Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Chitties Act and the Cochin Kuries Act, and the Travancore Chitties Act, the Cochin Kuries Act and the Cochin Starting of Kuries (Restriction) Act
  • purpose.12. Sec. 4 of the Travancore Chitties Act, XXVI of 1120 as amended by Act X of 1964
  • Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 and Cochin Starting of Kuries (Restriction Act, XII of 1120
  • provisions of Sec. 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act and Sec. 23 of the Contract Act
  • Sec. 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 and Sec. 23 of the Contract Act,
  • KERALA MONEY LENDERS ACT
  • rupees.13. Section 4 of the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107
  • provisions of Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • provisions of Secs. 6 & 7 of the Travancore Chitties Act
  • sub-section (1) of Sec. 3 of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • provisions of the Money Lenders Act and the Rules
  • Cochin Kuries Act and the Travancore Chitties Act,
  • provisions of Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.10.
  • clauses (1) to (3) of Sec. 23 of the Contract Act
  • sanction.xxxxxxxxx8. Sub-section (6) of Sec. 3
  • Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • KERALA CHITTIES ACT
  • provisions of the Money Lenders Act
  • Section 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act
  • Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • Sec. 72 of the Kerala Chitties Act,
  • Sec. 3 of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • Sec. 20 of the Money Lenders Act
  • SECTION 23 CONTRACT ACT
  • Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.11.
  • provisions of sub-section (1)
  • Act. Sub-section (1) of Sec. 6
  • Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.
  • sub-section (1) of Sec. 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Chitties Act and the Cochin Kuries Act, and the Travancore Chitties Act, the Cochin Kuries Act and the Cochin Starting of Kuries (Restriction) Act
  • purpose.12. Sec. 4 of the Travancore Chitties Act, XXVI of 1120 as amended by Act X of 1964
  • Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 and Cochin Starting of Kuries (Restriction Act, XII of 1120
  • provisions of Sec. 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act and Sec. 23 of the Contract Act
  • Sec. 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 and Sec. 23 of the Contract Act,
  • KERALA MONEY LENDERS ACT
  • rupees.13. Section 4 of the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107
  • provisions of Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • provisions of Secs. 6 & 7 of the Travancore Chitties Act
  • sub-section (1) of Sec. 3 of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • provisions of the Money Lenders Act and the Rules
  • Cochin Kuries Act and the Travancore Chitties Act,
  • provisions of Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.10.
  • clauses (1) to (3) of Sec. 23 of the Contract Act
  • sanction.xxxxxxxxx8. Sub-section (6) of Sec. 3
  • Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • KERALA CHITTIES ACT
  • provisions of the Money Lenders Act
  • Section 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act
  • Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • Sec. 72 of the Kerala Chitties Act,
  • Sec. 3 of the Kerala Chitties Act
  • Sec. 20 of the Money Lenders Act
  • SECTION 23 CONTRACT ACT
  • Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.11.
  • provisions of sub-section (1)
  • Act. Sub-section (1) of Sec. 6
  • Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.
  • sub-section (1) of Sec. 3
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed a complaint under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act against the 1st respondent before the Chief Judicial Magistrate's Court, Kottayam. The dispute arose from a private gold chitty conducted by the respondent, in which the appellant subscribed by depositing 148 grams of gold. The respondent allegedly agreed to pay Rs. 49,000 as the value of the gold and issued two cheques to the appellant. These cheques were dishonoured due to insufficient funds. Despite receiving notice of dishonour, the respondent failed to pay the amount. The lower court acquitted the respondent, holding that the appellant failed to prove all ingredients of Sec. 138. The appellant appealed this decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the cheques issued by the respondent were drawn to discharge a legally enforceable debt or liability so as to attract the provisions of Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  2. Whether the private chitty conducted without sanction and registration under the Kerala Chitties Act is illegal and void, thereby affecting the enforceability of the debt.
  3. Whether the transaction between the appellant and respondent is against public policy or immoral under Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant subscribed to a private gold chitty conducted by the respondent and deposited 148 grams of gold.
  • The respondent agreed to pay Rs. 49,000 as the value of the gold and issued two cheques in discharge of this liability.
  • The appellant contended that although the chitty was conducted without sanction or registration under the Kerala Chitties Act, the Act does not declare such chitties void or illegal, only penalizing the foreman.
  • Therefore, the appellant argued that the lower court erred in holding that the cheques were not supported by legal consideration and that the respondent was not liable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that the private chitty was conducted without government sanction or registration, violating Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act, rendering the transaction illegal and void.
  • He argued that the consideration for the cheques was illegal under Sec. 23 of the Contract Act and thus the cheques were not issued to discharge a legally enforceable debt.
  • The respondent relied on the penal provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act and contended that the lower court rightly acquitted him.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madhavan Nair v. Kunchu Nair (1959 KLT 43) Illegal and unenforceable nature of unregistered kuri transactions under Cochin Kuries Act and Sec. 23 of Contract Act. Distinguished from current case as Kerala Chitties Act does not declare unregistered chitties void.
Chellappan Pillai v. Kunju Pillai (1969 KLT 659) Foreman's obligation to register chitties; failure to do so attracts penalty but does not absolve liability to pay subscribers. Supported the view that subscribers' claims remain maintainable despite foreman's default in registration.
G. Balakrishnan v. P. Babu (1994 (1) KLT 947) Contracts under Money Lenders Act not void solely due to lack of licence; penalty imposed but contract enforceable unless void under Contract Act. Used to analogize that Kerala Chitties Act penal provisions do not render chitty transactions void.
Victorian Daylesford Syndicate Ltd. v. Dott (1905) 2 Ch. 624 (B) Distinction between statutes imposing penalties for revenue protection and those protecting public interest; contracts prohibited expressly or by implication are illegal. Applied to interpret that Kerala Chitties Act imposes penalty for revenue protection and does not declare chitties void.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act, particularly Sec. 3(1) and Sec. 3(6), noting that while the Act prohibits conducting chitties without sanction and registration and imposes penalties, it does not declare such chitties void or illegal. The court distinguished this from earlier laws like the Cochin Kuries Act, which explicitly voided unregistered transactions. It further analyzed the nature of the penalty imposed by the Kerala Chitties Act and concluded it was primarily for revenue protection, not for public interest, hence not rendering the contract illegal under Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.

