Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner contested the General Election to the House of the People (Lok Sabha) held on 22-11-1989 from the Kozhikode Parliamentary constituency as a candidate of the "Jena Seva" party. The respondent was declared elected from that constituency by a margin of 28,950 votes. The petitioner alleged that the respondent committed serious corrupt practices and sought that the respondent's election be declared void. The petition alleged four separate types of corrupt practices. The respondent filed preliminary objections denying the allegations, contending the petition was vague, frivolous and vexatious, and that the petitioner had not complied with Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The respondent sought striking out of the allegations under Order VI Rule 16 C.P.C. The court considered these contentions and the sufficiency of the petition under the statutory and procedural requirements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the election petition adequately pleaded the material facts and particulars required by Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, for allegations of corrupt practices.
  2. Whether each of the four specific allegations in the petition (false propaganda concerning retirement/withdrawal, use of motor vehicles for conveyance of electors, forgery of the petitioner's signature, and an announcement by the Prime Minister regarding a welfare scheme) constituted corrupt practices within the meaning of Section 123 of the Act as pleaded.
  3. Whether defects in the affidavit accompanying the petition (non-compliance with the proviso to Section 83 and Rule 94A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961) required rejection of the petition.
  4. Whether the petition, being bereft of material particulars and containing other formal defects, should be struck out under Order VI Rule 16 C.P.C. and/or rejected summarily, and whether costs should be awarded to the returned candidate.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Allegations / Contentions

  • The respondent committed serious corrupt practices of four kinds, set out in the petition.
  • Allegation 1: False propaganda was circulated on behalf of the respondent (with his consent) that the petitioner had retired/withdrawn and had appealed to elect the respondent; such statements were announced through loudspeakers at meetings and moving vehicles two days before and on the eve of polling; the petitioner attempted to counter by newspaper advertisements.
  • Allegation 2: Motor vehicles were procured and used (with the respondent's consent) to convey electors to and from polling stations; a specific Taxi Car No. K.R.Z 2430 was named.
  • Allegation 3: The petitioner's signature was forged for appointment of counting and polling agents.
  • Allegation 4: The then Prime Minister (President of the Congress (I) party), Shri Rajiv Gandhi, announced allocation of Rs. 5000 crores for employment and upliftment of women under a Mahila Yojana scheme, which allegedly amounted to corrupt practice.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The allegations in the petition were vague, frivolous and vexatious and did not contain the requisite particulars as mandated by Section 83 of the Act.
  • The petitioner failed to comply with the mandatory affidavit requirement in the proviso to Section 83; the affidavit was not in the prescribed form and was not sworn/attested as required by Rule 94A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961.
  • The respondent prayed for striking out the allegations under Order VI Rule 16 C.P.C., and for rejection of the petition under Order VII Rule 11(a) where a cause of action is not disclosed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri Udhav Singh v. Madhav Rao Scindia, (1976) AIR 1976 SC 744 (reported as 2 SCR 246) All facts essential to constitute a cause of action are "material facts" which must be pleaded; failure to plead a single material fact breaches Section 83(1)(a). The court relied on this principle to emphasize that the petitioner must plead material facts with precision and that omission of such particulars mandates striking out or dismissal.
Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi, AIR 1986 SC 1253 Election petitions alleging corrupt practices must comply with Section 83; non-compliance can lead to dismissal under Civil P.C. provisions. The court cited this authority to support the proposition that failure to state particulars of corrupt practices warrants summary rejection.
Manphul Singh v. Surinder Singh, (1973) AIR 1973 SC 2158; (1974) 1 SCR 52; (1973) 2 SCC 599 Same strand of authority on necessity of pleading material particulars in election petitions and applying Civil P.C. rules. Used to reinforce that vague or general allegations of corrupt practices are insufficient and are amenable to summary disposal.
Kona Prabhakara Rao v. M. Seshagiri Rao, (1982) 1 SCC 442 : AIR 1981 SC 658 Supports application of Civil P.C. provisions and the requirement of precise pleading under Section 83. Relied upon to justify striking out parts of the petition that lacked material particulars.
Dhartipakar Madan Lal Agarwal v. Rajiv Gandhi, 1987 Supp SCC 93 : AIR 1987 SC 1577 Authority on the standard of pleading and proof in election petitions alleging corrupt practice; the quasi-criminal nature requires precision. The court invoked this precedent to stress that pleadings must not be vague and that trial should not be permitted where a petitioner seeks a "fishing expedition".

