Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 302, 307, 341 and 34 of the I.P.C2. Prosecution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 302, 307, 341 and 34 of the I.P.C2. Prosecution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Appellants, accused 1 to 3 in Sessions Court case S.C 128 of 1987 at Trivandrum, challenged their conviction and sentence under Sections 302, 307, 341, and 34 of the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution alleged that the accused, acting with common intention, caused the death of Surendran and assaulted his uncle, P.W 2, who intervened. The incident occurred near the residence of P.Ws 1 to 3 on 17-12-1986, following a dispute over property and prior destruction of illicit wash by Surendran. The prosecution's case primarily relied on the testimony of P.Ws 1 to 3 and P.W 2 who sustained injuries. The accused were convicted by the Sessions Judge, and they appealed the conviction and sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the testimony of witnesses related to the deceased (P.Ws 1 to 3) can be relied upon despite their relationship and possible interest in the prosecution.
  2. Whether the accused 1 to 3 shared a common intention in causing the death and assault as alleged.
  3. Whether the non-examination of an alleged eyewitness, Pushpavathi, affects the prosecution case adversely.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The testimony of P.Ws 1 to 3 is unreliable as they are related to the deceased and inimical to the accused.
  • The prosecution deliberately withheld the examination of Pushpavathi, who was an eyewitness, to suppress the real incident and rely on interested witnesses.
  • Accused 2 and 3 did not share common intention to commit the crime.

Prosecution's Arguments

  • Relationship of witnesses to the deceased does not automatically discredit their testimony if it withstands cross-examination.
  • Pushpavathi was not an eyewitness as she arrived only after the incident, supported by testimony and the first information statement.
  • The accused acted in furtherance of common intention, as evidenced by coordinated actions during the assault.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hari Obulla Reddi v. State of Andhra Pradesh ((1981) 3 SCC 675 : A.I.R 1981 S.C 82) Interested evidence is not necessarily unreliable; it must be scrutinized carefully and accepted with caution if found reliable. The Court accepted the testimony of witnesses related to the deceased after careful scrutiny, holding that their evidence was trustworthy and unshaken by cross-examination.
State of U.P v. Paras Nath ((1973) 3 SCC 647 : A.I.R 1973 S.C 1073) No rule requires corroboration of straightforward evidence from relations of the deceased; such witnesses are natural and credible. The Court relied on the straightforward testimony of P.Ws 1 to 3 as natural witnesses, rejecting the need for corroboration solely due to their relationship.
D.R Bhagare v. State of Maharashtra ((1973) 1 SCC 537 : A.I.R 1973 S.C 476) First Information Report (F.I.R) is not substantive evidence; it can only corroborate or contradict its maker and cannot discredit other witnesses. The Court held that discrepancies or omissions in the F.I.R regarding eyewitnesses do not invalidate the credible testimony of other witnesses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the prosecution evidence, focusing primarily on the testimony of P.Ws 1 to 3, who were relatives of the deceased but provided consistent and straightforward accounts of the incident. The Court emphasized that relationship alone does not discredit testimony if it withstands cross-examination and is inherently probable, referencing established Supreme Court precedents. The Court found no adverse factors in cross-examination to disbelieve these witnesses.

The Court also considered the testimony of P.W 2, the injured witness, whose injuries and account corroborated the narrative of the assault and death. Medical evidence supported the nature and cause of injuries.

Regarding the non-examination of Pushpavathi, the Court concluded from the testimonies and the first information statement that she was not an eyewitness but arrived after the incident, thus her absence did not weaken the prosecution's case.

The Court further found that all accused shared a common intention, as evidenced by their coordinated actions during the assault, dismissing the defense argument to the contrary.

On the basis of the above, the Court upheld the Sessions Judge's reliance on the prosecution witnesses and confirmed the conviction and sentence.

Holding and Implications

Conviction and sentence of accused 1 to 3 are confirmed and the criminal appeal is dismissed.

The decision directly upholds the trial court's findings without setting new legal precedent. It reinforces the principle that testimony of interested witnesses, when credible and unshaken, can sustain conviction, and that the absence of certain witnesses who are not true eyewitnesses does not necessarily weaken the prosecution's case.

    Sahadevan Rajan And Others v. State Of Kerala

    Pareed Pillay, J.:— Appellants are accused 1 to 3 in S.C 128 of 1987 of the Sessions Court, Trivandrum. They challenge the conviction and sentence entered against them under Sections 302, 307, 341 and 34 of the I.P.C

    2. Prosecution case is that accused 1 to 3 in furtherance of their common intention caused the death of Surendran and assaulted P.W 2 (uncle of the deceased) who rushed to the scene imploring them to desist from doing anything against this nephew. Both the injured were taken to the Medical College Hospital. Doctor examined Surendran and pronounced him dead. P.W 2 was admitted in the hospital. It was P.W 1 who lodged Ext. P1 first information statement before P.W 14 Sub Inspector. The investigation was conducted by P.Ws 15 and 16. Place of incident is near the house of P.Ws 1 to 3. It is in the pathway leading to their house. Prosecution mainly relies upon the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 3 of them, P.W 2 sustained injuries. He is the uncle of deceased Surendran.