The court also considered whether the transaction was opposed to public policy or immoral and found it was not. The cheques issued by the respondent were held to be in discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability. Consequently, the court found the lower court's conclusion that the offence under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was not made out to be erroneous.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The judgment of the lower court acquitting the respondent is set aside. The respondent is found guilty of the offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. He is convicted and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 55,000, and in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for six months. The fine is to be realized, and Rs. 49,000 is to be paid to the appellant.

This decision directly reverses the lower court's acquittal and enforces liability on the respondent for dishonour of cheques issued in discharge of a legally enforceable debt. No new precedent beyond this case's facts is established regarding the legal status of chitties conducted without sanction or registration under the Kerala Chitties Act.

    A.N Nadarajan v. K.G Nadarajan & Anr.

    JUDGMENT

    1. The complainant in C.C 546/92 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate's Court, Kottayam is the appellant.

    2. The appellant filed complaint before the lower court against the 1st respondent alleging offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. According to the appellant, the 1st respondent conducted a private chitty in gold in which the appellant subscribed one ticket and deposited 148 grams of gold in the chitty. Since the 1st respondent did not possess sufficient quantity of gold to pay back to the appellant he agreed to pay Rs. 49,000/- being the value of 148 grams of gold. In order to discharge that liability the 1st respondent issued two cheques for Rs. 22,400/- dated 25-3-92 and Rs. 26,600/- dated 2-4-92 drawn on Kumaranelloor Service Co-operative Bank in favour of the appellant. When the cheques were presented for encashment, they were dishonoured for want of sufficient funds to the credit of the 1st respondent. Though the 1st respondent received the notice caused to be sent on behalf of the appellant intimating about the dishonour of the cheques and calling upon him to pay the amount, he has not paid the amount. Therefore, he is guilty of the offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the N.I Act.