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by first stating the controlling statutory and procedural framework: Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 requires a concise statement of material facts and full particulars of any alleged corrupt practice, including names, dates and places; Section 87 makes provisions of the C.P.C. applicable; Order VI Rule 16 C.P.C. permits striking out pleadings that are unnecessary, scandalous, frivolous or vexatious; and Order VII Rule 11(a) permits rejection of a plaint that does not disclose a cause of action.

The court then analyzed each of the four pleaded grounds in turn and applied the statutory pleading standards and the cited precedents:

  1. False propaganda (paragraph 3(a)(i)):
    • The petition alleged that announcements via loudspeakers and moving vehicles stated the petitioner had retired/withdrawn; these were said to have been made two days before and on the eve of polling.
    • The petition did not name any person who made the propaganda, nor identify vehicles by registration or other particulars, nor specifically plead that the respondent gave consent to such propaganda.
    • The court noted that Section 123(4) had been amended (words "retirement from contest" omitted by Act 58 of 1958), so propaganda regarding retirement does not amount to corrupt practice under that provision.
    • Because material particulars (names, consent, documentary proof such as petitioner’s newspaper advertisement) were absent, paragraph 3(a)(i) lacked material particulars and was struck out under Order VI Rule 16 C.P.C.
  2. Use of motor vehicles for conveyance of electors (paragraph 3(a)(ii)):
    • The petition alleged hiring/procurement of many vehicles for conveying electors and named one taxi registration (K.R.Z 2430).
    • To be a corrupt practice under Section 123(5), the use must be for the "free conveyance" of electors; the petition did not specifically allege that conveyance was free nor provide any specific instances or identities of electors conveyed.
    • The vagueness and lack of specific instances meant the allegations did not raise a cause of action and were incapable of being effectively defended.
  3. Forgery of petitioner's signature (paragraph 3(a)(iii)):
    • The petition asserted that the petitioner's signature was forged for appointment of counting and polling agents, but did not allege the circumstances of the forgery, nor any involvement or consent by the returned candidate or his agent.
    • Because the petition failed to allege material particulars connecting the returned candidate or his agent to the alleged forgery, the claim was insufficient to raise a cause of action.
  4. Announcement by the Prime Minister (paragraph 3(a)(iv)):
    • The petition alleged that an announcement by the then Prime Minister allocating Rs. 5000 crores for a Mahila Yojana amounted to corrupt practice.
    • The petition did not state when the announcement was made, supply the press report or speech copy, or allege what effect the announcement had on the election; it also did not allege any consent or involvement by the respondent.
    • The court noted proviso (B) to Section 123(2) expressly excludes a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action from being undue influence, absent intent to interfere with electoral rights; the petition failed to plead any such interference or intent.
    • Therefore the allegation did not amount to a pleaded corrupt practice and lacked necessary particulars.
  5. Affidavit and formal defects:
    • The court observed the proviso to Section 83 requires an affidavit in support of allegations of corrupt practice in the prescribed form; Rule 94A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 prescribes that the affidavit be sworn before a first class magistrate, notary or commissioner of oaths and be in Form 25.
    • The affidavit accompanying the petition was not in the prescribed form, was attested by a Senior Superintendent of the Directorate of Treasuries (Trivandrum), and did not state that the affidavit was solemnly affirmed by the petitioner before the attesting officer as required by Rule 94A.
    • The court treated the non-production of a proper affidavit as a violation of Section 83 and as a formal ground for rejection of the petition.

On the cumulative basis of these analyses — inadequate pleading of material particulars for each alleged corrupt practice and the procedural defect in the affidavit — the court concluded the allegations were liable to be struck out under Order VI Rule 16 C.P.C., and that the petition as a whole did not disclose a cause of action and was to be rejected.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court dismissed the election petition. Specifically, the court struck out paragraphs 3(a)(i) to 3(a)(iv) and rejected the petition in its entirety. The order concludes: "Petition dismissed."

