proper court and interference by the District
Judge under Ext.P5 was not justified.
The result of the above discussion is that Ext.P5 is set aside and
Ext.P4 is restored. The Writ Petition is allowed as above, but, in the
circumstances, without any order as to costs.
(PIUS C. KURIAKOSE, JUDGE)
tgl
WP(C)N0.20973/04