    3. The lower court after trial found that the appellant has failed to prove all the ingredients of Sec. 138 of the N.I Act and no offence is made out against the 1st respondent under that section, as such the 1st respondent not guilty and acquitted him by judgment dated 21-9-1995. Hence this appeal is preferred before this court.

    4. The contention of the appellant that he joined one ticket in the private chitty in gold conducted by the 1st respondent, he has altogether subscribed 148 grams of gold at 4 grams per month and the 1st respondent agreed to pay Rs. 49,000/- being the value of the gold and for that amount he issued Exts. P1 and P2 cheques in favour of the appellant, is not in dispute.

    5. The contention of the 1st respondent is that the private chitty conducted by him without obtaining the permission from the Government or from the competent authority and without registration under the Chitties Act in controvention of the provisions of the Chitties Act is illegal and void and therefore, the consideration for Exts. P1 and P2 cheques is illegal under Sec. 23 of the Contract Act. The 1st respondent further contended that the cheques are not issued in discharge of a legally enforceable debt or other liability so as to attract the provisions of Sec. 138 of the N.I Act. The Lower Court has accepted the contention of the 1st respondent and found him not guilty in this case.

    6. In this case the lower court has formulated six points for consideration. In point No. 1 it is found that Ext. P5 notice dated 14-5-1992 issued by the appellant to the 1st respondent is proper and valid. In point No. 2 it is found that the 1st respondent has issued Exts. P1 and P2 cheques in favour of the appellant to discharge the liability due from him to the appellant. In point No. 3 the lower court found that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques were dishonoured due to insufficiency of funds to the credit of the 1st respondent in the Bank. But in point No. 4 the lower court found that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques are not issued in discharge of the legally enforceable debt or other liability in favour of the appellant and accordingly found in point Nos. 5 and. 6 that the 1st respondent is not guilty of the offence alleged against him. The findings arrived at by the lower court in favour of the appellant are not challenged. Therefore, the only point for consideration is whether the 1st respondent has executed Exts. P1 and P2 cheques in favour of the appellant to discharge a legally enforceable debt or other liability.

    7. It is contended by the 1st respondent that admittedly the private chitty in gold is conducted by the 1st respondent without obtaining sanction from the Government or from the competent authority and without registration under the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act. Section 3 of the Act prohibits chitty not sanctioned or registered under the Act which reads as follows:

    “3. Prohibition of chitty not sanctioned or registered under this Act:—(1) No chitty shall, after the commencement of this Act, be started and conducted unless the previous sanction of the Government or of such officer as may be empowered by the Government in this behalf is obtained therefor and unless the chitty is registered in accordance with the provisions of this Act:

    Provided that the previous sanction under this sub-section shall lapse unless the chitty is registered before the expiry of six months from the date of such sanction.”

    xxxxxxxxx

    8. Sub-section (6) of Sec. 3 provides penalty for contravention of sub-section (1) of Sec. 3 which reads as follows:

    “(6) Whoever contravenes the provisions of sub-section (1) shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three months but which may extend to two years and with fine which shall not be less than five hundred rupees but which may extend to two thousand rupees.”

    9. The counsel for the appellant submitted that sub-section (1) of Sec. 3 of the Kerala Chitties Act only prohibits the conduct of the chitty without the sanction from the Government or the empowered officer and without registering the same under the provisions of the Chitties Act and provides penalty to the person who conducts the chitty in contravention of the provisions of the Act under sub-section (6) of Sec. 3 of the Act. But section 3(1) does not make the chitty conducted without obtaining sanction from the Government or authorised officer and without registering the same under the provisions of the Act as void, illegal or unlawful. Therefore, according to him, the appellant is legally entitled to recover the value of the gold subscribed by him to the 1st respondent in the gold chitty in spite of the fact that he has conducted the gold chitty without the sanction from the Government or the authorised officer and without registering the same under the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act and as such the lower court is in manifest error in finding that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques in this case are not supported by legal and valid consideration so as to make the 1st respondent liable for the offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

    10. On the other hand, the counsel for the 1st respondent submitted that it is clear from the provisions of Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act that conduct of chitty without the sanction from the Government or the authorised officer and without registering the same under the provisions of the Chitties Act is illegal and void, apart from providing penalty to the foreman who conducted the chitty in controvention of the provisions of Sec. 3(1) of the Chitties Act, under Sec. 3(6) of the Act. Therefore, according to him, any liability arising out of that illegal contract cannot be enforceable under law and that transaction is hit by Sec. 23 of the Contract Act.