Consequences and Practical Effects:

  • The respondent (returned candidate) was awarded costs of Rs. 1,000, to be paid out of the petitioner's security deposit; any balance of the deposit was to be returned to the petitioner.
  • The office was directed to inform the Election Commission and the Speaker of the House of the People (Lok Sabha) without delay, and an authenticated copy of the decision was to be sent to the Election Commission as required by Section 103 of the Act.
  • The opinion did not purport to lay down any new legal precedent; the decision was based on applying established statutory pleading requirements and the cited authorities to the facts and formal defects in the petition. Accordingly, no broader novel legal principle was announced in this opinion beyond applying settled law on pleading standards and procedural compliance in election petitions.

Result recorded in the opinion: Petition dismissed. Costs awarded to respondent: Rs. 1,000 (to be paid from security deposit).

    K.C Madhava Kurup v. K. Muraleedharan .

    1. The petitioner contested the General Election to the House of the people (Lok Sabha) held on 22-11-1989 from Kozhikode Parliamentary constituency as a candidate of “Jena Seva” party. The respondent was declared elected from the said Parliamentary constituency by a margin of 28950 votes. The petitioner alleges that the respondent committed serious corrupt practices and, therefore, his election is to be declared void. In the petition the petitioner alleges four types of corrupt practices committed by the respondent. The respondent filed preliminary objections denying the allegations in the petition. The respondent contends that the allegations in the petition are vague and they are frivolous and vexatious. It is also contended that the petitioner has not complied with the mandate of Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (hereinafter called ‘the Act’). The respondent prays that the allegations in the petition are liable to be struck out under Order VI Rule 16, C.P.C

    2. It is repeatedly held by the Supreme Court in various decisions that an election petition, where allegations of corrupt practices are imputed must be regarded as a proceeding of quasi-criminal nature wherein strict proof is necessary and the pleadings of the election petitioner in his petition should be absolutely precise and clear, containing all necessary details and particulars as required by law. The allegations in the election petition should not be vague, general in character or lack material particulars. Section 83 of the Act specifically gives guidelines as to the mode in which the pleadings are to be drafted in an election petition. Section 83 requires the petitioner to give a concise statement of the material facts on which the petitioner relies. It is also mentioned in Section 83 that the petitioner shall set forth full particulars of any corrupt practice that the petitioner alleges, including as full a statement as possible of the names of the parties alleged to have committed such corrupt practices and the date and place of the commission of each such corrupt practice. From section 83 of the Act it is clear that all preliminary facts which must be proved to establish the existence of a cause of action shall be stated in the petition. In the context of a charge of corrupt practice material facts would mean all the basic facts constituting the ingredients of the particular corrupt practice alleged, which the petitioner is bound to substantiate before he can succeed on that charge. Whether in an election petition, a particular fact is material or not and as such required to be pleaded, is a question which depends on the circumstances of the case. In Shri Udhav Singh v. Madhav Rao Scindia (1976) 2 SCR 246 : (AIR 1976 SC 744) it has been held (at p. 752 of AIR):

    “In short, all those facts which are essential to clothe the petitioner with a complete cause of action, are “material facts” which must be pleaded, and failure to plead even a single material fact amounts to disobedience of the mandate of Sec. 83(1)(a)”.

    The Supreme Court has consistently taken the view that an election petition can be and must be dismissed under the provisions of Civil P.C if the mandatory requirements enjoined by Section 83 to incorporate the material facts and particulars relating to alleged corrupt practice are not complied with. By virtue of Section 87 of the Act the provisions of the C.P.C are made applicable for the trial of an election petition. Under Order VI Rule 16 the Court is empowered at any stage of the proceedings to strike out any pleading which may be unnecessary, scandalous, frivolous or vexatious or which may tend to prejudice, embarrass or delay the fair trial of the petition or suit or which otherwise an abuse of the process of the court. Order VII Rule 11(a) mandates that a plaint shall be rejected where it does not disclose a cause of action. Therefore, it is clear that an election petition is to be summarily rejected where it fails to furnish a cause of action. (See Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi, AIR 1986 SC 1253, Manphul Singh v. Surinder Singh , (1973) 2 SCC 599 : (1974) 1 SCR 52 : (AIR 1973 SC 2158), Kona Prabhakara Rao v. M. Seshagiri Rao (1982) 1 SCC 442 : (AIR 1981 SC 658), Dhartipakar Madan Lal Agarwal v. Rajiv Gandhi, 1987 Supp SCC 93 : (AIR 1987 SC 1577).

