Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.11.
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.5.
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.8.
  • S. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.11.
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.5.
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.8.
  • S. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
Smart Summary

Case Summary — Appeal from Acquittal under S.138, Negotiable Instruments Act

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (complainant in the trial court) appealed against an acquittal of the respondent (accused in the trial court) in Criminal Complaint No. 9 of 1993, originally tried before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Sulthan Bathery. The complaint alleged that the respondent borrowed Rs. 37,000 on 5.10.1992 and agreed to repay within one month. After the amount was not repaid, the respondent issued two cheques in favour of the appellant — one for Rs. 32,000 dated 25.11.1992 and another for Rs. 5,000 — which, when presented for collection at the bank, were dishonoured with a memo stating that payment had been stopped by the drawer (the respondent). The appellant issued notice demanding payment after dishonour.

At trial the respondent contended the cheques were not supported by consideration, asserting instead that there was an agreement for supply of timber, Rs. 25,000 having been paid in cash and the cheques issued as consideration for timber which, he alleged, the appellant did not supply. The trial court, after considering evidence, acquitted the respondent under S.255(1) CrPC. The appellant appealed, seeking reversal of the acquittal and conviction of the respondent under S.138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in acquitting the respondent of the offence under S.138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act having regard to the evidence that the cheques were issued and subsequently dishonoured.
  2. Whether the presumption under S.139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act applies once issuance of the cheque is admitted and whether the burden to rebut that presumption lies on the drawer/respondent.
  3. Whether stoppage of payment by the drawer (the respondent) precludes an action under S.138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  4. Whether the absence of an averment in the complaint that dishonour was due to insufficiency of funds rendered the complaint defective when the memo recorded stoppage of payment by the drawer.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The cheques (Exts. P1 and P2) were issued by the respondent and this fact was admitted by the respondent in answers under S.313 CrPC and in a statement of the accused dated 11.4.1994.
  • There is a statutory presumption under S.139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act that a cheque is received for discharge of any debt or liability; this presumption places the burden on the respondent to rebut.
  • Evidence established that when the cheques were presented there were insufficient funds in the respondent's account (PW2 gave the balance as Rs. 1,017.85) and that the respondent had stopped payment; stopping payment does not preclude a S.138 action.
  • The complaint and the complainant's sworn statements contain averments that the respondent issued the cheques knowing there were insufficient funds; hence the trial court's finding that the complaint was defective is incorrect.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The cheques were not issued in repayment of a loan and hence were not supported by consideration; instead there was an agreement for supply of timber, Rs. 25,000 having been paid in cash and the cheques issued as payment for timber which the appellant did not supply.
  • Documents (labelled in the trial as Ext D3 and others) were produced to show the respondent had communicated stoppage of payment and asserted non-supply of timber as justification for stopping payment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1998 (1) KLT 582 (SC) (Modi Cements Ltd. v. K.K. Nandi) Holds that issuance of a cheque raises the presumption under S.139, and that stoppage of payment by the drawer (notification to bank/drawee) does not preclude an action under S.138. The court relied on this Supreme Court decision to conclude that the respondent's act of stopping payment did not bar prosecution under S.138 and that the presumption under S.139 applies once issuance is proved.
1993 (2) KLT 1027 (decision of this Court) Was relied upon by the trial court for the proposition that specific averment is required in the complaint where cheques are dishonoured for insufficiency of funds. The court explained the trial court's reliance was misplaced here because that requirement applies when dishonour is for insufficiency of funds; where dishonour is recorded as stoppage of payment by the drawer (as in this case), the specific averment of insufficiency in the complaint is not necessary. The earlier decision was therefore distinguished on facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by identifying the statutory framework and the evidentiary posture of the case. It noted the following key points from evidence and law, addressing them in sequence:

  1. Admission of issuance of cheques: The respondent admitted issuing Exts. P1 and P2 both during examination under S.313 CrPC and in a statement dated 11.4.1994. The trial court's finding that issuance was not proved was therefore incorrect.
  2. Presumption under S.139: Once issuance of the cheque is established, the statutory presumption under S.139 (that the cheque was issued for discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or liability) operates and the burden shifts to the respondent to rebut that presumption by adducing evidence showing the cheque was not issued for discharge of debt.
  3. Evidence regarding dishonour and funds: Bank evidence (PW2) and bank memos (Exts. P3, P4, and certified ledger Ext. P10) established that when the cheques were presented there was only Rs. 1,017.85 in the respondent's account and that the cheques were dishonoured with the bank memo recording that payment had been stopped by the drawer. The complainant had also issued the statutory notice (Ext. P6) after dishonour.
  4. Impact of stoppage of payment: The court relied on the Supreme Court decision (Modi Cements) to hold that stopping payment by the drawer does not preclude action under S.138; therefore, the mere fact of a stoppage instruction to the bank does not absolve the drawer from criminal liability under S.138.
  5. Trial court's misapplication of burden: The trial court incorrectly treated it as incumbent on the appellant to prove that the cheques were supported by consideration. The correct legal position is that, after issuance is proved, the presumption under S.139 applies and it is for the drawer (respondent) to rebut the presumption by affirmative evidence. The trial court thus applied the wrong approach in appreciating evidence.
  6. Documents produced by respondent: The respondent relied on certain documents (labelled D1–D3) asserting a transaction for timber and a claim that payment was stopped on account of non-supply. The court found that the single document relied on by the respondent (Ext D3) did not satisfactorily rebut the S.139 presumption or otherwise explain the issuance of the cheques as not being for discharge of a debt.
  7. Complaint averments: The trial court had held the complaint defective for not averring dishonour due to insufficiency of funds. The appellate court observed that the bank memo recorded stoppage of payment by the drawer and that the insufficiency of funds was separately shown by the bank ledger; the rule requiring specific averment of insufficiency in the complaint applies when dishonour is expressly for insufficiency, but is not necessary where dishonour is recorded as stoppage of payment. Thus the trial court's view that the complaint was bad on that ground was incorrect.
  8. Conclusion of sufficiency: Considering the admitted issuance of the cheques, the presumption under S.139, the bank evidence of insufficient balance, and the recorded stoppage by the drawer, the court concluded there was sufficient evidence to hold the respondent guilty under S.138.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed and the order of acquittal by the trial court was set aside. The court found the respondent guilty of the offence punishable under S.138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and convicted him accordingly.

Sentencing (direct effect on the parties): The respondent was sentenced under S.138 of the Act to undergo simple imprisonment for a term of three months.

Broader implications: The court applied existing statutory presumptions (S.139) and followed the Supreme Court authority that stoppage of payment does not bar prosecution under S.138. The opinion did not state that it was creating any new precedent; rather it reversed the trial court's factual and legal appraisal and applied established principles to the facts of this case. No novel rule of law was announced beyond application and clarification of the existing authorities referred to in the judgment.

    George v. Muhammed

    G. Sasidharan, J.:— This is an appeal filed by the complainant in C.C No. 9 of 1993 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Sulthan Bathery, from the judgment by which the accused in the above case was acquitted. The allegation against the accused, who is respondent in this appeal was that he committed the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act In the complaint filed by the appellant in the trial Court, the allegation was that the respondent borrowed an amount of Rs. 37,000/- from the appellant on 5.10.1992 agreeing to pay the amount back within one month. Even after one month, the amount remained unpaid and hence the appellant made a demand to the respondent to pay back the amount. Then the respondent issued a cheque for Rs. 32,000/- with the date 25.11.1992 drawn on Nedungadi Bank, Vadakara Branch and agreed to pay the balance amount of Rs. 5000/- within one week. The statement in the complaint is that the respondent approached the appellant after one week and told him that he was not in a position to pay the balance amount of Rs. 5000/- in cash and issued another cheque for Rs. 5000/-. When the two cheques were presented in South Malabar Gramin Bank, Sulthan Bathery, for collection of the amount, the cheques were dishonoured by stating that payment has been stopped by the respondent. On enquiry made by the appellant he came to know that there was no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent to honour the cheques. Thereafter the appellant issued notice to the respondent informing him of the dishonour of the cheques and also demanding payment of the amount covered by the cheques.