    11. It is clear from the statement of objects and reasons for the enactment of the Kerala Chitties Act, 1975 that since the law relating to chitties in force in the Travancore area of Kerala State is the Travancore Chitties Act, 1120, the corresponding law in force in Cochin area being the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 and Cochin Starting of Kuries (Restriction Act, XII of 1120 and there is no law on the subject in the Malabar area of the State, it was considered necessary to enact a uniform law relating to chitties applicable to the whole of the State and the enactment is intended for that purpose.

    12. Sec. 4 of the Travancore Chitties Act, XXVI of 1120 as amended by Act X of 1964 stipulates that transactions partaking of the nature of a chitty but not falling within the definition in clause (2) of Sec. 3 are void. Section 5 of the Act prescribes punishment for partaking in transactions declared void by Sec. 4 which provides that any person who conducts or is responsible for the conduct of any transaction of the nature of those declared void by Sec. 4 shall be punishable with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six months or with fine or with both. Section 6 of the Act prohibits chitties not registered under the Act. Sub-section (1) of Sec. 6 stipulates that no chitty shall after the commencement of the Act, be conducted unless it is registered in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Sub-section (2) of Sec. 6 provides that any person contravening the provisions of sub-section (1) shall be liable to a fine which may extend to five hundred rupees.

    13. Section 4 of the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 stipulates that transactions partaking of the nature of a Kuri but not falling within the definition in sub-section (1) of Sec. 3 are void and any person who starts such transaction or conducts such a transaction started after coming into force of that Act without the previous sanction of the Government shall be liable to a fine not exceeding five hundred rupees. Section 5 of the Act lays down that every kuri shall be registered in accordance with the provisions of the Act, and if not so registered, it shall be void and the foreman shall be liable to a fine not exceeding five hundred rupees.

    14. Even though it is clear that the Kerala Chitties Act, 1975 is enacted to bring forth a uniform law relating to chitties applicable to the whole State of Kerala in the place of the Travancore Chitties Act and the Cochin Kuries Act, and the Travancore Chitties Act, the Cochin Kuries Act and the Cochin Starting of Kuries (Restriction) Act are repealed under Sec. 72 of the Kerala Chitties Act, no provision is incorporated in the Kerala Chitties Act to the effect that the chitties started and conducted after the commencement of the Act in contravention of the provisions of the Act are void, even though there were provisions in the Cochin Kuries Act declaring the transactions as void. The Kerala Chitties Act only prohibited the starting and conduct of kuries after the commencement of the Act without the previous sanction from the Government or the authorised officer and without registering the same under the provisions of the Act and provides penalty to whoever contravenes the provisions of Sec. 3(1) of the Act. No clause is inserted in the Act making such kuries started after the commencement of the Act in contravention of the provisions of the Act as void, illegal or unlawful. Therefore, it is contended by the counsel for the appellant that the Legislature in its wisdom did not find it necessary to make the chitties started after the commencement of the Kerala Chitties Act in contravention of the provisions of the Act, as void, illegal or unlawful, as providfed in the Cochin Kuries Act, Though the foreman who started the kuries after the commencement of the Act in controvention of the provisions of the Act is liable under the penal provision, the chitty transaction will not become void, illegal or unlawful so as to make the claims under the chitty void or illegal.

    15. By interpreting Sec. 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act, VII of 1107 and Sec. 23 of the Contract Act, this court in the decision in Madhavan Nair v. Kunchu Nair (1959 KLT 43) held that the rights and liabilities of the parties in that case which spring directly out of the Kuri transaction cannot be enforced since the kuri agreement itself was illegal as the kuri had not been registered under the Act.