    3. In the petition it is alleged that on behalf of the respondent and with his consent a false propaganda was published that the petitioner had retired from contest and that the petitioner appealed to elect the respondent. It is further alleged that these statements were made by announcements through Loud speakers at meetings and in moving vehicles two days before and on the eve of the day of election. The petitioner's efforts to prevent them by a newspaper advertisements were in vain and the respondent made this propaganda to prejudice the prospects of the election of the petitioner and as such the number of votes secured by him was substantially reduced. It is pertinent to note that the petitioner has not mentioned the names of any of the persons who made such false propaganda. Even though several vehicles were allegedly used to spread this propaganda the register numbers or other identifying features of these vehicles are not mentioned in the petition. If seems that the petitioner alleged this fact as a ground of corrupt practice as envisaged under Section 123(4) of the Act. Section 123(4) was amended by Act 58 of 1958. Formerly under Section 123(4) of the Act, the publication by a candidate or his agent or by any other of any statement of fact which is false, and which he either believes to be false or does not believe to be true in relation to the personal character or conduct of any candidate, or in relation to the candidate, or withdrawal or retirement from contest of any candidate, being a statement reasonably calculated to prejudice the prospects of that candidate's election was a corrupt practice. By Section 13(6) of Act 58, the words “retirement from contest” were omitted from Section 123(4) of the Act. Therefore, the propaganda, if any, regarding the retirement from contest does not amount to corrupt practice. Moreover, the allegations do not disclose all material facts. It is not specifically pleaded that the respondent gave consent to any person to make false propaganda. The names of the persons who committed the said corrupt practice are not mentioned in the petition. The petitioner has also not produced the copy of the newspaper advertisement, alleged to have been made by him, to counter the propaganda allegedly made by the supporters of the respondent. The petitioner has no case that he filed contemporaneous complaint or petition against his alleged spread of false propaganda. The allegation contained in the first ground lacks material particulars. Therefore, the whole paragraph 3(a)(i) is to be struck out under Order VI Rule 16 of the C.P.C

    4. The next ground urged by the petitioner to challenge the election of the respondent is that the respondent used motor vehicles for the conveyance of electors. It is alleged that many motor vehicles were procured and used for conveyance of electors to and from polling booths for voting purpose on the date of the election with the consent of the returned candidate and his election agent. The petitioner has also mentioned the Taxi Car No. K.R.Z 2430 as the one used for the conveyance of electors in Kozhikode City. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner the allegations contained in paragraph 3(a)(ii) of the petition would constitute the corrupt practice under Section 123(5) of the Act. Under Section 123(5) hiring or procuring of any vehicle or vessel by a candidate or his agent or by any other person with the consent of a candidate or his election agent for the free conveyance of any elector to or from any polling station is prohibited. It is significant to note that the use of vehicle for the “free conveyance” of the elector alone would constitute a corrupt practice. The allegations contained in paragraph 3(a)(ii) of the election petition do not specifically say that motor vehicles were procured and used for the free conveyance of electors. It is also important to note that not a single specific instance has been quoted by the petitioner. A taxi cab number is mentioned in the petition but it is not specified as to who were all the electors given conveyance to or from polling station. The allegations are too vague and general and that the respondent may not be in a position to defend the same effectively. The allegations are not capable of raising a cause of action.

    5. In paragraph 3(a)(iii) of the petition it is mentioned that the signature of the petitioner was forged by somebody for appointment of counting and polling agents. Under what circumstance the petitioner's signature was forged is not mentioned in the petition. It is also not mentioned that the returned candidate or his agent had any hand in forging the signature of the petitioner. It is not mentioned that the returned candidate had given consent to any such malpractices. The allegations in paragraph 3(a)(iii) of the petition are also not sufficient to raise a cause of action.