    2. In the trial court, the respondent raised the contention that the two cheques issued by him to the appellant were not supported by consideration.

    3. According to him, the allegation by the appellant that the two cheques were issued towards repayment of the amount borrowed from the appellant is not at all correct What the respondent would say is that there was an agreement that the appellant would supply timber and on the basis of that agreement an amount of Rs. 25,000/- was paid in cash and the two cheques were issued for Rs. 37,000/- towards consideration of the timber that was agreed to be supplied by the appellant According to the respondent, the appellant did not supply timber as agreed by him and hence the cheques were not supported by consideration.

    4. Evidence was taken in the trial court The appellant gave evidence in the trial court as PW 1. PW 2 is the Manager of Vadakara Branch of Nedungadi Bank. Exts. P1 and P2 are the cheques issued by the respondent in favour of the appellant Exts. P3 and P4 are the memos issued from the Bank stating that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques were dishonoured since the payment was stopped by the drawer, the respondent Ext. P6 is copy of the notice sent by the appellant to the respondent informing the dishonour of the cheques and demanding payment of the amount covered by the cheques. On an appreciation of the evidence adduced, the trial court came to the conclusion that the respondent is not guilty of the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act On the basis of the above finding, the respondent was acquitted under S. 255(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Aggrieved by the above order of acquittal, this appeal is filed by the appellant praying that the order of acquittal may be set aside and the respondent may be convicted of the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

    5. The argument advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant is that there is sufficient evidence in this case to prove that the respondent committed the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act Admittedly, Exts. P1 and P2 cheques were issued by the respondent. When the respondent was questioned under S. 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, he admitted that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques were issued by him. In a statement filed by the accused on 11.4.1994 also he has admitted that he issued Exts. P1 and P2 cheques. There is a presumption under S. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act that unless the contrary is proved the holder of the cheque received the cheque of the nature referred to in S. 138 for the discharge in whole or in part of any debt or other liability. In the light of the above provision in the Negotiable Instruments Act unless and until it is proved that a cheque is issued in the circumstances mentioned by the respondent, it has to be presumed that the cheque is issued in discharge of any debt or other liability. The presumption available under S. 139 can be rebutted by the respondent by adducing evidence. So the burden of proof is on the respondent and the evidence available on record will have to be appreciated by bearing in mind the above fact regarding burden of proof.

    6. PW. 1 the complainant says in the chief examination that the respondent borrowed an amount of Rs. 32,000/-. His version is that the cheque was issued in discharge of the above debt PW 1 went on to say that the cheque when presented for encashment was dishonoured for the reason that there was no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent In cross-examination, he would deny the suggestions made regarding the alleged agreement between him and the respondent for supply of timber and issuance of cheque on the basis of that agreement PW. 2 the Manager of the Vadakara Branch of the Nedungadi Bank would say that on 11.12.1992 the cheque came to the Bank for collection of the amount covered by the cheque. He would say that on that day there was only an amount of Rs. 1017.85 in the account of the respondent. He would also speak about the letter given by the respondent stopping the payment of the amount covered by the cheque. Ext. P10 certified copy of the ledger was proved by PW. 2. So, this is a case in which it is established by the evidence of PW 2 that when the cheque came to the Bank for collection of the amount, there was only an amount of Rs. 1017.85 in the account of the respondent. There is evidence in this case to show that the appellant issued notice to the respondent demanding payment of the amount covered by the cheque and intimating the fact that the cheque was dishonoured.

    7. Even though there is evidence in this case to show that at the time when the cheques were dishonoured, there was no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent to honour the cheques, in the memo issued from the Bank it was stated that the cheques were dishonoured for the reason that payment was stopped by the respondent It is also not disputed that after issuing the cheques the payment of the amount covered by the cheques was stopped by the respondent In the decision of the Supreme Court in 1998 (1) KLT 582 (SC) (Modi Cements Ltd. v. K.K Nandi), it was held that once the cheque is issued by the drawer a presumption under S. 139 must follow and merely because the drawer issues a notice to the drawee or to the Bank for stoppage of the payment it will not preclude an action under S. 138 of the Act. It is clear from the above decision of the Supreme Court that when drawer of the cheque stops payment by giving initiation to the Bank, action can be initiated under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