    16. The above decision rendered by this court while interpreting the provisions of Sec. 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act and Sec. 23 of the Contract Act has no direct bearing on the facts and circumstances of this case since the Kerala Chitties Act does not contain such a provision making the chitties conducted without obtaining sanction from the Government or the authorised officer and without registering the same void as provided under the Cochin Kuries Act.

    17. In the decision in Chellappan Pillai v. Kunju Pillai (1969 KLT 659) this court while construing the provisions of Secs. 6 & 7 of the Travancore Chitties Act held that the obligation to register Chitties, or to take out licences for Chitties is cast on the foreman and his failure to do either invites penalty upon him and the subscriber Has nothing to do with the registration or the taking out of the licence. It is also held that the default of the foreman to obtain the licence for the conduct of the chitty will not absolve him from the liability for payment of the prize money. It is also held that the claim by the subscriber for refund of the paid up subscription is maintainable even if the foreman had defaulted to register the chitty.

    18. The counsel for the respondent submitted that Sec. 3 of the Kerala Chitties Act prohibits the conduct of the chitties without obtaining permission from the Government or the competent authority and without registering the same after the commencement of the Act and therefore, the entire transaction being illegal and void, the subscriber cannot under law claim either the prize amount or the amount he has subscribed to the foreman under the illegal and void transaction. The counsel for the appellant submitted that since Sec. 3(1) of the Act only prohibits the conduct of the Kuri without the sanction from the Government or competent authority and without obtaining registration and provides penalty for violation of the provisions against the person who conducts the chitty, it cannot be construed that the chitty conducted in violation of Sec. 3(1) is illegal. According to him, a similar provision in the Money Lenders Act, 1985 is considered by this Court in the decision in G. Balakrishnan v. P. Babu (1994 (1) KLT 947) and found that a suit can be instituted by a money lender even if he has advanced money in contravention of the provisions of the Money Lenders Act unless and until the contract is void by virtue of any of the provisions contained in the Contract Act. In that case a suit filed by the plaintiff for realisation of money with interest was resisted by the defendant contending that the suit is not maintainable since it is based on an illegal contract whose object is unlawful and the transaction is void and unenforceable since the plaintiff had not obtained licence under the Kerala Money Lenders Act. Section 3 of the Money Lenders Act prohibited any person from carying on or continuing business as money lender without a licence obtained under the Act or in contravention of the terms of the Act. Though Sections 17 and 18 of the Act provided for penalties to be imposed against the person contravening any of the provisions of the Act or the Rule made thereunder or of any terms and conditions of the licence, Sec. 20 of the Act stipulated that where a money lender is guilty of an offence punishable under that Act, any contract made by him in relation to his business of money lending shall not be void by reason only of that offence, nor shall he loss his lien on or right to the pledge of to the loan and to the interest and other charges, if any, payable in respect thereof. Therefore, the provisions of the Money Lenders Act in respect of which the decision reported in 1994 (1) KLT 947 is rendered and the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act are not identical since there is no provision in the Chitties Act similar or akin to Sec. 20 of the Money Lenders Act safeguarding the interest of foreman who has contravened the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act as that of the interest of money lender who has infringed the provisions of the Money Lenders Act and the Rules framed thereunder.

    19. But while considering the legality of the contract where the statute merely imposes a penalty on the parties to the contract without declaring the contract to be illegal and void, this court has observed in that reported decision as follows:

    “The legal position has been stated by Anson in his Law of Contract, 19th Edn. at page 206 thus:—

    ‘The effect in such a case depends on the proper construction of the particular statute. But where the words of the statute leaves room for doubt as to its intention, it is material to ask whether the object of the Act in imposing the penalty is merely to protect the revenue or whether its object or one of its objects is to protect the general public or some class of the general public by requiring that the contract shall be accompanied by certain formalities or conditions, as, for example, registration in the case of money lender. In the latter case, it is probable that the act for the doing of which the penalty is imposed is impliedly prohibited by the statute and therefore illegal.’

