Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code sought to set aside an order passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Parur, in Crl. M.P. No. 44 of 1985 in Sessions Case No. 17 of 1984 dated 19-3-1985. The impugned order had permitted the prosecution to re-examine the investigating officer to produce and prove an alleged confessional (disclosure) statement which purportedly led to the recovery of some material object.

At the time of the petition the trial evidence (including the examination of the investigating officer) was complete and the case stood posted for questioning the accused under Section 313 of the Code. The prosecution sought recall of the investigating officer to prove disclosure statements; the recovery mahazars and the case diary, however, were silent about any first-person disclosure statements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court rightly permitted the prosecution to recall and re-examine the investigating officer after conclusion of evidence for the purpose of producing and proving an alleged disclosure (confessional) statement relied upon under Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
  2. Whether Section 311 of the Criminal Procedure Code empowers the court to recall a witness (here, the investigating officer) post-conclusion of evidence when such recall would involve production of a vital record and may prejudice the accused's defence.
  3. What standards or safeguards (if any) the court should require in relation to disclosure statements relied upon under Section 27, particularly as to recording such statements and incorporating them in recovery mahazars/case diary.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded along the following lines, based strictly on the observations contained in the opinion:

  1. The court described Section 27 of the Evidence Act as an exception to the general rule that a confession to a police officer is inadmissible, and explained its limited scope: only so much of the information as led to the recovery of an object connected with the crime is admissible.
  2. The court emphasised safeguards: the information admitted under Section 27 must be exclusively available to the person making it, and the recovered object serves as corroboration of the information. The court warned that Section 27 is often misused to create evidence otherwise unavailable, which undermines a fair trial.
  3. To prevent manipulation and ensure correctness, the court held that disclosure statements should be recorded in the first person as and when made, and recovery mahazars or other records must contain such statements to the extent necessary; these records should be made available to the court and the accused at the earliest possible opportunity.
  4. In the present case the recovery mahazars and case diary were silent as to any disclosure statements; they proceeded as if recoveries were by search or otherwise, not by information from the accused.
  5. The court observed that recalling and re-examining the investigating officer after conclusion of the evidence, for the purpose of producing and proving a vital record, would prejudice the accused's defence because the material was not put to the officer when he was originally examined and its late production indicates potential prejudice.
  6. While Section 311 of the Code gives the court power to recall and re-examine any witness, that power is confined to situations where the court is satisfied that such recall is essential for the just decision of the case. The court found that recalling the investigating officer in these circumstances—after close of evidence to produce a vital record—cannot be said to be essential and may result in miscarriage of justice.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITION: The petition was allowed and the impugned order of 19-3-1985 was set aside; the petition was therefore allowed.

Direct consequences: the court's order permitting the prosecution to recall and re-examine the investigating officer to produce and prove the alleged disclosure statement was vacated. The effect is to prevent the late production and proof of the disclosure statement in the manner sought by the prosecution at that stage of the trial.

Broader implications: the opinion reiterates procedural safeguards concerning Section 27 disclosures (recording in first person, inclusion in recovery mahazars/case diary, early disclosure to court and accused) but does not purport to set a new legal precedent beyond the decision to set aside the impugned order. The court noted that misuse of Section 27 and late production of alleged disclosure statements can undermine a fair trial.

    Chandran v. State Of Kerala .

    1. This petition filed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code is for setting aside an order passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Parur in Crl. M.P No. 44 of 1985 in Sessions Case No. 17 of 1984. The order is dated 19-3-1985 and the purport of the order is to permit the prosecution to examine the investigating officer again to prove the alleged confessional statement which led to the recovery of some material object.

    2. Section 27 of the Evidence Act is a provision which is often complained of being misused for the purpose of creating evidence otherwise not available. It is an exception to the general rule that the confession of an accused person to a police officer is not admissible. What is admissible under Section 27 is only so much of the information which led to the recovery of the object proved to be having connection with the crime. The object recovered acts as corroboration of the information and assurance of its correctness. The information must be one exclusively available to the person making it. But many recoveries on the basis of search or otherwise are afraid of being attempted to be converted as recoveries on informations conveyed by the accused relying on the provisions of Section 27. Such attempts will cut at the root of fair trial which every accused person is entitled.

    3. In order to ensure fair trial and act as a check against manipulations at the hands of dishonest investigators and further to ensure correctness of the informations it is necessary that such informations which are called disclosure statements should be recorded in first person as and when made. The recovery mahazars or other relevant records must contain such statements to the extent necessary in first person and they will have to be made available to the Court and the accused at the earliest possible opportunity.

    4. In this case the recovery mahazars and the case diary statements of the concerned witnesses proceeded as if the recoveries were by search or otherwise and not on the basis of informations conveyed by the accused. They are conspicuously silent in regard to the disclosure statement. Now the entire trial including examination of the investigating officer is over and the case stands posted for questioning the accused under S. 313 of the Code.

    5. What the prosecution now wants and what the Court has allowed is recalling the investigating officer to be examined again for production and proof of the disclosure statements. The fact that it was not available for being put to the investigating officer when he was examined indicates that its late production and proof will prejudice the accused in his defence.

    6. Under Section 311 of the Code the Court is having the power to recall and re-examine any witness. But that could be only when the Court is satisfied that it is essential for the just decision of the case. Recalling and reexamining a witness like the investigating officer for production and proof of a vital record having great relevance in deciding the guilt of the accused and that too after conclusion of the evidence cannot be said to be essential for the just decision of the case. It may result in miscarriage of justice.

    7. The petition is therefore allowed and the impugned order is set aside.

    8. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chandran v. State Of Kerala .
    (Apr 10, 1985)