AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C
  • 2-1-1986. Article 91 of the Limitation Act, 1963
  • Clause (f) of Rule 5 of the Order 33, C.P.C4.
  • Clause (f) of Rule 5 or Order 33, CPC
  • case.5. Rule 5 of Order 33, CPC
  • Order 33 Rules 15
  • Order 33 Rule 5
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C
  • 2-1-1986. Article 91 of the Limitation Act, 1963
  • Clause (f) of Rule 5 of the Order 33, C.P.C4.
  • Clause (f) of Rule 5 or Order 33, CPC
  • case.5. Rule 5 of Order 33, CPC
  • Order 33 Rules 15
  • Order 33 Rule 5
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The counter petitioners in O.P (Pauper) No. 3/86 before the Principal Sub Court, Trivandrum, filed a revision against an order dated 16-3-1995. The impugned order allowed the respondent to file a suit as an indigent person under Order 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C). The respondent sought permission to sue for recovery of damages amounting to Rs. 4,08,000 for the alleged theft of his vehicle by the petitioners. The court-fee payable was Rs. 40,780, which the respondent claimed he could not afford.

The lower court accepted the respondent's claim of indigence and rejected the petitioners' contention that the application was not maintainable. The petitioners challenged this decision, contending that even if the respondent lacked means to pay court-fee, the suit was barred by law under Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C, and thus the application to sue as an indigent person should be rejected.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C. applies to the facts of the case, thereby barring the respondent's application to sue as an indigent person on the ground that the suit is barred by limitation law.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Even if the respondent lacks sufficient means to pay the court-fee, the suit is not maintainable under Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C.
  • The suit is barred by limitation as the theft occurred on 22-5-1982, but the application to sue as indigent was filed on 2-1-1986, beyond the three-year limitation period under Article 91 of the Limitation Act, 1963.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Relied on precedents such as A.V Chetty v. A.R Chetty and re K. Annamalai Chettiar to argue that limitation issues should be carefully considered at the suit stage and not summarily rejected at the indigent application stage.
  • Argued that the court should not prematurely decide complicated or doubtful limitation questions at the stage of permitting a suit as an indigent person.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Muhammed Kunju v. Sudhamma @ Saraswathi Amma & Others, (1990) 1 Ker LT 464 Interpretation of Order 33 Rule 5: Court must reject indigent application if suit appears barred by law. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the suit is barred by limitation and thus the indigent application must be rejected.
A.V Chetty v. A.R Chetty, AIR 1970 Andh Pra 411 Scope of enquiry into limitation at pauper application stage. The Court acknowledged the principle that limitation issues are often mixed questions of fact and law, requiring discretion in enquiry at the pauper stage.
In re K. Annamalai Chettiar, AIR 1956 Madras 677 Jurisdiction to enquire into limitation at pauper application stage with discretion. The Court distinguished this case on facts, noting that here the suit was clearly barred on the face of the application, unlike in Annamalai Chettiar where limitation was raised in defence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C., which mandates rejection of an indigent application where the suit is barred by any law in force. It noted that the theft occurred on 22-5-1982, and the application to sue as indigent was filed on 2-1-1986. Under Article 91 of the Limitation Act, 1963, the limitation period for compensation claims is three years from the date of theft, rendering the suit barred by limitation.

The Court recognized the respondent’s argument, supported by precedents, that limitation issues often involve mixed questions of fact and law and should not be prematurely decided at the indigent application stage. However, it distinguished the present case because the limitation bar was apparent from the application itself, without requiring factual enquiry or defence pleadings.

Relying on the precedent in Muhammed Kunju v. Sudhamma, the Court held that where the suit is clearly barred by law on the face of the application, the Court is obligated to reject the indigent application. Consequently, Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C. applied squarely, and the lower court’s order allowing the suit as indigent could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

The revision is allowed. The Court rejected the respondent’s prayer to file the suit as an indigent person on the ground that the suit is barred by limitation under Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C.

The Court directed the lower court to pass appropriate consequential orders under Order 33 Rules 15 and 15A. This decision results in dismissal of the respondent’s indigent application and prevents the suit from proceeding under the pauper provision. No new precedent was established; the ruling strictly enforces the existing limitation bar at the indigent application stage where it is clearly apparent.