    6. In paragraph 3(a)(iv) of the petition it is mentioned that the President of the Congress (I) party the then Prime Minister of India, Shri Rajiv Gandhi announced that an amount of Rs. 5000/- crores is earmarked for employment and upliftment of women under Mahila Yojana Scheme and this amounted to corrupt practice. The details of this allegation are not mentioned in the petition. It is not stated as to when this announcement was made by the Prime Minister. Either the press report or the copy of the speech alleged to have been made by the then Prime Minister is not produced by the petitioner. The petitioner has not mentioned as to what impact the Prime Minister's speech had on the election. It is also significant to note that in paragraph 3(a)(iv) it is not even mentioned that when the Prime Minister made this speech. Going by the allegations in paragraph 4 of the petition it would only indicate that the Government had declared certain policies and the Prime Minister was making announcement of such policies. That by itself would not come within the purview of corrupt practices mentioned in Section 123 of the Act. Under proviso (B) of Section 123(2) it is specifically mentioned that a declaration of public policy, or a promise of public action, or the mere exercise of a legal right without intent to interfere with an electoral right, shall not be deemed to be interference within the meaning of undue influence. To constitute undue influence as an electoral corrupt practice under Section 123(2) of the Act it must have direct or indirect interference on the part of the candidate or his agent or any other person or with the consent of the candidate or his election agent with the free exercise of any electoral right. It is not mentioned by the petitioner that the alleged speech by the then Prime Minister had any effect of undue influence on the electorate and that he had interfered with the free exercise of electoral right of any of the voters. The allegations contained in paragraph 3(a)(iv) of the election are also not sufficient to raise a cause of action.

    7. The learned counsel for the respondent stated that there are other material defects in the petition and, therefore, the same is liable to be dismissed in limine. It is pointed out that the affidavit accompanying the petition was not attested properly. Proviso to Section 83 of the Act says that where the petitioner alleges any corrupt practice, the petition shall also be accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed form in support of the allegation of such corrupt practice and the particulars thereof. Rule 94A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 further states that the affidavit referred to in the proviso to sub-section (1) of section 83 shall be sworn before a magistrate of the first class or a Notary or a Commissioner of oaths and shall be in Form 25. In the instant case the affidavit is not in the prescribed form. The affidavit is seen attested by a Senior Superintendent of the Directorate of Treasuries, Trivandrum. In the affidavit it is only mentioned that the same is attested. It is not specifically stated that the affidavit was solemnly affirmed by the petitioner in the presence of the concerned officer. Under Rule 94A the affidavit should be attested by a magistrate of the first class or a Notary or a Commissioner of oaths. The non-production of a proper affidavit is violation of Section 83 of the Act. The election petition is not in proper form and that by itself is a ground for rejection of the same.

    8. The Representation of the People Act, 1951 is a complete and self-contained Code within which any right claimed in relation to an election or an election dispute must be found. The scheme would show that an election can be questioned under the statute as provided by Section 80 on the grounds specified under Section 100 of the Act. As already noticed, Section 83 lays down that an election petition shall contain a concise statement of the material facts and set forth full particulars of corrupt practice. It is obligatory on the part of the petitioner to give requisite facts and details of each corrupt practice with clear exactitude. If the election petitioner fails to give such details and the allegations are vague and general, there may not arise a cause of action and the trial of such election petition is unnecessary. The Supreme Court in various decisions emphasised that if the allegations are vague and general and the particulars of corrupt practices are not stated in the pleading, the trial of the election petition cannot be proceeded with and the petitioner should not be allowed to have a “fishing expedition” or to have a “roving enquiry”. The allegations in the present petition do not give the details. They are of vague and general character and the names of the parties who alleged to have committed corrupt practices are not mentioned in the petition. The petition is not in accordance with Section 83 of the Act. The failure to produce a proper affidavit also is violation of the provisions of the Act. Under the above circumstances, the allegations in the petition are liable to be struck out under Order VI Rule 16 of the CPC. Therefore, I strike out paragraphs 3(a)(i) to (iv) of the election petition. As all the grounds urged by the petitioner are bereft of material particulars, the petition is only to be rejected.

    9. The petitioner, after having lost the election, has filed this petition without furnishing proper details. The returned candidate has been put to unnecessary hardship by this petition and he is entitled to get reasonable costs. Therefore, I hold that the respondent is entitled to get Rs. 1,000/- as costs. The costs shall be paid out of the security deposit by the petitioner and the balance amount is to be returned to the petitioner.

    In the result, the election petition is rejected. The office will intimate the substance of the decision to the Election Commission and the Speaker of the House of the People (Lok Sabha) without any delay. Thereafter an authenticated copy of the decision shall be sent to the Election Commission as per Section 103 of the Act.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.C Madhava Kurup v. K. Muraleedharan .
    (Jun 18, 1990)