    8. A reading of the judgment of the trial court would go to show that the trial court observed that PW 1 has failed to prove that Exts. P1 and P2 were issued by the accused for consideration. As already stated, it is for the accused to rebut the presumption available under S. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and to establish that the case set up by him regarding the issuance of the cheque is true. But the trial court is seen to have taken a wrong approach in appreciation of the evidence on the assumption that it is for the appellant to prove that Exts. P1 and P2 cheques are supported by consideration. On the side of the respondent, three documents were produced. Ext. D2 is the notice issued by the appellant to the respondent informing the dishonour of the cheque and demanding the payment of the amount covered by the cheques. Ext. D1 is a reply given by the appellant to the respondent to Ext. D3 notice sent by the respondent to the appellant Ext. D3 is copy of the notice sent by the respondent to the appellant stating that since the timber was not supplied by the appellant the payment of the amount covered by the cheques was stopped by the appellant Ext D3 was sent by the appellant to the respondent on 15.2.1992 There is only that document which is relied on by the respondent to show that even on 15.2.1992 he informed the appellant that payment of the amount covered by the cheques was stopped by him. In that notice, he mentioned about some transactions between the appellant and the respondent regarding the supply of timber and payment of an amount of Rs. 25,000/- in cash and issuance of Exts. P1 and P2 cheques. The above evidence will not in any way help the respondent to rebut the presumption available under S. 139 of the Act.

    9. The trial court took the view that the complaint did not contain sufficient allegations which would disclose the commission of the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act since there was no averment in the complaint that the cheques were dishonoured for the reason that there was no sufficient amount in the account of the appellant The learned counsel appearing for the appellant would point out that in the complaint filed in the trial court there is specific statement that the respondent issued the cheques on fully knowing that there was no sufficient amount in the account for dishonouring the cheques. When the appellant gave sworn statement before the Magistrate also he said that the cheques were issued by the respondent on knowing fully well that there was no sufficient amount in the account for honouring the cheques. The version of the complainant when he was examined as PW 1 is also in tune with the statements in the complaint as well as the statement given when the Magistrate recorded the sworn statement The decision of this Court reported in 1993 (2) KLT 1027 is relied on by the trial court for saying that there will have to be specific averment in the complaint when the cheque were dishonoured for insufficiency of funds. As stated earlier, the cheques were dishonoured for the reason that payment of the cheques was stopped by the respondent. That being the position, there is no necessity of having an averment in the complaint that the cheques were dishonoured for the reason that there was no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent. The above position mentioned in the judgment of the trial court will become applicable only in cases in which the cheque is dishonoured for the reason that there is no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent Here, reason for the dishonour is that payment was stopped by the respondent It is also a fact that there was no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent to honour the cheque. What PW. 2, the Manager of the Bank would say is also that the cheques were dishonoured for the reason that payment was stopped by the respondent. Hence, there is no necessity to take an averment in the complaint that the cheques were dishonoured for the reason that there was no sufficient amount in the account of the respondent The finding by the trial court that the complaint filed by the appellant was bad for the reason that there was no averment in the complaint that the cheques were dishonoured for the insufficiency of funds is not at all correct

    10. The reasons given by the trial court in the judgment for acquitting the accused are not at all sustainable. The evidence of PW 1 and P2 would clearly prove that the dishonour of the cheques was due to the fact that the payment was stopped by the respondent. As held by the Supreme Court in 1998 (1) KLT 582 (SC) which has already been referred to, once the cheque is issued by the drawer there would be a presumption under S. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and the stoppage of payment will not preclude an action under S. 138 of the Act So, this is a case in which there is sufficient evidence to come to the conclusion that the respondent committed the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act Hence the order of acquittal by the learned Magistrate has to be reversed and the accused has to be convicted for the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

    11. In the result, this appeal is allowed setting aside the order of acquittal by the trial court The respondent is found guilty of the offence punishable under S. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and he is convicted thereunder. The respondent is sentenced under S. 138 of the Act to undergo simple imprisonment for a term of three months.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    George v. Muhammed
    (Jun 1, 1999)