    Mercantile Credit Corporation Ltd. And Another v. K. Sathyan .

    The counter petitioners in O.P (Pauper) No. 3/86 on the file of the Principal Sub Court, Trivandrum have preferred this revision against the order dated 16-3-1995 by which the application by the respondent herein to file a suit as an indigent person under Order 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short ‘C.P.C’) was allowed. The respondent herein filed the petition to permit him to file a suit as an indigent person for recovery of damages on account of theft of his vehicle alleged to have been committed by the petitioners herein. The suit is valued at Rs. 4,08,000/-. The court-fee payable thereon is Rs. 40,780/-. He pleaded that he has no sufficient means to pay the court-fee.

    2. The Court below held that the applicant (the respondent herein) has no sufficient means to raise the required funds to pay the court-fee. He rejected the contention of the petitioners herein that the application is not maintainable.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioners contended that even if it is held that the respondent does not have sufficient means to pay the requisite court-fee, yet the prayer to file the suit as an indigent person deserves to be rejected on the ground that the suit is not maintainable under Clause (f) of Rule 5 of the Order 33, C.P.C

    4. The only question that arises for consideration is whether the provision of Clause (f) of Rule 5 of Order 33, C.P.C is applicable to the facts of the case.

    5. Rule 5 of Order 33, CPC lays down certain grounds on which the court shall reject an application for permission to sue as an indigent person. Clause (f) thereof provides that where the allegations made by the applicant in the application show that the suit would be barred by any law for the time being in force, such an application should be rejected. It is admitted in the application that the theft of the vehicle took place on 22-5-1982. The application to sue as an indigent person was filed on 2-1-1986. Article 91 of the Limitation Act, 1963 lays down that the period of limitation for claiming compensation is three years which shall run from the date when the property is wrongfully taken or acquired by theft. It is well settled that a suit by an indigent person must be regarded as a suit instituted on the date of presentation of application to sue as an indigent person. From the averments in the application it becomes clear that the claim is barred by limitation. This Court in Muhammed Kunju v. Sudhamma @ Saraswathi Amma & Others, (1990) 1 Ker LT 464 held on an interpretation of Order 33 Rule 5 that if the suit appears to be barred by any law, then the Court is bound to reject the application for permitting to sue as an indigent person. Learned counsel for the respondent relied on the decisions in A.V Chetty v. A.R Chetty, AIR 1970 Andh Pra 411 and in re K. Annamalai Chettiar, AIR 1956 Madras 677. In Annamalai's case it has been held that a Court has jurisdiction to enquire in the pauper application stage itself into the question of limitation, allowing evidence to be adduced by both sides. The scope of the enquiry, however, is a matter within the discretion of the trial Judge and in, exercising this discretion it must not be exercised arbitrarily or capriciously and must be guided by sound judicial principles. The Court should not at that stage embark upon the consideration of complicated or doubtful questions of limitation as may arise on the allegation of the respondent (Counter petitioner in the application) or decide questions affecting the merits, as questions of limitation are seldom pure questions of law but more often than not mixed questions of fact and law that more properly and fairly can be determined at the hearing of the suit. There can be no contrary opinion about the aforesaid proposition of law. But where it is apparent from the averments of the applicant and not from the defendants' statement in defence that the suit is barred by the law of limitation, the matter does not pose any complicated or doubtful questions of law. The facts of the cases of Madras and Andhra Pradesh High Courts are clearly distinguishable inasmuch as in those cases, the defendants raised the plea of limitation in their defence. But here it is otherwise.

    6. For the reasons stated above, I find that Clause (f) of Rule 5 or Order 33, CPC squarely applies to this case. The order of the Court below therefore cannot be sustained in law. The prayer of the respondent to file the suit as an indigent person is rejected. The Court below shall pass appropriate consequential orders under Order 33 Rules 15 and 15A.

    The revision is accordingly allowed. No costs.

    Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mercantile Credit Corporation Ltd. And Another v. K. Sathyan .
    (Jan 16, 1997)