    3. A3's father was the caretaker of a property. That property was purchased by P.W 2 in the name of his wife (C.W 4). There was some dispute with regard to it between the families of P.W 2 and the accused. A3's father was not agreeable to the enjoyment of the property by C.W 4. On 13-12-1986 Surendran had destroyed wash kept by the accused for illicit distillation. This aggravated the animosity of the accused. It was on 17-12-1996 that the incident culminating in the death of Surendran and P.W 2 sustaining injuries occurred.

    4. P.W 1 who is the son of P.W 2 deposed that on 17-12-1886 at about 8 p.m he was sitting in the veranda of his house along with his father, mother and sister and it was then that A1 who came to the pathway along with A2 and A3 called Surendran. There were two chimney lamps on the veranda. Surendran went towards them. A2 and A3 forcibly caught hold of the hands of Surendran and asked him whether he would destroy wash. A1 standing in front of Surendran inflicted a cut injury on the left side of his neck with M.O 1 chopper. On sustaining the bleeding injury Surendran fell down. Seeing the attack on Surendran P.W 2 ran towards the accused imploring them to desist from the assault. A3 made the exhortation to kill P.W 2. Immediately A1 attacked P.W 2 with M.O 1 Chopper aiming at his neck P.W 2 warded off the attack thereby sustaining injury. A1 again attacked P.W 2 with the chopper aiming at his neck. It caused a bleeding injury below the left side of his neck. P.W 2 fell down. P.W 1 his sister (P.W 3) and their mother raised an alarm. Hearing it neighbours Pushpavathi and others came. The accused fled away from the scene. The above evidence tendered by P.W 1 has been corroborated by P.Ws 2 and 3 in all material particulars.

    5. The main attack on the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 3 is that they are related to the deceased and inimical to the accused. Merely because they are related to the deceased their testimony cannot be rejected. So long as their evidence stands unscathed in cross-examination, it is not possible to hold that they have given a perjured version of the incident before the Court. As there is nothing inherently improbable in their evidence, no Court of law can discard it on the ground that they are related to the deceased. All that is necessary while scanning the evidence of an interested witness is that the Court must bestow extremely careful attention and should scrutinise it from every angle. On such scrutiny if the testimony of a witness who is related to the deceased is found acceptable, conviction can be based on it. Straight-forward evidence given by witnesses who are related to the deceased cannot be rejected on the sole score that they are interested in the prosecution. Cross-examination of P.Ws 1 to 3 has not brought out a single adverse factor to hold that they have uttered falsehood before the Court. In this context it is useful to refer to Hari Obulla Reddi v. State of Andhra Pradesh ((1981) 3 SCC 675 : A.I.R 1981 S.C 82) where the Supreme Court held:

    “Interested evidence is not necessarily unreliable evidence. Even partisanship by itself is not a valid ground for discrediting or rejecting sworn testimony. Nor is it an invariable rule that interested evidence can never form the basis of conviction unless corroborated to a material extent in material particulars by independent evidence. All that is necessary is that the evidence of interested witnesses should be subjected to careful scrutiny and accepted with caution. If on such scrutiny, the interested testimony is found to be intrinsically reliable or inherently probable, it may, by itself, be sufficient, in the circumstances of the particular case, to base a conviction thereon.”

    6. Straightforward and trustworthy evidence of relations of the deceased needs no corroboration for sustaining conviction. Such evidence cannot be discarded on the sole ground of interestedness in the prosecution case. As the incident occurred close to the residential house of P.Ws 1 to 3, they are natural witnesses especially when their evidence shows that they were sitting in the veranda of the house and it was then that the accused came there and called out Surendran. As the evidence tendered by P.Ws 1 to 3 does not in any manner show that they have falsely implicated the accused, it cannot be discarded merely on the ground that they are related to the deceased. It is fruitful to refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in the State of U.P v. Paras Nath ((1973) 3 SCC 647 : A.I.R 1973 S.C 1073) where the Court observed:

    “There is no rule that even straightforward evidence of relations of the deceased needs corroboration for sustaining conviction. That such witnesses happen to be naturally able to identify the assailants (coupled with the recovery of the blood-stained earth from the place of occurrence) leaves no reasonable doubt about proof of guilt. In absence of circumstances showing witnesses as inclined to falsely involve the accused, their being related to the deceased is innocuous.”

    7. As the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 3 has unfolded the prosecution case and as it stands unscathed in cross-examination, the learned Sessions Judge was justified in relying on their testimony.