    9. A distinction is drawn in Victorian Daylesford Syndicate Ltd. v. Dott (1905) 2 Ch. 624 (B) and the Statutes are gruped under two heads: (1) Those in which a penalty is imposed against doing an act for the purposes only of the protection of the revenue, and (2) those in which a penalty is imposed upon an act not merely for revenue purposes but also for the protection of the public. It is also observed that there is no question that a contract which is prohibited either expressly or by implication by a statute is illegal and cannot be enforced. The grouping was done only to see whether the contract in that case was prohibited expressly or by implication.”

    20. In this case from the enactment of the Kerala Chitties Act in the place of the Cochin Kuries Act and the Travancore Chitties Act, to make a uniform law relating to chitties to the whole of Kerala by repealing the Travancore Chitties Act and the Cochin Kuries Act, it is clear that Sec. 3(1) is enacted in the Kerala Chitties Act imposing the penalty is only for the purpose of protection of the revenue and not for the protection of public interest. If in fact, the Legislature intended to declare the chitty transaction conducted without the permission of the Government or the authorised officer or without registration under the Act, it would have provided a similar provision as is found in. Section 5 of the Cochin Kuries Act declaring the kuri conducted without registration under the Act as void. Therefore the intention of the Legislature is manifest in this case that the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act are incorporated to protect the interest of the subscribers and also the revenue of the State. Therefore, the contention of the respondent that the kuri involved in this case is void being conducted without obtaining sanction from the Government or the competent authority and without registering the same as provided under Sec. 3(1) of the Kerala Chitties Act and in controvention of the provisions of the Act, is not sustainable.

    21. The next question to be considered is whether the transaction between the appellant and the respondent is against public policy. Section 23 of the Contract Act lays down that the consideration and object of an agreement is lawful unless (1) it is forbidden by law, (2) It is of such a nature that if permitted it would defeat the provisions of any law or is fraudulent (3) it involves or implies injury to the person or property of another, and (4) The court regards it as immoral or opposed to public policy. In this case the transaction between the appellant and the respondent will not come within the ambit of clauses (1) to (3) of Sec. 23 of the Contract Act noted above. The only question for consideration is whether the transaction can be regarded as immoral or opposed to public policy.

    22. The chitty transaction without obtaining the consent from the Government or the authorised officer and without registering the same under the provisions of the Kerala Chitties Act cannot be characterised as a transaction immoral or opposed to public policy. The Kerala Chitties Act only penalises the foreman who conducts the chitty in contravention of the provisions of the Act and it does not declare such a transaction illegal or unlawful. Apart from infringing the provisions of the Chitties Act, a chitty conducted in contravention of the provisions of the Chitties Act cannot be construed as immoral or opposed to public policy by any stretch of imagination. Therefore, it cannot be held that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques issued by the respondent to the appellant in this case towards the value of the gold subscribed by the appellant to the respondent though in a chitty conducted by the respondent without obtaining sanction from the Government or the competent authority and without registering the same under the provisions of the Chitties Act, is illegal or opposed to public policy. Therefore, the finding of the lower court that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques are not issued for legally enforceable debt or other liability so as to attract the provisions of Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is absolutely illegal and unsustainable.

    23. From my foregoing discussions it is clear that those cheques are issued in discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability by the respondent to the appellant. Hence the finding of the lower court that the respondent is not guilty of the offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act has to be reversed and he has to be found guilty of the offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and convinced and sentenced for that offence.

    24. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case I find that imposition of fine will meet the ends of justice in this case. Hence this appeal is allowed. The judgment passed by the lower court is set aside. The respondent is found guilty of the offence punishable under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. He is convicted and sentenced to pay fine of Rs. 55000/- in default of payment to undergo simple imprisonment for six months. The fine is realised, Rs. 49,000/- will be paid to the appellant.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    A.N Nadarajan v. K.G Nadarajan & Anr.
    (Mar 10, 1999)