    8. P.W 2 who sustained injuries has narrated in clear and categoric terms as to how the incident occurred. An injured witness is not at all likely to spare the real assailants and allow some others being falsely implicated. Moreover, P.W 2's testimony gets ample support from that of P.Ws 1 and 3. P.W 4 doctor examined P.W 2 and issued Ext. P-2 wound certificate. Ext. P-2 shows that P.W 2 had sustained incised wound over supra clavicular region and also on the outer part of left forearm. P.W 4 doctor opined that these injuries could be caused with a chopper like M.O 1. He ruled out the defence suggestion that injury Nos. 1 and 2 can be caused by single action.

    9. Learned counsel for the accused submitted that non-examination of Pushpavathi who is an eye witness is really deterimental to the prosecution case. It is submitted that the prosecution deliberately withheld her from being examined in the Court with a view to suppress the real incident and to project the interested testimony of P.Ws 1 to 3. Learned Public Prosecutor submitted that Pushpavathi was not an eye witness as could be seen from the testimony of P.Ws 1 to 3 and also from the first information statement.

    10. P.W 1's evidence is that when Pushpavathi and others came to the place of occurrence accused ran away from the scene. He could only say that Pushpavathi might have witnessed the occurrence. P.W 2 asserted that Pushpavathi came only after the incident. His evidence would show that he cried aloud and it was then that Pushpavathi and others came to the place of occurrence. P.W 3 deposed that Pushpavathi reached the place of occurrence only after hearing the cry. Her evidence is that before Surendran was assaulted with the chopper no one raised any cry and that when her father fell down after sustaining injury she and others cried. Evidence of P.Ws 1 to 3 sufficiently clearly discloses that Pushpavathi and others came to the place of occurrence only after the assault on the deceased and P.W 2.

    11. In the first information statement also it is clearly stated that P.Ws 1, 2 and 3 cried aloud and Pushpavathi and others rushed to the place of occurrence. A stray sentence towards the concluding portion of Ext. P-1 that the occurrence was witnessed by P.W 1's mother, sister and others has been highlighted by the counsel for the appellants to contend that in all likelihood Pushpavathi is an eye witness. That contention is not tenable in view of the unassailable evidence to the contrary. It is also significant to note that name of Pushpavathi is not specifically mentioned as an eye witness to the occurrence.

    12. As the first information statement can be used only for the purpose of corroborating or contradicting the maker of the statement, the whole prosecution case cannot be thrown out on the basis of any statement in it. In a case as the present one where the evidence of the eye witnesses including the injured witness is totally acceptable, the attempt to demolish it on the ground that some other person who has witnessed the occurrence has not been examined is only an exercise in futility. The first information report cannot be utilised for contradicting or discrediting the testimony of other witnesses who speak about the occurrence. As the first information report cannot be considered as substantive evidence, it cannot encroach upon the periphery of the evidence tendered by other witnesses with regard to the incident. In this context the Supreme Court's decision in D.R Bhagare v. State of Maharashtra ((1973) 1 SCC 537 : A.I.R 1973 S.C 476) is apposite. The Supreme Court held thus:

    “The first information report is never treated as a substantive piece of evidence. It can only be used for corroborating or contradicting its maker when he appears in court as a witness. Its value must always depend on the facts and circumstances of a given case. The F.I.R can only discredit the testimony of its maker. It can by no means be utilised for contradicting or discrediting the other witnesses who do not have any desire to spare the real culprit and to falsely implicate him. Thus the prosecution case cannot be thrown out on the mere ground that in the first information report an altogether different version is given by its maker.”

    13. P.W 12 Doctor who conducted autopsy and issued Ext. P-8 post - mortem certificate stated that cause of death was due to the injury to the neck of the deceased. He opined that the injury could be caused by M.O 1 chopper and it was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Evidence of P.Ws 1 to 3 established unerringly that the fatal injury to the deceased was caused by A1 while/A2 and A3 held his hands. Contention that A2 and A3 have been falsely implicated also must fail in view of the trust-worthy evidence tendered by the eye witnesses. Defence contention that A2 and A3 did not share any common intention to commit the crime does not deserve acceptance as the evidence clearly unfolds that the criminal acts were done in furtherance of their common intention. The evidence is that the accused came together, that A2 and A3 caught hold of the hands of the deceased and that A1 inflicted the fatal injury on the deceased. The evidence also sufficiently clearly shows that on A3's exhortation A1 inflicted injuries on P.W 2. In view of the evidence in the case, the learned Sessions Judge was justified in holding that A1 to A3 shared the common intention in the perpetration of the crime alleged against them.

    14. On going through the entire evidence, we hold that the prosecution has succeeded in establishing its case against A1 to A3 (appellants). Conviction and sentence entered against them are confirmed. Criminal Appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sahadevan Rajan And Others v. State Of Kerala
    (Jan 17, 1992)